072c-1-opreview (1144098), страница 3
Текст из файла (страница 3)
B naHHOH rnaBe3KCIIepHMeHTaflbHbIXrrpaKTHKeMaKeTIIOKa3bIBaIOTHCCJ1e,II;OBaHHHKOppeKTHOCTbpa3pa6oTaHHbIXI1rrpaBHJ1bHOCTbpa3pa6oTaHHbIX TeopeTHLJ:eCKHX pellleHHH.B3aKnIOLJ:eHHI1 rrp11Be,II;eHbI pe3ynhTaTbI 11 BbIBO,II;bI, rronyqeHHbie aBTopoM Bxone BbIIIOJ1HeHH5I pa60TbI.BKOHIJ,e Ka)l(,II;OH rnaBbI n11ccepTau1111 aBTop nenaeT o6ocHoBaHHbie BbIBO,II;bI,rro3BOn5IIOIIJ,HeBbICTpoHTb enHHyIO11ccnenoBaHIDI.BeefIO,II;TBep)K)J;eHbIcTpyKTYPY B3aHMOCB5I3aHHbIX uen11 11 3anaqrrpencTaBneHHbieCOOTBeTCTByIOIIJ,HMHBpa6oTeBbIBO,II;bIKOJ1HLJ:eCTBeHHbIMI1o6ocHoBaHbII111KaLJ:eCTBeHHbIMHIIOKa3aTeJ15IMI1 .BCOBMeCTHbIX rry6n11KaIJ,IDIX BKna,II; COHCKaTefl5I 5IBIDieTC5I orrpenemrIOIIJ,HM .Conep)l(am1e aBTopecpepaTa nocTaTOLJ:Ho rronHo oTpa)l(aeT conep)l(aHHe n11ccepTau1111I1II03BOIDieTCOCTaBHTbuenoCTHOerrpe,II;CTaBneHHe0rrponenaHHOHpa6oTe.MaTep11anbI n11ccepTal(HH H3J10)l(eHbI rpaMOTHO, nor11qecK11 rrocnenoBaTenbHO 11 Bn aKOHI1LJ:HOH cpopMe . ,[(oCTH)l(eHH5I npyr11x aBTOpOB HCIIOJ1b30BaHbI KoppeKTHO, cYKa3aHI1eM CCbIJ10K Ha KOHKpeTHbie rry6n11KaIJ,HI1.BuenoMn11ccepTaIJ,IDIxapaKTep113yeTC5I3acepiueHHocmb10pellleHH5IHaYLJ:HOH 3a,II;aLJ:H I1 IIOKa3bIBaeT, LJ:TO ee aBTOp crroco6eH pelllaTb CJ10)l(Hbie HayqHoTeXHHLJ:eCKHe 3a,II;aLJ:H I1 rrpoBO,II;HTb caMOCT05ITeJ1bHbie 11ccne,II;OBaHIDI, ,II;OBO,II;5I HX norrpaKTHLJ:ecKHX peKoMeH,II;al(HH 11 pean113au1111 pe3ynbTaToB.MeTO,II;aMHHaYLJ:HbIXCOOTBeTCTBYIOIIJ,HH11ccnenoBaHHH,MaTeMaTHLJ:eCKHHo6ocHOBaHHOarrrrapaT,I1Co11cKaTenb BnaneeTKoppeKTHOo6nanaeTrrpHMeH5IeTlllI1pOKHMHaYLJ:HbIMKpyro3opoM .j(aJZbHeuiuuerrpo,II;OJ1)l(I1TbarrrrapaTaycJIOBI15IXBUCCJledOBllHUR B paMKax ,II;aHHOH TeMaTHKH uenecoo6pa3HOHarrpaBneHHHo6ecrreLJ:eHIDIycTOHLJ:HBOCTI1uen eHarrpaBneHHbIXC03,II;aHIDICI1CTeMbIaBTOMaTHLJ:eCKYIO,D;aflbHeHllleroHayqHo- MeTO,II;HLJ:eCKOrocpyHKI(HOHHpoBaHI15IKOMIIbIOTepHbIXHCKYCCTBeHHOroreHepal(HIOpa3BHTI15ICIJ,eHapHeBaTaK,aCJ10)l(HbIXTaK)KeHHTenneKTa,BCHCTeMBHanpaBneHHHocymecTBIDIIOIIJ,eHCKOOp,II;HHHpoBaHHbIXpeaKI(HH,HarrpaBneHHbIX Ha rronnep)l(aHHe cpyHKI(HOHHpOBaHIDI CHCTeMbI.3aMeqaHIHI no ,lJ,H CCC p TalJ, MOHH OH pa6oTe1.0TCYTCTByeT3a,II;aLJ:H, LJ:TO5IBHOccpopMynI1pOBaHHa5IMaTeMaTHLJ:ecKa5IIIOCTaHOBKa3arpy,II;H5IeT IIOHHMaHHe rpaHHIJ, pelllaeMOH 3a,II;aLJ:H, norrymeHHH I19orpam111eH11i1, B 11acTHocT11, He orpaHI11Ieij KJJacc K <DC 11 KJJacc aTaKyioru:11xB03,n:eHCTBl1H, OT KOTOpbIX rrpe,n:rrorraraeTC5! l1X 3aru:11ru:aTb.2.
