Отзывы официальных оппонентов 2 (Политическое управление развитием федеративных отношений в контексте национальной безопасности современной России), страница 2

3.irexropamHo-us6uparelrurtfinyn 3aKogoMepHo cnoco6crBoBaJr yclrneHuro KoIlKypeHIIr{u noJIHTr{r{ecKHX evIT LIrpyftrr, rotBJreHHIo HoBbIX ntall tlonnrl{rlecKoro ncreSirnrilMeHTa,BrICTyIIJIeHU}ouecgcrevHofi onno3gr{Hrl. Tel,t He MeLIee, He npol{3oluno naprufiuorroJrnltr4LreaKoro 3JreKTopaJrbHofo pa3Me)KeBaqr4fl uo cySteKTaM, TeppHTopvflM m3oFraM, r,rro Moi.Jlo6nr Hera'fr4BHo orpa3l{Tr>efl Ha Qe4eparnBHbIX orHorrleHl4flx, KaKno BeprI4KaIiLI, TaK u IIo fopH3oHTaJII4 (C.94-94 {rzcceprallllu)'B nepeoff laparpa$e eropoit[o,Turr4r{eeKolo yilpaRnei{-1991p.;1992-1998r,;vflrJraBbr aBrop BbIAerIHn ycnoBHble 3rallblpa3lwrl4eM Se4eparraBHblx orHolileHufi (xoneq 80-x1999-201i rr.; 2AI2 r.

- Hacronlrlee npenx)14IoKa3aJI,i-ITo B r4x paMKax cocro.sJTt{cb l,racrura6uble noJll4Tl4Ko-ynpaBreHr{ecKvre aKrJvrvr)LrarleJreHHbre r-ra: yilpolreFrr4e cyBepeHuTerauSesonacHocrl4 Pocclin; [pI4.{aFIHecydrexrau rroBor.o ypoBHfl cyBepeHI4Te't'a (no4unueHHoro ayRepeHlrrerySe4epaUxil). Tarx<e 3ro: 6opr,6a c rQppoplI3MoM v ceraparl43MoM;yperynnpoBar{t,te sTuorioJrr4Tt4r-recKuxJ'iefuTI4MI43aU[.rri orHoureHntie/{i4r,re.rBanov3TFIoleppl{TopuanbHbIX xoH$lnxron;BepTHKaJlIiLl IlO fOpI{30I]TanI{;AOCTI'IXeHI4enpaBonoro itoJrs ila rcefr reppl4Toput4 crpaHbl; yclaneHl4e IIpLIcyrcrBI4a$e4eparrrnoro LIeHTpa B perlioFlax; yKpyilHeHl4e pernolloB; co3AaHI{erlan cydr,exron P@'Se4eparir,Hbix oKpyroB; u3MeHeHr{e pernaMeHTa Ha3Har{eHVflKpove 3Toro coclo{Jrocbr43MeHeHr{e orrpeAeneHl{t coorana Coeera @egepa\wv uco:Aar-iue focygapcrBenHoro aonera.llovueltnro B.B.

Hasapoea, 3HaKoBbiMBoBHyrpH- u reonoJp{Tr4qeoKoM rrJTaHe eraJlo BXox{AeHI4e B cocran P@ Pecny6nnxraKpr,trrtw r. Ceeacronors B 2014 r. Ant'op cLII'ITaer,{'ITo Bce 3TLIaKIII4l4FrerrocpeAcrBeHHo r4 o[ocpe/IoBaHHO HanpaRJreHbI Ha yilpoqel]I4e Halll{oHalrnofi6e:orracsocr.r4 PO.B 'ro x{e RpeM.s pa3Bllrnecfeaepa'rnBHbTx orI'Io[IeFIafr Ha ecex3Tanax coAepxa'feJrbr{o H opfaHH3auI{OHHO CBfl3aHO C pa3l}I4THeM AeMOKqATLTV}npoBeAeHKeM aAMI4HtIorparunuofrpeQopvrr n pe$opur,r MCY. lloeronayfrorrr4Tr4rrecKoe y[paBner{r4e pa3]lr{TneMB cBfl3t{CQelepaluBHblx orgorueHuu pactuuprercflc noBbrureHr{eM [ori.r'u4r,recKofi KoMrIe'reHTHocrI4 rpax.4aH, pa3paoraHl4eMcl{creMr)r o6u{ecrsenHo-uor{HTnqecKr4x oprar{rr3arJwi H ABuxeHr{it ^ wuc'u.iryroBrpalKAaHcKoro o6qecrBa (C.

