Отзыв ведущей организации (793510)

Просмтор этого файла доступен только зарегистрированным пользователям. Но у нас супер быстрая регистрация: достаточно только электронной почты!

Текст из файла

(YTBEPXAAIO)flpoperrop ro naYtnoft Pa6oreSe4epaltHoro rocyAapcrBeHHoro6roAxeruoro o6pasoBareJlbHoror{pexAeH}It Bblcllrefo oropa3oBaHprs'<CaparoecK€ul rocyAapcrBeHHatIopLIAI{qeCKa.[ aKaAeMIiIt>'AOKTOp TOpLIAUTIT3CKI{X HayK,upoSeccop<<29OT3bIBne4yrqeftopranrr3arlrru(Degepa.rrbHoro rocyAapcrBeHHoro 6toAxcerHoroo6pasonareJrbHoro yqpelnAeHr{fl Bblclrrero o6pa:onaunr <<CaparoBcKaflrocyAapcrBegHafl ropnAurrecKafl aKaAeMI{fl>> Ha Alrcceprallurc 3afiUena O.neraB.rraAuruupoBuqa <<CranoeJreHr.rerpalr(AaHcKoro npaBasvpa3BrITrIe conpeueuHofi AoKTpITHbIPoccnrl>, [peAcraBJreHHyro Ha corlcKaH[e yuenoficTerreHrr AoKTopa nprrAr{qecKrrx HayKrloc[eqIIaJIbHOCTI{ 12.00.03rpargAaHcKoe IIpaBo; IIpeAIIpnHIIMaTeJIbcKoe IIpaBo; ceuefinoe [paBo;MexAyHapoAHoe qacTHoe rlpaBoZccle4onaHr4e, rrpoBeAeHnoe 3afiqeBblM O.B., aKry€ulbHo rlo prlAy [plFruH.Ha ceroAnsruuufi AeHb orcyrcrByrorKoMIrJIeKcHbIe LIccneAoBaHVtr AoKTpIIHbIqeM ponb I'I npupola AoKTpI4HbI BlpaxAaHcKoro npaBa s Poccuu, B cBq3LI cclrcreMe prcroqHprKoB pocczficroro rpax{AaHcKoro [paBa ocraerctHeorrpeAeneuHofi.MnorueacrreKThr AoKTpI4HbI rpaxAaHcKoro rlpaBa ocralorcfllpaKTuqecKr4 HerrccneAoBaHHbrMr{,aorAeJIbHbIe lpo6neMbl, 3arpoHyrbleBoTHecrLI' HanpuMep'pa6ore, BoBce He u3yqenu.

