Автореферат (1173694), страница 2
Текст из файла (страница 2)
u r4ubrx aBropoB.Cpe4u npaBoBeAoB, rrccJreAoBaBrxux fpa)KAaHcKG-npaBosofi acrreKT rrpaBa.racrHofi co6crnenHocrr4, MoxHo BbrAeJrlrrb C.C. AreKceeBa, E.A. CyxaHoBa, K.I{.CKroscKoro, B.A. ,{osopqeea, A.H. JluceHr<o, A.A. Px6ona, A.B. fepMaHoBa,B.B. Burp.f,HcKoro, JI.B. II{euHr4KoBy vr Ap.Bc$epe KoHcrlrryrlrzoHHoro npaBa oco6oe BH[MaHr4e 3acJryx{LTBalorpa6oru f.H. AHapeenofi, B.A. Kurotx, B.E. 9upKLIHa, n.A. Fapen6ofirua, f.A.faAxnesa,VLB. MraHra:apona, A.B. Eecruranrro, B.,{. Ma:aena, B.B. foruynrravw.Cpe4z Ar.,rcceprarlr{oHHbrx r4ccneAoBanuit, TaK I4JI}r r{Harle 3arparl{Baroq[xKoHcrlrryrlr{oHHble acneKTbr qacrnofi co6crseHHocrlru [paBa Ha Hee, cneAyerBbrAenlrrb pa6orrr A.A.
Ps6oaa dlpo6nerran o6ulero rorulrrlrl npaBaco6crsenHocrr/D) (Mocxna, 1998);A.B. Eecruranrro <<Koncrzryrll4oHHo-npaBoBbre ocHoBbr.racrHofi co6crseHHocrrl n Pocczficr<ofi @e4epaqura> (Mocrna,2003);B.!.Ma:aesa (KoHcrrlryrluoHHbre ocHoBbr uy6nnvHofi co6crseHHocrl{Poccr.rficrofi @e4epaquz>> (Mocrna, 200Q;cyrrlHocrb, coAepx{aHr4eB.M. 3axaponaB<Co6creeHHocrb:uSoprvru [potBneHr4fl: co\vaJrcno-SunocoScrnfiacrreKr) (Er<arepuu6ypr, 2012); A.A. Tecns <<(Duloco$cro I{cropkIrlecxHfiKoHreKcr aKclroJrorrlqecKoro craryaa co6crseHHocrl{) (Xa6aponcr<, 2006); E.B.Xaluuonofi <KoncrnryqlroHHo rlpaBoBble ocHoBbILIHTeJIJIeKTyalrHofico6crseHHocrrr) (Mocr<na, 1999); VI.B.
llpo:opona <<3ar<penneHl4e LrHcruryraco6crseHHocrr4 B KoHcrrrryrIHoHHoM rlpaBe PocculE>> (lleusa, 2010); C. ,,{ylarraa<<Co6crneHHocrb KaK rrpaBoBas, rleHHocrb: TeoperLrKo-rrpaBoBoe I{ccJIeAoBaH}Ie)6(Mocrna, 2015); A.VI. BaczrsHcrofi <<KoncruryrlrroHHoe rrpaBo Ha qacrHyroco6crseHHocrbB conpeuennofiPoccnlo> (Mocrna, 2011);IO.H. Xny4uenofi<KoHcruryrlkroHHoe 3aKperrJreHlre [paBa qacruofi co6creeHHocrlrcrpaH€x EnpoueficKoron Poccun r,rCorosa: cpaBHrrreJrbHo-[paBoBoe nccneAoBaHlre)>(Mocrea, 2014), M.E.
