Отзыв ведущей организации (793510), страница 2

Просмтор этого файла доступен только зарегистрированным пользователям. Но у нас супер быстрая регистрация: достаточно только электронной почты!

Текст из файла (страница 2)

(MEXAHUIIECKO|O) 3AHMCTBOBAHLTfl, IIOIOXEUUfi,3aKpelneHHbrx B 3aKoHoAarenbcrne rapy6exHblx rocyAapcrB) vI rrepreHeceHtrfl'Harlr{oH€LJrbHyro npaBoByro ctrcTeMyHe IIp}IHOCfTO)Ifl4AaeMOfO no3nTI{BHOfOeSQercra. HarluonalbHyro HarrpaBneHHocrb pa3Bvrrr4s. rrpaBaBcocrotHl{I4o6ecne.rurb roJrbKo rrpeeMcrBeHHocrb rlpaBoBoro MeHT€ulprrera, Ho cttoco6gocrrrrHTeJrJreKTy€urbHo-rro3HaBaremnofiBrAetreJlbHocrll Aonxna SopunpoBarbcflrrocrerreHHo, B rrpoqecce o6pa^eonarerurofi rloAroroBxz 6yayrqero lolplacra qepe3pa3ngqHbre)B ToM rI]IcJIe' uSopuu op1aHll3aqnu yre6Holo [poqecca,racTlre B Ha) {Ho-I4ccJIeAoBaTeJIbcKoft Ae{TenbHocTI4B(ctp'173 guccepr:aquu)'gJIeMeHTaMTpeTbefi rJIaBe, [OcBtIIIeHHOfi OCHOBHbIMAoKrpLrHbr fpax(AaHcKoro rrpaBa Poccuu, cAeiIaHTar,qepe3COBpeMeHHOfipfA TIpIIHIII4TII{aIbHbIXBbIBoAoB.O TOM' IIrO3acnyxuBaroqr{M o4O6peHrar flBIIfreTCfl. BbIBOAB AonxHOfiXapaKTepvIcTLIKa npeAMeTa llpaBoBoro peryn14pgBaHl{s He IIo3BoJIf,eTMepe OIISHI4T6 OCO6eHHOcru rofiunnuocKonbKyu]grOit oTpaCJILI'3€IKotHoAOTeJIb BKalK rJIaBHbIftKaIIecTBe OCHSB6I TaKOfi I4AeHTI4OI'lKaIIuu yK€BbIBaeT Ha MeToAgJreMeHT pa3fpaHLIqeHLIs, yKul3blBaf,B cT.

2BoJpr tr I4MyrrlecrBeHHyro caMocrotreJlbHocrbHefKP@ ua paBeHcTBo' aBToHoMI4IofracrHrlKoB. BcBfl3vrc 9TLIM' MeroATOJIbKO OIIpeAenteT IIpaBOBOe IIOJIOX{eHLIe )n{acTHI4KOB fpan{AaHcKLIXrrpaBoorHolueHl{fi, vrx npaBa LI o6xsaunocru, Ho 14 Qopulzpyer BIIyTpeHHeecoAepxaH[e MexaHr{3Ma rrpaBoBoro perynupoBaHllt B Tofi unvr nnofrt oTpacnl4 I4r,lMeHHo B Mero.4e 3€uroxeHbr ocHoBaHI{t l^nfl I{3MeHeHI{t cSepu [paBoBoroperynl4poBAHhrfl.VIBbIXOAa34 efo IIpeAenbI'cyilIecTBOBaBIIIUeBTeqeHI{eAnrrrenbHofo BpeMeuu (crp.

