Отзывы официальных оппонентов 2 (Политическое управление развитием федеративных отношений в контексте национальной безопасности современной России)

Or:rreoQuqualbHoro otrrIoHeI{Ta AoKTopa [oJrHTr{qecKrrx HayK, npoQeccopa.Kocosa r.Bo Arrcceprarlulr Harapona BarcropaBunropoBurra<<flo.unrnqecKoe yilpaBJIeHIre pa3BrrrrreM {re4eparuBHbrx orsorueHufiKoHTeKcre Halll{oHa,rsuoil 6esonacHocrlr conpeiueuuofiBPoccl.rr.r>>,rlpeAcraBleuuofi Ha colrcKangile yvenofi crerreHr,r KaHAr{Aara rroJrlrrrrqecKr{xHayK rlo c[equaJl[,Hocrlr 23,00,02TexHoJrot-ura- flolnrnqecKue uucrrrryrbr,rrpoqeccbr tr(noluruqecKHe Hayrcu)Axryalnuoarb npo6nentrl Ar{cceprarlr{oHHoro pa6orrr HecoMHeHrrfl. OHa onpeAenterctHHTepecH BeAercf, IroI{cKoTHorrreHvrtr, -raK14reM, r{To HaBbr3brBaercoBpeMeHHoM 3Talre Bo3pacraerHoBbrx rroAXoAoB KaK K pa3Br4rr4ro $e4eparuBHbrxK ynpaBJreHHro 3TrrM rlpoqecaoM.llepeocttblcJIeHI4e I4HcrI4Tyr{HoHaJrbHbrx ocoSensocrefi[oJrr4Tr4qecKi4xlrpoqeccoB c yqerolr Qe4eparHBHbIX orHorueHnfr, e coBpeMeHHbrx TeHAeHUH{x ti[oacK HoBbIX acrIeKToB sroft upodlentu BKoHTeKcre Haqr4oHanr,uofi6e:ouacsocra o6peraer ceroAn.s oco6yro cMbranoByro Hafpyx{eHHocrb.

lloerovryno3rrlllrfl B.B. HasapoBa rroBbL{BJIeHI4Io co.qepxaH:afl,Hailpanlesnfir4 TexHoJrorwfi,IIorHTHqecKoro ynpaBneHun pa3BkrraeM $e4eparr.rBHbrx orHorrreHvfit e KoHTeKcreHaUHoHaJIrHofi 6e:ouacuocrn coepeueuuofirr c cJreAoBareJrbcKyron p o 6,.rllponegeuurrffeMyAr4 cceprarlr4Ar4ccepraHroMPoccauaKTyaJrH3rrpyer14no4po6uufi auanr43cre[eHr4pa:pa6oraHHocrl4 upo6leuu ro3BoJrr4n cAeJTarr o ueo6xoAr4Mocrb AaJrbHefiruerou3yYeHr4fl, roJil4TurlecKoro yrrpaBneHnfl, pa3BVTr4eM$e4eparzBHbrx orHoirren ufr, vKOHTeKCTe Hardr4oHanrsofi 6e:ouacHocrrrBHeluHenoJrr4ra.{ecxoficvryarluw,araKx(ecP@, ocoSeuHo ayrreroMyrreroM Tex 3aka,qpa3gvrrkrflpoccnficroro o6ulecrBa, Koropble Srrnn [ocraBJreHbrBlloclannz llpe:ugeHraP@B.B.

flyruua @e4epanbHoMy CodpauHro P@ s 2018 r. u B ero uHayrypaquoHuofrpequ 1, a raxxer4 B<<uaficxux yKa3ax)) 2018 r.B Kar{ecrBe Me'rol{oJror-H{-IecKHx ocrIoB LIccJIeAoBaI{Llfl /IIlccepral{T14crroJrb3yer t4HcraTyrlr4oHaJrbHbrfr u IIeo14HcrI{TyrluoHaJIbHbIfi I1o{Xol{bI,fro3BoJIl,lBulr.{e Br)rqBHTbpoJlb rroJrHTlrqeaKofo yilpaRnell]/lfl, B llpoqecceSegeparra BHbIX olH ollien Hfi.uiirepecFryro c llayqHofr ro'{xu 3peHI,Ifl I'HIrore3yll.B.

