Отзыв оппонента (781837), страница 2
Текст из файла (страница 2)
Anropol,t paspa6oraHa MeroALrKa nu6opa ypoBur Hanp-f,xeHr4.rrreHeparopuofi ycraHoBKI4 pa3nI4qHbIX rr4rroB aBrorpaHcloprHbrx cpeAcrB,rlctloJlb3yroqa.f, :laBl4crrMocrb Berl4rrr4Hbl MareMarI4r{ecKofo oxtz.{aHr4qHarlpf,xeHprfl' B 6opronofi cerl{ or ypoBHf, perynupyeMoro Harrp.f,xeHz{, roKareHeparopttofi ycraHoBKI4, ToKa Harpy3KI4 Lr rracrorbr BpanleHr{f, reHeparopa(Crp.192...21 5, (fopuynu 5.7.. . 5.8 ).Taruu o6pasovt, AZccepraIII4oHHa{ pa6ora rlepuona Anercau4pa Eroponu.racoorBercrByer Kprrrepr{rc <Hay.urax HoBrr3Ha).Hayunax rleHHocrb HccneAoB aHkrtrC no:uquu coBpeMeHHoro ypoBHt HayqHbrx gsaHufi cocrorHr4 fl Lr pa3BvrruflcoBeplxeHcrBoBaHI4t cLICTeMbI COBpeMeHHOfO AB?rrareJreclpoeHr{f, K qr4cnyHaIa6olee 3HaqI4MbI.K HayqHbIX pe3ynbraroB Ar4ccepTaHTa cJreAyer orHecrLr:MeroAVKa vrMLrraIJr4oHHoro MoAenrzpoBaHLrq cr4creM gJreK.Tpocna6xeHras cyrIeToM MTHOBOHHLIX sHa.IeHzfi ToKoB 14 naupxxeuufi B 6opronofi ceTra AnflorrpeAeneHr{r pacxoAa rorrJrr,rBa ABufareneMeneKrpocna6xenux (crp.
12L . .17KOHIIeIqUtI,Ha pa6orypuc 24 ." . 3 7, SopMyrra3.2..ctrcreMbr.j .29).ULBTOMaTI4qeCKO|O ynpaBneHr{r ypoBrreM Hanpf,x{eHr4treHeparopnofi ycraHoBKrz, o6ecnerll4Baroqaq cHrl)KeHr4e pacxoAa rorrJrr,rBa 3a crrerBBeAeHI{.f, B3aI4MocB{3rr crelreHkr 3ap.rDKeHHocrr4 ar(yMyJrnropHofi datapeu cyKa3aHHbrM ypoBHeM Hanp')KeHHf, (crp. 227 ...26I). (ctp.pr4c.27 ...33).[4L..I64,MeroALIKa nrr6ctpa nepeAaroqHoro orHorrreHrzrf, ABr,rfareJrb-reHeparop Anflo6ecne.reuus cra6uJrbHoro ypoBHf, HanprxeHrar n 6oproeofi cerrr.MeroA pacrlera MareMarI4.IecKofi MoAenI4 An.'I onpeAeneHurr BrrvrflHvrfl cr4creMbroneKrpoo6opy4onar*rfl Ha pacxoA rorrrrvBa ATC (.tp.161...165, puc. 33...35.Qopvryna 3.31).MareMarl{.recKo.ft MoAenI,I cplcreM gneKTpocua6xeHiz.rr lr [ycKa rpaArrrlr4oHHbrxv ru6pz4nux aBTorpaHcrloprHblx cpeAcrB c alarrrr4BHbrN4tr aJrroprrrMaMr{yrlpaBneHnf, HarIptxeHI4eM reHeparopnoft ycraHoBKr4 B gKcnnyarar\Lrvr,o6ecue'{znarorqefi yr{er cnyuafinoro xapaKTepa r{3MeHeHr4f, sKcrrJryararlzoHHbrxSaxropon (uacrorsl BpauleHzt, oneKTpuqecrofi Harpy3Kr{, TeMrreparypbr Lrpexr4Ma ABrzx{eHrrx) (Qopuynu 5.1...5.3, wp.197...