K TaKoro PoAa BoIIpocaM MoXHonpaBa voco6eHHOCTefi B3anMHofo BJrLrtHr{r AOKTpI{Hbr rpaxAaHcKoroBbrqBreHr4e[paBiAcyAe6Hofi IIpaKTIIKIa, coorHolueHl,Ie AoKTptIHbI rpaxAaHcKoroI{AOTMII[paBa, BbIAeneHI{e cyAe6Hofi AoKTpI4HbI KaK Blr.EA AOKTpI4HrI rpax('4aHcKorocHcTeMe Pocczra,TrpaBa, olpeAeJreHr.re ee cyrrlHocTra u MecTa B [paBoBofiIrpaocMoTpeHLre rpo6reMbr sopvrnpoBa]Htrs. oTHOCI4TeJrbHo c6astailcupoBaHHoufpaxAaHcKI{XBHyrpeHHe coDracoBaHHofi KOHrIelqlII4 npaBoBoro pefynlIpoBaHlltgBOnIoqIII{npaBooTHoIIIeHI{IU, pacKpblTl4e STaIIOB CTaHOBJIeHI4'' oopMl4poBaHl4fl' 'IoAHOpOAHOCTI{coBpeMeHHOfi AOKTpr4Hbr fpaxAaHcKofo npaBa, o6ecneqenzeH€uILlqUe HeICUX O6rquxfpaxAaHcKo-rrpaBoBofi AOKTpr4Hbr, rrpeAllonafaloqefiHaq€ul AIIfl HayqHbIX ilI4cKycchfiI' (o6ulHocrs TepMI{HonorvII4, eALIHcTBonpeAcraB IIeHI4[Io [peAMeTeI4 MeToAe pefyntlpoBanvrfl',Qynrquf,X' IIpI{HIIunaxI4r{crorrHnKax fpaxAaHcKofo [paBa).C yreroMOBTOpTQ\4 qeTKoaKTyiIJIbHocrLI yKa3aHHofi TeMbI,c$opvrylpIpoBaHbl I{eJIb LI saqagrv uccneAoBa:nr4fl' KoTopble oTBeqaloT o6rqervry3aMbICny I4 TeMe AI4CCepTaIILIU, COOTBeTCTByIOT CTpyKType AI{ccepTaIILIOHHOfOrdccneAoB alnr4fl.)ape3ynbTaTbl npoBeAeHuofi pa6oTbl IIoK€l3bIBaIoT BbIcoKI{fiTeoperr{rrecKr4fi H npaKTr4rrecKr,Ifi ypoBeHb noAroroBKpl aBTopa,ero c)Iloco6Hocrbycl]erlrHo pa3peluarb HarrHble npooneMbl.Cle4yer orMerr{Tb o6ruupnyro r4crorrHl4KoBeArlecKyrousMIII4pLTrrecKyIoocHoBy LrccneAoBa]Hkrfl, rrpeAcTaBneHHylo HOpMaTI{BHbIMU [paBOBblMI4Poccnficrofi (De4epaqurar{ccJreAoBaHHbleALIl{cuolrsyxBMarepr{ulJraMl{ cy.ue6Hofi npaKTLIKLl, noApo6HoCCepTaHTOM.3Haqr4TeJrbHyro HopMarplBHyro ocHoBy uccneAoB'<LHr4fl', aBToprroK€l3brBaer yMeHLrenonrraf,vo6o6qaltb vr crrcreMarlr3rlpoBarb 3MrILIpI4qecKI4tft MarepI{EuI,pe3yJlbraTe HoBbIe I{ AOCTOBepHbIe BbIBoAbI.B rlenoM Ar4cceprarlrlrrrpeAcraBJrser co6ofi JIorHqecKI{ 3elBepIIIeHHoe,KOMTTJIeKCHOe, CaMocTof,TeJIbHOeTe opaKTaMLIeTr{qecKoMy14HayrlHoe uccneAoBaHvIe)ccJIeAOBaHI{rc AOKTpI{HbI fpaxAaH cKof o npaBa.IIocBtIIIeHHOenEolrruuscrBo noloxenufi, BbIHoctIMbIX Ha 3aIrII{Ty, o6ocnonanrr3acnyXI,IBaIoT IIoAAepXKll.Ar{cceprarJ.4v,BceIIOJIOXeHI{I OTpaxeHbIcrpyKrypa Koropofi flBilseTc{HaCTpaHI{IIaxpaqLIoHaJIbHOft' OTBeqarcqefirrro npeAorlpeAenl{no u:enbHocrbrrocraBJreHHofi rlenr{ H 3aAaqaM r4ccneAoBaflr4fl.,I,IrroJrHory Al4ccepralluonuofi pa6oru.3naquN,rocrr pe3ynbraroB, [OnyqeHHbrx aBTOpOM npr{ upoBeAeHurlo6yclaenvrBaeTcs'nccneAoB aHvtfl) Anfl pa3BkrT1rfl, HayKu rpaxAaHcKoro npaBacJreAyroqvloi1vt)BbI.qeneHHbIMI4 HaMI4 B coorBercrBl{u co crpyKTypofi 4ltccepralll4?I,BbIBO.{AMI4.B nepnofi HraBe 3acJryxr4Baror oco6oro14 poJII4 AOKTpI,IHbI BBHI4MaHus, BbIBoAbI aBTopa noHflTI{I4CI4CTeMe rpaxAaHcKo-IlpaBoBofo peryJII'IpOBAHUg"oopurraualbHbrM Lr CyqecrBeHHo pac]n;inpflrolquM rlpeAcraBlrelJlrfl'AOKTpI{He flBJIfleTC.rIpaBoBoI{BbIBOA O TOM, IITO 3HalIeHI{e AOKTpI4HbI' KAK OCHOBbI AN.f,Qoprr,rupoBaHLrnilpoqecca[pI{MeHeHI4gKoHKpeTHbIXHopM,tIpo'BJI.f,eTc'BCAENATb OCO3HAHHbII4YCTOfiIII4BbIX NOBEAEHqECK}IX CTEPEOTI{TIOB, TIO3BOJIf,IOIqUXnrr6op roit unuu;groit upaeoeofi KoHcTpyKr\LIu, T1paBoBofo cpeAcTBa3arrlrlrbl IIpaBaI{utlu cloco6aLIMSHHo qepe3 upaBoBylo AoKrpLIHy SopvrupyercxxapaKrep rrpaBorBoprrecrBa (crp.84 [ncceprarlun).nayrnufillpe4craulter 3Hiltll4reJlrnuffLrHrepec BbrBoA aBTopa o ToM, qTo cooTBeTcTBI4e AOKTpI4HbI AOfMe lpax.{aHcKofonpaBa rrporBJr.f,ercrBHacneAoBaHLrv npno6pereHHblx paHee AoKTpLIHanbHbIXycraHoBoK, Lr3MeHeHr.re Koropbrx AorlycruMo JILIIITr nyreM rpanrcSopMallullrlpaBoco3HaHLrfl.14IIpaBonoHI4MaHVfl, 3aKoHoAaTenflkI60nrruuncrsanpeAcraBurelefi :aayKtr u rpaKrr.rrn (crp.I2 4wccepraqnu).

