Отзыв оппонетна 2 (1105701), страница 2
Текст из файла (страница 2)
J I b ~ a T b 1 pa60~b16b1nu n p e A C T a B J I e H b 1MeXAYHaPOAHbIX6a3ax2.C.r J I a 3 ~ 0 ~ 0 fHi aP O C C H ~ ~ C K U XK O H @ ~ P ~ H ~ U I IMOJIOAbIXXYseHbIX,69TOCBHAeTeJIbCTByeT 0 ~ O C T ~ T O ' I Hanpo6aqnnO~~p e 3 y J I b T a T O B ~ H c c ~ ~ T ~ ~ H opa60~b1.H H o ~ ~nou a ~ ~ o p e @ e pA.C.a ~ a ~ J I ~ ~ K O BH MOeFe T~c R prrn s a ~ e s a ~ u Hf iTeKcTy A H c c e p T a u mBOIIPOCOB.1.
Mecc6ay3po~c~a.sCIIeKTpOCKOnHRHCCJIeAOBaHHII.~ O ~ T O MKYa s e C T B OB , Q ~ H H o ~p~a 6 o ~ eIIBJIReTCIIIIOJIysaeMbIX3THMMeTOAOMOCHOBHbIM MeTOAOMpe3yJIbTaTOBOIIpeAeJIReTCIIKaseCTBOM M ~ C C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O B CCn eKK OT pTO MO e T p a H M ~ T O A U K On~p~O B e A e H H I I U 3 ~ e p e H H f i .O A H ~ KBOOB T O P O ~ r~n a B e ,noc~xueasofi,BTOMwcneH MeToguKe sKcnepwMeHToB,H 3 ~ e p e H k i f iM ~ C C ~ ~ Y ~ P O B C nKe K~ T~p XOB nOCBIIueH0 BCerOHeAOCTaTOsHO.H e o 6 x o ~ u ~yoK a 3 a T b5onacaaumnpoBe,qeHurrn p e ~ J I 0 X e H k i f i( c T ~50)..3~01-0IIBHOTHII M ~ C C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O B CC ~K ~OKTTO~ O M ~ T ~ ~ n(pOU BBe )C,T H UXOCHOBHbIe XaPaKTePkiCTHKH, C n e K T p b I TOHKUX CTaHAaPTHbIX ~ o T J I o T H T ~ J(a-FeI ~ ~ ~ H HUTpOnpyCCU,QaH~TPHII) AJIR A B y X H C n O J I b 3 y e M b I X CKOPOCTHbIX n H a I I a 3 0 H O B , y K a 3 a T b @OPMY JIHHUfi HX C n e K T p O B HAaTbOqeHKHHXIUHPHHWBeJIHqUH3@@eKTa,3 K C n e p U M e H T a ( ~ o ~ o I I I o KKpkiCTaJIJI,,@Onbra HT O J I u H H y B MTF ~ / c MHpkiBeCTU~,np.),OnHCaTb06pa3qb1AJIR~ @ @ ~ K T U B H Y KTOJIWHHY)M ~ C C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O B C K O T O0 6 p a 3 ~ 0HJIU~HXH H @ o ~ M ~ ~ U 06K , O u e H H B a e M b I X n a p a M e T p a X , 0 @ O P M ~JIUHHfi, 0BO3MOXHbIX CBR3KaX H O T P a H W ~ e H H R XH a B a p b H p O B a H H e n a p a M e T p O B H T.A.2.
K ~ KaIIIIpOKCkiMkipOBaJICII@ 0 p ~JIHHHEa~ecc6ay3pO~C~HCIIeKTp,fin p k i ~ e f l e H H b 1 f i H a PkiC.35? K a ~ a ~ rH c I I o J I ~ ~ o B ~ J I ~~ck~i K? C H p 0 ~ i I J I k i CHJIHbC B O ~ O A H OBapbkipOBaJIkiCb H a P a M e T P b I n P HannpoKcuMaquw,Bp e s y n b ~ a ~KeO T O P O ~ ~~ 3 o ~ e p ~ bc n1BeH r H u3UIHPHH~I n k i ~ u f i o ~ a 3 a n k i c bCOOTBeTCTBeHHO OAHHaKOBbIMH AJIH P D H b I X KOMIIOH~HT?E c n ~UrHPHHbIJ I H H H ~ IIPHHHMaJlHCb~OAHHaKOBbIMH AJIH T p e X A Y ~ J I ~ T O BTO, KaK a B T O p O ~ ~ X C H HnTp H 9 H H y HX ~ ~ B ~ H C THaB ~KaKOM?OCHOBaHHHBBeAeHaTpeTbHKOMIIOHeHTaFeSq CHHTeHCHBHOCTbH)Hepe3OHaHCHOM y 9 a C T K e c I I ~ K T ~n 0~ 9? e ~ yAJIH HHTeHCHBHOCTHHBHOMeHbIIIeIIIYMaHa3 ~ 0 f iKOMIIOHeHTbI oIIIu6~aH aIIOPHAOK M e H b I I I e , 9 e M AJIH A p y T H X K O M ~ O H ~ H T ?3. Ha KaKOM OCHOBaHHH KOMIIOHeHTbI CIIeKTpOB C B ~ J I H ~ H HKBaApyIIOJIbHOTOo~~0.14-0.18IIOpHAKaMM/CHe~ d ~ n 6 .
