Отзыв ведущей организации (793510), страница 3
Текст из файла (страница 3)
CQopuyttlpoBaHHbleaBTopoMTeopeTI.IqecKLIeIIoJIoxeHVfl'3HaLIvTeJIbHoHayqHble 3HaHUtBpaccMarpl{BaeMofi cQepe.qBJlf,ercs HayrIHo-KBanusmaquonuofiBbrrroJrHeHHoroclrMr{ccJIeAoBaHvrs,pa6oroft,p acnrnpflIoTCylqe cTByIOIII{e,,{uccepraqur O.E}. 3afiqesaB roropofi Ha ocHoBaHI{lIpa:pa6orauu Teoperl'IqecKl{e IroJIoxeHI4t'oBoKynHocTb KoTopbIX Mox{Ho KB€Ulu$raqupOnaTb KaK HafIHoe AocTu:XeHI4e'Hapflgy c rloJlolKl{relrHofi orleHrofi pe3yJlbraroB AnccepralllloHHoroneo6xoauMblM BblcKa3arb HeKoropbler4ccneAoBaIJ,I,dg, IlpeAcraBJl.fierc.gKpLrrI4qecKLI e 3 aMeq aHVg'.1.B II.
3 uoloxeuufi,BbrHocLrMbrx Ha 3aIIII4Ty, ALICCepraHT, npeAnaras'STarrbI cTaHoBJIeHLIt AOKTpI{HbI rpax{AaHcKofo IIpaBa, LTcxo,qLIT l1:3 KpuTepvflpa3Br4Tocrr4orHoruesuit co6creeHHocrlrBTor uttu usoit [epLIoA rlcro]plIll HarlrerorocyAapcrBa. O,4naxo, rarofi noAXoA rlpeAcraBJlf,erct cJII{IIrKoM y3KI{M. Tar,3Harrr{TeJrbHbre r{3MeHeHr4rr B 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBe, [poI{3oIIIeAIIII4es 2013-2015 rr.,KocHynkrcb KopeHHoro peSopMr4poBaHllt npaBoBbIX LIHcrlITyroB, Ha11p-fiMylo HeorHoc;rrluxcr K orHorrreHlrtM co6creeHHocrl4, Ho cyulecrBoBaBrrrlx Ha Bcexgrarrax,BbrAeJreHHbIX Ar4ccepraHToM.Tar,cyqecrBeHHoMyI{3MeHeHI4IorrpaBoBofo pefynr4poBaHvfl, rroABepfnl4cb IIpaBOBbIe IIHCTIITyTbI, oTHt0c.'IIIII{ect KHpaBcTBeHHbIM ocHoBaMfpaxAaHcKoroIIpaBa,4o6pocoaecTHocTb,ne.{eficrsr{TeJrbHocrb cAeJroK, JrLrrHbIe HeLIMyIrIecrBeHHbIe rlpaBa vr utx cy4e6uax3arrlr{Ta.Bcngs14c gTr{M,rarofirIoAXoA, KaK MI{HI{MYM, He rlo3Bor.ler BbIAOJII4TbBKaqecTBe caMocTof,TeJrbHofo STarra cTaHoBJIeHI4t AOKTpI{HbI fpaxAaHcKoro lpaBanpolr3orrreArxyn l-2013-2015 rr.
pe$oprray lpax{AaucKoro 3aKoHoAareJlbcrBa.2.8 n.4 nonoxeHufi, truHocr4Mbrx Ha 3arrlrrry, Al4acepraHt, o6ocHoBblBaerBbrBoA o roM, qro cyqecrByroune croco6rt casrqlroHl4poBanlltr IIpI4MeHeHLISAoKrpr{Hbr rpaxAaHcKoro rrpaBaAnt peryJII{poBaHI{.s o6qecrBeHHbIX orHoIIreHI{fiKaK B npaBorBoprrecrBe, TaK r4 B rrpaBorlplrMeHeHkrv He o6ecue'rnBalor AonxHoroypoBHs ee Jrerr4Tr4Marlllr4 BBr4Ay rrplrHllulrualrnofi HeBo3MoxtHoc'rI4 qerKoroonpeAereHr,r-f,vro6terruevlr,ar\vr4 AaHHoro rIoHqrLIg,rITo [peIUITcrByerrrpr43HaHr{rc AoKTpr{nu SoprvraJrbHbrM I4crorIHI4KoM rpax(AaHcKoro rlpaBa.oqepeAb,Bceoros u. 6 rroJroxeHufi, nuHoclrMbrx Ha 3aIrII4Ty, Al{ccepraHT yl(a3blBaerHaL1,KaK MaTepllzulbHofo LICTOIIHI''IKa' OAnOfi VI3Qoprvlbr [posBleHr,rt AoKTprrHbrBKoTopblx tBJIf,eTct [pLIAaHLIe [poll3BeAeHuflM IopI4cToB o6sgarelbHocTl{HOpMaTUBHbTX npaBoBbrx aKTax.B n.
