Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (1149868)
Текст из файла
OT3hIBo$uqnanruoro ornoHeHTa Ha,{ucceprarluoHH},ro pa6ory Kararosa feoprur Aru6erosu.ra<Heuepryp6arueHoe peHopMrpynnoBoe r4ccneAoBasue cxefimaHroBoro [oBeAeHr,rr),npercraBJleHHylo Ha coplcKaHrae yueuofi cre[eH]r KaHAprAara Susuxo-rraateMarr.rqecrr,rx HayK rrocrequanbHocrpr 0 I .04.O2-Teoperlrqecxtrs Sraaura.{ncceptaqrroHHa.s pa6ora f.A.Ka-uaroBa flocBrrrleHa H3yqeHuro KprlTr.rqecKoro troBeAe:aus. uSasonsx [epexoAoB B HeKorophrx paBHoBecHbrx r,r HepaBHoBecHbrx MoAenrx crarucrzqecrofi(fusnxu B paMKax neuepryp6arl{BHblx reoperuKo-noJreBhrx Mero.{oB: r.rHcraHToHHoro aHirJrr.r3a r,rnenepryp6arunnofi peHopMirn[sarluoHHoft rpynnhr.Kpnruuecxoe rIoBeAeHLIe MHorLIx @usuvecxux cr{creM npr,rHaAnexr,rr KJraccy yHr,rBepcanbHocruuoAenefi gn, tr:3, 4, c lolluu pa3nlltlHofi reouerpr4vt vr rvilav,lr crrMMerpran.
IrlnQpaxpacHoe(ZK)noneAeHl{e noAo6usrx naoAerefi cqr.rraercflxopouoprccJreAoBaHnrru.O4uaro B cryqarrx,KorAa An.f, orI[caHI{, crlcreMu seo6xoAl{Mo r,rcnoJlb3oBarb 6olee cJroxHhre rurrbr napaMerpoBflopsAxa, cvrya\ufl oKtt3blBaerc, MeHee yAoBnerBoprarenrnofi v 3arracryro rpe6yercrrlocrpoeHlle HoBbIx nln o6o6rqenlae vr uognSuxarlus yxe cyqecrByro[u.rx MoAeneft.
EuE 6oneecloxnofi oKa3blBaercs cilTya\ufl B croxacrl,IqecKprx MoAeJrrx, olplcbrBtuoqux noBeAeHI,IeoTKpbrTbrx HepaBHoBecHbrx cHcTeM.Ycnexa B I,IccneAoBaHuL KplITI,IqecK[rx pexr{MoB r,r3f{aeMbx cr.rcreM yAanocb Ao6nmcs sa c.rerI{cnoJIb3oBaHI,Is MolqHoro u xopomo paspa6oranHoro MareMaruqecKoro aflflapara KBaHToBonoresofi peHopManl,Isaquouuofi rpyrrrbr (Pf). Pf no3BoJrrer nonyqarb AJu coorBercrByrounxruoAelefi I4K acunrorllKy (fyuxqufi fpnna t4rr, Ha r3brKe reopurr KpuTutrecKoro noBeAeHvrs.,KoppenflIllaoHHbx Oynrlllaft. Pearusallus MeroAoB Pf n 6o.mrnefi creueuu ocHoBaHa Ha reop[trBo3MyIrIeHIlfi no xoncraHTaM cBA3u Mo.4eJru, (pr,rrl,IqecKr,Ie [oKa3aren[ IIpI{ groM Bbrrrr,IcJl.firorcf,B BI,IAe perynrpHoro pa3noxeHr4fl no Sopnaanrno MaJrbrM [apaMerpaM. Xoporuo r.r3BecrHo, qroprAbl KBaHToBo-rIoJIeBbIx piunoxeHr.rfi ssrsrorc, pacxoArulvtuvtcs., a flapaMerp pa3noxeH]r, BSuruuecru LIHTepecHbIx cnyuarx BoBce He Miur.
