Отзыв оппонента 2 (Разработка квазиодномерных моделей гидродинамики и теплообмена двухфазных неравновесных потоков на основе универсальной системы замыкающих функций), страница 2
Описание файла
Файл "Отзыв оппонента 2" внутри архива находится в папке "Разработка квазиодномерных моделей гидродинамики и теплообмена двухфазных неравновесных потоков на основе универсальной системы замыкающих функций". PDF-файл из архива "Разработка квазиодномерных моделей гидродинамики и теплообмена двухфазных неравновесных потоков на основе универсальной системы замыкающих функций", который расположен в категории "". Всё это находится в предмете "технические науки" из Аспирантура и докторантура, которые можно найти в файловом архиве НИУ «МЭИ» . Не смотря на прямую связь этого архива с НИУ «МЭИ» , его также можно найти и в других разделах. , а ещё этот архив представляет собой докторскую диссертацию, поэтому ещё представлен в разделе всех диссертаций на соискание учёной степени доктора технических наук.
Просмотр PDF-файла онлайн
Текст 2 страницы из PDF
flogo1sas. uAeoJrorr{f MoAeJrr4poBaHvrfr 3aJIo}KeHa B KoMMeptIecKIrIX rlaKeraxrr4traRELAP u Ap.Cyrqecrnyer anbTepHarunnrrfi cnoco6 repexoAaKoAHoMepHoMyupn6nrNeHr4ro Arrfl orrvcaHtrfl. ryp6yneHrHblx 4nyxQasuux reqenrafi. EcnucJroxr4Tb rpexMepHbre ypaB*envrfl, 6wrulnca Maccbl,gHeprlltlhllMrlynbca6ucrrJlorrlHoit,gucxerHoft Sae,rorraeN$a:nbre cJlaraeMble, cBfl3aHHble cI4naMLITpeHr4r nanrex$a:uofi rpaH?rrle, Sa:onrrvu [epexo [avtur na rraeN$agHofi rpaHl4rler4cqe3Hyr.BsroN,r cnyqae rtonyqarcTct rpexMepHble ypaBHeHI4s.6wlattca Maccbl,3Heprr.ru ra ranruynrca eQ$erruIeHofi roMoreHHofi cpe4rt B AI4BepreHTHoM BuAe.llocneocpeAHeHr,rs[onf{eHHbrx ypaBHeHI,Ifi B rouoreHHoM npu6nuxeHl{I4 rloceqeHl4lo KaHaJIa, [pLIxoA?IM K OAHOMepHbIM ypaBHeHI4f,M' B KOTOpbIXecrecrBeHHblM rryreM yqlrrbrBarorc{ rpaHur{Hble ycJIoB}Ig Ha oNnrreaeN'IofirroBepxHocrz.
llolyrreHHar cucreMa ypaBHeHl4fi He saluKHyra. Tpe6yercfl' 3HaHvrepaclpeAeJreHr4.rr KoHrleHTparyufr"Sa:.CKOJIbXTEHH'rroceqeHl,Irc KaHaJIa, cKopocrl4 ocpe.4HeHHoroKoru.{ecrso oMnupl{rlecxofi unSoplvraqnn, KoropylooroMy rIoAXoAy Sn:z'recxoro cMbIcJIaueo6xoAuMo rrpgBJreqb Aflf,npvr1Lalnvrfl,MeHbrrre, rreMrnrra RELAP.BMoAeJr.ltxBHe[vcceprarlrzz npeAJraraerc-fl pflAyflpoqeHHbrx roAXoAoB An.f, 3aMbrKanvrfl. oAHoMepHbIX MoAelefi n roMoreHHoMupu6nux envr4 Ans np oqe ccoB KI{IIeHVfl n ryp 6yleHTHbIX IIoToKaX.flperanryrUecrBa oAHoMepHoro roMoreHHoro onLrcaHlrfl.
