Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (1146839)

Просмтор этого файла доступен только зарегистрированным пользователям. Но у нас супер быстрая регистрация: достаточно только электронной почты!

Текст из файла

OT3Ь IBanbHoro orrrroHe Hra o Ar4cc e pr awr*t C oruurosofi K apranrr 34yap4oBHbl<Axrtasu3alllafl [pocrpaHcrBeHHblx KoHcrpyKqrafi e pyccr<ofi peql4aHrJroroBopflurr{x cryAeHToB), [peAcraBJieHHofi, ua coucKaHl4e yueuofi creIIeHI4KaHALTAaTa neAafofl{r{ecKHx HayKcnerlraaJrbHocrb 13.00.02 - reoplrfl r4 MeroAr4xa o6yueHl4q u Bocrtvrantrfl,o Sraura(pyccxnfi.rr3blK KaKrHocrpaHurrfi)Ilpo6nevra BblpaxeHl4f, rpocrpaHcrBeHHbrx orsourenufi B coBpeMeHHoMpyccKoM f,36lKe, KOTOpaf, BKIrOqaer rrCCJreAoBaHr{e Bcex HroaHcoB KaTefopr{alruoficeMaHTI{KHkt cuoco6os ee3KcrrJrr4rlr4poBaHufl., .rlBJrf,erc.fiamyanrHofi KaK AJUIJIZH|BHCTIIKII, TaK U lnfl. MerOAAKr4 npenoAaBaHnf pyccKofo ,3brKa B r{HocTpausofiayLrTopulr.

B cessl4 c 3TI4M Ilof,BJreHpre Ar4cceprarltroHHofi pa6oru CorunronofiKapznrt 34yap4onHsl MoxHo paccMarprzBarb KaK BecbMa cBoeBpeMeHHoe.flpoae4eusufi anropoM aHaJIus yue6uo-Merorr4.recxofi Jrr{Teparyprr y6egnreJrbHonpoAeMoHcrpl4poBax Heo6xoAaMocrb paccMorp eHLrfl [pocTpaHcrBeHHbrxxoucrpyxqufiBSyHxqnoHaJr bH o - ceMaHTarrplccJIeAoBaHl/.fl.)ArrccepTar{r4oHHofOeacrreKTe. AxryalrnoctrcKoMI]OCB.TTUIeHHOfOaKTI'IBI.I3aIJkrLrrlpocrpaHcrBeHHblx KoHcrpyKqufi n pyccxofi peqr4 aHrJroroBopf,rrlux cry4eHronIIceprra@uxaIII4oHHoro ypoBH.t, otrpeAeJrf,ercf, KaK 3Har{r,rMocr6ro nrr4nuuyroftaBTopoM npo6neurr,TaKИИHTepΠ peTaЦ ИeЙJII4HrBHcrLIqecKoro HanpaBJIeHurocHosofi o6y'reuzxr4Hocrp aHHbrx3aclyNunaerMeroronoru.{ecxofi$ynxqzoHalrHofi tpaMMarr4Kr,r,yqau r4xcfl pyccKoMy f, 3 brKy.pa3pa6oTKacepЬ-rI3bIKO3HaHI4.f,, ICI{XOJII4H|BI4CTTIKI4,vI4H ocrpaHHbIx.f, 3e3HOЙ.rrBJr.f,IolleftcgTeOpeTИKO―v3yYleHii.fl UpocrpaHcrBeHHbrx roucrpyrqafi,npoBeAeHHa-[ aBTopoM B uepnofi rJIaBe ALIcceprarJVLrnp erIoAaB aHl/.fl.ΠepcΠ eК TИ BHO「 o-oД o6peHИ Я6asuee B pycЛ ebI Kocr4crroJrb3oBaHr,reM AaHHbrxIIeAaIO|I,IKI,I, IICHXOJIOr}Ir.r,n.

