Отзыв ведущей организации (1101907)
Текст из файла
(YTBEPXAAIO>llpopexrop no Hayunoiipa6o-re<DfBOyBIIO <Ioxso-Vpalrcr<vfiyHprBepcarer>(FMy)p C.A.Bay,runftf;'Y-,i",..$OT3bIBne4yrqerTopraHr{3arlnr4o Ar4cceprarlr4zJLo I4nr( I BopqecKar3BollroqLlr E. A. Harpoacrcois rcoHrexcre zrefiuo_gcrerr,rqecKl,lxncxauuit1910-xroaoe>,npeAc.aBJreHuoiina coucraHreyveuofrcreneHr4KaHAuaaraQaroIoruqecKr,IXHaYr(no crequanbHocru10.01.01_ pyccr<axrrr4reparypa(Mocrna,B xauAr'rAarcxofiguccepraqur4Jloznr2014)npe4.'oNeH aHaJrr43rBopqeorBanonyrapuofi B HaqaneXX eercanucareJrbHr.lu'rE. A. Harpo4cxofi B KoHre*creu4efruo*screruqecKr4xrzcr<auuii19 10_xroAoB.{uccepraquouHoe uccne.qoBar{ne,flro VIut[peAcraBnrercrr6e:yc:roeuoaKTyaJlbHblM,KaKB acrreKTereHgeprjoii npo6,reva.r.rxnB nrzreparype, rar(r4B cBr3rzc Heo6xo4rziraocr'ronarb 60ree norHyro 14 ueJrocrHyroKap'Hy nrareparypuorzxr't3Hr,rHar{aJraXX seKa.Hayuuaa HoBu3Ha Ar4cceprarlr4uJLo I4lrt TaK)r(e He BbI3bIBaer colraneuzi raonpeAeJlrercqMHofoacneKTHo.BaxHa.s3acryfa r4ccJIeAOBaHI{r3aKJiroqaeTcr B TOM,.ITO BB.AeHOn uayuur'rfio60por rBopqecrBo nficarerbHl,rubl(BTOpOfOprAa),BTBopLIecTBeroropoi o6rrapyxfl.rtaroTc,He .foJrLKo onpeAenqrculr4eTeHAeHUr4143noxu, a TaKXe Te 3neMeHTbI,KOTOpbIeHe nonyrlr4Jll4iIIUpOKOfOpacnpocTpaHeHl,Ir,HO OKa3anI4sosaefrcrsue Ha nr'rreparypHuii nporleccr4 co3AaJrr4.npeAeJleHHOe((noIe)).nr{TepaTypHoeJHa.{I-rrenLHLrMHayqHbrMBKraAoMpeqeH3r4pyeMoixasarzAarcrofrAr.iccepraqrzr4tBJr{ercr ycraHoBJreHr4eKaprr{H'rpa3Br4rr4rpyccroiiBeKa, a raKxepacuLrpeHue npe4cran:reuufi oNeucrofi npo:rr cepe6pr'ofoee xaHpoBbIX lpaHlrqax143CTeTIir{ecKI4X AOCTO14HCTBax.Ha6,rrcrenus,cAenaFIHLreB xoAe accJreAoBaHr.fi,rr03BoJir.IJ'rrzyrorrHurr,3HaqeHrzer.{ Mecro rnopuecrea E.