129 I30 fnccepraqun).Bo eropoM rraparpa$e, pa:nvaafl, Mbrcrrb V.A. Couruofi, I{.A. fpuropreea,B.B. Ha:apon AoKa3bIBaer, r{TorexHoJrorr.{n [oJrr4TrrqecKoro ynpaBneHrito6ectre'laBarcT oIrrHMaJIbl{oe coLIeraFIHe /1Byx IIporI4Bonoro}KI-IbIX,rXl4aneKTl'iqecKi{ R3anMocBt3aIIIlhIX rlpoqe0eoB(C. 132 {racceprallu14). I(-HoI{HTerpaI-UIH H perl4oHaJtvrcai.j.tlI4rrepnoff rexHonolr4r4 rroJrr{ruqecKoro yilpaBneHr4tpa3BLIrI4ev $e4epartr{Rl-Iblx olnoulei{r4it aBTop olHocr{T odpasoeaHxe B 2000 r.$eAepaltulrx oKpyroB KaK uonoft eAr{Hr4rlbr HaATepptiropr4aJ'rbuoroilorl4lllqecKoro ynpaBneHrr.r{ rroBoro ypoBH.s. Blopax rexHoJrorufl.

nolrv'rr4r{ecr{oroyrpaBneHlrt{ pa3BI{rueM tpe4eparanHbrxoruoureuuft 3To rpauc$opMaL\vrnHOpMaTI4BHO-[paBOBOrO ilpr4Frr_lr4[a 14 OpraHr-{3arlrroHHofo nopr{AKa o[pe/[eJrgFrr{r'rlan cy6reKToB PcD. C'rraraeM, qroAaurrax npo6leMa 3acnyx{r4Baer orreJrbr-roroLuyqetr4x, TeM 6onee B cr{ryarli4?r, Kory{a ry6epuarop 3ar,raryro nepecraervcySr,erloM uoJllltrlqecKolo trporleccaSurlcraHoBr4Tc.[ qacrb o5e:rnqeHHoroMexaHr43Ma KOpnopaTl{RHofo ynpaBne]iHg,B rperlefi rrape nropoii rJraBbr ol/]enhuoroBHr.iMaqrr4fl3aeJryxnraer aqanr43allropcKoro npar(Jrarr{oro r4ccJreAoBaHzfl.

