Автореферат (1173694), страница 5
Текст из файла (страница 5)
B XX n. KoHcrLIryIII{I{ craHoBtrct6onee coIII4€urbHbrMH, B Hr{x lro;rBJlllorcl HopMbI o roM, rITo co6crseHHI{KI{orBercrBeHHbr6olrruoeMaprc,[epeA o6qecrnou. Ha coquaJll{3alluro roncruryuufiBJTLTA:a:zI@.KOHCTT4TyTIHV,rpyAbr raKr4x MbIcJII{TeJIefi, rax T. Mop,Surerlc. B gro xe BpeMf, rloflBJltlorc.floKa3aJII4fI. xt. flpy4oH,K.coquaJlllcrl,IqecKuerrpoBo3rurarlaroql4e ynpa3AHeHlle'IacrHofi co6crnenHocrl'I. Anroprrro Qr,rnocofcKne B3rnf,Abl o neo6xoAuMocrl{ JIIIKBIaAaIIzU '{acrHofrco6crseHHocrr{ KaK r.rcroqHr4Ka gKcrlJlyara\w B coBoKyrrHocru c coquanbHo-rroJraraer,gKoHoM[rrecKr{Mr4 QaxroparrauBo MHoroM o6yclonulzcorlr4€rlucrzqecrofi MoAenI4 o6qecrsa, rocyAapcrBaI4[otBJIeHkIerconcrnryqufi.2lTperufi uaparpaQ <llcropuqecnafl oBorroquq KoHcrr{TyrlrroHHoro.racrHofi co6crseHHocrlr)) ocBerrlaer HarrpaBneHlrrrperyJrr{poBaHrrflr4cTopkTqecKofo rI3MeHeHLr.s KoHcTHTyI{rIoHHo[paBoBofo perynupoBalInfl..racrHofi co6crnenHocrlr.Cpe4z ocHoBHbr""urriu"gBonrcrlr4r.r AlrccepraHT BbrAenterneuuit 4anHoficJreAyroqve: 1) p€BBr{r}re Kpyra r4crorIHLIKoB npaBa, perynupyrcqux orHolxeHu.rco6crseHHocrr4;.{BIlxeHI4eor2)uzweneHr4e Kpyrao6rexros npaBa.{acrHofi co6crseHuocru; 3)aKrIeHTa Ha rrp}r3HaHLrpr oco6ofi 3HaqrlMocrr{, HelpI4KocHoBeHHocrI{qacruofi co6creeHHocrlr Kco6crseHHocrr4;4)[poBo3rnarrreHr4ro coquamuofi Synrqzz[orBJreHrre KoHcrr4TyIILIoHHor.rHTenneKTyalrnofi co6crseHHocTr4;coqlraJrLrcrlrqecKuxreopuft,5)-rlpaBoBoro peryill4poBaHLT;tnoeHzr<HoBeHLrecB.f,3aHHblxr{BonJrorqeHkre B )KlI3Hbc ynpa3AHeHLIeMvrlrvr cyIqecrBeHHbIMorpaHr{qeHr{eM .racrHofi co6crseHHocrr4; 6) uprasnaHvre gKonon4rlecrofi SynxquuCOOCTBEHHOCTI4.flo.sereHLre KoHcrr{TyrILroHHo-rrpaBoBoro perynl4poBaHkrs, vHcrvrryra vrrpaBa qacruofi co6crnenHocrrr cBr3aHorcoucruryqufiXVIIIccaMlIM Bo3HI{KHoBeHI4eM rIepBbIXBeKa.
OAuaro LlHcrlzryr .racrHofi co6creeHHocrrlcoorBercrByroqee [paBo LrMercT 6onee Anl4TenbHyrc I{crop[IoLrpa3BurLrs,.Tpa4uquoHHo cqr.rraercr, r{To qaerna.s, co6crseHHocrb tIof,BLIJIacb B grloxypa3noxeHrrr nepBo6urnoro o6qecrsa B cBt3kI c rIoAbeMoM no3AHeuepno6rrrHororrpoLr3BoAcrBa.llpanonoe perynupoBaHne vrHcrvrryraco6crseuHocrr{ cJrox{trJrocbBnepr4oAurlpaBa.IacrHoLI[pennero MI4pa. Han6onee rprofioco6ennocrbro ee pernaMeHTarlprkr roro nepl4oAa flBJl.xerc.fl To, qro [oBceMecrHoKaqecrBe o6rema ilpaBa BbrcrylarcT He roJIbKo BeIqLT, HocpeAHr4e BeKa pa3Br4Tr4e vrHcruryraI{ qeroBeK-Bpa6. B.IacrHofi co6crseHHocrl{ cBf,3aHocnorpe6uocrbro cno6oAsux cocJroBrafi gaunrllTb cBoI{ rpaBa, B ToM rII{cJIe npaBoqacrnofi co6crseHHocrlr,BoirbHocrefi>> 1215ornpor43BoJla npaBureJlbcrBa (<<Benur<a-r xaprprlr.). B nepnux KoHcrl{ryllusx [paBy .racrHofi co6crseHnocrl43arracryro [pr{AaBaJrc.rr cBrrrleusufi xapaKTep.