Teu ne MeHee, us noAo6Hbrx acr.rMnrorr,rqecKuxprloB MoxHo H3Breqb KoJII,IqecrBeHHbre pe3yn6Tarbl , ilrrfl lrero, oAHaKo, seo6xoAunaonpilBJleKarb rexHI,IKy 6opelencxoro cyMMr{poBaHr.r,vnncranrounrrfirroAxoA.Alrrepnau.IBHblM [oAxoAoM rBJrrercs MeroA neuepryp6arusHoft Pf, ocuonannufi ua pe[reHr4r4ToqHoro Pf ypannenns, fi He rlpeAnorararouluft cyqecrBoBaHrre B MoAenr.r MilJrbrx napaMerpoB.flplaltenenue u pII3BLITI,Ie Herrepryp6arnnHbrx MeroAoB B KoHTeKcre reopuu Kpurr.rqecKuxssreuufi vr o6yclannnnaer HayqHyro HoBr.r3Hy vr aKTyirnbHocrb reMbr Ar{ccepraUr{uunpeAcraBneHHbrx s Hefi uccle4onauufi.B qactgocrrr, B AI,IccepraIII4t4 c IroMorrlbroalurv3a r,r3yqalorc, ABe MoAeJr[criln pHiur MoAeJrb ap' , *urprqHarr MoAerrr rnna <p4rroJrr. 3ru naoAell,I I,IMeror orHoureHue K KpI,ITuqecKoMyr4HcraHToHHoropaBHoBecHoro Kp[TLIqecKoro floBeAeHr.rfl:KoMtIJIeKcHoro aHTI,IcHMMerpI,ItIHoro[oBeAeHLIrc B MatHerrxax (npo6rerr,ra -flura-Jlu)cBbIcIILIM cnLIHoM.B pauxaxu cuueMaxneuepryp6atreHofiPfHepensruBucrcKux $epnan-qacruunsyraercfl BJrrrrHue ryp6yneHTHoroABI{XeHI'Ifl CpeAbI Ha AuHaMuqeCKOe KpI,IT[qeCKOe [OBeAeHLIe, OlpIChIBaeMOe TaK HiI3bIBaeUOfiA.
Ilone cKopocrl{ MoAenr,rpoBirJrocb c floMorrlbro [onyrspHoro ancaM6nq Kpefiuuaua,xoropufi n cso€ BpeM.u npzudx 6ommofi r4Hrepec B cBr3r.r c npo6nerraofi anoualbHoroMoAenblocKefinl,IHraBTyp6yneHTHocrLI.Ycranouenue Bo3MoxHbrx cxefinuHrosrrx pexr.rMoBBEIrrucreHHe yHl,IBepcanbHbrx xapaKTepr.rcrr.rKvt- Kpr.rrr.rqecKux rroxa3areleft - B [epeqprcneHHbrxMoAeirrx sBJr.flercfl rleJrbro uacrosuefi pa6oru.Ctpyrrypa pI co.qepNanue lucceprauuu.
,{raccepraqu, cocror4T t43 BBeAeHr.rs, rp€x rlan,3aKrIoqeHI,L I,I AByx rpunoxeHl,rfi. flo reMe Ar{cceprarluu ony6rnxonauo 4 pa6oru B HayqHbrxvls4auvlflx, peKoMeHAoBaHHbrx BAK u r.rHAexcr{pyeMbrx 6azatvru AaHHbx Scopus pr Web ofScience.
I4graraeMHeeAuccepraur.M pe3ynbrarbr MHororparHo rrpeAcraBnfl;rucbHaMexAyHapoAHbrx ron(pepeuquxx.Bo nse.4eHuu o6ocnonHsaercs aKTyanbHocrb r.rccneAonanrafi, npoBoAlrMbrx B paMKax 4aunofiAl,Iccepralluonuofi pa6oru, ilpr.rBoAr,rrcr o6sop nayunofi nr.rreparyphr ro r.r3ytraeuofi npo6leue,craBrrcfl Ilenb v 3alaqu pa6orrr, c(popuynupoBaHbr lr'ayltnafl, HoBr.r3Ha H npaxTr,rqecKurs3Hatlr.rMocrb npeAcraBJrqeNdofi pa6oru.B nepnofi rnase I{ccneAyerc, cKi}nflpHas MoAerrb ,p3 nnarono* r.rHcraHToHHoro aHaJrr.rsa. B cxer\,reMLIHI{ManbHbx Bbltlurasuit la pa3MepHofi perynrpu3a\uu uafi4ena acr{Mflrorlrxa BbrcoKr,rxflopff.{KoB pa:noxenufi KoHcraHT peHopMr,rpoBKr.r kr Pf Qynxqnfi.
