Отзыв на диссертацию (авт. Строганова Е. Н.) (Творческая эволюция Е.А. Нагродской в контексте идейно-эстетических исканий 1910-х годов)

Orslrs oQlrqua,rluoro onnoHeHTao Auccepraqr.rnJfto llsr Ha reMy<<ToopvecrcaRoBo.,'rrcqrrflE. A, HarpoqucofiB KoHTeKcreuAefiHo-3crerlrqecKr{xlrcrauufi 1910-xroaoB>,rrpeAcraBJreHuofina coHcnaHlreyveuofi creneHr,traugnqara$uno,rorlrqecKr{x HayK rro cfleqr{aJrLHocru10.01.01- Pyccrcan.r'rr{Teparypapa6ora J}o I4sr npnBJreKaernpexAe scero N4acura6,{raccepraqraouuarHocrbro 3aMbrcJra14r4crroJrHeHr4r. 3a6uroe Ha MHorue necgru erur I,I Bo3Bpa-qeHHoee 1990-eroAr,rrBopqecreoE. A. HarpogcxofiBnepBbrecraHoBr,rrcrHeTOJTbKOnpe.qMeToMcneuu€urbHoroB],:^r4Ma]Fvfl, Ho o6beKToM MHorocTopoHHeror4 TrlarerbHoro a]i'alrv3a,- yxe 3To .{aer ocHoBaHr4efoBop}lrb o HoytrHofr Ho6uJHe vcclreloBaHrlr. B cooreercrsr4l4 c 3atBreHHofi TeMofi TBopqecKat 3Bonrorlr4t nl4careJr6Hr4rlbrpaccMarprrBaercr B KoHTeKcre n4efiuo-rcreruqecKr4xpyccxofi Jrureparypbr19i0-x roaoe.

TnopvecrnoHarpo4cr<ofiAl4ccepucxa]P.ui,tTaHTKar{HTeprrperr.rpyerKaK op}ifnHaibHoe rBJreHr4e,yTBepxAar efo 3anpe-AenbHocrbMaccoBofi6ernerplrcrr.rxe,npeAcraBnesnofiuueHaur.rA. A. BepBbIBecrIrHaMepeHIreM6uqr<ofi,,II. A. 9apcr<ofr14rp.Aerop pyxonoAcrByerc.{uMq nzcaTerbHrrubr <r43cQepH npuua4JrexHocTl4K MaccoBoft KynbType I4 BnI4carb efo B napaAr4rMyMoAepHucrcKr4xr4nr4"nofpaHr4qHbrx" MexAy peanll3MoMacxauui XX crorerus)>(c.

6 anrope$epara).llpe4nplznmoeer{ MoAepHu3MorranepeocMbrcJreHrle14crop14Ko-nI4TepaTypHofrArrccepTarlrloHHoM rzccJreAoBaHrrr,rpenyTallvl4 nI4caTeJIbHLIUbIOIIpeAeJI{eTero oKmyu'xbHocmbLI HayvHyto SHaquMOCmb.fluccepraqzouuyrc pa6ory Jho I4Hr MoxHo rnanuQzqupoBarbKaKnpocrpofrHoe vccJieAoBaHve,Bce rJIaBbIKoropofo opraHl4qAyMaHHoe,Jrorr4qecKr,rHo cBff3aHr,ru esalrMogeficrByror MexAy co6oi. flepnau r:taBa nocnarqena QunocoocKofi npo6neMarr.rKeI4 xy.4oxecrBeHHoi aHTpo[oJIorI4IrpoMaHoB (fHeBu <3lue AyxI4>.Bo eropoil ruIaBenoKa3aHo,[uouuca>>,<V 6ponsonofiABepIr))<Eopr6a<6eraq KoJIoHHaAa),Harpo4ucofi (e porr,ranaxKaKB [porr3BeAeHr4txNarus nosecru o6uurpo6on>>,B paccKa3e<Asg> n uanltcasuoi n QoprraeOluir.rnuaAe-Aene)eonrorqalorc.s MacoHcKVeuneu nxcareJlbHltllbl. B rpe'rrefiM€UIat po3a, KoTopat paccMaTplrBaerfrraBe B rIeHTpeBHVMaHLI'OKa3bIBaeTCtC IIO3ITIIIIi TO|O,STIOXUct B cBr3r{ c uleiHo-xyAoxecrBeHHElMll TeHAeHIII,I'MI4xar y6eNgenu fl tr4carerbHnlrbl npeJIoMJI{Iorct B xyAoxecrBeHuofi crpyrrypeee npor.r3BeAeHI414.Bo nnegenuu, paccMorpeB oco6eusocrN Bocnpltltrl{t Harpo4cxofi e xpzTr4Ker.r Jrr4TeparypoBeAr{ecKl4eoIIeHKI'I ee rBopr{ecrBa, ,qvccepTaHTKa aprl4Kynl4pyer c Bofi LlccJleAoBarerbcKyro rlo3l,Iqt{ro.

