Отзыв ведущей организации (сост. Проскурин Б. М.) (1098086)
Текст из файла
YTBEPXAAIOPerrop O|BOYyAapcrBeHHbIlIyHlIBepcLITeT)HAUUOHUTJIbHbIr lOprenuuMapra 2017 r.Orrmn neqyrqeft opraHl{3arlurr@e4epanrHoro rocyAapcrBeHHoro 6roAxernoro o6pasoBareJrbHoro frpexAeHllf,Bbr cruero o 6p asonaHu-a <llepvr cxuit ro cyAap crseHHnrfi HallrloHtumHrrfrur ccneAoBarenbcKl/tfi yullnepcLlTer))o Arlccepralrzrvr MoAzuofi falunm l4nanonnrr<Pannqt rpo3a frocrara (Dno6epa:CTaHOBJISHH e TB OpqeCrOfi vIIJ.AuBuAy aJrbHO CTI4 IILI C aTeJI.f ),rrpeAcraBlenuofi K 3aulrrre n flucceprarllloHHblfi coner A 501 .001-25npu MocroBcKoM rocyAapcrBeHHoM yHuBepcurere rrM.
M.B. JlouoHocoBaro crequzulbHocrLt 10.01.03 - Jlureparypa HapoAoB cTpaH aapy6exrx(enpHa COLICKaHIIeonefi cKafl vr aM ep IlKaHcKzuIyreuOfiCTeIIeHI4 AOKTOpaJILITe pary p a)SunOnOrruecKI{X HayK,.{nccepraqlu f.I4.MoauHofi rrocB{IrleHa cTaHoBJIeHkIIO TBOprIecKoI'Ir411uBu1yaJrbHocrlr fiocrana @no6epa u xyAolKecrnenHofi peaJua:,a\uvr sTororr.rrennfl, B ero paHHefi rlpo3e.ArcmyanuHocmb nrr6panuoro uccneAoBareJrbcKoro paKypca MorllBllpyerct,rrpelKAe Bcero, Heo6xoAuMocrbro BbrfBrrrb eAuHcrBo xyAolKecrBeHHoro Mlrpa, B3r'JrflA Ha paHH]IecorruHeHrr-fl KaK AoK)MeHTbr yreHruecxofi rropbl) (c.66), cocraBurbrrpeAcraBneHue o rnopuecxofi un4vrBvqyaJrbHocrpl rrplcareJlfl, Bo MHoroMpannefi [po3br f.Ono6epa, (firpeoAoJrerborrpeAenkrBrxerocJlo)KrlBrnuitco6nux conpeuennofi nureparypbl.
CraHosreHue rropuecxofrvHnvBvr1yilrrbHocrLt @no6epa paccMzlrpuBaercfl. KaK AuHaMurlecrufi rpoqecc,o6ycnornenHufi oco6eHHocrflMrr MrrpoBocrptrflTufl. aBTopa. Aerop A?IccepraIIuLIrrpecJreAyer rlenb uepecMorperb caMcrarycpaHHI4x rlpon3BeAeHprfi IlucareJrt.flocleaonarenbHo orcrauBaercfl rrccJleAoBarenbcKzLq rro3Llqu-fl: orpoqecKoe.roHorrrecKoe rBopqecrBo Ono6epa, ne npo6anlrreparypbr.vr[gpa, a 3Haqurelnnrtfi Qa*t ucroppll4I{enrpalrHofiALrccepraIIHI4 .tBJlaercfl upo6neua rnopuecrcoftNrflco3Aaer Bo3Mo)KHocrb cncreunofi penpe3eHTarlukrvrtr4krBvr4yulrlbHocrrl, tITopaHHero rBopqecrBa rrr{careJrfl.