198).KoHIIeuII4t aBToMarI{rIecKoro ynpaBJreHrrr HalprxeHrleM reHeparopnofiycraHoBKvr, clavDKar)Irlat pacxoA TorrJrHBa 3a crrer nuSopa ypoBHf, perynupyeMoroHanpt)KeHufl B 3aBLrcI,IMocrI4 or crefreHvr 3apfl)KeHHocrrz aKKyMyJr.flropnoft 6arapeu.MeroAI4Ka nrr6opa ypoBHfl Halp.ax{eHr4.rr reHeparopuofi yc'Ta}roBKr4 pirrkrrrHbrxTI4tIOB aBTOTpaHcIIOpTHbIX CpOACTB, LICIIonb3yloqa-{ 3aBI4CI4MOCTb BeIIzItII4HbIMaTeMaTLIqecKofo o)Kul.alr.I4fl HaIIpDKeHI4.[ B 6opronofi ceTr4 oT ypoBHtperyJll{pyeMoro HarptrxeHvrfl, ToKa reHeparopuoft ycraHoBKr{, ToKa Harpy3Kr4 r.rqacrorbr BparrleHr4r reHeparopa (crp.I92...2I4, Sopnrynu 5.7...5.8, crp.2rr...2rs).Tarulr o6pa:ovt, ArrcceprallkloHHas pa6ora gepnona Alercangpa EropocoorBercrByer Kprr'uepuro <Hayvnax rleHHocrb).Bkrvrallp amrv ve cKaf, 3 Haqr4 Mo crb Ar4c c eprarlr4 o HH ofi p a6 orul.llpanrHqecKa.fl 3Harrl4Mocrb pe3ynbraroB Ar4ccepraqnonnoft pa6oru3aKJlloqaerc.[ B ToM, qro pa":pa6oraHHble rlpeAnox(eHLrfl o6ecue.rzBaK)TcHrrxreHr4epacxoAa rorlnI4Ba Ao 6.
. .8 % npl4 ol(oHoMr'rz oHeprr{r4 or 27 MAxrc 26 Mlx na100 KI4JIoMerpoB ilpl4 cpe4Hefi cKopocrr4 60 rcu/q. 4uanason r43MeHreMbrxyponuefi HarlptxeHl4tB 6opronofi cerr4 cpa:paSoranmb.rM peryJr.rrropoMHanpsxeHll.fi y.{oBnerBop.fier rpe6onau[{M K KaqecrBy gneKTpr4r{ecrofi,"ap.",6opronofi cerr4. Perynmop Hanp.f,xeHr4r BHeApeH Ha 3aBoAe oAo"<3rerrpoMoAynb) (r. Mono4euuo), o6reu npor43BoAcrBa c 2007 rona roHacro.sulee BpeMf, cocraBr{n 1 000 000ruryr.2.
Pa:pa6oraru,I I43Mepl{TeltHufiKoMrrJreKc Lr MeroAr,r.Kacl4creM SneKTpocna6xeHu.q aBTo'rpaHcnoprHbrx cpeAcrBAnr zcnrrranrzfiBoKcrrJryar arJprLr,o6ecne'ruBaroql4e rto3Moll{Hocrb oIIeHKr4 Kaqeat"u pu6orhr cr,rcreM rro pacxoAyrorrJrr4Ba r,r uo SyuKur4oH€LrrbHbrM rroK€r3arerrrM ("rp. 177 . .. 1g9, prac.3g.. . :bl.HoszsHa TexHI'IqecKLIX perueruuit, npeAJrolKeHHbrx aBToporvr, noATBep)KAeHarareurouP@.3. Kovulerc npolpaMM IIoI4Mr4TarIuoHHoMy KoMrrbrorepHoMyofynMoAenkrpoBaHr4ro cr4creM sneKrpocHa6xesprr BHeApeH eril/fuLA3.I4srrrepvrelrHrrfi KoMTIJIeKcraccneAoB a"LrfloKcrrnyar arJ'ru cr4creMsneKTpocna6xeurzf,, BHeApeH Ha 3aBoge <3nerrpoMoAyJrr> r,r cpfVll HLIIrIAO.rnflB4.Pa:pa6oraHHa.,{ col.cKareneM reHeparopHas.