B eeAeF{IaeHacbllqeHo Qaxruvecrulasa6rrc AeHr4r.Mr4,KoropEle Eo3xe noryqarorMarepvarJroM r{ niloAorBopsr,tvunoATBepxAeHIre B aHaJrI43eKoHKperHbIx npou:eegeuufi. B '{acrHocrz, KacafrcborHorrreHr4rHarpo4croii r< Qerlzurlauy, AlzccepraHTKacnpaBeAJlfiBonl4[ler oToM, irro $evuuucrcxue LIAeI4He BcerAano,'Iyqan[ [oAAepxKy B xeHcKofi rII4-2careJrr,croi cpeAe(c. 7 4raccepraqliu).B srou cMbrcJreMoxHo roBopr{rbo roM,uro Harpo,4cKa;rnpoAonxana rpaAr4rlr,rn,olpeAennBrxylocr yxe eo nropofinoJIoBuHeXIX s., xor4a Qenzur4crcKr{eycraHoBKr4Bbr3brBaJruy aBTopoBxeHrIr{H He ToJrEKOnOAIepXKy, HOrr OTTOpXeHr,re,BOBCSKOMCryr{ae -- Ha Bep6a,rr,nou ypoBHe (nara6oneeqpro 9To 3asBreHoB rBopqecrBe H. .{.

Xeourrancrcoft). O6nagaloqee 6orluruu HayqHbrMnoreHr-u4a!'roMBBeAeHr4eAeMoHcrpr{pyeT rrr[poTy r{cTopr]Ko-Jrr,rTepaTypHofoMbrirrJreH}rraBTopa,Ho HeKoTopbre3atBreullr BEr3brBarorBorrpocbl. Hanpl.rMep,Spara o roM, rITo KJIaccI4rIecKarIJIIITeparypa He nplreMner AUAaKTHKTTr,rHpaBoyqureJrr,Hororoua (c. 47 guccepraquu). Ho KaK B raKoM cnyqae 6url c KnaccuKoMII. H. Toncrrru? 3air.re.ryraxxe, qro $amuvecr<aa Hacr,ruleHHocrrnopofi oKa3brBaercrraa6rrrovnofi, TaK, HapacuupeHa nepcoHarbHar perlpe3eHTarlr4rrrucareJlbHlIIIrraofre:rrtr4., r43JrurrrHe- E. JlerKoeoii,3. funnuyc, A.

Mupe, Anuu Map, JI. 3aHoerecoBpeMeHHr4rIKoropar uoclrr pe$eparusHufisofi-AHHr,r6anr4 Ap. (c. 13*36 4raccepraquu),rrToyrueHululo 6u ia6urr coKparleHa,HecKoJrbKoxapaKTep14noToMyrr,ror:raqacrHocrl4,orruaBuoexe, o6ocuoeaHHocrbo6tev 4ltccepraquu.O4uaro 9ToqerJrHBo BbrpaxeHHofo HaMepeHI]{ BbrrcHrlTb, B r{eM 3aKrloqaJlocb x]'Aoxecr-BeHHoeHoBaropcrBo Harpogcr<oft, 14nepeolpeAeJllrrb Mecro IIucareJIbHIrIIr'IBlrarepa'rypuofi vepapxLru. 3ro craHoelzrct crepxHeM pa6oru 14oflpeAenterMr'Icnb. HaMe.{eHnaSoc nepecuorpa, crrrMynrapyroqui i4ccJreAoBareJlr,cKylopeanll3yercx r r<aN4ofru3 ruIaB.Har crparerl{r nocJreAoBareJrbHorBopqecKux ucxauuit Harpo4cxofi paccMarB nepnofi fJraBe ,qrrHaMrrKapr,rBaercr qepe3 coflpl4qacrHocrb ee BeAyrIrrM Iageiuo-xygoNecrBeHHblM TeHAeHur4rMCepe6p*roro BeKa: aHrepec K aHrI,IqHocrI4,yBrer{eH e $r,rnocoQrzefiK KoHllenquu O.

BefiHusre@. Huuure, o6saNeuue BonpocoBiIoJIa,BHuMaHI,Iepa, pacnpocrpaHeHuocrbSeuuHucrcxtrx noaapenrzfi.,{uccepraHrra BbItBJIternpoqecc ycBoeHl4t nLIcareJlE'HIlLIei pLlnr\vnvanbHblx ycraHoBoKcloxurrfior Hl,tx. Kax noxao orraIJtKI4BaHI4tu BMecre c reM noJ'IeMlrqecKofcI4MBoJrr43MasaHo e pa6ore, oco6euuo aKryaJIbH;I4rt Harpogcroi.r 6t'ntu Kareropuu anoJlJroHr{3Mau guouucuitcrBa? cBt3aHHbIec onno3llquei xpacorrt u 6ezo6pazun,4o6pa a ua.

