Отзыв официального оппонента (1149001)
Текст из файла
HaOrrsrn oSuqua;rnnoro otrloHeHTaArrcceprarl[rc E;runrconofi ArerccaHlprr O,reroBnbr <<O6pa:onaulre B o6,'Iacru peJrlrrlrlrB rrrKoJre e Poccuu rr crpaHax EnponefrcKoro coro3a: cpaBHr{rensnrrft aHaJrI{3D,rrpeAcraBJreHHyro Ha corrcKaHrre yqeHoe crerreHrr KaHArrAara Qu.rroco$cKlrx HayK rlocneqrraJrbHocru 09.00. I 4 - {n,rocoQun pe;rrlruu u peJrr{rr{oBeAeHrretBo:pocuree Bril4fl:avre penuruu u ee 6oree aKTuBHafl ponb B uy6rrauHorr,r npocrpaHcrBe,I43MeHeHr,Ie penl4rlao3Horolaruua$ra *nofr4x'crpaH,cBr3aHHoecB3allMocBg3b penr4rr4o3Hbrx Morr{BoB 14 ueNayHapciAHofo reppopr43MaMI,IrpaII[eft, croxHaru r.
A. KapAHHzuIbHbMo6pa:orrl rroBJrlr{Jrlr Ha BocnpuflTue pentrrulr B Mr4pe rd nocnyxranr.r npuuunofi pocra oco6oror.rHTepecaro6pasonaH4roB o6tacrnB rrofipenprrrrr4.cr4Tyar\r4vr rrrKoJranpeAcraBnser co6ofiI{Aeanbnyro urar(foprr.ry, rAe B rrpouecce rtrarora, o6cyx4eHus. H anurv3a reM, cBt3aHHbrx cpelurzefr, o6re4uunorc.g o6ulecrBoLr Lr:e^rr4BH4.,rrro tBrsercs o6gsareJrbHblM ycnoBueM AntcyuecrBoBaHuq Mexpen[rrr4o3Horo Lt MexKynbrypHoro o6qeuus.Tarulr o6pasou, TeMaAl,Icceprarlr4oHHoro uccneAoBaHus A.O.
Erusxonoft <O6pa:onaHr4e B o6racru penurvru B IITKoJIesPoccuu Lr crpauax Enporeficxorocoro3a:upe:nuuaftHo aKTytu'rbuofi u cBoeBpeMensofr'cpannure.nrnlrft aHaJrr43) rlpeAcraBntercs.HoeusHa [peAcraBneHuofi Ar4cceprauuu. o6ycloBJreHa reM,qro n nefi BnepBble Baxa4enauuecroft HayKe npeAnpr4HrrMaeTcr rlorrbrTKa KoMrrneKcHoro KoMndpaTr4BHoror4ccJreroBauur o6pa:oBaHvfls o1nactu penklrnrre conpefeHHofi Poccun rr B HeKoropbrx crpauaxEnpoueficroro colo3a, F.naroAaps r4crronb3oBaHulo cpaBur4TenbHoro anarru3a,LI3yrIeHI4egraHoBJreHr{fl,Mpa3ltrrr4s tuKoJrbHoro o6pasoBaHrrg.
n o6racru pennrl4l{ s Poccuu tloMelrlaerctMelKAyHapo4uufi KoHTeKcr,rrpenoAaBaHr,re perrr4rr4r4rrroBrro3BoJrrer BbItBr4Tb ornl,rql,ITenbHb{ r{eprbr, nptacyllldeB poccuficxoilrrrKoJreB paMKax npeAMera <OcuoebrpeJIIlrI4o3HbIXKynbryp Iz csercxoE 3Tr4Kr4).luccepraqur r4Meer r{erKyro crpyKrypy: oHa cocror.rr ,r3 .[Byx fJIaB, BBeAeH]Is,3aKrrroqeHut u o1utupnoit 6u6ll.uorpa@rau, BKrrroqarcqei,t a ce6fl.340 HauruesonaHufi TpyAoB HapyccKoM H auuuficKoM r3brKax, MHorr4e r43 Koropbrx B[epBbre BBoAflTcfl e uayuurtft o6opor norerlecrBeHHbrx rlccneroBaHr4rx penr4rrra.g aiiy* rJraBax Ar4cceprarlr{r4peualorcr saraqv, c$ opnayrupoBaHHbreeAeuuir.noneIIocneAoBareJIbHollepnaa rJraBa <LflrolrHoe o6pa:onaHr4e B o6racru penr,rrlrn B crpaHax Enpoueftcrorocoro3a) cocror.rrr,r3AByx naparpaSqBrrpenoAaBaHn.rr 3HaHr.rfi o14rrocBstuena aHanr43y vro4ereft LI TeHAeHIIui,tpelurur4 B rrrKoneocHoBHbre Melr4yHapoAHbrenB crpaHaxEaponefrcroro coro3a.