,{a cc epraHT uo4poMeroArrKLr6Ho aHailkr3Lrpyer M oA enrr3Tarrbr peqelopoxleHa.E, paccMarpuBaer Borrpocbr o6yrtenur- MexaHr{3Mynep6anruoro MbIIrIreHufl Ha HepoAHoM ,3brxe. 3Ha.rprreJrbHoe BHrrMaHr4e K. 3.CorHuxona yAenf,er rIoH.rITrIro rpaMMarr{r{ecKoro HaBbrKa: I4MeHHo oco3HaHrre roro,KaK oH Sopvrrapyercx Lr coBeplxeHcrByerctr,raerBo3MoxHocrb o$sexrr,rnnoopraHr{3oBaTb rlpoqecc o6yveHurrrpocrpaHcrBeHHblM KoHcrpyKuLIflM.pyccxofi lpaMMarl4xe, B ToM rIHcJIe vO6pauteuue .{uccepraHra K uenoMy pflAycepbe3Hbrx Teoperr,lqecKHx BonpocoB, t,Ix pa3HocTopoHHee AeTaJIbHoe ocBelqeHl,leBo MHorou o6ycnoBJrrzBaer reopernqecKylo 3Har{r4Mocrr pa6omr.Brr6op QyuxqnoHamnofiΠpocTpaHcTBeHHЫΠepByЮx KOHCTpyКoЧ epeД Ь,I-paMMarr4Kpr B KaqecrBe ocHoBbr npIa aKTuBu3arluLrЦИЙΠpeД ΠoЛ a「 aeTB pyccKOЙpeЧ ИBHИ MaHИ e Kф yHК ЦИOHaЛ ЬHo― KOHЦ eΠ TyaЛ ЬHoЙcyIrIHocrH QynrqaoHaJlbHo-ceMaHTr4rrecxofi Kareropr{r4 vrKarcy6rareropl,I3aIIpII4.eerny6znHofiorMerraer aBTop, BnepBbre rronbrrKr4 nocrpoeHrr.f,xnaccuSr'rKallua npocrpaHcrBeHHbrx orHorueHufiIIpeArIppIHrITbIyЧ aЩ ИxcЯ ,BИHocTpそ λHHЫ XBpyccKoM .rr3brKe 6rrrua6onee rrflTu gecxtwtetwit Ha3al, ocyulecrBJr{roTc.fl ogr,r uBHacrof,Irlee BpeMf,.

B ocnony cyrqecrByiou{I4x xnacczQnxagwit rpocrpaHcrBeHHbrxoruoruenzfi noJloxeHa cl,IcreMa onno:rqnfi: o[no3LrrIHI4nepeMelrleHprfl', JIoKaTHBoB Lr AHQeKTI4BOB,r.E. O4naxo,AI'IHaMI{KLr LrJIoKanr,I3auI4r{ H.{efircuca r{ JroKEuII43ar\uv, crarg1l,rHKaK crrl4Taer AaccepraHT, Ha ceroAngruuufi ,qeHb HecyqecrByer eAaHofi 'IerKofi xnaccu$uxallar4 npocrpaHcrBeHHbrx orHoureHufi,Koropafl ucqepnblBata6s BcIo cJloxHocrb rlpeAcraBteuuit pyccKoro rreroBeKanpocrpaHcrse (c. 41). Y'Iurltsaf, orblTpIccJIeAoB alufl. JroKarrlBHbrxKoHcrpcnod uecro B sToM rrluoroo6pa3ur HccJre.qoBauuit HaxoAr,rr uHapazpa6arbrBa.rrф yHKЦ ИOHaЛ ЬHO_ceMaHTИ ЧecKOИcy6xareropr43ar{r4ro@CKJIoKaTHBHoCTI{, KoTopoeaKTI{BIa3aIIIZHcryreHroBVIIerJIoBK.3. Colruxona,ocHOBeBbrcrpoeHHoeyxtluit,rny6unuyrcHa ee 6a:e @CIIocHoBy nl4HrBoMerolu.{ecxofiMo.qeJrrInpocrpaHcrBeHHblx KoHcrpyxUrzfi s pyccxofi perrr4 aHrJroroBop{u{uxIIceprnQzxarluoHHoro ypoBHr.