A. Harpo4cnofi eo6u1eu Jrr4reparypHoM, Lr1efiHo_3CTCTVqECKOMKOHTCKCTCf,NOXU HAqAJIAXXS., B'IBECTI,I I4M, NI4CATEJI'HUU'I }I3cQepbl MaccoBofrxynr,rypr,r H Bnr4carbefo BnaparufMy MoAepHr,rcrcKr.ixucKaHr4rTXX croreruq.lIpoAyMaHHaqr'rJrofr'rr{HarcrpyKTypa pa6orrr,MeroAr4qecKr414MerorororuqecKr4o6ocHoeaFrHtrftaHa:rr43 3Mnr.rpr.rqecKoroMarepr.rar,ra,o6ocuonauuue MeronlrtccreAoBaHl'rrfro3BoJrrz,rrrnprafirux y6e^ure,rlubrMtsblBoAaMn pe3yirLTaraM.{uccepraquouHoeuccJreAoBaHrlereMoHcrprrpyerBr,rcoKyroHayqHyroKynbrypyJ*o tr4Hr' KaK B crrJre v3roxeHr4r, TaK 14B or6oper4 KoMMeHTLrpoBaHr.rr4Mal.cpxana.Hay'ruo ueHHbIMrBJrrercr ro, r{1'opaccMorpeHKoHTer(crNeucrcofrnpo3br Haq€rnaXX eexa, ocMbrcreHan noKa3aHaoBoJrlol.r.rfl$eHoveua Nescr<ofi npo3Er ts 3TorIIepIzoA' yKa3aHbl I'IMeHa, AauaQuloloruqecKa{oUeHKa TBopqecTBa KJrror{eBLIXstrryp npoqecca, npr, 3ToM npor'JreHa 3rrarrr4TeJrbFrarn'.repary p*a, v KyJrbrypHa,ocBeAoMJreHHocTL.Bfnaeenpo6levaruxaIpeqeHsupyeraofipa6orsr paccMarpr4Barorc,$u.,rocoQcr<axHxyAoxecTBeltHataHTporloJrofutBpoMaHaxE' A Harpoacr<oi, uro, 6esyclonno, rB,rrercroAHnMr43npr4opr.irerHLrxacneKToBaHurl43anpo3bi nI-icaTeJrbH14ul,t.B cospeueuHoMJlr'rreparypoBeAeHu14'onpocbrxyAoxecrBeHHot aHTpononoruxaKTT4BHOr43yqarorcrrr.r o606rr1aro'cr l.eope'fHqecr<ofi'ayr<oii.floerorr,ry BaxHbrMr4npercraBrtlorctaHa!'II'ITI'IqecK14erzccreAoBaHr4t.'Koropbre noMofyr yroqHl4TbHeKOTOpbIeTeoperr'irrecKr.reacneKTbr npo6.nevsr,14 B STOM TaKXe [porBrrerc,aKryanr,Hocrr4peueu:upyeuoii/lr.iccepTarlurz14$arr ee Hayuuofi 3HarliMocrri.,IIrctr4ntclr rae.r.neo6xoAl.turtnIlOCJIeAOBaTen[,HopaccMoTpeTbanoJr,l.Hr'{qecKoer'r A'oHr4.Cr.rficroeHaqaJraB poMaHe E.
A. Harpoacxoft<fHeezger.t Kpacorbr ra 6e:o6pa:ur n povaHe <V 6pon:oeofiIBepH>;xyAoxecTBeHHOegrr{rlecKr4xr<areropuii<:la> u (Io6pa)BonJrouleHr{eB poMaHe<3nrre Ayxr4>. Tarnu o6parov, aHl.porroJrorr4r.recKr4eacneKTbr poMaHOBfluoHuco;E' A. Harpogcxofi oxa:rrearcrcr cBq3aHHbrMr{ aBropaperreH3r.rpyeMoEA!'rrpa6orrr cnpo6,renraruxofiQurocorpcr<ofi(<tr4veuHoQzlocoScrar a.qet cocTaBJIreT IIXcrepxeHi, 14 3aqacryro npuBoAr{T rreotrerpuuecxoil paccraHoBKe$uryp uonpe4e,reuuoii cxeMarr.rr.tHocru)(C.
76), a rar<Nec relecnoiu reH4epuofinpo6levaruroii.faasa II Aucceprarlr4oHuofipa6orr,r ocBerqaer olr.{H u3 LtHTepecHeIlruxacneKTOB TBOpqecTBa r43yqaeMofo aB,fopa,csfl:aHur,riicxyAoxecTBeHHbIMBonroueHr4eMMacoHcKxx llAeff r npo:e E. A. Harpo4cr<ofi.B aHa,usupyeMbrxflpor.r3BeAeHrzrx(paccxa: <Aru>,poMauax <Eopr6a lrurpo6oe>,<Be,ra.tKOJTOHHaAa>,(<xurrze OnuvnuaArr-reuur>) noc:re40BareJrbHor.{HTepnperr4poBaHbrnpo6neva <reu21epnofi BHHr,r) ri rporpaMMaocno6oN4euraa xeH[Ir.lHbr:n:auvogeficrer4e((MacoHCKOrO>ra<npo$aHHOrO))MrpoB B 3epKar'Hofr K'Mno3r4lrrupoMaHa;cJrI,trHI4eaHTr.rqH[txo6paron r4r.i21er4MacoFlcrBa.Xy40xecrneuHoe BOrrJrorrrerIr.re B TBOprjec'rseE. A.
