Автореферат (1173694), страница 7
Текст из файла (страница 7)
a3MeHeHueBpeMeHr4creqeHlleMKpyra ofnexmoo [paBa .racfiIofi co6crseHHocr]I. ,{auuufi rrpoqeccnpoucxoAr{T HerrpepbrBHo Ha rrporDKeHLIIi ncefi rlcropuu cyulecrBoBannfl 'racrHoftco6crnesHocrr{. Tax, qeJroBeK (pa6) BbIcryrIaJI B KarlecrBe o6rerra 'racrHofico6crseuHocrrr B ApeBHeM Mr{peu g.a>Ke -B BI{Ae ucKJlroqeHLrs.-Ha Haq€t[bHoM3Tane Mr{poBoro KoHcrr{TyrIlIoH€rnLI3Ma (nanpuuep, KocBeHHo pa6oma,qeHl{e[pr43HaBaJra KoncruryrJus,CIXA).
ConpeueuHoe xe [paBo, npf,Mo3a11peq€u pa6crao KaK r<pafiHeenI4JILI KocBeHHoBorILTaIrIe HecrIpaBeAJII{Boe cocrotHuenecso6oAbr, [p]r3Haer B KalrecrBe o6texros [paBa co6crneuHocrl{ He roJIbKoTpa,qIlIILtoHHbre Marepl,rtubHble Belqv, Ho I,I <<6ecrelecHble), ((HeMarepkIuulbHble)>o6rerru,BqacrHocru nHSopMarIrIo (cr. 69 Koucturyqun Erunra2014 r., cr.233lKoHcrzryqnr,r fpyswu 1995 r., cr.
33 Koucrvrylqlzrkr MorAonrr 1994 r.), a raKxenpaBarpe6onannrperrrenlnrMprECrr[I).pa3rurrHbre collla€ulbHbre BbrrrJrarbrllpzcoorBercrBr{Lt ceroM rrocKonbKy Kpyr o6rerron rpaBa .racrHofiBecbMa cyqecrBeHHo 3arparuBaer upanonofi crarycCOOCTBEHHOCTLI[OnyqaroTKOHCTTTTyTILIOHHOeAnrop oco6o [oAqepKLIBaer, qro pocrzn$opl,raqnoHHo-COOCTBEHHI{KOB I4 krHbIX JILrrI, BaXrHer4IrII4e OObeKTbIoQoprraneuze.(nrexHonorufi [p]IBoAI4T r< QoprrarapoBaHllro (Bl4pry€ubHoroKoMMyHr{KarIproHHbrxgKoHoMlrqecKoro flpocrpaHcrBa), (Bl{pry€lJlrnofi co6crseHHocrll), Koropblerp e6yroro cMbI c JI e lavrs.tr up aa o n o fi p errl aMeHTar\sLr.Cne.4yrorqefi renAesqzfi coBpeMeHHoro pa3Bvrrufl, qacrnofi co6creeHHocrl{rBJr.rrercs coqemoHue uHmezpaqauaduQQepeHqual4uu KoHcrrITyIIIroHHo-rrpaBoBoro peryJrr4poBaHvrs, .{acrHofi co6crseHHocrlr. ,{nQQepeHIIkIaIIrtnpof,BnreTc'' B ToM,qToKoHcTLrTyrILroHHO-[paBOBOe perynupoBaHI4e qacrnofico6crseuHocrLT B pa3Hbrx rocyAapcrBax cyryecrBeHHo orJlllqaerc.f, B 3aBLIcIiIMocrI4or IdAeoJrofl{qecKl{x, gKoHoMI4qecKHX I{ IToJII{TI{rIecKLIX IleHHocrefi romperHoron 3arraAHbrx rocyAapcrBax npl{3Haercs IopI{AI4qecKoe paBeucrBoBcex $op* co6crseHHocrlr, B corlr4€IJrrrcrr{qecKI4x crpaHax, KaK rIpaBI4JIo,o6ulecrna.
Tar,rrpr{oplrrer orAaH o6ulecrsennofi (rocyaapcrnennofi) co6crseHHocru, a qacrnas.BMycyJIbMaHcKI[xrocyAapcTBax, ocHoBaHHbrx Ha npr.IHrII4rIax ruapl{aTa, He MoryT6rrrr o6tenrauzco6crseHHocrbwr6oyrpa3AueHa,nu6oolpaHl4rleHa;[paBa qacrHofi co6crnenHocr]r 3eMeJIbHbIe y^{acrKl{ I{ BoAHbIe MaccI{BbI. OAuaronpu BceM 3ToM rrapaJrneJrbHo rrpoucxoAtr npoqeccbl c6luNeHus npaBoBbxcr,rcreM Lr HHKoprropvrpoBalkrfl, sapy6eNnrrx IlHcrrlryroB B c$epe rpaBaco6crnenHocru, yakrlrtrBaeras.
