Отзыв оппонента 2 (Разработка квазиодномерных моделей гидродинамики и теплообмена двухфазных неравновесных потоков на основе универсальной системы замыкающих функций)

or3 brB o @ H rI r4A/lbHof o o il II o H E HTA HAKopunenrcoAHCCEPTAII14IOIopnn HurcolaeBrlqaPA3PAEOTKA KBA3ITOAHOMEPHbIX MOAEJIEfrrrrAP o ITIHAMITKI4 rr TETIJIO OEMEHA AByXOA3HbIXHEPABHOBEbHbIX TIOTOKOB HA OCHOBE YHIIBEPCATbHOIZCI4CTEMbI 3AMbIKAIOIUIX (DYHKUI{fr[peAcraBneHHyro Ha coprcKaHr4e yueuoft creneHl4 AoKTopa rexHI{rIecKI4x HayK IIocnequaJrbHocrr401.04. 1 4-TennoQnsura?rreoper?IrlecKat rerIJIorexHZKaAnrya.nrHocrb reMbI ArlcceprallrluIlpoerrrapoBaHze coBpeMeHHbrx HayKoeMKr{x gHeprerlrrlecKllx o6rerronHeBo3MolKHoBHacro.rrrrdee BpeM.rr6eg HaAexHbIX MeroAoB MareMarl4qecKoroMoAeJrr{poBaHvrfl.. OcoSoe 3HaqeHue MeroAbr MoAenI4poBaHUfl.pa3paooTKe rrpoeKToB, KoHcTpyprpoBaHLrkr14npzo6peraror rrpzcTpoLITenbcTBe cJIo)KHbIX3HeproHarrprxeHHux o6lexroB aroMuofi sneprerklK?I.

AHalug anapuit Ha pfl.IearoMHbrx DHeprerr4r{ecKr4x crallrlufi cBr4AereJlbcrByerqlrcJreHHofo [porHo3a pa3Br4Tarfl BHerrrrarHblx cl4Tya\nitnpoMbrruJreHHo pa3Br4Tbrx crpaHaxpa3paoaTbrBaloTc.rrrrcoseo6xoAptMocrllua A3C. llosrorrlyMoTTIHbIMLI sHeprerLIrIecKI{M}Ir{crroJrb3yloTc{ KoMMeprrecKue KoAbIno6terraurarlo MoAenI4poBaHLIIo,repMoru.{paBJrr4qecKr4x rrpoqeccoB B sJreMeHrax o6opy.uonalrtnfl,A3C. flpuuepavrznoAo6Hux KoAoB -flBrrrorcr qucJreHHbre KoMrIJIeKcbI RELAP,TRAC, HAKPA,COBRA, KOPCAP, ATI{LET n Ap. Kar upanrrJro-erooAHoMepHbre cr4creMblypaBHeHuit 6atanca Maccbr, r4Mnynbca r{ rerrJra AJIfl naposofi3aMbrKaHr4r4 cr4creMbrz xIaArofi$a":.llpuypaBHenufi ucuorb3yrorc.{ rroJrygMnlrpl4qecKue Sopiuynrt,[olryqeHHbre Ha ocHoBe o6pa6omu gKcrrepr4MeHTaJIbHbIX AaHHrIXaHarofr4qHbrx TeqeHr.{r4 krnvrr4ApoArlHaMrrKr,rrpolpaMMarr,rB pe3ynbTaTe Tpex rrvLr reurooSuenaB 4nyxSasHofiANSYS CFX, FLUENTuAnAAByxMepHbIX pacqeToBcpeAeIIoKoMMeprIecKI4Milp.

Bosl,roxHo coqeraHr4erroAXoAoBr4cnonrcyloulnx TpexMepHble pacqerblcoAHoMepHbIMI{ KoAaMI4'OCHOBH6IM I{OTSIIHI4KOM aBAp:aI4, npUnO,4ru1efiKiltnA3CT{XteJIbIM iloCJIeAcTBVIfrM)IIo AByXrBJrseTcq ttotal",TerrJroHocr4TeJrfl B aKTI,IBHOfi SOHe peaKTopa. Pac'{errtlITpe6yIoTTpexMepHbrM MoAeJrrM ryp6ynenTHofo Heu3oTepMplqecKofo TeqeHutcyqecrBeHHbrx peeypcoB KoMrrbrorepnofi TexHuKI4.llpnypaBHeHr4fi ryp6yneHTHOfO ilepeHoca r{Mnyilbca, reIIJIaeron'l tIpH 3aMblKaHrrvrI{ MaCCbI n 4nyx$asHrtxrroToKax TaKXe nCIIOJIb3yIoTc.fl oMnlIpurIeCKI{e QOpuymI, Halpl4Mep,rrprrcTeHoqHble QyHrquu, orrr4cblBaroql4e 3aryxaHl{e [apaMerpoB n6tuzurroBepXHOcT?I.Tpe6yrorcx TaKXe [onysMnl{pl4qecKue rI'InoTe3bI Orry3blpbKoB, KaIIeJIbyI Ap.pa3MepeI4cnolrsoBaHkrfl' cy[epMotIIHbIX KoMnbIoTepoBvrTIpI4BOAI4T K3Haqr4TeIbHOe BpeM.rI pacqeToB, vrcrlkrcIIfl.eMoe, KaK npaB.[^I.tO, Yrac,aMl4Bap[aHTaM'Heo6XoAI,IMocTI4 peAyIIZpoBaHkIfl.

