Отзыв оппонента 3 (781835), страница 2
Текст из файла (страница 2)
prvrr4Talll4oHHa.fl MoAeJrb, paspa6or:aa.HaraBTopoM, cyrb Koroporococrozr BBoc[poI43BeAeHI4I'I I]oBeAeHr4r r{ccneryeMofi czcrerubrBoBpeMeHr,rHaocHoBepe3ynETaroB aHuwBa uau6onee cyqecrBeHHLIX B3aIrMocn.ssefiMe)KIy ee 3JreMeHTaMr4.B uelon'r BbIBoA 5 no 4anuoMy HayrIHoMynonoxeHr4ro o6ocnoeauu uo>xer 6rrtrnprr3HaH 3arrlHrueHHbrM.2.6. Mero4rzxa sKcnepr4MeHTaJrbHbrxoneKTpo cH a 6>rceuus. B gKcfrnyaraur4zccne.4oeaHzftpa3nuqHLIXCIICTeMrzAnropol't paspa6oraua MeroAIrKa oKcnepuMeHTaJrr,H[,r]: r4ccnero sauufi pa3n2qHbrxcrrcreM 3neKTpocHa6xenus.
B sKcnnyarar\!r!r, o6ecneqzearoqar Bo3MolxHoorboueHKrrKarlecrBa pa6oTl,r crrcreM rlo SKoHoMIrIz rorlJrl,rBa u$ynr<quoHzrJrr,HbrM troKa3areJrrM.llpraHerlocpercrBeHHoM yqacrzrn aBTopa co3AaH r,r3Mepr4TenrnrriKoMrrJreKc,npeAHa3Ha'IeHHrrfi lnfl klccreAoBaHu.s 3Hepfer[r{ecKlrx, TeIJIOBLIXLr nu6paquoHHrtxnpoueccoB, rIpoTeKaroUIuX B cIrcTeMaX u KoMIIoHeHTaX olerrpoo6opyAoBaHr4rnplrnpoBeIeHI4I'I SKcrInyaraIIIroHHLIX u ta6opatopuo-creHAoBBrx r4crrtlra1t4fr.,a raKi1eAn.flonpeAeneHI4.f, MOMeHTa corporvBneHl,I.f, ABr,rfareJrf, BHyrpeHlrefocropaHlrflHenocpeAcrBeHHo uanpu lycKeanrolro6ule.ocHosHoe Aocrol4HcrBo co3raHHofo KoMnJIeKca 3aKJrlorlaerctl B ToM,ro3Bor'tler cI4HTe3I4poBarE' Ir vccneAoBarb B ycnoBl4qx peanlHo.ft erccnlyarar\ur4qro oHpa3JrrrqHbrecnoco6rr ylpaBneHl{t reHeparopuoft ycraHosxofi.,{o Hacroxxlero BpeMeHr4 aHa.rrorrrqHoeo6opy4onaHrre B oreqecrBeHHoM aBToMo6rarecrpoeHzlr He rrpr.rMeH{nocb.B uelovt6 u 7 rro raHHoMy nono]r(eHzro o6ocnoBaH r.r BbrreKaror v3 cyrr4rrccneAoBanufi u nosToMy OHO MOX(er 6srrr npn:uaHo 3aqzxleHFi.BrM.BLIBOAT,I3.