llpeacraBneHbl MHorotILrcJIeHHbIe noAXoAbIK3Toro Senorvrena. Tnopuecxafl nHlvrBLlAyzurbHocrb LlccJleAyerctBrroHprMaHr{roac11ercregBonrorlr{ll. Axqenrupo BaH 6raorpa$rue crrafi rIoAXoA rr xpoHonoruq e clcufirrprrHIIkIrI.Ono6epfrocraeoAr4Hlr3 Han6oneeLI3) IeHHbrx aBTopoBrr1rreparypbr, Srro6eponeAeHlre Mo)KHo Ha3blBarb orAeJIbHbIMB vrcropkrkrHanpaBJIeHLTeMMlrpoBoro nrrreparypoBeAeHrrfl. Hayuuan Hoeu3Ha rlpeAcraBnenHofi pa6ornro6ycnouena HeAocraro.rHofi u3freHHocrblo orpoqecKorovrroHorrrecKoroHacneArrrr rrr{careJrr.florrpeAcraBJr.rrer co6oro[epBoe B orerlecrneHnofi HayKe o6paueurle K rIoJIHoMyclpaBeAJrrrBoMy 3UUIBJIeHLIIo aBTopa, Aaulrafi. paooraKopnycy pannefi rpo3br @no6epa.B uefi nnepnue rpeArlpplHrlro no4po6uoe?rccneAoBaHrde paHHux nporr3BeAerruit llepe3 rIpIl3My craHoBneHllr rBopqecKol4LrHALrBvrAyrZlIIbHocTtI, [OCneAOBaTeJIbHO Il3]IeHbIugTopkIqeuxui1rcnxoJropuuecrcuir, $ruoco$cr<11fi, arro6uorpa$nuecxufi qztcnrr paHuefi rpo3bl,rrpo cJre)rsB aeTc_fl SBoJrroqrur TBopqeAnropcKoro c aMoco3HaHl{fl rIrIcaTeJUI.Alrcceprarlrdu npn6eraerKpa3nI/FIHbrM*temodau anarwr3avrB pa6ore rcnoJrb3yerctuoAxoA, BKJrloqarou\r4ir s ce6.fl l4cropllKo-LrHTepnperar\ukr nrrreparypHoro rporrcBeAeHprn.crrHTerurrecr<rafi rrccneAoBareJrbcKr4finr4reparypuufi, lrcroprrKo-KyJrbrypHrtfi, 6uorpa$r.ruecrrafi,krcropr{rrecrzfi , repMeHeBruqe cxraft MeroAbIcpaBHureJrblro-.B KatrecrBe ocHoBHoro Jvamepuailo uccneAoBarg.vfl.rrporr3BeAeHr{.fl (Dno6eparoAoB, KpoMeroro183l-1849 rr., a raKxe pyKotlucu u rucbMa 1831-18806oJrbrrroe BHLrMaHrre yAeJulerc.a I4croprrqecKrlM, $unocoScKl4M,SCT9TLIq9CKUM TPYAaU COCTaBI/IBIIIIIMvrll AkrBvrAy arrbHoBblcrynz[orcTI4 IIHC areJl.f,KoHTeKcr SoprvrnpoBankrs.
rnopuecrofi.Qenu AIIccepTaUIroHHoro uccneAoBanufl f.I'I.Mo4ranofi - c$opullpoBaTbcr{creMHoe npeAcraBneHr{e o paHHrrx cotIrrHeHVrIX Ono6epa, (BorIJIorLrBIrruxcraHoBJreHr{eerorBoprrecKofr Lrnl.vrBvr[.yarlbHocrtl, BbLgBlITb]IxHcroplrKo2nlrreparypHoecoorHocr{Tcrcucm eneHb uayuuC mpyrcmyp aoud o cm oe epH ocmu.pa 6 omu, coorBercrByer rlocraBneHHbrM 3aAaqaM.krg BreAenra-fl, rrerbrpex rJraB, 3arcrtro.reuurcrrrrcKa, BKlrorraroqeroBogro o6eclequBaer AucceprallzonuoftMeroArrKoit a:narusa. Bcepa6ore BbrcoKylococrolrrxyAolKecrBenHoe 3HarIeHpIe)) (c.65). VIz6pannufi Marepuzu767 sanueHosaHufiBne.qenvrvr o6ocnonano6"ao, [peAMer, uenb vrfluccepragunvr 6u6nuorpa$zuecroro.nu6op reMbr, ee arcryaJrbHocrb, oflpeAenflorct3a1anrvr, Ha)rHarHoBrI3Ha, TeoperuqecKzulkrrparcuqecKar 3HaquMocrb uccJreAoBalufl..
