Отзыв оппонента (Методология повышения энергетической эффективности систем электрооборудования автотранспортных средств), страница 5

..215).npl4npOBeAeH?II4t4Bo nropou rroArryHKre (5.3.2) rperberoypaBHeHr4f, perpeccBuu (crp.2lpa3Aena n.f,roii rJraBbr npr{BeAeHbr| ...212).rperbeM rroAnyHKre (5.3.3) rperbero pa3Aena usrofi rJraBbr rrplrBeAeHaH€LnI43 Blt;krflHtrfl rlacrorbl BpaIrIeHH.rr reHeparopa Ha oSoporax xoJrocroro xoAa.[nrararel.a asroN4o6l,Irts Lr ypoBHq perynr4pyeMofo HarrprxeHr{f, HaBenI{qI4Hy MaTeMarrrrlecKofo o)Kr4IAHr4fl HanprrxeHl4.rr Ha npr{eMHr{Kaxe{eKrpr4rrr:crcofi oHeprr4r4 (crp.2 12...2I4).IlstasrJIaBa rlocB.nnleHa pa^:pa6orr<e reoperr4r{ecKr4x ocHoB co3AaHHtsS@errunruux npI4HIII4rIoB ynpaBneHr4r, o6ecre.ruBaurlr{x rroBLrrrreHrle3arel efi cucreMbr 3Jr e KTpoo 6 opy4 o BaHutt ATC .Zccne4onaHzre [pI4HrII4tIoB ynpaBneHrrf, Ha[p-rr]KeH?reM reHeparopHofiHepf err4rre c Kr4x rroKa3ypraHoBKlr rIpoBoAI{JIocb c rIoMoIIIbro MareMauaqecrofi MoAeJt.r{, pa":pa6orannofi uorucaHHoft n rperuefi rrtase Al{cceprarJvrkr.

Aualug pe3yJrbraroB r4ccJre4onanufirloKa3blBa,or, YTo uau6oree [epcrIeKTHBHbrM Anf, cHr4xe:rrvrfl. pacxoAa rorrJrrrBa r4ttbt<cu'ttto,ctu Of tBJlflIorct cuoco6rr, HanpaBneHHbre Ha r{HTeJrJreKTy€LnbHoeynpaBneH.ae Halp.slKeHI,IeM reHeparoptrofi ycraHoBKkr B 3aBzclrMocrr4 orHanprxeHr4f, aKKyMynsropHo ir 6 at ap eu.flsrax rnaBa Ar4ccepraquonnofi paooTbr 3aBeprxaeTcrr 3aKIroqeHLreM prqacrHbrMzr BbrBoAaMz (crp.

2I5 ...217).B urecroii uaae colIcKareneM rIpLrBeAeHbr pe3yJrbrarbr p€Bpa6orr<v [pr4HrlrrnoB3J[eKTpocua6Nenux, o6ecnequIBaloulux rroBbrlrreHr{e rorrJrtrBr]rofi erouol,rr{qHocrr{aprorpaHcnoprHbrx cpeAcrB (crp.218...26I).B rIepBoM pa3Aene ruecrofi rJIaBbr (6.1) o6ourosaH nu6op He3aBucr4Mbrxnep eM eHHbrx o rp aH u'retrwiT. ra qeleuo fi Qynrcqurz (wp .2 | B . .

