Отзыв оппонента 1 (Физико-химические и каталитические свойства сложных фосфатов циркония, допированных ионами кобальта и никеля со структурой NASICON)

Orsrrsr4rlr4€urbHofo orrnoHeHTa Ha Ar4cceprarll4ro qepurrruenofi MaprapuruKoJIaeBHbIHa reMy <<@lrgl,txo-xI4MHr{ecKl{eu Kar€url4Tl{qeclo4ecsoficrsaox{Hbrx $ocSaronqLIpKoHI4{, Aorrr4poBaHHbrxr{oHaMr4 r<o6alrra n Hr4KeJrq,copofi NASICON>,npeAcraBneHHylo Ha cor4cKaHr4eyvenoiicrerreHr4HAI4AaTa XI{M I4qe c KI4X HayK HO Cneql4 €UIbHOCTLI:02.00.04 - @r4s.aqecKarxr4Mux(xuvruqecKraenayrz)T€UIPITHTIeCKLIellpeBpaqel{vIflJIC)KATOpraHHr{eCKHXBeII{eCTB pa3nHqHhIXB OCHOBe MHO|I4X npoMibrruneHHhrx npoqeccoBnoJrr{eHr4rKJIaccOBsaxHer4rur4xrrpoAy oBi ne$rexuurau, a rarcKe ocHoBHoro u roHKoro opraHuqecKoro cHHTe3a.BnonIroH{TeH noerrureHHrrfr r4HTepec MupoBoro HayrrHoro c,co6uqecrna KKe[pI4HIII4IHaIIbHOcyIIIec Byr(f,llll4x rexnonorr,rfiHA3aAaHOBbTXpa,{rrKaJrbHoMyHrereporeHHoroKaTaJIrr3a.

HayCOBepmeHcrBoBaHHroSTHX Miarr4cTpanbHbrxeHI{.tIXHayrlHo-TexHllqecKoro nporpecca B conpeiuennofi xHNTHHperrraercflpa3paooTKH HoBbIX KaT€UrI{Tr{qeCKI4XKOMnO3r4THbrXMaTepr4€UrOB,trrO3BOJrrrOqUXpe3Ko oBr,rcrrTb aKTHBHocTb H OeJIe)KTHBHOCTbpeaKrlr4l4 nO IIeJTeBOMyrrpOAyKTy.noJII4B€uIeHrHbrx3JreMeHroBco crpyKrypofi NASICON o6laAarorKOMIIJIBbICOKKcoM yHI4KuLrIbHbIX cnoficln,TaKLrx KaK BbrcoKafl vrololnafl npoBoAr4Mocrb,]rporlHocTb, xl4Ml4qecKarr, paAHarluoHH.afl 14 TepMuqecKa{oTaor4JlbHocTb,) a. B ptAe cnyqaeB Aaxre orpurlaretrurrfi, xoeSSnqHeHT TepMr4qecKoropacIxHIttfl, HI{3Kafl TennonpoBo,{Hocrb. Enaro4apr yHuKulnbHrrtiacsofrcrBaM, oHHHH3KHIIonyLlKaqnI4 Ixl4poKoe rrpr4MeHeHr4eB pa3nr4rrHbrxo6nacrf,x Hayrr.r. IrIx ucnonb3yror BceHcopoB,ToIIJIpIBHbTx SJIeMeHTOB, SneKTpOnI43epOBBOIITHO|OfrapA.,Marep €LIIC)BI'Jrfl ITkITLIT{-r{OHHbrXaKr(yMynfl TOpOB H KaTaJII43aTOpOB.:,rofi TolrKr4 3peHru, He Bbr3brBaer couuenufiaKmyqJtbHocmbpa6oru9epH ueBofi M.H., uaqereHuofi Ha err6op cJroxHbrx QocQaron co crpyrrypofirax $u:uro-xHMI4qecI(HXceoficre uNASI N e Kar{ecrBeKaraJru3aropoB,r,r3yr{eHraeaKTHBHooTI{ vr ptcrroJrb3oBaHl4e ,{aHHbrx KoMIIo3HToIr B peaKIII,IflxrrpeBpqeHr4r crrr4proB.

