Отзыв на диссертацию (авт. Кузнецова А. А.) (1101913)
Текст из файла
roro olrrrorIer11aO'r':l,rno{rraurzaJrLro Ar4ccep'faufinJiro tr4ur,<'fnopuecral seolrrorlr4l11.A.Harpogcuotr s xouLer<cle uAefiso-acreruqecKhxucxauuit l9 I 0-x roAorrr,lrpcAc'faBneHHoiua coucrasue yueuoi cre[eH!.ta (r n.lto.ttot'uuecr(t4x Irayt(r(aHJll4llaiI 0.01.0 L PyccttanJll4Teparypano cneuhaJrbuocrufJraccepraqrllt Jho tr4ur lnlrrclcrcaMoctoneJlL"rtrHCCJIeAOBaHLieM,llOCBqrlleHHLIM flpe3eltTaUUU,3aBeplueHHbrMW\eiigO-3CTeTHTIeCKI4X nCXaUUii1910-x rolou B npou3BeAeuurx npo3auKa Il.A.
Ilarpogcr<oii, qle rBopqecrBo14 rrott't'ucoBpeMernraq all'l opy r(pl.rl 14Ka u 6o. ree I ro'rltnt4c 14ccJIeAoBarereAriHol.llacHoo[pe/{enr4Jrr.i B pa3pt/l <6yr t,sapuofi J]Hlepalyp},I>.I4ccleAoeasue ocHoBaHo Ha aHanlr3e6onrutot o r{opnyca xpyluoi.i v laattoilnpo3br, lz:.4aHsofrnxcare"[bHr{rleii s Poccuu Ao orbe3Aa B 3MI4fpar]I4Io.leMbt IIe noAre)Kul coMIIerJI4lo.Arlya;rsuoc'ru ra:6pat.rt-tofif{,u uulnleHunMeHTalrblloro KoHTe(c'fa H no:laer.iclBnl <o6ulux Mecf f ttoxu) Ha yMbl nroAeiir.i3yrrelMeTBopqec'fBa (B'fopopa3prlllr blx) 14(Tpcl l,cpa3prAfrbrx)) rucareJleii eajlaJIH lle Ba)I{Hcc, LIeM Kpylrn'tx, u 'fBopqecl'Be KolopLIX aln <o6ulue Mecla)I.icKaxeHbl cl4JtollbtMIroreM MoulHolo xyaoxec l'ner-rHoroirar.rpa.Bo Bsereuuu ttAuccep'larIHHu n calaoli pa6ole ue pa3 crpaBeilJr!.rnoolMeqeHo, t{'fo Hacne/rt1eE.A.
Ilarpolcxori, co4epxraluee Mlroro rtiue3rroii urr(ropuaqr.uz Anr uoseiiullrxcc:leltoBale'lreii,1o cux llop npaKfur{ecKhHe lr3yqaJIocb.Arrya:rrHlnl lBrtercl{enoclHoe paccMorpeHue npo3auqecKofo Hac'lle/(ulE.A. Harpoacrofr, enyrpeuHee eAuHcrBo Koroporo onpeaentercr uAefrltt tutzflor.lcKaMr4aB[opa, co3ByL]HblMHItoHTeKcl)/ 3noxH.KaK K Irpc3crraut4u eeAn'r'yarsrro o6patqelrue K.
feKc'l'aMttHca'r'cJli,lrHLu,ry6ex<,leuuli, c'faBtru4xpe3yJlt,'fa'foMee HpaBcf lreHHO-llcHXoJtot'ltqecKtlx lol.lct(ou.BLItBJtel{ue HllTepecltofo cn,raBa yBneqeHht nHcarerbHl.tublAxryallltoMacoI-rcKHMHI4AerMHu ee v;tc.rtefi, rocBrrl{er.Tl{Lrx(xencKoMy Bofrpocy)).14:6pauualr MeloaoJrorul HccJle1oBaH14l,coqe'r'arcu(al uvuaseurssti'i lrepMer'reBTu.iecK14t noaxoAbr, no3Bort4Jla cBrr3atr, yc'r'arroBKl.l aBrnpa fipilbrH r(o lcl(c'f 3IloxH.co3llarrr.jHxapat('lcpoBH 14cropl.]l{()-r(yjrbr)/ppcr(oMcnrar(nrj,llllr,llo/u,r nc{roplyrruporauHsteIlo.lroxeunr,HayqHoo6ocrrorranrtt,rmlt, lloKa3areJrbclBatgJttuo'lcqlluccep'fallu 14,y6e4z'rerlur,r 14xopouro apryMculnpoBanrt. I layurtr,rc pe3ynbrarr,r Llcclle.uoBanltrlbclnyer o rHqHoN4 gKJrare u ccJre/loBaletrt llJlo I4rrr, lleJroci'nLr H c tlt4,tle'l'eJrocMblcreHue JrH'repalypHolo r{acne,rlr,tlI 0-x loaon XX nexa.npcAclaBJrcIllrblxf{ocrrl ucp r ocr't'lle3yllbraroBrroATBcpxrcHanocJre.qoBarenbHlrMr.i AeraJrbr{r,rMaHa[u3oM npou:;ncAeunil E.A.