.222).Bo nropoM pa3AeJIe (6.2) eroft rJIaBbr npr,rBeAeHbr pe3yJrbrarbr paspa6orruCucreurt gJIeKTpocna6xenz.s c qacrr4rrHo orrrr,rMr43r{poBaHHbrM €rJrroplrrMoMpa6oru (crp.222...223).B rpe'meM pa3AeJIe (6.3) ruecrofi rJraBbr npLrBeAeHbr pe3ynbrarbr ucrrsrrauuircl4creMbl gneKTpocHa6xegu.s c qacrl4qHo orrrI4Mr{3HpoBaHHbrM €LnropIuITMoM(crp.223.."227). B uerneproM p€l3Aere (6.4) ruecrofi rrraBbr nprzBe,qeHa MeroAr4KaHPnpephlBHoro olpeAeneHl{.a crelreHr,r 3apf,xreHHocrr4 aKKyMynfropnofi larapeuBo BpeMf, ,IBrzx{eHlrs ATC (crp.227...243).Bu.f,t,oN4 pa3AeJIe (6.5) ruecrofi rJraBbr npr4BeAeHa MeroArrKa HerrpepbrBHor.ooupeAeneHr4.s cTerreHlr 3aprxeHHocTr4aKKyMyJrmopnofi 6arapeu Bo BpeM.flATC (crp.243 ...25 5).B urec;rola pa3Aerle (6.6) urecrofi rJraBbr nprzBeAeHbr rrepcleKTrzBbr pa3BzTufl.cI4creM SJIeKTpocna6xenr.rs aBTorpaHcnoprHbrx cpeAcrB, o6ecne.ruBaronlr4xcHrDr{eHr4e pacxoAa'rorrJrr4Ba Ha npr4BoA feHeparopa (crp.

2 5 5 ...26 I).TTTecreu rJIaBa rlocB.f,IrleHa pa":pa6orr<e [pr4HrlurroB, o6ecne.rzBaroquxApr4xeHprr:cnoficra cucreMbrQyurqzoHeurbHbrx3neKrpocHa6NeHIa.s aBTorpaHcnoprHoro cpeAcrBa; perynrropa Harrpfl)KeHzn,o6ecue.rznarculero BbrrroJrHeHr4e pa3pa6oraunoro npaHrlrzrra.LLlecra:r rJIaBa Arrccepraqzouuofi pa6oru 3aBeprxaercf, 3aKJrroqeHkreM LIqacrHbtMr4 BbrBoAaMu (crp.

262).OIITI4M€UIbIIOEI4CIIOJIb3OBAHI{E15,{zccepraqrroHHar pa6ora 3aBeprlaercr 3aKJrrorreHrleM ilo Arlccepraqzonnofipa6ore (crp.262. . .264).llo3aMe-{aHz.rr no Ar4cceprarlrroHnofi pa6orenpe4craBJIeHHbIM AIrccepraIII{I4 r4 aBTopesepary He<l6xo4zr'roc.rleJrarbc+eAyroqr4e 3aMeq aHLrfl Lr rro)KeJraHu.rr :1' B nepnovr sau6oJlee BaxHoM rIyHKTe <ocuonHbre pe3yJrbrarbr14 BbrBoAbr))Al4ccepraqzounofi pa6oru Heo6xo,4znro c0opMynupoBarr n o6o6qennorra BLr.rIecoAepxaHl4e lr pe3yJlbrarbl peneuuofi HayqHo-nparruuecrofi npo6leurrHPII?IOHiulHrofi SKoHOMI'IKI4. BrtnoAu He conpoBox(Aarorcf, KoJrr{rrecrseHHoftoqenrofi.2.

B Marepr4arax A'ccepraqzonHofi pa6orrr He pacKpbrro Ao ypoBF'I4sBecrHocrl4 ocHoBHbIe l]'oHflTLrfl. lr coAepxaHue pa:pa6oraHnofi(KoHIIelUI4{ rIoBbIIxeHI4.[ ronlnnuofi gKoHoMr4qHocrl4),raro,uonoa",(KoHUeIrUutaBroMarlaqecKofo ynpaBneHl4.[ HanprxeHr{eM feHeparopnofi ycraHoBKr4)),(qrHTenneKTy€LJIbHbIe cl{creMru).Marepu€trlbl no sraM Kprrrepr{flM coAepx utafl. BorAenbHblx pa3Aenax AI4ccepral{ul4, Ho He npeAcraBr.rrror co6ofieAr4Hoe rlenoe.3 ' B Marepl4a-Ilax pa6orbl He pacKpblT MexaHr43MBrrLrflH.r4fl. gHeprerrrrrecKuxnpoqeccoB paspa6oraHHblx TexHl4qecKrrx peuenzfi or4eJrbHbrx KoMrroHeHToBr{34eKrpoo6opygonaHtrfl B IIenoM Ha pacxoA TorrJrr4Ba z nu6pocBpeAHbrx BerrlecrB.Harz'rue lo4o6nrrx Marepl{€uloB rro3BoJrr{T BBecrr.r KoppeKTr4pyroq'exqsS(bzql4eHrhl B orpacneByro cl4creMy HopMr4po BaHufl pacxoAa rorrJrrrBaHaagrovo6rzJlbHoM TpaHcrlopre Lr I4clroJrb3oBarb vx npv orIeHKr{TexHr{rrecKoroYponru coBpeMeHHbrx TpaHcrropTHbrx cpeIcTB.4' B luccepralluu He nplrBeAeHa IleneHarrpaBJreHHar MetoALrKa npoBeAeHr4,SIqcnepI{MeHTaJIbHbIX v reoperl{qecKrzx r4ccneAoBauwit, orcyrcrByerorr1rcaHr,reKoHcrpyKTr4BHbrx peureuzft ocHoBHbrx KoMrroHeHToB.,I{enecoo6pa":no nprrBecrl{ o6qyro cxeMy clrcreMbr oneKTpoo6opy4ona;1uflLrSparrraeurapHble HoBhIe rexH'4rrecKl4e perxeHr4.rr KoMrroHeHToB pa3nr{rrHbrx cLrcreM3neKrpoo6opy4onauz.a.