3naquuuM tBrterc.sO TOM, IITO OTKa3 OT AOKTpIIHbI KaK VCTOqII?IKa IIpaBanpoALrKTOBaH HeBo3MoxHOcTbrO qeTKoro OnpeAeneHl4t u o6terrprsv3arlprvBbIBOA AprCCepTaHTa.uaHHofo froH,rTHrl, IAeefooTHOClITeJIbHat ycnoBHocTb cB.f,3aHa c I{HTt3fpaTI{BHbIMxapaKTepoM coBpeMeHHofo [paBonoHplMa[I45., H€uII{qUeM pa3nLIqHbIX HayqHbIXrrrKoJrtI [paBoM cso6oAHofi uHrepuperalllll4 TexI4IILI I4HbIx rIoJIo]KeHnfi gaxona spaMKax IIpoBoAkIMbIX Ha) IHsIX I4ccJreAoeaHllfi (ctp. 82 AllccepTaI\vv).Anropol,l rrpe,{naraerc-lt BbIAeiIrITb BI4ArI oSzquanbHoroBblpaxeHl4tM6ISJIII' flpucorJlacut Ha IIcnoJIb3oBaHLIe AocTIIXeHIIfi rcpllAllqecKoftArrccepTaHTOM rrpeAJroxreHbrTanrxBLIAOB B3ToMy6e4urelbHble o6ocnosaHllt TaKOrc pa3rpaHu-reHvs"[poII3BeAeHI4t:M IOp]IcToBAI,IccepTar\nvBbIAeJIeHo IIf,Tb: rIp]r.Aa]HvlteHao6sgarenrHocrrr B HOpMaT[BHbIX IIpaBoBbIX aKTaX; ccbIJIKaAOKTpI4HaJIbHbIe[poI',I3BeAeHI{',IX'IIO3nIII4I4 IOpIICTOB, BbIpaxeHHbIe B KOHKpeTHbIX[pII[pI4H'f,TI4I{IIo KoHKpeTHOMy IOpI4AI4qeCKOMy AeJIy; ccbIJIKa Ha AOKIpLIHaJIbHbIe[peAcraBJIsIouII{e co6ofirroJro)r{eH v5 KaK o6nleussecrHbre E o6uelpr43HaHHble,arreJIJIf,III{Io K o6rqevry ypoBHIo upo$eccuoH€UlbHoro npaBoco3nanufl;qCIIOJIb3OBaHIde B Cy,4e6nUX peIxeHI{tX TepMI{HOnOTI4VI, He LI3BeCTHOfiperueH?rr3aKOHOAaTeJrbcTBy, HoHayKeIIoryrII4BIUefi TeopeTI,IrIeCKOe O6OCnOeaHI{e B IOpilAI{qecKoI',IB Ilenflx ycTpaHeHl{t cyqecTByloul}lx [po6enoB vInporTuBopequfi;aKTa (crp'82BKrroqeHr{e [paBoBofi 4orrpLrHbr B TeKCT HOpMaTLIBHO|O rlpaBoBofoAr,rcceprarluu).

