Текст отзыва оппонента 2 (1139622), страница 2
Текст из файла (страница 2)
rdcrroJrb3oBaHufl.opranusaqufi p€r:nratlHblx0op,rroMorrlb n arvr6ynaropHbrx ycJroBr,rflx.Marepnarrr Alrcceprarluu ucuonb3yrcTcflo6yrarorqLrxcfl, rro rpolpaMMaM opAr{Harypbr rroByre6uol,rrpoqecceNrs.<OpranusaL\LTfl,CneIII{ELJIbHOCTLI3ApaBo oxp aHelrtufl. ur o6ulecrB eHHo e 3AopoBbe).Pesylrraru3ApaBooxpaHeHurrpeKoMeHAa\uvrrEuccneAoBaHr4r prclonb3yrorc{Bpa6oreMrEruacrepcrBaPoccnficxofi (De4epaqruE paspa6oranuMeTOAI,IqeCKHeyue6no-MeroAr{rrecKoe noco6ue.[ocronepnocrb u o6ocnoBaHHocrb HayrrHblx tloJrorrceHnfi, nmno4onlr pexoMeuAarlnfiAnrop [ocrpouJr Ar,rcceprar{rroHHoecucTeMHoro [oAxoAaLrr{ccneAoBaHueKoMlJreKcHoM r.r3yqeHr,ruHaupo6reurr,rrpuHrlr{[axBKJrroqaroqeMTeopeTuqecKHe ocHoBbI HeIIeHoBoIZ KoHKypeHIII{u B 3ApaBooxpaHeHLrlr, cTpaTeu,urpa3BI,ITu, 3ApaBooxpaHeHl4.fl ropoAa Mocxnrr, MeroAr4Kr{ [JraHLrpoBaHVfl.
pa3Bvtrkrs,ueguquucxoft opraHu3alluv, IroAxoAbI K ylpaBJreHuro KarrecrBoM ue4uqr,rucxofinoMoIqI4, TexHoJIoruH yIIp aBJIeHu, qeIoBeqecKIiIMLI[pI4HIIurIbI,pecyp CaMu B 3ApaBooxpaHeHuu,$opuu kr MeroAbI upoSeccuoHurrrbHoropa3Bkrrufl MeAurlr4HcKorolepcoHaJla, MeroAbI ylpaBneHLrfl Morr4Barluefi, [pr4Hrlr{[br y[paBneHr{,opraHll3a[uonnofi rynmypofi. Mero4onoruqecKiur 6asa uccJreAoBa1ufl,kt[peAcTaBJreHa coBpeMeHHbIMU MeTOAaMI4, aAeKBaTHbIMr,r UeJrr{llccle4onanne BbIrIoJIHeHo Ha3Halrr{TeJrbHoM3aAaqaM.o6reue [epBr,rqHoro Marepvraila, crrc[oJIb3oBaHHeM coBpeMeHHbrx MeroAoB crarracrr4qecKofi o6pa6orKra AaHHux.
Bce3To cBl{AerenbcrByer o AocroBepHocrr{ [onyqeHHhrx pe3ynbraroB, o6ocHonauHocruHafrHbrx rroJroxeHufi, nrrno4oB14peKoMeHAarlufi.OrIeHrca coAeprrcaHlrfl Alrcceprarllrrl lr ee 3aBeprrreHHocrlr[uccepraq]IoHHtul pa6ora I{3JIoxeHa na 313 Jrucrax rr cocrolrr113BBeAeHu{,o6:opa JII{TeparypbI, tJIaBbI <Oprauusa\r4fl,, MareprrrrJrbr, MeroAbr u xapaKTepr{crr{Ka6agrtI{ccJreAoBanvIfl>>,Iuecrl{ uIaB co6crnennrrx rrccneAoBanuit,BbIBoAoB, [paKT[IqecKlltx peKoMeHAaguitkt3aKlrloqeHLrfl,qeTblpex upruoxeuufi.
