Отзыв на автореферат 5 (1150954)

Просмтор этого файла доступен только зарегистрированным пользователям. Но у нас супер быстрая регистрация: достаточно только электронной почты!

Текст из файла

OT3bIBHa aemoperfuepam duccepmat4uu MycaotnHa Apmeua<P a3 sLtruLtenpww€1euemo dwtect<o?oo 6 ecneueHun€ n o d nuu u utx 6y x z an m ep c KuxKHMtnqilnoruua Ha mey4yyHemHbtx npoqe dypuz cp e d u e e e Ko 6 btxxiii-xivrco un auee.uil)(ua>t,l,tpedcma+neuttoil Ha coLtcKaHue yqeHoil cmeneuu rcaududama gKoHoA4uttecKLtx HayKna' cneL?tanbHocmu 08.00.l2B-ByxearmepcKuil yuem, cmamucmuKa(loBpeMeHHbIX ycJIoEI4sx, KorAa na6nro4aercx AocraroqHo 6rrcrpoepa3iBI4TPIe 3KOHOMI4KI4I4 ee rfuuanconoro ceKTopa, Bo3Hr4Kaer Heo6xoArzMocrbMoAz$zrtil]lakr f{erHbrx cr4creM, rpe6yroqux paspa6orrucoBpeMeHHbrxyuuSuqzpoBalrHblx Sopna SuuaHcoeofi or.{erHocTlr, Koropbre MorJrrr 6rr crarr,oOqenpI43iHaHHbIMI4, rroHtrHbnMraAnr rxr4poKoro Kpyra rronb3oBarelefi.

B cnssu cyveruofi leopllu l4 ee I4crol)vIr, HanpaBneHHbrfi, gaclaHOBrIeFII4ttuBblf,BJreHr,re 3aKoHoMepuocrefipa3Bl4Trre MeroAurrecKoro o6ecneqeuras MexaHrI3MoBf{erHbrx cr4creM 14 vrx yr{erHbrx upoqe4yp. 14lro:rToMy oI{ ilpl4ooperaer HeManoBa}KHoe 3HarleHr4e B QB'3rl C OTCyTCTBHeMBdryrrrqraoHl4pollaHl4t paHHLIXTerteHI4e .IJII,t.TeJrbHOfO BpeMeHr{ AOCTyrra K cooTBeTcTByrolqur M MexAyHapoAHbrMnclopuqecKr4M $oH4avr,K pe3ynbraraMHeETO3MOX{HOCTV rrplrHflTld.'x yLrACTLrflHCCn eAOBlrccJlenoBawufr 3arranHbrx KoJrJrerLrB MaCrXTaOHbrX MeXAyHapOAHbrX apXUBHbrXAtHpIfl)( IdCT OpkILr.3rorcleopl{T o roM, rqro, Borrpocbr reHe3llca 6yxralrepcKoro yrrera Ao cr4xnop KoMn"[el(c1{o He u3yrlelrbl, a [peAnafaeMoe Alrcceprar{voHHoe rzccneAoBalJLre,oplztel{Tl4poBilH.Hoe Ha u3yqeHr4e rrcTopr4qecKofo orrbrTa pa3BllTrrflpaHHI4xcla uflx efocraHoBJneHu-sefo MoAelefi saB KoHTeKcre B3arzMocBr3r4 6yxrallepcKr4xr4Ha npl4pa[IeHr4e :nanUfi B ClSlacrrEucropzireoKrrx ero acuei<ros.

B eBfl3u c orr{M, 3acny)KrzBaerSI{OHOMI4qTOCKHX AOKTpr4H,HailpaEneHOTeoperuqecKlrxuBxtr{MaHI4s BE,II{Br4r{yrafl aBTopoM, rl4rrore3a pe3Brr'wrfl6yxranrepuu; B XnII-XV se..y.rernofi ilpaKTr4Kr4 upocrofiOua Aana Bo3Mo)KHocrb eMy cSoprr,rynr4poBarbBAi4ccepTa\r4r4. pflA BbTBOAOE, IIO3BOLf,IOIIII4X BOCTTOIHI{Tb HeAOCTaTOT{HOCTb pflI.aSarcron reopl4ld u traropLru 6yxratrepcKoro yr{erazonpeAeJruTb HanpaBneHr{e Hapia:pa6orKy oorBpeMeHHbIX yqe'rHbrx cr4creM, oprreHTLrpoBaHHbrx Ha Aocrr4xeHr4ee4Ianoo6pa:lu vconocraBr{Mocrr4 $unanconofi orr{erHoc'ul4,Me)KAyHapoArrclM, TaK14HaKaKHaHaurzroHuurbHoM ypoBHe.B nu4y rolo, qro AiIHrIoe I4ccJIeAoBaHr4e r4MeerI4cropr4r{ecKrle acrreKTblxapaKTep:acrvrr:lr 6yxranrepoKor'o yr{era, nooroMy K ero Aocror4HcrBy, rro HarxeMyMFIeHraro,cneAyer orHecrrzr, @yu4anaeHT€urbHyro HcrorrHzKoByroI4(lcJIeAoBan288r{ux 10 zcropnqecKrrxucror{Hr{K:oB, r436*y.r4croqHrlKoBAnropBBr{AeSolorconrzrf cpeAHeBeKoBbrx yrrerHbrx KoMrrJreKcoB kr3 apxrrBoB @nopeuqzu,flparo 14 6ra6rnoreru I\dedicea Laurenziana Bo @lopenquz.nJ0z.BJIer{eHHr,IX HcroqHkIKonl o6.ua,4aerrlenocrHocrbrorrocraBJreHHbrx.