B pa6oTe YKa3aHo, 1ITO "Orrpe,n:erreH11e ycToi11I11BocT11 K<DC cocTOl1T Bou:eHKe B03MO)!(HOCTl1 HaXO)!(JJ:eH115! ee B ycToi11111BoM cocT05!H1111, rrp1111eM ,n:aHH~ou:eHKa JJ:OJI)!(Ha rrpoBOJJ:l1TbC5! JJ:JI5! Cl1CTeMbl B u:erroM,a He OT,n:eJibHbIX ee3JieMeHTOB." ( CTp. 102), o,n:HaKO TaK 11 He ,n;aHO T01IH0f'O orrpe,n:erreH~, 1ITO )Ke BpaMKax l1ccrre,n:oBaH11i1 rroH11MaeTc5! aBTopoM rro,n: "Y cToi11111BocTbIO K <DC".3. B pa6oTe BBe,n:eHbI o,n:11HaKOBb1eo6o3HaqeH~ pa3Jil11IHbIX rroH5!Tl1H, 1ITOHeCKOJibKO 3aTpy,n:~eT rroH11Mamre cynr rrpe,n:rraraeMbIX perneH11I1. TaK, Ha crp.75aBTOp BBOJJ:l1T o603HaqeH11e rpacpa 11 YKa3bIBaeT Ha TO, qTo Bepilll1Hbl 113 MHO)!(eCTBa"V"xapaKTep113yIOTco6bITl15!,rrpo11cxo,n:51ru:11eBc11cTeMecpyHKU:l10Hl1pOBaH~ TIO, a pe6pa rpacpa (113 MHO)!(eCTBaBpe3yrroTaTe"E") - BpeMeHHbie l1Jil1rror11qecK11e OTHOlileH~ Me)!(,n:y rrapaMl1 co6bITl1H.
,I(arree, Ha CTp. 96, 97 BBOJJ:l1TC5!,qTo "K<DC MO)!(eT 6bITb rrpe,n:cTaBneHa B B11,n:e rpacpa G =<V,E>, r,n:e :VMHO)!(eCTBO Beprn1rn rpacpa, KOTOpbie rrpe,n:cTaBJI5!IOT co6ol1 KOMITOHeHTbI K<DC. E MHO)!(eCTBO pe6ep, crry)!(aru:11x ,n:m orr11caH~ Me)!(KOMrroHeHTHbIX CB5!3eH K <DC." .4. Ha cTp. 117 B rryHKTe "4.1 Tpe6oBaH~ K cpe,n:e pearr113au:1111 rrpe,n:rro)!(eHHOHMeTo,n:orror1111 06ecrre11eH~ 11HcpopMaU:l10HHOH 6e3orraCHOCTl1 Kl16epcp113I11IeCKMXc11cTeM" Bee Tpe60BaH115! ( 5 WTYK) YKa3aHbI B Mo,n:arrbHOCTH "Heo6xo,n:11Mo .
. .",o,n:HaKO Heo6xo,n:l1MOCTb He JJ:OKa3bIBaeTC5!.5. Ha cTp . 120. YKa3aHo, qTo ",I(m Toro, qT0601 rrpo113BOJJ:l1TeJibHOCTbcpyHKU:l10H11poBaH115! K<DC He cH11311rracb, Heo6xo,n:11Mo, qT0601, B crry-qae BHeceH~l13MeHeHl1H B MaprnpyT ero ,n:rr11Ha yBeJII11Il1Barracb He3Ha1Il1TeJibHO."' o,n:HaKO HeyKa3aHo, B qeM l13Mep5!Tb ,n:rr11Hy MaprnpyTa, 11 qTo TaKoe "He3Ha1111TeJibHo" .,.6.B5 .3 .3rro,n:rryHKTe«3Kcrrep11MeHTaJibHbiel1ccrre,n:oBaH115!MeTo,n:arrp11op11T113au:1111 ceTeBbIX rroTOKOB ,n:aHHbIX B TIKC» ( crp.152-158) YKa3aHo, qTo Bxo,n:errpoBe,n:eH~ceTeBOH3Kcrrep11MeHTOB11HcppacrpyKTypo1noTIKC,cpaBHeH11IOl1crrorrb3YIOIIJ:eHrrporrycKHOHcrroco6HocT11pa3pa6oTaHHbIHcrroco6,110601qHol1 TIKC rrp11 o6pa6oTKe Tpacp11Ka pa3rr1111Horo T11rra 11 I1HTeHCl1BHOCTl1f!OKa3aHO,qTopa3pa6oTaHI-Ibiecnoco6brynpaBJieHl15!ceTeBbIMl1TIOTOKaMI1noBbIWaIOT npo113Bo,n:11TerrbHOCTb ceTeBOH 11HcppacTpyKTypo1 TIKC Ha 1% - 10% (B3aBI1CI1MOCTl1 OT Tpacp11Ka), o,n:HaKO 5!BHO He OTMeqeH BKJJa,n: 3TOfO B JJ:OCTl1)!(em1eu,err11 ,n:11ccepTau;110HHbIX l1ccrre,n:oBaH11I1.7.B(cTp.27, 92),TeKcTe,n:11ccepTau,1111orreqaTKl1,B p5!,n:errp11cyTCTBYIOTcrry-qaeBcT11rr11cT1111ecK11eOTCYTCTBYIOTorn116KHHeo6xo,n:11Mb1e3HaKHnpen11HaHI15! ( CTp .