BJrr{flHI{e Mex.qyHapoAHoro rlpaBa (npeueHufi EnpoueficKoro cy4a no npaBaM qeJloBera) ua roJIKoBaH?reperyJrr4poBaHlre[paBa qacruofi co6crneHHocrl{BpaMK€xrou14ql{cJrerlpaBoBoeHaIII4oHzuIbHbIXrrpaBoBbrx cr{creM.B .racruocrlr, poccuftcrzfi sarcoHoAareJlb,coqlr€url{crurqecKoro3ar,rMcrBoBurJrcrpeM-scb ycKopurb [epexoArvrra xossficrnoBanvrfl K prrnovuofiorgKoHoMI4Ke, IxupoKoycneuHbre uHcrLrryrbr sapy6exnoro 3aKoHoAareJlbcrBa, rtpnqeM He32TOJTbKOkr3 TpaArrquoHHo poAcrBeHHofo poccr4ficKoMy rrpaBy repMaHcKorovrSpauqyecKoro lpaxAaHcKoro rrpaBa, Ho vr rI3 aHrurmarcoscrofi upanonoficucreMbr.Bpe3ynbrare, B lpaxAaHcKoM o6opore [orBrrJrlrcbAeHe)KHbre cpeAcrBa>, (oe3AoKyMeHTapHbIe<<6esHanuqHblerleHHbre 6yuarn>, duore.rHrrecepru$urarbr yqacrr4r, AoBepr4TeJrbHoe y[paBneHrie uMyrrlecrBoM, nLrslrHr. Tarc, n2003r.BLTAoBB rpaxq{ascrufi o6opor BBeAeHbI I4tloreqHble IIeHHhre 6yuaru, oAHtIMpI3Koropbrx .sBrrrorcr r{rroreqHble cepruQuraru yqacrr4fl., KoropblerrocrpoeHbr Ha rrpvHrlurrax aHrJro-aMepllKaHcKoro npaBa.Tarofi rIoAxoA BycJroBrrrx KoHTLTHeHT€LrrbHbrx npaBoBbIX rpagwlquit IpLIBoAI{TB orHoIxeHLILt [paBa co6ctnenHocrl4:rrporr{Bopeuuit, rJraBHbrM o6parour.rroreqHoe [oKpbrTr.{e cepTr4snraron wacTkrfl, He MonrerBco6crseHHocrr{coorBercrBLrncK MHo)KecrBy6urr o6rexrou [paBalpa}K4ancro-uparonofi rparronrofi [paBaco6crnenHocrrr; 3aKpernenHas,3arcoHou o6 I4I-p o6rrla.s AoJIeB€uI co6crseuHocrbBnaAenbrlen cepruQr{KaroB rrpor}rBopeql4T rIpI4HIILIlaM, ycraHoBJIeHHbIMPO vru.
1 6 fKreopuefi lpaxAaHcKoro npaBa.rrporl{Bopelrufl, Bo MHoroM cnoco6norpaALIIIIaoHHo rIoAAepxI{BaeMhIMflpe4cranrrflercfl,qrocH-rrrb AaHHbreKoHrlerrry€urbHoe KoHcrrrryrlrroHHoe peuleHlieo Kpyre o6reKros qacruofico6crseHHocrr{ Ha ocHoBe pa3yMHoro I4cIroJIb3oBaHLIa nrrpa6oraunblx nazpoaoftrrpaKTr4Kofi uoAxoAoBTarxe Bs [pueMoBK peryJII,IpoBaHLTro AaHHoroLrncrvrryra.KaqecrBe reH.{eHrlr{Lr pa3Burus, .racruofi co6crneHHocr}IvrcooTBeTaTByroqero ilpaBa Ar{ccepTaHT BbIAeJUIeT OQtUflneHAe ee ZnpaHmuil, noco6euHocrr{-vrnquBr4qyalrHofi co6crBeHHocrl{. llogurueHble acrleKTrr AansofiTeHAeHrIr{U 3aKrroqarcT0.flBCTpeMneHI4I4 3aKOHOAaTentHeAOTIyCTI{Tb3Jroynorpe6leuzfi [paBoM .racruofi co6crneuHocrrl n yqep6 I4HrepecaM IlHbrxqJreHoBo6qecrna; orptrrlareJrbHbre- BorcyrcrBLIl{4olxnofirrpolleAypbl/\(uexauuerraa) u KpHTepHeB ocyu1ecrBJleHlls BbItIJIarbI cnpaBeAJlIlnofi KoMrleHcaqr,rLlIIpugKcrrpo[pr4ar\r4kr,a raKx(e [polopUI4oHaJIbHbIX ocuonaHzfi,MexaHH3MoB Lr olpa:nu\euuirOcna6lenLre raqtalaTufiqerKlfxcauofi sKcrlponpvar\ukr.racrHofi co6crseHHocrLI..racrHofi co6crseHHocrl4 IpaxAaH o6yclonneHo, Bo-rrepBbrx, pearru:aquefi coqraalrnofi Qyurcqun co6creeHHocrll; Bo-BTopbIX,aaJJMLTpoBbrM$znanconhrM KpLr3r4coM, Bbr3BaBIrIIaM yMeHbrueHrae AoxoAoB HaceJrenvrfl.,cHI4xeHI4eM crolaMocrrl r,rMyrrlecrBa; HaKoHerI, eofiHaiuu,BJreKyrIILrMrrryMaHurapnrrfi rpus[c.