I{arporrcxoti, aTaK)Ke r(pHTliqecxoii orlcrrxoii cyulec'rBVrorrlHx pa6o'r' rro 'reopur4 u ,1c'topuanHTepa'fypbl.tr4cc,re4ouauue6a:upyer.cl ua BHy[rr4Ten",tu* *opnyae reoperr4qecKr4x14'fpylloB,Hcl'Opr,rKO-Ju4r'epa't'yprrLtxSra6trlrorpa$rarK lu4ccepl.aqll ar.,rrovaer.24guaraueuosauuii.B nepr:ofi rraBe Et4ccepra\t4n <tltuloco4tcralnpo$nevarnxa L4xyl{oxec'rBeHHarraHTponoJrofrzrB poMaHaxE.A. Llal'poAcxofi> Br,tnBJreHacBrr3l,eaNuer.irul.rx3ThKo-3clelHqecKr.ixngeil eloxu co c.fpyKTypoil nepcouaNa yT-.larpopcr<oii.PaccvarpuRanofino3r4uur.ianornollfiqecKn,ar, /lroiorauficroro, Kpacorr,r146c:o6parrr, Jto6pa H 3la lta Ma'lcpualc poMalroul:.A. I.:tar.portcxori, Jlro I4rrr,BblrBJr'e'r IIocJrelloBarenbHoe Br,IpaxeHhe rrttca'r'ejll,surleii ee y6eN4enr.ri,lrronoBoAy JrhqHoro xH3lrecrpoeHr4tB r{orrreKcreo6qnx Mecr 3noxH, Tar{HXKar{yB.[eqeHlieaHl ur roc'fbto H BonpocaMll <ocuo6oltJ(eHfi' xeHU]HHLI), c yqe.r,oMtllra:rococpcru x,c 14xolon4LlecKrx, corll4oJronjqecic4x r..r Kynbr.ypoJlor14qecKHXxourle rlrzii(d).
Hurlrrre,O. Beiiuru|epa,3. furrruyc, J1.Kotro6aenoii,O. Ma.r.uv;.'l'o'lHollblrBJreua paqronanblar flocJ'leAoBarellr,lrocl b l]brpa]r(eHur r rrHblxy6cxrlenrfirrca'r'erLuHur,rqepe3 rroc'rpoeHr4eJrHTepat.ypHbrxxapaKTepoBr.iJro|r4l{yfix ltporBjrerrHrru cfoxeTe.^tLToIjJlo obl r()nl'Ko orMerHTb, qro raKatl BblAepxal{lla'nocneAoBarent,t.tocrt).l.pe.t.bcfoxapaK'lepHa hMctrrro lIJrr IIHca'l'cltcH rlropol.o Hp'/Ia, BClloMIIhjl,HanpnMep,KaK xaJlonarcl Jlee To'lrc'r'oirua cBOeBorHeAHuu Kapeuuuoii,6opurleeca c ero xyl(oxecrseuHoli so,refi:<Korr.tas 1883 r.oly f .A. pycauon'I'olcrofi3aFOBOpr.tno6 o'rnouentrul aBTopar Arlrrc I{aperrr.rrroii,cHoBacocJrarclHa ol )r'r'I 1yr-rrrnHa."l'oropln, q'lo lrbr oqerib )r{cc'foKoIrocTyII4JInc AHHoilI{apeHarroii,3acl'aB}lBee yMepe'tblo/t BaloHot\4,q.r'orre Morjla xe oHa scK) xl,r3r{l>cl4Ac'11,c <<l't'orituclrrr.rlrofr> Alercecr,r Alercarrlll0tH.{eM", - cra:a,r Pycauor:."...1)'r'ourrcrrne Ha oMt4rraetvue crryuari,6LtB ir.iiac flyurrulrr,lv, - o'rBe't.fiJtl-o:rcrofr.