cI'IcTeM ypaBHeHHfi r< oAnoMepHbIM3ra [poUeAypa KoppeKrHo pearr3yercf, IIyTeM ocpeAHeHl4fi TpeXMepHbIXypaBHeHl4fr rIO CeqeHI4IO KaHaJIa' IIpn ocpe,qHeHl4l4 Bo3pacraer lIpIcJIoIIOJIySMIII{pUqeCKI,IX |I{IIOTe3, I{CIIOJIb3yIOqI4XC'I1pv3aMbIKaIJIdVT OAHOMepHbIXcucreM ypaBHeHr{fi. Yclonr4e 3aMbrKalzrr. ypaBHeHl4fi ocpe4ueHvrs' no cerIeHI4IoKaHaJIaocHoBaHo:HafipeAnonoxteHl4llopaBHoMepHoMpaclpeAeIIeH|4utloroKa. ,{onepue I4HXeHepHororepcbi{ana oHeprerrrqecKrrx craHrlr4fi K pe3yJlbraraM pacqera rlo oAHoMepHbIMrrapaMerpoB AByXOa3Horo ryp6ynenrHoroKoAaM 6a:upyerc.rr Ha MHofocryleHqarofi BepI40I{KaII?1?I AaHHrIX MoAenr4poBaLrv[cr4Meroql4Mcr6anrougKclepr4MeHTaJIbHbIX ,qaHHbIX.

Korr'rruepuecK[eoAHoMepHbre KoAbr ocHoBaHbr Ha pa3AenbHoM orrucaHur4 rlapaMerpoB crlJlollIHort'vrMoAeJItrMA[crrepcHofi Sa:tr. Pearngarlvrfl, paorreroB rlo 3TI{M AByxxI{AKocrHbIMrpe6yer npnBner{eHl4t coBpeMeHHoro aililapaTa [pIaKJIaAHofi MaTeMaT?IKH.Hanpzvrep, pacqerbr HecrarllroHapHbrx Kone6areJIbHbIX ilpoqeccoB B AByxSa3HoMrroToKe ocHoBaHbr Ha MoAepHI,IsaWrr4 MeToAa PnuasaBo3MyIrIeHr{r rro pa3nr4qHbrM HanpaBJIeHI4.aM.cBbIAeneHI4eMB grolrn cnytlae BcefAaBOJIHBo3HuKaIorlpo6reMbr c ycrofiuuBocrbro r{LrcleHHbrx cxeM. Kpoue roro, qucJleHHble pacr{erblrro ABypKHAKocrHbrM MoAeJrrM B KaHaJIax cnolKHofi Soprrau, TaKHX KaK c6opKarAepHoropeaKTopa, trpeAcTaBlsroT rroKa HeperueHHyroupo6nevry.HrBenl4pyeTIrlcnonrgoBaHlae MeToAa <e$QerruBHoro AI'IaMerpa)BceB cflyr{ae cnor1tHoft reoMeTpl4ll'rrpeI4MyIIIecTBa AByXx{I4AKO9TH6IX aIIlpoKclIMaUI4fipealrnrle, [oTpe6Hocrr,l uHxeHepHofi [paKTLlKI4 rpeSyar 6onee rpocTblxTeOpeTI4tIecKuX MOAeJIefi, KOTopbIe MeHee Tpe6oBaTeJIbHbIKKoMIIbIoTepHbIM)Ke BpeMfl, AaIOTpecypcaM, o6na4aror qucneHHofi OTa6I,IIbHOCTbIO Lr B TO3TOfipe3ynbTaTbr, npeAcTaBJrsroul4e npaKTI4tIeCKI4fi I4HTepec.