I'Ia:apoB nollrBep/Iuno roNl,pa3Bvrtr4fiLrro . cfe4eparr.rBllbre o"tliorrreHl4.fl HNlelor BbIpalKeHHoe TIoJIHTt{r{ecKoeco4eplr{aHHerarpe6yro'r rrocroflr-rFioro :$cpercrrzn}loro IIoJII'tlnqecKoro yrlpaBne}II4sr4x pa3Br.l.fr{eM, TaK KaK xapaKTepr43yroTcrr o6rqea:necTHbIM llpoTlilloper{I4eMMelr(lly ttenrpaJrr4:arlneil i{ Aerlerl'rpanl43atrl4eii eracra, Koropoe Moxer }rpoxolll:Harlr4o HaJr bHofr 6 e:onacilocrl{rocyAapcrBa.06ocuonatkre v noATRepxAeHr4e rnrrore3bl orKpblBaer Anf,aBTopaMr{o)KecTBo (I4CAIeAOBaTeJIbCKr.rX OKOI{): 3'fO w.

necJle/loBalHkle cooTBeTcTBi4efroirr4rr4Lreci{oro Kypca Ha ypoBi{edte,4epalri-,Hoi'ot1ecy6lex'ra Qelepa]'IwvTIoJII{THqeaKoMy KypcyHTpa; 14 o6ccne.{eHlie nar-II4oHanruofr 6e:onacriocrl4I]Qe4epa'rranHoM locyAapcrBe; r.i peaJrr43ailtrx toJIt4TLlLIecKoro Kypca Ha MecrI'IoMypoBHe;y ri p aH enrpa6orxan J{ e Fr raacpedi$eK'fuBrrbrx rexIIHI{ 14 'rexuottornlt noJil'trt4qecKoroe4ep a'rl4 B FI bI M 14 orHo t LI eII 14tMI{.Crpymlypa paOorsr B rlenoM coorBe'rcrByer3aAar,raM r4ccneAoBatr4tr.rJran[ocraRJIeHHbIM uer.sM14Peileu:upyeMat Al{ccepraqrlfl coaror4T tr3 BBeAeI{I4-f,, AByxno rpr{ [aparpacpa coo'rBerarReHFlo,3aKJIFoqeFIr4tL 14cnl4cKa ncnoJIb3yeMI]IXHCTOTII-IHI(OB,Anlop, paccMarpuRas rroAxollbr K rrotu4MaHnro cyuHocrl'l Ilornrl4qecKol'oyilpaBIeHarI, eTaHoBr{Tcr Ha tl0314r-lHH TOi'O, r{TO 3'IO HHCTI{TyUUOgallUntfrilpoltyK'r noJrr.irl4KH B ee rntl6aJrbrroMrIoJirl-il.J1{9CKOet-rot{HMa}IHH.OsAoKa3blBaer, r{'toyilpaBJreHr4e ?'fo rIpal('fl4r{ecKoe v JiyqrxeeBofIJlouleHHeIloJtultar(!t, Koropar, n oOrqena nJraHe, HanpaBJreHa Ila cofnacoBarlue I{HTepecoBrocy/{apcrBe,B o6uleclne Ha Bcex ypoBHsx v Mexqyr{eroBeqecKoro od[{eNurux (C.il6 l,BBaeMI4 yr{acrFII{KaMI4l[rzcceprarlurz).rrepBoM napalpa$c ncpeoit fJraBbr aB'rop reoperl4qecKu oQMLIcJII4Bae'rrroJrprlr4qecKoo coAepxairHs $e.4eparnBHbIXorsoruesatl Ha 6a:ertpaBoBofr(enporoHTHHeHTaJltuorz)rIo3BOJIf,ereMy14rloirnTr{.{ecxofi (aulno-auepr4KaHcK ofi) rpaguqafi, v'roaKueHTI4pOBarbllBa83anMOCB.g3aHHbrxSe4epatnBHbIX orHolueHrzfi: qeurp anusautrflprnpoqeacaBHyrp14AeqeHTp annsarJzrfl.