- O,rjrraxrt,r orr cxa3ar KoMV-l.or43cnoax npulretrcfi: <flpe71cr.ars.KaKyroturyKy yApana co uuoii vos Tall,nual OHa - 3aMyx{ Bbtil;ta. Sroro lr-l-oIlllKaK He OX(tr.rt2U]Ot'Hee".Nc cavoe Ll r M()]-ycr(a3arbIIpo Arrrry l{apenr.rr-ry.Boo6ulc repou 14l'cpo'.rrH Mor.iAeraro'r'Huor'/lal.aKne ur.ryKu,KaKr.{xl He xeJlaJt6t,r: oull /(enatolro, qTo .rloJllKHbltsoii xll:Hu u rcarc/.leJlarbn leticrgu.r.e.n6r,rBae.r.LITon Aeicrgrzrerr,s<'ti.'txuzllu, a He ro,MHexoqcLcr,r'.Bcl nlopoi r'.llanc<XylolKecnleHrroc ltotrJrotueuHeruracorrcrc.rxlrrci.i>ocyrrlecr'rltctr anutLi3 rrpon:tuc71ctrr,tr.i lr.A.
I lar.pqlcroii, o6.se/tuseunuxur|LeurlueiiBr,tpaxeHr..i'ee MacoHcKl.rxy6exlennl.i: paccr(a3a<AHrr)),IloBec}l<)i{Hrrae OlnmnuaAlr-Ienn>,poMaHoB <Bopl6a urtrpo6or>u <Be.nanrri.oKoJroHFra/ra)).3lecl, cnpancA:n4BorroK:l3arro,repoH 3Tl4x npou:te4eHufrIlecbMa I I OCJleltOBaTenLHo llpo'fhBOltoc fat:,Jlet{t,l/tpytr j a l e A r u H c n e p r I t , r u [ y 1 ' l ) J ] l . . r L t r r o f]oK H 3 H e c T p o e u h ' ./.lpyry KaK Halrrelltufie U He' (tl.H. Torcroi B aocnoMfiHaHurxcoBpeMeHHhxo8))?I 2-x roMax,T.
1. M., 1g55,c.231-232.Z 't'arNe Moxuo 6r,r,lto6tt 3aMe1'r4'lb, rt ro ltoc.lieAoBa'teloro peaJII43oBaLItralaBTOpCKarrparlHorlarbl'toc'r'b IIp14Boat4'rK ctoxert-roMy cxeMa'fu3My u t|JItAerctlpr.r3Har(oMr{enbrcoKoro xyAo)Kecf BeHHor-oypoBHrr npousneTleuuii.B rperleriuane <<Malar rtpo3a: gevnr]roloru:taqul,(tanrac-tvla Ll'rpaBecfHpoBaHI..tc)) paccMorpeHaIrpo3a Maroro xat.tpa, u ro ropofi E.A.HarpoTlcxal flpoBena pr;^q 3c1'erkqecl{l4x 3nc epr.JMeHToB,onrrb}Ke, KaKcnpaBeAnuBo nor{a3aJra JIxt 14nr,, n rrpxn,toil ri n ocJlcAoBare,tbltoii oBr3t4 cco6cTBeHr-lr,rMl..tMt4poBo33peHqecKHM14 ycraFroBKaMu.
I-{anpuvep,Kpt4ruKaxH3llccrpoolir..trrocyrilccl'llJteFla4uourzcufrcttol'ocro 9cpc3 r apo/ltjpoBarIt.lcr t p o t zr t r c t t c l r r i i n n h B c l t ) t ( e n u h t U , t, ' l t 4 o l h c i . i c l ( ( ) t ( ) r ( y n r ) t a t .3nrtogucuoliAurru6atr. 34ccr, nurepecHal llaxoAr{a }4ccJtcAoui}IcJtr- MbtcJl, o roNa,.lro ij.A.IJarpolcxarrrpelUroxr4lra <<cuoii,"xeucruzapnan'r" ro.ffinr4) (c.
