Автореферат (1173694), страница 3
Текст из файла (страница 3)
KAns, ycraHoBneHLrs, 6atancaAeMoKparr{rrecKoro rocyAapcrBa, c- c 4pyrofi.qrlcJry eaacuettruux cospeweHHbtx meruderuqurt paseumun npasaqacmuoil co6cmeeuHocmuueeo KoHcmumyquoHHo-npaaolozopezyJruponaHuncJreAyeT oTHecrr4:- y cnJreHrae coqrraJrbHofi Synrcq Lrkr qacrHofi co6 crBeHHocrl4 ;- ocJra6lenue KoHcrrlTyrlrroHHo'[paBoBbrx rapaurufi.racrHofico6crsennocrt4;r0-ocJra6JreHrre pr]F'IiLrBul'y€urbHofiqacrHofi co6crBeHHocrt4 v pocrKopnopaTr4BHofi qacTHofi co6crBeHHocrrlt, oKa3brBaroqefi olpoMHoe BrrvrflIFlue HaoOuecrso-r'rrocyAapcrBeHHylo BJIacrb;pacrunpeHrre Kpyrao6rerroeKoHcrLITyIII4oHHoroco6crseHHocrr{,B ToMunSopuaqlillo6lexra [paBa .racrHofi co6creeHHocrrl;-KaK"iranacoqeTaHr.re r{HTefpar\vru3aKperIJIeHLIe[paBa .IacrHofiHa KoHcrlrryr{rroHHoMn auQQepeHIII,IaIII4I{ypoBHeKoHcTI{TyIII{OHHO-IpaBOBO|OperyJrupo Ba:rtvrfl, qacrHofi co6crseHHocrl,t.Kax,qax us o6osHaqeHHbrx reHAeHr{ufi parnrErLrr qacrHofi co6crBeHHocrl4r.rMeerprA npof,nneuufi, Koropbre pacKpblBalorcr B nocneAylolqux rronoxeHnf,x,BbrHoclrMbrx Ha 3aIqI{Ty.3.
Haz6olee san,temuoil u3 nepequcileHubtxmeudeuquaycureHufl coquailbHoilQyurcquu uacmHoil co6cmaeHHocmL,Ona flBlrflercfl. BecbMacot4u&rttrnaqun.meudeuoluil abtcmynaemcJIo)KHbIMSenouenou,urueeBKJIIoqaTIcJreAyrouhe acneKm6, coAepxaHvfi.:Bo-uepnrx, co6crneHHrrKKoJrr{rrecrBo KorophrxclloruzuoyBeflLrrrrdBaercfl.Hiurorlr [o.f,Br{JrrrcburroMr4MoaKTuBr43aquefinpaB HMeer raKxe o6nsauuocmlt,counalruofi SyurqNu co6crneuHocrrlKJraccr4rlecroft o6ssaHuocru co6creeHHuKoB rlJlarvrbnoJrfrLrJrra KoHcrI4TyIILIoHHoeo6sgauuocrr,I: ryMaHHo orHocr{Tct K xIlBorHbIM(ct.
72 KoHcruryuunco6crseuHocrr{rrcrroJrb3oBarb 3eMJrooTHoc.f,rrluec.f,(cr. 44raroQopulenue r4x HoBbIeo6teKTaM npaBa qacrnofir.),Cronenupr 1990KoHcrvrcyr\krpro6pa6arnBarb I{Typuuz 1982 r.), nrruoJrHtrb 3allaqu,K ot<pyxaroqefi cpeAe, rIaMlTHrIKaMKyJIbTypbI(c".20Koucruryquz CloBaKHr4, cr. 54 KoscrI{ryIII4rI Jlutnu, cr.cr. 11, 35 XapruuocHoBHbrx rrpaBncso6oA rlexuzI99I r.) u r.u. flpuoroM I{ KJlacc}IqecK€tto6ssaHHocru co6crBeHHr4KoB nJrarr{Tb H€trIorI{ B coqualbHoM rocyAapcrBe I{MeerTeHAeHrIr{rcK3aMerHoMy[por.r3BoAI{MbIen3pocry coorBercrByloq}Ix o6peueHeuufi, rlogroMyCpeACTB 3TLIX H€LIOrOB pa3naqHblecoquaJrbHble BbIrIJIarnSarulqecKll rrpeAcraBJltrror co6ofirocyAapcTBeHHbIeIIepepacIIpeAeJIeHLIe.racrHofi co6creeuHocrl{.1lBo-eroprrx, coquaJrbHa{ $ynrqux co6crnenHocrr{ [peAlonaraer qerrrfipsA KoHcrrrryrlrroHHbrx 3anpemos: [pr4 ocyrqecrBJreHlTlr cBor{x rrpaB co6crnesnurHe AorrlKeH HaHocLrc yn1ep6 oKpyxaloqefi cpe4e, 6e:onacHocrrr rocyAapcrBa,eceo6quNa LrHTepecaM, LrcropuqecKnM Lr KynbrypHbrM rleHHocrrM, 3AopoBbK)mo4efi, Hapyruarb npaBaB-rperrux,4py.r" nrq.KoHcrvrryrJuflMr4 rrpeAycMarplrBaerc.rr aosu4oJtcHocmb u3bflmuflqacmuoil co6cmeeuHocmu B lrHTepecax o6u{ecrBa, Koropar aKTr{Blr3rrpyerct HarrpaKTrrKe BMecrerrpo{BJrf,-flcb,(ecaKTkrBvrzar\uefi coqvanrl3arlkru rocyAapcrBB ToM qncJre, BTaKr,rxrpafiuzx Sopvrax, KaKI{ KoHcr[Tyr\krir,HallrloHzulu3ar\ufl.rc up on puagux) LrMyrrle crB a.4.
