Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (1150252)
Текст из файла
OT3bIBoQuquanrnofo olrroHeHTa Ha Ar.rcceprarluoHrrlro pa6ory Merexosofi AnnrrAn4peennrr <Kounnercu vre4ra(I) c nsoqnanv1aNrvr vt 4vrurKvrnurraHaMrlAaMrl:crpoeH[e v peaKrlr4oHnafl cnoco6nocm>, [peAcraBnennoft K 3aIrILITe HacoracKaHlre y.reuofi crerreHr.r r.aHliv!.ara x[Mr,rqecK]rx HayK rlo crrequanbHocrl402.00.0I - HeopraHllqecKiulxvIMlzfl..,{uccepmq[oHHiur pa6ora MenexosofiA.A.naxryanrnofi o6lacruBbrrroJrHeHanocstlrlena l43freHvlo crpoeHl,It,coBpeMeHHofi xuuuz KoopAvHarlr4oHHbrx coeAr{Heur4fipearqraoHnofi cnoco6nocrvKaraJrrrrr,rqecroft aKTr,rBHocrri KoMrrJIeKcon ue4I'I(I) cuuII3OIJLIAHkIIHbIMI'I LI 3aMeIIIeHHBIMLI quaHaMI{AHbIMI{ JMaHAaM[.Pearquu (pynrqnonaJrr43arlurr opraHutrecKr.rx coeAltrenuficrloMolrlbro t43oIIuaHIlAoBr4Meror oqeHb BaxHoe 3HarreHr{e KaK B $yn.qaruenranrHofi Ha}aKe, TaK I{ B npoMbrllJleHHocr[,Koropoe rpyano nepeorleulrru.
HzrpzJrbr, r{3orluaHr{Abl, qtIaHaMI4AbI flBlIl.rorcfl. npeKypcopaM[rrpl4 nonyqeHrlr4 BantHefturrax KJraccoB lerepoqlrKJrr{qecKr4x coeAItHeHI{fi, npIEuen.tftolplxct B6zoxuunr,r, MeAr{q}rHe u $apvraroJrofiaIa. B 6omnuHcrBe cnfraeB peaKIII{u c BoBrerIeHI{eMAaHHbrx coeAuHeHr.rfi rpe6yror aKTVBarIvfir cBflspr a3or-yrnepoA r,r [poreKaror c ) racrlreMcoe4unenufi [epexoAHbrx MeTaJIJIoB (n qacrHocrr,r, [po]r3BoAHbrx MeranJIoB nnarunosoftrpynnrr). lloracr 6onee AocryrrHbrx KoMnoHeHToB KaraJrr4TlrqecKlrx crrcreM Anr [poqeccoBaxrlrBarlvrr cBfl3vrur3or-yrJrepoA rBJrflercr aKTyarrbHoft saAaqefi B coBpeMeHnofi neoprana.Iecxoft14Koop.ur,rHarlnonnoft xvtMvru.C y.rerovr BbrrrrecKa3aHHoro, TeMa AzcceprarlzoHHofipa6oru, nrr6paHnas MerexonofiA.A., 6e:ycrouro, flBrnercs.
aKTyaJrbHoft, r.K. rronf{eHnbre p$ynbrarbr BHocrr cyurecreennrrfiBKnaA KaK B (byn.qauenraJrbHbre rrpeAcraBneHr.rr o crpoeHr4r.r KoopAI{HaIIIroHHbrx coe4unenufirueau(I) c LI3oqvaHI4.4HbrMr{ v quaHaMr.rAHbrMr4 nr,rraHAaMrr, TaK vI o MexaHI43MaxKaraJrlrrrrqecKux pearqufi aKTr4Barluu cB-rr3r.r C-N c fracrr.reM coeAkrHeHr,rfi ueAIa c JILITaHAaMTIAaHHbrx rr{rroB, TaK r{ B pacuupeHr4e 3HaHr,rfi npraxra4Horo xapaKrepa (no46op 3aMecrl{rereft,JII,ITaIIAOB, paCTBOpr,rTeJIfl, peIKLIMOB SKCIIeprrMeHTa r,r T.A. rrpr{ rrnaHI4pOBaH[[ KaTaJII,ITI,IqeCKT4Xnpoqeccon).[zccepraq[oHHiur pa6ora Merexonofi A.A.