<Srccneprrrar orleHxa s$cpexrr4BHoc'rr4norI4T'I4r-recKoro yirpaBner-iu.s Qe4eparnBHbrMi4 orFrorueHr4flMkrBFIaqHoFIant uofr 6esonacuocrr,r aoBpeMeHuofi P@>, npoBeAeHHofo B MaeKoHTeKcre20I6 r.Ocuoerrrre HayrrHbre pe3yrbrarbr r,rccneroBatvrfl, 3aKrloqaurcr BfIOJIVqCHI4A HAVqI{O*14CCJIEIOBATEJIbCKOfOrlpoliyK1'4, o0ecIIeq14Baroruel.oAOCTOBepHOe nOHr4MaHLre nOrr.rT'Kr{e0KO|O yrrpaBJreHkrfl. pa3BrlTr4eM QeAepal'r4BHbrxornou:enufr Lr BbrflBJrer{nz pecypcoByrtpoqeHBr.{flu ar I i.{o }rzurrno r.r 6e:o il a c H ocrl{rroBbrureHr4.qaoBpeMefo :SSexrunFrocrr4 anfleHn o ft P @.qeJroM rroJro)K14TeJrbrro orJeHr{Batr ;1Hccepraur4onHoe r{ccneAoBueodxoAlrl,ro yKa3arblra prrA :avleuaunfi,aHLre)Kacarc[]Hxcrr crropHblx vrr4He/{ocraror{Ho apryMer{fi4poBaHHbrx uoroxeuufr, Hy)KAaroqprxcfl, B yrorlHeHnur4nH I{OrroJrHI4TeJrbrroH apfyMeHTatIr4r{.1.Ae'rop orMeLiaer, Lrlo (KrIroLIeBbre pucKi{5e:onacnoclr4n14yfpo3bl HalIaoHanbFlofrpa3Rlrurr4 $eTieparuBHbrx oruolueHr{fi cBtr3aHbl Bo MHoroM cIOITiTHTIECKI4MII IIPOTHBOPEIIH,f,MI{ MC}I{AY YIIPOqEHI,IEM TICHTPAITHOfi BTIAATI4T4cyBeperiuzauuei't cy6r,ex'ron cpe4eparr4BHolo focyAapcrBa).

Ha rtaul esettad, Surno5u nozutrtrn eosoputnb o uercoil xtqnnlH?tKoaotlLduua,vLtLrceKrnqelbm puc/{o6Hal,ptoLtanutLoit Sesonacrtoctl,t.Lt 6 pa36umuu cpedepamurHbtx omHotLteHutL,LL))epo3xomopttitycJtoltto .r4o)rcHo npedcm.aaLtmb ntaKoit cxeu.oiL: cna6uit qeHmp * cunbHbtiL pezwou,cuttt urrtiL LFHnxp --cLtJtbrtutit peettou. IlezanttteLtbrc nocJtedcmaun nepTozo cLPHapua.uurta(,tnpdanue 90-x zodctxnpoLtt,,tozo6eKq. BoemopoA4 cnyuqe pa3peutunxbnpomulopequtt .tteacdy tqtlnlov,L u pezuoHoM. 6 cumyaLluu npoLqccol ynpolteLtLut\ertmpan,"uoiL 6Jtctct't'tLt uzocydapcmlq, noLnll4attLLxq)sepeHu3aLlltLt cySaercmoe Qedepamu7HozoKeK lseLtMottcKflroqapLque, rcpatiue sampydHumerbHo.ilpeodo,teHue neplozo n.potllttlopeLn,rtr cmano 6o3wo)tcHo, 6 mott qLLCre u qepe3cozdqHLte cpedepanurtbLx oKpyzol Lt Llrtcnlum))me nonHoMorulbrx npedcmaeumeneil.Xomenocunp eodot5u ycttbtLLtctmbet nLtL 6 mop o ?o npoct6mopcK))to txo3LtLlunm.u6openoMexaHLBA4qA4, mexHo,ryoeLffi.M.Ltutt.2.