199 lvrcceprallnu).CyrlecrneHHbrM flBrrfierefl. o6ocrosaHl4e aBTopanpeeMcTBeHHOCTr4MeXAy pa3rr4rrHblMl{06orcyrcrBl4l{I.'ICTOpUqeCKLIMI4 IIepI4OAaMI{ pa3BLITIlflrpaxAaHcKoro npaBa B AopeBoJrroqvoHHofi, conetcKofi H coBpeMeHHofi Pocculao acBflgbrc qeMocHoBorronararou{ue HopMbIo6ulecrseHHbrx orHorrreHr4fi BkInp}IHII?InbI peryJILIpoBaHVscQepe gKoHoMlIKI4,peryJILIpoBaHVfl'r4MyrqecrBeHHbrx r4 rr{qHbrx HeI{MyIrIecrBeHHbIX orHoIrIeHI'Ifi MexAy IpaxAaHaMHoTpaxaloT He TOJIbKO JrOfI{Ky pasBl/jTl4fl,TIaCTHOTO[paBa, Ho, npexAe Bcero'rleHHocrHbre ycraHoBKkr KoHKperHoro rIoJIrITLIqecKoroAl{cceprarllrg). Cne4yer corJracraTbc.flcArlccepraHToM,nepuoAa pasB1rTtts, flpaBa XapaKTepHbIMLI 6rtnucrpottrrro(crp.2L7Ane' coBercKoroI4AeI4 KOJIJIeKTI'IBII3Ma,[puopuTeTacollr4€ulgcrr4qecKofi co6creeHHocrlr, yMaJreHrle TpaAHIILIOHHbIX rIoJIoxeHI4filpaxAaHcKoro 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBa (crp.2l7-2I8 4IEccepraqnu).BHacrotlqeeBpeMf, ocHoBorronararcrryre MexaHr43Mbr lpax(AaHcKo-[paBoBofo perynl4poBaEvrflnpoBo3rnarrreuhrB Koucrzryquu Pocctrficrofi (De4epaquu(crp.218KArrcceprarlr4l4).HIIM oTHoctTct: Tpe6oBaHI'Ie 06 ocyqecTBJIeHLII{ [pa'B I{ cBo6oArlpaBa LI CBO6OAbI ApyfLIXrreJroBeKa rr rpaxrAaHlrHa, KoTopoe He AOJIXHO HapyIraTbqacTHoft )KI{3HI4|, JlruHofi 14nurl (cT.17), upano Ka}KAor.o Ha HeIIpuKocHoBeHHocTbceMefiHofi rai4Hbr,3arqr{ry cBoefi qecrll I4 AoSporo I,IMeHIft (cr.23), [pa-Bo KaxAoroHacBol/x cnoco6Hocrefi vcBo6oAHoe uclloJlb3oBaHIiIelpeAnpI4HI{MaTeJIbcKofiLrI4HOfiHe 3arlpeu{eHHofi(cr.34), Tpe6oBaHr4e oAe_f,TerbHocrr4JILIureHr4r4I4MyIrIeCTBa AIrs'3aKOHOM gKorltoMl{qecKofiplMynlecrBa roJIbKo Iro peureHurocyl;a (cr.35).3acnyxznaerBH',.:$.4.AHLTS, TIOAXOAaBTOpaKorIpeAeiIeHI4IO rroHflTkrfl'(r{cToqHI4K rlpaBa).

Anropotvt BbIAeJIeHbI ABe BO3MO)I{HbIX TIO3LIIIUU K TaKOMyllepnax cBoALITct K oTKa3y oT IIoH.gTLIt <$Optua ltrpaBa) KaKupaeonofi Kareropl{H, T.e. AaHHoe rroH.flTl{e He HyxAaeTct B rIpaBoBoMorrpeAeJleHulo.onpeAeneHur414Ant eroonpeAeneHl4t .4OCTATOqHO I{CIIOJIb3OBATb TO'I I4JII4 I{HOficnoBapb pyccKofo .g3blKa. Bropar opI4eHTLIpoBaHa Ha TpaKToBKy iloH'f,Tl'Ift(HcroqHr4K>v<<Soprvra>>ilpaBa B KaqecrBe npaBoBbIX, c olpeAeneHlleM ux qepe3o6qeyuorpe6uruue cJIoBa, oAHaKo((ucrorrHr4KrrpaBa)HeolpeAeJIeHHbIM.r4rrr4 <SoprvraBsToM cnyqae onpeAeneHye nongrufirpaBa) 6y4er eIrle 6oleeB CUly rlefo [pI4 onpeAeneHLII4ofpaHlTrrlrTbct JII,IIUb yKa3aHI4eM UXnpI43HaKOBau.opQHuiravryK€BaHHbIX rIOHf,lrI,Ift Cne4yerKaK rIpaBoBbIX rareroPufi(crp .2 4 6 -2 47 tuc cepraqura).Bpa6ore ycraHoBJreHo, arro sJreMeHTbI AoKTpI4HbI fpaxAaHcKoro lpaBapa3Aensrorc.rHa co.{epxareJrbHbre 14 SopvrupyrouzernaccuSuKaIIuI4gneMeHTbI.rroJrolKeHbl QyurquoHzulbHble oCO6esnocruAoKTpr4Hbr lpaxAaHcKoro rrpaBa.KBocHoBySJIeMeHTOBcoAepx(areJlbHblM SJIeMeHTaM AoKTpI{HbIfpaxAaHcKofo IIpaBa oTHOCtTCtr [peAMeTvMeTo,4 lpaxAaHcllofo IIpaBa,Synrquu Lr rplrurtrLrnbr lpaxAaHcKoro rlpaBa; K Sopvtzpyoql{M sJIeMeHraMOTHOCflTC' I4CTOIIHI{KLI IPAXAAHCKO|O IJPABU .qOKTPI4HUTJIbHbIE IIOJIOXEHKI'cyge6Hofi rrpaKrlrKrr, HayqHbre rpaBoBble IIrKorIbI (crp.279 Al{ccepraqlzu).B uerneprofi rJraBe AXccepTaIII{?I, B KoTopoE olpeAeneHbllocHoBHbIereHAeHulrra (HanpaueHzr) H3MeHeHr4r AoKrpI,IHbI rpaxAaHcKoro npaBa n Poccuu,ycraneHl{I',I AI4CnO3UTI4I}HbIX HaqzulB rrepByro oqepeAb cneAyeT BbrAeJrprTb BbIBOA O6fpaxAaHcKo-rrpaBoBofo peryJrupoBaHl{t.ocHoBaHHAfl.