Asrop o6ocuoBblBaer, qro KoHKperHbrM]r [porBJreHwtMvrfapaHTrrr4rrpaBa qacrHolrocra6renus KoHcrrrryrlrroHHo-upaBoBblxco6crseHHocrr{ cneAyerBbrrrJrar, 3aprrJrar&"tur", B qacrHocrl4, coKpalrleHrrez c6epexeuuit, yBenvqeHl4e HaJIoroBpIcoqpl€ulbHbrxT.Ir.Ha {oue ocna6lenug KoncrlrryulroHHo-npaBoBbrx rapanrnfi .IacrHofico6crseHHocrlr fpax(AaH B cBr3rr c yMeHblrreHneM nJrlr HeBbrnrarofi coqLI€uIbHbIXuoco6ufi, neHcufi, yBennqeHLIeM H€rnoroB, rrponcxo4rlT pocm rpynnofiKopnopamueruort, KoJlileKmueruofi ,tacmuofl coficmeeruHocmu vr Bce 6oleeycvnuBaroqeecr ee Bo3Aeficrsue Ha rocyAapcrBo H MexAyHapoAHoe npano.
BycnoBr{sx gKoHoMprqecroft uecra6unbHocrl{ rocyAapcrBarroAAep)KvrBarb Kpy[Hbre rrpe4rrpvrrTLrfl, 146anru. 3ro AaerBbIHyxAeHbrBo3Mo)KHocrbrrocJreAnr4M ocyqecrBJrrrb pr{cKoBaHnyro QznaHcoByro Ae-f,TenbHocrb,ue 6oscrKopnoparzBHiul co6crseuHocrb HepeAKo craHoB[Tc{odanrcporurbcs.TpaHcrpaHraquofi. Co6crneuHuKrl TaKIrtx Koplopaqr,rfr orasrrBalor cyulecrBeuHoeunoJrr{Tr4rlecKoegKoHoMlrqecKoe BIrurnlnvreKpynHbIX KoprtoparluitHa rocyAapcrBa. ,{errelruoctru 6anxon, ocHoBaHHas.
