Отзыв на диссертацию (авт. Строганова Е. Н.) (1101914)
Текст из файла
Orslrs oQlrqua,rluoro onnoHeHTao Auccepraqr.rnJfto llsr Ha reMy<<ToopvecrcaRoBo.,'rrcqrrflE. A, HarpoqucofiB KoHTeKcreuAefiHo-3crerlrqecKr{xlrcrauufi 1910-xroaoB>,rrpeAcraBJreHuofina coHcnaHlreyveuofi creneHr,traugnqara$uno,rorlrqecKr{x HayK rro cfleqr{aJrLHocru10.01.01- Pyccrcan.r'rr{Teparypapa6ora J}o I4sr npnBJreKaernpexAe scero N4acura6,{raccepraqraouuarHocrbro 3aMbrcJra14r4crroJrHeHr4r. 3a6uroe Ha MHorue necgru erur I,I Bo3Bpa-qeHHoee 1990-eroAr,rrBopqecreoE. A. HarpogcxofiBnepBbrecraHoBr,rrcrHeTOJTbKOnpe.qMeToMcneuu€urbHoroB],:^r4Ma]Fvfl, Ho o6beKToM MHorocTopoHHeror4 TrlarerbHoro a]i'alrv3a,- yxe 3To .{aer ocHoBaHr4efoBop}lrb o HoytrHofr Ho6uJHe vcclreloBaHrlr. B cooreercrsr4l4 c 3atBreHHofi TeMofi TBopqecKat 3Bonrorlr4t nl4careJr6Hr4rlbrpaccMarprrBaercr B KoHTeKcre n4efiuo-rcreruqecKr4xpyccxofi Jrureparypbr19i0-x roaoe.
TnopvecrnoHarpo4cr<ofiAl4ccepucxa]P.ui,tTaHTKar{HTeprrperr.rpyerKaK op}ifnHaibHoe rBJreHr4e,yTBepxAar efo 3anpe-AenbHocrbMaccoBofi6ernerplrcrr.rxe,npeAcraBnesnofiuueHaur.rA. A. BepBbIBecrIrHaMepeHIreM6uqr<ofi,,II. A. 9apcr<ofr14rp.Aerop pyxonoAcrByerc.{uMq nzcaTerbHrrubr <r43cQepH npuua4JrexHocTl4K MaccoBoft KynbType I4 BnI4carb efo B napaAr4rMyMoAepHucrcKr4xr4nr4"nofpaHr4qHbrx" MexAy peanll3MoMacxauui XX crorerus)>(c.
6 anrope$epara).llpe4nplznmoeer{ MoAepHu3MorranepeocMbrcJreHrle14crop14Ko-nI4TepaTypHofrArrccepTarlrloHHoM rzccJreAoBaHrrr,rpenyTallvl4 nI4caTeJIbHLIUbIOIIpeAeJI{eTero oKmyu'xbHocmbLI HayvHyto SHaquMOCmb.fluccepraqzouuyrc pa6ory Jho I4Hr MoxHo rnanuQzqupoBarbKaKnpocrpofrHoe vccJieAoBaHve,Bce rJIaBbIKoropofo opraHl4qAyMaHHoe,Jrorr4qecKr,rHo cBff3aHr,ru esalrMogeficrByror MexAy co6oi. flepnau r:taBa nocnarqena QunocoocKofi npo6neMarr.rKeI4 xy.4oxecrBeHHoi aHTpo[oJIorI4IrpoMaHoB (fHeBu <3lue AyxI4>.Bo eropoil ruIaBenoKa3aHo,[uouuca>>,<V 6ponsonofiABepIr))<Eopr6a<6eraq KoJIoHHaAa),Harpo4ucofi (e porr,ranaxKaKB [porr3BeAeHr4txNarus nosecru o6uurpo6on>>,B paccKa3e<Asg> n uanltcasuoi n QoprraeOluir.rnuaAe-Aene)eonrorqalorc.s MacoHcKVeuneu nxcareJlbHltllbl. B rpe'rrefiM€UIat po3a, KoTopat paccMaTplrBaerfrraBe B rIeHTpeBHVMaHLI'OKa3bIBaeTCtC IIO3ITIIIIi TO|O,STIOXUct B cBr3r{ c uleiHo-xyAoxecrBeHHElMll TeHAeHIII,I'MI4xar y6eNgenu fl tr4carerbHnlrbl npeJIoMJI{Iorct B xyAoxecrBeHuofi crpyrrypeee npor.r3BeAeHI414.Bo nnegenuu, paccMorpeB oco6eusocrN Bocnpltltrl{t Harpo4cxofi e xpzTr4Ker.r Jrr4TeparypoBeAr{ecKl4eoIIeHKI'I ee rBopr{ecrBa, ,qvccepTaHTKa aprl4Kynl4pyer c Bofi LlccJleAoBarerbcKyro rlo3l,Iqt{ro.