HarpoAcr<oii iraacoucxofinpo6nenaruruz o6pa:uocru B rr4ccepraqr{ouHoipa6ore ocMr,rcJreHocraAuurir'Ho,B Ar,ruaMr.rKeu rpaucQopvarluu.Tar<,s poMaHe <XurueOlwrrarrua4rr-geetr>.Hanr,rcaHHoMn :pellriinepuo,1 TBoprrecrBa,aBTop Ar.{ccepraut{u yKasrlBaeroqeB,.lHbre nph3HaKUCaMocr orreJ.]buofi aeropc*ofirparcrosru vacou*<orl uaeu.JIto I4sr noAMeqaer opr'ir'HaJrbHoc*, 3Toro npor43BeAeHl,rs,3aKJrloqaloqyrcc, B ToM,tITo poMaHHanI4caHB xaHpe)Kv'tt4tr't{To nprzBHecJloB TpaKToBr(yr,{Aer,rMacoHcrBaueoxr4aHuuil cnexlrfi 3JreMeHr,noc*o,rbKyAa'nni xaHp oKa3aJrc's 60rsueiicreneHl4 cnoco6unu BbrrrBr.trbr,rHTeHrlr4rouacoucr<ofi AoKTpt4Hbr,.{eN{Kaxofi 6lI rouu 6ruo apyrofi.llo useuurc aBropa ar.rccepraur.rouHoipa6orr,r,E.
A. Harpo4cxaq 6rrra(eAI'IHcrBeHHaq'KTo pllcKHynnponafaHAl4poBarb KoMn-[eKc MacoHcKrrx rzAeE exy'4oxecrBeHHoM BI4Ae,npur{eM AeJIat aKIleHT rrcKJrloqureJrbHoHa cecrpI,IHcKoMeAI4HeHr{rr'I BOCXOXreHr4r4no cryneHrM AyXOBHO.OcoBepneHcrBoeaHux>(C. 5);(E. A. Harpogcna;r BCBOI4X[pot{3BeAeHU{XpoBoII,ITMaCOHCKyTOr4AeroxyAoxecrBeHHo,a He r43Jrafaeree ny6ruqucrr{qecKr4,He npu6eraer K rrra6roHHbrMQpa3aMnacoscr<oi nponoBeAr.i,a Bcefra HaxoAr.ircnoco6 qepe3xapaKTep'r,croxer,Qa6yry z rous:rur<ryBHAerr,nper4Myrr-recrBaMacoHcKoroMt4poBo33peHas>(c.
I 13).Brrrecrec rev, Jho I4ul lre oqeHriBaerpoMaHbrE. A. Harpo4crcoiixar noJrHoleHHbreI4AeOIOrAqecKr4epoMaHLr, ltocKoJrbKy,IIo ee MHeHHTO,B HXX OTCyTCrayerr,ranur,Ifinpr43HaK- HaJrI4qr4er.r4efrutrx cnopoB.BaNuo, qron 4auuoii nraBe ,rLo tr4ur., xapaKTepr43yerHOBaTOpCTBOE. A. Harpo4u<oiiu cur3r,tBaer:lry oco6enuoc.rbc pacKpbrrueMopuruna,rsnofiuacoscr<of ureu' 'ro, no croBaMaBTOpaAr4cceprarlrroHuofipa60*r, ((HecoMHeHHO.3HaMeHyerco6ofi reopuecxufi c4uzr 14HoBaropcrBo grofi nacareJtbHr.{rlbr,a Aa)KeBLI.M-TOAeJraeree yHr4KalTbHr,rMrfllreHueMe pyccxoii n,Teparype Haqara XX s.>( c .1 1 4 ) .B fraee III npoaHanusrrpoBaHaMiurar[po3a E.