Co6creeHHocrb rloHkTM€trlacb(Herrpr{KocHoBeHHoe Lr cB.f,rrleHHoe> [paBo(cr.KaK17 .{exnapaqurkr npaB qeroBeKaI422rpa)KAaHprHa 1789r., cr.KoHcrrrryrlrroHHbrx aKTax114 Koncruryrlr4vr Ypyrnax 1830XVIII - XIXr. u r.g.). Bo uHornxBeKoB rIoJIolKeHId{ o HerrpraKocHoBeHHocrrlco6crseHHocrlr AorronH.f,rorc.f, ycraHoBJIeHHeM rapanrnfi(Hanpurvrep,rtpu eeH3loflTprvrV uoupaBKa r Koncrzrylluu CIIIA).OAnaro raKr.re ,uput i^npe.qrroJraraJrvry)Ke Ha HaqzurbHoM srarre pa3BurLr;_KoHcrI4TyIII{oHiLIII{3Ma,rITo npaBo .ractHofi co6crseHHocrrr,rrpoBo3rnarrreHHoe (Genpr4KocHoBeHHbIM I{ cB.f,[IeHHbIM)), seTar,cr.
4.{eruapaqr4r4 ilpaB rreJroBeKaLIA€DKe6rtro a6comorHrru.rpax{AaHusa 1789 r. [oAqepKuBaer, qrocno6oAa cocrour B Bo3MoxHocru Aenarb Bce,qro He BpeA{T ApyroMy:TaKIMo6pasou, ocyuecrBJreHrre ecrecrBeHHblx rlpaB Kax{Aoro uMeer JIHIUI re rpaHrIIIbI,Koropbre o6ecneqprBaror Apyn4M rrJreHaM o6qecrna rroJrb3oBaHlae reMrl xerrpaBaMr4.Pa:szrIae KoHcr]rryrlr4oHHoro peryJll,IpoBanvrfl ]IHcrLITyra vr npaBa qacroilrco6crnenHocrlr orpaKaercfl, B qacrHocrr4, B krcropuqecKoM LI3MeHeHwr Kpyrao6terros npaBa .racrHofi co6crseHHocrll. Bnnorr Ao cepeAUHbI XX serano6texron npaBa qacurofi co6crseHHocrl4 npu3HaBaJILIcbrrper4MyrqecrBeHHo Marepr{€LnbHhre Belqu. llpu oroM B XVIII-XIX BeKax BKarrecrBeKOHCTT{Tyr\UrflX BrrepBbrenoJrr{r{nH [prr3HaH[eUHTeJIJIeKTyZUIbHbIe npaBa aBTOpoB,HaqaJrcs sTarr KoHcTnTyrIHoHHo-[paBoBofo peryJlllpoBaHus.
LIHTeJIneKTyalrsofico6crnenHocrr4.XIX -HarraJroXXseKa 3HaMeHyIor co6ofi 3arlper pa6crna uaKoHcrlrryur4onHoM ypoBHe. Jfto.qu (pa6u) repecrarcr6urr o6lerrourpaBa.racfirofi co6crseHHocrr.r (KoucrnryqNr fpeqlrr,r 1864 r., cr. 61 KoncrnryunuBonrapcxoro KHflKecrBa 1878 r., Ap.)I4ctopuapa3Br4Tufl, KoHcrr4ryrlr{oHHoro peryJlr{poBannfl, I{HcrLITyra rrpaBa.racrHofi co6crneHHocrla BXXBeKe aBfl3alclac[o.gBJIeHLIeM HoBbIXreopuf!- HoBoMy cyrb r{ Ha3HarleHus.
