Автореферат (1138481), страница 2
Текст из файла (страница 2)
llpe4ueroM rlccJreAoBaHuqrBrrsercq nnKBuAarrr4oHHat crouMocrr noprQers) yrrvrrbrBaloulaqran$oprr,rarlzrco ruy6raHe14penaKcarlr4r4pbrHKa.TeopernuecKatrI{ MeroAoJrorr{qecKafl ocHoBa uccJreAoBaHufl. Teoperuue-cKyro ocHoByHacro{Iqero I{ccneAoBalar4flcocraBJrf,}orHayr{Hrrepa6ortr :apy6exHbrx14 OTer{eCTBeHHbIXaBTOpOB B OoJIaCTH MHKpOCTpyKTypbr pbrHKa r4 ynpaBneljldflpvlc-(8. Anexr,ru,P.
AmMrpeH,f. Arvruxy,4,KaMr4A.Banrrur',B. Erafro,@. Blex, [.f.arrafi,JI. fnocreH, A. foroAur.rxon,X. '{eruceq,P. flNeppoy, @. [rae6ong,A. Kaftn, K. Koou, H. KpHcc,,{N. Jlap,{x, 3. JIo, C. Mafiep, X. MeHaeJrbcoH,lL Munrpov, M.Mumep, A. O6HxaeBUA. lleponbA, X. Croll, !x.Crpayrxafiep, P. lllnapu, T.lllyepuan, l. Vnrxorra,C. Vprcren, JI. Xapprzc,Ax.Xac6pyr 14Ap.).llprz paspa6orre cnoco6a onpe.qeneHl{rJrrrKBz4aquoHuoficror{Mocrr4 6lurrIpI4Hf,THa BoopyxeHl4e noAXoA A. Kafina x pa:6r,reHr4roJrr4KBr4AHocrHHa rptr orKoMrIoHeHra(<cxarocrb), rny6uHa r4 penaKcaryut).B xaqecrBe rleHoBoroAeJIbHbIX6euuuapxa ilpr4 oqeHKerpaH3aKIdHoHHbIXH3Aep)KeKLrclonb3yercr 4eSHTIHTr4crroJrHeHr4q(implementation shortfull), rpeAJloxeHurrfi A. fleponr4oruo.
Ha ero ocHoBeqBJr{rorqaflcflvrHTerparrHofipaccr{r4TbrBaerc{r43Aep}KeK,Syurqux rpaHcaKrlr4oHHbrxxapaKrepracrnrofi ((clxarocrra>ra rny6r4HbrpbrHKa. llpra nrr6ope $opruynr4poBKr4ongap.aqvAnq onpeAeneHusnr,rKBprAarluouuofrTr4Mr,r3ar.Ir4olruoficrorrMocrr4 r4crronb3o6 Perold,A.The implementationshortfall: Paperversusreality ll Journal of PortfolioManagement.- 1 9 8 8-. V o l . 1 4 .- P p .
4 - 9 .B€uracbMeroAonofr4-flP. Anrnarpena u H. Kpucca, coBMecrr.rMarc rroAXoAoMA. tleponbAa. [nxoqeuru BpeMeHI4penaKcaIIHHpbIHKa 6lr'l rpr4MeHeHno4xo4 {x.pbrHorrHbrxHa KJraccusr,rrcaqraroJlaprxa', onnparcrqufi.cs.co6rnnfi, npe4roxeHHyro-8 -E. Bzilo ra Ap." B ra.{ecrne o6o6uleHHoro noKa3areJrflnr4KBvt4Hocrrrrrpu anbrepHaTTTBHOMCrrOCO6e OIIeHIIBaHI4' BpeMeHI4 penaKCar\Lrr4 r4CnOJrb3OBa[aCb Mepa nr4KBHA-HocruXLM (corparqeHr4eor aHrJr.Xetra Liquidity Measure).llu$opvraqnoHHas 6aza uccJleAoBantnfl.Bce pacverrr 6ruz npon3BeAeHbrcr4crronb3oBaHneM pe€LnbHbIX BHyTpTIAHeBHbIX AaHHbIX O XOAe TOpfOB aKrIr4rMH HaMMBB 3a rrepr{oAc flHBapfl.2006r. ro 4era6pr 2007 r. OHrano4po6no orrr4cbrBarorBce BbrcraBneHHbleI4 cHf,TbIe B pexl4Me ocHoBHbrx roproB MMBE3aflBKr4Ha noKyn-Ky I4 rrpoAa>Ky)a raKxe 3aKrrcr{eHHbre Ha r4x ocHoBe cAenKr4.