4 n n. 6 BLIIVITC'. [poTLIBOpeque' [ocKOJIbKyrrprAaHr{e rpor{3BeAeuusM lopl4croB o6ggatenLHocrl{ B HopMarI'IBHbIX rlpaBoBbxuo ce6e roBoprrr o SoprraarbHoM (ropn4ravecrorr,r) 3aKpenJIeHuLI[plIMeHeHvIfl' vr3Tr4X IIpOu3BeAetwIit, rIpvTAA;1I4u I{M CTaTyCa OflszareJIbHOcTLI AntaKTax yx{e caMoo6ecne.reHHocrt4 rrpr,rHyxAeHrreM,npaBa.qroxapaKTepl43yer Sopnnanurufir I{croqHI4KB cesgu c 3Tr{M no3r{qur aBTopa rpe6yer AononHLITeJIbHofr apryMeHTarJllr4.3.Ha crp. 264 Ar4cceprarluu o6ocHoBblBaercs cBt3b uayilrofi AoKTpI{HbIrpaxAaHcKoro npaBar4 AoKTpLIHiuIbHbIX rIoJIolKeHuit' cy Ae6noft uparrvlKv\ a raKx(eyrBepxAaercr, qrocyAe6Hbre rlpaBoBble tIo3I{qrI[, So'prrlzpyeMbleKoucrzryrlr{oHHbrM Cylovr P@ rz BepxonHuvr CyAoIr,r P@ u QopvtzpoBaBluuectBrrcruuu Ap6zrpaNHbrM Cygovr PO B rlenrx ycrpaHeHl{t BbUIBJIOHHbIXHecooTBercreufi4e@uHvqzrx,kr npo6enon coAepXaTeJIbHoIo XapaKTepa BAOKTp14 H€uIbHbIerrpeAcraBJrrlor co6ofiIIpaBoBbIXQopuurrpaBopeaJrr.r3arl[oHHofi rroJrr{TriKr4 BbIcIIIIlx cyAe6HbIX I4HcraHIIult, KoropbleHyxAarorc_f,B3aKperrneHr.unonsuafi (rrpaBoBa.lt rIo3I{III{t KoucrurylllloHHoro Cyaa P@>oQraquanbHoM rrpv:sHaHuvr [ocpeAcrBoM 3aKoHoAareJlbHoro((npaBoBar rro3arlr4rr BepxonHoroCyaa PO).
,{aunrrfi re3I4.c rpe6yerrorronHr,rreJlbHofo o6ocuoeaHrrfl, nocKonbKy, rlpeAcraBlrflercfl,BBeAeHr4e B 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBoCynu P@>LrrroHgrufi<<npanoBas. no3HIII4.xqrocaMo rlo ceoeKoucru'ryllI4oHHorou (rpaBoBar rro3r{qur Bepxonnoro Cy4a PO) sPsA nla cylqecrBeHHorroBJrkrfler Ha HecoorBercrBtrau npo6eJlbr I{MeHHo coAepx(areJrbHoro xapaKTeparrpaBoBbrx 4e$rznuqr4f,x, rrocKoJrbKy coAepxaHl4e rIpaBoBbIX no3llIlzftBse 3aBurcuror Soprr,rn I{x 3aKpe[reHl{s.4. B u. 9 noloNenI,Ifi, nuuocr{Mbrx Ha 3aIqI,ITy yKa3aHo, rITo B AvrcceprarJ.ur4onpeAersroTcfl sJreMeHTbr AoKTpr4Hbr lpaxAaHcKofo IIpaBa, KoTopble pa3AeJItIoTCfHa coAepx(areJrbHbre sJreMeHTbr AoKTpLrHbr vr sJIeMeHTbI, SoplvrHpyxrrrlue ee.
BocHoBy rnaccuQllKarlzn rroJroxeHrr QynrqLIoH€uIbHbIe oco6enHocrpl.qoKTpr4HbrlpaxAaHcKoro rrpaBa.KgJIeMeHToBco.{epxareJlbHblM gJIeMeHTaM AoKTpI{HhIt2|paxAaHcKofonpaBaoTHoc.'{Tc'IIpeAMeTkIMeToAlpax.4aHcK0rolpaBa,QyHrquunpIlHIItIIIbI rpaxAaHcKoro [paBa; a K gJIeMeHraM' QopuupytoqllMuAOKTprrHy,trcTorrHrrKr4 rpaxAaHcKofo IIpaBa, AoKTpI'IH€uIbHbIe [oJIoxteHLIf,-cyle6nofi npaKrlrKlr, HayrHbre npaBoBble IIrKoJIu.