npaBa.raculofi co6crseHHocrll.OAna r43 Hr{x - Teopur corlkrurJrbHofi co6crBeHHocrlt JI. ,I[oru. B uocleAyroqeMo6nscHsroqux nocoqr{arbHax QyHrcqux co6crBeHHocru HaIxJIa orpaxeHple B KoHcrLITyIItIoHHbIxaKrax MHorvx rocyAapcrB: Mercuru (1917), @ln:r.trrr:aguu (1919), fepnaanzn(1919), Vlptauaum (1937), (DPf (1949), EpasunIEu (1988), l4lcnalauu (1978),23Xopnanau (1990), MaxeAonnu (1991), Pyuunuz (1991), Kolyl,r6uu (1991),r{exuu (1,992), Yxpamu (1996),VIpaxa (2005), IOxnoro Cygaua (2011), u Ap.Eqe oAHo H3 nanpanrennft ucropwrecKoro pa3Bkrrutr qacrnofrco6crseHHocrr{ B XX BeKe cBr3aHo c cold}Izull{cru.recrofi reopuefi Qoptco6creeHHocrr.r, cornacHororopofi ilpaBo .IacrHofi co6creeHHocrrl rloAJlexanoLrcKopeHenuro ma6o cyqecrBeHHoMy yIrIeMJIeHuro.
Irlct<opeHeHl{e [paBa qacrnofic .{ercpera o 3eMJIe cbe3Aa coBeroB pa6o.rux uAenyraroB l9l7 r., B coorBercrBuvr c KoropblM IrpaBo .racrHofico6creeHHocrtr Harr€r[ocbcoJrAarcKuxco6crseHHocrlr n Pocclrz Ha 3eMJrrc orMeH.tJlocb HaBcerAa, HeApa 3eMJILI, reca,BoAbI, KoHcKLre r{ cKoroBoAqecKr{ev npoque 3aBoAbI rlo.qnex{€Lnz xon$ucKar\ukr.flogxe err{ nocryJrarbr Harxnu orpaxeHlleCCCP.
B ronueB KoHcTLITyIITIoHHrIX aKrax PC@CP uXX sexa B cor{r4€rJrucrrlqecKlrxcrpaHax IiHcrLITyr rlpaBa.racrrlofico6 crs eHHo crLI Haq€u uo crerleHHo Bo ccraHaBJILIBarbTaruu o6parou,ct.qacrH€ur co6crnenHocrb KaK npanonofi I'IHcrI4Tyrkrcy6nexruBHoe [paBo HaxoALrrc.f, B rrocro.sHuofi AI{HaMLIKe noA sogAeficrBLleMcoquaJrbHo-3KoHoMr{rrecKr{x SarropoB Ia TIoJII,ITI4Ko-SunocoScKI{x esrr.f,Aon. BxoAe I{cropurlecrofi oBoJIroIII4I{:-rrocrerreHHo rrporr3orxJro npr{3HaHLIe oco6ofi 3HaqkIMocrl4 qacrnofico6crseHHocrLI;-rrpaBoBoe peryJrrlpoBaHue orHoruenufi co6crBeHHocrl4 crtuloOCyqeCTBJIteTcfl He TOJIbKO Ha OTpacneBOM, Ho I4 Ha KOHCTLITyIII{OHHOM ypOBH.flX;- ycraHaBJrrrBarorcr HopMbr, 3arrII4IIIaIoque [paBa rlacrHblx co6crneHHI{KoBorHe3aKoHHoro t43:lflTufl.'racrHofi co 6crseHHo crpl-yrBepx{Aaercr AoKTpHHaco6creeHHr4KoB rrepeA;o6 oco6ofi orBercrBeHHocrl{rIacrHbIXo6ulecrnou, o6ocnosrrBaerct coqlt€ulbHas, a no3xevrgKoJrorl4rlecKaffSyurqur co6crseuHocrll.He[pepbIBHo yTorIHqeTct nepeqeHb o6reKros [paBa 'racrHofico6crneHHocru: HeKoTopble uz HHX I4cKJIIoqaIorct (uaupuuep, pa6u), Apyrl{e3aHuMaror trx Mecro (znSopvrar\ufl,o6rexru l{HTenneKTyalrsofi co6ctnenuocru).24HeupepuBnar 3Bonrorlr4{ paccMarpuBaeMofo I,IHcrrITyra BbI3BaHa saxHofipoJrbro qacrrrofi co6crseHHocrlrB rrocro.lHHo puBBllBaloqeficsgKoHoMkIKe, aTaKXe reM, rrro cy6terrzBHoe npaBo.racrHofi