HarrucaHa rro r"paAr.rqlroHHoMy rIJIaHy,Ir3JroxreHa na 109 crpan[rlix r{ cocror4T r.r3 rrrecrr.r rnan (nrruoquul BBeAeHvIe, TpvI fJIaBbI corrr4caHr{eM rroJrf{eHHbrx pe3ynbraroB, gKcrrepuMeHTanbHyro qacrb rI ocHoBHbIe nrrno4rr),crrrlcKa coKparqeHlrtrt u cnucxa qr.rrrrpyeuofi rurreparypbr, BKrloqarcqero 188 nalrtvrenoeanufi.,{zccepraqr4r BKJrroqaer 36 pracynron, 28 cxeM 14 2 ta6tut\st.Bo sseAeHzz aBTop cQopnrynnpoBaJr Lr qerKo o6ocuosar aKTyanbHocrb reMhl, \env vIocHoBHbre 3aAarrr{ Ar,rcceprarlzonnoft pa6orrt.o6naAaror nayunoft noslrsHoft, Teoperrrqecrcoft n [paKTuqecrcofi 3HarrrrMocrtt, *otop"r"Bbl3brBaror gaiueqannft y o[[oHeHTa."JOcnonurre zrorra pa6orrr cBoAtrct K cne.qyrorleMy:Asrop clrHTe3rapoBana r{ oxapaKTeprr3oBaJra prl HoBbrx }r3orlrraHlrAHbx KoMrIJIeKcoBnefirpanurre KoMrrJreKcbr Bkr a [CuBr(CNR)3] vr KoMrIrIeKcbI BLrI.aueaz(I)[Cu(tpmx)(CNR)]*[BF4]- c KoMrrrreKcnbrM MeAbcoAepxarqrM Karr{oHoM.
B cepkrargKcrreprrMeHToB aBTopoM rroKa3aHo, qro Ll3orlr4aHrrAbr B He3HaqIareruuofi crerIeHI,InoABeprarcrcr sneKTpot[unruofi aKrprBar\vpr ilpr.r KoopArrHa\vu x ueau(I). YcrauosreHo, rITo B:rrutuwffprrrecKr4x KorlrqecrBax KoM[Jrer<cu [CuBr(CNR)3] cnoco6urr K aKTLIBauI,ITI Ir3oIII{aHLIAoBIIO OTHOIIIeHI{IO peaKIIII?I C IepBLIIIHbIMI,I n BTOpI,IIIHbIMII aMUIHAMU\ qTO npnBOAI4T Ko6pa:onanulo aMlIAt4HoB.Anropou [onyrreH tr oxapaKTep]r3oBaH prA HoBbrx roMoJIerITpIrIecKvx LIoHHbrxrueau(I) c ALIaTIKI,IIIIzaHaMTAzIMLI BLrAa [Cu(NCNRa)+]-[BF+]- v pflL-KoMrrrreKcoB-.cMerrraHnonr{raHAHbD( KoMrIneKcoB BI{Aa [Cu(tpm* )(NCNRT)] [BF4]-Anrop [poBenac]IcreMarvqecKr,re uccneAoBaHlrr KaraJrlrr]rqecKoro npoqeccarlr{KJrorrpucoeAr.rHeHr.rs KeroHr.rrpoHoB K rr{irnKunrlr4aHaMr,rAaM (c o6paaonanveu 5ElMnno3aMerrleHHbrx rerepoqurlon) c fracrr.reM B KarlecrBe KararllrcaropoB KoMrIJIeKcoBueav(I).
Baxnrrft rroJrorc.rreJrsnrrfi pe3ynbrar AaHHbD( r4ccJle.4oBaHufi - npe4JloxeH Honrrfirro.ryoA K cvHTe3y 2,3-aurugpo-1,2,4-oxcaAr{a3onoB B oAHy craArrro. flpone4eua oITLIMLI3aIITUIKarilJll,ITuqecroft c[creMbr Lr ycnonzfi npoBeAen[r KarilJrr,rrr{rrecKoro [poqecca. AnropycTaHoBLrJra, IITO B XOAe peaxqllllll q[KJIOlp[coeAVHeHI4r aKTI,IBaIIU' AOCTI{raeTC.S 3a CqeTKoopAI{HaII[?I qI{aHaMLIAoB K MeTaJIJIoIIenrpy ue4I'I(I).IIpu LrccJreAoBaHlrr{ peaKrlr,rrr r43orlrraHr.IAHbx KoMIrJIeKcon nre4I,l(I) c HLITpoHaMLIaBTopoM BrrepBbre rron1'.reH r{ crpyKTypHo oxapaKTeprrcoBaH roMoJle[Tvqecrufi KoM[JIeKc[Cu{ON(Me)CPh2}a]2*[BFo]-r, c qerbrpbM.f, MoneKynaMr4 HzrpoHa, KoopAI{HLtpoBaHbIMa KrleHTpurnbHoMy aToMy MeTaJIJIa [ocpeAcrBoM aToMoB KvcnopoAa HilTpoHoB.C nDarruqecroft ro.rKlr gpeHzs p*ynbrarbr BbrrroJrHeHHoft Merexonofi A.A.
