Отзыв ведущей организации (1147360), страница 3
Текст из файла (страница 3)
Kax n reoperlrqecKoM aHaJII{3e, TaK I'I B3Mllr.rpuqecKoM uccJreAoBaHIrI{ flpocJlex[Baerct lzqnrrft BKnaA aBTopa Bpaspa6orxy Aannofi TeMbr, [oJIf{eHIr e HoBbIx Hay{HLIX AaHHrIX.Hosugna ocnoBHbrx Hayrrnblx pe3yJrbraroBrr Hx 3HaqlrMocTb Arq HayKr{ r{ [pon3BoAcTBaOcnosHrre p$yJrbrarbl, floryqeuHble aBTopoM:L Bueprrre olpeAeneHa v o ucana crlequ$IrKa coqItELIIbHbrxnpe.qcraBJleHlli o neycnelrrHoM qeJIoBeKe B 3aBr,Icr,IMocrI,I or coIII4aJIEHoAeMorpalpuqecKr,rx xapaKTeplrcTr4K rpyfirlbl II JII{tIHoro orIbITa flepexuBaHvrflyclexoB 14 HeyAaiI.
lloxarano, qTo coIII4anbHbIe npe,qcTaBJleH[t o Heyc[eIIrHoMlreJroBeKe orrpeAeJrrrorc.rl cvryar[BHbrM[ xapaKTepI4 cTLIKaMI{: OTCyTCTBI,IeKapbepHoro pocra, Haruqfie Marep[ulJlrHrrx npo6nev, rpy.quocrl,I c ycrpoficrBoMHa pa6ory, rrJrox€u pa6ota, nusrufi coqr,ra.lrrnrrfi craryc, a raKxe JrIrrIHocrHbIMr'IqeneycTpeMneHHocTI,I,oTcyTcTB eHeyAoBneTBopeHHocrE co6oit u xLI3Hbro B IIeJIoM, oTcyTcTBI4e cI4JrbI BoJII{, JIeHb,6esorsercrseHHocrb, HeyBepeHHocrl e ce6e.
VcranosreHo, vto uau6oreepacflpocrpaHennrrfi nporornrr (HeycfleuHoro)) qeJIoBeKa y HeycrreruHblx - sroqeJroBeK, He Brlr,rcaBllrfificq s coq[arbHbre paMKr{, He naureAurzfi cBoe Mecro Bo6qecrae; y yclerrrHbrx - flporBnrrorqrrfi rzvnocrnyro He3penocrb.2. B pa6ore o6oorosauo rl 3MuupuqecKu repuQnquponaHo flonoxeHlre oToM, qro B KarrecrBe rrpeAr.tKTopoB corlr4 €rJrLHErx npe4craueuufi unpoSeccuonanLuoro Heycnexa Brrcrynaror nr.rsKlrft ypoBeHb nputxsannit, uOTBCTCTBCHHOCTI4. BbIYqEHHAII OECIIOMOIIIHOCTb. qpe3MepHLrr4ONTUMII3M BcvTya\vfrx HeyAaqu 14 cyrqecTBeHHoe paccorJracoBaHr,re MexAy caMoorleHKofi 14ypoBHeM npurxsaHufi.3.
Brlgnltenrr coruulJlbuo-flcl4xoJlorrlqecKl,Ie rr,rnrr no4eft, flepexuBrrr[xuey.{a.rurrfi orrbrr. llpeo6ra4arorquur,r rvrrraMr4 (Heyc[eIIrHbIx)) gBlrrroTcqrrpeAr4KTop€rMrrHeycnexa:(HeyBepeHHbIe olrrlrMlrcrbl) t4 (lIeccI4MI'IcrbID, KoropHe o6ycnoBneHblOrrpeAeJIeHHbIMI{ JIIIqHOcTHbIMII xapaxTepz CTI,IKaMII, OCO6ennOCrs['IIl[peAcraBJreHlrft o Heyclexe u nepexl'rBaHlltMl4 Heycllexa. ocnosHHr'{I'Ioco$eHHOcTqMu (HeyBepeHH6IX OITIIMI4ST9B) BEIcTynarcT p1LI3Kafl. caMooIIeHKa,cJrr{rrrKoM B6lcoKr4fi ypoBeub rTprrT\3alLrir I{ OrITI'IMI',ICTI{qHOCT6.