lopraenofi <Tpanc$oprvraqur orHorrreHuft co6ctBeHHocrrrn rauQoprvraquounofi eKoHoMI4Ke>(Caur<r-flerep6ypr, 20 1 5 ).llepeuuclenHhre pa6our BecbMa o6ocuonaHu, coAepx(areJlbHbl ur4HTepecHbr.O4uaro, KaK sBcrByer H3 LIx Ha3BaHuft, uus oAHofi I{3 HIIX HerlpoBeAeHo KoMrrJreKcHofo r4ccneAoBaHufl coBpeMeHHoro cocrotHplfqacrnofi co6crseHHocruKoHcrrrryrlrroHHo-[paBoBoro peryJrr{poBanurfl.o6qervrzpoBoM ruacurra6e, To ecrb He rIoKa3aHbIBo6qze reHAeHIILtu, upo6leMbl I4[epcneKT]IBbr raKofo peryJr[poBaHr{t, a raKxe oco6esnocrl{ pa3JILIrIHbx crpaHBAauHofi c$epe. Haupurvrep, corrlrHeul4e IO.H. Xny4nenofi <KoncruryIILIoHHoe3aKpelneHr4e rrpaBa rracruofi co6crneHHocrlr n Poccuz rr crpaHax EnpoueficKoroCorosa: cpaBHrrreJrbHo-[paBoBoezu$opl,raruBHo, aBTop npoBoAl{rr{ccJreAoBalaue>>aHurpr3vt(Mocrcna, 2014)BecbMaI{3JIoxeHIae 3aKoHoAareJlbcrBa,Kacaroqr{xc.f, BorrpocoB qacrnoft co6crneuHocrr4, rocyAapcrB EaponeficKorocoro3au Poccltr.
B pa6ore A.IrI. Baczrxucrofi<<KoHcrpITyrILtoHHoe npaBo HaqacrHyro co6crseHHocrb B coBpeMennofi Poccnn> (Mocrna, 20Ll) I4ccJleAyrorctrTeoperlaqecKr{e Bonpocbr KoHcrr4Tyrrl4oHHororrpr{MeHr{TenbHol4rax,r[paBa .racrHofi co6crnenHocrupoccuficKoMy olblTy.rroJraraeM,qTo B conpeueuuofi JII,ITepaType HeAocTaToqHokrccJreAoBaHbr acreKTbr KoHcTuTyrIrroHHo-[paBoBoro peryJlrlpoBaHut qacrnofico6crnenuocrr.r B MlrpoBofi nparrure, upo6reMbl ero I{cropruecrcofi gBoJIroIII4Il,[epcrreKTraBbrureHAeHrlr,rr4 pa3Bururfl,.Ha HeKoropoe BocnoJIHeHIreAaHHoroupo6ela HarrpaBJreHbr ycr{Jrr{fl aBTopa AaHHoro Al{cceprallploHHoro uccJleAoBaHvfl.O6rercrour I{ccne.rloBaHtrs .rIBJItIorct o6qecrseHHble orHorIreHI{rI,cKnaAbrBaroulr4ecf, rro noBoAy Bo3Hr4KHOBeHUfl, pa3BVrrr4fl., pealrkr3ArJkrlr [paBa.{acruofi co6crseHHocrr4. rlpegrvrer uacrosqefi pa6oru-KoHcruryl{LroHHo-rrpaBoBbre HopMbr, perynr4pyroque LIHcTI4TyT qacTHofi co6cTBeHHocTlrkrcooTBeTcTByrouee [paBo B coBpeMeHHoM MLIpe, ee TeHAeH\vrnu [epcrreKTLrBbr.I{e.nrro [peAcraBnenHofi pa6oru Bblcry[arorcyulecrBeHHbrx acrreKToBuBbrrBJreHr{euanaJrn3xapaKTeprlcrl4K KoHcrr4Tyrluonn<i-upaBoBoroperynupoBaHr{tr coocTBeHHocTH B coBpeMeHHoM Mrrpe, TeHAeHrIuuuilepcrreKT}IBee pa3BrITI,It.,,{nr peurelanfl.