Heo6xo4uvro pacKpbrrb r(oHcrpyKTr4BHoe perreHr4rr,npI{BecTkI KpaTKI4e sHepreTrlqecKlIe XapaKTeppIcTuKu BHoBb pa^:pa6oraHHbrxvrMOAepHu3I4pOBaHHbIX KOMTIOHeHTOB B AOOTBercrBr{e cpaspa6orannofiuero.uoloruft.5' B reKcre rvrcceprarrvu K o4nofi v rofi)Ke coBoKynHocrr{ ycrpoftcrnnpLIMeH.flrcTc-[ pa3Hble repMrrHbl: KaK ((cr{creMa gner(Tpoo6opyAonaHvr.fl>>,TaK(crzcreMa gneKTpo cna6xeHz.s).146' Ha":saHI4e naparpa0a I .2 ue n noruofi Mepe coorBercrByer r43JrolKeHHoMyBHeM Marepurarry (crp. 43...48).7' BAkrcaeprarJvrkr rt3JII4IxHe uo4po6no orzcaHbr rreKoropbre cxeMbrKoMrIoHeHToB cI4creMbl sJleKTpoo6opy4onanzx ATC uoco6egnocrz ux$yurcquoHzrpoBalufl, B rlacrHocrI4, cxeMbr anrouo6zJrbrrbrx peryJr.rrropoBHanprxeHr{.r Ha pr4c. 10 (rtp.

60...62) u OrpyKrypna.rr cxeMa6rorcanpgABapl4renHrofi noAroroBKu cI{rHaJIa cxeMa rrcrorrHaKa ololpHoroHanpr}KeHr,r.rrHa prlc. 50 (crp. 24I...243).168. flpnorvrcaHr4r4 cnoco6oe yrrpaBJreHnfl, :nanpfl)KeHlreM r4 MeroAoB pacqerauononb3ylorc.fi TepMI{HbI <<6omruofi >> z <<xopourufi > He xapaKTepr,r3yrour4e AaHHbreupoqeccbl KorI{rIecrBeHHo. Kpovre roro, Anr cxeMbr Ha pl4c. 55 He yK€BaHbrrlapaMeTpbl 9JIeMeHTOB, TaKTOBat qaCTOTa yrlpaBJreHl4rr cI4noBhIM KnrOqOM rr r.rr.9. VIs Marepll€uloB Al{cceprarJurn H aBTope$epara HeflcHo, yA€lJrocb Jrr{ B rlrorecHrr3r{Tb nu6pocrroTpa0oTaBIIrr4Mkr|A3AMH JIE|.KI4X HecfopeBrxr4xyfneBoAopoAoB, KoT'opbre lr3Haq€urbHoIIOCBbIIIIAI?IIIOKA3ATEJII{.perJraMeHrlrpyeMbre |OCT P 5 1249 -99B pa6ore He rIpI4BeAeHa oIIeHKa loryqeHHoro rro pe3yJrbraraM r4ccJreAoBaHut.corlrranbHo-oKoHoMrrrrecKoroLroKoJrorurrecKoro e$Qerra.llep Bafl.