I4ccneAoBaTeJrr,cKr4x 3aAarr"pa6olytsrrrrBJleHrrro 3aKoHorropa3lBvrTl1rflAocraroqeEAn.a peueHr4snogeoJrrrJro npoBecrLr cepbe3Hyroepuocrefi kr orJrzrrlrreJlbHbrx oco6euuocrefiMeroAr4rrecKoro odecne.{eHu-sSyHr<qraoHnpotsaHx{.f,3ror4Korrannercv yqerHbrx nporleAyp Bnpoqeccenpocrofi 6yxranrep:zra, SopvzpoBaHvrfl clarr4r{ecKofi uo4ervru(lrll4cJreHvtn'$vruaucoBoro Fre3ynbrara.Kponae'roro BalKHo, Fra Harrruc[orrb3oBaHueM o6rqeuayrHbrxr40[orlByeT MeToAoJlofr4rorrB3rJr-f,A,orMerrrrb, r{To HapflAycucropr4qecKr4x MeroAoB r,rccneAoBaHkrfl. aBTopl4ccneAoBaHvrfl. SKoHoMI{rIecKr4xkrcoIII4anbHbIXAr4crlr4rrnuu.

Oco6oe BHr4Mar{He i} r4caneAoBaHr4r4 yAerreHo MeroAy KoMrrbrorepHofipeKoHcTpyKIII4I/I yLIeTHbIX cI4cT'eM, paspa6oraHHoMy poccuficr<unau f{eHbIMI{.3trclyxzneLel Blu:zv.aHvrfl [pn rzHTep[perar\r4v I4cror{HI4KoB, orpaxarorqrrxorpeAeneHHyro Ae-f,TenbHoclbatpv6ytueHrrfiKOrrOp5lfi,KaHaJrprg, rronr]^{zBlrlvtit. npuzuaHkre BC0nrarreHr4ro,o6uleuayrr,rrix,nwnert, npunaenreltufr Borer{ecreeuuofi nrlTeparype, HoHe o'rpax{eH AHccepraHToM B anropeQepare HLr BHr4 B r4cropr4irecKr4xMeroAax. llpunreneHpre urppr6yrunHoro MeroAaI4MC)ET BAXHOE 3HAI{CHI4E ANfl, AIiANI43A CPEAHCBEKOBbIXcloco6I4ccneAoBaHr4r4crn'ye:l 6 one e uy6 ox oMyn oHr4M aHvrro3T{CTHbIX KOMIIJIEKCOB, T.K.aKo HoMepnoocor6ensocre.ii pa:lBvrrvrfl Merc,Iu4qecr(oro o6ecneqeHkrfrvcrefi M o'r Irkrqr4TeJIbHbIXy{erHbIX npoileAyprrpoqecce rSylxquoHrrpoBaHrrq cpeAHeBeKoBbIX rounanzfi.B[ouoJIHeHI4eurpv1yTuEiHclfl0 aHaJrr43a cpaBrrareJrbHbrM MeTo.4oM rroMofJro aBTopy ycnerxHoBocco3Aar.b o6beKTr4BHyro pearnbHocrbrro3BoJrr4Jrorlofre'rHofi npanrur<u XInI-XIV en.