,{ocruxeuuroaKTVnJrbHoft uenr4 rrocBrrrleHa AI4CCepTaI\lrfl'IO.H. KopnzeHKo. BilpeAJraraeTc-q uciloJlb3oBaHl4e ocpeAHeHHofi rlo KoHIIeHTpaIIIltMMoAenI4 sQser1unnofi roMoreHHofi cpeAbl.llpuAI',ICCepTaIIIIITFSa: o4uoMepHofrocpeAHeHI{I{ rpIIBJIeKaIorctKOHIISHTpaIMIT' 111HAKOftrronysMrrr4pr4rrecKr.,re afl11poKclrMarlu1a paclpeAe1Ie1vIfl'rrapoBofi $as IIo ceqeHuro KaHaJIa. 3roHepaBHoBecHocTtrBAaeT14BO3MOXHOCTb yqeTapacnpeAeJIeHIII{ flapaMerpoB Typ6yneHTHOrO TeaIeHI/ItAByx$a3Hofi cpeAbl.

[nsoAHoMepHbIX MoAenefiBoAHoxI4AKocrHoMrrpn6nux e1vI:n cyIqecTBeHHo yllpoqaeTct TeXHI{Ka pa6oTblcypaBHeHI{f,MIIyrleTa cnoxHofilastrluca Maccbl r4Mlrynbca r4 TeIIJIa. llo.flsJlsercfl BO3MOIKHOCTbCpeAbI'rcOMeTpr{r{ aKTLIBHOfi gOHrr Ha ocHoBe MoAenI4 IIOpIICTOfiMHOTOCBT3HOfiHO,TII4cJIO [OnySMIIlIpI4tIecKoficOBepIUeHHo ecTeCTBeHHO, BblpacTaeT14IIpllBJIeqb Ar;.flsKcrrepuMeHTulnbHofi I4HOopMaIII4I'l, KoTopyrc Heo6xoAIIMo3aMbIKaHut yp aBHeH uit' u B epI4sI4KaIII{I4 MOAenu'OcnosHaq Ilenb Hacrotlqero or3blBa BbrfrrpeAJlox{eHHofoBB14T6IIpeI4MyIrIecTBa I4 HeAOCTaTKLIMOAeJIefi HaAI4CCepTAWV MeTOAa IlonyqeHl4q OAHOMepHbIXocHoBe HHTerpaJIbHoro ocpeAHeHLIfl IIapaMeTpoB Su:"yrIeToM HeoAHopoAHocTI4pacnpeAeJreHr4fl rrapaMeTpoB Qa3 IIo ceqeHI4IO KaH€UIOB.Ha u 6o.n ee cyu ecrBeH H bIe rr p I'I H II rI rr rI aJr b H o HOBbIE HAYTIHbIE U IIPAKTIIIIECKI'IEpe3yJrbraTbl ALICCepTaIIUIIF flpe4logeHa1a1z4TprtlecKl{fi MeToA yr{eTa HeoAHopoAHocTI4 paclpe/4elIenvlflMe:roAcKopocrl{, TeM[eparypbl rr KoHIIeHTpauI4I4 Qa: no cerleHuro KaHanoB.I{CIIOJIb3YET CEMEfiCTBOyHI4BepcaiIbHbIXarfe6pal4qecKl4x3aBUCplMOCTefiorro3BoJrf,roruuxesQerrunuo yqrrbrBarb HepaBHoBecHocrb rypdynenrHororrepeHoca n geyxQa":nofi cpe4e.F flonyueHn yAo6nue l.nfr unNeHepnofr npaKrrKl4 BblpaxeHl4t AI7flroe$$r,rql4eHroB rerrlroorAaqu vI rpeHl4q B 4nyx$a":Hux ryp6yleuTHblxnoroKax rrpr4 K,pr[enuu.

lIpoBeAeH yrrer aHoMaJIbHoro pocra ruApaBnl{qecKoroconporr,rBJreHr{r r4 Tenlroo6vreHa n 4eyxSa:HbIX [apo)KI4AKocrHbIx IloroKax.)HepaBHoBecHbIo ';JIafionar{HrefpanoBooooqeHl{eIlpone,qeHoryp6yrenrHbre reqeHn.fl 4nyxQa:nbrx Kldn.aql4x ryp6yneurnux rloroKoBocHoBe yqera HeoAHopoAHbrx paclpeAerenrafi Bfl3KI4x HanprxeHultTerrJra.u rloroKoBllpe4noNenrr oSo6qeHr4r rr3BecrHblx lI3 nuTeparypbl coorHoutenzfi,yqlrrblBaroqzxo cpeAHeHHo e cKo JIbxeHI,I e $a:.flp egloNeH a o.4HoMep Harr rronyoMrrr4pr4rlecKa.f, oAHoMepHa.x MoAeJIb KvrrreHkrfl,Kplr3r4ca Kr{rreHu.f, c HeAorpenou.