pa6orrtr{HTepecHbr reM, rrro aBTopoM rrpeAnoxeH AocraroqHo e(f(fexrunnrnl ueroA rlonyrreHlltI,2,4-oxca4r.ra3oJroB IIlIKJIonplIcoeAIrHeHI,IeM KeroHlrrpoHoB K3arueIIIeHHbrxpa6ore u3oIII{aHI4AHoro KoMlJIeKcarrrorrpeAnoxennrrfi aBTopoM KaraJILITLIqecrcvft npoqeccrraeau(I). Heo6xoArauo oco6o orMerr{Tb,rrporeKaer B AocraroqHo MsrKr,rx ycnoBr4rx.
VcraHonnenze oIrrI4MilJIbHbD( ycronuftgKcnepr,rMeHTa, uo46op cooruorreHr{.f, KaraJrrircaropa 14 peareHToB, pacrBopl,ITent n r.Ir.tBrrrorcs HecoMHeHHo BaxHbrMr4 MoMeHTaMH rrpu nparruvecroft oTITLIMLI3aIILIIIKaraJr[Tr{rlecKoro rlpoqecca.llpe4loxeHHbre aBTopoM MeroAr.rKra cr4HTe3a r.r3orluaHlrAHbrx n qTIaHaMLIAHrD(KoM[JreKcor vreav(I) 6ylyt rrHTepecHhr c roqKr.r 3peHrlr cr.rHTerr{rrecr<oft xr.ruzu npv [onfrenlltlKoMrrJreKcHbx coeAr4Henuft ue4r.r n ua6oparop[tx pzt3Jl]Iqnoro npo(f unx.ArIiIJIKr4nrIr{aHaMr4AaMcIrp}rMeHeHr4eM r4ccneAoBarrHoro BBtrgoArr coorBercrByror 3ar{BneHHbrMsoupocrr uo .4r,rcceprauuoHHofi pa6ore1.flpuu5-7>>rIeJUrMriccJreAoBan[rr,rxopomo apryMeHTl{poBaHbr.:uccneAoBaHrrr,r peaKrlr.ronnofi cnoco6nocrlr Lr3orILraHr.rAHbD( KoM[JIeKcos NaeaIa(I) aBTopAeraJrbHo rrepeq[cnrer Hyrcneo(pr{Jrbr, c KoropbrMrr <6ruru npoBeAeHbr peaKII}IIa coeAznenufi 1-4(crp.
47-48 4uccepraguu), rocne qeroaBTop roBopt4r o6 orcyrcrBlll4 rlpoAyKroBAaHHbrx peaxqufi. ,{anee cneAyror yroqHeHrrrr (crp. 48 Ar{cceprallrara), vro B HeKoropbrxKoHKperHbrx cJr1..{uil, Koropbre orrr{caHbr yxe 6oree AerulJrbno, yAanocb Ha6moAarro6pasonanlre [poAyKTon peaxqzft. O4naro, [pr.r groM Hr.r B rJraBe 2 (o6cyxaeHlle pe3ynrraron),HH B rJraBe 5 (3rccnepuMeHTaJrbHiur uacrr) He rrpr,rBeAeHbr ycnoBrrt npoBeAeHl{t gKcrIepI4MeHToB,AJrf, KOTOpbD( He yAanOCb AeTeKTr,rpOBaTb B peaKrlrroHHbx cMectx [poAyKToB coqeTaHu.f,nyrneo(fuloB v AufloJrefi c ilsoquann4aNru. Aryaro, ero 6rrro 6rr o.reHs [oJIe3Ho Ars.rrnrarer*,r.r.