ycraHoBrcaArrfl ropoAcKr.xanro6ycon JftaA3, Iro3BoJltroqat cHrl3r{Tb pacxor rouruBaro 2,5yo,""a4pa"uOOO fI4OP. O6leu roAoBoro rpol{3BoAcrsa 1 500 unyr.(arr BHeApeHr{f,crp. "BenrznrHrrfi enercrpoABLIrareJlb, paacrrr4TaHHbrfi no MeroAr{Ke uMr.rrarluoHHoroMoAenvpoBaEkrfls saueHxrorqufi sapy6eNnrte oneKrpoABlrrareJrr4Qzpuu<Be6acro>, BHeApeH B ooo fl4op Arrf, asroNao6unefi KAMA3. b6".,NPOII3BOACTBA SJIEKTPOABI4|ATETEfi COCTABJIflET 1 3OO IIITYK B IOA.5.3r<cuepuvreHT€ulbHble I4ccne.qoBaHLrfl. 6srriu npoBeAeHr,r Ha asroNao6rarxxMapoK KaIuA3 (24 B 6opronax cerb, 4uselr), 3uII-4334, fA3, BA3 (6oprona.aceT,r 12 B, 6eu:uHoBble ABI4rarenLI BHyrpeHHero cropaHn r) z anro6ycaxJir,rA3 cABI4rareJIeM <<Kar:epnvnnep)).
Paspa6oraHHbre TexHr4LrecKr4e peureHr4f,,NPCAJIO)KEHHbIC YCTPOfiCTNA V KOMIIOHCHTbI 3HAI{I{TCJIbHOYIYIIIUAIOTsKcnnyaralll4oHHble xapaKTepLraruKu ATC u Moryr 6urr peaJrn3oBaHbr 11pLrco3AaHI4I4 HoBbIX O6pa:qon anrouo6ulrnofi TexHr4rsz u npn MoAepHr43arJvrvr9Kcnnyarl{pyeMblx enrovo6zlireit, a raK}Ke I4crroJrb3oBaHbr n yue6uoM npoqeccepn4a BV3oe.6. llolyveHnrre aBTopoM pe3yJlbrarhr r'crronb3yrorc.f, vr BHeApeHbr HanpeAnpr4f, TLrflX, lpopr3BoAf, rqvx aBTorpaKTopHoe gJreKrpoo6opy4onanze.llnrennerryalrnrtfi peryJr.grop Harrp-DKeHLr{, oSecue.{ernaroulzfi cHunreHr4epacxoAa rorrJrHBa BHeApeH ua OAO <SnerrpoMoAynb) ra OOOfIrIOp.7'Kounler<c nporpaMM LrMkrraIJUoHHofo MoAenr{poBaHufl cr{creMbrsneKTpoo6opy4onaH.Llt pa3JIkItIHbIX rl4rroB ATC B pe)Kr{Me peaJrbHoro BpeMeHu,onpeAen-fircrqufi BJII{.IHLIe Ha oKoJlorl{r{ecKr{e xapar(TepucruKu rpaHcnoprHorocpeAcrBa, BHeApeH e ofYil r*fur-A^o, oAo <AsroBA3), oAo 3zT.6I4zweputenurrfi KoMrrneKc,rro3Bon.flrorqzfi frpoBoAr4Tb r4CCneAOBarnvesHeprerl{rlecKux rloKa3are]ireit, Yw6paIII{oHHbIX 14 yAapHbrx g:arpy3oK pu6nr4qHbrxclrcreM, BHeApeH Ha OAO <SrerrpoMoAyJrb)), @fyII TfufuIAD, OAO<AeroBA3), OAO 3zT, Oy|I MA3 u <Ilpavro>.