oqeBI4AHbI - 3Torrpocrora rrprcJreHHofipea.rrrE: arJkrvr,HarlpuMep, MoxHo I4crloJlb3onam SopMyJIbITr4na fIafioua, rBJ1xroqr4ec.f, rrepBbrM HHTefpaJroM ypaBHeHI4Te[JrA.B ,qr4Beprenrsofi @Opvre. KpOrraenpoBoAI4Tb pacrlerblorreMeHraxnpocToTa ypaBHeHI'Ifi nognolsercroNuofi reoMerplll,I-fl3V c BB3P. fonaorennufi uoAxoArrpr4MeHeHvrfl11Brofo,fi 6 atauca LIMnyJIbca LIKaHarIoB peaxropnoft 3oHbIBrIpeAHa3HarIeH Anf, l4mreHepHoroHa cra1vrpr paspaSorKl4, TpeHI{Hra ilepco*ura I4 3KcrlJlyara\w A3CApyrl4x o6teKros c MoITIHbIM TelJIoBbIAeneHI'IeM.O6sop coAepxaHuq AuccepTallrruBoBBeAeHrrr{ o6ocnosaHa aKTyanbHocrb Auccepralluonnofi pa6orrr, eeHAyqHAfl, HOBI{3H a, IIp aKTI4qellponegeHcKatIIeHHo cTb IIOnyTIeHHbIX p e3ynbTaTo B.aHarryr3 coBpeMeHHorococrofHlz{ TeopernqecKzx l{ccJleAoBatruitB rpexuepnofi nocraHoBKe rrpoqeccoB IIaApoAI{HaMIaKH I{ TelrJloMaccoo6ueua4nyxSasHux ryp6yneHrHblx rroroKoB B KaHaJIax cloxnoft reoMerpl{[,7xapaKrepHofinocTaBJIeHbIAm oJreMeHroB -fl3y c BB3P.
OSocuosaHa aKryaJlbHocrb reMbl'qenn V 3aqaqn pa6oru. CQoptuyll4poBaHbl 11ayv6ae' HoBlI3Ha,npaKTHrIecKa-'I IIeHHOCTbAOCTOBepHOCTb pe3yIIbTaTOB ALICCepTaT\ukI'pr1IIOJIOX{eHLIq, BbIHOCLIMbIe Ha 3aIIII4Ty'B rtepBofi rJIaBe paCCMOTpeHbI coBpeMeHHbIeMoAeJrr{poBailkrfl. TypSyJreHTHbrx AByxoa3HbIX TerIeHI4fir{HTeHc?IBHbIX TeIIJIoBbIXBMeTOAII qplc;teHHoroKaHaJIaXB ycnoBl{txHalpy3oK I{ cKopocTHoft HepaBHoBecHocTIl' lIpeAcTaBJ,IediloxHblfi O6SOp, B KOTOpbIfi BKlIor{eHbI KaK MeTOAbI nptMoroqncneHHoro MoAenupoBaHvrfl. Typ6yleHTHocTI'1, TaK vr MeToAbI ocpeAHeHHbIX.IOoTaTOTIHOypaBHeHufi Hasre-Crorca14TenJroo6ueua.Olncauu o6teKrzsHblerpyAHocrl4,Bo3HuKaroque rp?r 3aMbrKaHuI{ cl4creMbl ypaBHesufi SataHca Maccbl I4MnyJIbca3Hepfr4r4 B Typ6yJreHTHbrx TerreHuqx [apoxI4AKOCTHbIX IIOTOKOB.kIcAelan o6:opHeKoropbrx 3aMbrKaHr4fi, yqt4TblBaror{I4x B3auMHoe Blrr4flHr4e Al4cKperHofi LrHa npoqeccbl ryp6yneHrgoro 1lepeHoca.
lIpe4craBJIeH o6sopcnnorxHofiSa:coBpeMeHHbrx 3aAarr MoAeJrr4poBailkrfl. OHJIbHO HeCTaIII4OHapHbIX npoqeccoBryp6yneHrHbrx AByx$a3Hbrx rroroKaxOuucauaBrpexMepHofiuTAByxMepHofi rlocraHoBKe.nocTpoeHl{{ ocpeAHeHHbIX IrO CeqeHHIOI{AeoJIorl4flBKAIJAJJAJaTerIJIa I4 l4Mrlynbca, zcrIoJIHyeMbIXAByXXIIAKO CTHbIX yp aBH eHI4I4 rrepeHoca MaccblBKO,IIAX TVIIARELAPVICATHARE. Ouucanrr cilolKHocrl4 3aMbIKaHutcJlaf aeMbIX, yrrr4TblBaronryrx Mex$ a3Ho e83al{MoAefi crBI.{ e B 3TI4x KoAax.@oprvrynupyercf, I,IAeoJIorI4f, oAHoMepHbIX ocpeAHeHHbIX ypaBHeHl4fi AntgAHOXI4AKOSTH9TO npl46nl,lxte1vlg.gKcrrepuMeHT€LIIbHbIeVTeOpeTLIqeCKI4e3aM6IKaBIIIIaX BbIpaXeHI,IfiOnucrrnarOrcs Heo6XoAnMbIeI4CCJIeAOBAHvIfl' AIIfl IlonyqeHl4tV pacilpeAeneHl4fi Anfl BbIBoAaypaBHeH[ft'[pr4MeHuMbrx B rrurpoKofi oSracru rl3MeHeHLIfl pexI4MHbIX [apaMerpoB pa6orblpeaKropoBcKonblceHI4flA3C.14 HIlpe,4cranneu a1atrvr3 $opnryr 1rrfl yqera Mex$a3HofoeoAHop oAHo cTI4 p acilpeAe Ile:avIfl.
