Отзыв официального оппонента (1146472)
Текст из файла
Orsrrn oQuqua.nbHoroo[rroHeHTaAorffopa ucropr.rqecKr{xHayKcenesHena(DegopaA.nerccanApoBuqaHa Ar{cceprarl[rc Tunroxnnofi [apru AprcagreBHbr(cAHKT-trETEPEvPrCKA.flOPrAHr43ArIr4rIKOHCTT,ITyTIUOHITOAEMOKPATIITIECKOII IIAPTI,II4 B 1905_19t7 rr.>>,rIpeAcTaBJreHHyroHa col{cKald'Ideyuenofi cTerleHrrKaHAr{AaTar{cTopuqecKr{xHayK rro crequaJrbHocrr.r 07.00.02.- oreqecrBeHHaq r.rcropr{qllsyuenue LIcropvla KoHcTLITyIII{oHHo-AeMoKparuqecrofinaprvrv flBrrflercflOAHI{M vr3 naz6oleenocrpe6oBaHHblx BHayqHoM rrJraHe nanpaueuuficoBpeMeHsofiucropzorpa$uu pyccKoronH6epa-rrlr3Ma.I{enrrfi pflAvccneAonannfiobIJI rIocBf,IrIeH MecrHbIM opraHl43arlr{fM napruru KaAeroB (4eficrnonaBrrrrrM Havpale,BCvt6upu, flonorxre,B Mocrcne, Huxeropo4cr<ofi,Ty6crcofi,BopoueNcrcofi14Apyrux ry6epnrarxeBporeficxofiqacrvrPoccura).B roxe BpeMtAo cl4x rlo BHe rroJlf, 3peHLIt freHbrx ocraB€uracb rrerep6yprcrax opraHrrcarlkTtnaprkru Hapo4nofiCno6ogrr, KoropattrpeBocxo Auna rro qlrcleHHocrpr BceHI43oBbIeKaAercKI4eopraHl43aqrru, KpoMe uocroncr<ofi, v 6naro4apr cBoeMycroJII'FIHoMycrarycy I{ HaxoxAeHl4ro B orrr{rleHTperronr4rlrqecxofi x{r,r3Hr4crpaHbr- llerep6ypre3aHI{MaJIa oco6oe noJroxeHr{e B rraprur,r.
MoxHo cKzparb, qroToJrbKo c fIo.aBJIeH[IeMAl{cceprarlrrr4 A.A.TzuoxzHofir{cropr4KLr nolyrrr4nr4nonHyrc KaprLIHy Ae-f,TeJIbHOCTr4MeCTHbTXCrpyKTyp naprukr KaIeroB. B srofiaBflsHaKTy€ulbHocrr4trccepralll4l{ A.A. Tuuoxznofi ne Bbr3brBaercoruHenufi, anz.rHHfi BKnaAaBTopaB HayKy orreBuAeH.llpo$eccl4oH€urrl3M aBTopa nporBr.rJrcf, B ToM, rrro eMy yA€Lnocb.{erKoo6ocnosarr o6texr,[peAMer I4 xpoHonornqecKr4epaMKLrr{ccJreAoBa14q, rrroo6ecne.rzJroJrorprqHocrbcrpyKTypu pa6orrr H ee BHyrpeHHeeeA[HcrBo,coucrcarenbHr4ua[peKpacHoopzeHrr,rpyercrB r{cropr4orpa0nuBonpoca,BToM tll4cne Honefiruefi. Ona BblAenklna Lr KoMrrereHTHo npoaH€urr43r4poBaJrao cHoBHbIe STalbr vrcYreHl/.fl Lraropr4v KoHcrLrryu r,roHHo-AeMo KparH.recro fi naprr4u.HaB3rntAolrloHeHTaI{cropt'Iorpa$uuecr<ufipa3AenBBeAeHr{-f, Aax{e(reperpyll{eH)) znQopvraqraefi.I4snu:l;tuuMrlpeAcraBr.f,ercrrepequcneHuepa6orBbrrrreArrrlrxB nepnofrrroJroBuHeXX s. (rpy4rr c.E.