KorucmumyquoHruorc odasaHHocmarroApa3AeJrlrrbHacmHozo codcmeeuHuKe MoxHona o6ulrEe r4 cneur4€rJrbHble. O6u4ue o6nsauuocmu)KaK rIpaBLIJIo,pacupocrpaHflrorcr Ha Bcex qacrHbrx co6crseHHI{KoB. Cner{uanbHble o6ssaHHocrpl4eficrnyror roJrbKo B orHorrreHkrn co6crseHHI{KoB orIpeAeneHHbIX o6lexron. KlepBbrM orHocrrcx: o1xzarrHocrb co6moAarb 3aKoHoAareJlbcrBo, He HapyllrarbrlpaBa rperbl{x JII4I1 tIJIarHTb HaJIorI{, o6ecne.runau gKoJlon{qecKylo6esonacHocrb. 3na.rlrrerbHatr rracrb o6u{nx o6ssaHnocrefi coAepxllTcf, BKoHcrrlTyrlulr rocyAapcrBa.B3aBI4cLIMocrIior o6rerra [paBa.Iacfiroftco6crnenHocrr4, cyulecrByer MHoxecrBo cnequailbHbtx o6asauuocmeilco6crnenHvKoB, Harrpr{Mep, o6rsanHocrl{ co6crseuul{KoB 3eMeJIbHbIX)IacrKoB,o6ssaHHocru co6crseHHlrKoB uorrrelqeuufi, o6ssaHHocru co6crseHHllKoBAoMarrrHr.rx )KtrBoTHbrx r4T.rr.
Tarze o6ssaHHocTI,I ycTaHoBJIeHbI IIO 6OlrrUefi-.lracru orpacJreBbrM (cuequalrrHuira) 3aKoHo,qareJlbcrBoM.AeJraeTc{ Jrr4rxb HeKoTopbrMr4 KoHcTr{TyIILIf,MI4co6crnenHocrrrHa3eMJrro BBr4Ay(npnrraepoM Moxrer cnyxr4rb cr. 44- B OCHOBHOM An{ IrpaBa qacruofiKoucrnryqzu Typuuvr 1982r. r4Irr4 cr. 155qro o6pa6oma vvcno.Ilb3oBaH]Ie- o6.ssauuocrb 3eMJleBnaAenbua rro orHoIUeHI4Io5.O4Hzrr,r vr3I4cKlIoqeHLTeoco6ofi 3HaqI{MocrI{ AaHHoro o6terraBefirraapcrofi KoHcrvrryrlkrvr rpoBo3rnarra[a,3eMJrr4ZsorAaK o6rqecrny).nocleAcrnzfi [pLr3HaH]Irr coqnannnofi Synrcquu .racrHofico6crnenHocrr4 .sBr.sercr HeKoropoe ocnadneHue ee eapaHmafi, y oco6ennocrurt2vrH4vrBvrIly€lJlbHofi coocTBeHHocTr{,qTo Tox{e MoxHocqLrTaTb coBpeMeHHor,rTeHAeHIII,Iefi pazuurvrfl. npaBa .racrHofr co6crseHHocrrr.KaK Iro3IzTLIBHbIe,3aKrroqarorc.f,B[auuat reHAeHrluf, LrMeerTaK vr HefarI4BHhIe npo{BneHl4fl.
