Отзыв ведущей организации (сост. Проскурин Б. М.) (1098086), страница 2
Текст из файла (страница 2)
Tar<, ocuoBareJrbHo ocBerlrBgcrerkrqecroft ueHHocru v )KaHpoBoHanro6raorpaQuuecrcux npolr3BeAenufi 1838-1841HarrHyrorroJreMuKyrprrpoAbrrroBecTrrconuAapHocrb<<oco6yroOTHOCLITEJIbHO<Menayapu6eeyrraqa>, f.I4.Mo4vrnac X.Eprono B ToM, tITo gro upoI,I3BeAeHpIeSopry anro6uorpa$uu: n nefi coeArrHr{Jrrrcbo6o6qenlr.a, cB.rr3aHHbre cBbICKA3bIBACTrpeAcraBJr.uer co6ofiLrcnoBeAblaH4vrBvrqyuurbHbrM )Krl3HeHHbrMu $urocoScrueorrblToM) (c.182).Kffo.resrrM Nrfl groro npolr3BeAelnvrfl flBrrflercfl MorLrB 6esyrvlax, uMeHHorrprrAaer BHyrpeHHroro rleJrbHocrb HcrroBeAairbHbrM Sparrvreuranr. EesynaneHcroJrKoBbrBaercfl npex(Ae Bcero KaK (Mera$opa rBopqecKofi cso6oAbr).[peAcraBJr.rrer co6oro krcrroBerbfloera ur) oAHoBpeMeHHo,oHllograIlorecrr(MacrepcKyro)rrncareJur, craHoBrrqerocf XyAoxur,rrorvr.3Ha.rurerbnas, qacrb rJraBbr rrocBrrrleHa rrccneAoBanuro Mrrcrepuu <Cuap>(u.u. 3.1, 3.2, 3.3), oAHoMy vrs Han6onee nporrrBopeqrrBbrxrrpol,leBeAerruir paHHero [epuoAa rBopqecrBa rrcarew.
fluccepraHTucJro)r(HbrxanarrvgnpyerMHOIOIII{CIeHHbIe JII,ITeparypHbIe VCTOIIHI,IKI,I, IIOBJIrITIBIIIIIe Ha CTaHOBJIeHLIe STOIO53aMbICJIa, AOKa3aTeJrbHo yTBep)KAaf,frTo B cI4cTeMe ul[Jrlo3rrr4 llpo.flBnteTctaBTo6uorpaSuuecrcufi xapalcrep coqr,ruenvrfl.. MucrepnzlJlbHuul$opua oK€t3zlJracbaxryanrHofi Nrfl, BbrpilKeHr/rrr rpaHcIIeHAeHTHoro, Ml4crkIrlecKoro Lrr4pp auHoHaJrbHoBe orIbITa MoJroAoroIILI c areJrfl.3aKrroqeHr,re rJraBbr Aenarorc-n [pr4HIIulI4aJrbHbIeBbrBoAbro6 ycno)r(HeHrrr{xaHpoBbrxna6moAe;g1]grfl 3aoB grofi qacru rarcKe rpo.flBarlc-flo6cro.areluufi r4cropr{3M, rrpltcyrqufi BceMyc^lrfl.$opt, yrny6nenuz npeAcraBJleHlr.acyrrlHocrlr rBoprrecrBa H TBopqecKoro aKTa.Blrpryo3Has. pa6orauccJreAoBaHufluccJIeAoBaHuIoBaerurflwru, $arraivru.
OcyulecrBneHrr uyborvreuIIeJroM,roHKrIecruJreM rrrrcareJr.rr. B qacrnocrrl, oAHLtM us HauooJree rIHTepecHbIXnoKa3zlJrocb pa3MbrrrrJreHlreBbrpa)KeHr,ru oco 6ofiroqrlro rporecKe B <Crr,rape>> rIKaK o upz€ue, H KaK o3peHkl.a (c. 2 I 8).I{ccneAonanve gBonrorlr4rl rropuecrofi vr:nqtrtBlaqyuulbHocrtl @no6eparrpoAonlKeHo BrpeuefirJraBerpo3a 1842-1845 rr.)).MorrrBoB-B<Or lloera x Xy,uonffir{Ky. Asro6uorpa$uuecrca-rrroBecru <<Hox6pr>> orMeqaerc.fl roflBJreHlle HoBbIxMorrrBon rno6nu H crpacrlr. I4ueuuo crpacrb HatlrlHaer ocMblcJrtrbcflKaK CrprMyr rBoptrecrBau ocHoBa Jrr/FrHocrlr llosra. B uosecru <Hox6pr> (Dlo6epfpaHr4 co6crneuHoro cyrqecrBa: gcrerlltlecKoe co3Hanlle,rryBcrBeHHocrb vr rrpaKTrrecxufi pa3w.