pa:pa6oraHHoe aBropoMJIOKaTHBHOCTH BKJIIOqaeTKOTOpbrxuJroKarr4BHocrrrocorepxr{TMecroHaxoxAeHH-f,14ABa cefMeHTaMecra r{ HalpaB [reilVrfl, XaN4trfi nsIIo ABa Mr,rKponoJr.s: cefMeHT MeCTaMecra Aeitctnux cy6rexra,ABI{XeHI{f,; CefMeHT HanpaBlreHl/rflKoHqa ABHXOHI4-,I.-B-ocrlaMr{Kpoloneraxxe MrrKponoJre [pocrpaHcrBaMAKpOnOre Harrana ABr.rxeHufluMt4KpOnOneocHoBe cy6rareropu3alluu @CK JroKarrlBHocrr4 Jrexr{TuHBapwaHTHafl. coAepxaTeJrbHa.[ cTpyKTypaJroKaTaBH€UI CLrTyarJufl,2IIpeAcTaBJreHHat TpeMf, ocHoBHbIMH KoMIIoHeHTaMI4: JIOKanI43yeMbrfi cy6EeKT,ЛOKaЛ И3aTOp И ΠpeД ИKaT.И MeHHoc yЧ eToM cTpyKTypЬ I ЛoKaTИBHoИcИ TyaЦ ИИ Иcl4HTaKcl{qecKoro [po$I4nf, SyHxqaoHaJ'rbHo-ceMaHTI4r{ecKofo noJI.[ JroKaraBHocrr4BKaqecrBe cpeAcrB BblpaxeHr4, npocrpaHcrBeHHbrx orHorueuufi aBTopoMBbIAeJIflIorcfl rJlaronruo-cy6craHTllBHble KoHcrpyKrJatkr c npeAJroray1uurJraroJrbHoHaperrHbre KoHcTpyKrIr4r{.Honaur'refi cneAyer rpl43Harb paccMorpeHaeΠepИ ф epИ ЙHЫ x ЛOKaTИ BHЫ xKOHCTpyKЦ ИИ3ro orBerlaer IIccJIeAoBareJIbcKofiИK.3.

Coruzxosofi cuequouxuBBeД eHИ eИxB yЧ e6HЫ Й MaTepИ aЛzalLate aBTopa: [oKa3arb uomrlrfipa3HoypoBHeBblx {3bIKoBbIx 9.{HHI4II, yqacrBylou{uxBIl KaTr.IBH OqACTOTHOCTH,CTr,r,qelecoo6pa3HocrH,apceH€LnBbrpaxeHur4npocrpaHcrneuuoft ceMaHTHKI4. Onrzpaxcr Ha Mero.u4r{ecKzeK O MMyHrlpr{Hr{plrrbrMeroAHrrecKofi.4OCTyTIHOCTT{,yve6uoro Marepr{aJra r.r ero auQ$epeH11pra\uvpeqenrHBHOfO ycBoeHr4.rr, Ar{ccepraHT OrrpeAeJr.rrerMI4HIIMIa3arJLruAnfl [poIyKTI4BHOfO uoIITI4M€LJIbHrtft o6reM I{ rocJle.{oBarenbHocrb npe3eHTaquuyve6Horo Marepu€ura BayAuropuu.BecrualICcneAoBaHHfl"3Hat{aMbIM upercraBlrflerafl corocraBuremurrfiCpaanutelrHrtfi aHalru3 cpeAcrBpyccKoM u arurIuitcKoM.rI3bIKax no3BoJl{eracIIeKTBErpaxeHr4.rr JroKarlrBHocrra BBbr.rrBr4Tb KaKo6rque, TaK 14 yHr4KaJrbHbrecnoco6rt [peAcraBreHkls usyuaeuofi Karerop[r{.