Attg BoccraHoBJreHvtKaprI4HbI xoAa roproB HeAocraer roJIbKo yKa3aHun vnnr\vruropa xaN4ofi r.r:nolnofi3aqBoK,qro, orreBlrAHo,flBrrflercflxon$u4enquamHofi rau$opiraaryvtei,t,He rroAnexa-qefr pacxpbrrriro.Hayunar HoBrr3Ha[ccJIeAoBanvfl. HonzsHaAr4cceprarllroHHoror4ccneAoBaHuq 3aKiuoqaercq e pa:pa6orKe aAeKBarHofo, Kar{ecrBeHHoHoBoro cnoco6a onpeAe-crollMocru uopr$eJrq, rrcrroJrb3yroqeropeanbHyroraH$oprrenr4flnrrKBr4AarluoHHofipbrHKa.flauuax unSopvrarlurr rronyqaerc{ nyreMMarrurc o rny6raue H penaKcaIII4I4o6pa6orru no4po6Hblx BHyTpI4AHeBHbIXAaHHbrxo xoAe roproB SunauconbrMr4r4Hrrro 6ruo BbrnoJrHeHocTpyMeHTaMr4,BrrepBbreAnq poccuficxofo pbrHKaaxrlufr.Hara6oneecyqecrBeHHble HoBbIepe3ynbrarbr Ar,rccepraunoHHoror4ccJreAoBaB cneAyloqeM:Hr4r3aKJrroqaroTc{1) upe4ro)KeHa HoBaf, MeroAr4KaKoJrr4trecrBeHHoroanarwrcanr4KBr4AarIHounofi cror4Mocrr4,orpax{arculaf crpyKTypy pe€rJrbHbrxAaHHbrxo xoAeToproBnr4Ha poccr4ficrou pbrHKe;ee oco6eHHocrbroflBJrsercflorHocr{TerbHaq npocrora, o6ecnevuBarc[{a-flBMecre c reM rrpr4eMneMyroroq'Large,anelectroniclimitorderbookll Journalof FinancialMar-/.Measuringtheresiliencyof-2007.Vol.
10. Pp. 1-25.kets.8Bioit, 8., Hiltion P., Spatt C. An empirical analysisof the limit order book and the order flow inthe ParisBoursell Journal of Finance.- 1995.- Vol. 50, no. 5. - Pp. 1655-89.HOCTb C TOr{KU 3peHr4{ npaKTr4Krr ynpaBneHr4r rroproeJreM c yqeroMpr4cKa;2) noxasaHo,rITo npeAno)KeHHarMeroAr4Ka[o3Bon-f,eronpeAeJrr.rrbpaunoH€LnbHyrocrparefr4ro pecrpyKrypu3ar\uu noprsenr,orBer{aroqyrc 3a-K plzcKy; rIpI43ToMMeroAr4Karro3BoJrreryqecrbAauuofr HecKJIoHHocrI4HeKOTOpbreMHKpOCTpyKrypHrreessexrbr, HarrprrMep,(r4Mnynbc BoJraTrzJrbHocrr4)),coorBercrByroquft nepepbrBaMMe)KAyropraMr4;3) paspa6oraHacxeMarrpordeccaynpaBneHrarnoprseJreMrrpr4pecrpyKrypr43arJvrv,I4cnonb3yroulat rloreHrdr4anbHyronr4KBr,rAarlr4oHHyrocror4MOCTbB Kar{ecrBeMepbr essexrunHocrr4; nrrpa6oraHbr peKoMeH$a\hv\no