Отзыв на диссертацию (авт. Строганова Е. Н.) (1101914), страница 2
Текст из файла (страница 2)
fpavena, nrrsBr.rBrrrarrB npolr3BeAeHr,ruuurJreropr4qecxufruaconcxlrfi nlacr. llpe4npaHarufiB Aucceprauuuct(pynyne3Hsitauannt reKcra, aaer eue 6o,reenoluoe npe4gToro poMaHa.Kax nuuer Ar,rccepraHTKa,craBJreHr.reo6 zcrznsorra coAep)r{aHr.tuB MacoHcrBenlicarenlHlrqy npI4BneKaileto (fyMaHrrcrnqecnui cMsIcJr<...>cnoco6urrii "lr:leqrlTb" r{eJroBeKaor cla6ocrefi, ocBo6oAr4Tbor nopor{HbrxHanepexuii> (c. 108). He uMeq Bo3MoxHocrr.rHa3brBarbBerrlr4cBor,rMr4r4MeHaMIl,Harpo4craa ucnonb3yer cr.rcreMyrznocra:anlifi. Tauscrneuuoc'rrro ogesHo6pa3 reporiHrz rro r4MeHr.tKceHrls Hecroponua PafiHep, Koropar Ha4eleHa nexofisrlcuefi MyApocrbro.
(llonyrHo 3aMeqy, rlro B pyccKofi ,rureparype yxe 6unrrepcoHax no $aMnrur4 Paiuep - repoil aH.rrrturr4rrllc-rr4qecKoropovaua H. C.Ilecxosa <Hexy4o). lfto L'IHr y6e4lrre,rr'Ho noKa3brBaer,qro MacoHcKiur[oAonJIeKapoMaHanpoqBnqerct He roJIbKoB Hcnorb3oBaHltl4MacoHcKofrcuir,rsoruKIr, Ho B uso6paNenuz nyreii npuo6rqeHuq K yqeHulo z esar.ruo4eficrBrzr4nepcoHaxefi no MacoHcKrrMMoAeJrrM.OAsaxo 3To eArrHcrBeHHoenporr3Bei{eHaeHarpolcrofi, B KoropoM nosBrrlorcr r'tHocra3aren6HbreHaMeKr.iHa MacoHcKoeyqeHt,re.'opratr43arlr,tror] riprzHaAnexHocrr,x nefr or.qeJrrHrrxlepcouaNeft.Bnaecre c reM AuccepraHTxa BnepBbrecraBVT ceoeii raAaqefi pac[rr4pr4TbKpyf <MacoHcKr4x)npor43Be4euufinzcarenbH14r-lbr,nr,rrarrcbnpoqr4TarbHeKoroqepe3pbrerraaconcxrzfiro^q.
Cue,rocrb r{ccreAoBareJrbHnrlr,rMoxHo roJrbKorlpl4BercrBoBarr. llpegroNeHHbre B Euccepratftlu rpaKToBKr{ B rlenoM Aocra-rovuo y6e4zrerbHbr, so cnoco6 penpe3eHTaur,iuMarepvara nopofi eu:rrraerBo3pDKeHVe.B qacrnocrz galBrreHvfl,AJlr Korop;rx, ua uoi B3rrqA, Her AocraTorrH[,rxocnosaHzfi.Tar, o repozHe paccKa3a<<Aux>,roropui paccMarpr{Baerct KaK (r{epHoBofiBapr.{aHT>uaconcroi vqen, B Ar4cceprarluucxasar.c: <Anx,IIo MrIcJII'IaBTopa,IrMeer B ce6e noreuquan HocuTerq uaconcrofi grurn.
B treftqeIoBeKa, KaKMxJrocepAr.re,BOnJTOUIaTOTCTTaKr4eBbTCOKUeAyrrreBHbreKaLlecTBaTepneHlte, crofixocru, or3brBrrrrBocr!,,qyBcrBo AoJrra flepeA 4olrovagqaruu> (c.116). Ho pa3BeHenb3rcKa3arbro xe caMoeo Cone Maprr.rela4onofi,uanpznaep.O,{HaKo3To He Aeraer ee noreHrra€urHslMHocureJreiralracoucxofi erurz. Aareerrrrxer: <...o6pa:onrAnv E. A. Harpo4cr<aro rofi xe Ane 4rlccepraHTKaoAHo-5BPEMEHHO AAET NOH'TI,, IITO I4AE' CAMOIIOXCPTBOBAHU' flBIIflETCfl BAXHLIM 3BE-HoM MacoHcKofrloKrpvHbr, (c.