Cuucoxnl{reparypbl BKrloqaet 507 pa6or - 301 oreqecrBeHHbrx vr206 sapy6exnbx aBropoB.,{uccepraq ufl uJrrrro crpr4p oB aH a 9 6 ru6 tr,rrlaMr{ u 3 I pucyHKo M.HayuHrre [oJroxeHurr Aucceprarluu coorBercrByror rryHKTrrMnacropra uayruofi cuequarrbHocrr,r14.02.033, 5, 6,8<O6qecrseHHoe 3AopoBbe u3ApaBOOXpaHeHr,re)).JIrn'IHuft BKJIaA aBTopa orBerlaer rpe6onanrEau, [peAbf,BJrfleMhrMcol,IcKareJlrouayruofi creleHl{AoKTopa MeArIrII4HcKr.rx HayKIIoKc[equarrbHocrr,r14.02.03.BoBBeAeHuI{ o6ocnosaHa aKTytulbHocrb LIccneAoBaHVss o[peAeJleHbr eroIIeiIb il 3aAAI{I/., [peACTaBJreHbI HayrIHa' HoBI{3Ha I,I [paKT[rIeCKiUI3HaqrIMOCTb,IIOJIOXeHI'I, BbIHOCUMbIe Ha 3aIqI4Ty.flepnaa ulaBa rocBf,IIIeHa o6sopy Jrureparypbr rro BorpocurM KoHKypeHrIur43ApaBooxpaHeHru.BArroporu rpoBeAeH aHarru3 npeArocbrnoK 3apoxAeHr{fl HcoBpeMeHHbx reugeuqufi pa3Bhrrvs.
KoHKypeHrIuuB3ApaBOOXpAH)H]/'I]/.;c$oplrynupoBaHbl 6agosrre[oHf,Tr.rflKoHKypeHur{f,, KoHKypeHrocnoco6Hocrb,KOHKypeHTHOe flpeuMyrrlecrBo; [pelcraBJreHbrMHeHrr_f, yqeHbrx o BilAaxKoHKypeHIII{[ Pr Saxropax, Hd Hee BJrr,Hrorqux. Ouzcanrr MeroAbrH3yqeHr,rflKoHKypeHTocuoco6Hocrl,I MeAuIIuHcKr{x opraHr,r3arlufi. CauocrogrenrnrrfinoApa3AeJr uocBflIIIeH KOHKypeHUT{U B HerocyAapcrBeHHoM ceKrope orerrecrBeHHoro3ApaBooxpaHeHl4q. O6o6qeHvrevaHaJrI{3 tro3BoJrLrnuHa phIHKe MeAilIIHHcKnx ycJryrBycra*oBr4Tb, qro KoHKypeHrU{,coBpeMeHHbrx ycnoBrrflx nepecraer 6srrrI{cKIrcquTeJIbHo SKOHoMLIuecKIIM Ia MapKeTI,IHroBbIM floH.f,Tr,reM.
OHa CTaHoBr{TctKpI{TepI{eM co orB eTcTBLIf, MeAHIII{Hcxo[ opraH u3ar]J1,kr coBpeMeHnuru rp e6oBaHr{{M KKatlecrBy rue4uqI.,Iucxoft rroMolrlll,upo$eccIEoHttrlbHblM KoMrIereHqrIrMIoaopa oypoBHroMorrrBauur{ MeAr.rqr,rHcKoro [epcoH€IJra.HaOpraHr,r3arlHLtcocTo.f,Hl4u upoqeccoBt4xKaK [poU3BOAr4TeJreHaKoHKypeHrocnoco6Hocrr.rycnyru' ypoBHe ee KaqecrBa. flpu 3ToM yql{TbrBaer, qroKOHKypeHTHOfO [perIMyIrIeCTBaO Bp eM eHH IIp Oqecc-o6ecne.reHue3TO He OAHOp€I3OBOe MepoflpLrf,Tvre, apacrxnyruftp a3BkITkIfl. opraHLI3 aIII{LI.Bo nropoft uane upeAcraBJleuu o6reKTna6lro4eruEaMeAr,rur{rlcKr,rx[por43BoAcTBa, aAeKBaTHOCTt4 pecypcHoroo6ecue'IeHIaa, s$QeKTLIBHocru ynpaBneuvrfl., a raKxeBpa3BrTkrfl,KoHKypeHTHoM npeuMyrrlecrBe opraHr43arluu aBTop crpaBeAnr,rBoKOHTIeHTpI{pyer BHI{MaHI4eycJlyr,uLIHHoBarIr4oHHoMyrt ero o6teurt, 3Talbrr,rnpeAMer HccJreAoBaHr4f, e,{I{Hr,rrlbrr,IccneAoBaHprs,Lr ero [poAonxureJrbHocrb.Anropola AocrarorlHo uo4po6no oulrcaHbr MeroAbr uccJreAoB aHyrs., o6ocnonanpa3Mep nrr6opo'rurx coBoKy[Hoctefi, o[LrcaHbr cnoco6rr crarLrcrr4qecxofio6pa6orx?I14KpllTepkrkr.qocroBepHocrr.r nonfreHHbrx pe3yJrbraroB.BHAe nporpaMMa vccJreAoBanufl np[rBeAeHa B Br,rAeBo6o6qeHHoMra6rurqu.
