Отзыв официального оппонента (1145953)
Текст из файла
tDe4epanuoe arerrcreo mpnux opra*rsaqrfitDegeparuoe rocy4apcruermoc 6mgxenoe8anH0e y{pex,,qeHHeEAeparbfluf ilccrqqoearen cruri qenp Bcepoccuficuil r,rnreH€nqecru{x pecy@a pacrrerui ruern H.H, Barnnosa'(BB OoHrIUaJrbHOrO OlrrOHeHTarrcceprarluro ,{3apaxil Max6y6exIlquoHrroro QaKTopa KNOX3 B rlpoqecce oprallorelle3aKJryoerrbKos 6o6osrrx pacrerrHfi)), [peAcraBJrelrHylo Ha coIrcKaIIHe yqdHof crerlcllHKarrAr{Aara SnoloruqecKrrx HayK rro crrellnaJrbllocrrr 03.02.07 - reIIerHKaAnryaltnocrbreMurprKr\ cBll3aHHoftcuccJIeAoBaHI4eM oAHofo I43 KJIIoqeBbIXQar<ropon opraHoreHe3a a3or$r4Kcr4pyroqux Kny6eHE,KoB 6o6osux pacrenvriLo6rxcrurercx, c oAHoil cropoHbr, BarKHT,TM npaKTr4rrecKl4M 3HarreHZeM BBI4Ay porll4avrMlvrorvqecKr4x Kny6eHr,KoB B HaKorrJreHI4I4 pacreHl4eM a3orcoAep)KaulfixopfaHr4r{ecKI4x coeAr{HeHufi.C ApyroftcropoH6I,14ccJIeAoBaHI4eHafeHerl4qecKoMypoBHe rrpouecca Kny6eHbKoo6pa3oBaHuq, KaK MoAerrbHofi cncreurr, rlo3BoJlter nyqmerroH.rrrb npoqeccbr [poJlr4$ep arfuvruaeau$QepeHllrrallm pacrr4TeJIr,HbIX KJIeroK.
BcBoefi pa6ore aBTop rrcrroJrb3oBarra rrrr4poruft cuexrp reHerrrllecKl4x, MoneKyn.tlpHo6uonorm.recKrrx r4 6vox[Nru.recKr4x MeroAoB AJIq I{3yrIeHI4r ponu feIIoB ceMeitcrBaKNOXB KJry6eHbKoo6pa3oBa:n:aLry JrroqepHw Medicago truncatula, arawr<eBLIIIoHeHI4.[poJrrr AaHHr,rx reHoB B perynf,quvt 6vocuHTe3a II[ToKI4HLrHa. fpaMorHaf, IIocraHoBKasa1aq, rro46op aAeKBarHbrx noAXoAoB AJrr r4x pelxeHl4t 14 LIerKoe IIJIaHI4poBaHI4e pa6orblIIO3BOJIIAJIII aBTOpy[OnyrII4Tb OpHII{IIaJIbIIbIe [pUOpIIT€TIII,IO pe3yIIbTaTLI, aI4MOHHOBlepBr,re ycraH0814T6 ponb rpaHcKpr4tIIlI4oI{HbIX Qanropon ceueficrna KNOXpa3Brrrr4lr cIaM6uorlarrecKr4x r<ly6eHrxoBxefr,crst;,r,s.yBJlroqepHbl, rIpeArIoJIox(I4Tb MexaHI4sM vrxB AaHHoM rrpouecce (uepes aKTl4Baurrrc III4ToKI4HItHoBoro ornera); B[epBbIeQaxropa KNOX3 BrroKa3aTb Bo3Mo)I(HOe yqacTl4eaBroperynflr\LruKry6eHbKoo6pasonau[s nyreM Btvrfl:ar4fl.