f{enuocrr, Ar_s HayKrr14rrpaKTrrKrr[uccepraur e ceoefi pa6ore rronyqun krpeanr{3oBaJr HayqHo-,r'exHr4qecKyroMerononofulo IIoBbIIIIeHu.fl 3Hepreruqecxofi e$(lexrunnocrll cricTeM3neKTpoo6opy4oeanuxaBTorpaHcrloprHblx cpeAcrB' c yqeroM coBMecrHoroSyulcqzoHupoBaH4fl ocHoBHr,rx3tIeMeHToB ckI creMbl 3neKTpocHa6>xeuus, H onrI4MI43arlr4r4:/[paBneHr4.f, reHeparopnofiycranonxofi.{uccepraqr4oHnafl' pa6ora I'IMeer cyilIecrBeHHyro Teope'uqecKyro rIeHHocrb,HayrIHyIo HOBI43Hy, KoTOpa-s 3aKIIOrraeTcs B TOM, rrTo HOBbreHayrlHbre pe3ynbTaTEI,ononyr{eHHble JII4qHO aBTOpOM, paClIIzprIoT HayrrHoe3HaHVeBO6naCTu OHepfeTr4rrecKorzsssexrunuocrl'I cl4creM oneKTpoo6opyAoBaHrr{ aBTorpaHcrrcrprHbrxcpeAcrB, ro3Bor.srorpelxarlrIpI4KnaAHbIe 3aAar{vnocoBepIrIeHcrBoBaHI4Io ct4creM elexrpoo6opyAoBaHzqcrJenr'Io rloBbrlrreHIr{ TotIJII4BHofi sKoHoN4IzrIHocrIzaBToMo6an.g B ToMsreKTpr4rlzcrer{ecrofi rpancu uccuefr,.cru6pu4uort ufiucceptaryux orJrI{r{aerc-r BbIcoKI,IM ypoBHeM Teo]cerrrrrecKr4x paspa6oror<AOCTaror{Ho 60nrurrauo6relrorullpaxrzuecrax IIeHHocrb n rloJre3Hoct pa6orsr 3aKrrotraerc-fiB ToM,paspa6oraHHble rrpeAnoxeHl{t o6ecneqzearorcHt4)r(eHr4e pacxo/qa ro[JrrzBa3KoHoMI'Iu 3HepfIzI4kr3KCfrepLrMeHTaJrbHbIX UCCreAoeraHr4rz.or 21 M{N ryo26 MA>x Ha 100 Kl4noMerpoB rrpurc6yo-go/or{Tonpucpe4Hefr crcopocrz 60xlr/qac.Paspa6orannufi peryn-srop HarIpt)I(eHV-s BHeApeH Ha3iBore oAo 3nercrpoMoAynr,(r' Mono4evuo), o6teM rIpoI43BoAcrBa c 2007 foAa rroHacrorrrlee BpeM, cocraBrrn 1 000 000lxryK' Kolr'ner<c [pofpaMM no ITMI4TaIII4.HH.My KoMrrr,IorepH.MyMorenupoBaHrrrocr{creMsneKrpocHa6>rcertus' BHeApeHe OfYn HVII4A3.
Izlslrepzrerr,uufiKoM[JreKc nnflB SKcrlnyurarlnLr crlcreM 3neKTpocH a6>xeTun, BHeApeH HA 3aBone3rerrporuorynb v @fyll lHvrr4A3. feHeparopHa.rr ycraHoBKaAn.s fopo4cKrrx arlro6ycoet4ccJleAoBaHrrtJiuA3, [o3Bonqrcqafl'cHLr3LrrBfoAoBofo npolr3BorcreapacxoA rorrJrrrBa 4o 2,5%o, BHeApeHa noooI-I4OI,, O6renrI 500 [rryr<. BeHrunlnrrfisrexrpoABrrfarerrb, paccqrrraHHrrfr noMeroILrKe I4MI4TauI4oHHoro MoAenvpoBaHrrfl.. 3aMeHsrorllufi.zap5,gelKHbre 3neKTpoIBr4rareJrr{ooo fI4oP An.rr aBroMo 6utefiKAMA3, o6rerra nporr3BoAcrBacocraBJrtrer 1 300 [rryK B fon.
Bne4pen:ve rexHr4rrecKux perxeHr4fr0upn'Gr Be6acro, BHeApeH e3neKTporBt4rarerieftnoATBepxA aeT cfl aKTaMr,r.{ocronepHocrl Teoperl4rrecKux noro>neHraft Ar4cceprarluousofi pa6or.rrrocrr,rHyrarlorl4qecKI4 HenporI4BoperII4BbIM IrctIoJIr,3oB aHi1reMMareMarr{rrecKofoCOIJIACOBAHHOCT'IOPACqETH'IX I{ SKCIIEPI4 MCHTAJI'H'IXAAHH'IX.Marepualu AI{ccepraIIIrI4 Motyr 6r,rrrHa[[apara, a raKxeIpOeKTHO-KOHCTpyKTOpCKI'IX opfaHlr3arlzvcnoJlr,3oBaHr,I B rJayrrHo-uccJIeAoBareJIbcKI.xflX, 3a1r4Maroqzxc-seletcrpoo6OpyAoBaHr{r aBToTpaHcnoprHbrx cpeACTB,elercrpoo6opyAoBaHkle,araKll(enHa[poe](Tt4poBaHr4eM cr4creM3aBOAax, rrporz3Borquluxyue6Hov npouecce Bbrcrrr4x yve6Hrrx3aBeneHr4rxrexHr{qecKoro npo$zrn.4.