rJraBa Ar4ccepraquouuofi pa6omr [peAcraBJreHa BpeQepupoBaHr4fl. kI3BecrHbIX Marepr4€uroB, rrro He [o3BoJrre:r B uolnofi10.Br4AeMepeonpeAen[Tb aKTy€ulbHoorb cSopvrynLrpoBaHHbrx rlenr4 Lr 3al\aq uccneAoBalrtzfl.Orcyrcrnyror ccbrJrKlr Ha JrkrreparypHbre r{crorrHr,rKr4 1,30, 4A,4I,57,58,48,63,64,65,66,69,70,7r,77,91, 90, I02, I05, 106, 107, 109, 109, 110, 111,Il2,ll3,I57,172, 178,779, Ig0, 191, 192, Ig3, 184, 195, 196, 1g7,Igg, 1gg,190. 3ape:epnupoBaHHbre Mecra Mo)KHo 6rrno 6rr gauorHr4rb orcyrcrByroulr4MCILICKOM TpyAoB OIIIIIOHeHTOB.fly6nzraWV v c o o rB ercrBLrecoAep )KaHVtr4ac c epr ar\utru anrope$eparaOrvre.{eHHHe HeAocrarKl4 u 3aMer{aHla.f, HecKoJIbKo cHl{}Karor KarlecrBoLxccJleAoBauuit, Ho oHI{ xre BJrI4tIor Ha ocHoBHbIe reoperllrlecKlle I{ [paKTI4rIecKIzIep e 3yn bTaTbr vr [va cepTarl H o H H o f o r{ c c Jr eA o B aHkrfl..Pa6ora I{Meer AocrarorlHyro aupo6aquro Ha Mex{AyHapoAHbrx, Bcepocczfi crux,I,n By3oBcKrax rconQepeHlll,If,x (ony6nzroBaHo 10 rvrarepnarroB rconSepenqufi)"Peaymraru [poBeAeHHoro I{ccJIeAoBaHLrA aupoSzpoBaHbr Ha pa3nlrqHbrxMexAyHapoAHbrx, Bc poccr{fi crrax, r4 By3oBcKux rou$epeHrlr4f,x.Ocsonnoe coAepxaHvre Arrccepralluonnofi pa6orrr orpaxeno n 39 pa6orax, 14I43 Koroprx ony6nHKoBaHbI B r,r3AaHr{f,x, BKnroqeHHbrx B nepeqeHb BAK POpeIIeH3I4pyeMbIX BeAyIrIux HayrIHbIX )KypHanoy u uzgauuit, oAHoM rrareHTe rranso6pereHue v 4 rpy4ax rouQepenqzfi .AaropeQepar AocrarorrHo tIoJrHo orpaxaer ocHoBHbrepe3ynbra.TbrI4coneAoBalauit, rpI4BeAeHHbIe B Al4cceprarluonnofi paSore.