feHeparo]lH€r-f, yaraHoBK a r\nnropoAcKl{x anro6ycos JIHA3 c y4enbHblMr{ rroK€Barer.rrMr{ 400 Br/rr BHeApeH BOOO |IIOP n OOC) <Srerrpovr>.Tarcult o6pasov, rl4ccepralll4oHHar pa6ora Yepuoea Anerrcaugpa Eroponzuac oorB ercrByer Kpr4Tepkr ro <llp axrrav e cKa.rr :]H aqr4 M ocrb )) .I?eanusaqkr.rr pe3ynbraroBpa6oruPesynrrarsr pa6orr,t BonJIoIqeHbI B cneAyrcrqrrx rexHr.rqecKr4x perreHr4f,x:pa3pa0oraHpefyrrf,ropywysvvreurlqLryrLtl\erLvL ) \ru\turrE.tt4BaIuIlJL4I4ywL JJL^Lvy HarrpD(eHr4f,,o6ecne.rzsarctuufi gHl4)KgHVeCHI{XTEHVE pacxatAaTOIIJILIBa 6olee rIeM Ha 7 Yo la 100 r<unoMerpoB npoSera aeroMo6un.fi BA3"ropoAcKoM pe)KLTMe gKcnJryar arJvrkr szuofi ;co3AaH KoMTIJIeKc npofpaMM HMr{ral[r4oHHoro MoAeJrr{poBaHufl C3C n:n{onp eAeJreHLrfl p aaxoAa TonJrLrB a Tp aHcrroprHof o cp eA cTB a;pa":pa6oraH I{3Meprarenrnrrfi KoMrrJre c, rro3BoJrruorqufi uocneAoBarb cr4creMygneKTpoo6opy4onauzx aBTOTpaHCnOpTHbrxaBTorpaHcnoprHbrx cpeAarBgKcrrJrvararruoHHbrxcpeAcTB rrpurrpu 3KCnnyaTar{r{oHHbrxI4CUbITaHLI.f,X;c yqeroM noryqeHHbrx pe3ynbraroB t4ccneAoBauuit co3AaHa feHepaTopKanycraHoBKa p.nfl ropoAcKlrx anro6ycon JIzA3 c ABlrrarenrMr4Srapuu<<Karepnunnep);paspa6oraH BeHTl4lruufi oJIeKTpoA Btrra eJ-rb An.rr [peAnycKoErbrx noAorpeBarelefi3 aMeH,rrc q uir zapy 6exHbr e 3 Jr eKrp oABr{f areJrr4s zpvEr < B e 6 acro > .Peaymrarrr Arrccepraquouuofi pa6oru (rouunexcrporpaMMI4MI'ITaIII{oHHoro MoAenl{poBaHufl.
C3C, onpeAeJr.firoqzfi BJrr4rrHr4re Ha rorrJrr4BHyrosKoHoMl4rrHocrb anrouo6unefi, ar<t o BHe.4peuuu crp.287) BHeApeHbr B orrbrrHoeupoeKrl{poBaHlule I{ olrblrHoe rpol43BoAcrBo @fyll HI4WIA (r. Mocrcna).Pesylrraru pa6orbl pe€ull{3oBaHbr s OOO (|I,IOP) (Arcr, ctp. 289 r{ aKr crp.290),ooo<Topronuft 4ou, SnexrpouoAyJrb, aKr crp.til4I4AO (arr, crp.
288) (r. Mocxna).286>>(r. Mocxna),(Dfyllo6ocHosaHHocrb r4 AocroBepHocrb HayqHbrx uonoxenzfiAr{ccepraquonuofi pa6orrrC MeroAonorz'{ecxofi TorIKI4 3peHr4r o6ocHoeaHHocrb Lr AocroBepHocrbHayrIHbIXnoroxeuuft,noATBepxAeHa H€UrzrrkreMo0IxlrpHofosKCneprIMeHT€UIbHOfO Lr reoperl{qecKofo Marepr4€ura, BocllloLr3BoAr{MOCTbTO VryAoBneTBopI{TeJIbHEIM COBrIaAeHI4r4 pe3yJrbraroB Teoperr{rrecKr4x vsKcnepI4MeHT€uIbHbI.K I4ccneAonauuit, aAeKBarHocrbro MareMiITLrr{ecKI{x vto.uelefiocHoBHbIX CpICTeMbI, npLIMeHeHI4eM COBpeMeHHOfO u3MepI4TeJIbHOfOo6opy4ona:rtLrfls MeroAaM[ ee o6pa6orKr4, Ha Korophre cchrJraercf, aBrop.locronepHocrb lro.qrBepxAaerct npr{MeHeHr4eM anpo6zpoBaHHbrx MeroAoBKOMIIbIOTOpHOTO MOAenI4poBaHvIfl sJIeKTpOTeXHZqecIs4X CIzIcTeM, pe3yJlbTa'IaMkrn a6 op aropHbrx r{ o Kcnnyararlr{oHHbrx r{ crrbl t ariuit.,7l.,,{vIccepraHToM pa:pa6oraHa MeroAoJrorrrf, rroBbrrrreHujfi oHeprerkrqecr<ofieS$enrranHocrr4 cr4creM gileKTpoo6opy4oraunr Anrr rroBbr:rrreHr.rf, rormrsHofigKoHoMurrHocrr4 aBTorpaHcnoprHbrx cpeAcrB.