Ori Aoxa3brBaer,r{ToI{Hcr}iryl{HoHalruofi ayr{Hocrbro Se4epanL'cwa flBlrflercfl crrcreMa rroJrr{Tr{Ko*[paBoBbIX oruorueuuft Me]KAy cydlerralta, a rarcKe Mex(Ay cy6lexraua vrIIeHTpOM: COTpyAHL{qecrBo, QofJracoBaHHOCTb, naprHepcrBo,KoHKypeHrIr,r.s,co[epHurlecrBo, pac[peAerleHHe, KoMrrerer{rJLrpr w Ap. @eaeparr4BHbre orHorxeHr,rtB pa3I{bIX [apaAr4rMax (copenHoBarerbHa-s, [aprH epaKafl,I4HHoBaI-u4or'rHaa) w B pa3HbIX MoAentx (culruerpr4.ulafl' acr{MMerp LrrtHagrpeanl{3yrorct/IofoBopHafl, KoHcruryql{oHHar{, cMeuaHHa"q, AenerupoBaHHa.s 14 Ap.).

AeropAoKa3brBaer ,r{To $op,vnpoBaHr4e pa3HocrarycHbrx cy6texron B paMKaxQe4epaqafr. ssnxelcn pe3ynbraroM oSrexrnnsrrx HcropuqecKr,rx, coqganbHo*3KoHoMHrrecKaxvo6qecrreHHo-IIoJIr{THr{ecKr4x rrpoqeocoB; pe3ynbraroMHaI{erIeHFIofo rorurnqecKoro ynpaBneHaflcrpol{TenbcrBa. Pa":euraecoAepli(aHLlkr,B cSepe focyAapcrBeHHoro$e4eparzBHblx oruorueHufr B ux [oJrr]THr{ecKoMno MHeIlnrc aBTopa, IrpoucxoAHT ]l pa3Hbrx Ha[paBJreHr4rx:yBenar{eHue o6t,eiraa rroruoN,ro.rai{ cy6texron $e4epaquu, urlorrHrLlr{ecKofo aBTopllTera qeurpalruolz BrraQT:a,reppuropui w 3oFI BaBtr3trpa3nv'rvflMli HacereHntvcv3TO14ycuneHueaa$sepeHLJr4ar\ufr3TFloAerraorpacpuuecKr{Mu 14 3rHoKynbrypHbrMriAeMoKparusaFeia Mex3THr4qecKr4x oruoureuuil, cMnfpaqnoHHblMlI [epeIBI4X{eHVflMLr HaCeJreHafl;cI4MMerpuI4 Se4eparilBHblx oruorueuuftB14 ynporreHr4e acr4MMerpvrucBrr3r4ctufirodpa:oeaHaeM HoBl,rxcyobeKToB; I4 yKpy[HeHI{ea, eoorBercrBer-rHo, yMeHbrrreHne q.vara cy6tex'ron :acrler HX o6r,e4nHeHvrfluxoxAeHnr ollHoro n Apyrofi unu yBengrreHr{e qxcJracy6r'er<ron 3acqerr4JrHBXo)r{AeHHrrB cocraB $e4epaquuFroBbrx cy$1,exroe um1pa3AeneHwx cylr.,exra Ha ABa r4IIw HecKojrbKo.B3aKJ'uoqeur4erraparpa0a BTop rrpr4xorlu.rKBbrBoAyIIorI4THr{ecKoe coAepxaH14e Se4eparriBHbIX omrorueunfi/XeMol(paTl43auilrc roCyAapcTBeHHorOpa3HoypollHeBocrLl Blraerr4, rroJrrirr{Kr.r14tIo roM, r{Too6yc"uae.ryHRaerHatlaeoTpor.rTeJrbcTBayrtpaBneHnfl-3acr{eTHa ypoBHe Se4epaqrzrz, aI{eJroM, Ha ypocHe cy6r,eruon $e4epaqure,ua MecrnoM yponHe.