I4HrepecHbrMTOM.u 3acnyx[BaloqllMIIOAAepXKI4 tBJItreTCf, BbIBOAqro ocHoBHOe MeroAoJrofr{qecKoe 3HarreHue AofMaTHKIAfpaxAaHcKoro rpaBa(rax ee uacru) cocrol4T BOB rlpaBe ln AoKTpHHbIQOpuupoBaHvIkI IIeHHOCTHbIXycraHoBoK peaJrr43arllrlr HopMaruBHbIX rrpeArll{caHuitu ycraHoBJIeH[e opl4eHTupoBAns Aanbuefinrefi 3aKOHOrBOpqecKofi AetrenbHocrll("tp.I07 luccepraqnu).HeMeHee uHTepecHofi flBIIfleTQfl. oUeHKa coBpeMeHHoro cocTOtHI4'I AoKTpIIHbIfpalK,{aHcKoro rpaBa, KoTopat,roero MHeHIIIo, nepexl4BaeT TpaHc:Sopuaquro,o6ycnoaneHHyro Brpr.f,HraeM nocrKJraccprqecrofi [apaArlrMbl, opueHTrrpoBaHHofi naccoBpeMeHHbre Tr4rrbr npaBorroHnwaHkrg, oTpa3I4BIIrefi zsN4eHelrJLrfl', Ilpol{l3olxeAlxl4e[poqeccuoH1lJrbHbrM ropr4ArarrecKr{M coo6qecrBoMHoBbre reHAeHrlr4tr B3ar4Mo AeircrBtrfl, npaKTuKI,IvB nocneAHl{eHayKk1[pI{AecsrI{JIerI4t'gToM' cyqecrBeHHoeHa ee pa3Br4Tr{e oK€t3brBaloT llpoqeccbl coquaJru3alJvru fpa)KAaHcKofoIrpaBa, ((aHTpO[oJIorLI3aIII4D) upanOnoft pe€LIIIHOCTLI' yKpenneHue Hall€lJIB[rhrfl]Flr4eHeorIo3IarI{BI43Ma(.tp.111 Araccepraquu).Hau6olee UeHHIIMI{ BbIBoAaMI4prccneAoBaHo SoprvrupoBaHue AoKTpLIHrIf,BJrf,nropofi rJIaBbI, B Koropofi 6rtlorpaxAaHcKoro npaBaBPoccuu,rorcs cJIeAyIo UII{e :-HaSopvrrapoBaHtre coBpeMeHHoro o6ttttrca HayKpILrAoKTpIlHbITpaNCAaHCKOTOpeqeuqutUpaBa oKa3brB€uru u flpoAoJrxcaror oK€t3brBarb BIrLrflH.Vre3apy6exHbrx rrpaBoBbrx KoHcTpyKIJtIf: 3aI'IMCTBOBaH[e IIpaBoBbIXrporxeArrrefi racropuuecrofi srroxn (crp.129JIeMeHTOB1 guccepraryuw);- npr4MepaMr,r yHr{KarrbHbrx npaBoBblx xapaKTepI4CTI4KOTeTIeCTBeHHOTOrpaxAaHcKofo [paBa tBJIflIOTCfl TaKr{e I{HCTI{TyTbI Lr rIoHf,T}It K€lK CI{CTeMafpaXAaHcKI{X lpaBooTHotueuzfi, cLIcTeMa oTpacnu fpaXAaHcKOro npaBA,np anocy6b eKrHocm (crp- cnequQnra.I 28 - |29Alzc c epr arJvrv) ;coBpeMeHHofo cocTorHlrr poccuficroftfpaxAaHcKofo npaBa nau6onee orqerrr4Bo nposBnrercgAoKTpI{HbIB ycur'elJulrponlrpefynzpoBaHyIfl'BAetrTeJIbHocTLIIopI4AuIIelCKI{XJI}I{,[y6nllrrHo-npaBoBoroBneKyrrlero rIotBJIeH?IeHe xapaKTepHbIX Anfl sapy6exnux npalBolloptAKoBopraHkr3arluoHHo-[paBoBbrx $optnr ropI4AI4qecKI4x JII4ILorcyrcrBlleeAI{HofiKoHrlenqvv npaBa co6crBeHHocrr4 r4 r,IHbIX BeITIHrIX rlpaB, [pI43HaHu:e AoroBopaKaK yHllBepciilIbHoro rlpaBoBoro cpeAcTBaorHolrreH ufi.(wp.l 44 tuccepraquu)peryJILIpoBaHLrfl.

o6UecrseHHbIX;- cyulecrBeHHbrMr{ oco6eHHocrrMr4 coBercKoro 3Tarra pa3Burvrfl AoKTpI4HbIlpaxAaHcKofo [paBa143aKoHOAaTeJrbcTBa flBJIflIIVCb: npuopl{TeT uAeoJIofI4qecKI',IXnocTyJraToB HaA rrpaBoBbrM coAepxaHueM; rocIIoAcTBOrroAxoAa,rr o3r4TraBH3Ma; rrpv oplaTer rocyAaprrpaBoBbrx rcoHcrpyrqzfi, cBs3aHHbrxSKOHOMLTKIIUHOpMaT'I4BI4CTCKO|OcrBeHHofi co6crseHHocrll ; BHeApeHLIec IrJIaHoBo-aAMkrHvrcrparLIBHbrMyKJroHoMMLIHI{MLI3aIJULI 3HaqeHUt:rrapaJrnenbHofiTaKOfOocHoBononafaroqefo rrpr{Hrlr4rra rpaxAaHcKofo npaBa KaK cBoooAa .{oloBopa(.rp.17 2-173 guccepr aguu);-IIOTIbITKLI (CJIEIIO|O>.

Характеристики

Тип файла PDF

PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.

Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.

Список файлов диссертации