Отзывы официальных оппонентов 2 (793241)

Просмтор этого файла доступен только зарегистрированным пользователям. Но у нас супер быстрая регистрация: достаточно только электронной почты!

Текст из файла

Or:rreoQuqualbHoro otrrIoHeI{Ta AoKTopa [oJrHTr{qecKrrx HayK, npoQeccopa.Kocosa r.Bo Arrcceprarlulr Harapona BarcropaBunropoBurra<<flo.unrnqecKoe yilpaBJIeHIre pa3BrrrrreM {re4eparuBHbrx orsorueHufiKoHTeKcre Halll{oHa,rsuoil 6esonacHocrlr conpeiueuuofiBPoccl.rr.r>>,rlpeAcraBleuuofi Ha colrcKangile yvenofi crerreHr,r KaHAr{Aara rroJrlrrrrqecKr{xHayK rlo c[equaJl[,Hocrlr 23,00,02TexHoJrot-ura- flolnrnqecKue uucrrrryrbr,rrpoqeccbr tr(noluruqecKHe Hayrcu)Axryalnuoarb npo6nentrl Ar{cceprarlr{oHHoro pa6orrr HecoMHeHrrfl. OHa onpeAenterctHHTepecH BeAercf, IroI{cKoTHorrreHvrtr, -raK14reM, r{To HaBbr3brBaercoBpeMeHHoM 3Talre Bo3pacraerHoBbrx rroAXoAoB KaK K pa3Br4rr4ro $e4eparuBHbrxK ynpaBJreHHro 3TrrM rlpoqecaoM.llepeocttblcJIeHI4e I4HcrI4Tyr{HoHaJrbHbrx ocoSensocrefi[oJrr4Tr4qecKi4xlrpoqeccoB c yqerolr Qe4eparHBHbIX orHorueHnfr, e coBpeMeHHbrx TeHAeHUH{x ti[oacK HoBbIX acrIeKToB sroft upodlentu BKoHTeKcre Haqr4oHanr,uofi6e:ouacsocra o6peraer ceroAn.s oco6yro cMbranoByro Hafpyx{eHHocrb.

lloerovryno3rrlllrfl B.B. HasapoBa rroBbL{BJIeHI4Io co.qepxaH:afl,Hailpanlesnfir4 TexHoJrorwfi,IIorHTHqecKoro ynpaBneHun pa3BkrraeM $e4eparr.rBHbrx orHorrreHvfit e KoHTeKcreHaUHoHaJIrHofi 6e:ouacuocrn coepeueuuofirr c cJreAoBareJrbcKyron p o 6,.rllponegeuurrffeMyAr4 cceprarlr4Ar4ccepraHroMPoccauaKTyaJrH3rrpyer14no4po6uufi auanr43cre[eHr4pa:pa6oraHHocrl4 upo6leuu ro3BoJrr4n cAeJTarr o ueo6xoAr4Mocrb AaJrbHefiruerou3yYeHr4fl, roJil4TurlecKoro yrrpaBneHnfl, pa3BVTr4eM$e4eparzBHbrx orHoirren ufr, vKOHTeKCTe Hardr4oHanrsofi 6e:ouacHocrrrBHeluHenoJrr4ra.{ecxoficvryarluw,araKx(ecP@, ocoSeuHo ayrreroMyrreroM Tex 3aka,qpa3gvrrkrflpoccnficroro o6ulecrBa, Koropble Srrnn [ocraBJreHbrBlloclannz llpe:ugeHraP@B.B.

flyruua @e4epanbHoMy CodpauHro P@ s 2018 r. u B ero uHayrypaquoHuofrpequ 1, a raxxer4 B<<uaficxux yKa3ax)) 2018 r.B Kar{ecrBe Me'rol{oJror-H{-IecKHx ocrIoB LIccJIeAoBaI{Llfl /IIlccepral{T14crroJrb3yer t4HcraTyrlr4oHaJrbHbrfr u IIeo14HcrI{TyrluoHaJIbHbIfi I1o{Xol{bI,fro3BoJIl,lBulr.{e Br)rqBHTbpoJlb rroJrHTlrqeaKofo yilpaRnell]/lfl, B llpoqecceSegeparra BHbIX olH ollien Hfi.uiirepecFryro c llayqHofr ro'{xu 3peHI,Ifl I'HIrore3yll.B.