,{ana xapaKTepucrr{Ka6a^:u HccneAoBaHnfl.TperrrMOAI4III{H0KI{XrJIaBa rIocBflIIIeHa aHarru3y ana6ynaropHoro cerMeHTapbrHKaycJlyr ropoAa Mocxnrr. Anrop ycraHoBrlJr orHocureJrrno cra6uJrbHoecoCTOf,HLIe [ap€IMeTpOB, xapaKTepI{3yIOUI{x €MKOCTE pbIHKa MeAI4rIuHCKrlrx y0Jryr,TaKLIx KaKHarypalrsrtfi I{ cror.rMocrnofi o6revrtr; crpyKTypa rro cloco6y oularuIueguqzncrofi rloMolr(rl. Hecuorpr Ha yxyArxeHrae gKoHoMLrrrecxofi cktryarryrucrpaHerIAl{HaMIzqecxufipocr IIeH, 6rursaQuKcr{poBaHcra6rurHufi ctrpocBHaMeA[II[HcKI,Ie ycJryru,B ToM qucrerrJrarHbre, o6yclonneuuufi,[pexAepocroM HaceJIeHI{fl I4 rlpeo6naAanueM TpyAocnoco6noro KoHTr.rHreHTa coypoBHeM AoxoAoBuBcero,cpeAHLtMBbIIIre. CroNnnurraecs BHerrrHr{e ycJroBur, HapfrAy c4ocrarovnofi o6ecue.reHHocrbloyr qacrHbrMr{HaceJreHurr rocyAapcrBeHHbrMr.rMeAUIIIIHcKI{MI4 opraHll3allvlflMla, colocraBr.rMbrMr{[ore.re6Ho-Ar,rarHocruqecKr{MBO3MOXHOCTf,MI,I, IIO3BOJII,IJII,I CAeJIaTb BbIBOA, IITO SKOHOMUTIeCKTIe MeXaHI43MbI UpIL3BLITI,IeMarepuiubHo-TexHl,Iqecxofi 6asrr ucqepnaru ce6s.
KaK caMoAocrarorrHbreI{croqHuKLI pa3Bkrrl4fl. fIepcueKTI,IBbI cBfl3aHbrctIoBbrrrIeHHeM KarlecrBaueguquncxofi rloMolqu, [HHoBaIIuoHHbrM pa3Br{Tr,reM, coBeprrreHcrBoBaHr{eMylpaBJreHl{, BrryTp eHHUMI{, IIp exAe B cero, qeIoBerIecKLIMu pecypcaMll.B uerneprofi uane [poBeAeH SWOT-aHarus cra6brx rr cuJrbHbrx cropoH cerr,rrlacrHhrx MOAUIIIIHCKI]IX opranrasaqraft, ee BHeruHux noguoxnocrefi 14 yrpo3, cIroMouIEIo sKcrepron(pyroro4urelefi 11oIIeHKa BepoflTHocrl'I Ltx peaflu3alluu.HaopraHrd3aqraft, nxoA.rrqr4xrceru) AaHaocHoBaHrau non)qeHHbrx peyJrbraroB,aBTopoM cQoprraynupoBaHbl [puopnTerHbre Ha[paBJreHr.r, p€l3Br4Tr4flceru rracrHbrxMOAI4IIIIIHOKI{X opraHrasaqufi, yHI{BepciIJIbHbIe prrLfl. MeArzrluHcKrlrx opranu:aqnfipiI3rI,IqHbIx $oprur co6crnenHocrl{, oKa3brBarcrrlrlrx MeAHrIraHcKyrc [oMorrlbau6yuaropHbx ycnoBl4rx-B$opnrupoBaHr.re BHyrpr4opraHrd3arlr4onuoft crrcreMbrBHyrpeHHero KoHTpoJIf, KarlecrBa rueAurluscrofi rroMorrltrvunHoBarllrpHHoropasBvrrufl; SopunpoBaHlle BrryrpuopraHn3arlzoHnofi cucreMbr