KoHIIeHTp al1au ra3oBofi $ a":u uocer{eur4ro KaHaJra. PaccuorpeHbr rroAxoAa AJIS orrvcalelvrs. ceqeHl4fi Mexrpy6HoronpocrpaHcrBaBaKTr{BHofi 3oHe peaKTopa. OuucaH MeroAB paMKax MoAeJII4nopncrofi cpeAbr Anfl yqera MHorocB;rsHofi noBepxHocrz rpy6 n c6opxe rBsJIa.Bropan .fJraBa rrocBrrrleHa olucaHrllo Mero,qurta srr6opa KoppeKTI4pyIorIIHXpacnpeAenevufi, c rleJrbro yqera Heo,qHopoAHocrla rlapaMerpoB B ceqelIldkr Kallaila.CropocrHoe cKoJrb)KeHr4e Sa: yuurblBaerc.r Ha ocHoBe sMll,Ipl4qecrofi Qopnaymllo cKopocTl4 BcIIJIbITIIf, IIy3bIpbKoB vI cKopocT?I BrITaHI4fl KarreJlb. AnxKoppeKrr4poBKH paclpeAeleHufio6leusofiKoHueHTpaIJvIuucIIonb3ylorq.'IcreneHHbre arrlpoKcr4wa:Jvrr4. Bu6op xapaKTepHoro pa3Mepa ny3blpbKoB I4 KaleJIbpe€rnq3yercfl, Ha ocHoBe rroJrysMrrrapl4rlecKl,Ix Sopnryn.prA JIeMM OCIIMMeTpI4TTHOCTI'IQa:. Jleuurr tBrqrorcf, orpaxeHl4eMs, 6anasca cyMMapHoro pacxoAa 4nyx$a:nofo noroKa B crarll4oHapHoMcnyqae.
llpunleueHr4e rpyAoBaHaJr1r3y,AoKa3aHpacnpeAelre:nvrs. pacxoAHblx o6relrlsrrxKoHrleHTpaguit ra":osofi 14 xuArofiypaBHeHr4Bo nropofi rnaneA.H.KomraoropoBarloQyuxquoHanbHoMyB KarrecTBe apryMeHTa KoppeKTHocTLI JIeMM He o6ocnoBaHo. llpoee4eHrpa$rauecrIEfi a*aurvrs napaMerpoB pacrpeAeJleHllfl geyxQa":Horo noroKa AnfBbrrryKJrbrxLr BorHyrbrx npo$nneft HcrI4HHoro o6tevsoro [apocoAep)KaHl{fl.Ilpe4craureHbr orIeHKr4 cKopocrrl BoIJIrITTI{ naponofi Sasn. 06cyx4aerc.rnro4ra$3rrca\yrfl.
rrporleAypbr ocpeAHeHr{rcpaBHeHr4a c KpyrnofirocerreHuro KonblleBoro KaHaJIa rlorpy5ofi. llpe4JroxteHa MoAenb?I3 AByx KoHIIeHrpI4rIecK?IXKonerd Anf, pacflpeAeneHr,rr sHTiurbrrlrr4 cpeAbl B cJlyqae KI4IIeHufl, C HeAofpeBoM.lloly.reHa npeAenbHbre nepexoAbr K rr3BecrublM I{3JII4TeparypbI pa3AeJIeHI{.f,M3HT€UIbIII4I4 IIO CeqeHLIIO KaHaJIa.B rperbe rJraBe paccMarpvBaerefl. o6o6uleuue MeroAa ocpeAHeHl4f,,npeArro)KeHgoro B AHccepTaIIuu, Ha roeQSuqI4eHTbI TpeHus, TenJIo- vtuaccoo6ir,reHa [pr4 Kr4rieHr4r{ n ryp6yneHTHbIX rloroKax. B ne6onbllroM o6sopeo6cyN4aercr KoppeKTHocrb rpaAr{eHTnofi ruuore3bl An{ 3aMbIKaHI4{ rloroKoBMaccbr, TerrJraurrMrrynrca.