117). VI no oroMy noBoAyMoxno npr4BecraKoHTpapryMeHT:He rBJr.flercflrru vpeq caMo[oxeprBoBaHrrro4nofi ua feHAep_Hbrx KoHcraHTn u:o6paNeurzprxeHcKr4xnepcouaNefie pyccrofi nureparype?onpe4ereuze repor,rHtrpaccKa3aKaK(AeByrxKr{-MacoHO)(c. 150) [peAcraBJrrercr r,r3JrrrrrrHeKareropuqHrru. He 6yay aa,ree pa3Br4Barbsry reMy, cKa)nyJ 4rrrb,qro nogo6ntre HeyBfl3KrlMOXHOpaccMarpr4BarbKaKcJleAcrgueuexoinoAMeHbI,Korra He BnoJIHeOUenU4Ur,tfiTe3r4Cnpr{Hr4MaercrKaK6e:ycnonnufi.geno143AecbHe B ,qr4cceprarluouuofixouqenrJr4t4,Koropar, KaKyxe roBopr,rJrocE,Aocraror{HoorqerJrr,rBarz crpofiHa, a e rep6a_,rtuoilra'reropnvuocrn, Ko_ToparHe Brror'rHeyMecrHaa nogo6HuxrrocrpoeHr,rrx.B nepcnerrune6rlro 6uoqeHbBaxHo Br,rrBr.{rbaBToAoKyMeHrrrHarpogcxoi, xoropue uorla 6u cocraBr4Tbueo6xo4uvyro ricrorrHr.rKoByro6a:y (nnpouev, He 3Haro,Bo3MoxHonr4ero).Ha6lro4eulrx 14BbrBoAbr,cAe!'raHHEreB [epB6rxfJ'raBax,noAKpenrqlorcr 14rperrefi rnanu.
llpo6:reMarr,rKa.qonorHrrorcqMarepr4aJraMr4rr,ra.,rofinporr Harpo4cxofi paccMarpzBaerc.sB KoureKcreu4efinux ir xyAoxecrBeuuux ucrasufinl4carerbHI4l1brrr3yqaeMoronepr4oAa.Zcc:re4orauue o6orarqaercqHe roJrbKopaculrpeHrreMJrr.rreparypHoroQoua, Ho u 3a cqer B;rrBreHrrr raMMbrxyAoxecrBeHHbrxnpueMoB,xort r{ ceoicreeHHsrxApyrrIMaBTopaM,uo npuo6peraroulux oco6yro oKpacKynoA nepoM Harpo4crofi. V6e4rzrelruo rpoaHaJrpr3r4poBaHarroJreMzxac ycraHoBKaMr4paar4Kanr,HoroQeurHz:ua B TaKr4xpaccKa3ax,rax <<3acaMoBapoM)),<<CMeurHaqAc'tophs>>,<9acraqrrc6oBb) raAp. Oco6ennorpKo noKa3aHa MHoroac[eKTHocTb aHTI4cuMBO,qr4CTCKOrOAr4CKypCaB paCCKa3aXHarpo4cxofi, B qacrHocrr4 [apoAl4poBaHrre MoAerr4 cr4MBoJr]icrcKoroxr.r3He-pa3pa6oraHHoilrBoprrecrBa,s nogecrlx ,rI. {. 3rauoereeoi-AnHz6an(c. 182190).
Bcruecrofi noAAepxKr.r3acJryxr.rBarorr{ rleHHbreHa6rroAeHu{Ar4ccepTaHTKr4no noBoAyxy,4oxecrBeHHoroocMbrcrerr4rrucaterbuuqefi nonylxpuoro uu$a o 3olyurxe, xoropui, KaK3To crrpaBeAJrr4BoorMeqeHon pa6ore, z noHbrHeTr.rpaxupyeTcr B MaccoBor4Ky,rrbType.I paBecTrzpoBaHrre3Toro cloxeTa BpaccKa3e(CaHApr4nr,oHa>rBopAaer Jfto tr4nr ocHoBaHr4e4raS$epenqrzpoBarbqecrBo Harpo4croft 14npor.r3BeAeHus<Naaccosoii6y,rtrapHofi rxreparypbr)) (c.194).CnequaJrbHoeyAeJreHoBHr,rMaHr.reB ruraBeSynxquu $auracrzxv B MaJroiinpose Harpo4cKofi, Koropar BKJrroqaercrn ruupovaftruufi,rureparypurrft ronrexcr.