B rax4oM LI3pa3AenoBrJIaBbIaHanlt3l4pyercs npeeMcrBeHHocrbpa3Brlrr4r sroft npo6rerraarl4Kl4or poMaHa K poMaHy, AI4ccepraHTKanpocnexl4BaeT, KaK aBTOpCKaf MbICJIT' BbIKpI4CTtUIJII,I3OBLIBaeTC'U [pOtBJIteTCtB XyAO-xecreeuHofi cl{creMe npou:ae4euufi .poMaHa<Y 6pousoeoii ABepI4>,Oco6oro BHuMaHIat3acJlyxlrBaer aHaJILI3roroprrfi paccMarpl4Baerct KaK [poAoJI)I{eHnepoMaHa <fuen .{uoHrtca>>.[uccepraHTKa cr{r.ITaer,r{To 3Aecb no-ApyroMy pa3BopaqfiBalorcl o6slrpauulte alepBoM poMaHe croxernrle Konntetrrr u 6olee orr{erJlrrBoaprl'IKyJrrrpyercr pa3Haqana.B poruaueguonUCufr,cxorou yTBepXAeHI4eaIIoJIJIOHI4qecKorOBeHrtaHrzeqeluiE KoMrIneKc[po<V 6pou:oeofi 4nepu> AeicrsurerbHo aKKyMynLrpoean6lerra, arrya.,rbHblx AJrt MoAepHr{crcKofr:loxu: aHAporuHHocrb, roMoceKcyB Bo3MoxHocrll coqrraJltHux npeo6pa:oaJrrHocrb,6esyuue, pa3orlapoBaHrresaluia u Ap., Ho o4uofi ur fJraBHI'IXtBJrtercq npo6lelra BJracrrl qeroBeKa Ha,qJr{eJroBeKoM.Pa-:suTue croxerHr,rx r<o,r:rzguiu n pa^:uoficrerreHr4nep6anusoBaHHarno3r4rll4tnepcoHaNeftBbttBJrr]orpa3HbteI4rrocracr4sroil eracru.

KaKoAHa r43$OpV nnacrra noKa3aHa eracrr, rro6ez - Ha 3TOMOCHOBaHLTOTHOrrreHr4'- Touu _ K ero Mareprr,a raKxeoAHofo rr3 UeHTpanbHbrxnepcoHaxefrporr,rauaorHorrreHl,Iei<Tonu ero cecrpbrMaprapurtr. z4eo:rorou Bjracrr4KpacorElrBJrrercr Touu, o6ragarorqafipegxocrlrofi xpacoroi r4 HareJreHHbrfi cunofi prrrflfr4BarbK ce6effoAeii n o6eopaNraeaGzx. oco6ofi Qopvoi B,[acrr.roK?3brBaerct xecroKocr6, I,rAeoJIofoMxoropoft BbrcrynaernepcoHax no Qarrfl{,rrzzcanynoe.

ToHr4pa3BeHqr4BaercrB AuccepralJr4r4KaK HOCIrreJIr,<6e:Hpancrneuuocrra>(c. 79).,ayaurrcpacr (c. 80), rro Br4HeKoropofo rrl6nyr apy.r" nrogn. llocJroBaMr4MeHHoveper o6pa: 3Tororepor B poMaHe[poucxoAr4TAr.rccepraHTKl,r,pa3BeHr{aHrze4nouzczfici<oroKyJrbra.Ho eoguoNuo n lpyroe flporlreHve [epcosaxnofr crrcreMbrpoMaHa.lyvaro, uro n pa6oreHeyAeneHoAoJrxHoroBHr4uauna o6pasy oxr4peBrrreroncen4o-Me$acro$e,r.aCa,nynona,roropufi nocloxery I4cnbrrblBaerrrllorc(oe BJrelieHr4eK Tonlt, Ha ugefinorr,rxe ypoBHe,Brqercr ero ceoeo6pasHrrrra4eoiiuuxov.