Bso ilvrrafl, rroHtrlte oSo6ulenHoro an$QyrvoHHoronepeHoca r4 rroHf,Tr4e Soprvr-SaKropa pacrpeAerreHufl., @opnl-$aKTopbl orpaxalorMepy BrrtrflHkrfl, paArlaJrbHo pacrpe4erdunrrx e$Qercroe oSo6qeHHbIX MaccoBbIXcr4Jr B KBa3uo.qHoMepHofiKaH€LJroBMoAenz. PaccuorpeHo rlocrpoeHne Sopnr-QaxropoB AJIIKoJIbIIeBoro ceqeHl4q. llpe4cranJleHblKOHKpeTHyIO feoMeTpl4rc pacnonon{eHLrfl. KaHaJIOBTeuIoBbIAeJIf,tOSopuynu,ylrr,rrblBarolrlueTerrJroHocrTerrs.B c6opre.-IrIHX CTepX{HeI4.B uerneprofi rJraBe HafiAeHHsre Ar{ccepraHToM Qopvrynu rlo BJII4-aHI4IoHeoAHopoAHocrr{ paclpeAerrentrfl. rypSynenrHblx rapaMerpoB B 4nyx$a:norr,rrroroKe rrpr4BJleKalorct Anfl coIIocTaBJIeHI4t OTHOCUTeJIbHbIX aarOUOn,ronyrleHHbrx B paSorax Apyrlrx aBropoB. B pe3ynbrare ananvsa nonyqeHblSopnaynrr, orHocr4TeJrbHbrM odpa":ou yqurbrBaroullle BnLIf,HLIe reoMerpl,Ila KaHaJra,MaccoBbrx cvJr) KoHKpeTHofo pacilpeAeJreHl4.fl [apaMeTpoB TypoyneHTHbIX4nyx$a:Hbrx rroroKax.
CAenan BbrBoA o roM, rrro Arq [onyqeHl4r Qoprvrynbl AJIIAaHHoro 3aKoHa [epeHoca neo6xoAzMo r4Merb ran$opvraqvrcopacnpeAeJleHl4flxrrJrorHocrl4, MaccoBofi cropocrr4, [JrorHocrll rloroKa IrepeHocl4Iraofi cy6cranIJvrv\ araKxre o roeS$urlr4eHrax ryp6ylenrHoro rlepeHoca.flpe4craueHaHaJrr43 pa3rr,rrrHofi SopvrynlrpoBKl4 aHaJIorI4I{PefiHolr4ca,yqr4TbrBaroqrafi oco6eHHocrrz pac[peAerreHr4fl.
KoHIIeHTpagufr, no cerreHl4lo KaHaJIan ryp6yneHTHoM rroroKe. B srofi xre rJraBe coAep)Karc.f, coBeplxeHHo HenoHtrHbleu nehb4rBepxAeHHbre HuKaKr4Mr{ cneAcrBnflMpr<o6o6qeHHbrxpcr,rJrax>).acrp eAe rrenus.Ko HIIeflpe4cranJreHLr3ypaBHe:euit GataHca BbIBo.{rt o6aHaJrLr3 BIrvrflH:zrfl, rpaBurraL\krvrHrp ar\vr4 Ia roe S S NIII4 eHr rp e HLII.B erofi xre rJraBe pa3B:aTa AByx3oHHa{ MoAenbTpeHHrr rerrJroo6naena 4nyx$a:nnx ryp6yJreHrHblxAns,pacqera roe$Suql4eHroBrloroKoB.Ha rrpeArroJloxteHl{e, rroATBepxAeHHoe 3Kclepr{MeHToM,cr,urbHo HeoAHopoAHoe paclpeAeJreHr,re KoHrIeHTp arJI4kIMaKcrlMyMoMua npo$vlmze6rusz creHKLr. 3ro flBrqercf, errle3Mnr{pnqecKoro xapaKTepa pa:nunaeuofi Teop:zrnycraHaBJrvrBaercfl rpaHr4rla,B xoropoftMoAell orlupaercso ToM, qTo cyqecTByeTrlapallo ceqeH[IoKaHaJIa coAHI4M noATBepx(AeHIdeMI4s reKcra HeBHAHo, KaKpacrroJrolKeH MaKcI4MyM KoHrIeHTpaIIrII4naponofi Sa:u.