Ha HOpMaxllocrolrryAI4CIIO3I4TI4BII[OCTb ecTbrpaxAaHcKolo [paBa IopIIALIqeCKa.fl cBo6oAa cy6lexroerpaxAaHcKr4x rrpaBoorHorueHufi sH6prparbrorI4JII{uttofiBapI'IaHT rIoBeAeHI{'I'HanpaBneHHofo HA npuo6pereHr.re cy6rerrraBHblx I"pax.4aHCKI'IXBbrrrOJIHeHI{e Bo3JIo)KeHHbIXr4MeHHon[paB vHaHa 1I4IIO rpa)KAaHCKIlX o6sgaHHOCtefi, [OCTOnbKyfpan(AaHcKo-rpaBoBoro peryJlllpoBaHusSoprr,re npotBneHus cno6oAblcIIpaBeInI,IBOCTb CylqecTByloqefo MexaHI{3Ma IIaCTlt{oIo npaBarrpotBnteTcs, kI(wp .326 -327 pluccePraqzra).I{ennuna flBlrfl'ercfl. BbIBoA, qro AoKTpLIHa fpaxAaHcKoro rIPaBa n Poccuz neMox{er6rrrrrpLI3HaHa c$opuupoeaHHoft.

K ocuoBHblvr upo6neMal\4 pa3Br4Tvrl.cJIeAyIOIII{e sarropu:fpaxAaHcKofo rrpaBa kr 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBa oTHoctTctorcyrcrB7e cr{creMHocrr{ npaBoBoro peryJlllpoBaltrfl. orHoIIreHLIii B c$eperracrHoro rrpaBa; (pa3MblTocrb) AoKTpI{HbI rlacrHoro npaBa;rpaxAaHcKo-[paBoBbrx rrHcrraTyroBnoA nos4eficrBl4eM2qeQopuaqurpIHTerpaIILloHHbrxnpoqeccoe (crp.3 54-3 5 5 araccepraquu).3aclyxznalouefiBHr4MaHr4errpeAcraBJlterct rIo3I4UI4.fl aBTopa o roM, qroHa[rnq]ue rco4llSuqr4poBaHHoro 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBa cocraBJlter cyxlecrBeHHylooco6ennocTb poccuficroro rpaxAaHcKofo ilpaBa' IIosToMygKoHoMprrrecKr4xyxe c rrepBoroSTarIanpeo6pa:osaHzfi pa3Bnrtre qacrHoro npaBa ocyqecrBJltJlocbrrper4MyxlecrBeHHo qepe3 r<o4uQraralllllo,[pI4 sroM,peurvrcarJvrtt [paBoBoI{rrepe3 ro4uSuxaIII4Io fpalxAaHcKoro,rroJrr{TrrKrr B rracrHoM rrpaBe ocyqecrBJr.f,Jlacbceuefinoro" 3eMenbHoro 3aKoHoAareJlbcrBa.pa:pa6orrH ur{ccneAoBalr.r4fl.B cBorooqepeAb, HafIHbIe\pe4BapflIru [pLIHtrI4e vrilvru3MeHeHKecoorBercrByloqux KoAeKcoB (crp.3 5 6 4xccepmqvu).Cne4yer corJracr{Tbcr c aBTopoM, r{To 3aAaqefi upanoeofi uoILITIaKH n c$epeqacrHoro npaBa.4onxHa crarb KoHconl{Aarlvrflycutrnfi 3aKoHoAareJIt u f{eHbIX nopa:pa6ome piBnurrHhrx nJraHoB 14 rlporHo3oB coBeplileHcrBoBaHl4rl3aKoHoAareJlbcrBa, HaIIeJreHHoro Ha IroBbIIueHLIe crerleHll o6irerrueHoroBo3AeficrBkrfl, npaBoBbrx peryJrrropon.