Tax, aBTopcoBeprrreHHocnpaBeAJII{Bo rIplxoAI4T K BbIBoAy, rITo crpyKTypanpocTpaHcrBeHHbrxKoHcrpyKuzfi s pyccKoM w attrrrrtitcKoM fl3brKe cxoxa, rrro rro3BoJr{erpeaJrr.r3oBarbnaNHefiurufi lreroru.r.ecxuia lIpr4Hrlr[ onopbr Ha poAHoft .ssrrxo6y.rarorq uxcfl.llo4.repxaBarorcf,vKOHTIe[TyaJrbHbre pa3nu:Llufl.,cBf,3aHHbrenpocTpaHcTBeHHbrMHnl4HrBoKynbryp'3rauocurelefirrpeAcTaBrrelHkrflMupa3lrrl.ufl oco6esuo .rrpKo orpaxeHbr BccpaBHI'IBaeMbIXnperleAeHTHbrxTeKcrax : [ocJroBr{uax, rotoBopKax,Sp as eolorkr 3Max.ΠpИHЦ ИΠИaJIЬ HO BaЖ HoЙЯBЛ ЯeTcЯBTopaЯ「paspa6arbrBaerc.rrΠpocTpaHcTBcHHЬMeroAl4r{ecxuitIX KOHCTpyKЦИЙЛaBaДИccepTaЦ ИИ,B КOTopOИI{HcrpyMeurapuir.aKTLIBLT3AIJI1IIIB aH「 ЛOЯ 3Ь IЧ HoЙ ayД ИTOpИ И . KoЭ . COTHИ KOBanpoBoAI,Ir AeraJlbHbritauatu: yve6uux npofpauvr (16 ucro.{uurcon) u yue6usrxuoco6uft (19 ucrovuuxon) Ha rlpeAMer ocBerrlenr4fl. B Hr.rx [pocrpaHcrBeHHbrxoruourenzfi.

,{anee AuccepraHT o[acbrBaer caM KoMrrJreKc ynpaNneuufi,npeAcraBlsroulufi co6ofi 3aKoHr{eHHoe, caMocrof,TeJrbHoe yre6Hoe noco6ue,oSoprraneHHoeBKar{ecrBe npr4Jroxeur,rf,Kruccepraqtvtu, fpauuarwq.ecxufaMarepI4aJI B HeM opraHH3oBaH B coorBercrBlrr4 cocrpyKrypofi @CIl JioKarr{BHocrH(pas4enrr uoco6ng coorBercrByror cerMeHTavr nonr). BaNuo [oArreprHyrb, rrroBKaxAoM pa3AeJIe paccMarpl'IBaerct 6olrruofi pertepryap npocTpaHcrBeHHbrxKoHcrpyKqrzft, xax ,AepHbIx, raK I'I nepzseprzfiurtx. K vracnyAocror4Hcre pa6orrrcneAyer TaKXe orHecrl4BHI,IMaHr4eKreKcr4qecKoMyHarroJrHeHlrropaccMarpl4BaeMblx fpaMMarllqe cKux crpyKTyp : Bc e pasAeJrbr3Kcrrepr4MeHTaJrbHof oy're6Horo noco6u-s coAepxar ra6;raqrrceMaHTLIqecKPIxrpylnc[epeqHeM r4cnonmyeMbrxrJIaroJIoB.