EesycronHo IIeHHofi .racrrrc pa6orrr.flBJUreTC.fl OTAeJTbHO rrpeAcTaBneHHa.flplcTopl{rl rBrIeHHrI paHHefo TBopqecTBarrlrcareJur: [oAXoAbr, oueHKLr, orrbrrbr rcraccn$uKallrrrl paHHrIX [pou3BeAerruit ur.A. Bo MHoIoM AuccepraHr u4er :a $pauqy3cKl,IM nllTeparypoBeAoM XanovEprono, KoropoMy ([pr,rHaAJre]Klrr rrepBar rcnaccz$uKarlprfl paHHHX coqunenufi.VqnrHsar ux)KaHpoByro[prrpoAy, oHBbIAeJII4JT Ltcropuqecrnfi,rclrxoJrornuecrufi, Snnoco$crcufi (uucuruecxufi)rlzKrrbrvranro6uorpaSr,ruecrufi) (c. 1 5 ). I,IsroxeH a krcr opufl.
uy6nlrxaq ufi. pauuux reKcroBBo BropoM.pa3Aene BseAeHLI-fl KoMMeHTnpyerc.fl KrroqeBoe Mflr{ccneAoBalJufl rroHrrTne (TBopqecKafluE4vrBlrAyarrbHocTb)) B acrleKTe cTaHoBJIeHLItoraHTrrrrHocrr{ ,qoXXIBeKan $unoco$uu u JrlrreparypoBeAeHllu, B ToM rIrIcJIelzreparypnofi KpLrruKe. Anrop AlrcceprarlrlrrcrpaBeAJIr4Bo 3aflBrrfler'- rITonoHkrMaHue SenonaeHa rBopqecxofi vrnilr4BnnraJrbnocrtl ((cB.f,3aHocrIoHHMaHueM[prrpoAbr xyAoxecrBeHHoro reKcra, BHprMaHLreM K nureparypHblM TpaAuqPItM,BKlrrorreHpreM,lz6oBlrccJreAoBarenfl or{cKrroqeHueM TBopqecrBa flvcrreIrfl.m,rreparypHufi [poqeccHrrpeAcraBJreHr4.rrMrrrlcroprlKocylrlHocrl4rrcroprrecKoro rpoqecca> (c.55).flepna.a lrraBa <<Wepapr'un yHI,IBepcWa B paHHefi npose @no6epa (18311838rr.))BKJrroqaer qerbrpe uaparpa$a. 3Aecr B rlenoM npeAcraBJleHa vcropurlCTAHOBJIEH}I'I OHTOJIOTIIIECKUX, SK3UCTEHIIIIAJIbHbIX, I{CTOPIIKO-SruTOCO$CKTXycraHoBoK frLrcure[fl., rrccneAyroTcfl npolr3BeAellvrflrrcrfrxoJrorurlecKorou $unocoscr<oro qlrKJroB no rceuucTopuqecKoro,nrHoroo6pa3kru x€HpoBbIXSopr.
Bolrruoe BHHMaHrre yAeJurerc.fl rro3TlrKe (HerrcroBoro) poMaHTu3rraa. Bflepnou naparpa$e anarru3r4pyrorc.fl LrcropruecKr{e coquHeHrlrl (Hore.nlrt<JlroAonzxXIII> (1831), <Tafina @unuuua Ocropoxnoro, Kopoltklcnalrrnu>>,<.IWa no OlopeHrluu)), <HoprvrauAcKar xpoHlrKa X seKa) (1836), ucroplltlecKplecrleHbr dlocneAuss crleHa cMeprl4 Maprapurrr BypryH4cxofi> (1835), <Crvrepurepqora Ae fr,rsa>,<<AnepyKu Ha KopoHe> (1835), Ap?ua <JftoAosurc XI> (1838)).y5egr,neJrbHo apryMeHTkrpyer coAepx(areJrbHyro kr gcrerurlecKylof-Z.MoauuarleHHocrb rrpotr3BeAeuuit, KoMMeHTupyer npeAcraBrrenvrfl,o cyrrlHocrnLIcropuLIroHoro Olo6epa, cuequ$ury pr cre[eHb BrruflHkrr Ha Hux ro3AHeaHtuuuofi,poMaHTruecroftpeHeccaHcHofi3aKrroqeHzercoHrleuqlrft.