I'Ia:apoB nollrBep/Iuno roNl,pa3Bvrtr4fiLrro . cfe4eparr.rBllbre o"tliorrreHl4.fl HNlelor BbIpalKeHHoe TIoJIHTt{r{ecKoeco4eplr{aHHerarpe6yro'r rrocroflr-rFioro :$cpercrrzn}loro IIoJII'tlnqecKoro yrlpaBne}II4sr4x pa3Br.l.fr{eM, TaK KaK xapaKTepr43yroTcrr o6rqea:necTHbIM llpoTlilloper{I4eMMelr(lly ttenrpaJrr4:arlneil i{ Aerlerl'rpanl43atrl4eii eracra, Koropoe Moxer }rpoxolll:Harlr4o HaJr bHofr 6 e:onacilocrl{rocyAapcrBa.06ocuonatkre v noATRepxAeHr4e rnrrore3bl orKpblBaer Anf,aBTopaMr{o)KecTBo (I4CAIeAOBaTeJIbCKr.rX OKOI{): 3'fO w.

necJle/loBalHkle cooTBeTcTBi4efroirr4rr4Lreci{oro Kypca Ha ypoBi{edte,4epalri-,Hoi'ot1ecy6lex'ra Qelepa]'IwvTIoJII{THqeaKoMy KypcyHTpa; 14 o6ccne.{eHlie nar-II4oHanruofr 6e:onacriocrl4I]Qe4epa'rranHoM locyAapcrBe; r.i peaJrr43ailtrx toJIt4TLlLIecKoro Kypca Ha MecrI'IoMypoBHe;y ri p aH enrpa6orxan J{ e Fr raacpedi$eK'fuBrrbrx rexIIHI{ 14 'rexuottornlt noJil'trt4qecKoroe4ep a'rl4 B FI bI M 14 orHo t LI eII 14tMI{.Crpymlypa paOorsr B rlenoM coorBe'rcrByer3aAar,raM r4ccneAoBatr4tr.rJran[ocraRJIeHHbIM uer.sM14Peileu:upyeMat Al{ccepraqrlfl coaror4T tr3 BBeAeI{I4-f,, AByxno rpr{ [aparpacpa coo'rBerarReHFlo,3aKJIFoqeFIr4tL 14cnl4cKa ncnoJIb3yeMI]IXHCTOTII-IHI(OB,Anlop, paccMarpuRas rroAxollbr K rrotu4MaHnro cyuHocrl'l Ilornrl4qecKol'oyilpaBIeHarI, eTaHoBr{Tcr Ha tl0314r-lHH TOi'O, r{TO 3'IO HHCTI{TyUUOgallUntfrilpoltyK'r noJrr.irl4KH B ee rntl6aJrbrroMrIoJirl-il.J1{9CKOet-rot{HMa}IHH.OsAoKa3blBaer, r{'toyilpaBJreHr4e ?'fo rIpal('fl4r{ecKoe v JiyqrxeeBofIJlouleHHeIloJtultar(!t, Koropar, n oOrqena nJraHe, HanpaBJreHa Ila cofnacoBarlue I{HTepecoBrocy/{apcrBe,B o6uleclne Ha Bcex ypoBHsx v Mexqyr{eroBeqecKoro od[{eNurux (C.il6 l,BBaeMI4 yr{acrFII{KaMI4l[rzcceprarlurz).rrepBoM napalpa$c ncpeoit fJraBbr aB'rop reoperl4qecKu oQMLIcJII4Bae'rrroJrprlr4qecKoo coAepxairHs $e.4eparnBHbIXorsoruesatl Ha 6a:ertpaBoBofr(enporoHTHHeHTaJltuorz)rIo3BOJIf,ereMy14rloirnTr{.{ecxofi (aulno-auepr4KaHcK ofi) rpaguqafi, v'roaKueHTI4pOBarbllBa83anMOCB.g3aHHbrxSe4epatnBHbIX orHolueHrzfi: qeurp anusautrflprnpoqeacaBHyrp14AeqeHTp annsarJzrfl.