OqeHxa coAepr{aHr{q Auccepra r\krv rr ee 3aBeprleHHocrr{fiuccepraqun cocror,rrPICIIOJIE3OBAHHbIX I4CTOIIHI4KOBw3 BBeAeHI'It, [IecrIr fJlat], 3aKrrorleHrq,IZclIllcKarrpuno)KeHr4_rr, coAep)Karqefo aKTbr BHeIpeHLrs.O6rqafio6r'eNt 290 c'rp. ocHoBHofo reKcra, BKJrroqar14crro Jrb3oBaHHbrx14croqHr{KoB corep}Kr.rrBo eneAeuzn o6ocuoBaHa1g0 nazM59pncyHKoBeu os aHrafirr 6ta6tmtryr. Cnncor.aKTyaJlbHocrb pemaelroftB rrzccepraqnrzcQopn'rylzpoBaHbl Ilenb Ir cBfl3aHHble c ee Aocrr.I)KeHr{eM H&}yHIi€Lrnpo6JreMbr,rexHl4qecKue 3anaql4.B uaee 1 npone4eH Teoperllqecrcufi, anattu3 oHepre'ruqercKr4x ycraHoBoK asro14o6urs14 anfoplrrMoe pa6orsr clrcreM 3neKTpocHa6>xenun, HarrpaBJreHHErx Ha rroBbrrrreHueronrueuofi3KoHoMI4 rIHocrrr.B uase 2 nponegeH Teoperl,Iqecrcufr aHuru3ocHoBHbrx MeroAoB pacrrera BbrxoAHbrxnapaMerpoB KoMIIoHeHToB clrcreMa 3neKTpocna6x<eHz.su [ycKa (reneparopuofi ycrauonxz,aKKyMyn-sropHofi 6atapeu, craprepHoro sneKTpoAuararelx) aBTorpaHcrroprHbrxcpercrB.f-rrasa 3 nocnxuqeHa MerorI.'IKe Mo.qenupoBafrj/,fl crzcreM sneKTpocHa6xenuszrvcKa.yrrr4rbrBarorqefi peanrHr,re ycnoBr4r oKcrrnyararlr4lr.hasa 4 nocnxuleHa pa^rpa6orKe MerorlzrIz n o6opyAoBirHr4.f, /{n.s Acnbrranrafr cracrensneKTpocHa6xenus vr nycKa B gKcrlnyararryrr4, a raK)Ke rrpoBepKeaAeKBarHocraMareMarr.,rqecxofi MoAeJrv, paspa6orannoft ehaea 5rperreftfJraBe.nocnrrqeHa pa3pa6orxe reoperurrecKux ocHoBNPIIHUI4NOB YI]PABNCHI,I', O6ECTCqKIEAIoUIHX IIOBbIIIICHT4EczcreM sneKTpocHa6r<enusaBTo rpaH cnfnasa 6 nocnxulenaII CIIOJIb3OBAHI4EoprHbrxco3AaHrz_rre1p$errznnrx9FIeprerl4rIecKI{x norasarereftcp e.qcrB.paspa6orr<e npuHrlr4noB, o6ecueur4Baroul4x orrruMaJrbHoe@yHnquoHaJrr,HbrxaBrorpaHcrroprHofo cpeAcrBa,CBOI-,ICTBa raKlKeCIICTCMI,ISneKTpocHaOx{eHr.rtpa^:pa60rrce pefynsropaHa11p.f,xeHr.rq,o6ecneqrzearcrrlefo BbrrroJrHeHrre paapa6oraHHoro nprrHrlr{na.TeoperzuecKl{e pa3pa6orru aBTopa Ar{cceprarl r4r4 BbrflBrrflror ero BbrcoKyroHayr{Hyro3pyAt4llzrc, yMeHIZe IICIOJIb3OBaTb B cBOI,IX uCCneAOBaHLIflX OcHCTBHbIe IIOJIOXSHTZT14MHO|I4X OorqErrAYUNbIXIITEXHI,IqECKLIXI'1,C,\^TIIZU, 4O6POCO,BECTHbIfi NOAXO.q KBbrBOnbIOIIEHKEco6crneHnrrx pe3yJlbraroB, KporlornuBocrb npr4 orIeHKe pa:inlrqHbrxSaxropon.