B eeAeF{IaeHacbllqeHo Qaxruvecrulasa6rrc AeHr4r.Mr4,KoropEle Eo3xe noryqarorMarepvarJroM r{ niloAorBopsr,tvunoATBepxAeHIre B aHaJrI43eKoHKperHbIx npou:eegeuufi. B '{acrHocrz, KacafrcborHorrreHr4rHarpo4croii r< Qerlzurlauy, AlzccepraHTKacnpaBeAJlfiBonl4[ler oToM, irro $evuuucrcxue LIAeI4He BcerAano,'Iyqan[ [oAAepxKy B xeHcKofi rII4-2careJrr,croi cpeAe(c. 7 4raccepraqliu).B srou cMbrcJreMoxHo roBopr{rbo roM,uro Harpo,4cKa;rnpoAonxana rpaAr4rlr,rn,olpeAennBrxylocr yxe eo nropofinoJIoBuHeXIX s., xor4a Qenzur4crcKr{eycraHoBKr4Bbr3brBaJruy aBTopoBxeHrIr{H He ToJrEKOnOAIepXKy, HOrr OTTOpXeHr,re,BOBCSKOMCryr{ae -- Ha Bep6a,rr,nou ypoBHe (nara6oneeqpro 9To 3asBreHoB rBopqecrBe H. .{.
Xeourrancrcoft). O6nagaloqee 6orluruu HayqHbrMnoreHr-u4a!'roMBBeAeHr4eAeMoHcrpr{pyeT rrr[poTy r{cTopr]Ko-Jrr,rTepaTypHofoMbrirrJreH}rraBTopa,Ho HeKoTopbre3atBreullr BEr3brBarorBorrpocbl. Hanpl.rMep,Spara o roM, rITo KJIaccI4rIecKarIJIIITeparypa He nplreMner AUAaKTHKTTr,rHpaBoyqureJrr,Hororoua (c. 47 guccepraquu). Ho KaK B raKoM cnyqae 6url c KnaccuKoMII. H. Toncrrru? 3air.re.ryraxxe, qro $amuvecr<aa Hacr,ruleHHocrrnopofi oKa3brBaercrraa6rrrovnofi, TaK, HapacuupeHa nepcoHarbHar perlpe3eHTarlr4rrrucareJlbHlIIIrraofre:rrtr4., r43JrurrrHe- E. JlerKoeoii,3. funnuyc, A.
Mupe, Anuu Map, JI. 3aHoerecoBpeMeHHr4rIKoropar uoclrr pe$eparusHufisofi-AHHr,r6anr4 Ap. (c. 13*36 4raccepraquu),rrToyrueHululo 6u ia6urr coKparleHa,HecKoJrbKoxapaKTep14noToMyrr,ror:raqacrHocrl4,orruaBuoexe, o6ocuoeaHHocrbo6tev 4ltccepraquu.O4uaro 9ToqerJrHBo BbrpaxeHHofo HaMepeHI]{ BbrrcHrlTb, B r{eM 3aKrloqaJlocb x]'Aoxecr-BeHHoeHoBaropcrBo Harpogcr<oft, 14nepeolpeAeJllrrb Mecro IIucareJIbHIrIIr'IBlrarepa'rypuofi vepapxLru. 3ro craHoelzrct crepxHeM pa6oru 14oflpeAenterMr'Icnb. HaMe.{eHnaSoc nepecuorpa, crrrMynrapyroqui i4ccJreAoBareJlr,cKylopeanll3yercx r r<aN4ofru3 ruIaB.Har crparerl{r nocJreAoBareJrbHorBopqecKux ucxauuit Harpo4cxofi paccMarB nepnofi fJraBe ,qrrHaMrrKapr,rBaercr qepe3 coflpl4qacrHocrb ee BeAyrIrrM Iageiuo-xygoNecrBeHHblM TeHAeHur4rMCepe6p*roro BeKa: aHrepec K aHrI,IqHocrI4,yBrer{eH e $r,rnocoQrzefiK KoHllenquu O.
BefiHusre@. Huuure, o6saNeuue BonpocoBiIoJIa,BHuMaHI,Iepa, pacnpocrpaHeHuocrbSeuuHucrcxtrx noaapenrzfi.,{uccepraHrra BbItBJIternpoqecc ycBoeHl4t nLIcareJlE'HIlLIei pLlnr\vnvanbHblx ycraHoBoKcloxurrfior Hl,tx. Kax noxao orraIJtKI4BaHI4tu BMecre c reM noJ'IeMlrqecKofcI4MBoJrr43MasaHo e pa6ore, oco6euuo aKryaJIbH;I4rt Harpogcroi.r 6t'ntu Kareropuu anoJlJroHr{3Mau guouucuitcrBa? cBt3aHHbIec onno3llquei xpacorrt u 6ezo6pazun,4o6pa a ua.