Coenac:LLivcfl c auteodol4 a6tnopa, ttnto <xpcpercmunHocmb notrumuuecKo?oynpqsneHun pa3runxuLett rpedepamusLtbrx omHouteHuit e rcoumeKcme HaquoHalxuuoitSesonacuoctnu ocyulecnxzJutemcn 60 ffiauu4onpoHuKHoleHLn,t pecypcos n.oiruImuKu upecypcol ynpasneHlffi dtLn docmuaceHuil), IIo xomenocb 1ut Soneea6mopct{o?o noHLtMattLttt n'lozo,4eHmpanLaaLpruuqmo ecmb<onmuMaJlbHoeLLetnKo?ocoLLemqHuede4euntponLzaLpru SedepantulHbtx omHoweHuit>, r<pumepueht.Ilpttomo.\I 6o3HuKeem. erye oduu Bonpoc:n4ctpKepo6emoil6o3.t4o)tcttonu docnlu)KeHueAt emof,L ohmuuct.nbHocmLt 6 pan4KaxonmLuvre.itbuoctl,tlt.:laKotLo6, no.nLtmlrrccKuxLL xo:tniLcm.aeHHbtxnpoKmuK?cyulecmlyrcLl4LLxllnu ouu mpe1yromuercoiLl{oppeffilLttt dnn docnttnrceuun eQcpeKmurHozo (tyuruptouupolaHun QedepamuzHbtxotnuottteuuil?c mer4, Lttno acoapetteuuoii HayKe cyLqecmGyenx A4tlo)rcecnllo nodxodoe K noHuA4aHwo3, Omtt.emua, Ltmo o6mop,noHu.r4ettLtcoe,neLLtctttcbHarluoHattuuoit SesonacuocmLL, Ltnlo e poccttilcrcoit HopJwamueuoit Sase uottctlo6ctnpenlLlmb noHLt'ttctHue HaLruoHanbtloit SesonacHocmuntt'LHoiL corytta.nuuoituu KeK mpueduucmeazocydctpcmeeuuoi,t Sesonacttocmu,tneK u m.o, Lmto<Hq\uoHattbHan 1esonacuocmb zKnrcqaem e ce6n oSopouy cnxpaHbru Bce eudbrSesonacuoctnu, npedycLvLon'tpeHHbte KoucmumyqweiL Poccuitcrcott Qedepa4uu u:tcrrcoHodanlerbctl'tlo"u Poccttitct<ctit 4>edepatluu, npeucde 6ce?o zocydapctnleLtHyto,oSulecnleeHLt.y.to, t'nclloll.vcn1'L,rot1t1yto, glelto?LtLtecKyto, gKotloMurt.ecKyto,mpaHcnoptnHylo, eHep?emuqecKyto 6esonacHocmb, 6esonacuocmt) r.tuqHocnlu,(<Cmpame?ufl HaLluoHeJ'tbtloil SesonqcLtocmLt Poccr.titcrcoit cDedepaaluu) atcxodttmLt3 snlqruLtcmcKozo noHLtl4qHLrn.dauHo;t Kame?opuu, /-{anee 6 met{cme paSoruut oupaccyacdaem o nomtmuqecKol4 ynpalneHuu pq.t6umuen4 QedepamLtlHbtxontttou,tettut) 6 Lqrtnx eduucmea norutnuqecKoeo Kypca, udeituoit tlop?aLtu3atluouuoil cnroqeMtocmu nonumLnecKo?o Kltqcca3Jrtumd, nottlml.Ltqecrcoil.

t<ot-tco-,tudql4uu epaucdouXom.e.ryocu,ynpq6"rteH'tecrcoiL60 scex cy6tercntax P@qmo6ut a6mop demanusapolctJt A4exeHlt3wbl, nrexHonozuLtnotrutnl.LnecKozoy6er1,{q.eHLtnuynpailettLttt pc[3BLlt]ute.tt Qedepantltzttbtx omHoLLLeHuit e cwtyaLluu.yzpo3 u pLtcKOq t{QK qHeUtHL X, mqK U gHympetffiLtx.Bl,tuteyxa3aFlHl)Ie KpHTHLIecKI4e 3aMe\alwfl, B oilpeAeneunofi Mepe HocrrrI(i4aKycct4ot-tt-tt'til,cy6lexrltniluti xapaK'rep w He criuxaror o6rqefroqeHI{I4 Al4ccepraut4orlHol'o I4ccJre,tloBarrws.,efo reope'ru.-IecKofi H [paKTu.{ecxofr3IlaLII'lMocrp] draccepraqrzx Fla:apona BNxropaUOJ'IOX{I4TOJII)IlOe RIIeLIaTJIeI{LIe, BbIIIOJII-IeH?'feope'fH rrec KoMnr,rcoxofiRurropoelr.la ocraBrrrerLIa IIbICOKOM M9TOIIHLIeCKOMUypoillie.Anlope$eparvFiaylrHr)ieny6ruxaqr.tu coor]leI'arByer coAepxaHrJroAACCepTaqAOHrrOfO i4ccIeAoB aqr4flu B HeM npeAcTaBJlerIbr ocr{oBHble [olo]r{eHntpa6orr,r.