6onee ycfierrrnbre peaxqr{r4 coeArrHeHrrir l-4, orrr4caHHbre aBTopoM Ha crpaHl4uax 48-49Ar,rcceprarluu, B T.rr. v KaraJrr.rrlrqecKrre, [pvBeAeHbr y]Ke c neo6xoALIMbIMI4gKcnepnMeuTaJrbHbrMu no4po6nocrxun (uro Bbr3brBaer saronouepurrfi Borlpoc o6oco6ennocrsx [poBeAeHr.rr Bbrrlreo6osHa.reuHbrx gKcrlepuuenron).onvcanvrv xapaKTeprrcrr.rK HoBbfx coeArrHeHr.rfi asr p oqeHb JIaxoHLItIHo (unor4a,cnuurr<ou) olLtchrBaer crreKTpanbHbre xapaKTeplrcrlrKrr coeArrHeHllit, u npunoAI,IT pe3ynbrarblrasuepeuufi uonapnoft aneKTporpoBoAnocrr4 vr repMorpaBnMerpkrkr (crp. 44, 54, 60Ar,rcceprarlzz).
Bosru.rKaer Borrpoc, c rarofi rleJrbro 6srlrn Bbr[oJrHeHbr AaHHbIe Ir3MepeHI4t..{annyro qacrb o6cyNgenu-a MoxHo 6rno 6rr pac[]rpr.rrb Anr n]qruero noHuMaHI4rI rIrITareJIeMpe3ynbraroB rrpoBeAeHHbrx LrccJleAonanufi .2. flpu3. Crp. 59 4ucceprarltrtr. flpz ouzcanuu VIK crreKrpoB KoMnJreKcos 16-23, aBrop o6paqaerBHlrMaHr.re qurraters. Ha HaJrnqr{e AByx rroJroc rrorJrorrlenrlf, s o6nacrqx 2239-2252 u 2208-2224-lcM-', xapaKTepHED( AJUr BarreHTHbx xore6anufi cBfl3u C=N, u roBoprlT, tITo BepotrHo grocB.rrcarro c pa3pyrleHr4eM KoMrrJreKcos s ra6rerrax KBr. flpu erolr aBTop He )[{a3blBaerBo3MoxHbre npoAyKTbr pirnoxeHl,I.fl KoMrIJreKcoB. T.r.
Aanee (na crp. 60) AnAcoorBercrByrorqr4x ceo6oAHrx Ar{iIJrKrrnqLraHaMLrAoB yKzr:aH AI,IarIa3oH r<one6anuficoorBercrByrorqefi cBfl3kr xat< 22Il-2224 cr-t, ,o ror[rrHo rrpeArronoxuTb, rITo pa3pyIrIeHLIerrporeKaer c Bbr,4eneHr{eM HeKoopAHHr4poBaHHoro ALraJrKVnrIr{aHaMr,IAa. 9eu Moxer aBTopo6r.f,cHrarb noAo6noe pa3noxeHrle KoMlJIeKcos n ra6rerKax KBr?4.
Cneayroqufi nonpoc ((BbrreKaer) rr3 npeAbrAyrqero. Anrop o[rrcbrBaer KoMtIJIeKcbI 16-23 xarruaroycrofiqlrBbre B pacrBope. Hanpuuep, B pacrnope CDCI3, KaK yKa3aHo Ha crp. 60, onuHaqurHrilor pa3Jrararbcr B rerreHrie 15-30 Mr.rHyr npu KoMHaruofi reuneparype. Bu.quuo uo srofirpurrlrHe nx crreKTpsr -f,MP 6rrnz sa(furcupoBarrbr B pacrBope CDzClz. Bognzraer Borlpoc: BrreM npurrrlHa neycroftrrr4BocrLr AaHHbD( Ar,rurnKr,rnrluaHaMr4AHbrx KoMrrJreKcoB MeAI,I (nanpzuepcoeAr.rHeHrlfi [Cu(tpm*XNCNRT)]+[BF4]-? Oxucnenue KricJropoAoM Bo3Ayxa, r]rApoirr43 srarofiBo3Ayxa, Ar,rccorlr4arlurr KoMrrJreKca - orlrleflneH]Ie qrIaHaMI,IAa c AanbHefturuura rpoueccaMu,r4nr.r peaKrlns.
atTvtBvtpoBaHHoro qnaHaMr4Anoro m,rranAa? Kpoue roro, [poBoArrnrlcb JwIHccJreAoBaHus. cta6utsHocrr,r 14 rrpeBp2rrleuufi rounneKcoB B p Jrr4qHbx pacrBoplrrenxx (uaup.,HacKoJrbKo cra6ranuree pacrBopbr KoMrrJreKcon n CD2CI2, rreM B CDCI3? Bo3Mo)KHo, KoMrIJIeKcbI6ylyr ycroft.runrr B pacrBope Tf(D, arleroHrdrpuna) u rnepAoft (|ase?5. B rnase 4 npu [orrcKe orrrvMaJrbubx napaMerpoB npoBe4envs.
Характеристики
Тип файла PDF
PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.
Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