,{parvra rroltcKa LIAeHTurIHocrr4 6nnarrpeAcraBr4JrrprrrrpoAonlKeHa B poMaHe <flepnoe "BocnuraHr4f, tIyBcrB").qrorepoft-xyAo)KHlTKvrl1uBrrg;yuurbHocrlrOlo6epa, rrrorrBopqecKnx crpeMneHufi>>r{erreprarB poMaHelloBbIBoA o roM,((crIMBoJILIqecKoe BorlJrolrleHue$oprvrupoBa:nurfl. o6paea(<x) vr IIeJIb ero(fi24).rJraBa rrocB.rrueHa anurtr3yAnronu-a) (1849).,{elaercxueprofi BepcrlllsaMe.raHuro AprccepraHTa,3ro<<I4crcynreHrlrl cB.f,TororIpou3BeAeHHe 3aBeprraerfraBa cocrovrr u3trflTvr naparpaSoB,BKaIKAOM tr3 KOTOpbTX nOCJreAOBaTeJrbHO OCMbICJUtrOTC' BCe BOnpOCbI CB.fl3aHHbIeCpaHHufi neprroA TBopqecrBa rrucarerrs.racropuefi co3AaHrrrr ApaMbr, rrcroqHr4KaMlr BJlrlflnux, oco6eHHocrtMrl peqeruIrrll Bo(Dpanqzu u Poccura Lr, KoHerrHo, cuequ$r{Ka reMarLIKlI, [po6leuarzxu, rIo3TuKLI.OcnorareJrbHo ocMbrcJreH alrJreropuqecrrafi oK3tIcreHIItIzlJIbHbIft uoArercr clo)I(erao6 ucryru entrvr cBtroro.Vlsapy6exHoe,o6parqanocrvroTerIecTBeHHoe JIHTepaTypoBeAeHne HeoAHoKpaTHoK uepnofi Bepcr4vr<I4crcymeHrllD).
I,IccneAoratervI, HarlpuMep,ll.@.flpeo6paxencrufi, cxlroHHbr KoMMeHTupoBarb (orcroplrtlecKrle I4cKaxeHLIt))Kr4Tvrfl.cB.flToro, (HeBepnbrfi parcypc), [peHe6pexeHl4e coIIr4zuIbHbIM KoHTeKcroM y@no6epa. Anrop Atrcceprarlvrv orcrauBaer MbIcJIb o roM, rITo"I4ctcytte;g{ut cB-nroro AHToHu-fl"6rrnganeprueH aBTopoM,co6creeHnofi cuuclonofi u gcrerurrecxofi rleHHocrbloI,r<raxAufiraxArrfiBapLIaHTo6naAaer3acny)KuBaer orAeJrbHorofipoqreHu.rr u noHr4MaHufl). Cssroft AnroHufi Bblcryilaer B ApaMe cl4MBoJluqecrofi$nrypofi XyAoxHr,rna, a ucxryrxenus, s laeir rpeAcraBJreHbl KaK co6rasH orKa3arbc-aor rBoprrecrBa Lr Bepbr B r{cKyccrBo.