onpeAeJreHHroB3a?IMocBq3aHHbrxparlr4oHanbHbrxcrparerufr JlrKBr,rHa pa3nwrHbrxypoBHf,x,coorBercrByrorrlr4xAnuHaMBpeMeHHbrxAar\krLrHHTepB€LrrOB.Teoperra'recnaq v [paKT[rrecKafl 3HaqlrMocrb trccJreAoBaHnn.Pa:pa6oTaHHbII{crocoo rlo3BoJl-f,eronpeAenr,rrbnrrKBr4Aar{r4oHHyrocronMocrr noprSeJrr KaKB cnyqae IroreHIIkI€uIbHbIX(ex-ante), TaK r{ peilnr43oBaHHbrx(ex-post) rpaH3aKl(r,roH-HbIXI43AepxeK.Teu canarrrrapa:pa6oraH zHcrpyMeHT,rro3Borqrcqufi SuuauconouykrHcrr4Tyry oqeHrrBarb JII4KBzAaIIHoHHyTocror4Mocrb roproBoro3Ta crouMocrbflBlrflercfl gKoHoMl4rrecKlr6olee o6ocHoeauuofinopr$enx;vMeHHooueuxofr ero cror4-Mocrl4 tlo cpaBHeHI{[oc pblHor{Hofrcrourraocrbro.llpe4noxeuurrficnoco6 Moxer6rtrr raKxe I,IcIIoJIb3oBaHHe roJIbKoAnf, TopfoBbrxnoprSenefi, Ho u AnflonpeAeneHvrflpa\vosalrHoZ crparerHl4 rlepecrpoftrra xpynHoro t4HBecrr4rlnoHHoronoprsenr(ecrn onpeAeneHblHarIaJIbHaflcrpyKTypa, KoHerrHa{crpyKTypa v cpoK nepecrpofr-Kr.r).Kpolae rofo, cnoco6 oilpeAeneHkrflpa\Lronamnofi crparer[r4 nr{KBr4Aaur,rr4noprSenr Mo)Ker 6rrrr zcrIoJIb3oBaHHa npaKTHKe4nx 6onee ror{Horo H3MepeHr4qpbIHor{HbIXpHcKoB rr, KaK cneAcTBI4e,6oree KaqecTBeHHoro ylpaBneHr4fl trMvr.
Taxoro poAa LlHcrpyMeurapuit Moxer 6rtrr oco6eHuo [one3HbrM 4la lro6oro9yr{acrHr4KaQaHanconoro pbIHKanpvrpa6ore ua poccuficKr{x 6upxenux [noqaAKax, B roM qr4cn e .4nr Knr4pr,{Hronofi oprau v3ar\uu ul utm rIeHTpulnbHof o KoHTpafeHTa.llpe4noxeHHrtfi cnoco6 Moxer 6rrrr r4crroJrb3oBaHAnr rrocrpoeHur p3HKr4HraJII'IKBTTAHbIXIIeHHbIx 6ynaar c qenbrc or6opa 6yuar Anr yqacrarfl B MapxnHanrnofiroproBne, a raK)KeAnq orpeAeneHrrflqen 6ynrar Anq rrpoBeAeHr4qcAenoKPEIIO. llocneAHeeHa[paBneHueIacrloJlb3oBaHr4f,cr€Lrrooco6euso aKTy€LnbHbrMrrocJreKoJrJra[caHa poccnficxoMpbrHKePEIO s 2008 roAy.Aupo6aquq pe3yrbraroBHccJIeAoBaHnfl.Pesylrrarrrpa6oru 6rrru npeA-craBireHbrHa HayrrHrrxronQepeHrlr4rxLrceMr{Hapax:-MexAyHapoAHaq lts.ayqlHaflr<oHSepeHquacryAeHToB, acnr4paHToB14 MoJroAbrxyudHrtx "JloMoHocon-2009", r.