209).Hayulrau rrollu3la pa6o'rbr o6yc:ronleua c:le/lylou.tuMt4 $arroparrau. 3.r.o.npex/(e ncero, o6parqeHue K Kopuycy Heu3yrjerrll j,rx n MaJtot43yr{eHutrxrexc.r.or;lr.A. I-larpo2lcr<oii,,r<oropr,rcr.tyxAarorcrr lt rreper43/lat1r.ll4t4 l.layqHoManarru3e.grzccep'r'auulJBuncpBr,le llpeAltputrrl a\ fii3 o6paron lepcouaxeii B rrpo3eE.A. Harpogcxofi u n;rlgleHlr BorrJlollleHHr,reB Hux aB'ropcKr.leLrH.reHqr4u.'Flosusnao6ecne.leHa ral(xe paccN4orpeHteM npo3at4rlecKofo rBopqecrBaI:.A.
Ilalporte r<oli r(aK llc-loL"rrroi.i xytro>rcccurerrrrr)i.i cHc tcMrir, o6.rallarouru.rcBor.lMnoco6errHoc'r'rrNar..tl.t Blly'fpeHHtlMl13aKoltaMl.i.J'arcuu o6pa:orv, t(eJrr, Hccne/(oBarrHfl- paccMorpet{14e<r.eopuecx<lii3Bonrout tl L.A. I larpo4crrtli'feHI{eHuHrMrznurepa'ryp}rot'ogolM r-paqfil4 n coorno[reurr H c BeAyutl.tMtlnpouecca I 91 0-x lr.> H ur,rrB;reHr4e(AHnaMHKhr r o c u l ) u rt t 4 t r l ( ) c l t M l ] ( ) J u . 1 ( ' t c l ( o t.
(t )h c t ( )n c a . r l r er r n r r u t . . t e< n x u n t e r t t l r . t i . il rroTu.rccnot 'rpaAullrzH), rrro llo3Bojlrrcr Bnl]ca'lL ee hMr (B flapaAur.MyMoAcpLllrclcKHx r.tcranuii XX c'r'o.rre|r.l'r> (c.6) - ltoct,Hr] ty-t.a, I locl.allJrerrFrLlcSa,ItaqHpc r.uc r,r.[r.rcceprarlul J]ort4rlto nbtcrpoeHa 14yilaqHo c.fpyl(rypr4poBaHa, Harrucal{axopolllHMrr3btr(oM uaKKypaTHo ocfopu,re r.r:,r, oTpa)KaeT I{aqr4TaHItoc.l.blrccnelloBa'teJrr,r{Hl_lt,rH ee cBo6oI oe Bjral(crrue o6lxupHr,rrrl ret(ctoBblMMaTepHaJroM.[1pz o6ulcit sr,rcoxoii ouef] Ke /p.lcceprau]414Herr,3rrHe o'rMcl.rrb HeKo'ropbrece IIcr(ortctbr.l). llo-lcpr:r,tx, Iro prA uecl(oJlbl(o3atralrr,qHBl,lx cylt2leuuii co 13neleuzu, uKoTopoMJho Zrrr, olpcAc:rrcl r,reclo tl.
Ilalpo;1cr<oi.iu JtHrepa.rypr.loMtrpouecce,qecKueo6o:penan Kpl4Tv14nr4TeparypoBeJtqecKHeoLleHKZee rBopqect.Ba.I3 o6:ope nonei.innx ucc,re4otarrui xieHcr<oi npo3l,l Konua XIX - rra.raJlaXX scrca JIto l4nr, y rBepxAacrJ rtro B coBpeN4cu.uoMJrllrepa.rypoBeAeHt4H lteul'tpa6o'r'atrocr, o pelteJrcIIlto|oMljerII4rr o roc14leJlbtIop14r.rHcJteHr.ltnpou:neilerruii A. ISep6rzurcoi;i,c roroptnrx r(pHTut{x-coBpeMeHHr.tKr.1nocloflHLrocpaBrruBanr4E. Flaryro4cxyro,rMaccosofr <6ynr,napHofr>>6el,rerpucrnre.ra c'r'aBHr'ro/r coMLlcl]Hc]ror,rBycMbrcilcrrrbref{nccepTar':tnbmolll,r11.M.3oprroia,Ilp14 31'oM IIpH3l'lallat,9'fo HccjIcj(ollaLcJtl,ttnrlcuycIIcluHo pctuct-ra3aAarla(or/lejru1b :epua S,rraropo/lHofor4cr{ycc'fBao'r IJrcBeJrpacxoxu x tolle;ror<> (c.28) u nnepnbre nor(a3aHbr<xolr6uHaqur4,cro)r{erub.rexoAbr, ocr,roBrrr,lerHrrr,rcroxel'olt ...
Характеристики
Тип файла PDF
PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.
Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