Ee IIo3I,ITI4BHbre acleKTblcrpeMneHr{}r 3aKoHoAareu HerrpaBoM .racrHofi co6crseHHocrlrn yqep6Aolycrlrrb 3noyrrorpe6neunfir{HTepecaM HHbrx rrJreHoB o6qecrsa.OrpuqareJrbHbre acrreKTbr Aasnofi TeHAeHIILII4[posBn{eTcf,, B rIacTHocTI4,orcyrcrBur4 Aolxnofi npoqe.qypbl (rraexanusvra)uBbrrrJrarbr clpaBeAnzeofi KoMrreHcar{uurrpv.racrHofi co6creeHHocrr{. flpe4cranIrflercfl.,npanonofi olpeAeneHHocrlrnKpurepr{eB ocyTrlecrBrreHLrs.gKcrrpolpvrar\Lrvr,I{ orpaHr4.reuufi cauoficrrpaBeAJrrrBbrx ocHoBaHrafi, ruexaulr3MoBqroauoAqacBecbMa yAaqHbrM rrprrMepoM14 o6rqecrsa {BJrsercrBenecyelrr, B roropofi HeKynbrr4Br{pyeMble ceJlbcKoxossficrneHubreo6lararorcrrroBhrrrreHHbrM H€uroroM,aecJII4-efoJlfrruero rarofiA€LJrbHerrrxeM [peAocTaBJrfleTct6esseN,renbHblM Kpecrb-f,HaM, Koropble o6-rsyrorc.f,foAa BrrpaBe nproopecrl{orrblTgeuemgrrfi fracroK nnoula.qbrocBbrrrre 100 remapon) He I{crloJlb3yerct Ha 80 yo,r{acToK 3eMJrr4 sK0rrponpvupyeTcfl. u BKMaccLIBbI6olee 5 Tbrcrq reKTapoB (a Anr.
3eMeJIb, KaqecrBo Koropblxcpe4nepafioHHorovr3Kcrrponpvar\vrLro6ocnoBaHHoro rlportopquoH€urbHoro rroAxoAacoorHorrreHLTro nHTepecoB co6crseHHI{KoBBero Bo3.{enbrBarbI4 rrepe3 TpI4B co6crseHnocrb. llpe4cranlrflercqenecoo6pa3HbrM yqecrb Aannrrfi rro3Ltrl4BHufiourrr Benecysnbl B pocczficr<ov3aKOHO.[areJIbCTBe.6. BaNuofireuAenqzefi pa3BlaTufl, KoHcrLITyrII4oHHoro [paBa 'IacrHofico6crnenHocrlr flBlrflercs.
To, rrro npoucxoArT pocm I{ Bce 6onee ycl4nllBaroqeectno:4eficrnne Ha rocyAapcrBo 14 Mex{AyHapoAHoe npaBo Kopnopamueuort,KoJuteKmueruofi qacmHoit coficmeeruHocmu. TaKas co6crseHHocrb craHoBl4TctTpaHcrpann.rHofi. Co6crneuHtrKtr oKa3blBaror cylqecrBeHHoe IToJII{TI{qecKoe }IgKOHOMr4qeCKOe BlrrrflHl..'eHA fOCyAapcTBauMe)KfocyAapcTBeHHbIe coro3blBJIUqHbrx [HTepecax, 3arracTyro rroApblBa{ SKoHoMutIecKZe, KyJIbTypHbIe,AyxoBHbIe ocHoBbI o6qecrsa.137. Oauofi vr3 reu4euqufipa3Bvrrkrfl .racrHofi co6crseHHocrucooTBeTcTByrcIrlefo IIpaBa "rrBrf,eTcr usJrreHeHaevrc TeqeHLreM BpeMeHV Kpyraor rrpLr3Halanfl qeJroBeKa (pa6a) nco6crnenHocrlr B ApeBHeM MLrpe u AalKe - B BnAeof'uexmoe [paBa .racrHofi co6creeHHocru:KaqecrBeo6terra .racrHofiI'IcKJIIoqeHuA-Ha HaqaJl"io* gTarle Ml4poBoro KoHcrr4TyrlLroH€rJrLr3naa (uauprrMep,KocBeHHo pa6onla4eHl4e nprBHaBaJIaKoucruryUux CIIIA) Aorrpr{3HaHr{to6rerrauu zu$opvraquu (Eruuer, fpysrEx, Mol4ona), a raK}KecoIII{€uIbHbrx Bbrrrnar B coorBercrBvrvr c perrreHLrrrrrar,r ECIH.