HerpepbrBHoroupoSeccnoHaJlbHoro pa3BrTufl MeAr{rlr{HcKoro [epcoHnJra; coBeprueHcrBoBaHr,re.BlryrpuopraHn3alluoHsoft cucreMbl Morl{Barluu MeAr4rluHcKoro [epcoHaJra;Soprr,ruponaHl,Ie I4 [oAAepxaHl4e[peAlorrrrarelrnofi opraHlr3arlrEounofi KyJrbrypbr.B usrofi rJIaBe coucKareJleMBbIrBJreHbr ocHoBHbreHeAocrarrn, 4eficrnyroqefiB cerl{ rlacrHblx MeAuIIuHcKIax opraunsaqzfi cucreMbr BHyrpeHHero KoHTpoJr.f,KaqecrBa uegnquHcxoft [oMolqu.
Ha ocHoBe pe3yJrbraroB HerrocpeAcrBeHHoroHa6lro,qeur,Ix,ercuepurofi oIIeHKr{, o[poca pyKoBoArrrelefi kt npaueft [oKa3auaHeBO3MOXHOCTb AOCTLIXeHLL BbICOKOIO KaqeCTBa HCKJIIOqUTeJIbHO3aCqeTSlaHanconbrx BJroxeuuit, coBeprrreHcrBoBaHkTf, MarepuarrbHo-Texny.recrofi 6asr,r uocHaIrIeHHf, coBpeMeHHbIM re.Ie6Ho-Al{arHocrr,rqecKr.rM o6opy,UonaHr,reM.HeAocraroqHoe BHuMaH[Ie pa6ore cMeArarIr.rHcKr4M nepcoHarroMneus6exHo BeAerKcHI{xeHI'Irc KaqecrBa neqe6Ho-AllarHocrrlrrecKoro npoqecca,pe3yJIbTaTI4BHocTI4HeAocTarKoB,ero MeAr.rqr,rHcKofiu coIII{€IJIbHofi s$$errnnHocTl4.
C yqeToM BbrrBJreHHbrxa TaKxe uclloJlb3oBanufl 6euulaapxkrHroBoro [oAxoAaaBTopoMpiBpa6oraHa I4 rlpe.{craBJleHa rlerbrpexypoBHeBair cLrcreMa BHyrpeHHero KoHTpoJrf,KarlecrBa MeAIiIIII4HcKofi noMolqravrrHHoBaIIuoHHoro pa3B1rrufl MeAr{rlr{HcKofiopraHl43alluu, oKa3hlBarcIqefi MeAuIII4HcKyro rIoMoIIIb B aM6ynaTopHbrx ycJroBusx.flpegloNeHHa, cucreMa Ha[paBJreHa Ha HerrpepbrBHoe uoBbrrueHgrrKaqecrBa[oMoIrIu, [pI{3BaHa o6ecne.rr4m BoBrerreHHocr6 B npoqecccorpyAHLIKoB Bcex yponuefi B paMrax I4Meloqtrxcf, npo$eccuoHirrrbHbrxrraeAzrlugcxofiKoMllereHrluir kr aAMuHI{crparI,IBHhrx uonHououuft; cuoco6crBoBarb ycrpaHeHuro4e$exron 3a cqer reKyrrreroBbrflBJreHr{fl,ux IIpuqrIH [yTeM He TOJTbKOKOHTpOnrrMeAr.rrlr{Hcxofi goryMeHTarlHrr, HO IiI B pe3yJlbTaTe OIIOHKLI IIMeIO[U,rxCf, SHauZft cIIeJIbro KoppeKIII'Iu u o6yueH[fl lepcoHarra HoBbrM KoMnereHrlr.rrM r{ HaBbrKaM.L[Iecras ruraBa uocBtIIIeHa Id3rreHr{ro opraHrr3arlr{r,r B cerr.r rracrHbrxMeAUUI'IHOKI{X opraHl43allufi o6yrenrar MeAurILrHcKoro [epcoHarroB krucnonb3yrcIq[xcfl MexaHLI3MoB cruMyJrrrpoBaHurr.