llpegnonaraercs, rrro sTor gMrtupuqecxufi [apaMerp rlo nopr,{Ky10BeluqHHbI coB[a.qaercpa3MepoM orpbrBHoro rry3brpbKa. flosnlf,rorctSMnI4pUqeCKI4e rrOHfTHf, (ny3brpbKoBAfl IUepOXOBaTOCTb), (KarreJrbHattuepoxoBaro.l:rr, llpe4craureHo yAoBnerBopr4reJrbuoe coruracr4e pacr{erarroc gKcrrepuMeHT€rJrbHbrMrr .qaHHbrMrr roeS$uqr4eHTaH r{I4cJIa.
Cranrona Knrr{qero rroroKa B rpy6ax. llpe4noxeuoIroJlyoMnl,Ipuuecrofi MoAeJrr,rTpeHu-aaHarorl{qHoe BblpaxeHr4e Anfl 3aKpr{3r4cHoro renroo6veHa, KorAa B rroroKe napaMeJIKIze Ka[JII4.VrnepN4aerc ,, qro Kanrn ryp6ynr{3r4pyror rroroK u yBenr4qr{Baror,roeQ QuqLreHT conporlrBJrenr4fl.Ocralruas qacrb rJraBbr, rro MHeHkIIo oilrroHeHTa, He coAepxr4TKoHcrpyKrrzsHofi IaH$opuarlvrr4, a flBrrflercfl cno6o4nofi Qanra:uefi o nceo6rqefiB3auMocB-a3I4 JIoKaJIbHbIX14HeJroKaJrbHbrxssreuuir n ryp6yneHTHbrx re.reHusx. KTeMe ApICCepTaIIUI4 3Ta IIaCTb TeKCTa He UMeeT Hr{KaKOfO OTHOITTeHT{f,.B nsrofirJraBe paccMorpeHbr MeroAr4KLr noJrygMrrr4praqecKoro pacrrerarenloo6uesa rerlnorl4ApaBnr4qecKr4x xapaKTepI{crI4KKI4IIeHHLIcTerrJroHocr4TeJrf, rrpuHeAorpeBoM.
Ilpe4crauleHa KJlaccl4r{ecKa.fl cxeMa SopvrnpoBa:nvrflo6nacrefi KurteHl{.flg.krcceprar\r4LroraB crrMMerprlrrHoMKaHane 6eg yrrera MaccoBbrx cr4Jr. B3aAarra petuaercfl. Ha ocHoBe [onygMnlrpr{arecKoro nog6opapacupegeJleHl4f, naponofiz xIa4rcofi Sa:. CnaraeMbre, olr4cbrBaroulr4e paAr{alrnufiIrepeHoc ycpeAHf,Iorc.a tro ceqeHI4ro Kanarra c yqeroM nu6pannofi anupoKcr{Mauur4pacnpeAeJleHl4r napa. llpegcranJleHa 3aMKHyrar Ha ypoBHe rronyoMilHpr4qecKuxcoorHolrler.nrt, zauMcrBoBaHHbrx r43 nlzTeparypbr, pacqernafl, MoAeJIb KI4neHr4r cI,lcuonr:yercr AByx3oHHafl annpoKcLrMarlrrf, pacnpeAeJreHr4tKoHueHrparJvru naponofi Qasrr. llpe4craaneHa 6ror< cxeMa .rracreHHofiHeAorpeBoM.nporpaMMbl.BIUI{poKoM Al{ala3oHe pe}KrrMHbrx napaMerpoB npoBeAeHocorIocTaBJIeHI4e c gKCrrepUMeHTaJrbHbrMr{ AaHHbrMr4 rro paclpeAeJreH}rro r4cTr{HHofoo6reuHoro[apocoAep]KaHr4.rrrroAJr]rHe DKcrrepr4MeHTzrJrbHoro yrracrKa crrocrotHHofi uroruocrbro rerrJloBoro rroroKa.11'..B urecrofi rraeeKo.rIoB rvrrra[peAcraBJreHbr pe3ynbraru nepvSnKarII4I4 KoMMepqecKI4xTRAC z RELAPS sa recroBblx Bapualrax re-reHlafi.