cesa,E.f. gepuencrcoforaAp.). I-{enecoo6pa3Hee 6nno6uyAenl4rb 6oreerpucr€urrHoe BHHMaHT{gcoBpeMeHnofiucropuo rpa$zH MecrHbrx opf aHr4za\uit Ka.qercKofi napruu.[uccepraqrzx !.A. Tzuoxunofi onzpaerc.rrHa rur4poKyror{ pa3Hoo6pa:nyroI{crorIHpIKoByIo 6azy. 3aclyrofiaBTopa tBJlrrercr BBeAeHLreB HafrHbrfi o6oporKoMIIJIeKca Aenolpol43BoAcrBennofiAoKyMeHTaWpr croJrzqHbrxrlpexAe Bcefo, AoKyMeHToBllerep6yprcKofoKaAeroB H)ropoAcKoro KoMr{Tera u pflAaropo,4cKllx I{ ye3AHbIXrpyrrrr (upororconbr 3aceAauuit, crLrcKH rrJreHoB,orrrerbr zo6sopu AesrenbHocTLT, afzrallkIoHHbleMaTepI,I€urbI, Bo33BaHr,rt, lucronru).Oco6ufi I4HTepec npeAcraBJl-f,ror QHnanconbre AoKyMeHTbr, rrocKoJrbKy noupoc o6I{croqHI,IKaxQunancl4poBaHIlfl naprvrv Hap o4noft C so6 olbr Bbr3brBaer Ar.rcKyaevLrB I{cropl'Iorpa$uu.BaxurtuBKJIaAoMB I4cropr4orpaQrEroBorrpoca flBrrflereflocyulecrBJleHHoeaBTopoM BBeAeHLTeB nayvHrrft o6opor neony6luKoBaHHbrxBocrloMLIHanuitnl4Aepa KoHcTI,ITyIILIoHHo-AeMoKparLT.recKofiSparqzra f{arrlkrxc.rrcpeAHI'IXyue6Hrrx 3aBeAeHHfte l9l7-1918rr.
!.I4. Meficrrepa, orJroxr4Brrpxc{ BfAPO.Enaro4apx6orarcrny r4crorlHl{Kon!.A. Tzuoxrauofi y4arocb HacbrrrrrbAI'IccepraIII4Io LIHTepecHbIMQarruuecrurra Marepr,rzuroM,xoropufinoABeprHyraBTopoM Aonx{HoMy HayqHoMy aH€IJrr,rsy.Ero Bocnpr4.rrrveo6lerqaerIrIecrI4 upuloxeHufi,B KoropblxcrpylrrrlpoBaHbrHarkrqr4eocHoBHbre coqnarrbHbrexap aKTepHcruKlz TIJIeHoBuerep 6yprcrofi opraHrl3arIHZ rraprr4r4KaAeroB.Baxnoe HayqHoe 3HarreHrler4Meer, ocyqecrBrenHufiA.A. TuuoxunofiaHalrvr3LI3Aarenbcrcofi.qe.[TeJIbHocrLIuerep6yprcKr4x Ka.qeroB.B racropuorpaQrauHCT EAKIHO|O MHCHVTfl IIO TIOBOAY TOIO, KAKI4C IIMEHHOK KaAeTcKLIM -ToJIbKo o$zqualbHbleII|3AAIF'KTfl.CJIEAYET OTHOCHTbIreqarHbre opraHbr ilaprr4Lr r4Jrl,rra3erbr(xypnanrr), a pe4aKllr{tx Koropbrx HMeJrocbqJreHoB3Harrr4TeJrbHoerrpr4cyrcrBr4enaprvr]/,Hapo4nofi Cno6oau.
Perua.soror Borrpoc,!.A. THuoxuHao6ocuoBaHHoBbIABI{faerB KarlecrBeKpLITepr{r r4MeHHO KaAercKororIpLI3HaKI4: ero MarepI{€IJIbHyro u u4efinyrclolynrpn3arlzroLrM laprzfruofiee crpyrcryp.Ae.rrrenbHocTkru3aaHkrfl. cneAyroqr{erroAAepxKy naprufinuMznporpaMMbropraHaMq,Hrrkr nn$oprraupoBaH?reoO'reHr HHTepeceHBbIBoAaBTopa,Kacaronlzitcs tolurraqecrofi Susuonouuura3erhl <<Pe'Ib).
lloMHeHI{Io Al{ccepraHTa, oHa ((He Bbrpa}KaJrarro3r.rrlvtluaprufiuoro 6olrruplHcrBa, 6oree roro, oHa AalKe He orpor€ura iuHenux L[t,Bblpaxas [o3LIIIZrc caMoro n.H. Muffoxoea Lr ero 1nuxainterooKpy)KeHu.f,...)(c.71). OnuoHenr Bblpaxaer corJlacl4e c grHM BbrBoAoM,zMerorllrM BalKHoe3HaqeHr4e 4rrfl. xap aKTepucrr4Krr p acKJraAa cr4rrBHyrp r4 KaAerc Kofi napruu.HosrrN{ HayqHbIM pe3yJlbraroM, nonyqeHHbrM Ar{ccepraHToM, flBrrflrorcflorKpblTble I{M cBeAeHI4{o rrpkrrrr,rHaxrrpeKpauleHr'rqBbrrrycKa<<Becrnzra ilapruuuapo4nofi cno6o4rr>.