Ha JILttIHbrxrroApbrBaer gKoHoMrrrre cKrle, KyJrbrypHble, AyxoBHbIeoLlHTepecax, 3arlacrylocHonrr o6rqe crna.Anrop orMerraer HeodHosHaqHocmb BbI{BJIeHHsx meruderuqufi. Px[ us Hrax3acJryxr{BaroT rroAAepxKr{,B TOM TII4CJIe KOHCTI{TyIItrOHHO-IpaBOBbIMI{MHeHI{ro ALIccepraHTa,orHoctrctpa3yMHar 14 au$SepeHqkrpoBaHH€ur rloAAepxKa yssBr{MbIX cJIoeBla.acenrenr4tlcpeAcrBaMra.Kno3umu6Hbr.l/t "reHAeHIItItM,tlocoqraalrnofi Qyurquz co6crnenHocrll, pacruupeHue o6rerrosqacruofi co6crseHHocrr,r 3a cqer <6ecrelecHblx) (uervrarepualrurx) o6rerron,rrocpeAcTBoMB3ar,rMHOe I4CIOJIb3OBaHI4e IO3LITI{BHO|OOfIbITa peryJl}IpoBaHnflqacrnofico6ctseuHocrl{ coBpeMeHHbIMLI rocyAapcrBaMu.klusteTeHAeHIILII4I4MeIor ueeamueuatil xapaKmepHlpLrocraHoBJIeHI4t Aeitcrsus. (cyulecrneHHoe orpaH[qeHLIe [paBco6creeuHrrKoBnrpe6yrorqACTHbIXrapaHTprfi co6crBeHHocrll, yMeHblxeH[e AoxoAoB HaceJIeHI{rI c34pocToM KoplopaTLrBHor{ coocTBeHHocTLr, nooqpeHrle ux.{uBeHqecTBaHaceJreHLTrr BqacTLrrrpoqecce nepepac[peAeneHrrr AoxoAoB HaceJreHr4f,).I4ccue.qonanne cyqecrByloulzxreu4enqzfi pa3Burkrfl, qacrnofico6creeHHocrll rlo3BoJrrrno BrITBLITI cneAyroque nepcneKmunb,KoHcrI4TyIII4oHHo-[pu"o"o.o perynl4po BaHvfl.racrHofi co6crseHHocrr{pa3BurLrfl.trrrpaBa HaHee:-fapMoHyl3arlvs, Me)KAyHapoAHofoT4HCTI{TyTOB kIlpaBa, efor4HKoproptrpoBaHHbrxBHyrplrrocyAapcrBeHHoro KoHcrlrryrllroHHoro npaBapefyJrrpoBaHI|Ifl .{acrHofi co6crseHHocrll (upeN4e Bcefo, HopM [paBaoB cQeperleHHbrx6yiuarax, [paBax rpe6onankrs, LrrTerrneKTy€ulbsoft co6crBeHHocrz, uH$opvraquu);-coBeprrreHcTBoBaHLre KoHcrlITyIIrIoHHo-[paBoBbrxUX F,aIranca MeX{Ay r4HTepeCaMLr qaCTHbrXAOCTr/DKeHCO 6MEXAHI{3MOBCrS eHHr{KOB LI OOIICCTBA BpaMKax peurvrcarJvrkr coquamsofi SyHrqIaz co6crseHHocrll (ycrpaHeHLreHefarr.rBHbrx reu4enqzfi peaJrr{3arlnll coqua$nofi syurcquz co6creeHHocrrr;rroAAepxKa pr 3arrllrra un4uBpr4'yamnofi .racrHofi co6creeuHocrLr, B rracrHocrll,npuBbrrrJrare clpaBeAnusofi KoMrreHcaIII4I4tlpuu3lflTLru LIMyIrIecrBa p'nfl.o6qecrneHHo 3HarrurMblx qerrefi );-BbrrBJreHr4e xapaKTepHbrxrlepr xpynnofi KoprloparusHofi.racrHoftco6creeHHocru; ocyulecrBJreHr{e upanonofi perJraMeHTar\vrkr AorIycrI{MbIXcnoco6osr4MeroAoB ee Bnrd{Hvrfl.HarocyAapcrBeHHyro BJracrb u?rx orpaHLTqeuuit;pa3Br{Trre rrpaBoBoro peryJrr4poBaHr4s corll4ulnbHofi ornercrBeHHocrw 6uzyeca;-rroBbrrrreHzeponvKoHcTr{TyrIr4oHHofo rrpaBaBperynupoBaHvrkloco6eunocreft HeMarepuurJrbHbrx o6reKros [paBa qacruofi co6crnenHocrl{,BrracrHocrr4, r,rnQopuarlr{oHHbrx o6rexros (<nupryanrnofi co6crseHHocrLD),(Blrpry€rJrbHoro rrpocrpaHcrBa))LIAp.).3aKrro.reHne ArlcceprarlktoHHofi pa6orhl coAepxur BbIBoAbI, cAenaHHblepe3yJrbTaTe npoBeAeHHofo r4ccneAoBaHkrfl.perynupoBaHvrfl .racrHofi co6crseHHocrl4BBKOHcTI{TyIILIOHHO-IpaBOBO|OcoBpeMeHHoM MHpe, BbuIBJIeHI4tTeHAeHrdLrfi ra nepcneKTLIB ee pa3Burrvrfl.35CIII4COK PAEOT, OIIYEJIITKOBAHHbIX ABTOPOM TIO TEMEAIICCEPTAIII,INIly6.nunaq[rrBxypHaJrax, BxoAq[IrIx B rrepeqeub perlen3rrpyeMbrxHayrrHbrx xypHaJroB rr rr3AaHnfi, percoMeH,qoBaHHblxBAK nplr Mnno6pnaynuPoccllll4.nn ony6Jrr{KoBaHuq ocHoBHbIx HayqHbrx pe3yJrbraroB Aucceprallurl:t.