Atts(fIeccuM[CToB> XapaKTepeH BHeIIIHI,Ifi JIoKyc KoHTpOJITI, HII3KI'Ie nOKa3aTeJII'IoTBeTCTBeHHOCTI4, CaMOOIIeHKI{ U yAOBIeTBOpeHHOCTII XI'I3HbIO, BbD IeHHUUI6ecuorrrorqnocrr.corlr{anbHo-AeMorpa{pfi tIecKr.Iepa6orerrpoaHanl{3IrpoBaHbIoco6euuocrr4 6espa6ornux KaK coIII{aJIBHofi rpy111rbl: reHAepHLIe 14 Bo3pacrHble' aTarcKe ypoBeHb o6pa3oBagufl lr ceMeir6oe [oJIoxeHI'Ie' BlepBLIe BbrAeJIeHbI I{onr4ciurbr Tr,r[LI 6e3pa6OTHbIx c freToM coIIuaII6HLIx npeAcTaBJIeHIl[, coqualrnolclrxoJlorrrqecK[x oco6eHHocrefi,xapaKTepI,IcTr4K,AeMorpaiplrqecKr.rxorleHKrr ycleluHocTt4/Heyc[elrrHocT]I,cy66eKTuBHofto6beKTI,IBHOfiyAoBnerBopeHHocrr,r xI,I3HbIo, OCO6eHHOCTefi UepeXUnaUnt HeyAaqHoro orIbITa.5.
flpe4noxeHbr peKoMeHAaIIr{u rro oKa3aHr,Irc rloMotrlu 6espa6otrrlr,AJTUTeJTbHO COCTOq IT4M Ha yqeTe e cnyx6e 3aHtTocrI,L6. Arropcxar aHKera c IIeJIbIo t431'rreuvs. caMooIIeHKI,I I,I 3HaqItMocrI'Iflepexr{BaHnr HeyAaqHoro orlbrra, a raKxe MoAI{oIIq[poBaHHLIe BapI4arITLIMeTOAUK paCUr}IprIOT AI{arHOCTI4qeCKrfi I4HCTpyMeHTapnft IM r43YrellLrfllepexr4BaHrr{ [polpecclroHaJlbHoro Heycflexa.3naquuocrr pe3yJrbraroB I4ccJIeAoBaHI,If, rnfl. rrayr.rr 3axrloqaerct B ToM,rrTo TeopeTltqecKr4e BbIBoALI [o3BoJIIrJIIr C!ICTeMaTI{3I4pOBaTL OCHOBH6IeTeopeTr4 irecKr4e [oAxoAbI K aHaJILI3y COqU€LIIbHbIX rIpeACTaBJreHlIft 14npo+eccrzoHtur6Horo Heycflexa.
CoAepx(areJlbHo orIpeAeJIeHbI TaKI,Ie [peAI4KTopbIcoqv ajrbHbrx rrpeAcraBJreHlIfi I4 [poibeccl4oHanLHo[ HeycnellrHocrl{ KaxcaMoorleHKa, ypoBeHb rrplTT'^3a]Jvir, JIoKyc KOHTpOJUI, OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb,lepoeKqrroHr{3M, BErfreHHaq 6ecuolvrorqnocrb. flonf{eHHble pe3ynbrarbl Moryr6rtrr ucnonrsoBanbr rrpr{ [porHo3IlpoBanl4rr coquaJlbuoro [oBeAeHLIt poccuficKl4x6eapa6orurrx, T.K. B pa6ore ocyulecrBneH aralrrr3 coIIIraJIbHo-rIcLIxoJIor[qecKLIXfpylrrbr,poccrrficKr4 x6espa6oflGrx KaK coIII4€IJIbHoioco6eHHocrefipacKpbrBaroTcf,ficr{xoJrorr{qecKr.re xapaKTeprrcrrrKr{ 6eepa6ornrrx rpa)KAaH.npeAr{Krop6l6espa6ornrrx rpaxAan,OnpeAerennsreIlpoQeccrloHanLHoro Heyclexa u npeAJIoxeHHbIe peKoMeHAaII[lI flO OKa3aHr{rOIoMoIIII{ 6espa6ornuv, AJTI,ITeJIbHo cocrotrq}IM Ha ) Iere a Cnyx6e 3aH{TocrI,I,rro3BoJrrror nnaHr4poBarb flporpaMMbl no [poo[naKTLIKe }I IlpeoAoneHl'Irco$paooTuubl KaK coIII{€InbHoro f,BJreHr{.fl .Ilparcruuecrcoe sHa.renue pe3ynbraroB pa6orbr olpeAenterct reM, rITo oHI44.8Kar.tecTBe ocHoBbt EJlfl IIpoBeAeHr,rtucrrxoJror[qecKrlx KoHcyJlbTar\vfi c 6espa6otnrrufi rpa)KAaHaMv, Ans.