OAuaKo, B Al4cceprallrilL HeHaTIIJIo oTpaXeHIIe o6ocnosaHue Te3l{casJreMeHTaM AOKTpLTHrToKcoAepXaTeJIbHbIM6urroTHeceHbI TaKLIeToM, rroqeMylpaxAaHcKofo npaBa He MOfyTnanSolee Ba)r{Hbre Kareropr4r{ rpaxAaHcKoro rlpaBa KaK cl{creMa rpaxAaHcKoroz cy6lerrunpaBa (o ee poJILI I{ 3Har{eHLII4Ha crp.l29'I30 4zccepraryuu), o6lerrulpaxAaHcKoro upana (o6I{x BaxtHocrl{ ua crp.l3} 4zccepraquu), rpaBoHa3auII4Ty, OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb.o ToM,5.
CnopHrrna flBJrfleT:s, KaTefopr{.rHHfi B6IBOA aBTOpaAeficTByloqee fpax(AaHcKoe3aKOHOAaTeJIbcTBoHe oTpayaeTqToAaXeyKIIaAA'nepcneKTr4BHOfO peryJrr,rpoBa1krfl. BkIAeH]/rs. HOBO|O TeXHOJIOf?IaIecKcfroocHoBaHHOfOHa coBpeMeHHbrx rluopoBblxBbrcoKorexHoJlorLIqecKoro 6uzueca, HoBbIXAr4cceprarlriu).TeXHOJTOTU'X, pa3BVrTLrno6rer<roe o6opora (crp'369llo uaueMy MHeHrrro, I4croptrefi,pa3Bvrrus,qacrnblxorllollleHl4fi Hepa3 rroATBepxlalocb, lrTo p€t3BIlTI{e HoBbIX TexHoJlorvriL He MeHfeT cylqecrBarpaBoBofiperynupyroqefi o6ulecrneHHble orHoIIreHI4rI.:y1utepvrr4,Bo3Hr4KHoBeHue HoBbrx,bopr B3alrMoAeitcrsus.
cy6beKToB rlpaBa (yorHarrrr4cbMo, renerpa$, reJrerafirr, cerb ((I4HTepHer), 6JIoKrIefiH) He rIpzBeJIo K3HaqeHr4r r4 cyrqecTBa TaKI{x KoHcTpyKqIafirax AoroBop,aKII€TITnAP.Tan,perlb,yrpareB sroficBfrsvr,3aKoHoAareJrb B cQepe lpaxAaHcKoro rrpaBa cKopee AoJIXeH clpeMllTbct KyHr4Bepc€ubHocTtr, He)KeJru pyKoBoAcTBoBaTbc-s cTpeMneHLIeM ypeIyIIkIpoBaHvIArro cTo.f, HHo6.BIIo.xBJItIouII4Xct [poAyKToe qu$ponblx TexHolorufiAucceprar\uv I4Merorct.orAeJrbHble cTuIrlrcTLrrIecKLI HeyAaqHbleI04, crp.242 Ar.rccepralluu) u rloBropbl (crp. 102 n crp.109-110 AucceprarJvrv; crp. 82-83 vr crp.278-279 4uccepraqnra). Kporvre rofo,npeAcTaBlrflercfle IIr{TI{pOBaHLIe He sBrrfleTcs.