co6crnenHocrll tBJlterc.u oAHLIMLI3ocHoBorronararoqux upaB qeloBeKa, Koropoe rpe6yer BcJIeAcrBLIe grororr ocro.rrHH o rocoBep IIreHcrBoBaHLrflerocoAep )Kanus.ur apauruilB naparpaQe uerneproM <[pano .racrHofi co6crneHHocrl{ KaKeaxHefirunx rrpaBooAHo rr3rleJroBeKa)> paccMarpl{Balorct 3HarILIMocrb, cy6rerrrr,6terrrr u c oAepx{ arrae cy6rerrraBHororlpaBa .racrHofi co6crseHHo crl{.L{ennocrb KoHcrr4TyrllroHHoro lpaBa.racrHofi co6crseHHocrLT rlpotBnflerc.ttB TOM, IITO OHO CJryXr4T, BO-IrepBbrX, MaTeplilalblrofiqeroBeKa, Bo-BTopbrx,ocnoeofixfl43HeAetrTeJIbHOCTLIlpeAnocrurofi I4 rapaHTraefi peanvrca\uv ]IHrIX rlpaBceo6oA rreJroBeKa (4ocrofiHufi ypoBeHb xI43HI4, Ha cno6oAnoerI3aHtrLIerrpeArrpr4Hr4MareJrbcrofi Ae.sreJrbHocrbro, Ha xtHJII4IrIe, Ha oxpaHy 3AopoBbfl, Hao6pa:oaauze, Ha KynbrypHoe pa3BHTLIe, H& cno6o.4y uepeABuxe*vIfl,noJryqenLreHauuSopvrar\w, Ha Marepr.rHcrBo, sa rpyA, Ha coqu€L[bHyro rIoMep)KKyrocyAapcrBa, Ha IreHcI4oHHoe o6eclerleHlaeI''IAp.).B pa:Hux crpaHax rrpaBo qacurofi co6crseHHocrll pa3nl,Iqaercf, c rorIKI43peHlrr Bcex ero crpyKTypHbrx 3JIeMeHToB.
3ro o6rscHsercs' MHo)KecrBoM$axropoe, [pe]KAe Bcero AoMr4HI,IpoBaHueM Tex vrv I4HrIX noJII{TLIKOrrpaBoBbIX KoHrleilrlrlfi, oco6eHHocrflMu upanonofi cncreMbl, coqniulbHogKoHoMr4rrecKr4MoqeBuAHo,cocro{HlreM o6ulecrna rcourpeurofi crpaHhl. Conepureuuorrro, K [pr{Mepy, Kpyr cy6rerron vr o6terron [paBaco6crsenHocrr4'racrHofi6y4er cyqecrBeHHo orJltlrlarbct BcoIII4uuII{crI{qecKLIXkrB rocyAapcrBax cKoHTLTHeHralruofi14KallzTanr{crr4rlecKr4x crpaHax,aurJrocaKconcrofi TpaAI4IIV e fi. rrpaua.Kar [paBuJro, cy6rerrou flpaBa qacruofi co6crseuHocrLl Moxer 6uTbrreJroBeK (rpax4aurlH, LIHocrpaHeII, arrarpv4, 6unarpug) lr rcpuAlIqecKoe nnqo(HaqzoHalbHoecyobeKTaMuuHKopropupoeanuoe).flp"oroM B HeKoropblx crpaHaxrrpaBa qacruOfi co6crneHHocTllrrpeAb.rrBJrf,K)Tcf, AonoJrHrrreJrbHbleHaoIIpeAeJIeHHbIeKo6terrurpe6onaHIar.
Haupztuep, ueo6xoAltMocrb25fpaxAaHcTBa, co3AaEr4e ropuAr4r{ecKofo nI{IIa B cooTBeTcTBLrv c 3aKoHoM AaHHofofocyAapcTBa, MecTo HaxoxAeHne efo Ha TeppI,ITopzI{ AaHHofo rocyAapcTBa (cT.22lt Koscrr4ryrlzu Bpazvuruu 1988 r., cr. 47 KoncrvrylJurkr Jlurnu 1992 f., cr.127 KoHcruryuulr fnareva-rrr 1956r.).lloAo6Hrre orpaHI4rIeHI4rIBbI3BaHbroco6ofi 3HaqnMocrbro otAan"""r* o6rexron [paBa co6crnenHocrrl (cpe,4crnalaaccosofi un$oprvraquu,3eMJI.rr, BHyrpeHHI{e BoAbI,Jleca, rrapKll, 3eMeJIbHbIefracrKLr, pacrroJroxreHHbre BAonb IpaHLIIIbI ra upu6peNnofi uonocrr) I4 cBt3aHbI c6esonacHocrbro rocyAapcrBa.