A. Harpoacxoi. yxa:'eaq HaHeAOCTaTOT{Hyron:yvenHocrs :rofiNauponofr pa3HoBriAHOCTHB TBOpqecTBerr14caTeJrr,aBTOp guccepr.aquorruofi pa6orr,r ocBelrlae'fTaKI4e aCTIeKTEI,KaKrpaBecrr4poBaunenraQoe14feHAeprrbrxcrcpeo'rr4noB,crr.rJrr.i3arruru sauracrzuecrlre3ICMCHTLI.C nenrro..3aMeTr4TL, qTor.rMeHrro B 3TOM pa3AeJte AUCCepf alIH]t OITCBI,IAHOnpoqBnreTct yBJreqeHHOCTb ,rLo ZHrrenrofi, r,rro, 6eryc,roeuo, HEMOXCTBoonpr{Hr'IMarbcrHefarr{BHo,lro B To xe BpeMrMerrraeraBTopypa60ru o6reKrr.reHooqeHr4BarbxyAoxecrBeHHr,reAocror.rHcrBanp03br E.A.
Harpogcxoilrz, llpex,{eBcefo, KOHTeKC.I.,K r(oTopoMy cJIeAyel oTHOCr.r'fbee TBopr{ecTBo.AeropAuccepraur{truacrofr.rfigocrpeMr4TcryBrjAerE,IIpo3er,. A. fiarpoAcKOr4XyAOXeCTBeHHbteAocror.{'crBa raK Ha3lrBaeMoi <60lluroft><etrconofi> rzTeparypbl t4, yBJtcKarcLrofrulrnuneefi, He 3aMeqaernr4TeparypHbrxcTepeoTr4noB,rBrrloulr4xcq MapKepaMr4MaccoeofrJ'rr4reparypbr,sapoN4alorqeficrenepl4oA, KorAa 3aHr{Ma!'racbrBoprrecreola E. A. Harpo4cr<an. Jko tr4Hr oueHr4BaerCIO)KETHbICKoJrnn3uu paccKa3oB E.
A. Harpoacrofi.HanpflMyro, He ycMarpr4Bar3a 3Tr4MKaKKa)KeTCt,CJILIIIIKOMJrr4reparypHbrxSyHxquouuponar,ruaKJrr4ruezIxraMrIoB' He noApa3yMeBat' .rronr4careJ'rbHr.iqaHe croJ,IbKo Bbrcrpar4BaeroplzlI4HanEHyIoxy.qoxecrBeHHyIo KoHrIenqr4ro,cKoJ'rr,KocneAyerorpa6oraunuvvr<6o:*uroii>,rurepa:rypoii.Hanpuvep,3a crepeorr4rraMr.{,a*a,'u3vpys pacc*a3<Ponranruqecxoe[pr4*J']roqeHr4e), aBrop Arzcceprarlu[ B Kar{ecrBeorruqiare*uoirqeprbr BbrrenqerQarr coeAr4HeHnrB reM Tpex 3J.reMeHTOB:aBaHTiOpHOfOCru,nrera,pouanz.recxoi :rrc6osHoi r4c-ropuvuIereKraBa (C. 177), qro Ha Harrr B3r.rrrA,tB.IteTct cTepeoTI4rIHr,IMHCloxeTHbIMr.tKornr4314qMr4n 6e,uerpncrure.flosrorr'ry,uoNer 6rrrl, r4Bo BropoM'aparpa$e rperlei rraBr,rKoppeKrnee6rr,r6rr nrreo4 ue o napoAr.rpoBaH[r4cr{MtsoJrr4crcKr.rxuyefi, u reKcroB!a o6 nxrrepeHeceHl{uB BIrAe aKTyanbHbIXK.nulre n 6ellerplrc:ruqecruirercr, xotopuinpeAcraBJ'rqerco6ofi paccxa: HarpoAcxofi .Bnpoueu,:ro 3aMer{aHr{eHr,rKar(He o.r,MeHrrer3HaqeHrzsf,raerl III, nocKoJr'KvBHet [peAcraBreH noApo6nr,rii aHar'rlr3 ocHoBHbrx KarrecrBno3TrrKt4 paccKa3oBE.
Характеристики
Тип файла PDF
PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.
Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