Bo eHexrHefirrporr4BorrocraBr'reHHocrr.tTosu z Ca,ryuoeaHaurAHo rrporBJrrercrorno3r4rluqKpacorbru 6ezo6pa_zut,xorq B cBoeM crpeMneHr4r4K Bjracrr.rHaA rpyfr4Mn oHu oKa3brBaro'rcg.6ttuzxu.rreM9To [oKa3aHo BO4naro, ua naofiB3r:rSL o6pa: Tonu MeHeeoAHo3HaqeH,pa6ore. lepoil rpe6yer qecrHocrr,rB orHorrreHr4rxMe)KAynroAbMr.r,qecreH r4rroorHollleHrlro x ce6e, npa3HaBar, r{To 14eMy He qyx(Aa xecroKocrb, TporareJrbHo3a6orr"tcr o xuBorHbrx, orBepraer [r']orcKy]o :uo6osr 14He [oHr.rMaer r4crr.rH-nofr npuuuutr BJrerreHr,r{K HeMy Canynoea u Bapapuua f apuoHra:lrpyrorqeearroJrJroHr4qecKoeHar{a;roe o6pa:e ToHz noAvepKHyro ero npeo6paNeHr.reueoBTopoi{qacrrr poMaHa:oH craJr cnoroi.rHee,cocpelorogeHuee, <colzgHee> (c.150 pouana).

Pa:pyuri.rrenrHoe iqr.roHr4cuficKoeua.{aro s 6ortIrref, creneHr4cBr3auo c 6esygepNnuM B cBorrx crpacrrx, BHyrpeHHeonycrorxeHHbrrraCany-HoBLIM,r<oroprrfi 3aMbrrrrJrrery6uficrno Tourz rar cpelcrBo o6lapauut uut,nogrrlrHeHrlr ero ce6e, T. e. B.[acrr4HaA Hr.rM.Orcyrcrnyorquit $uuast, roroprrfiTpaKTyercr n pa6ore KaK ((oco3HaHHoexyAoxecrBeHHoeaBTopcKoeperueHr{e)(c.77), HaBepHrKacn.sr 6u Morzpa3HofJracr4rc Ar4ccepraHrKofi.Cocpe4oroveHHocrb aBToparr4ccepraur4r,rHa xeHcrBeHHou o6pa:e ToHr'tyBoAur ee or oMyxecrBreHHoroo6pa:aMaprapnrr,r,B rroprperexoropoi axrleHTupoBaHbrMyxcKr{e qeprbr: ee Surypa <cxopei HaroMr{Haer}oHorxy, qeMa flpuqecKa<erqe6o:reenpr.rAaerei cxo4creo c M&'rbAeByurKy(c.

5 porraaua),qItKoM))(c. 6). B 3ToMpoMaHer4Haqe,qeM e ((fHeBelzouuco, pacnpeAeJrrrorct poJrr4Seuuuu:zponaHHoro Myxqr4Hbr rr MacKyJrfiHrr:upoaauuofixeHUIr.{Hr,r,so n pa6ore 3To ocraercs 6eg o6bscHenr4q.Hecuorpa Ha BbrcKa3aHHbreBo3paxeHlrs,cquraro HecoMHeHHbrM.qocrot4HcrBoMAucceprauuu aKryzrnr43arlulopoMaHa<Y 6pousoeofi ABepu) r4 ero op|AHI,ITIHOE BKIIOqCHHCB IiCTOPI4IO TBOPI{CCKOIOPA3BVL'II,', NUCATEJIbHIIIIbII,I BKoHTeKcruAefirio-screrur{ecKfix ncxa:e.uhpyccxofi nLrreparypbr 1910-x rogor.Oco6enno orMerry upe:erruafiHo rrHrepecHyrorpaKToBKyHa3BaHr{{poMaHa,Ko-4Topaf craHoBr'rrcr [oHrrHa ronbKo 6naro,qap.s14cro,uKoBaHr4roefo cr4MBoJrr4qe-cKoro cMr,rcJra.I4nrepnperupyx o6pa: 6ponaonoftABepr4,MoxHo 6uro 6u eqeo6parzrt BHuMaHr4eHa Aer€urb,Srarypnpyrollyro B reKcre poMaHa,- py6auu,yKparxarculr4e4nepr (c.

77 poxraua). BosuoNHo, o6palleuze K cr.rMBorrr{Kepy6una 4onomruro 6rr xouueutapuit K Ha3BaHuIopoMa'a 14ero Kmoi{eBoro o6pa3a.Pa:HocropoHue apfyMeHTxpoBaHHarvuc:* o6 orpr4rraHr4tn[careJlb'r,rqeil guouucui'tcKoro Har{ajrar{aKocHoBbrxr,r3HeHHoronoBe,qeHrrrnoryiraer nocJrelyrcqee pa3BI4Tr4eB aHaurH3euacoHcxofi ocHoBLree npor.i3BeAenuft.Bropa-apa60rrruanaoco6euso r{HTepecHa,noroMy qro 3recb creJraHanonrrrxa o6ua-(noAKnaIKy)ueJlofoprAa lpou3BegenzfiHarpo4cxofi.Hepyxrrrb MacoHcKyrorrro MacoHcKIze y6ex4euzx8613LrBaerCOMHeHIZT,nflcareJIbHr4rlt I npo{BLIJI14CbB- Ha 9To o6paurla BHr,rMaHr4epoMaHe <<Ee,ra-qKoJroHHa,qa>,A. M.