rrocraBneusofi IIeJII4 rlpeAcraBJlserct neo6xoAraMblM peIxI4TbcJre.4yroq}re saAaqII:- BbIBUTbB3AKTMOCBf3bQunocofcKoro rroAxoAoBKLI B3AI{MOBJIUfHVESKOHOMI4TIECKOTOVTrroHr{MaHr{ro .racruofi co6crseHHocrl4 cKOHCTT{TyrIr4OHHbrM npaBOM ;- orrpeAeJrlrrb [pupoAy, cylrlHocrb, 3HaqeHI{e, coAepxaHl4ecy6rerruBHoro upaBa .racrHofi co6crnenHocrll-rrpoBecrr{ r4cropr4rrecxuit aHaJrr43 KoHcrrrryll}IoHHo-npaBoBoroperynupo Banvrfl..racrHofi co6 crseHHocrpl-B KoHcrLITyrIuoHHoM npaBe;oxapaKTepr43oBarr;o6que qeprbr r{pEr3rlkTq]I{ KoHcrLIryII[oHHo-rrpaBoBoro peryJllipo Bankrs..racruofi co6crnenHocrtl B Mrlpe-BbrgBuTb coBpeMeHHbIe TeHAeHIIT{rr.racrHofi co6crseuHocrl4;vr [epcleKT]IBbIpa3BLrTLr',;cQopvryr?rpoBarb IrpeAJIoxenr4s,nocoBeprneHcrBoBaHl4loKoHcrr/rryrlr{oHHo-npaBoBoro peryn[po BaHkrs..IacrHofi co6crnenHocrl4.MeroAo.uofrlfl *r MeroAbIItts,BbIlorHeHLIsrrocraBJreHHbrx 3aAaq ocyulecrBJrtJlo cb KoMIrJIeKcHoe upuMeHeHrleo6lqenaytrrrxI{ IIACTHOHATIHbIXMCTOAOBlrccJreAoBaH[fl.:- Ar.raJreKTlrrrecKoro (uput trccJreAoB alaur4 rlHcrrlTyra .{acrHofi co6creeHHocrl4B,qLTHaMr4Ke, paCCMOTpeHLrr{efo B3aLrMOAefiCrsUtC IIIHbIMI{ LIHCTI{TyTaUnUpana),- racropraqecKoro MeroAa (npur a*alrtrge pa3utrrLrs..racrHofi co6crseHHocrllBpa3rlrqHbre BpeMeHnrre suoxz),- Soprr,ranruo JrorlrqecKoroyMo3 aKJrro.reH[fino6 ocnosauuit),MeroAa (npn flocrpoeHl4rl JrorplqecKklx(nptaIIoAXoAaCLICTeMHOfOpaccMorpeHvrkrB3alrMoBnwrHuflSKoHoMLItIecKIlx Qar<ropoa, Suroco$cro-noruITurlecKux KoHrlerr\uftu.racrHofico6crseHnocrn),- KplrrlrqecKoroMero.{a (npu anarrvr3e rroJroxureJrbHbrxnorpnriareJrbHbrxcropoH KoHcrr4Tyq"o""o-rriaBoBoro peryJrr4po Barrufi.
.racrHofi co6creeHHocrrrPoccuzrasapy6exHbrx crpanax),- Soprraalbno-B- ropnAzqecKoro(upz yflcHenuu cMbrcJra r4crorrHrrKon upana),cpaBHrdreJrbHo-rrpaBoBoro MeroAa(trp"rrccJreAoBaHtrvr KoHcrlrryrlrroHHo-rlpaBoBoro perynupoBaHurr .{acft{ofi co6crseHHocrlre Pocczu pr B 3apy6exnrxrocyAapcmax).Ilopuarunno[paBoByro 6ary r4ccJreAoBanufl, cocraBJrrrcTKoHcrr{Tyrl}roHHo-npaBoBbre aKTbr Poccuz vr :apy6eNnux crpaH, a raK}KeorpacJreBoe 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBo AaHHbIX rocyAapcrB Asep6afi4Nancrcofipecuy6rzr<u, Apuenzz, Beropycclrrz, Benrpuz, BeHecyoJrbr, Bretuavra,fsareNaann,fpysttu, Eruura,Vlparca, I4cnauuu,Wanun, Ka:axcraHa, Karapa,Knpru:uu, KFIP, Koponencrna EytaH, Jlutnrt, Merczrpr, MonAontrr, Heualla,llorlruu, Pecny6nuxu<Coros Mrsulda>>, PyurrHr4v1 Cep6uu, Cnoneuuz, Clf[A,TaulanAa, TyprrvreHr{craHa, @paHqura, OPf, Xopnaruu, IOxnoro Cyaaua,flrrcnuvrr.rAp.).9run npuuecnofi dasoftcy ge6naa rpaKTuKa,tBJltrorctrryt6nlra\nu ClvfuI,ceru l4urepHer, crarr{crlrqecKl4e AaHHbIe.Ilay.rHan HoBr{3Ha ArrcceprarlnoHnofi pa6oru 3aKrroqaercr B ToM, rIToBbUIBJIOHbI, [pOaH€UILI3IIpOBaHbIUOXapaKTepI/BOBaHbI rJIaBHbIe aCIIeKTbIKoHcrr4Tyrlr{oHHo-[paBoBoro coAepxaHzrr .racrHofi co6crseHHocrrr, ocHoBHbIeTeH.qeHrlr{uu[epclreKTr{Bbr p€t^:Burnfl.