YcranosneHaacnMllTorllqecKafl $opuyna An, roetfSuqrEeHToB e-pa3JroxeHr,rq Kpr{Tr.rqecKoro r.rHAexcaOuruepa. llponeAeuo cpaBHeHr,re rotrHo Bbrtu{creHHrx ros$SnqpreHToB r-pa3JroxeHvrs, rr vtx }Ke3HatIeHHrM[I, BhItII{cJIeHHbrMr4 rro acl,rMrrroruqecxofi (popuy:re. YcraHosreHo, rrro r,r3BecrHble HaceroAH, 4-neurenue ros$SuqpleHTbl eul0 ne BbrxoArr Ha coorBercrByroqyro aclrMflrorr.rKy.flponegeuo nepecyMMHpoBaHI,Ie t-pa3noxeHr,rfl lrrfl r{HAeKca Ouqepa pa3nuqHbrMurvro4u$raxaq ilflMvt MeroAa Bopelr.Bropaq rrasa nocBsrrreHa r.rccJreAoBaHr.rrc (fasonsrx nepexoAoB B cr.rcreMe (fepuuonon cBbIc[rLIM cII[HoM s>112. flrr uo4enlr KoMrrJreKcHoro aHTr.rcraMMerpr.rrrHoro MarpratrHoro rroJupaHra N:2s*l onpeleneHo ceMefictso r.rHcraHToHoB.
Hafi.Uena acr4MnrorrKa BbrcoKr.rxrIopflAKoB 6era-Synxquft n paMxax t-pa3noxeHur. flpone4eHo rrepecyMMr.rpoBaHue ypanuenufiPf ypanneuuft na ocHoBe 5-uetersHx pa3noxeuufi. IloxasaHo, qro npra N>4 B cucreMeorcyrcrBylor B rp€xnaepuofi MoAeJrr,r orcyrcrByror I,IK-upnr{r}rBa}oque QuncuponaHHbreToIIKLI.
PenoprrarpylltloBble rpaeKTopr,ru, crapryf, c pa3nr4qHblx HaqaJrbHbrx 3HarreHIzfi, nrrxo4rrus o6racru ycrofiuuBocrl4 crlcreMbr, qro rparTyerc, KaK yKa3aHr{e Ha cyqecrBoBaHr,re BcllcreMe (pa:onoro nepexoAa rlepBoro poAa. Penopurpynnosoft aHaJrure cocraBHbrx oneparopoB,npone4€nnufi n oAnonerJleBoM npra6luxenuu, rroKzl3brBaer, rrro reMrreparypa o6napyxeHHoroSaronoro [epexoAa flpeBbrrrraer 3HarreHr{e, floJryqaeMoe n upu6nuxeHr.ru reopuu cpeAHero rroJuJlaugay (roropar K roMy xe npeAcKa3brBaer HerrpepbrBuufi Saaonufi uepexog npu mo6rrx3HaqeHzflx N).
flpora:neAeHa orIeHKa reMreparypu (pasonoro repexoAa.B rperrefi rrtase Ll3yualorc, cxefiruuroBbre pexr.rMbr B MoAeJru A noA nosgeficrnueM ancaM6rsKpeftuuaua. C uouoqbro Henepryp6arnnnofi peuopurpynnbr rroKa3aHo, trro paccMarpr,rBaeMa-,rcucreMa Moxer .ueMoHcrpr.rpoBarb qerbrpe crefimasroBbrx pexuMa: Tpr,rBlrur:ouas. rayccoBaToqKa, .rrvcras. MoAeJIb A, ryp6yrentrrufi rrepeHoc [accuBHoro cKilJrrpa r.r Herpr,rBr.ralrnrrfipexuM, rAe KpI{TI,ItIecKLre u ryp6yreHTHbre SnyxryaqNil oAr4HaKoBo cyruecrBeHHbr. Oqenenu3HaueHu, KpI,ITI,IqecKI,Ix rroKa3arerefi, xotopble, oAHaKo, oKa3brBarorcq HeyHr,rBepcEUrbHbIMLI, a3aBr,ICf,T OT IIapAMeTpa, 3aAarOUerO CxtI{MaeMO CTb CI,ICTeMbr.B 4uccepra\uu npilcyrcrByer prA He3Hatrr,rreJrbHhx oleqaroK (nanpurraep, Ha crp.