Klrroqeni,reny6,rnrcal\wtrx)pe3yJrb'ra'rbiHccJleAoBaLrr4fl r43rrolKeHbr aBTopoMB ToM r-tL{cJ'Ie 7 B xyprianax,Milnuc'repcrBa oSpa:onauuuwI-tayKi{B16peKoMeH/IoBaHHbrx BAKPCI, 14 anpo6npoBaHbr HaHayrrHo-rrpaKlnq ecKnx r<oH$epeuullrx./-{i.iccepraqran FlasapoBa Ri.ix'ropa BuxroponJ4Lra Ha reMy: "llo.xurnqec6oeyilpallJreljl4e pa3RI4'r?IeM cbelepaTprRi-tr,rx oTl-roureHvv.sKoHTeKcre Haqr4or{?.JlbFroil6e:onacuocrlz conpevouuofi Pocetrrn" rnr.rrercrr :anepruenuoffHayqHo-rea:tll{tuxauiaourtoii pa6o'roft, o5"na/tarouler)i eceri coBoKyrrHocrbro Heo6xoTirzrr,mrxxea.irn(l,txB.t{HoIIIri:IX IrpI43IraKoB, a r4MerfHo aKTyanrlrocrbro, uayuuofi noeu3Hoil,'feope'rllr-Iecrolr H ilpaKTh.lecxoii 3rrarrl{Mocrr,ro.

l-elta H coAepx{a}-rr4e lJrneeep'rarJur4coorBelc'rByror rrpoSu,rio crreql{aJrbrrocrrl n.0A.A2 - llo:rnruqecKae riHc'fr.rryrbi,flpolleccr)r t{.'l'exrjoJTofr4rJ. capra pa6ora cooTBeTcTByeT Kpr4'Iepu.sN{, corIlacHo(O [opr/lKe rrprac]]r{7letr4r4Ilo,rorxeunxyr{eHbrx creneuei.r>>, yrBepxr/lesuoilnoclai{oBlelllleM llpar:nrerrr,cre PO o'r 24 ceurxSpx 2013 roaa i\b842 (n pe4. or02.08.2016 r'ola J\b 748), a ee aBrop- Ha:apor; Bnxrop Bux'ropoelrr{ 3acry}Kr{Bae'rrlpHcyxlternr4 y.reuofr crerreFrr4 KarrAr4Aara [onalnrrecKr4x Hayr{rroc[e{]4aJIIbI{ocrLI 23.00.02 - florurnqecKr{e r4rrcrr'iryrr)r, [poqeccr,I H Texr-roJ]orr{r.i,Orbu r tua"rri,utrfi oirrrolrerlT:Aor{'fop rroJrLmr4LrecKXX rrayK, tpocpeccop,npo Qecco p xaQ e4pbr Me)r{/\yu apoAr{brx orHoureu afrft oJlr.{'f oJI ot'14r7wN.{ t4poBol4 3Kori oN{,'.-T*$tr'OI'FOY BO "llx'luropcxnfryHHBepo{'rer" (23.00.02 rtporleccbr14IlI-.8.

KocoeTexllononz lr)_ffi357 532,F7r. flgriafopcx, C'ranponorr,crcufi(8793) 400-219E-rnai I : kossov 1 @vandex.rurcpafi, rrp./3KalnHut,d+f,,,9.