Paccnrarpl{BalorcsenponeftcKr4e AoKyMeHTbrQoprr,rupyrorurae o6uleeeponeftcxufi KoHceHcycrlaccnouxaqua cyrqecrByrou{uxnBs o6nactun c$epe penl4ruo3Horo o6pa:oBanr4fl,3ToM Bonpoce. flponoAurca aHuru3 nEnpone ir,roAe:refi [penoAaBaHr4s znauuiropervtun,yAenfleTcq BHr,rMaHr4e coBpeMeHHbrM o6uleeBponeficKl4M TeHAeHUPIqM B OOIaCTI4 I{IKOJIbHOIOo$pa:oeauuq o penufI,ru. ,{elarorcq o6ocHosaHnble BbIBoIbI o roM, tiro cyuecrByrouue MoA€JII4I4 rro.qxo.4br KnpenoAaBatnro penr4fl4u B rrrKore B crpaHax Enponu pa3nuqalorcs ilo orHoIrIeHuIoK cyrqecrByrouleMy penun{o3HoMy MHoroo6pasuro, no xapaKTepy uepKoBuo-rocyAapcrBeHHblxorsorueHufi rr ponr4 penurr4o3HF,rx opfaHr4zauuitt n o6pa:oearelrnoft c$epe, ilo IIeJII4' KoropyrcnpecneAyer penr4rr4o3Hoe o6pa:oBaHrre.
tro feofpa$uuecro-rou$eccltonanbHoMy nplaHul4ny,cB{3aHHoMy c rrcropr{qecKr4Mr4 oco6enHocrqMl4 paclpocrpaneHl4qroroI{JII,I t4Horo HanpaBneHI'I{xpr4crr4aHcrBa, a raKxe no cnoco6y opfaHl'I3auuu o6pa:onal,:^ufl.Bo nropofi rtraBe <O6pa:onaHue B o6:racrn penvfuu B coBpeMeHuofi poccltficxofr [IKoJIepr enponeitcxufi KoHTeKcr), cocrorrqeil v3 rpex naparpa$oB, paccMarplrBalorct Prcropvrfl3apoxreHr4srrpa3Bvrrzrfl rrrKo:rr,Horo npenoAaiaHuxopenl4flru[oApo6Ho r4ccneAyercfl coAepxaHr.re Kaxroro ir3 MoAy.neft., nxo4atul4xpenr4rr4o3nbrx Kynbryp Lr cBercKofi srraKra)enponeficxr4x MoAeJreff o6pasonaHr4sBnBconpeueuuofi Poccuu,ruxolrnrtfiKypc (OcHoBv npoBoAl{Tcs cpaBHl4relrnrtfi anurkr3 poccnficKofiI4o6lacru penl{rl4u B tuKotle.
B xoHrle lJIaBbI cAenaHbl rrerKoc$oprraylnpoBaHHbre BbrBoAEr o xapaKrepe H ueJltx pen?Ifl{o3Horo o6pa-:oBaHr4s. n poccnftcrofiruKoJre B cpaBHeHIrI4 c eBponefrcxxru oIIbIToM.BsarrroqeHr4r4 Alrccepraqr4r4 rroABoArrcfl. HTorllr LIccJIeAoBaHLrflpl t43llafalorgq eroA. O. EruHr<osa orMer{aer, qro, rtpucyulne npeAntery <OcnoBbI penurl{o3HblxKynbryp Lr ceercxoit orlrKr4) rou{eccuoHaJlbHble xapaKTepl{cruKu, cenaparvBHocrbopfaHl43arlHr{ ypoKOB O pen\rTr4 B LrrKorre, [puopl4TeTHoe noJloxeHze AoMl{Hl{pytouefipe3ynbrarbr.pen?rfr4o3Hofr rpaluUu1414 ee qesuocrefi, Koropble IIpupaBHI{Balorct K o6u1esarlHoHaJIbHbIM, HerBJrrrlorcs yHr4KaJIbHblMr.r qepraMu poccufictcofi MoAeJII{, ecJII4 paccMarpllBarbeeBo6qeeeponeficrou KoHTeKcre.