18 BSoprrayle 1.1 sN.{ecro 3arpaBotrHoro 3ap.rrAa HarucaH peHopMuporaHHbrfi, xoroprrfi BBoAr,rrcsroJIbKo n Sopuyne 1.2).Ha crp. 60 4rx ua6opa uoreft n $opuyne 3.4 ucnolr3yercs raxoe xeo6osFra.reHr.re, KaK Lr il1fl, Synxquu XesncafiAa.CAelannue 3aMer{aHLL He BJIIaflIor na o6rqyro rroJroxr.rreJrbHyro oueHKy pa6orsr..{ocronepnocrb nonfleHHblx pe3ynbraros o6ecuequBaercs. KaK r{cnoJrb3oBaHr.reM MorqHoro uxopouo pa3BLIToro anlapara xeaHronofi Teopuu rroJr.fl, TaK lr cpaBHeHr.reM c pe3ynbraraMu,LI3BecrHbIMI,I pauee Anq pa3n[qHbrx rracrHbx cnyqaeB.
flolyuennue n pa6ore pe3ynbrarbrMoryr nocnyxnTb crl{MynoM Anfl npoBe4eHufl. HoBbrx gKc[epr4MeHTirrrbHbrx raccne4onauuftKpLITI,IuecKoro noBeAenur (xar paBHoBecHbrx, TaK r.r HepaBHoBecHbrx crrcreM noA Bnr.rflHueMryp6ynenrnocru) hSasonux nepexoAoB, B rracrHocrlr BbrcoxoreMueparypnofi.{uccepraq}roHHa, pa6om raKxe cuoco6crnyer pa3Br.rrr.rrccBepxnpoBoALIMocrLI.uenepryp6arl{BHblx MeroAoB npI4MeHI{TeJrbHoK aHirnH3ycoorBercrByrou[x noneBbrx uoAelefi.BceBbllrrecKa3aHHoe rlo3Bonrer 3arrro.ruTb, rITo At4cceprauuoHHa, pa6o:ra<Henepryp6atflsHoe peHopMrpyflrroBoe r,rccJreAoBaHue cxefimanronoro noBeAeHrls))yAoBnerBoprer BceM rpe6onanuxu, npeAbrBnseMhrM K KaHAr{AarcKr.rM Ar.rcceprarlr,rflM rrocleqllaJlbHocru 01 .04.02 - Teoperur{ecKtur Sr.rsuxa, a ee anrop, Ka-uaron feoprufi Alu6eronuu,3acnyxlaBaer [p]IcyxAeHLIfl yt€noft creneHr,r KaHAr.rAara $usuxo-trareMarr.rtrecKr.rx HayK.O(pvquanrnrrfi ouuoueur,offi/,,fra4uruen Arexcefi Ba-ueprenuuKaHALIAaT Qrasuro-uareMarr.rtrecrr.rx HayKlrru$p creqlraJrbHocrr,r oilnoHeHra-0l .04.02 <TeoperuuecKiur (pusura>Jla6oparop[Ll Teoperr{qecxoft $usuxnO6regunenHoro r,rHcrr,rryra rAepnbrx r.rccJre.(osaHIafiHaquuIbHLIK ceKTopa141980,prrra.H.
H. Boromo6ona!y6ua, Mocxoscxafl o6n., JITO OVIflVIPa6oquft rere(pou: 8 (49621) 64980E-mail : gladysh@theor j inr.ru23 mas.2018 roaao!{efloAur,rcr fra4uruena A.B. yAocroBeprrcYqeurrfi ceKperapb JIT(D OWflVI23rray^2018 roaaA.B.Angpeen.
Характеристики
Тип файла PDF
PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.
Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