Anropola [oKa3aHo, rrroSopnaanruufi uo4xo4 x o6yueHlIro BeAer He roJrbKo K cHuxeHlr]o KoMrrereHocrHoroypoBH-rI corpyAHrIKoB, HO TaKXe Hefarr{BHo orpaxaercfl, Ha KaqecrBe ue4uquncxofitroMolqu v cocrorHllucTLIMyJIoBMOTLIBaIII4I{.?IcuolrsoBaHue roJrbKo MaTepu€nbHbrxc orpl{IIareJIbHbIM rloAKpe[neHr{eM n upene6pexeHr{e HeMareprrulrrbHbrM,rHe Ilo3BoJrrer csopuzponarr y [epcoH€rlra AoJrxHoro ypoBH,u cuoco6crnyer pocry reK)^IecrI,I KaApoB.
C yrerou BbrrBJreHHbrx ccrr.rMynaMr.rMorLIBaIIuI4[oMolrlbro oUeHKLt pe3ynbraroB nnyrpeuuefi arrecrarlulraAMuHlIcTpaTI{BHorouuaHKerr4poBaHufl,rpave6noro [epcoHarla HeAocTaTKoB Lr HaLIcrIoJIb3oBaHkrfl 6eHuIraapxl,IHroBoroocHoBaHLrurloAxoAa aBTopoM 6rgru paspa6oranuTpexypoBHeBaf, cHcreMhl He[pepblBHoro npoSeccnoHarrbHoro prBBr4Tr{,uctrcreMaMarepualbHoro Lr HeMarepl,IulrlbHoro crr,rMynr{poBaHrrfl. BnyrpnopraHr.r3aqr4oHHiurcl'IcreMa HerlpepblBHoro upo$eccuoHttirbHoro pirBurr.rr MeAr,rqlrHcKoro [epcoHarraBKTIOtIaeTBTpI{ ypoBHf,: (aAanral{Ltfl>> - (KoppeKrlltfl>> - (pa3Br{Tr{e)), r{HTerpupoBaHa[paKTLIqecKyIo pa6ory lepcoHulJla kr o6ecueyunaer nocneAoBareJrbHocrbqelenofi xapaKTep o6yrenua Hakrpa3Jrr{qHbrx 3Tauax rpy.uonofi .qe.rrreJrbHocrr{.pa6orofi yqe6Horo rleHrpa, KoopArHupyroqeroO6ecue.ruBaercflAeflTeJrbHocTbcKIILI HI{qECKI4MI,IktCTpaTerI{qeCKIltXaAMI{HIIICTpaTI{BHbIMI,I CTpyKTypaMI{o6pasorareJrbHbrMr{ opraHu3arl}rrMr4C€TI'I,HacBoroKpy[HbIMEocHoBeco3AaHr{.rr€rrrb{HcoB.
Anroporra piBpa6oTaHbr aJrropuTMbr pacqeToBMarepuaflbHbx crr.rMynoB$op* MoruBarlr{u corpyAHr.rKoBB Br{Ae [peAocraBJleHl{fl Bo3MoxHocrefi Ars KapbepHoro pocra, B ToM qucre BpaMKax c[equ€urbHocTl{, yqaaTl,Ifl. B HacTaBHr{rrecTBe, a TaKxe Bo3MoxHocTHBHeApeHr4x ranuonaqrafir4 Br{Abr HeMarepuilrrbHbrx.B rrtase ceArrr,rofi AhccepraHToMycraHoBneHo,rrro 6esrlereHa[paBneHHoyrpaBneHr{fl cyruecrByer pHcK SopuuponaHnfl, opraHr{3arluonnoft Kynbrypbr,IIeHHocTLIroropofi nporllBope.Iaro[peAeneH Tuu unrr6paHHbrM HanpaBJreHuflM p€BBurr{f,.