gouycrunrofi rexuut<ofi npLTBbrpaxeHut, (crp.48, crp.Harwrc aHLrI{ aBropeO epar a(crp. 3 6, crp. 4 5 aBropesepar a4Iaccepraqun ).Bucxa:aHHbre 3aMeqaHLrA He BJrLrgnr Ha BblcoKr4fr,HaYrHo-TeopervrqecKvrl4u1314 HOC-SI] alacrHblfirpaKTuqecKr4fi ypoBeHb npeAcraBneHHofi AI{CcepraIIuLIxapaKrep.!I oTpa)KaeTAnropeSepaT ALIccepTaIInn cooTBeTcTByeT ee coAep)KaHIIIocoopuynupoBaHHbre B AuccepTarlr{oHHoM I{ccJIeAoBaH[I4 BbIBoAbI I4 rIo.IIo}KeHI4-fl.OcHoeurre pe3yJIbTaTbI ?IccJIeAoBaHI4t, cQoprr'rylllpoBaHHble AIIccepTaHToM'ycnerlrHo anpo6upoBaHbl Ha Bcepoccl4ficrux Lr MeXAyHapoAHbIX HafIHbIXKoH$epeHrlr4rx, r{3JroxeHbr B ony6JII{KoBaHHbIX pa6orax aBTopa, B ToM rII{cJIeBBeAyIIIuXpeIIeH3I{pyeMbIXHayIIH6IXLIgAaHI4gx'yKa3aHHbIXB[IepeqHeBucurefiarTecTaIII{OHHOft KOMLICC}IU.vIcrpyKrypavrlroJIoXeHI{t,(DopnaynupoBKa TeMbI I4ccJIeAoBalrvIs' coAepxaHl{eA1rccepraqrlrv,KpyrpaccMarplaBaeMblxB pa6orerIpo6JIeMBbrHocr{Mbre Ha 3arrlr{Ty, coorBercrByror crrelll4uulbHocrl4 12.00.03-rpaxAaHcKoeqacrHoerrpaBo; rrpeAnpuH?rMareJrbcKoe rlpaBo; ceMefiHoe IIpaBo; Mex(AyHapoAIIoerpaBo.I4sloxeHHoe Bbrrrre rro3BoJrser cAeJlarb BbIBoA o ToM, qTo AI4ccelpTaIII4oHHatpalora ((CraHoBneHrde lrpul3Br4rr4e coBpeMeHHofi AoKTpI{HbIfpax{AaHoKoro lpaBaB poccr4r.D) noJrHocrbro coorBercrByer rpe6oBaHl4tM Pa3AeJIa II flcuoxeuprfi' oenrru f{eHbrx crerreHefi, yrBepxAeHHoro llocranonJleHueMflpanurenbcrBa PO or 24 cenrx6px 20t3 foAa J\b 842, a ee aBrop olerrrpr4cyxcABlaAnuupoBr4q 3afiUee 3acJryxr4Baer rlpucyxAeHl,Is f{eHol4 crerleHl4 AoKroparoplrAr{qecKr{x HayKrro cnerlr4zlnbHocrl{ 12.00.03lpaxAaHcKoe rlpaBo;qaclHoe npaBo.npeArrpraHzMareJrbcKoe rrpaBo; ceMeftHoe IrpaBo; MexAyHapoAHoeOrsrre rroAroroBneH I-\u6ynenrco 3nuonraeuI4nauonrnueivr, AoKTopoMropr{AuqecKr4x HayK, npoQeccopoM, rrpoQeccoporra rca$eApbl rpax(AaHoKoro rrpaBa(De4epalrHoro rocyAapcTBeHHoro 6rcAxerHoro o6pasoBaTeJlbHoro rrpe)KAeHI,ItBbrclrero o6pasonatrur <CaparoncraraKaAeMI4t>),UEa6arosHNarocyAapcTBeuHasBra4Iauupovt ArerceesnqeM,FOpr4AI4qeCKarITKaHAUAaTOMropgAr4qecKllx HayK,,UoIIeHToM, npo$eccopoM Ka$eApbI rpaxAaHcKoro IIpaBa@e4epanrHoro rocyAapcrBeHHoro6rcIxeruoroo6pa3oBareJlbHoro yqpexAeHl{f,Bbrcrrrero o6pa:onaHzr (CaparoBcKar rocyAapcrBeHHatlopl'IAurlecKaflL4aKaAeMI{rD),o6cyxgenuo4o6pen Ha sace1anukr yra:anuofi rcaSe4pu15Mapra 2018 foAa, rporoKoJr Nl 8 (410056, r.
Caparon, yn. BonrcK€ul, 4ovt 1).IIp eAceAarenb crBYIo ryuirraQe4Pulpa)KAaHcKoro rlpaBa Se4epalrHororocyAapcrBeHHoro 6roAxernoroHa 3aceAaHI,ruasonareJlbHoro yqp exAeHl{fl Bblcluero o6paso Banus'<CaparoecKa.tt rocyAapcrBeHHat IopI4AI4rIecAoKrop IopI{ALIrIecKIrx HayK, npoQeccopo 6p4gee\3.14.I{u6yrenro.;'a1:16["a-[4j----{Ha,{anuxnt{[paene*rsKa.qpcBSeneparb|toe rocyAapcrEerHos 6nqxerHotofpa3oBarenbloe yrFew:B*ue suctget o oSgasolah$,"-it K4b"ual€*",kt-ffi9A4pec: 410056, r.
Capator, yl. Bolrcxaa, Aollr If ereQon: (8452) 299 -003Slerrponuax noqra: Post@ssla.ruSlerrpor*rar noura Pnr@ssla.ru.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