OcyrqecrsreHHrrfi aHaJrLI3 Aenaery6e4urenbnbrM BbrBoA: <o6pas cBflToro orrrreJlbHuKa craHer 3HaKoM o6perennx(Dno6eponr rrAeHTr{rrnocrr{u6yger raKoBbIM Ao KoHIIa ero Auefi> (c.398).B 3alcnro.renm rrocJre.rloBareJrbHo v qerKo rIoABoMTct I,IToruIlccneAoBaH.krfl'.B coorrercrBuu c orrpeAeJreHHbrMtr rr rrpoaHuuIH3LIpoBaHHbIMLI n uerup€xpa6orrrrJraBaxcraIlzlyrluLr rBoprrecKoro cztMoco3Hald.ufl Bblcrpal4Baercfl. nepuoAkl3ar\vrfl.paHHero TBopqecTBa @no6epa(3nry:ua"suKapnana.nvCrusrenueflpeo4oreHue).Hecrvrorp fl. HaLrcqeplbrBaroqzfiaHaJrvr3,xoreJlocb 6rI saAarr AuccepraHTyHecKoJrbKo BorrpocoB.1. Ecrr nu ilprrHrln[LrzurbHbre pacxoxAenufl Baruefi KoHIIemIUH paHHero rBopqecrBaOno6epau roir, rrro BbrcrpauBaerc.flB Alrcceprallurl O.B.A$aHacresofi (<PanHeerBopqecrBo fiocrana @no6epa (1835-1845)).M., 1975)? I{eu onu o6yclonrreHu?2.
B Barrreu LrccJreAoBa'rr:sln pannuit reprroA TBoprlecrBa @lo6epa ilarvrpyercs1849rr. (c l0 ao 28 ner). C rarrauuBCTyrrJreHr4rr frvrcaTe[fl,BnperIeAeHrHbIMrI1831-cJlflaflllu croJlb paHHerorronHorleHHylo TBopqecKylo )KI{3Hb MOI(HO eroconocraButs?Ocvuecrsr€HHoeOro6epaBacreKref .I4.Molunofi vccneAoBalrlae paHnerorBopqecrBacraHoBJreHurl rnopueclcofi uu.AnBrz.ilyzlllbHocrr4 rlMeer6onrruyro meopemuqecKytounpaKmuqecKyto 3HaquMocmb.nureparypoBeAeHue sneAeHHonufiBoreqecrBeHHoeMarepLIuIJr xyAoxecrBeHHoro6uorpaSrvecKoroxapaKTepa,rrpoLr3BeAeIJI..Ifl., IIocyrr4, Bocco3AaH AHHaMIlrtIeCrulfi IlpoqeccxyAo)KecrBeHHoroorKpbrBaerrpoueccaHoBbIenpOaHUUILI3I{pOBaHbI HeI/BBeCTHbIe paHeecraHoBJreHLIeMlrpa BeJrrlKoro nvcuterl. [uccepralln I f.I4.MoauHofirepcrreKTrlBblBocBoeHkILI cneqraQzrn JluTeparypHoro$paHI1yscxofi, TaK LI MplpoBofr nrlTeparypbl.xar<PesyntrarrrMarepuzurkrr4ccJleAoBanvtfl.,Moryr 6urrKyJrbTypoJrorr4rrecKr.rxarrcrroJrb3oBaHbrkrTarcKe nneAeHHufiB nayuuufto6oporB Jrl,ITeparypoBeAtlecKzx, Snnoco$crux,Me)r(Ar4cIIuruIIHapHbIXPICCJIeAOBaIIUTIXTBOpqecTBavr nl4reparypHoro rpouecca XIX BeKa B IIeJIoM, B By3OBCKOMrperroAaBaH:ala plcropvu uupoeofi Jlllreparypbl, vrcropvn $paHqyscrofi@no6epaJruTeparypbru rBoprrecrra f.@no6epa.