B Ue:ronr, opfaHr43alll,If, I4 IIeJII{ txKoJlbuoro npenoAaBaE[s. openurr.rue PoccuuSoprr,lzurrHo coorBercrBylor enponeficxul.t MoAetIqM penfirllo3Hofoo6pa:onauus. B ro xe ripeMq aBTop'AHccepraIII4I4 orMerraer, qro penl4rllo3Hoe MHofoo6pazue uMHoroHarlr4onalrnufr xapaKTep poccrlficxoro o6ulecrBa B coAep)KaHva LI crpyKrype KypcaOPKC3 orpaxeHbr HeAocraroqHo, a ceilaparl4BHocrb poccuftcttofiMoAeJIIT o6pasonanu.a no6lacru penlrfr4r4 B rrrKone trcKrroqaer uHrerparuoHuft IIOAXoA, eaNHrtfr I^nfl raxofivHoroxou$ecclroHaJIbHofi crpaHrr xar< P occlt g.OgrosHHe nonox{eHr,rqocHoBarerbHyxt alpo6aur4ror.rupe3ynbrarbl AI'IccepraIII4oHHoro uccre.{oBaHl4s npolllnuilpeAcraBneHbr B'5 ny6nnr<aul4tx aBTopa (n rona qucJle, n oAnofrcrarbe B per{eH3r4pyeMoM )r{ypHane v3 flepeuirx BAK P@r4HAeKcr.rpyeMoMe SCOPUS), a raxNe B BbrcrynJleHl4qxnAByx crarbf,xB* xypHiIJIe,Ha xou$epeHunqx.
Aerope$epar uny6:u.rraqnrr Aocraror{Ho rIoJIHo orpaxarcT corepx{aHl4e AI'IccepraIII4I4.Taruru o6pa:ou, Ar{cceprauraq A.O. Brl,tHnosofi [peAcraBnser co6ofi op]IruHaJlbHoe,caMocToqTeJrbHoe, 3aBeprxeHHoe HayqHoe l,rccneAoBaHue, pe3ynbTaTbl KoTopofo I,IMeloT KaKTeoperr.{qecKyro, TaK u [paKTI4rIecKyIo I]eHHocrb e ircc,re4yeuofiB ro Ne BpeMr Atrcceprauuq A.O. E:ruHxosofro6lacru.coAepxlzr HeKoropble [oJIoxeHLIfl,Koropbre xoreJrocb 6sl ocnopurb, a raK)Ke onpeAeJI€HHbIe coAepx{areJlbHbleHEAOCTATKI4:1.8I,IMeroAoJloruqecKue.Ar,rcceprarluu AoBonr,Ho Lracro ynorpe6nriercx BbrpaxeHple (rocyAapcrBeHHaflrlepKoBb), r4 K r{r4cny LrMeroulr4xAr{cceprarluu Ancrpas. Eemrus(nru uueeruux) ee crpaH npl4qrtcntrcTcs B pa3Hblx Mecrax, Vicnatut floruuta, LUneqn.r, Hopnernx, flanw.H Anr;rus.flpe4crannflercfl, rrro oro BbrpaxeHr4e rpe6yer 6oree ror{Horo onpeAeneHlztr, rIocKoJIbKy6olrrunscrBe cnyqaeB peqb r,rAer He croJrr,Ko orIepKBr4, cKoJrbKoo rpaAr4qr{ouHofiAn.sroro3aKoHoAareJIbHoMr4Jrr4Bcraryce rocylapcrBeguoftl{Hofo rocyAapcrBa penvruvr, a KTaKOBIIMrocyAapcrBau n Enpone orHoc.r{Tcfl [paKTr4rrecKl{ Ece.
[uccepraur IIIrIrrer, qro cyuecrBoBaHl4erocyAapcrBeuHoft rIepKBr4 BJrr{.rrer Ha coAepxaHrae penl4rl,Io3Horo o6pa:onanl4s, rIocKoJIbKy, KaK3To r4Meer Mecro npnMeHl{TenbHoxpr4crr4aHcKrre rpaAr.rqun> (c.rIx Beluxolpurauuu,52 guccepraw4u).OiHur.ocoBepuIeHHo cBercKr4e KaK Opauqlra, uMelorKOTOpbrg, TeM<oro6paNaer [pel4MylqecrBeuHoBce eBponeffcrne crpaHbl, B ToM tIt4cJIe,'uc*rloututeJlbHoxprlcrlaaHcKtre rpaliurluu,He MeHee, ilOpoxAaror caMbre pa3Hble llocneAcrBtlfl, B TOM rrLICIe, BC(bepepenunlo3Ho ro o6pa-: o Baur4fl .flpe4crannAe'rcs, rrro Anr Aausoi.r Anccepraupll{ BaxHbIM.gBJlserct He crotlbKo craryc rofir4rrkrlruoftuepKBr4, cKoJrbKo cneuu$u'{ecxfie oco6enuocru roHxpernoft xpncruaucxofirou$eccul.r, Koropafl B r4cropr4rrecKoMr.r Mr4poBo33peHqecKoM cMblcne AoMI4HI4pyern roftnlunuofr crpaue, B ToM r{r{cJre, oKa3brBar Btr4flHkre Ha coAepxaHlle IuKoJIbHoro o6pasonauur.