Bce sroAlrocepraHTy cAeJra'Tb rrHT'epecHble HaxoAxIa c$opvryJll,IpoBarb BbIBoAbIpa3Bl4Trarcr rvroToAr4rlecKoroo6ecle.IeHl{f,){eTHbIXilepBbrx yrrerFrbrx cr4creMuuSoprrraquu 'r'oJrbKolJlpilrruuer]K]4l{cpeAHeBeKoBb-f,.B pa6ore BbIBoA, o roM,Tarc,, Brl3blBaer r,rHlepec, cAenaunrrfiHa3Har{eHr4elpoqeAypSuroHanpaBneHoHar{ToSopuupoBaHl4eo cocloqHr4r4 pacrreroB c Ae6raropaMll vr KpeAr{TopaMI,I.ceroAHq orr4 sJreMeHTbr $zuauconbrx I{HarpyMeHToB tBJlarorc.f,sraxcHefiultuu o6leKTaMI,I 6y><rarrepcKoro yqera, KoHTponfl LI 3KoHoMl4r{ecKoroatFraJrrr3a.'Iarxe Aocrarorrto uHTepecHaBbrrBJreHHafl ilpvluraHa Bo3HI4KHoBeHI4.flIO.r.rroBbIX o6-s:iarertrcrn (r<ar rtaccl{BHbrx r4 aKTlzBurtx), cBt3ar{Hafl c HeAocrarKoM.reKannofi rdoHerbr B nepr4oA peHeccaHca oKoHoMHKI4 (c.6).

O4naro,Bc'oBpeMeHuoffi znrepnperarlIara SyxranrepcKoro 6ata:r'ca AoJIroBr,Ie o6.qsarerbcrBa,no-BrrAkrM,cuy, Soree roqHo ur4euru$nlll4poBarb roJIbKo KaK rIaccI{EHbIe.3ac;rynznaerBHLrMaHr4fl, AoKa3aHHoeHa peaIIbHbIX npuMepax orKpblTueneFlBeHcrBa rpr4MeHentrfl. cr4creMHbrx ganucefi B KHI4re Recordanze (1363r.), r.e.llaqoru (1494), rcoroprrfionHcariAono-rrBne',HvrflKHrrryc'rpaKTara o or{erax vr 3ailvcflx JI.no4o6nrrru Ha3rlaHrreM, KaK rIpeAHa3Har{eHHyIo p'nfl HecI{creMHbIXzitnuceit, To e)crb He r4Mer()rqyro curcreMHblx cn.f,sefi c 6yxralrepcKl,lM yreroM.(<;.14).Kar nu4norr3 aBrope$epara, n pa6ore noKa3aHbr 3HarleHrae Meuopr4ana,uecr6xo4zruoro Anltt nepBz.{Hofi perucrpar\krkr ar4creMHblx sanl4ceu I4 rroAnex<allll4xnepeHocy n f'raauyro KHrrfy,T'arxer4MexaHrr3Ma ero BbIAeneHI4q Iae Recordanze.Bbr3.brBaer I4H'repec Kpl4Tr4r{ecKatoIIeHKa, rlpoBeAeHHafl.

Ha ocHoBeAeraJrbHoro vr:tyqeHurs. paHHrTX KHI4I r<ounanrafiolFrocr{TeJrbrro AeneHr4flfraenoft KHIrrI4 HaO. [aruuu B4lBa pa3Aena:AeuuroHe,crreron 4eSHropon ucqeroB KpeAr4Topon. Cne4yer corJracvrrbes. c MHeHI4eM aBTopa o roM, qro Ha oAHo{ru3uuecx,ce vrnkr ropvAr4qecKoe nzqo rorAa onHoBpeMeHHo orKpblBanprcb ABacqera: 4e6uropct<oit. u KpeArlTopcrofi 3aAonxeHHocrl4, noroMy r{ToB nporI4BHoMcryqae 6rrlo 5rr He Bo3MoxHo opraHl43oBarb KoHTponb 3apacr{erHblMl4oreparluqr\4r,r.focra:ro,rHo 3Haql{uclfi, Ha Halrr B3fJIrA, flBrrflercfl orIeHKa rpe6onanuit rcBeAeHr{ro paHr{vx KHr4f rreT,a rro ABzxeHr4ro HaJrl{qHbrxAeHe}KHbrx cpeAcTB.flpanznruo o'Meqaer aBTop, rrro 3acnyxI4BaerKOTOpOMy 3arrl4cLrorroKarloJlonteHr4e, cofJlacHoHiuII4r{HOCTr4, 3apefIrcrpl4poBaHHbrekrfl,uBury€urr,H{) pa3Hocunr4cb Elnpzxo4)BHLTMaHLTfl<uscitu(B pacxoA), n roB Meltopzale,BpeM.f, KaK B <Entrata>rrepeHocr{Jrr4cb HAKOIIJIEHHbIE AAHHbIC IIOCTYTIICHI4.S HAU4qHbIX[ONH.SMuJrlr 3a HecrKo,JrbKo .unefi.