nenaercs o6ocHosaHHoeo roM, rrro vrcroptrr (B paHHnxcMbrcJr He loJrllTr4.recKufi uJrrr MopulJnnrrfi,[porr3BeAeHllflx (Dno6epa klMeeruo uera$rircrirrrecKllfi u ecrerrqecxzfi>(c.e3).Bropofi uaparpaS uocnsrqen rcuxoJroruqecKr4MHoBeJrrraM(<Herecra uMort4rra) (1835), <Enaroyxanvre, vrru KoueAuanrrr>> (1836), <Crpacrrto6po.qereJrb) (1836), <Eu6nuorvrannn>> (1836), <cfpocrru 6eccurue>vr(1836)).OcHonareJrbHo npoaHaJrlr3upoBaHbr t4x cro)KerHbre ucrorrHrrKr4, rlooroJrorrl.lecKueoco6eHHocrv.Bnporr3BeAenkrflx $znocoScKoro qrrKJra($ 3) oco6oeBHVMaHUeyAeJrrercr cranoBJreHuro oK3lrcreHrlrr€urbHbrx ycraHoBox f.@no6epa.
B uerneprouuaparpa$e uccireAyrorc.rr rpeAcraBJreHv-fl o rBopqecrofi JrurrrHocrr{ (<Cueprurrfiqac),<<XeresHaf,pyKa), <Agcxax rpe3Du<Quidquid volueris>). AnropBrIeJroM Tparcryer nporl3BeAelIufl, ucropuqecKoro,rrcrfxoJroruqecKoro vr SruocoScKoro qLrKJroB KaK orrbrr caMoaHaJIrI3a,SK3rrCTeHrILraJrbHOrO kr rBopqecKolo co3nAaHr/rrr.
Becrua r{HTepecHbl uAr4CCeprarIuHKoHrlelryarrbHbr na6rmAenurt 3a reM KaK MorlrBbr orporrecKoroTBopqecrBa peaJrlr3yrorcflurouorrrecKoroB 6onee 3peJrbrx rporl3BeAeHrrrrx Ono6epa (c.la\.Or4emuo xorrerc-fl orMerr,rrb HeBeporrHyro rrrlareJrbHocrb f.I4.Moanuofipa6orecBxyAo)r(ecrBeHHbrM Lr AoKyMeHTamHo-6norpa$nuecKr.tM Marepl4€uloM(uaupuruep,trpEycraHoBnenvrkr r4crorrHr,rKoB BlrLrflraprr,Sznoco$cKpre HoBeJrJrbr-HaroHoilrecKuec.144). flpuuqnuu€rrrbHbrM Nrfl ucureAoBaHrrrr flBJr.rerc-tBhrBoAo ToM, rrro [rrcbMo craHoBr{Tcrrro3HaHurr Mupa pr caMorro3HaHrrr)AJrrr roHoro xyAo}KH}rKa ((LrHcrpyMeHToM(c.16l).Bo nropofi rnase <MerauopSo:u flosra.
Anro6prorpaSuuecKr{e coquHeH}rt1838-1841rr.>> paccMarprrBarorc.rr upo6lervrrr (crorrcKa prAeHTr/rrlHocrn cylrlHocrplTBoprrecrBar4TBopqecKoro cy6rerra>. O6pauraercfl BHuMaHr{e Ha Bo3H}rKHoBeHr4enonofi roBecrBoBareJrbHofi $oprvru (ucuone4zrJrbHbrx $parnaeuron) n rBopqecrBeOno6epa. Arro6uorpa$rvecKrae [por{3BeAentrt KoMMeHTupyrorc.rr qepe3 rrpLI3My3K3vcreHrllruurbHbrx MorrrBoB TpeBoru,cyAr6u v cMeprrr.CyruecrneHHoeBHr4MaHkre yAeJreHo (QrcrorrHrrKaM BJrLt rlJvrf>>, uHTepTeKcTyzurbHoMy KoHTeKcTy.Trqarenruo ocMbrcJreHa oprreHTarlr,rf, groro grarra rBoprrecrBa He roJrbKo HapoMaHTrlqecKyro, Horr HanpocBerprreJrbcKyro TpaArdrlzrc.coAep)KareJreH amaJrvrg ((Bonbrepr.flHcKofi)B .racruocrn orleHbLr (pyccoucrcrofi>>cocraBJr.flroulux@.249.,,{lrccepraur Aenaer pflpBDKHbIXorHocnTeJrbHo npo6reuarnru,fIOSTLIKI4,AIr'd nccJreAoBalIkrfl3aKIIoqeHHucneqn$urur )r(aHpoBblx Soptrr.
Характеристики
Тип файла PDF
PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.
Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