Taxoe Bo3Aeitctsue AoJIXHo BKilloqarbBce6s Bce c$epurocyAapcrBaIIpa3BI,TVrfl. coBpeMeHHOrOcoIII{aJIbHo-eKoHoMI{qecKororpe[XAaHcKoroQarruuecKl{ pac1uupsrb MeXoTpacJIeBbIe cBfl3llupaBa (crp.37 9 4IaccePraqull).Haroseq, oco6orIeHHbrMr4 B Ar4cceprar\Lrr4,IIo HaIIIeMy MHeHI{I0, f,BJIf,IorctcneAylouxe BbIBoAbI aBTOpa:- AoKTpLIHa KaK KoHIIeIITyaJIbHafl ocHoBa SopultpoBaHvlfl' rpai11AaHcKororrpaBav er.o pa3BuTvrfl, xapaKTepu3yeTcflBHyTpeHHI4M eALIHCTBOM I{CTOpllKO-rrpaBoBofo orrbrra, HayqHofo ocMbrcJreHr{r aKTy€trlbHofo cocroflHl4rl rlpaBoBofi.[efiCTBI,ITeJIrHOCTI4,V3KOTOpOTO BbITeKaeT OcO3HaHI{e IIOTpe6HOCTI{BHa6yAyIUee,o6yclour4Baroqeft SopnrupoBaHr4e coorBercrByloqvx TeHAeHIII{fi e|opa3Br4Tuflpr3MeHeHutx ckIcTeMbI fpaxAaHcKo-IlpaBoBoro perynupoBaHklfl'(nonoxeur4e 2, BbIHocI,IMoe Ha 3auIIlTy);- c oBeprxeHcTBoBaHr{e MexaH Lr3Ma p efynl{poorHorxeHr{fi cBr3aHorpaxAaHcKofo npaBarrpr4Hrlranorrac 6oleevBaH.I4s.

fpaxAaHcK0-IIpaBoBbIXr{erKHM Soprr,rylrapoBaHlleM ocHoBHbIx HaqaJIvrx HopMaTr4BHbIM 3aKpeIIJIeHI{eM BCneA 3a 3aI(pe[JIeHUeM4o6pocoBecrHocrn, rrocKonbKy Ao groro rpe6oBaHufl' pa3yMHocrl4 lIcnpaBeAnr{BocTpr He MoryT paccMaTpprBaTblfl, B KaIIecTBe O6IIIIIIX [p]1Hr(I4IIoB npaBa(nonoNeHue 14, BbIHocI4Moe Ha sarqury);-yBenuqenue ny6nlrqHo-[paBoBbrx cpeAcrB yMeHbruaer o6be]\,I cBo6oAbI'IITO,AJI'KPATKOCPOIIHO|O IICPHOAA, MOXET TIOKA3ATb HEKYIO TIOJIOXI{TENbHYIOAr{HaMLrKy perynupoBalr4fl.,Ho B AonfocporlHofi [epcrIeKTEBe,Mr4HrrMtr3krpyer rro3r4TtrBHoe coAepxaHl{eroficBo6oAbIHanpoTLIB,ocylJlecTBIIeIJufl'rpaxAaHcKr4x ilpaB, Koropar 3€rJroxeHa B MeroAe rpaxAaHcKoro npa3a (cTp.296ALrccepraIII4LI).I4sroxeHze MarepkraJraB lvrcaepraryla ocyulecrBlrflercfl.