JIro I4ur npoclexnBaer Brrulnvre rora.recKoft Tpa1larJtrll,nagrreaq HarpoAcKylo B r-r?rcJrerrucareJrbHr.rq,co3.qaBaBrrr4x<xeHcrnfi Bapr.{aHT)rorrxr.r (c.209). (3aueuy a cro6rax, qro Ar4ccepraHrKaorcbrJraerx pa6ore conpeveunofiqepTbrB TBopqecTBenr4car.rccJreAoBaTeJrbHrrrlbr:'KoTopar HaxoIriT foTt4qecKr.reTeJIr,HzrIbrnepaofi rroJroBuHbrXIX nexa E. A.
faH, Ho ropa3Ao c 6o:nruuv ocg sroft csq:z MoxHo roBopr4Tbo npor.i3BeAeHusxHoBaHr4eMH. A. [ypceon). Br{TogrofrIJenoM xe emaee raK MHofo uHTepecHr,rxHaxoAoK,ee co,qepxcaHr4enaor.no6rr crarr, npe.{MeroM orAeJrbHofopa3foBopa.flpracyulufi aBropy Arzcceprar{r4r{naQoc nepecuo.rpa,r{3MeHeHr4,r4cro-pr4Ko-nr{reparypuofrpenyraqr,ruHarpogcroi use uy6oxo uunonupyer. Ho,AyMaIo, r'ITo norIbITKa IloBblclrrb peHoMe rIucareJIbHI4IIbI He AoJIXHa ccnpoBoxIarbct 143JII4IrrHI4MllrIoxBaJ'IaMLIB aApec ee xy,{oxecrBeHHoro MacrepcrBa.
rro-TOMyrITOMHOfr4eaHaJrr43llpyeMbler pa6ore nplreM[,I 6bIrH SnOrHe O6rrqurruu,rtro6br He cKa3arbrpaoaperH6rMu.He BnonHeyMecrHbrMr4npeAcraBnrrorctpeMapKr,rruna ((oHaroHKo norryBcrBoBana)(c. 122), KorAaper{brrAer 06 A3o_6paxeuuu <$a:uuueoro ruua Hoeoi xeHu-u{Hbr))(zsrecruo, r{To raKlre rxesMaHCr4naHTKu6r'tru yxe nepcoHaxaMnnr4Teparypuaropoil noroeuHH XIXnexa).3roKacaercs r.{ cAeJlaHHErx B pa6oreganae.{aFrui t4croor4Ko-JruTeparypHofoxapaKrepa.Tax, 4uccepraHrKaBr4Ir{THoBaropcrBoHarpo4cxofi B roru, rrro Ao Heen pyccrcofiJrrireparypenopoKr46unz npucyrur4flepcoqecrzii cpegu, (a npocrbre ,rrogu o6:ra4a.nunrrcoroiiHa)r(aMr43apr,rcroKparr.rHpaBcTBeHHOCTbIO)),rr{CaTeflbHrrrla xe noKa3blBaeT, r{To r4 (B MLIpe [pOCTbIXrrogei 'rar xe yKopeHeHo:no> (c.
I29). finn KoppeKrrrpoBKr4orofo cyxAeHr4tHanprrMep,nlecy JI. Tolcroro <Blacru TbMr,I>r,rJrrrIocraroqHo BcrroMHr.rrb,paccKasHHexona,rar <B oBpare>u <Ba6r,r>.lle4a.,rapoaanzen pa6oreTaKLreHeoqeBZAHbIXMoMeHToBreu 6o,ree I43JII4llHe,rrro II4ccepraHTKeyAaJrocr,BnorHe apryMeHTr.rpoBaHHorroKa3arb, B qeM 4eicrrure,uuo 3aKJrroquurocrceoeo6pa:ue nr4careJrbHr,rrlbr,o6 arov BHrrHo cKa3aHoB rroJroxeHl4tx, BbiHo-crlMbrxHa3aulrrry(c. 7-8 aeropeSepara).llo:renan.{ecKlze ttoJroxeHur Moero or3brBa nlt s Koe[ MeDe He cHl]xalorpa6orbr.Oua 4euoHcrpupyerspenrri npoSecAocroLIHcrBAncceprarlr{oHHoficaosa,rlnr,rft noAXoA, B3BerxeHHocrbaccreAoBaremcxofi norzqulr, trrlrporyHayrrHoro Kpyfo3opa ee aBTopa.BaNur,rlr AocrorzHcrBoMpa6o'ru flBlrfle.tct HayqHocrr 6es uaryNnoil Hayxoo6pa:nocrn, coBpeMeHuufiyposeHt rrocraHoBKrjrr peueHr4r npo6neu coqeraercq c qcHocrr,ro 14Tor{Hocrbroxsura.