Pasyrraeerc ., KpyrTaKI{Mr.ro6tercros [paBa .racrHofi co6crseHHocrla BecbMa cyqecrBeHHo 3arparlrBaernpanonofi craryc co6crnesHl4KoB LI I4HrIX Jrrrq, BcneAcrBr4e qero saxHefirxueoobeKTbl,a raKme r43MeHeHne ux Kpyfa rroJrrraroTKoHcTr{TyrI}roHHoeoSopuleuze.8.Covemauue aHmezpaquuuduQQepenquar4uu KoncrlrryrlnoHHo-rlpaBoBoro peryJrrlpoBaH[rr .racruofi co6crseHHocrrr KaK oAHa r{3 coBpeMeHHbrxTeHAeHIIUfi pasnzu{rr AaHHoro I4HcrI4Tyra HaxoAlrr orpa}Keur4eogttofi cropoHbr, [poucxoAlrr pa3MexeBalnlrteB ToM, rrro,cKoHcrrrryrltroHHo-[paBoBoroperynrdpoBanr4fl..IacrHofi co6creeHHocrl4 B crpaHax c pa3HbrMr{ r4AeoJronrqecKr,rMr,rI4 BbITeKaIoIuI{MIa }I3 Hrrx gKoHoMI4qecKr{MLr u [oJIrrrLrqecKI4MLr IreHgocrrvrz.
Bsanaduwxcmpanaxlpr43Haercf, lopr4Ar4qecKoe paBeHcrBo Bcex Soptco6crseHHocrr4. llpano .{acrHofi co6crseHHocrlr 6 coqueJtucmwtecKlffi cmpoHoqKaK IpaBLIJIO, CyIqeCTBeHHO OrpaHuqeHo HJIW 3alpeqeHo, [pEOpI4TeT IIpI{3HaeTCt3a o6qecrnennofi(rocy4apcrnenHofi) co6crseHHocrbro.cmpaHax, ocHoBaHHbrx Ha rrplrHrlurrax uapuara)He MoryT.racruofi co6crseHHocrrr3eMeJrbHbre yracrKr4BMycyrbMaHcKttx6lrrr o6rerrarr,rvilpaBar{ Bo.{Hbre MaccrrBbr. C 4pyrofi xecropoHbr, ua6lroAaerc.s c6mNenue npaBoBbrx crrcreMgr.rHKoplopr4poBaHuerapy6exnbrx rrHcrlrryroB B cQepe [paBa co6creeHHocr]r, a raKxe ycunlenpreBnrptflHurfl,MexAyHapoAHoro \paBa, B qacrHocrra, peureHrEfi Enponeficroro cyAa nonpaBaM qeroBeKa, Ha ToJrKoBaHLreu[paBoBoe peryJrr4poBaHlre lpaBa rIacTHoI4co6crseHHocrr4 B paMKax HaIIuoH€uIbHbIX npaBoBbIX cLIcreM.l49.
BrtssreHHble meruderuqau pa3Btrrufl, qaerHofi co6crBeHHocrr H TrpaBa.racfi{ofi co6crseHHocrl4 HeodHosnaqHb,t. Heroroprre vr3 Hrlx (pasyunaa uanQQepeHIILIpoBaHHar rroAAepxffia yt3BlrMbrx cJroeB HaceJreHlrr rocpeAcrBoMcoqzamnofi Synrcquu co6crsenHocrkr, paclrrapeHrre o6texroe .racrHofico6crnenHocrrr, uru"*iro" ucloJlb3oBaHLre rroJrolKr4TeJrbHoro orrblTaperyJlllpoBaHvrfl, .racrHofi co6creeuHocrl{ coBpeMeHHbrMr{ rocy,{apcrnarran)no3umusHbtH 3acJryxHBaroTnoAAepnffill,B ToM qncreKoHcTr{Tyr{r{oHHo-rrpaBoBbrMrr cpeAcrBaMlr, Apyrl4e IzMeror ueeamueuatil xapaKmepupr{ocraHoBJreHr4r Aeficrr'ufl.