MoAenb BHeApeHa B KoAbIHa ocnoseMoAeJrr,r fapMoHl4qecKoro ocIII4JIJIf,ToparpaHI{IIbr craruqecrofi neycrofiqusocrl4cr4cTeMe lIapof eHepupyloFHaqux14cuRELAP5, TRAC.rpeHHeM I4ccJIe,qoBaHbIHeycrofi.Iusocrl4 BoJIH rIJIorHocrI4BKaHaJIoB c noAbeMHbIMI4 yrIaCTKaMI4.flpe.qnolxeHo o6o6qenkre pa3pa6orasuofi aBTopoM AI4ccepraIII4Lt MoAeIrv HarerreHr4e n c6opre peaKTopa Ha ocHoBe npu6nraxeHvs. uopucrofi cpeAbl.Pesynumamut asmopct duccepmaquu ucnonb3oaaHupacrreTHofo KoAa AJrr MoAeJrr{poBaHr{f, rIepexoAHbIXnpuu aeapuitHblxyrorIHeHI4LlnpoqeccoB AJI'A3C B AO<<I4sxeuepHo-rexHu.Iecrnfi IIeHrp AX{ST) (Arcm euedpeuua).

B AO (TBOJI>ocHoBe pe3ynbraroB Al.dccepTalJvrvrKoprroparlrar4 POCATOM HarroirHoMacrura6uux rpeuaNepon vr cl4MyJlf,ropoB enepro6noKoBycoBeprxeHcrBoBaHn Srasuro-MareMarr,rqecKr4e MoAenH orpacneBblx o,{HoMepHbIXKoAoB, r{crroJrb3yeMbrx[nflnrr6opa KoHcrpyKIII4H vr oIIeHoK e$SeruunHocrl4rrpoeKrHbrx peureHr4fi, paztmuHblx BapI,IaHroB TBC ans BBOP-1000 n(A**BB3P-I200euedpeuun).4,[ocronepHocrb pe3yJlbraroB Al{cceprarlunHa I4cIIoJIb3oBaHuv,{ocronepHocrb pe3ynbraroB Ar4cceprall?It't 6asupyetcs.o6qenpuHqrbrx ypaBHeHr4fi 6atauca Maccbl, I{MrIyIIbca u sHeprl4ll B AByx$a:nuxryp6ynenTHblx noToKaX. Koppermrocm [onyqeHHblxpeKoMeHAar].lrfr"uoATBepx(Aaerc{ coilocraBJleHl4eMcB.qI4ccepTaIII4I{IxI4poKI{M cIreKTpoMSKCrrepHMeHTaJrbHbrx AaHHbrx, 3aLTMcTBOBaHHbIX I43 nHTepaTypbl I4 [OnyqeHHbIXnp1a yqracrvu aBTopa lr4cceprarlr{r4.

HenpornBopequBocrb reoperl4rlecKl4xuoloxenrafi lrnnrocTp upyeTcfl. B npeAeJIbHbIX cnyqa.sx coBrIaAeHI4eM co6rqeupu3HaHHbIMHpe3ynbraraMlr ApyrIIX aBrop oB'Crpynrypa AI{ccePTaIIrucilLlcKa,,{raccepraq}It cocToI4T I{3 BBeAeHI,If' ceM?I HIaB I'I 3aKlroqeHl4t,Jrprreparypu ug 328 Hal{MeHoBanuir' u flpunoxenufi.,{uccepraqr,rflHarru caHa JrureparypHbrM pyccKI4M t3bIKOM.Anropeoepar coorBercrByer reKcry Al{cceprallutr, orpaxaerpe3yJrbraru pa6oru, ee HoBur3Hyflo14ocHoBHbIerroJlolreHlr.fl, BbIHoc?IMbIe aBTopoM Ha 3aIrII4Ty.marepIIaJIaM AIIccepTaIIuIr ory6.ulrrconaHo ABaAIIarb ceMb pa6orperIeH3I{pyeMbIX xtypHanax I{3 cIIHcKaBAK, a raKxe IItrHaAIIaTr pa6orB ApyrlaxperleH3r{pyeMbrx xypHanax, cSopnuKax rpyAoB I4 re3l4cax MexAyHapoAHbIXpoccraficr<lx xon$epeuqnfi.