AnroprlpoBen e 6orLIxoN4 o6:selre pacqerbl, yqacrBoBara B npoBeAeHrrr4 Tpy.4oeMKaxSKcIIepI4MeHToB' pe3ynbTaTbl KoTopEIX BecbMa I{HTepecHbIIIcolepx{aTeJlbHbr. Kponre rOrO,sKCrIepuMeHTr,I rIoATBepAI4nrr [paBoMepHocrb pa:pa6oraHHofirvqHoaBTODOMMareMarr.rqecrofr MoIerrr4.KsaNaeqaHr4sMno n[cceprarlzouHofi pa6ore cneAye.r orHecrrr cneAyroqee:1' I4s rexcra rkrocepraql4u He tcHo, rITo raKoe Irrar ArrcKpMOIenr4 rr KaK oH orrpeAen_rreTcs.e'r.nr3ar\vt4 MareMarr4r{ecKoe82' lloueiray pacxoA TorInI{Ba6om'[rze 3HaqeHlrt (puc. 35)'Ha npI4BoA cr4creMbr oneKTpocHa6>xeHus r4MeerraKr.reHenon-{rua pa3MepHocrb rro BeprrrKanbuoliocaAaHHororpaQzrca.3. tr4s $oprr.rynsr (1,2) neno:uor(Ho nonyqzrstpopuyny (1,3).4.BIfJraBe o6ocHonrrs aercfl.
aKTyan'Hocrb,groo6r.l'orenaerc_s eo sseneHl4rz. BfraBax (novzuo nepnofi a nropoli) rrocro.qHHo rrorBJrrrorcxo6sopu paHHeecAenaHHbIX pa:pa6oroK' qro 3arpyAHter orlpeAeneHr4eaBTopcnofo BKJra.4a. o6rF{no o6sopyocraJIbHbIXnpe4brlytqv x14ccneAo sauufi. orB oAr.rrctr5' B rexcre rI4ccepTaIIuI41 __srrasa.Bcrper{arorc.s oreqarKr{,B HeKoropux SopvyJraxHeBLIAeJIeHI'I nOACTpOTIHbIe V HaACTpOTIHbIeIIHAeKCbI, rITO 3aTpyAH.f,eT T{X IrOHZMaHI,re, pa3HlreBeJrr.rqrrHr,r o6ognaqarorc.s oAuHaKono (VuTeKCTac'Ip,l2r-r23Yr<aganHr'reHe ce-flsauaro_ cKopocrr, n (2.20)la ycKopeHues (2.25)), uacrrcMbrcJry c r43JraraeM6rM Marellr4aJ,roM.BbIIle 3aMeqaHI4t He r{3MeH{ror o6qeft no.noNzre:*HofrorleHKr,rAuccepTa\w.Bce cxasaHHoe Aaer rlpaBo cqararb rrzcceprarluro tlepuoBaA.E.
3aBeprrreHHbrMr4ccneAoBaHr4eM, Koropoe Aaer paspa60rvur<yHayqHO-Mero4zvecxufr antrapur,''o3Bor'srcr{2fis$SerrI4BHo pelrarb pa3rl4tlHble r.rH)r(eHepHbre 3anar{',Bo3HrrKaroqr4eBIlpoqecce co3AaHU.s cr4creM erercrpoo6opyAoBaHrr_f,aBToTpaHcrroprHbrx cpeAcrB.HayvHr'Ie pa6orrr, ony6mxonaHHlle no reMeAr{cceprau vu (39 pa6or, 14 zs xoroprxony6lzxonaHbl B r43laHzrflx,peKoMeHAoBaHHbrx BAKPo, oAHoN,r rrareHTe Ha zso6pererrr{e, 144 tpygax xoHsepeuqztz), 4ocrarorrHo pacKpbrBaror ee ocHoBHoecoAepxaHue, fleqarHbreTpyIbI ucoIeplKaHI'Ie ,Ilzcceprarryv xapaKTepr43yror gepHonacnoxr4Bl'efocr yqeHOrO C BbrcoKori reoperzqecxofi no4roronrorzi.{uccepraqlrfl' orru.qaerc-s BbIcoKIrM Kaqecrnovrof,opM.rreHr4-rrA.E.