B Ka.{ecrBe MoAeJrrsofi peaKrII4I46rua ucrroJlb3oBal{apeaKlrl4qKATZUIrpeAefHecrofiueHlrruso6yrauora,KoropaqnporeKaerIroAByMHanpaBneHI,I-trM:r$fl, c o6pa:onaHneM u:o6yrena, vr AerHApI{poBaHI4e,c o6pa:onaHl4eMHso6HaJr,[. C qenbro noBbIIrIeFrH-rraKTr4BHocrH H ceJIeKTHBHocrI.Il(araJln3aropoBrrpHfl ercf, rrJIa3MoxI4MI4rIecKafl o6p a6 orr<a rlo BepxH ocrl4 KoMrIo3HToB.Sc,pvrynnpoBaHHbre B Aucceprarlur{ rlenu H 3ailaqv HX BbIrIoJIrIeHHfl,BfIoJIHeo6ocn BaFrbrr4 oa3l4pyloTct Ha BE,Ioope oobeKToB pa3nl4r{Horo cocTaBia, a TarcKe HaMeroAoB (penrreno$a::onrrfi a:r'aIr:a3,3Kcrrep)HMeHT€r[bHbrxrrpHM HerrvLrcoBpeMeHHbrxMaKpocKorrnflv, IIK- u Y(D-cneKrpocKorrufl, pacrpoBar oneKTpoHHo-HoHHaf,Ap.).

B Auccepraur4u HccJreAoBaHbrcBoficrBa v $yHrqIroHaJlbHajr aKruBHocrbPOKOMTIIIpLIMB Io r4 rrocne o6ry.reHzr BblcoKoqacrornofi rrJra3Mor{apfoHa rr BoAopo4aHaMoAenbHofipeaxqur4pa3no)KeHLrflcnrlpra.nl4reparypHoM oO3ope [peAcraBJIeHaHanr43coBpeMeHHbrxrrpeAcraBlesufi ocBoHOBOfo KJracCaMarepr4ElnoBco crpyKrypoft NASICON, o MexaHH3MaxpeaK ft f)a3noxeHl'1.flcrll{proB.

llpone4euHufi aHaJrpr3rro3BoJrraJrcsopnayru4poBarboaHo ble IIeJTHkr nyrr rlx perueHnfl B Aucceprarlr{oHuofi pa6ore.I4oOJIee r{HTepeCHhIMr,r H3HaquMbrMr4 pe3ynbTaTaMr4, noJIyrIeHHbrMr{ Bnuofi pa6ore M.H. r{epHrrurenofisnrsrorcr cneAyroulue:Buepnrte rlrs I4ccneAoBaHkrflKararrr4TuqecKrzx[peBparqeuufi r,r:o6yranola6r,rrun eu6paHu cJrox{Hbre KoMrro3r{THbre Marepu€urbr Ha ooHoBe qe:ufi-qupKoHHeaux-SocSaroB,B Koropblx3aMeIIIeHI4OHaMI4 HI4KeJIf,Kar€LIIrITI4qecxofiIIe3HfrHlrkr ro6amra.tlacrrzlrHor4lrrr rloJlHocrbroYcrauoBJreHHa{B3ar,rMocB-fl3baKTrrBHocrI4 c KpHcrannorp aSuv ecKrrMr,r xap arKTepucrr4KaMHH Kl4cnorHocrblorroBepxHocruAsofiHbrxH rpofiurrx Cs-Zr-Soccparon(CZP) epeaKIII4H AeruApararJuruzo6ytuttoBorocnr4pra, flBJlf,ercfl Ba)KHbrMp%ynbraroM, ro3Bor-f,rotrluM nporHo3upoBarb ycnoBr4qQyudarueHmailbHbtrtnco3AaHI4tHoBbIXMarepu€urbra ga4.aHHbrMHcnoficreaMkr vt $yrrrquonanrnofiAKTI4BHOCTbIO.Ycranorreuo, rrro nplr .{acruqHofi 3aMeHe uoHa qe3nr Ha HoH Mer€LrrJra(xo6anrra/Hrarenx) B 2-3 pa3a yBenr4quBaerc.r cyMMapHa"fl KoHBepcHquso6yraHora.