Ha sKcnpeccl4ro reHoB, KoAl{pyloqux CLE-rIefITIrAbr; oAeJrar'b 3aKJIroqeHIrgur4ToKr4Hr4HaocxoAHLIX MexaHlr3MaxB lo6erosofi arrr4KaJlbHofiMepIacreMeI{aKTvlBa]J]1^]1lrcry6eur,xax,a6uocutlresararcKeIlpI4aBToperryn flr\vrkr Kry6 eHbKoo6pasorauux.f[ocranosKa 3aAarr B Hacro-sqefi gracceprallr{oHHoft pa6ore JIofI4qHo BbITeKaerI43pe3ynbTaToB TrrlaTeJrbHofo aHarrr4sa oTHoctuuxc.tl K l{ccJleAyeMofi npo6neMe AaHHLIX,ony6lzr<oBaHHbrxBoroqecrBeHHbrxvsapy6exturrx HayqHbIX vsraHuflx.
O6:opJrrrreparypr,r, 3aHr4Marouufi 44 crpauvrqbl TeKcra Alrcceprallnousofi pa6orbl, coAep)I(I4To rpaHcKprrnrlr4oHHblx Sarropax ceNreficrsa KNOX I4 I4x poJII4 Bpacreuzfi Ir, B qacrHocrlr, B pa3Br4TIrI.r cnu6uorl4rlecKr{x rly6enrxoB, a raK)Ker43Becrl.rbre cBeAeHr4-[pa3BVTt4Lroponrzr pa3rurrHbrx rpaHcKprrlur4oHHbrxQarropoB14ropMoHoB B 3TI4x rlpoqeccax, oMoJreK)/nrpHr,rx ocHoBax 6o6oso-puso6uamuux 83arrMoAei4clsvfr,.I{3Jro)KoHr4lllocrI4JIIoo6:op Hoclrr Fre [pocro otlplcareJlr,ttstfi, uo aHarlrrvrrtecrufr xapaKTep, qro1gfo BecbMa IIeHHbn\4. 3anepuaerc.f, AaHHrrfi pas4er 3aKrroqeHl4eM, B KoropoMKparKo cyMMr4poBaHo cocro.rrHr4e Aen B vunponofi HayKe rlo I43yLIeHuIoAeJraerTpaHcKpr4rrr{r4oHHbrx Sar<ropon ceMeftcrsaHepglreHHbre BorrpocbrrroKNOX B pa3BI4Tt4I4 pacreHl4fi,o6osHaqeHblvo6ocHosaHoAaHHoMy HarrpaBrreHr{ro uccre4onaurafi,I4ctIoJIb3oBasve M.
truncatula B KarrecrBe MoAenI4 An.rr psrrleHl4.s rocraBJIeHHLIX 3aAar{.B csoefi pa6ore aBTop rrcrroJrb3oBana mr,rporufi cnexrp coBpeMeIIHLIx MeroAoBfeHerr4Kt4, reHerz.recxofi r{H)I(eHepI4I4, 6vsxurvtutt 14 MorleKyntpuofi 6noloruu,SncuepzueHTrr, ocHoBaHHbre Ha KoJrr4qecrBeguofi cpaBHlrrenruofi oueHKs, BLItIoJIHeHbIc yqeroM neo6xoArzMoro -uvrcra 6no;roruqecKr4x vr rexHl4rlecKlrx noBTopHocrefr,rrpr{MeH:eHbr roAxoAflrrlue MeroAbrcrarl4crlrqecKofo alralrv3a.Mareprlanbr 14 MeroAbr onlrcanbl nolpo6Ho,AOCTaTOTTHAn rofiIzlcnonrsyeMblecrerleHrr 4eraIrv3a\uvr, Koropat4rfl. BOCfrporr3B e[eHlllfl 3KCnepI4MeHTOB.l]onyrleHHble aBTopoM pe3yJrbrarbr orreHb xopotuo 3aAoKyMeHTI4poBaHbI,Bo6cyxr4euue rrpeAcraBrreHbr 6oree 40 KaqecrBeHHbIXrznSopvau4BHr,rx r4nrrrocrpaqufi.