Mocxsa, anpeJrb2009 r. (4oxnaAy 6rrno npr4cyxAeHo 1-oe uecro B rIo.qceKIIrrI4<@nuaucoBafl3KoHoMr4Ka))ceKur4n<SxouovuKa>);-MexAyHapoAHblfrHayuurtfi ceuHsap Perm Winter School 20ll (r. llepvm, S""p a n b2 0 l l ro 4 a );-MexAyHapoAHat cryAeHqecxaa xonSepeHllI4f,rlo MoAenupoBaHnlo$zuaucoerrxpbtHKoBFinMod-2O11 (r. llepnar, ceurr6pr 20ll ro4a);-BcepoccuitcrcasxonSepenqzr $arcyJlbreranauponofisKoHoMr4KvrLr MupoBofi noIrhrrvrKkrHVIY Bru3 <llporuo3lzpoBaHr4eSrauancoBbrxpbrHKoB)(r.
Mocxe a, rvrair2010roaa);-ceMI4Hap orAena "Mateuarl,IqecKoeMoAeJIZpoBaHHe3KoHoMur{ecKI4x cI,IcreM"BtI PAH (r. Mocrna, Mapr 2009);-BbIe3AHatrrKoJra-ceMr4Hap,opraHr,r3oBaHHarHay.rurrrr,rSoH4ola fy-BlII3(Moc-KoBcKa.rro6lacrt, u.
folr.rqbrHo, orcra6pr 2007 ro4a);-uayvuuft ceMI4Hapna6oparopvra HHBecrr4rlr4oHHoroaHaJru3aHVly BIII3flepur (r. llepnm, Senpanr 20ll ro4a);-4 HayqHo-yqe6uux ceMrrHapa HyJIroLi pucKSnnanconofi prHlr(eHeprrr4MeHeAlKMeHryQarynrrera oKoHoMuxu }ifzIY BLII3 <Mo4enupoBaHr4eSnuauco-l0(r. Mocrna, HrcJrb2007 ro,qa,arpenb 2008 roAa,Mapr 2009 roAa14BbrxpbrHKoB>xraia2010 roaa).BuegpeHne pe3yJrbraroB HccJIeAoBaHIrfl.Pa:pa6oraHHbreB Ar4ccepra\wMoAerrvv KoJII,It{ecrBeHHbreMeroAr,rKr46sttu BHeApeHbrrroJlo)KeHr4r,Teoperl4qecKr4eHayqHo-yqe6sofi na6oparopl4r4rlo Suuauconofi uuxeuepvpr 14pucr(B r4ccne.{oBanr4flB cocraBe llpoMeHeAXMeHrySaxynrrera 3KoHoMuxuIfuIY BIIIS I{ HcnoJIb3oBaHbIrerta$yurpaMMbr$yn4aueHrarbHblx HccneAoBauui,tHI4y Bru3 npl4 BbInoJIHeHnr4BbrcoKonpor43BoAr4TeJrbHccJreAoBasuit:s 2009 r. <<ZcuoJrb3oBaHrreAaMeHTanbHbrxpr pr4cKHbrx lapannenbHbrx euqr4creHuft B 3a.{aqax SzuaHconofi r4H)KeHepr4r4s 2010 r.
<ZccneAoBaHHeMr,rKpocrpyKTypbrMeHeAXMeHra)),QrauauconbrxpbrHKoB))Mr4KpocrpyKrypu SuHaHcoBbrxpbrHKoB)).llo4rnepxAeu s 201 1 r. <I,IccneAoBaHrreHo coorBercrByrcrqefi cnpanrofi o nue4peHlar4.Ily6"rrurcaqlln. OcHoeHrre rroJroxeuufl [vrcceprarlr{r4r43Jro)KeHbrs 6 crarF,rxo6rqurrao6renaou6,52 n.t. (nr,ruHufiBKnaA- 5,38 n.n.).O6rervr rr crpyrflypaorrpeAeAucceprarluu. [enu v 3aaa.uvr4ccneAoBaHuflrrvJrkrcrpyKTypy pa6oru, Koropat orpaxaer ee o6rqyro rrAero H norr4Ky.luccepraqur cocror4Tu3 BBeAeHr{r,Tpex rJIaB,3aKrlorleHux, 6u6tuorpa$uuecKoro cnr4cKa14[pr4noxeHr4r4.II.