]F.anvca]F'vflpeKoMeHAarluft nuqal/., flepexr.rBrrrlrM HeyAaqHbrft orrbrT, c rlenbro KoppeKrII 4 I,IxrroBeAeHr.rr rr AocrlrxeHr4f, ycnexa (rpanr <MonoAbrM rreHbrM OnafY>, 2011 r.).Moryr flpr.rMeHrrbcf, n Cnyx6ax 3au-srocrfi Anfi, ara rar\ulr JIrIq, ArIIrrenLHococroqrqfix Ha rrere B KarrecrBe 6eapa6o rux, I,I rrckr xoJrorl{qecKofi KoppeKrlr{r4r,rx Jrr,rqHocrHbrx oco6eHHoc:refi. llorryveHHbre pe3yJrrrarrr 6yAyr noJre3HbrMOryTOLITLITCIIOJIL3OBAHbIlpaKTr.rqecKrIM rrcr{xoJroraM Anf pa3paooTKll TpeHI4HroBhrx [porpaMM, oKasalItraKOppeKrIr{oHHoft floMorq]r rI4UaM, nepexuBarcrrlr4MKOHCYIIbTATI{BHOI{ 14HeyAaqHbru orrbrT.Pesyrurarrr AucceprarnoHnoro uccJre,qoBaHut MoryrcJryxrlTrpeKoMeHAarlufiMr4 B vtE4vrBuAyiurbHoM KoHcyJrbTrrpoBaHvrE 14 KolnrlrHre AJrt JIIlq,3ar.IHTepecoBaHHbIx B rroBLrruenu[ csoeft nuqnoft eQQercrunuocrrr rr ycfielrlHocrtr.flonyrennrre pe3yJrbrarbr uoryr 6rrru rrcrroJlb3oBaHbl a BY3ax npzlpoBeAeHr4rr nexqrafi ra npaKTr{qecrnx saHsrl,rfi (coqualrnax flcllxoJlorrlt,flc[xoJrorur.r ylpaBneHur, rreAaroDlqecKarr Ilcl,IxoJlorfit, Bo3pacTHajr fic]rxoJrorur,npaKTr4KyM IIo ncr4xoAr4af HocTuKe).flomrora oly6nr.rKoBauubrx pe3ynbraroB pa6orhr pacxprraaercx r 30rrerrarubrx pa6orax, B ToM qr,rcJre 6 crarrqx B Haln{Hlrx xypuanax, BKJrroqeHHbrx Bllepevenr perleH3r4pyeM6rx Ha)rH6rx usaanui4 peKoMerlAoBaHnrrx Brrcurefinprr Mznzcrepcrae o6pa:onauux 14 HayKrtPocczficxofi @egepaqr.ru Ans o[y0Jrr,IKoBaHr,rt HarrHbrx pe3yJrbTaToBvuccepraguir, 24 ny6.nuraqzxx B Mareprrarax 8 rrrex4yuapoAHbrx, 7arrecrauraonnofi KoMr{ccueftncepoccr,rficrr,Ix , 2 iraeNnysoBcKrzx Ha) {Ho-[paKTuqecKr.rx ron(fepenqr.rfi.Percouen4aquu no [crroJrb3oBaH[x) pe3yJrbraroB u BbtBoAoB nccJreAoBanntCqzraeNl rlenecoo6pa3u6rM rrpoAoJrns4Tb pa6oryI{CCneAOBaHLI' XapaKTepr{CTr4K OObeKTr{BHbrXIIrroHafipaBneHr,rrcCyObeKTr4BHhrX OTIeHOKHeyclexaCTOqKII 3peHr{t pa3nuqHBrx [epr{oAoB B3pocJrocTr{, rroKuBaB TEM CAMbIM H'II,IOOJIEEyxsnururrfiSTOM OTHOrrreHIir{ [epIIOA paSVlzlr:at.