rlpaBa .IacrHofi co6crseHHocrllKoHcrr{ryrlr4oHHo-rpaBoBoro perynupoBanus,.KoHcrlrryrlrroHHbrxHa sarqzryo6.ss aHHouerollpe4raraerca ruaccuQuKallrf,crefi .{acrHoro co6crBeHHLIKa.BhrHocflTcs. cJreAyroql4e rroJloxeHprfl, o6raAaroqze nayrHofiHoel,Isuofi uJIr4 gJIeMeHTaMId nav.{Hofi HoBI43HrI:1. fnaeuutuu acneKmuwuua c mu oilco6 cmeeuHocKoHcmumyquoHHo-npanonozo codepucaruuamu, BbrtBJreHHbIMr{ aBTopoM, Bbrcryrraror:- rlpu3HaHlle 6olrrul{HcrBoM KoHcrl4Tyqufi upana .racrHofi co6crseHHocrrrBKaqecrBe o.4Horo vrs ocHonHbtx (rcoucmumyquouuatfnpieHenoneKa.Koucruryquousrrft ypoia"" rpaBa qacruofi co6crseHHocrlr o6rsursercf, reM,qTo oHo BaxHo He ToJIbKo caMo rlo ce6e KaK LTCTOTTHLTKMaTeppr€urbHofo6narococrofllavrfl vr cra1krIrBHocrr.r xpl3Hr4 qeJIoBeKa 14 efo ceMbu, Ho Ia cJryxurocuosoftIJI'peaJlu3a\Lrkr MHorI4x Apyrux KoHcrkrryrlLroHHbrx rrpaBrpax(AaHLIHa:u cno6oAHa .{ocrorrHcrBo (gocrofinufi ypoBeHb xusHu), Ha cno6oAnoe3aHtTI4e [peAIIpI{HI{MaTeJIbCKOI{ Aef,TeJIbHOCTbrO,Ha)Kr{Jrr4rrle,HaOXpaHy3AopoBbs, na o6pa:oBaH[e, Ha KyJlbrypHoe p€r3Br.rrr{e, Ha cno6o4y rrepeABr{}Kenus,uAp.
flpz3aqacrylosrou c freroM oco6ofiB3Haqr{Mocrvr rrpaBacoBpeMeHHbrx KoHcrrrryl{Lr.rx rroMr4MoyK€r3brBarorcrqacruofi co6crnenHocrr.rQurcaqxn caMororrpaBao6rerru, cy6rercrrr [paBa .racrHofi co6crseHHocrr{, [peAenbr eroocylqecTBJreHr.r.f, r{ Bo3Mo)KHocTr{ ero orpaHuueuwit, TapaIJlTLrH.z cnoco6br 3arrlrrTbr;-3aKpelJreHl4e KoHcTrrTyIII4tMI4 p€BlprrrHbrx cTpaHHeToJrbKocy6rerrnBHoro [paBa.racrHofi co6crseHHocrlr, Ho r{ saxHefiur4x xapaKTepr{crllKv-qACTHOI{ COOCTBEHHOCTI4 KAK I{HCTITTVTA OObEKTTIBHOTOcoomHouteHttflcrpaBa, [pexAe Bcefo - eeuHbtMtt Qopuauu co6cmeeuHocmut,coquanauatil xapaKmep,aacmuoil codcmeeuHocmu.
KoucrzryIIIroHH€uI plHcrlrryrluoneurr43a\ufl, .Iactuofico6creeHHocrr4 o6ycronreHa ee orporrauofi ponbro KaK qpe3srr.rafiHo BaxHoroSarropa o6qecrsesnofi 3HarrLrMocrl{, B qacrHocrkrKoHcrr{TyrlzoHHbrx rleHHocrefi upanonorokroAuofi cropoHbr, lr coulr€rJrbHoro rocyAapcrBa2.