(cyqecrneHHoe orpaHuqeHr,reco6crseuHuKoBlr rapaHTufiurpe6yrorupaB rracrHbrxco6crBeHHocrl{, yMeHbrrreHr{e AoxoAoB HaceJreHu.f, cpocroM Koploparr,rsHofi co6crneuHocrl{, rrooulpeHkre r.DrAr{BeHrrecrBa qacrvrHaceJreHr4rr Bnpoqecce [epepaclpeAeneHl,It AoxoAoB HaceJreuvr).10. C )nreroM 3aAaq rroAAepmKvrro3rlTrrBHbrxrenqenqufi Bpa3Bvrrvru.racrHofi co6crnenHocrr{ u 6opr6rr c [potBJIeHI4rIMLI n 4annofi cSepe Bo3MoxHbIenep cneKmugb, pa3Br4TvrfrKoHcTr4TyIII4oHHo-[paBoBoro peryJrrrpoBaHkrfl, rIacTHoI4co6crseuHocrr{ 14npaBaHa Hee 3aKrloqarcTctBcneAyroqeM:- fapMoHu3a\I4fl MeXAyHapoAHOro IIpaBa, eror{HcTr{TyroBLIHKoplopI4poBaHHbxLr BHyTpr{rocyAapcTBeHHoro KoHcrLrryrllroHHoro rpaBa BperyJrrdpoBanr4s..racrHofi co6crseHHocrll (npeN4e Bcero, HopM [paBaocQepeIIeHHbx6yrraarax, npaBax rpe6onanr4fl., vrrTerrJreKTyulJlbHofi co6crBeHHocrn, uuQopuaqnu);coBeprrleHcTBoBaHLI eAOCTr/DKeHMEXAHI{3MOBKOHCTprTyrIr{OHHO-rpaBOBbrXUs.
6atattca Mex(Ay krHTepecaMLI qacTHblx co6crseHH[KoBpaMKax peaJru3aIII4I4 coqualrnofi Qynrquu co6crseHHocrllHerarr{BHbrx reuAenqufi pe€u}r3aulll{coqualrnofi Qynrqun14OOIUECTBA B(ycrpaneHnecobcrnenHocrl4;[oAAepxKa H 3arrlr{Ta uH1r4Bvrqyamuofi .racrHofi co6crBeHHocrl{, B rlacruocrla,npvBbrrrJrare clpaBeAnunofi KoMleHcaIII{I{o6ulecrneHHo 3HaqrrMbrx rlenefiug+ar43TflTufl, IlMyIIIecrBa AIrfl);Ha ocHoBe Bhr{BJreHu.rr xapaKTepHbrx qepr rpyuuofi KoploparusHofiqacrnofi co6crnenHocrlr ocyulecrBJleHl4e upanonofi peulaMeHTaq.uu Ao[ycrHMbIXcuoco6os r{ MeroAoB ee BJrprsnufl.Ha rocyAapcrBeHHyro BJracrb uvrx orpaHllqenufi;15pa3Br{Tkre rrpaBoBofo6usneca; ycraHoBneHLre nepcoH€rJrbHofipeIueHLIt IIOBJIeKJILI upruLIHeHI,Ie ylqep-nAeI1I coqLr€LJrbHoI4perynupoBaHufloTBeTCTBeHHOCTITOTBeTCTBeHHOCTLI TOII-MeHeA)KepOB, qbkl0a;KOHCTLTTyTILTOHHO rIpaBOBOe peryJrprpoBaHkTeHeMaTepl{uurbHbrx oobeKToBr4H$opMarlr4oHHbrxOCO6eHHOCTefinpaBa llacTHor4 coocTBeHHocTr4, BqacTHocTr4o6rerron (<nrapryanbHofi co6crBeHHocrr.r>).TeoperuqecKaq u [paKTrrrrecKafl 3HaqlrMocrb rrccJreAoBaHl{fl cocrolrrBToM, rrro npeAcraBneHHtur pa6ora AorroJlHfler n pacruvrpfler reoperprqecKpre 3Ha:rtLrs.IIoBorrpocaM KoHcTr4TyrIrIoHHo-rIpaBoBofoco6crBeHHocrrrs Poccr4[ r4 B 3apy6eNnrrxperynr4poBaHLrfl qacTHoucrpaHax; [peAnoxeHHbre BbrBoAbIMOryT ObITb IICIIOJIb3OBaHbI An.[ A€LIbHeI{IIIIX Ha) IHbIX I{3bICKaHI{I{ IIO 3a'BJIeHHOLIrrpo6JreMarr{Ke;BflpaKTr4r{ecrofinpoqecce o6yveuux rro rcpLrALrqecKHM[paBorrpLrMeHLITeJIbHofi,ALTcrILrrrJrrrHaM, BrrpaBorrHTeprrpeTarlHoHHolrrrpaBoTBopqecKofr Ae.f,TenbHocrrr.Anpo6aqr{fl pe3yJrbraroB rrccJreAoBaHuq ocyulecrBJleHa n MocroBcKoMrocyAapcrBeHHoM ropr4Ar.rqecKoM yHr4Bepcnrere HMenu O.E.