B rIacTHocTI4, AaHHbIe,[on] rennbre Ha cryAeuqecxzx arr6oprax, Moryr rzcloJrb3oBarb cfl 4rrfl. BbrfrBlretvrfl.ycnozurt $oprur.rponanur rpeAr{KTopoB upo(peccuona-nrnofi ycfierrrHocrr4II{IIHOCTT4 Ha grarre 06) reur4-tr B BhIcIIIr4x ) {e6uhrx 3aBeAeHu-sx. ,{annrre,rrloJrfrennbre ua arr6opxax MonoAblx crreqlr€urr4 croB, MoryT Jrerrb B ocHoByIIeneBLIX [pOrpaMM rrcrrxoJroruqecKoro colpoBoxAeHvr rrpo(peccrroH€rJrbHoropasBrr'tLrs, a Aarrubre, nonfreHHbre na arr6opxax cr,DKr,IcroB, cloco6crBoBarb[po$rraKrr.rKe npo(pecolouaJrrubrx .qecrpyKrluft .uxapaKTepr,rcrr.rx o6rerrrlnnrrxcy6lexrzrurrx orIeHoKHeycnexa B Ap)arrrc(f epax xr43HeAerreJrbHocrr.r Jrrrquocrr.r voxer 6rrruIoJIe3HLIM rrpu paspaOorre KoMnJreKcnbrx nporpaMM npoQr.rnarruxra rryKpelJreHr4r ncaxoJlorl4qecKoro 3AopoBE_s HaceIeHLI.rI.YroqnenlrexO6ruue 3aMeqaHHflKcolKaJreu[ro,[p]rorrvcaHrru err6opru BTopororu4Jror€DKuoror{ccJreAoBar{I{t aBTop He oTMeqaeT, cKoJrbKo pecrroHAeHToB MoxHo oTHecTrr Kycneruurrv/neyc[errrubrM.
flo pe:ylrraraM BToporo [r,rJror€DKuoro accJle,UoBaHr{to6lJrr4 [OJrrreHbI AaHHbre, qTo TpyAHbre xr.I3HeHHbre cvTyal\hu, cBr3aHHbre cHeraTrrBHErMr.I 9MOrIUSMr,r 14 AeTepMr{Hr.rpyrcrur4e Heyclex Jlr{rrHocTr{, Ans.rrcrrblTyeMblx, OTHOCSIII4XCq KO BCeM [epIIOAaM B3pOCJIOCTI4, CB{3aIIbI B IIepB}.IOorrepeAL c [po6neMaMI,I TpyAoycTpoficTBa, fipoQeccl{oHzlJlbHoro pocTa I,I BIDKHbIMAJrr AaHHOTO BO3paCTHOTO nepI4OAa AOCTITII(eHI'eM - CO3AaHI{eM CeMeftHOrO Oqara'noATBep)KAzIrcqrIe rIo3ItIIuIo 3.@pefi4a, qro 3AopoBEI{ Jlr'rquocrL AoJDKHa yMerr<<mo6nrr u pa6orarr>.
Teu ne Meuee, He r'IcKJIIoqaeM Bo3Moxnocrll, qro tlpuApyroM KaqecrBeHHoM cocraBe pecrIoHAeHToB MOTJII'I 6rrrl rIoJrrreHLIAOIOJTHTITeJIbHbIe AaHHbIe OTHOCITTeJI6HO XI43HeHHbIX CII fya\ufi,AerepMrrur,rpyrourlx Heyclex. 3ro o6crorreJlEcrBo He craBur noA coMHeHI'IeKoppeKTuocrb ocuosaurlft ocHoBHoro 9M[I{pllqecKoro uccneAoBaul{t, Koropbley6egrarenrno Lr3JIoxeHLI no rropoft rJraBe Ar4 cceprallrlouHoro [ccJIeAoBaHLIt.Aaropou aJrr rpex ltccre.qosaH i (4nyx naloraxHbtx I,I ocuornoro) 6uloHcrroJrr3oBauo 9 pa:nr,r.rnrrx MeroAt4 K.