OcHonHbrerroJror(eHuqu pe3yJrbrarbrArrcceprarlr{oHHoror{ccJreAoBaHufl.B uepnofi rJraBe r43JroxeHbrMeroAonorr4rrecKr4eocHoBbr MoAenupoBa:nlaflpr4cKapbrHorrHoit ttuxnugHocrl,I.llo4po6Ho paccMorpeHbr{BHbre H HeqBHbrerpaHr43AepxKrru nocneAcrBr4flr4xyqera B KJraccuqecKuxMoAeJux rlenoo63aKur.roHHbrepa3oBaHr4qBpeMeHeM,HcIIoJIb3yIotrIr4xrrpr4 nocTpoeHr4nnpeAnoc HenpepbrBHbrMcbrnKyo coBeprxeHHoMpbrHKe.Tarxe [pr4BeAeHrrcoo6pa)KeHr4rB rronb3yroro, rrroynpaBneHne noprSeJreM ilpu yqere rpaH3aKIII4oHHbIXH3AepxeK Aon)KHo Hocurb HM-nylrcHrrft xapaKTep, T.e.
KoppeKTHatIIocraHoBKa.qauuoil 3a4a.uvrroApa3yMeBaerB TepMHHaxAI4cKpeTHofoBpeMeHrI.orrpeAeneHr{eilpbrHKa flBrqercqB KoHTeKcre pecrpyKrypv3ar\Lrr4roprQen-s JrHKBr4AHocrbBaxHbrMKpzrepueM rrpr4Hrrllt pelxeHuit Als, rlHBecropoB,TaK KaK rrorBJrrercr Heu3Aep)I(eKkr prx BrrLrflHvflHao6xoAuuocrb orIeHKr{ o)KlIAaeMbIXTpaHcaKIII,IoHHbIXqr4cryro AoxoAHocrb rrHBectuuui,t.B craryaqu{x, KorAa o6neu rro3prrlr{r4r4 TeKyulr4eycnoBr{q raKoBbr,rrro Mo)KHoroBoprrrb o6 orsocurerruofipbrHor{HbreHusxofr rraK-HHcrpyBr{AHocrrrpbrHKa,nprz y[paBJreHrlr{nopr$eneru neo6xoAr{MoHcrroJrb3oBarbpbIHKa COOTBeTCTByTOqIXJIHKBI,IAHOCTHaKTr4BOB.MeHTbrilnfl. aHanv3a u r43MepeHI,IqJrr,rKBr4A,,{anee onlacaHbr pa3nr4tlHble no.{xoAbl K orlpeAeneHl4ro I4 r43MepeHr4roHocrr{ pbrHKa.
Oco6oe BHLrMaHr4eyAeneHo reopr4r4 prrHouHofi MnKpocrpyroypbrkr3yr{eHr4eMnpoqecca TopfoBJrkr14opfaHr43arJnvtpbrHr(oBpbrHKa, KoTopar 3aHHMaeTc_sHa (Mr{KpoypoBHe), cBq3aHHoM c orrr4aaHneMB3ar4Mogefi,ctuunpbrHor{Hbrx areHToB.llpe4craureHbrpa3nuqHbre pblHor{Hble crpyKTypbl 14 orll4caHo oKa3brBaeMoe r4Mr4BJrr4rHHeHa npoqecc $opnaupoBaHl4tI{eHbI.Eoree roro, IroKa3aHo,rrro KaxAoMy rnrry pbrHorrHoficrpyKrypbr coorBercrByer cBoq Mr4KpocrpyKTypHaflMoAeJrb,KoropatB 3aBvreuMocrl4or ApyrHX peneBaHTHbrxQaxropon. B gaer.rMoxer Bapbr4poBarbcfl.pbrHKa,Koroor rlapaMerpoBMoAenr46y.Uero[peAen-srbcflvr nrrKBr4.qHocrbcr4Mocrr.rpafl.flBnflercrro eyruroHAoreHHofiuepeuensofi.rocBqqeHo noAXoAy A.