llpan;rexaer pa3Hoo6pasze [peAJraraeMbrxBrrAoBynpaNHeurzfi: .rr3brxoBbrx(uaMoAenr{poBaHae, BcraBKy,Ha6lroAeul4e, 3aBeplueHne [peAJIox eauir,nepeBorcoCTaBJIeHae AI4aJIoroB' oTBeTbIAI4cKycc?I'f,xMarepr4€ur,JreKcraKo-u Ap')' BprAp.)r4rpaucSopMarlrro,KoMMyHr{Karr{BHbrx (uaHa BoIIpocbI, [epecKa3 TeKcTa, yqAcTLreBpa6ore npe.&craBneH aurepecnrrfi Kyn'ryposeAqecrufio6ecnevusaroqufi [oBbrrueHr{eMorur B arlut406yraeuux.HecouueHHa npaKTLIqecKa.[ 3Harrr.rMocrbAr{cceprarJLrH, olpeAen{eMa.rr reM,rITo pe3yJlbrarbl IaccneAoBaHufl'Moryr 6rtrr ucnoJlr3oBaHbr Ha 3aHflTuflx rrorpaMMarLIKe' B cnellKypcax u c[eqceMr4Hapax,B rrepcleKTr{Be MoryT 6r,,rBKrroqeHbr B yue6uoe noco6ue rosyHxqnoua*sofi fpaMMarr{Ker{Ho cTpaHHbrxArrflyqaq Lrxcfl..3$SexrraBHocrb paspa6ora,sofr ruccepraHroM MeroALrKr{aKruBu3arruurlpocrpaHcrBeHHblx KoHcrpyKqzfi e pyccxofi peqtaHrJroroBop.suux cryAeHToBnpoBepeHa 3KclepLtMeHTaJIbHbIM nyreM.

Pe:ymtarrrBbrrroJrHeHr.rrKOHCTaTI4PYIOUIeTo cpe3a, a TaKXeAaHHbre [poBeleHr4, npel_14IIocTSKcIIepI4MeHT€LnbHoro TecTLtpoB a:F{ufl Harnf,AHonpeAcTaBJIeHbronucaHbrn ra6lzqax zn naparpa$e 3 nropofi rnaBbr. Baxuyro poJrb, 6esyclonHo, crrtpiurloI'IcKoBo-pa3BeIbIBareJIbHbIfi excnepI,IMeHT, B paMKaxKoroporo aBTopoM pelxeH4IIenbIfi pf,A BaxHefiurux MeroAl4r{ecK}rx 3a1aq, B ToM rIr4cJIe yror{HeH cocraBo6reu yve6Horo Marepl,I€ua, cKoppeKTnpoBaHa crpyKTypa noco6r{f,,ueo6xo4uMoe KoJIHT{ecrBo yue6urrx qacoB.ЭKCΠ epИ MeHTa」 IЬ HoЙ3lKf+26yo,Bapr4aTLrBHOCrr4:+ 1 6oh,KfrpyΠ Πe B cpaBHcHИ И c KOHTpOЛ ЬHoЙ (ypoBCHЬ+39%,KforrpeAeJreHoEolrurufi npr4pocr rroKa3areJrefi+l2Yo: ypoBeHb qacrorHocrr.r:3l113f+20%,KfnΠpaBИ ЛЬHocTИ+10%; ypoBeHb+21o/o; ypoueHb aAeKBarHofo AeKoAnposaHzs:3f+4%) AoKa3blBaer eSQexrH BHocrb yve6uoro noco6ux, pa:pa6oraHHoroK.3. Coruzxosofi.Pa6ora coAepxl{T ctIlIcKarpoaH€LnLr3HpoBaHHbrx npofpaMMa, TecroB,yre6urrx noco6ufi, a TaKxe rlpunoxeHr,rr, HarJrs.qHo AeMoHcrpr4pyrorr{HeMare pH an brr4ccn eA oBaHkrflup azp a6 orKra aBTo p a.Brtcoxo oI{eHI{Baf, HayrIHyIo HoBrr3Hy, coAepxareJrbHocrb,3HaTIIIMOCTb ALICCepTaIII4OHHO|O ZCOJIeAOBaHy]fl., ctILITaeMrrpaKTl,rqecKyloIIyXHbIMBbICKa3aTbHeKOTOpbre 3aMeqaHHg.1.

Характеристики

Тип файла PDF

PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.

Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.

Список файлов диссертации