OcnoaHHe pe3ynbra.TbrAI4ccepraIILIoHHoro LIccJIeAoBa:nurs. rrcrroJrb3oBaHbr n yue6HoM npoqecce.[uccepraHT BJIaAee'r coBpeMeHHbIMr{ MeroAaMr'r rrpoBeAeHufl vrccnepLosatruir uananvrca u o 6p a6 orKr4 rronyrr eHHbrx p e3ynbraro B.fucceprallzt npeAcraBJleHa B Aoarynuofi 4nx rroHr{MaHrzx Sopnre, HarrucauaHaAon)KHoM HayrIHo-TexHr'IqecKoM ypoBHe. llpune4eHuue Marepr,r€urbrAHccepraIIIrlI no3Bor.ser nonyqLrrb rroJrHoe kr AocraroqHo uo4po6rroee o [poBeAeHHbIX aBTopaM I,Ic c JIeAo B aHvIflx.Anrope$epar orpalKaer ocHoBHoe coAepxaHlre AucoepraL\Lrkr.,{ucceprarrkntIIp eAcTaBJIOHIzIprantopeSepar coorBerorByror rpe6onanuru |OCT P 7.0.11-20II, clrcreMecEaHAapro B rro un Q oprra aq uu, 6u6 nuorerrHoMy r{ }r3A are nbc KoMy Ae Jry.17filccepralll4oHHa.l pa6ora r{epuora AnercaH4pa Eroponuua BbrrroJrHeHa HaxopoureM MeroAZqecKoM I4 HayrrHoM ypoBHe, coAepxr4T AooTaroqnrrfi anaJruspaccuarpzsaeNaofi npo6nevtrt HaIILIoHaJrrnofi oKoHoMHKz so6racu co3.rlaHurr ucoBepIIreHcrBoBaHAt cl4creM sJleKrpo o6opy4onaHl4.rr aBrorpaHclopTHbrxcpeAcrB.lloly'rennrre Teoperl4qecKl4e 14 sKcrrepr4MeHTaJrrHbre pe3ynbra.Tbrr{I4ccepraquouuofi pa6orrr He coAep}KarArrcKyccr4oHHbrx Mareprur€uroB.3arffo.reHzeMarepualrr Arrcceprarlr4oHHor-o r{ccJreAoBaHLrfl v aarope$epara noJrHoppcKpblBalor BbIIrorIHeHHyro pa6ory Lr o$opvrnenrr B coorBercrBr{r{ crpe6oeaHkrflMpr BAK PO.fi'rccepraqux r{epnona Aner<can4pa Eroponuva Ha reMy: <<MerogoJror.r4.f,n0BbIIIreHI4f, 3Heplerl4'recKofi e$SexrznHocrLr czcreM 3neKTpoodopy4onannxaBToTpaHorroprHbrx cpeAcrB), flBrrflercfl.

saeepueunofi uayuuoft pa50rofi,rrocB_f,rqeHa perxeHr4ro aruyalruofi npo6leuuIIOBbIIIIeHI,I{ SHepf eTI4.IeCKOfreftSexrunHocrrl crrareM oneKrpoodopy4onanz.a aBroTpaHcrropTHbrx cpeAc,rB,r4MeeT AOCTaTOrrHyro HayrrHyro u npaKTr4qecKyro TIeHHOCTI, [pr4BeAeHHbres HefrHayrrHo-[paKTr4rrecKl4e pe3ynbTaTbr pe€url43oBaHbr B npoMbrruJreHHocrr4 z yue6nounpoqecce.BIIenoMrloaKTyanbHocrlz, nayunofi HoBr43He, o6rervry Marepr4€uroB,nayvuofi I{eHHocrI4 Teoperl4qecKl4x u oKcnepr{MeHTaJrbHbrx r4ccneAoB auuit, aTaKX{e npaKTl4rrecKoMy 3HarIeHI4IO nonyrleHHbrx pe3ynbraroB, BbrIIOnHeHHa_spa6ora rlepnona Anercau4pa Eloponuva orBerraer rpeSonauuxu BAK pO,rIpeAbtBn-[eMbIM K IoKTopcKZM ALrcceprarlrr.f,M, a ee aBTop gepnon Anercan4pEroponvu 3acny)Kr{Baer npr4cy}Kr eHufl eMy yvenofi .tirr."" AoKropaTexHr4qecKr4x Hayr( rro cler{r4anbHocrr4 05.09.03sneKTpoTexH?1qecKHeKOMIINEKCbI14CI4CTEMbI.3acnyxeunrrfi 4errelr nayr<z PO[orrop rexHr4qecKrrx HayK, npoSeccopheun/4€B.UEpoxoellb4uracr npo$eccopaEboxoeaB Hr<rop aI4sarrosu\a3ABep.[rc:frasHrrfi yvenufi ceKpelapr V-reHoro<VIo cKos crcuftCupanovHbrellolnrex),coBeraVI.V,KonrvHosAoKropAaHHbre:iiil','Epoxor Barrop I4riauoluq, AoKrop rexupoQeccop, 3acnylKeuHrrfi AerreJrb HaynpoQeccop rca$eaprr <<3rcororr{r{ecKatorB oy B o <Mo croe cKHfi rro Jrr4rexH u\e cxuir yHr{B ep cr4rer)Mocxna, yn.AnrosaBoAcKar, AoM 16, Ten.

8-916-150-17-g7bHAqAHI4KA.