o6re4r.ruxrcilrve HecKoJrbKo crpaHr4qMeuopvana. Tar<ofifIO,AxoA na(rrno4ae'raflu B coBpetreHHoMAoKyMeHTaJrbHoM o$opnaneur4r4 H€urrzrrHbrxIe)HexHbIX cpeAcrB, HarIpI4Mep e 6anr<ax, rAe npl4MeH-f,rorc-q ropa3Ao 6olee crporr4enpaBl{na oQopuleHl{l BhrAaqI{ ltaJll4qHbrx cpeAcrB, rro cpaBHeHr4roc ux npr4xoAoM.Brtsbrearor raK)Ke I4Hlepec BbuIBJreHHbIe MeroA br Lrcrrr4clrelrLrflSuuancoeorope3ynbrara' npl'4Me)H-f,eMble B cpe,AHeBeroBofi 6yxranreprau.

CneAyetcorJracr4TbctcIl-prIBeAeHIrbIMI4 AOKa3areJIbcrBaMr4 aBTOpaBTOM,qroMeroA pacrleraSznauconoro pe3ynbrara, Irpl4MeHf,enarrfi n 4nofiuofi 6yxranrepuv, ocnoeaHHrrfiHa rlo[ocrlaBJleHl4rr rlonf{eHHrlx AoxoAoB u o6ecnequBlrrr4x Lrx pacxoAoBI4CTIOJIb3OBZIHI4eMcCleIII{alE,HbIX Cr{eroB (troKynKr4 Lr [poAa)Kr4 TOBapOB),npuueuxevltil B HeKoropblxcrarllr{ecKafi MoAenbefoI4Mylr{ecrBa, 4eSzropcrofiKoMrIaHH.f,x,6ur 6oree [porpeccr4BHbrM, qeMv}rrnclre]ts'hrfl, OCHOBaHHa-fluHAr4HBeHTapu3ar\kruKpeAl4Topct<ofi 3aAon)KeHHocrr4, rrpr4MeHseMaflMHOI'I4MI{ Apyt-'vr]Mll KOMlaHI4j[Mr{ B TeqeHve HecKonbKr4x rIocJIeAy}otrIHXcronerzfi.SroT BbIBoli 6rrn c4ela.', cyl.fl ITo aBTope$epary, Ha ocHoBe AerzlJrbHoro arr€urr{3ayqerFIbIX IvIeroAI{K LrC.ilrcneHr4fr Szuanconoro pe3ynbrara, nprlMeHrreMbrxBKoMilaHr4-rrx {x. @aponz (1299-1300rr.),{enn Eene (131g- r324rc.),rc)u(136t5-I410 m.), roroprrfi rroKa3arr krxHeAn6epru4erm l{xyAr4qe (1302-1329oTMeTI4Tb,q:fococTaBJIeHI4K) rOlOeofirrpoBoleHr4_s uHBeHTapu3ar\krn4@pauvecr<oflaruvu e AsuHroHer4AeHTnqHocrb.llp"3ToM BaxHoOTTIeTHOCTZ npeAlxecTByeT STarrBcex ctateit Salawca, T.e.

cBn3b MeronvqecKzx[ollxoAoB {roplrzpoBaHnfl yqernblx rroKa3a'renefi npocJrexr4Baeror cKBo3bO4,na.r<o )KaLlIE,, qro kr3 an'rope$epara HeAocraroqHo BrrAHbrBbrBo4aMI4, AAenaHHbIMr4B Ar4CCepTarIr4r{ vr coBpeMeHHbrMr4BeKa.ar)fl3r4 Me)KAyHarrpaBnelJprfll.{upa3pa6orKl4 6yxralrepcKrlx clrcreM Lr r4x MoAenr4poBaHLrfl.HaIloJIHeHa coBpeMeHHbIMuI Karerop[rr v'kr vr noKa3hrBaer,Xors rlcnpa6otarrro QyHrcqzonupyrorqrafiB Hacrotqee tspeMx 6yxra-rrrepcnufi yrler rlMeer cepbe3Hyro MeroAonorrlqecKyroocHoBy14,HecMorpr Ha 3HarII4TeJrbHbIe ero MoALr$uraqzz, f,BJr-flercs saxHefirxefi3KoHoMllrlr:crofr nayrofi co oBoI4Mu cnequ$r4qecKrlMr4 npeAMeroMVxarasnuer4 MeroAaMr4.3aMeqaHlzrq ruoc.sr peKoMeHAarenrrrrrfi xapaKTep kr He yMoJrrrorHayqHoro 3Har{eHllf, BblrloJrHeuuofi pa6oru.

Характеристики

Тип файла PDF

PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.

Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.

Список файлов диссертации