Ori Aoxa3brBaer,r{ToI{Hcr}iryl{HoHalruofi ayr{Hocrbro Se4epanL'cwa flBlrflercfl crrcreMa rroJrr{Tr{Ko*[paBoBbIX oruorueuuft Me]KAy cydlerralta, a rarcKe Mex(Ay cy6lexraua vrIIeHTpOM: COTpyAHL{qecrBo, QofJracoBaHHOCTb, naprHepcrBo,KoHKypeHrIr,r.s,co[epHurlecrBo, pac[peAerleHHe, KoMrrerer{rJLrpr w Ap. @eaeparr4BHbre orHorxeHr,rtB pa3I{bIX [apaAr4rMax (copenHoBarerbHa-s, [aprH epaKafl,I4HHoBaI-u4or'rHaa) w B pa3HbIX MoAentx (culruerpr4.ulafl' acr{MMerp LrrtHagrpeanl{3yrorct/IofoBopHafl, KoHcruryql{oHHar{, cMeuaHHa"q, AenerupoBaHHa.s 14 Ap.).

AeropAoKa3brBaer ,r{To $op,vnpoBaHr4e pa3HocrarycHbrx cy6texron B paMKaxQe4epaqafr. ssnxelcn pe3ynbraroM oSrexrnnsrrx HcropuqecKr,rx, coqganbHo*3KoHoMHrrecKaxvo6qecrreHHo-IIoJIr{THr{ecKr4x rrpoqeocoB; pe3ynbraroMHaI{erIeHFIofo rorurnqecKoro ynpaBneHaflcrpol{TenbcrBa. Pa":euraecoAepli(aHLlkr,B cSepe focyAapcrBeHHoro$e4eparzBHblx oruorueHufr B ux [oJrr]THr{ecKoMno MHeIlnrc aBTopa, IrpoucxoAHT ]l pa3Hbrx Ha[paBJreHr4rx:yBenar{eHue o6t,eiraa rroruoN,ro.rai{ cy6texron $e4epaquu, urlorrHrLlr{ecKofo aBTopllTera qeurpalruolz BrraQT:a,reppuropui w 3oFI BaBtr3trpa3nv'rvflMli HacereHntvcv3TO14ycuneHueaa$sepeHLJr4ar\ufr3TFloAerraorpacpuuecKr{Mu 14 3rHoKynbrypHbrMriAeMoKparusaFeia Mex3THr4qecKr4x oruoureuuil, cMnfpaqnoHHblMlI [epeIBI4X{eHVflMLr HaCeJreHafl;cI4MMerpuI4 Se4eparilBHblx oruorueuuftB14 ynporreHr4e acr4MMerpvrucBrr3r4ctufirodpa:oeaHaeM HoBl,rxcyobeKToB; I4 yKpy[HeHI{ea, eoorBercrBer-rHo, yMeHbrrreHne q.vara cy6tex'ron :acrler HX o6r,e4nHeHvrfluxoxAeHnr ollHoro n Apyrofi unu yBengrreHr{e qxcJracy6r'er<ron 3acqerr4JrHBXo)r{AeHHrrB cocraB $e4epaquuFroBbrx cy$1,exroe um1pa3AeneHwx cylr.,exra Ha ABa r4IIw HecKojrbKo.B3aKJ'uoqeur4erraparpa0a BTop rrpr4xorlu.rKBbrBoAyIIorI4THr{ecKoe coAepxaH14e Se4eparriBHbIX omrorueunfi/XeMol(paTl43auilrc roCyAapcTBeHHorOpa3HoypollHeBocrLl Blraerr4, rroJrrirr{Kr.r14tIo roM, r{Too6yc"uae.ryHRaerHatlaeoTpor.rTeJrbcTBayrtpaBneHnfl-3acr{eTHa ypoBHe Se4epaqrzrz, aI{eJroM, Ha ypocHe cy6r,eruon $e4epaqure,ua MecrnoM yponHe.