KpoueTofo, orr4 cneuusu.recxue oco6eHHocrn raKxe otcl:rmator cyulecrBeHHoe Bo3AeficrBl4e Ha ro,r{To B rr4cceprauuu(u B MHoroqr4creuHorixou$eccuoHaJrbHoeHnr.{Teparypelro ?ToMy nono4y) o[peAentercsuexouQecclroHaJ'rbHoe o6pa:onaHue.,{rzccepraur Hac. 34 r?Iller:<KouSeccuoHaJrbHoe penr.rfr4o3Hoe o6paso BaHvre, KaK npaBI4JIo, xapaKTepHo An.ugauaAuoft Enponu, B Koropbrx upeo6na4aer Karonuqusr,I nrla [porecraHTlr3Munprlo14KaK'rex ctpauKoropble IIMeJIIIcl4x nop uMe]oT focyAapcTBeHHyio uepKoBb)).
onHaro 3ToT BbIBOA HyXAaeTctByrorrHeHr4r4, rrocKoJIbKy, Bo-rlepBbx, riexou$eccr4oHaJIbHoe penurl{o3Hoe o6pa:onan}Ie rorlHo raKxeAnr crpaH sanaAuofi Eeponu, B Koropblx upeo6la4a,r KaronI4III{3M HIrn(a qro Apyroe raM Morrro [peo6naAarr?). Bo-nropblx, ronSeccuoHtu{bHoexapaKTepHonporecraHTu:rr,rpenvrr4o3Hoe o6pa:oeauue BrronHeMoxer 6uruMeroAonofl4r{ecKll uefirpzutlurru, anexouseccvoHanbHoe -.rrBHo HJrr4 He.rrBHo or4aroql4M npeA[oqreHlle KoHKperHoft pemaruoruofi'rpa1r4r\Lrkr, Ha rrro aBTop c[paBeAnr{Bo yKa3brBaer, HaIIpI4Mep, Ha c.
51 Auccepralll4tl.42.Xors r{3Ha3BaHug. g.uccepraqr4u cneAyer,qt'b osa orrracrr4 lrocBsrleHa anuil43yIrIKoJIbHoro penlrrrro3Horo o6pasoBaHnfl. B crpaHax Eepoueftcrcofo coro3a, ocHoBHoe BHr,IMaHIreyAeneHo crpaHaM Cenepnoft EnpilnrrvHeKoropbrM Apyrr{M. flpeAcrasrflercl,cpaBHHTeJIbHoro aHanr{:a c Poccuefi He nrenee TIeHHrIM6ulo 6rr ilpr.rBneqeuusMarepl4aJla I43 rrpaKTr{K}r penufuo3Horo o6pasonauutAlaccepralluz 6o.neer.rJrrrBHecoMHeHHo,rrparanoXorerocr 6rr noNelarbar4MeHHo,3croHua), Tarr4x, HanpuMep, KaK-npaBocnaBHbrx crpaHax, TaKrrxEolrapur u Cep6v.t.3ror lrarepr4an no3Bolu:r 6rr yrny6urrpoAcrBeHHbrx coBpeMeguofi Poccuu,Ssnr-ur€ro o6seN4aB rrocrcourraJrracrlrrrecKr,rx ctpanax (eMeHee no4po6uo yrroMr4Haercs roJrbKoBeurplrx, llornura, Cronaxua, Ilutna, a raKxeqro rnflaHaJru3 3a cr{er AByx KoHTeKcroB,IlocrarelrcrurlecKofo6u 6o:nurufi odrenl r..n.4ouarrr4rorar fpeqnr,14cr,rryaur4r4 BrlpaBocnaBHoro, qro,poccuficnofirrrKoJre.aBTopy yqecrb 3ro 3aMeqaHhe e 9yaytqena.3.Buno 6rr xeJrareJrbHo npo{cHr.rrb orHoureHr.re aBTopa K TaK Ha3brBaeMoMy(KynbrypoJrofuqecKoMy.
Характеристики
Тип файла PDF
PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.
Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