flora:ano, qro pa3nuque B Aerl4Aparlapyrouleii axrrasHocruAnofinrrx14 rpofiurxI(ATAJI'dTKIIIECKI4cB.rr3aHo c$ocQaronAKTI4BHbIXrIeHTpoB,BH3MeHeHHOMrlpupoAbrpe3yJlbTaTeu3MeHeHI,ItTr4ila+ MoHoKlnnHar).Kpr4crannuqecrofi peilrerKr4 (po\,r6oe4pr4rrecKaflHecouseHHbrMnpaKmwtecKuBaxHbIMpe3ynbraroM pa0o'rbr, sBJrsercflAnfl yBenur{eHl4-trKaT€LIIITTI'I.IeCXOfraKrr,rBHocru4nofi urrx $oc$aroB. BrrcoxoqacrorHafl o6pa6orxa. noBepxHocrliHonoJIb3oBaHI{e BV-n.uasurrKaT€LtILI3arOpOB fro3BoJrrerArvHryBelr4r{UTb B 3-3,5 pa3 KoHBepcI{Io cnupra 3a cr{erpeaKrlr{oHHbrxrIeHTpoBVT H3MeHeHHr SHepfHkr QBfl3r4MOneKynoop€BoBaHr{.f,crrHpTac rroBepxHocTbro.pe3yJrbraraM allaJr?r3a xapaKTepa a.4cop0uHH Tecr-IvtoJleKyn COzyoTaHoBneHo,r{To HaLIOOJIbIxee BJIH.IHHe Ha COCTO-flHHerroBepxHoc:ruAeofiHrIxr{roSoc$aron oKa3brBaereosAeficrBue aproHoBofi BrI [JIa3MbI.

Iloxa":ano,florocne o6pa6orxu npoucxoAlrr [epecrpofiKa crpyKrypbl IIoBepxHocrI4TerlJlorofiaAcop6qnltrleHTpbrc HI43KoftSocSara, ttoflBJrrrorcflpeaKunoHHbreBo3pacTaer.COz 3Har{I4TeJIbHoa4cop6r4poBaHHorou o6ulee KoJrr,rqecreoflonrleHHbre B rrpeAcraBneHHofi pa6ore 3KcneFrHMeHTUrirbHbreKacarollHecs pa3pa6orKu HoBbrx Karilrr43aropoB rrpeBparrleHrztIl[CJIOM,pe3yn,oil€I, co crpyKrypofi NASICON, croco6Hblx c BblcoKoficeJreKrr{BHocrbronpoBo I,ITI peaKIII{rc Aerl4Apurar\krkrr43o6yraHoJra,Moryr 6rrrr KBanr4$pltrr4poBaHbrKaKHOBbIC Lr BalKHbIe.CoeorynHocrb HclroJrb3oBaHHbrxMeroAoBSusnxo-xl{Mr4qec)Kr,rxAHAJIopecnequBaeT BbrcoKyro cTerreHb AocToBepHocTranoryrreHHbrx pe3yJrbTaToB.OcHoe ble pe3ynbrarbl AucceprarluoHnoft pa6orrr ouy6ruxoBaHbr s 5 crarrflx neperrHtBAK, 16 resucax Mex{AyHapoAHbrxr4 poccuficxnx ron0epenqufi. AnropeSepar 14ny6rru aIJVTrdrroJrHo cTbro oTpax aroT coAepxraHHe I.I4cc epTauuu.eM He MeHee, no Ar,rccepraquoHHofipa6ore r{epHuureeofi ld.H.BbICKcneAyerTb p{A saN{eqaHzfi:He.{ocraroqHorIoJrHo npeAcraBJreHo B pa6oreo6cyxgeuueBrrvrflHkrnBblcoKorlacrornofi rIJIul3MbIna SopvrupoBaHl4eI{ ilprlpoAy aKTHr}HbrxrIeHTpoBllpe4craBrrs,ercs, HHrepecHbrMyror{HeHueAerHAparar\HH 14Aen4ApkrpoBaHLrfl,.lpHr{I4HbI3HaqI4TeJIbHofo yBenuqeHl4-fl aKTI{BHocrrz r4MeHHo 4nofiHrrx6116oneeno4po6Hoo6cy4r,rrrSaxr ((rroflBJreHr,rtSoc$aroe.