llpnLroNIeHKJrarypa cyOrercror:pacur14pfle'fcflolHorrreHr4flMyr. Ilolauvo$ege pa'ruBrrL,rMaIIOJIHT'I'ILIECKOI{3JIHTb] B HCErrpoTiccca cy6r,erron3ToMllOJTHTHT{eCKO|O ylipaBneHH.B'cpegepa:ri,uofiBKJIIOqAIOTC'upelr4oFrannuoficySt cySreKTbr rroJrHTr4rrecKoroMecTllafl 3JlI{Ta,Se4epaqnnMeCTFIbieo6ulecrneIJI{oIroJIL{'tnqecKHe opfalr143au1414 Lr. il-t}r4>r{errr4fl) MecrI-IbIe or4eneFIrr.BttoJIL{THr] ec I{I4xnaprrziiCor:racul,tcrrcaJrropoNf B TroM, r-rro ((N{erol{oJlol'lirrecKne I4l'ITeprrperaL\wI4noiir.r'r'HL{ecKolo ynpanJreHL{rI trnJlrlrorot{ oliIrHM14ccJreAoBareJIbcKL{xH3 caMbIXnocrpe6oBauHbIXnalipanlerrntl B c14creMe noJII{ToJIoftl.-recKoro 3HaHr{fl,ripelKAe Bcelo, fioroMy, r'rTo froJrr-ITr{rrecKoe ylrpaBnerlr4e Ha ilpaKTHKe 3ar{I4MaeTolirjo143 BeAyilIr4x rvrec'filc14c'r'eN4eIloJIr.I'fl{qecI(HX r4I'rc'faTyToB, nporieccor]texnolorufr> (C.