r{epe: Aassufi pa3AeJI r{erKo rlpocne)I(I4Baerctr JIorIrKapa3AeJro Pesynrrarr,rvpa6oru. I4ccle4onauue rrMeer sanepmeHnuft xapal(Tep, anocJIeAHI4eefoorarlbl;rBflfltolcq Hacrorrxl[M yKparxeHr4eM pa6oru. Anrop He npocro rIoKa3aJIa B3alrMocB-s3bQarropa KNOX3 c gKcrrpeccuefi renos Mera6onl43Ma rIHToKI4HI4Ha, Ho I{ ocyuecrBr{rlar43yqeHae cB{3r,rBaHr4s AaHHoro Qar<ropa c flpoMoropaMlr rlpeAnorafaeMllx feHoB-Irunregeft npr4 r{crroJlt3oBaHtrkr AByxHe3aBI4cI4Mr,IX oKcrIepI,IMeHTaJIbHbIX noAXoAoB(ayattuza cABr4ra enercrpo@operr4qecKofi tIoABI4)KHocrI4 I4 MeroAa noBepxHocrHororrJra3MoHHoro pe:ouauca),a raK)r(e AoKa3anapoJrbKNOX3 BaKrIrBaIII4I4 nyrl,I6uocraHresa ur4ToKr4Hr.rHa rryrgM cpaBHr4Tenruofi oUeHKrr ypoBH.fl III4ToKI4HITHoB B KopHtxTpaHcreHHLIX pacreHnfi, olrtnuarcuruxcq tro ypoBHIo oKcnpeccuuKNOX3.llaxuoe Aocru?r(errrre ycraHoBneHl4e porfi TpaHcKpI,IlqI{oHHLIX Qar<roponceNreftcrsa KNOX B pa3BvrrvrLr curl.rr6voruqecKl4x r<ry6enrxon y JrrouepHbl LrycraHoBneHr{e MexaHr{3Ma 1eitc:rsus.srux TO B AaHHoM rlpouecce.
[orca:auo y-uacrveQaxropa KNOX3 B aKrr4Baur4r4 feHoB 6uoclaHresa ul{roKlrHvrua (MIIPT3/5, M|LOG2), vrBr,rflBJreHo B3arrMoAefr.c-rsvre roMeoAoMeFIa TO KNOX3 c pefynsropHblMl4rrocJre.rroBarerbHocrqMr4 reHoB M|IPT3, MIIPTS, MTLOGEil,M|LOG2.pa3Aene <3axrrc.reHr{e)) aBTopoM o6o6ulenu [o[yrIeHHLIe pe3ynbrarbl tro roM, qro peryrxropurrfi MoAynb KNOX-IPT/LOGMo)Ker Synr<qzoHr4poBarb rroMr{Mo IIAM Ir B Apyrl4x cnyqa{x: npll pa3BrrrvrvcAerraHo npeAnonolKeHrreaavu6yr(r'wqecKr4x Kly6eHbKoB,aBr op erfy nflr\prr4Kly6Hapr4y ceTaKx{eBII4CTb-rIXnpl4aKTVrBAIJr4pr CI4CTeMbIHb Ko o 6p a3 o B a]F^rlfl .oTr4Mrr npuoprrrerHr,rMlr pe3ynbraraMuvr BDI(HI,IM Teoperl{qecKl4Mo6o6UenueM, r4MeIouII{Mr,r Br,IcoKyro reoperr,IqecKylo 3llaql{Mocrb, crleAyer orMerplTbM[pi]KTr4rrecKyro UeHFrocrbxny6eur,roo6pasonaHr,rrypa6oru, TaK KaKJuoUepHr,rTIoHI4MaHI{e MexaH!{3MoBAaer ocHoBy Anf, ynpaBneHl4.s AaHHrIM npoqeccoMfiyreM HarIpaBrIeHHbIX I{3Meueunfi B fgHoMe.O6ocuonaHlrocrb rr AocroBeplrocrb 3aKJlloqelruituBLIBoAoB, cAeJraHIlbIXBpa6ore, He Bbr3brBaer HlrKaKrrx coMHe:avtit.