llpnLroNIeHKJrarypa cyOrercror:pacur14pfle'fcflolHorrreHr4flMyr. Ilolauvo$ege pa'ruBrrL,rMaIIOJIHT'I'ILIECKOI{3JIHTb] B HCErrpoTiccca cy6r,erron3ToMllOJTHTHT{eCKO|O ylipaBneHH.B'cpegepa:ri,uofiBKJIIOqAIOTC'upelr4oFrannuoficySt cySreKTbr rroJrHTr4rrecKoroMecTllafl 3JlI{Ta,Se4epaqnnMeCTFIbieo6ulecrneIJI{oIroJIL{'tnqecKHe opfalr143au1414 Lr. il-t}r4>r{errr4fl) MecrI-IbIe or4eneFIrr.BttoJIL{THr] ec I{I4xnaprrziiCor:racul,tcrrcaJrropoNf B TroM, r-rro ((N{erol{oJlol'lirrecKne I4l'ITeprrperaL\wI4noiir.r'r'HL{ecKolo ynpanJreHL{rI trnJlrlrorot{ oliIrHM14ccJreAoBareJIbcKL{xH3 caMbIXnocrpe6oBauHbIXnalipanlerrntl B c14creMe noJII{ToJIoftl.-recKoro 3HaHr{fl,ripelKAe Bcelo, fioroMy, r'rTo froJrr-ITr{rrecKoe ylrpaBnerlr4e Ha ilpaKTHKe 3ar{I4MaeTolirjo143 BeAyilIr4x rvrec'filc14c'r'eN4eIloJIr.I'fl{qecI(HX r4I'rc'faTyToB, nporieccor]texnolorufr> (C.