O6Uee rIHcJIo ony6nuroBaHHblxAr4ccepraryuu pa6orp oc-IIoS epLIreMeceMbAecrr. Peaylrrarbl AuccepraTlLrv o6cyx4anucbcufi cr?IX I4 M extAyH ap oAHrtx xoHBHaeHIIIltx.OcnonHat{ IIAes AlIccepTaqraOunoft pa6oru, no MHeHIIIO olIIOHeHTa,3aKrroqaercr B cJreAyroueM. Pacqerbr rpexMepHbrx 4nyx$asnux ryp6yJIeHrHbIXre.{eHlrfi B KaHaJrax rpe6yrcr pazBvrrvrfl. ir,loAeleft ryp6yneurHoro repeHocaAucrepcHofi Sa:u (nysrrprr<vvrvr<anru) B IroroKe xLIAKocrI{ vrnkr napa c yrleroMrIJIeHKI4 rlo creHKaM KaHaJra)Sa^:onrrx flepexoAoB, Terleurag.gectaSvtJlbHofi xraAxofiucKaxeHr4fl ryp6yneurHhrx [apaMerpoB TeqeHuflB npl{cyrcrBllu 4ucnepcuofi$a":rr.

KpovleroroBo3HrrKarorr43MeHeHr,rf Ar4crrepcHoroupoSreurt,cB.f,3aHHbIecMoAenI4poBaHLIeMcocraBa nprlMecl{. floerouy, roBopLITb o 3aKoHqeHHocrI4MaTeMaTI4IIecKLIX Tr,TO.4EICfi, ONI4CbIBAIOqI{X NPOqECCbI KLTTIEHI4f, B KAHAJIAX BO BCEM:Ar4ana3oHe r43MeHeHLr{ ilapocoAepxaHkIfl, B HacTotlqee BpeMt npe}KAeBpeMeHHo.B roxe BpeMr Heo6xo4raMo orMernrb, tITo s Hau6oree Bepo{THoM cIIeHapI4I4aBap47;4 Ha A3C, cBfl3aHHbrM c rrorepefi rennoHocl4TeJls., rrpovcxoAl4T nonnsrfiur4KJr rlapooopa3oBaHI{tTeIJIOHOCVTeITfl.B KaHaJIaX aToMHOfOgucregnas peanv3apfl.

yxe cyilIecrByIoIrIHX rpexMepHblxpeaKTopa.rr,roAenefi rpe6yercyqecTBeHHbrx 3aTpaT IlpoqeccopHofo BpeMeHI4 pI IIpeAbtBIIteT IIOBbITeHHbIerpe6onauu.ar 6rrcrpoAeft crszlo KoMrlblorepoB.Ocpe,4Henue rro cerreHr4ro KaHaJra ypaBHeHl4it lwruuca Maccbl, uMnyJlbcasHeprr4pr14upn ryp6yJreHTHoM TerreHrll4 cnlrollrHoit u avtct<pernofi Qa:, rauucaHHblxB Ar4BepreHrHofi Sopue, npr4BoAr4r K oAHoMepHbIM ypaBHeHl{rvr 4nyxSa3HororroroKa c oAnopoAHofi rro cerreHr4ro KoHueHTpawtefi. xI4AKocrI4 vr ilapa. BocpeAHeHHbre ypaBHeHrafl ecrecrBeHHbrM o6pasovr BKJlroqarorct fpaHI{rIHbIeycnoBr{r Ha rroBepxHocrrr KaHaJra.oMnr{pruecKyro ransopuaqraroobBypaBHeHHt Heo6xoAutvto BKrIorII4TbQa:onrx repexoAoB vrxuAroft vr 4racrpernofi Qas, a[HreHcIaBHocrIaren4oo6ueHa Ha MHorocssguofi noBepxHocrl,ITaKXe cuJrbr rpeHr{f, MerIc4y 4racrcperuofi kr cnnoruuofi cpe4ofi.npeue6peqb r,r3MeHeHZeM AlrclepcHoro cocraBa AucKpernofinpoqeccoB KoaryJrflrJuvr[aNeecJII{B pe3yJrbrare$a:rru 4po6leHr{f, KaIIelrb r4Irkr rly3blpbKoB, To ueo6xo4ziuuor{eHKE rrpeAenbHbrx AlraMerpoB KarreJrb znl4 rly3blpbKoB n rypSyneHTHoM IroroKe.Bcrtyqae AucnepcHo-KonbueBoro pexrMaconp{}KeHHar MoAeJrb rerreHr4q xruAKofi nnenruTeqeHr4f, rpe6yerc-a raKxez 4nyxSa:Horo IIoroKa KaTIJII4-nap.