B pTcropllorpa$uu B KarrecrBe npurruHbr rpeKparrleHlrtu3l.aHprfl )KypHarla o6H.rHo yKzt3blBalor Ha QHnauconue rpyAHocrr4.A.A.Tuuoxuua BBoAtIr B HayqHblfi o6opor Marepzanu cy4e6noro pas6zpareJrbcrBarlo Aeny o uy6nr.rra\w <BecrHuroM naprr4r.rHapoAHoficso6oAbr))B 1906 r.Marepl{€ilon ronSepeHIIHLI PCFII,B pe3ynbrare rrero ro rprzroBopy Cauxr-flerep6yprcrofi cy4e6nofi rarrarbr u3ftaHvrexypHaJra6uro 3anpeqeHo.3ror Salcr rpafine BaxeH v rnfl xapaKrepucrvrKrorHorrreHufira4eroB ccoqllan-AeMoKparaMvr vr coIII{zuII{craMI4 B IIOJIOM.K coxaleHkrro.colrcKareJrbHr4rlao6xo4rarsror Ba)KnufinoupoccropoHofi.A.A.
Travroxnna paccMarpl4Baer I'Icropkrrc nerep6yprcxofi opraHlr3arlLrkrnaprkrvr Hapo4nofi Cso6oAbI KaK rIpHMep craHoBJrelnfl B Pocczu LrHcrrrryroBrpaxAaHcKoro o6ulecrna. 3ro BecbMa[JloAorBopurrfi v opr4rr{Halrnrrfi noAXoA.OH snorne Moxer 3aAarb HoBoeHarrpaBneHr4eB orerrecrBeHnofir{cropzolp a$uu.BeAr Ao cux IIop I4ccJIeAoBareJII4paccMarpvrBaJrr onrro3r4rlr{oHHyroaKTT4BHOCTbKaAeTOBz odqecrBeHHbrx crpyKTyp, rAe oHlr AoMr4Hr4poB€rJrr4B roAbr llepnofiunponofr nofiult, KaK rrpofBneHr4e Kplr3r4ca rorr4Tr{qecrcofi cprcreMbl qapcxofiPocczra,xoroprrfi npl4Benrced xpaxy - @enpanrcxofipeBonroquu.OruaKoora )KeaKTI4BHocrb,ecJII4cneAoBarb JIoTLIKe!.A.Tuuoxznofi, MolKer paccMaTpvrBarbcflKaKrrporBJreHr.recTaHoBJreHr4qrp a)KAaHcKoro o6rqecrna.B roxe BpeM.a[o coAepxaHl4roAI4cceprarlr{r4Mo}KHocAenarb Her{oropbreKpHTr,rqecKr4e3aMeqaHr4fl:l. HelocrarorlHoeBHLIMaHITeyAeneHo conpeuenHofi r4croplrorpa$uuMecrHbrx opraHLr3aqrafi ra4ercxofi naprkrkr1'2.
CoucrareJrbHr4rla o6orulacropouofiBonpocuerep6yprcKllx KaAeroB tI coIIIzanLIcroB,naxnrrfirroJrr4Tr4qecrofi Quszououlrut crorruHofiOOOTHOIIIEHI{{XAnfl.xapaKTepr4crr4KllopraHu3arluzrraprkrvHapo4noftCno6o4u;3. Anrop oAHo3HaqHoorHocr4T KaAeroB K tulepataM, B Toxe BpeMf, BcoBpeMeHnofi zcropraorpa$zl{ orMeqaerc.fi rroJrlrrr4qecKrrfipa4uralusl,rKaAeroB n BIrkrflrrvreHa HI4xklAeonorraucou:nurr{3Ma.llosrouy,Ha B3rJrr.rIorrrroHeHTa, cneAoB€Lrro6u Ha Marepr4aJrax LrcropHr{ nerep6yprcrofiKaAercKofi opraura3arJvrvAarb oIIeHKy coorHorrreHrlronu6epanrHbrx r4COqLI€IJILTCTI4IIE CKI4X 3JI EMEHTOB KAAETCKOfi IE,UEOIO f T4I4.4. C upe4uAyrrllrM 3aMerraHneMcB-f,3aHocneAyroqee.
Anrop clpaBeAnLrBoyKa3brBaer Ha ro,rrroMHofLre kr3 nerep6ypfcKlrxKareroB BcryAeHqecKue foAbl npI4MbIKaJIrrK HapoAoBoJrbqecKrrMopfaHr43arlr4.flM,.rrBJr.rrJrHcbnra6epanrHbrMr4HapoAHr{KaMr4u MapKcr4crauu (c.33), no neAeJraeTLr3STOrOHr4KaKr4XBbrBO.rIOB.5. flpe4cranIrflercfl ney4aunoft SopnrynzpoBKa BocbMoro rroJrolKeHpr[,BbIHOCIIMKaAercKLIenkIAepbl cblfpanl4 3HaqlrreJrbHyrcponb B HaBeAeHr{r4rroprAKaB cronrlqe vr co3n.arraLrHoBbIX opraHoB nnacru>).