60 /{rzcceplar1zH). 'I'o ecr},, 6omuroffHecJre/IoRare,rr,cxr,ifi14Ir'fepec IIpeAaTaBJr_fleT Lre ToJrbr{o r{3yqeHr4e rroJrHTnrrecKofo ynpaBneHZ.sycloBltsxt}le-qeparnnHbrX orrroureunfr,rlo u/utrprx cra6nrr,uocru,3iiarir4T' r.r /-urri cL':r6iarr,rroc'rr,I H 6eso[acFroc'ru{ Bcel'o locyAapcrea.HeaHa Halr] }i3fJrr/1,Hl{lloilarluo}ulocl'b Aaunofi HecJle/IoBareJlbcKott svuru o6yc;rou.lieHa reM, rrroIlpOfiBItCTCflBn3yareHne [orHTr4lrecKoroynpanner{arr caMraMrr cpe4epalrznr{brMn o'rFlonrerrrr.flMrrpa3BL{Tl'ria cpe4eparrrB}lbrx o'rFioirreHrzfi14Be xoHreKcre rrar{uo}raJrnsofi 6e:onacuoerr4'rOJrbKO riOpN4a'fr4BHO-rIpaBOBat{, OpI'aHI{3aqI{OI-IHafl,HOt1no.iitn'tirrecKat cocl'aBJ'rrroLqar; $e4cpari{Bllbre o'fl"roiueHur LrMeror BFIpa)KeriHufrAIaHa\.r"rl.{Lrbrfi(iro4nraxrrrllli) xapaKTep; tpeaeparunH6re orHotrreHr4r{cJlolKrlococl'aBHylo c'fpyK'rypyQclcpa'rraBrJ brc,Ti4{p(l)epeH rdr.lpoBar-rcoof'tl0ureHI{gr{hrxMHolKec'rlloM cy5:nexroeBO|IJIOIJIaIOTC.f, llur4Me}orcy6cy6reKToR;pa3Lroo6pa3HbrxrroJrr4Ti4r(o-optarir{3aru4o}IHl)rx, HopMaT[Btro-IipaBoRbixMo^rlcJrrrx; pa3nr.JT'r.Jc cbeltepalraBHbrxorr{oruerlnit orpa>rcaer lJraBHoe npo'rulBopelrr4ecpe4epa"rru:nra MelKAy r,leuTparrr4:ar(llen/{eN,{oKparn:aqlreu BJrac"rr4lineprnr(aJrr.r3aqi4eilvAer(errrpa:;.rtzatluefr, Mex(/{ynraclia; y[paBne]rnepa3nHTr4eN4{rc,1cpa'rrrlribrx ot'nourerruli l.1N4ee'f i:upaxcunr,iff rtoJlr4Tr4r]ecxnii acneK'r' t4peaJrH3yc'rcn cpax'ru.recxu KaK rioJlri'r'r.{qecKoe ynpaBJreHne qepe3 pa3Jrurrribrepa3BI4THeM $e4eparuBHblx OruoureunilTexHoJrofI4H; noJrg'f6qecKoe yrtpaBnennetta o6retcT' Ilo 1a B3aHMOAeftCrnUevflBIfleTcfi He ToJlbKo so:AeiiCTBHeM Cy6:uerracy6terroe u cySlcy6lexron $e2leparuBHbIX orlloureHl4n'HerpaMorHoe vnr4 L\wukrr{Ho*Corlacul'rcfl o aBTopoM, '-rro <Hee0$exrneuoe'yupaBneFII{e pa3BIITIIeM Qe4eparUBHbIXAeMarorur{ecKoe ;1OIyITI4LIeCKoe.rax 11o BepT[KaJII4, 'faK 14 no I'oplI3oHTaJIIl, MoXeT IIpI4BecTn KoTllo[IeHuffxoudUux'ralt c 3JIeMeHTaMI4 ceUecoun VCyUIecTBeHHbIM IToJII4THKo[paBoBbIMHI|H K BbIXO'4yfpalKAaHcKofi BOilHbr 14 Aax(e K pac[aAy focy.4apcTlraorAeJIbrIbIXTeppl4ropl4fi)lJ(C' 64'65HeI'O/{raccep'rarlrau)'/IaFrHoM pa3AeJre peqeH3HpyeMoli lIuccepTaIIKHBrJr4MaH!{s paccyx(Ael{I4tlli3oco6o3acJIyX(I{Ba}orlnS$epekIWaI\1414 norturur{ecKoroaBTopa oy[paBneHr]ecKofo c.rvrr]fl, fIIaB Cy6:L,eKTOe $e4epaunu'IIO efoMHeHI4W', TAKafl'caMofrpa3Jlnqu,IMu AeTepMI4I]aHT sopvrrapoBa1vlflau-$QepeHuHaLIH{ BbI3I]aHacy6beKrax $egepal!'Lrv', [pex.4e Bcelo'froJr.lTi4r{ecxofr 3Jrl,rrbr B Tex r4nr4 vrlbrxrlcropr{Ko-Kylb.fypHbix H couranbl{o*KrlaccoBux(c'69-70 /lracceprauun)'13rperr,eMnapafpasenepnofirlanr,taRTopAoKa3blBaeT'r{ToaKTyaIH3AI\LrfrnoiII4TtI4qecKoI'oynpaRIeHKt $e4eparnBHbINt14oTI'IoUI9Hwfl17rkIRKOHTeKcTertOII4TI4TIeCKHMI4yilpoqerrnfi i{aquorrarbrlofi 6e:onacuocTI4 PO OSyClonleHaMbI paQOMoTpl4MBI{yTpeFIHHMl,l 14 BI{eIuHI4Mu, KoTopbie$axropaltu,an$$epeHrlr4poBaHHo:A) $axroprrBHeIUHeIloIurHr'IecKofinpl4poAbl3roKoTopble np[oSpeTaro'IFreraTI{BI{bIe MexAyHapoAHble oScroqrellbcTlla'BeKoB (C' 89 fluccepraUran); 6)rlo6a:6sbli4 xapaKrep, ycl{JII4BaflQb Ha py6ex(enprapoAblsax.ropr,r BHyTpr,lrroJII4'II4r{eQKOir-3TO: HefaTI4BHbIe 3KOHOMI4qeOKIIe14poQ"fa', naAeI-IUe3aMe,qneHl4e TeM[a 3KOHOMKT{ecKofouporleccbl,$uuaHcoeue6e:pa6oruurt 14 CHn)KeHI4eKypca HarIHOFrarbHoil BaJltOrbI Poccnn; pog'fxr43HeHHofo ypouHfi HacerleHl4t(c'92-93 [ucceprauar'i)'ItoMHeHr4roB.B.l{a:apoea,Ba}I(HbIMBHyTpt{iloJII{TI4qecKI4Msaxropolt',tynpaBneHl{f pa3BI{TI4eMrroBbr11tegntt e$sexrrar]HocTI4 IIOIHTI4q9OK9TOtssBJIfleTct BcTy[neIII4e poccI4fiCKOfO O6I]IecrBao'fHOlIIeFII4fiQe4eparraBrrbrx2017 f' - 2018 f' (nsrSoprt nI{!{KrI 2016 r.3neKroparrblro-r436t{pa'fenbl{blfi-focy4apcrBer{HyroAy*yMCy cySlexros PO,PO, ntr6oprt B opral-Ibl Hcrlorlul4renbHofi BJraQrvCDCvrnr,r6oprr llpe:n4eHra PQ).

Характеристики

Тип файла PDF

PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.

Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.

Список файлов диссертации