llpo$eccnopa6orbi rroATBepxAaercr npr,rBJ'reKaeMbrMHaJII43MKoHTeKcrou. pasuoo6pa3rieMu no:rHorofr BKJrroqeHH;rxB r4ccJreAoBaHuexyAoxecrBeHHbtx,QttnocoQcxux,LlecKr.rx(6rz6,rrzorpa$ rar Hcnorb3oBauHofilureparyKynbryponorl-rcrorrHHKoBpH coAeplr{Hr248 noruqrzft).pa6orbrHecoMHeHHa.Ilpaxmuaecxan sHd.tuJrtocmbOuenz4uo,r{ToocHoBHbrenoJroxeHlJre o6ueu rcypce4rzccepraunvoryr 6srrs Hcnorb3oBaHbrpyccr<oiiJrrrreparyp;rpy6ex<aXIX-XX BeKoB,B cnequa-rrbHbrxr.rcropr4r4Kypcaxrlo rBopqecrBy pyccKxx rr careJrbHr,ruCepe6pauoro BeKa, B Kypcax, rocBr-IueHur,rxxaHpoBoMycocraBypyccroil nrrreparypLr1910-xroAoe, a raKxe BMexAr.rcqurrJrr.rnapHoiinpaKrr4Ke.Marepualu Ar4ccepraur4146yAyr xeo6xogurr,ruB KoMMeuraropcroii pa6ore npu peny6,ruKarlru npor43BeAenmftHarpo4cxofi,I4x MoxHo peKoMeHAoBarb,qJrrBKJrroqeuuxv yue6uuxra r.ryue6Hue noco6r4qnocooTBeTcTByroulrrM.qr{curznJIlrHaM.Hayvuue florox(eH]iq u BbrBoAbrAr4cceprar1lzuo6ocHoeaHHr,rIt AocroBepHbr,oHr4yoeAvTerbHo n3roxeHlr B aBTopeQepaTeH oTpaxeHbr B ABeHanrIa-Tr,rny6JrrzKarlurx(r{erbrperr3 Hrrx B r43AaHr.rrx,perlen3rrpyeMbrxBAK p(D), nnorHoi MepenpeAcraBJrrroqr4xnpo6neMarrzKy14coAepxaHrrelr4cceprarlu[..{raccepraqzoHuaapa6ora J[o Znr Ha reMy <Tnopvecr<aaeno,rroqra_rE.gA.
Harpo4croft xonrercre agefino-ecrernr{ecKrixucxal,ui,rl9l0-x ro4on>,flBrflercfl caMocroqreJrbnofi nayvHo-r<ea,wr$uxaquoHHofipa60rofi . coorBercr-Byer clelluaJrLHocrr410.01.01- Pyccrax nr4reparypau orBeqaerrpe6cnaurzxNan. 9 <lloloxeHur o riopsAKenpucyxAeHrrryqeubrxcreneHefi>,yrBepxAeuHoro llocranoe,'renueullpanureJrbcrBaP(DNs 842 or 24 ceurx6ps2013 rola.JLo Zrir 6esyc:roruo 3acnyxr4BaernprzcyxAeHru efi yueuoi creneHr4KaHApr4ara(pr4nonor[qecKrrxHayKrro cneqrraJrr,Hocrz10.01.01 _ pyccKa, nr4_reparypa.floxrop QuloloruvecKr4x HayK,npoQeccop,masHurfiHayuHurficorpyAHrzKHayrrHo-LIccneAoBareJILcKoroUeHTpaTBepcxoroKpaeBe,qeHr4rz eruorpaSraraTnepcroro rocy.qapcrBeHHofoyHr4BepcrrreraH. Crponanonaw'6?t;ffi.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