CroeocoqeraHr,re(HaBeAeHkIe IIoptAKa)BAaHHOM krcropkrqecKoM KOHTeKCTerlpeAcraBIrflerafl onnoHeHTy HeyMecrHbrM. Cne4onalo6urarcKeIIO-f,cHI'ITb, O KaKLIX OpfaHaX BJTaCTLTr{AeT peqb.O4naro, yKa3aHHbIe3aMeqaHLIt He BJrr4flrorHa o6rqyo ronoxrr{TeJrbHyroorIeHKy AI4ccepraIII4lI A.A.Tzuoxuuofi.B IIeJroM rroJro)KeHr.rr,BbrHocr4MbreaBTOpOMHa 3aIrIHTy H CAenaHHbIeHM BbrBOAbrroD4qHbr, KoppeKTHbrc uayunofiTorIKI4 3peHI4-svr xopouocoAeplKaHr{eAr4ccepTarJvrr4.o6ocnosaHrr. AeropeQepar [onHocrbro orpoKaerTpyao6naAaer necovsennofinay.urofi HosrasHofi vorBelraer BceMHeo6xo4zMblM rpe6onanvIsM, rlpeAbrBnqeMbrMK Akrcceprarrvv Ha colrcKaHgecrelreHl{ KaHAVAaravcropuqecKllx HayK.
3rono3BoJrf,er HaM yrBep)KAarb, rrrocoI4cKareJrbHI4IIa'A.A. TuuoxzHa, 3acnyxrrBaer rrpucyxtA e;g{Lrflzcrouofi crerreHr,rKaHAI4AarazcropvqecKl4x HayK no cneqvalbHocrz 07.00.02 - (orer{ecrBeHHa{vcTopufl>>.Cenegnes@e4opAlercan4ponu.rCnncorcny6.nunauufi oQuquaJrbHoroolrroueHTaA.rr.H.rupo$eccopa O.A.
CeresHenarorrcropr{H[apuu KaAeroB3a rrocJreAHue5 aer1. KoncruryllI4oHHo-AeMoKparl4irecKas ilaprvfl n 1905 - lgITrr.: sKoHoMr4trecKatnpofpaMMa I4 orHolrlelJufl. c 6ypxyasueft Caap6pror<rceH:Lambert academicpublishing,2072. 440c.2. cJo. Burre, A.o. Tpeuonrr KaAerbr(6opr6a BoKpyrHosofipeAaKrlr4r{OcnosHHX3aKoHoBPocczficxofiurvrnepzrprB anpe.ne1906r.) //kon crnry:qul 1993roAa u poc cvritcruft tu6 epatm3M: K 20- rcruro p occufi cro fi rcon cr LrryrJkr1r.C6opnurcHa) {HrIXcrarefi. Oper: Lls1aretrcAlercan4p Bopo6ren,2013.
C.10515.3. flaprux KaAeroB n 6opr6e rporr4B ceraparHoro MLTpaMelKAyPoccrEefir,rfepvraHraefi:cy4r6a reopnkr (AByx 3aroBopoB))B coBercrofi Hcropr{orpa$uu- 1960-xLvzv-x1,920-xLvou-x rr.rr. llZunepcxar// yrMnepcKatI4MoHapxuqecKa.f,cocraBJrf,rorqatrnu6epanruofruAeonorLIIa:C6opnLIKMarepI4EUIoBBcepoccraficrofi nayvHofi ronfrepenUuu.24 26 ce;ar.2014 r. Open: I4r4arenr AnerccaHApBopo6r en,2014. 4l-6 c. C.230 - 238.4.
@parqrls KaAeroBa BorlpochlroproBo-npoMbrrunennofirroJurrr4Kr4(uo pe.rau4.I4. [hEnrapeBa B III focy4apcrBeHHofi4yue) ll TanpuuecKr{errreHr.rr2013.Arryaluruenpo6reurr [apJIaMeHTapH3Ma:vrcroparfl Lr coBpeMeHHocrb.Mex4ynapoAHasHarrHa.flrou$epenqzx, C.-llerep6ypr, Taepuuecrufi ABopeq,II - 12 4era6px 2013 r.
C6opru.IKHayqHbIXcrarefi lllot pea. A.E. Hzroraesa: B(SnerCuc>>,2-x\acrf,x. ClI6.: r4zaaretrccreo2014.r{.1. 360 c. C.198 -203.5. flapwtx KaAeroB KaK tApo KoHTpgJII{TbILr Borrpoc o cenaparHoMMrlpe cfeprraanraefi(19141916 rr.) ll llepnax MlrpoBaqsofiHa - rponor XX sera.Marepualu Me)I(AyHapo4uoftnayvnofi nonQepeuquu. Mocrsa.
Характеристики
Тип файла PDF
PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.
Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