rpaMorHblMropr4Ar,rqecKr4M .'I3bIKOM, CCbrJrKI4 Ha HOpMaTI4BHbIe I,I nl4TepaTypHble I{cToqHLIKI{Bnr4cbrBarorcs Bo6qzfiKoHTeKcr paccyxAeHl,Ifi aBTopa, npeAnoxeHllf, t4 BbIBoAbIorJrr4qarorct caMocrorreJrbHocrbro, crpofiuocrbro, apryMeHTllpoBaHHocrbro uuawnofi uoeusHofi.Cne4yer orMerl4rb BbIcoKI{fi Haf{Hblfi ypoBeHb pa6orbl Al{ccepTaHra:rrpeAJrolKeHl4t, BbIHOCHMbIeHA 3aIIIlITy' qBIsIOTCt[ocneAoBaTeJIbHbIM]I VrroAKpeIIJIeHbI AocraroqHo crpofiHblMll paccyXAeHI4{MlI.,{ucceprilqun O'B'3afiqeea XapaKTeprr3yeT opr{ruH€rJrbHocTb TeMaTI{KI,I, JIorlIrIHOcTb I{3JIOxteHI{s'KoMnrreKcHbrfi roAXoAK npoSreMarl4Ke, mo6anbHocrb o6sopa pooctlficKoil3apy6exHofi nprreparypbr, 3Mrtrlrpr4qecKaf rIoAKpelneHHocrbBbIC14LIccJIeAoBaHns',OKat TeOp eTI4tIe CKafl LI IIpaKTLIqeCKaf, 3HaIII{MOCTb'6rrrr I4cnoJIb3oBaHbI B ,n,arlbHefirlrl{xfpaxAaHcKolo [paBa LI cBfl3aHHbIX C HI{MI4Marepualsr AucceprarlzIa Moryrr4ccJreAoBaH:/IflX AOKTpT{Hbrreoperr4qecKr4x [po6neM.

Pesyntrarbr AI{ccepraIII4oHHoro Hccile4oBitrrns. MoryT6rrrrr4c[oJrb3oBaHbr B rrpoqecce rrperroqaBa:avs, KypcoB: <fpax4aucKoe npaBo) u<<ArryalrHbre rpo6JreMbr rpax(AaHcKoro rIpaBD), <Teopux [paBaJlu.{HrrfiBKJra.q aBTopa AtrcaepralJvrvI4rocyAapcrBD).B HayKy rlpocnexl4Baerct BcoAepxaHuu nu6paHHofi TeMbr ra crpyKType pa6orbl, crLIJre LI3JIoxeHZt pa6orbl,rrpr4MeH.f,eMofi MeroAoJrorr4r4,o6ocroeaHzzvrQopuyltlpoBaHlal{ ocHoBHbIXp$ynbraron pa6oru u Lrx anpo1aqlz'n.Anropol,r BbrrBJreHa Lr npoaHuurr{3upoBaHa cnequQvrKa BIwrflHI4n AoKTpIIHbIrpaxAaHcKoro rrpaBa Ha peQopMr4poBaHr{e rpaxAaHcKoro 3aKoHoAareJlbcrBa,araKxre [paKTr{Ky ero npr{MeHeHr{.f,, paccMoTpeHa AoKTpLIHa rpax{AaHcKofo IIpaBaKaK KoHrlerrTyanbHuur ocHoBa Anfl. onpeAeJIeHLIfl [peAMeTarrpaBoBofo perynkrpoBaHlrrrrI MeToAa fpax{AaHcKo-u peanr43,arlul4 cLIcTeMHOfO IIO.4XOAaK ilpllHIII4IIaM,Qyurqnrna vr r4croqHr.rKaM rpaxAaHcKoro npaBa, ortLIcaHMexaHI43MqacrHolpaBoBoro perynr{poBaHr4fl., pezilrr43yeuufi B ycnoBl4.flx npol4cxoAtlquxBo6qecrse rpauc$opvaguir, oKur3brBarorlr{x BnI{flHLre Ha pa3Bvrrl4e rpitxAancKoro3aKoHoAareJrbcrBa, AaHbr BbrBo.qbl o6 ocHoeHbIX TeHAeHIIVtx pa3BvrrLt:E.qoKTpLIHbIfpaxAaHcKofo rrpaBa, cpe4r KoTopbrx oTMeqeHbI ycl{neHl4eAI4CIIO3LITLIBHbIXHaqaJr lpaxAaHcKo-rrpaBoBoro peryJll4poBaHvrfl, rpaHcSopMalll{rr orpacJlHtpaxAaHcKoro npaBa r{ lpax{AaHcKoro 3aKoHoAareJlbcrBa, a raruKe QopMupoBaHueupanonofi IToJII{TI{KI4 n c$epe qacrHoro rlpaBa.Bce yrasaHHbre pe3ynbrarbrr4ccneAoBaluvrfl, .f,BJltrcTc.f, cyIqecrBeHHbIM I{3Harrr{MbrM BKJTaAoM B poccuficnylo ropuAuqecKyro HayKy.

Характеристики

Список файлов диссертации