Tarcofi o6seNa nczxoAllarHocrllrlecKoroHHCTpyMeHTaprrr roBopI,IT o rIoHLIMaIrIIIr A[CCepTaHTOM CJIOXHOCTI'I 3aAaqlt' HO, BToxe BpeMr, cyrqecrBeuHo ycJloxHter a*uvt3AaHHLrx. flonyrennuegMlrrprlqecKrre pe3yn6Tarbl AByx [Ilnorax(Hblx l4ccJreAosauufi strHeceHbl 3apaMK[ aHanr{3a MaTepI4€IJIOB OCHOBHO|O ALICCepTaTILI OHHOTO UCCJIeAOBAIIIIfr v HeBcerAa r{crroJrL3yrorcr aBTopoM .4ns o6cpKAeHI{t [oJIyqeHHEIX pe3ynbraroB(r,rlrerorcx ccbrJrK[ ua ny6nuxaquu, orpzDKalorqr.re no4po6nrotit ar^a:lug 4aunrx),xort raKxe [Meror 6oruruoe 3ttaqeulle.flpu o6cyxgennn pe3ynLTaroB t4 3)nreHrl-s cy6rexrr.rnnux KplrrepueBnpoQecczonamnoro Heyclexa, B pa3.qene 3 .2.1.
aBTop orMeqaer, qroHeycneIIIHbIe pecnonAeHTbr qalqe flep xI{BaIor neyAavnrrfi onrrr, oco6euno anporpeccraonanrnoft Aerrenbuocrll, rro orHoIrreHI,IIo K cBoeMy coq[aJIEHoMycrarycy 11 B )Krr3:uvr B rIeJIoM. Ho seAr rpyrr[y Heyc[eIuHLIx pec[oHAeHToBcocraBvrlrrt JrroAr{, Haxo.qtrquecr B cLrryar\ a Arulrenrnoft 6eapa6oruqrr, nogToMyHeyArrBr{TeJrbHo, qro BeAyTIIII M nepexr.IBaHr{eM HeyAaqHoro orrbrra ABlrqercflr4MeHHo nepexr4BaHlre cnoefi npoQeccuonamnofi Hecocro.srerLnocrra. MoxnorrpeArronoxr4 rL, qro crparrr$r.maqzx nu6opxr,r rro unoMy ocHoBar{I4lo Aala 6uApyrfie pe3ynbrarhl.Hecuorpr Ha npaKTuqecKyro Baxnocrb rlpeArlaraeMblx peKoMeHAaIIufi nopeaJrr.r3arlr4 r.r crrcreMlr Mepolpl4 f,TLII, HaTIpaBJIeHHbIX Ha aKTyzIJIIr3aIInoJrr{qHocrHoro n npo$eccuonzulbHoro pasBrrrrtfl.6espa6onrrrx B ycJIoBLItx leutpor3aHrrocrr{, oHr,r r.rMeror BecLMa o6o6qennufi xapaKTep, AaJIeKo He BcefloJryrreHHbre aBTopoM pe3ynbTaTbl Ha uul oTpax{eH[e B IIeJIeB6IX KOMflOHeHTaXnpeAJroxeHHofi nporpauurt.3rucoo6oaxeHr.rs HucKorbKo He cHru(aror oueHKa,ulrcceprarllr[ 113HaqeHr.rs flon]nreHHbrx aBTopoM pe3ynbTaToB, oHI,I HOCTT IZCKJIIOTtUTeJIbHOAr4cKycczoHHrrfi xapaxrep r4 MoryT 6rrrr snorHe cHrrEr nprr ny6nrauuofi 3aIIII{Te.3ar<.nroqenueTarlrru o6pasoM, Arrcceprarlru O.II.