Crovr orMerl4Tb, qro pe3ynbraru pa6orrtxoponyro anpodaqurc Ha orerlecrBeHHblx vr Me)KAyHapoAHbIX HayrIHbIXxouSepenUr4-[x v 6sttu ony6luxoBarrbr B BIrAe \lrv crarefi B peIIeH3I4pyeMbIXHayqHbxx )KypHalrax vr3 crrrrcKa BAK, B ToM rrucne rpex B Br,IcoKopefrrunroerrxflporrrJrrr)r(ypHailax, r4HAeKcI4pyeMbIX Web of Science, Ir AByx n Scopus.BrlenoM pa6ora BLIrroJrHeHa Ha orreHb BLIcoKoM ypoBHe KaK rro rlocraHoBl(ev MeroAl4qecKoMy r.rcrroJrHeHlllo, TaK 14 flo rny6aHe o6cylt4euaxp g3ynbraron.
[nr leanvrcanzrr ArrcceprarlnoHuofi pa6orur aBTopoM npoaHarl[3l{poBaHonpo6neur,I234 ntrreparypHblx I4crorIHI{Ka.A.nropeSepar o$opMJreH rro BceM rrpaBr4naM rr orpDKaer ocHoBHbIe rtoror(eHuqrrpeAcraBneusofi pa6orsr.E[aseaHrae rroJrHocrbro orpa)Kaer KoMrrJreKc BtITIoJIHeHHrIX IrccJIeAoeaHufi.3arclroqertue. fivrcceprarlr{oHHan pa6ora Asapaxur Max6y6ex <<I4zyteuve ponl4rpaHcKpr4rrur4oHHoro Saxropa KNOX3 B rlpoqecce opraHoreHe3a r<ly6en;xoe 6o6onbtxpacreuafi>), npeAcraBJreHHa-[ Ha colrcKanue yuenofi crerenu Kann'Lrnara 6uoloruqecKl4xHayKno03.02.07 reHerLIKa, tBJl-{erc-l 3aKoHqeHHLIM HayqHor,rccJreAoBaHr4eM.
llo opuruHaJlbHocrl{, HoBI43He, AocroBepHocrl4cfrerlr4anbHocrLrxnaludurarlr4oHHbrMMarepr4anoun c$oprraynzpoBaHHbrM14 <fforoxeHu-s o [oprAKerrocraHoBJreHr4eMBbrBoganapa6ora coorBercrByer KpI4TepI4tM nn. 9-np[cy)KAeHr4fl yqeHbIX cteneHeft>>, yrBepnqeHHorollpanurelbcrBa PO or 24 cevrs6px,2013 r. J\b 842, npeab.sBJlteMblMAr4cceprarlnrrM Ha coucKaHue yvenofi crerreHl4 KaH1'Lrp:ara HayI(,Ka ee asrop AsapaxurMax6y6ex 3acJrylKlrBaerrIpI{cy)I(AeHI4.t{ 4Ka.OI4OJIO|I4qECKI{X HAYK fIO CTEUI4AJIbHXrecrruna Eresa I(oucranruHoBHaA.6,H., npo$eccop PAH,BprEo 4npenropa@egeparruoro rocyAapcrBeHHoro6roAlcernoro Ha) {Horo ) Ipex(AeHI4t<(De,4epanrurtfi uccleAosarerlclfl4fr IIeHTpB cepoccnft cxufi uncruryr reHeruqecKuxpecypcoB pacreuuft IrMeHIz H.LI.
Banulona>,yl, Eolrrlraq MopcKas, 42-44,Casnr-flerep6ypr,190000ren.: +7(8l2)3125161e-mail: director@vir.nw.ruCauxm-Ifemep6ypz, II uan2018ofi yu€uofi crerleHu KaHAI4Aarae.4.
Характеристики
Тип файла PDF
PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.
Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