l 00), Hepau:110HaJibHO l1CIIOJib3yeTC51 o6rraCTb TeKCTa - HeKOTOpbieCTpaHHU:bI rrorryrrycTbie ( cTp. 60, 84, 108 11 ,n:pyr11e), rrp11cyTcTByeT p5!,n: orn1160K 11HeToqHocTeH B ocpopMrreH1111 6116rr11orpacp11qecK11x 3arr11cel1 B crr11cKe rr11TepaTypo110(I1CITOJ1b30BaHHbIX I1CT01:IHI1KOB), OTCYTCTByeT CITMCOK ycrrOBHbIX o6o3HaLieHHH I1COKparn,eHHH, 1:ITO HeCKOJibKO 3aTpy.n:mreT pa6ory c TeKCTOM.TipHBe.n;eHHbie BbIIIIe 3aMe1:IaHI15I He CHmI<aIOT o6rn,ei1: I10JIO)KI1TeJ1bHOH ou:eHKI1):(I1CcepTaU:HI1 I1 He BJ1I15IIOT Ha rnaBHbie TeopeTH1:IeCKI1e I1 npaKTI11:IeCKI1e pe3yJ1bTaTbI.,[(n ccepTaU:I15ITiaBJ1eHKOE.IO.5IBJI5IeTC5I3aKOH1:IeHHOHHay-qHo-KBanHqrnKaU:HOHHOH pa60TOH, B KOTOpoi1: co.n:ep)l(I1TC5I peIIIeHMe aKTYaJ1bHOH 3a.n;a11M.Co.n:ep)l(aHHe .n:nccepTaU:MH cooTBeTCTByeT crreu:nanbHOCTM 05 .13 .19 «MeTO.D:bI MCHCTeMbl3aIIJ,I1TblI1HcpopMaU:HI1,m.:icpopMaU:HOHHa5I6e30ITaCHOCTb»,OTBeLiaeTTpe6oBaHH5IM rr.9 TI011o)l(eHI15I o rrpncy)l():(eHMM y-qeHbIX cTerreHei1: M~842 OT 24ceHT5I6p5I 2013 ro.n:a, rrpe.n;o5IBJI5IeMbIM K KaH.n;n.n;aTCKMM .n:nccepTaU:I15IM, a ee aBTOpTiaBneHKo EBreHMH lOpbeBI11:I .n:ocToMH rrpncy)l(.n;eHI15I y-qeHoi1: cTerreHM KaH.n;n.n;aTaTeXHI11:IeCKI1X HayK no crreIJ;HaJ1bHOCTI1 05 .13 .19 «MeTO):(bl I1 CMCTeMbI 3aIIJ,I1TblI1HcpopMaU:I1I1, m.:icpopMaU:MOHHa5I 6e30IIaCHOCTb».0cpHU:I1aJ1bHbIH OITITOHeHTHa11a11bHMK Kacpe.n;pi,1 CncTeM c6opaH o6pa6oTKI1 MHcpopMau:nn<DfEBOY BO «BoeHHO-KOCMM11ecKa5IAKa.n;eMM5I MMeI-rn A.
<D. Mm1rni1cKoro»MHHMCTepcTBa o6opoHbIPoccnlicKoli <De.n:epau;nH,.D:OKTop TexHn11ecK11x HayK, .n:ou:eHT&3'. /,,! . .!O/?~~EHpIOKOB ,[(eHHc HHKonaeBMLI197198, Pocciur, CaHKT-TieTep6ypr,)K.uaHOBCKa5I yrr., .z:i;.13 .TeJI.: 8 (812)-347-96-87e-mail: Biryukov.D.N@yandex.ruITo.n;rrHch ocpHLI}IaJ1hHoro orrrroHeHTa .n;oKTopa TeXHHLieCKMX HayK .n:ou:eHTaEHpIOKOBa L(eHHcaHHKonaeBffC.~:~~~~~-~ ·· :· - ·:· "~i;~?C;::~{~;~:~:1::·.,:. :.·.HaqanbHHK oT.n;ena Ka.n;poB /:":: .: .:.· -- : ..:\ .,}>~ \~\~ ,f~'.' ~~~~';Wf .B .TinoTHHKOB.