B rax4oM LI3pa3AenoBrJIaBbIaHanlt3l4pyercs npeeMcrBeHHocrbpa3Brlrr4r sroft npo6rerraarl4Kl4or poMaHa K poMaHy, AI4ccepraHTKanpocnexl4BaeT, KaK aBTOpCKaf MbICJIT' BbIKpI4CTtUIJII,I3OBLIBaeTC'U [pOtBJIteTCtB XyAO-xecreeuHofi cl{creMe npou:ae4euufi .poMaHa<Y 6pousoeoii ABepI4>,Oco6oro BHuMaHIat3acJlyxlrBaer aHaJILI3roroprrfi paccMarpl4Baerct KaK [poAoJI)I{eHnepoMaHa <fuen .{uoHrtca>>.[uccepraHTKa cr{r.ITaer,r{To 3Aecb no-ApyroMy pa3BopaqfiBalorcl o6slrpauulte alepBoM poMaHe croxernrle Konntetrrr u 6olee orr{erJlrrBoaprl'IKyJrrrpyercr pa3Haqana.B poruaueguonUCufr,cxorou yTBepXAeHI4eaIIoJIJIOHI4qecKorOBeHrtaHrzeqeluiE KoMrIneKc[po<V 6pou:oeofi 4nepu> AeicrsurerbHo aKKyMynLrpoean6lerra, arrya.,rbHblx AJrt MoAepHr{crcKofr:loxu: aHAporuHHocrb, roMoceKcyB Bo3MoxHocrll coqrraJltHux npeo6pa:oaJrrHocrb,6esyuue, pa3orlapoBaHrresaluia u Ap., Ho o4uofi ur fJraBHI'IXtBJrtercq npo6lelra BJracrrl qeroBeKa Ha,qJr{eJroBeKoM.Pa-:suTue croxerHr,rx r<o,r:rzguiu n pa^:uoficrerreHr4nep6anusoBaHHarno3r4rll4tnepcoHaNeftBbttBJrr]orpa3HbteI4rrocracr4sroil eracru.
KaKoAHa r43$OpV nnacrra noKa3aHa eracrr, rro6ez - Ha 3TOMOCHOBaHLTOTHOrrreHr4'- Touu _ K ero Mareprr,a raKxeoAHofo rr3 UeHTpanbHbrxnepcoHaxefrporr,rauaorHorrreHl,Iei<Tonu ero cecrpbrMaprapurtr. z4eo:rorou Bjracrr4KpacorElrBJrrercr Touu, o6ragarorqafipegxocrlrofi xpacoroi r4 HareJreHHbrfi cunofi prrrflfr4BarbK ce6effoAeii n o6eopaNraeaGzx. oco6ofi Qopvoi B,[acrr.roK?3brBaerct xecroKocr6, I,rAeoJIofoMxoropoft BbrcrynaernepcoHax no Qarrfl{,rrzzcanynoe.
ToHr4pa3BeHqr4BaercrB AuccepralJr4r4KaK HOCIrreJIr,<6e:Hpancrneuuocrra>(c. 79).,ayaurrcpacr (c. 80), rro Br4HeKoropofo rrl6nyr apy.r" nrogn. llocJroBaMr4MeHHoveper o6pa: 3Tororepor B poMaHe[poucxoAr4TAr.rccepraHTKl,r,pa3BeHr{aHrze4nouzczfici<oroKyJrbra.Ho eoguoNuo n lpyroe flporlreHve [epcosaxnofr crrcreMbrpoMaHa.lyvaro, uro n pa6oreHeyAeneHoAoJrxHoroBHr4uauna o6pasy oxr4peBrrreroncen4o-Me$acro$e,r.aCa,nynona,roropufi nocloxery I4cnbrrblBaerrrllorc(oe BJrelieHr4eK Tonlt, Ha ugefinorr,rxe ypoBHe,Brqercr ero ceoeo6pasHrrrra4eoiiuuxov.
Bo eHexrHefirrporr4BorrocraBr'reHHocrr.tTosu z Ca,ryuoeaHaurAHo rrporBJrrercrorno3r4rluqKpacorbru 6ezo6pa_zut,xorq B cBoeM crpeMneHr4r4K Bjracrr.rHaA rpyfr4Mn oHu oKa3brBaro'rcg.6ttuzxu.rreM9To [oKa3aHo BO4naro, ua naofiB3r:rSL o6pa: Tonu MeHeeoAHo3HaqeH,pa6ore. lepoil rpe6yer qecrHocrr,rB orHorrreHr4rxMe)KAynroAbMr.r,qecreH r4rroorHollleHrlro x ce6e, npa3HaBar, r{To 14eMy He qyx(Aa xecroKocrb, TporareJrbHo3a6orr"tcr o xuBorHbrx, orBepraer [r']orcKy]o :uo6osr 14He [oHr.rMaer r4crr.rH-nofr npuuuutr BJrerreHr,r{K HeMy Canynoea u Bapapuua f apuoHra:lrpyrorqeearroJrJroHr4qecKoeHar{a;roe o6pa:e ToHz noAvepKHyro ero npeo6paNeHr.reueoBTopoi{qacrrr poMaHa:oH craJr cnoroi.rHee,cocpelorogeHuee, <colzgHee> (c.150 pouana).