60 /{rzcceplar1zH). 'I'o ecr},, 6omuroffHecJre/IoRare,rr,cxr,ifi14Ir'fepec IIpeAaTaBJr_fleT Lre ToJrbr{o r{3yqeHr4e rroJrHTnrrecKofo ynpaBneHZ.sycloBltsxt}le-qeparnnHbrX orrroureunfr,rlo u/utrprx cra6nrr,uocru,3iiarir4T' r.r /-urri cL':r6iarr,rroc'rr,I H 6eso[acFroc'ru{ Bcel'o locyAapcrea.HeaHa Halr] }i3fJrr/1,Hl{lloilarluo}ulocl'b Aaunofi HecJle/IoBareJlbcKott svuru o6yc;rou.lieHa reM, rrroIlpOfiBItCTCflBn3yareHne [orHTr4lrecKoroynpanner{arr caMraMrr cpe4epalrznr{brMn o'rFlonrerrrr.flMrrpa3BL{Tl'ria cpe4eparrrB}lbrx o'rFioirreHrzfi14Be xoHreKcre rrar{uo}raJrnsofi 6e:onacuoerr4'rOJrbKO riOpN4a'fr4BHO-rIpaBOBat{, OpI'aHI{3aqI{OI-IHafl,HOt1no.iitn'tirrecKat cocl'aBJ'rrroLqar; $e4cpari{Bllbre o'fl"roiueHur LrMeror BFIpa)KeriHufrAIaHa\.r"rl.{Lrbrfi(iro4nraxrrrllli) xapaKTep; tpeaeparunH6re orHotrreHr4r{cJlolKrlococl'aBHylo c'fpyK'rypyQclcpa'rraBrJ brc,Ti4{p(l)epeH rdr.lpoBar-rcoof'tl0ureHI{gr{hrxMHolKec'rlloM cy5:nexroeBO|IJIOIJIaIOTC.f, llur4Me}orcy6cy6reKToR;pa3Lroo6pa3HbrxrroJrr4Ti4r(o-optarir{3aru4o}IHl)rx, HopMaT[Btro-IipaBoRbixMo^rlcJrrrx; pa3nr.JT'r.Jc cbeltepalraBHbrxorr{oruerlnit orpa>rcaer lJraBHoe npo'rulBopelrr4ecpe4epa"rru:nra MelKAy r,leuTparrr4:ar(llen/{eN,{oKparn:aqlreu BJrac"rr4lineprnr(aJrr.r3aqi4eilvAer(errrpa:;.rtzatluefr, Mex(/{ynraclia; y[paBne]rnepa3nHTr4eN4{rc,1cpa'rrrlribrx ot'nourerruli l.1N4ee'f i:upaxcunr,iff rtoJlr4Tr4r]ecxnii acneK'r' t4peaJrH3yc'rcn cpax'ru.recxu KaK rioJlri'r'r.{qecKoe ynpaBJreHne qepe3 pa3Jrurrribrepa3BI4THeM $e4eparuBHblx OruoureunilTexHoJrofI4H; noJrg'f6qecKoe yrtpaBnennetta o6retcT' Ilo 1a B3aHMOAeftCrnUevflBIfleTcfi He ToJlbKo so:AeiiCTBHeM Cy6:uerracy6terroe u cySlcy6lexron $e2leparuBHbIX orlloureHl4n'HerpaMorHoe vnr4 L\wukrr{Ho*Corlacul'rcfl o aBTopoM, '-rro <Hee0$exrneuoe'yupaBneFII{e pa3BIITIIeM Qe4eparUBHbIXAeMarorur{ecKoe ;1OIyITI4LIeCKoe.rax 11o BepT[KaJII4, 'faK 14 no I'oplI3oHTaJIIl, MoXeT IIpI4BecTn KoTllo[IeHuffxoudUux'ralt c 3JIeMeHTaMI4 ceUecoun VCyUIecTBeHHbIM IToJII4THKo[paBoBbIMHI|H K BbIXO'4yfpalKAaHcKofi BOilHbr 14 Aax(e K pac[aAy focy.4apcTlraorAeJIbrIbIXTeppl4ropl4fi)lJ(C' 64'65HeI'O/{raccep'rarlrau)'/IaFrHoM pa3AeJre peqeH3HpyeMoli lIuccepTaIIKHBrJr4MaH!{s paccyx(Ael{I4tlli3oco6o3acJIyX(I{Ba}orlnS$epekIWaI\1414 norturur{ecKoroaBTopa oy[paBneHr]ecKofo c.rvrr]fl, fIIaB Cy6:L,eKTOe $e4epaunu'IIO efoMHeHI4W', TAKafl'caMofrpa3Jlnqu,IMu AeTepMI4I]aHT sopvrrapoBa1vlflau-$QepeHuHaLIH{ BbI3I]aHacy6beKrax $egepal!'Lrv', [pex.4e Bcelo'froJr.lTi4r{ecxofr 3Jrl,rrbr B Tex r4nr4 vrlbrxrlcropr{Ko-Kylb.fypHbix H couranbl{o*KrlaccoBux(c'69-70 /lracceprauun)'13rperr,eMnapafpasenepnofirlanr,taRTopAoKa3blBaeT'r{ToaKTyaIH3AI\LrfrnoiII4TtI4qecKoI'oynpaRIeHKt $e4eparnBHbINt14oTI'IoUI9Hwfl17rkIRKOHTeKcTertOII4TI4TIeCKHMI4yilpoqerrnfi i{aquorrarbrlofi 6e:onacuocTI4 PO OSyClonleHaMbI paQOMoTpl4MBI{yTpeFIHHMl,l 14 BI{eIuHI4Mu, KoTopbie$axropaltu,an$$epeHrlr4poBaHHo:A) $axroprrBHeIUHeIloIurHr'IecKofinpl4poAbl3roKoTopble np[oSpeTaro'IFreraTI{BI{bIe MexAyHapoAHble oScroqrellbcTlla'BeKoB (C' 89 fluccepraUran); 6)rlo6a:6sbli4 xapaKrep, ycl{JII4BaflQb Ha py6ex(enprapoAblsax.ropr,r BHyTpr,lrroJII4'II4r{eQKOir-3TO: HefaTI4BHbIe 3KOHOMI4qeOKIIe14poQ"fa', naAeI-IUe3aMe,qneHl4e TeM[a 3KOHOMKT{ecKofouporleccbl,$uuaHcoeue6e:pa6oruurt 14 CHn)KeHI4eKypca HarIHOFrarbHoil BaJltOrbI Poccnn; pog'fxr43HeHHofo ypouHfi HacerleHl4t(c'92-93 [ucceprauar'i)'ItoMHeHr4roB.B.l{a:apoea,Ba}I(HbIMBHyTpt{iloJII{TI4qecKI4Msaxropolt',tynpaBneHl{f pa3BI{TI4eMrroBbr11tegntt e$sexrrar]HocTI4 IIOIHTI4q9OK9TOtssBJIfleTct BcTy[neIII4e poccI4fiCKOfO O6I]IecrBao'fHOlIIeFII4fiQe4eparraBrrbrx2017 f' - 2018 f' (nsrSoprt nI{!{KrI 2016 r.3neKroparrblro-r436t{pa'fenbl{blfi-focy4apcrBer{HyroAy*yMCy cySlexros PO,PO, ntr6oprt B opral-Ibl Hcrlorlul4renbHofi BJraQrvCDCvrnr,r6oprr llpe:n4eHra PQ).