fluccepraqufl f.tr4.MoAnnofi .gBJr-gerctaKryztrrbHbrM, apryMeHTI4poBaHHbrM, LrccneAoBaHLIeM, BHocLIT6olrruofiBKJTaA BMrrpoBoe $ro6eponeAeHkle.Ha 3aTTILrry rroJrox<eHl4.fl Arlcceprallupl f .tr{.MoaunofiB vrg4anvrflx,pacKpbrBarorct B 58 ny6tuxaryutx, r{3 Koropblx 17peKoMeHAoBaHHbrx BAK PO, 2 - vorrorpa$nu, 3 - yue6Hrre roco6r4t, 6 Brr4ruraeMbrenepeBoAbr paHurrx rrpor,r:BeAenuit Ono6epa c KoMMeHTapvflMvr r4 BcrytILITeJrbHbrMLIcrarb-flMr4. Ony6nuKoBaHHbre rro reMe uccneAoBantrfl MarepLIaJrhI Id aBTopeSeparrroJrHocrbro orpalKullor KJrIorIeBbIe rIoJIo)KeHvfl, Al4cceprarlrlH.,,{uccepraqrroHHoe uccJreAoBaHnefarunrrI4eaHonHu MoAnnofi <PaHHxsrrpo3a fiocrana Ono6epa: craHoBJreHrre rropuecrofirrprcareJr.fl), npeAcraBJreHHoevrnl:vBvruyanbHocrllB finccepraqzoHnrtfi coBer LMocxoncKoM rocyAapcrBeHHoM yHr{Bepcvrere501.001.25 rpnnu.
M.B.JlonaonocoBa, orBerlaerTpe6oBaHvrflM, rrpeAbflBJrfleMbrM K AoKTopcKr4M ALIccepraIIHrIM Iro crrerluzlrlbHocru10.01.03<Jlureparypa HapoAoB cTpaH sapy6exrx>> (enponeftcr<axaMepuKaHcKa.fl JrrlTeparypa), oTBerIaeT rpe6oraHllf,M nyHKToBLr9, 10, ll, 13, 14<flotoxeHlr.fl o rpucylKAenvpr yreHbrx creneuefi> (ymepxAeHo nocraHoBJreHueMflpanzrenbcrBa Poccuficrofi @eaepar\r4kr l\b 842 or 24.09.2013). B raccneAoBaHlrllf.I4.Monunofiperi[org.gHa]rqHble npo6neMbl I4Meloque cyqecTBeHHoe 3HarIeHI'IeAJI' CoBpeMeHHoro nureparypoBeAeHllll.Anrop Ar,rcceprarryroHHoro rrccJreAoBalufl,3acJry)KrrBaer npucyx(AeHrrrrcrequ€IJlbHocrl4falllnaMoAnna?IsaHonHa-$ulorrorrrecKl{x HayK IIo((Jlp1reparypa HapoAoB cTpaH :apy6exlx>ucrouofi crerreHll10.01.03(enp o uefi cKar, vr aM ep rlKaHcKa.fl-JILIrep aryp a)AoICTopa.o AorcropcKofi Aucceprauuu f .kI.Mo.qunoft rroAroroBJleH AoICropoMvSunorrornvecKl{x HayK, upoSeccopol,r ra$e4pu naupoeofi nllreparypbl-Ors51BKyJrbrypbr@fEOy BOrrccJreAoBareJrbcKr{fiyHnrepclrrer) fIpocrypHHHbIM Bopuconr MprxafiioBr/ttleM.OrsrIr o6cyx4en unureparypbrkr<fleprvrcxrafi rocyAapcrnenuufi HaUrloHaJrnnrrfiyrBep)KAeHKyJlbrypblHaOfEOy BO3acera:nuvrJ\bMLIpoBofi<<flepvrcrufi locyAapcrnenuufiHaUr{oHaJlrnufi LlccJleAoBarelrcrufi yHVBepcLITeT)(llporoxorxa$e4prr20MapTa 2017 IoAa7).3ane.4yrorqufi xa$e4pofi urzponofi nureparypblr4KyJrbrypbl'OfEOy BO <flepucrufi rocyAapcrneunufiHaIII{oHzuIrnrrfirrccJreAoB areJlbcKufr ynun epAor$op $nnonorntlecKl4x HayK, npo$eccocurer))p----flpocxypnuH BoPuc MuxafirosuqCseAeHur o BeAyqefi opranu3alluu:(De4epanrHoe rocyAapcrB eHHo e 6roAlKeruoeBbrcruerooo 6p asoeareJrbHoe yqpe)KAeHl're6pasonanua <lleprvrcrolfi rocyAap crn eHnnrfiHarlrroHulJlrnrrfi uccJreAoBareJlbcKl'Ifi ynunepcllTer)),614990, r.flepur, yl.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