Tarxe cneAoB€LrroIIeHTpOB, XapaKTepr{3yroqr4xctfroBbrrrreHHoH 3Hepfrrer4 cBfl3vl c MoneKyJraMprcur4pra))rocJreB9-o6pa6oror.Ha I43orepMaxa4cop6qr.rra(p"c. 4.2 rr 4.5, crp.95, 97) cJreAoBiLJro6uAr4arr€BoH AaBneHHr4Bbrrrre Tex, npuHacbrrrleHHea4cop6quouHoro cJror.KoTopbrx HacTyrraerpaculrpr4TbBBbrBoAax He orMerleHbr HeKoTopbre 3HalIpIMbIe pe3yJrbrarTbl, Koropblerrpr4BeAeHbrB TeKcre Ar4ccepraqraz. Tar, cJreAoBuulo6rt ilpl4Becrl{ KoHKperHbIe3HarreHr4flBeJrrlqr4HKoHBepcr4u cwrpra Ao vr rocJle Br{-o6pa6oroK,KaK COCTaB OOpa3IIOB LI trpr4po.{AIloKa3arbpIOIIA-AOrraHTa BlrkrfleT Ha aKTZBHOCTb HceJreKTr4BHOCTbKaTiLrrH3aTOpOB.coorBercrBeHHo,. Ha puc. 10 ra 4.2 n reKcre aerope$epara v AkrcaeprarJnp1nepenyraHbr reMrreparypbr B no.4nl{csx K I43orepMaM a4copt6qTv COz.

Banrope$epare Ha prac.10-11npzBeAeHblAaHHbIeroJIbKo 4nx Co6,5Zrz(PO+)t,xorq r43 noAnucrr K pr4cyHKy cneAyer, qro AoDKHbI 6uunpI4BeAeHbIAaHHhIeH Anr,Nis.5Zr2(POa)3.llepevHc.ileHHbre3aMeqaHr4{He cHHXa}or oIIeHKHEr 11 [paKTr.rqecrofiorlue.IeHiHofruayuHofr3HarrllMocTrr, a TaK]Ke o6u{eroeprarlr4oHnofipa6oTbrr{epuHrueBofiM.H.BblcoKol-o ypoBHq14AocHoBaHHprpaccMoTpeHr4.rrcoAep aHr4fl. AHCCepTaTIHU,aBTOpeoepATA vrBaHHbrxaBTopoM pa6oT cneAyeTTb cneAyrorlee 3aKJrrorreHHe:rlepHrrruecceprarlr4oHu€ur pa6orai4 M.H. <<@rasuKo-xr4Mr{rrecKne14rne cnoficrBa cJrolnHbrxTIHpKOHH,I,r4oHaMHAOrrr4pOBaHHbrxr{ H}rKerrr,co crpyxrypofi NASIC N>>cooreercrByer rpedonanptswn. 9eft (llocraHoBJreHraefTpaaureJrbcrBaft (De4eparlr4rror 24 certrslpt,201 r.

J\b 842 <<Orop{.qKe npucyxqeHtrrcreueuefi>>), [peAb.rrBnf,eMbrMB ureft arrecrauuossofirouuccraefiea o6pa:oBaHur H HayKLrP@ x Ar4cceprarluflM Ha cotrcKaHpreyreuofiHI,I' O IIpHCy)KAeHIdI,t yrleHbrxLIyqebIXMuKaHAUAaTaHa'HoIi{C)JIbCoMC'i)XHMHr{eCKI{XcTeccepTarlrrf, _f,BrreTcr 3aKoHqeHHoHHayK.- rnaluSuraquonuoft pa6orofi,roropofi rroKa3aHa Bo3MoxHocrbqeccoB AerkrAparar\vu uso6yranolaktfl. B KaqecTBe KaTa[r{3aTopoBAep)KarqraxSoc$aron qe3r4r HpKoHLrf, (CZP),COCTaBOM LI KaTaJIX XIIMLIIIECKI{MI4qCCKOI{Aucceprardulr rlepuruuenacTerrAKTLIBHOCTbK)I4 IIOKA3AHAer o6nyrelnvrs.B9-unasvrofi aproHalraKTI{BarlHH KaTAnU3aTOpOB3aBaeT IIpI4CylK.qeHr4s yqeHouycraHoBneHa cB{3brapr4Ta HrnronaesHa 6eeycloeuoH KAHAT4AATAXr{Mr{qeCKHX HayK rroHocrn 02.00.04 - (Dusu.{ecKaflxr4Msnrrfi o[rroHeHTnayrHufi corpyAHprrna6oparopuuHhrxu forounrrx ilpoqeccoBBbrx HaHoMaTepuaJraxSusuuecxofi xuruuu H oneKTpoxr4I4M.(DpyuruuaPAH,AoMI{qECKI,IX HAVK.TE8-4l1lIovJrp (Su:rauecKaflxNurEr)ex_revina@mail.ru,t7A.A.

PesraHa4 /fr/%.ocKBa,Ile:s'uucxrdir,3 | I 4r PenrEuofi A.A. 3aBeprrc:ceKperaprl4ucrwryraXI4M}IIIECKI{XHAVK[4.f. BapuaBcKa.n.