Pa:pyuri.rrenrHoe iqr.roHr4cuficKoeua.{aro s 6ortIrref, creneHr4cBr3auo c 6esygepNnuM B cBorrx crpacrrx, BHyrpeHHeonycrorxeHHbrrraCany-HoBLIM,r<oroprrfi 3aMbrrrrJrrery6uficrno Tourz rar cpelcrBo o6lapauut uut,nogrrlrHeHrlr ero ce6e, T. e. B.[acrr4HaA Hr.rM.Orcyrcrnyorquit $uuast, roroprrfiTpaKTyercr n pa6ore KaK ((oco3HaHHoexyAoxecrBeHHoeaBTopcKoeperueHr{e)(c.77), HaBepHrKacn.sr 6u Morzpa3HofJracr4rc Ar4ccepraHrKofi.Cocpe4oroveHHocrb aBToparr4ccepraur4r,rHa xeHcrBeHHou o6pa:e ToHr'tyBoAur ee or oMyxecrBreHHoroo6pa:aMaprapnrr,r,B rroprperexoropoi axrleHTupoBaHbrMyxcKr{e qeprbr: ee Surypa <cxopei HaroMr{Haer}oHorxy, qeMa flpuqecKa<erqe6o:reenpr.rAaerei cxo4creo c M&'rbAeByurKy(c.
5 porraaua),qItKoM))(c. 6). B 3ToMpoMaHer4Haqe,qeM e ((fHeBelzouuco, pacnpeAeJrrrorct poJrr4Seuuuu:zponaHHoro Myxqr4Hbr rr MacKyJrfiHrr:upoaauuofixeHUIr.{Hr,r,so n pa6ore 3To ocraercs 6eg o6bscHenr4q.Hecuorpa Ha BbrcKa3aHHbreBo3paxeHlrs,cquraro HecoMHeHHbrM.qocrot4HcrBoMAucceprauuu aKryzrnr43arlulopoMaHa<Y 6pousoeofi ABepu) r4 ero op|AHI,ITIHOE BKIIOqCHHCB IiCTOPI4IO TBOPI{CCKOIOPA3BVL'II,', NUCATEJIbHIIIIbII,I BKoHTeKcruAefirio-screrur{ecKfix ncxa:e.uhpyccxofi nLrreparypbr 1910-x rogor.Oco6enno orMerry upe:erruafiHo rrHrepecHyrorpaKToBKyHa3BaHr{{poMaHa,Ko-4Topaf craHoBr'rrcr [oHrrHa ronbKo 6naro,qap.s14cro,uKoBaHr4roefo cr4MBoJrr4qe-cKoro cMr,rcJra.I4nrepnperupyx o6pa: 6ponaonoftABepr4,MoxHo 6uro 6u eqeo6parzrt BHuMaHr4eHa Aer€urb,Srarypnpyrollyro B reKcre poMaHa,- py6auu,yKparxarculr4e4nepr (c.
77 poxraua). BosuoNHo, o6palleuze K cr.rMBorrr{Kepy6una 4onomruro 6rr xouueutapuit K Ha3BaHuIopoMa'a 14ero Kmoi{eBoro o6pa3a.Pa:HocropoHue apfyMeHTxpoBaHHarvuc:* o6 orpr4rraHr4tn[careJlb'r,rqeil guouucui'tcKoro Har{ajrar{aKocHoBbrxr,r3HeHHoronoBe,qeHrrrnoryiraer nocJrelyrcqee pa3BI4Tr4eB aHaurH3euacoHcxofi ocHoBLree npor.i3BeAenuft.Bropa-apa60rrruanaoco6euso r{HTepecHa,noroMy qro 3recb creJraHanonrrrxa o6ua-(noAKnaIKy)ueJlofoprAa lpou3BegenzfiHarpo4cxofi.Hepyxrrrb MacoHcKyrorrro MacoHcKIze y6ex4euzx8613LrBaerCOMHeHIZT,nflcareJIbHr4rlt I npo{BLIJI14CbB- Ha 9To o6paurla BHr,rMaHr4epoMaHe <<Ee,ra-qKoJroHHa,qa>,A. M.
Характеристики
Тип файла PDF
PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.
Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