9 6 ~ ~ ~ e o . 0 4H0 1AP.)?2,annPOKCHMMPOBaHb1n 0 9 e ~ yKOMIIOHeHTbIKaKPaCueIIJIeHHH(PHc. 35, 36, 38CHHTJIeTbIFe(2)CIIeKTpOB, OTHOCHuHeCH KEiAJIHFe(3)HH M e I o u H e n p a K T H 9 e C K H OAHHaKOBbIe I I a p a M e T p b I ( K ~ KB C J I y 9 a e @ ~ K T H % C K H X C H H m e T O B , T a K HA ~ ~ J I ~ T-oTa6n.B9TOFe(2)5H6), H ePaCCMaTpMBaJlHCb KaK O A H a H T aXeK O M ~ O H ~ H TABTOP~?YKDbIBaeT,a Fe(3)HaXOAHTCH B CHMMeTPH9HbIX KHCJIOPOAHbIX OKTa3ApaX,OKTa3ApH9eCKHX( ~2 5 d+~6). OAH~KOOAHHaKOBbIenOJIH3ApaX- B CHMMeTpH9HbIXIIapaMeTpbICB~~XTOHKO~~CTPYKTYPbI AJIH C O O T B e T C T B y I o u H X KOMnOHeHT C n e K T p O B MOTYT Y K a 3 b I B a T b H a TO, 9 T OFe(3) HaXOAHTCH B OAHHaKOBOM O K P Y X e H H H4.
HaCTP.803 @ @ eAonnepa~~OYeBHAHO,a B T O p n P H B O A H T HSBeCTHYH) @OPMYJIYa2.36b1no 6b1~ e AJIH~ b HeCneqHWHCTanOJIe3HbIMAe6mH p H M e H e H H e MOAeJIHB TeOPHHA e 6 a ~ OD, aTeMIIepaTypyYKDaTbOM, X a p a K T e p H 3 y H ) r r l y H )TeMnepaTypAJIHccTeMnepaTypaTBepAbIXTenHaKBaAPaTHYHOTOH a TOT @KT,ee3aMeHHTb~@@~KTHBHO~~e ~ ~ 6 a y 3 p 0CneKTpOCKOnHH,~~~0fi9T0,CTPOrOMHOTHeH a TaKTOBOPH,HDbIBaeMyIo06JIac~b(XOTHJIOKaJIbHyH)aBTOPbIHeCMOTPH H aAJIHM ~ c c ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o B c K ~ HH 3 - 3 a ~ ~ H ~ K OCMbICJIaT O3THXYnpOueHHHHCIIOJIb3yH)THApe57FeYTO H 3 0 ~ e p ~ b 1 fXi H M H ~ ~ C K CABHT,M ~ ~ TaK@ ~ K T H ~ ~ c KHHe3 @ @ e ~ Aonnepa~ac t A ~ a n a 3~3aBHCHTIIpOIlCXOAHT( q e ~ ~ p a J I b ~ b 1CABHT)fiKOMnOHeHT CIIeKTpa CnHCaTbB O~JI~CT~HOD HBJIHeTCHHa3BaHHeC T p O K a CHHSY, H a n H C a H O : ( ( A H W H ~T ~ M I I ~ ~ ~ T 3aBHCHMOCTHY ~ H o ~ ~ XHMH9eCKHX...9.
O A H ~ KHSBeCTHO,O3JIeKTPOHOBOnHCbIBaIouyH) K B W P ~ T H ~ H ~ I ~ ~Ae6m))).3 ~ e c bXe, 8CABHTOB(31),3 @ @ e ~MeccGayspa,~aHeKOppeKTHO YKDbIBaTb C O ~ C T B ~ H H OCJIeAyeTTeMnepaTypyHH MOTYT 6 b 1 ~ b3KBHBWeHTHbIMH.B PaMKaX A ~ ~ X B CMOAeJIH,K O ~H ~Y K D b I B a e T , 9 T O0, HTeMnepaTypbIFe(2)M ~ C C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O Bn Ca pKa MOe MTpe,H3MeHeHHenOJIOXeHHHK O T O P ~ I ~H~M e e TCJIy9aeHOUeHTpaH3MePHeMOTO6b1~10661IIOHHTHO,TeMnepaTYPHYH)BCJIeACTBHeT O M KYO p p e K T H e e3KCIIepHMeHTWbHOB AaHHOMKaK H nJIOTHOCTbTeMnepaTypbI.~ e ~ I I e p a ~ y p 0~f Oi . ~e ~ n e p a ~ y p ~3aBHCHMOCTHofiH 3 0 M e p H O T O [ J I H ~ O~ ~ H T P ~ X I I ~ H OCABHTa)).TO]OTXe9TO3aBHCHMOCTbTHXeCTH6bmo 6b13Ha9eHHHpe9b H A e T 0H3-3aBKJIaAaKBaApaTH9HOTO 3 4 4 e K ~ Aonnepa.a5.
BonpocIIOTeKCTYHaCTP.MOXHO JIH83-89.OnHCaTbPOCTKBaAPYnOJIbHOTOP a C U e n J I e H H H C I I O H H X e H H e M T e M n e p a T y p b I B M ~ C C ~ ~ Y ~ P O B C KCMn eXK T p a X MaHTaHHTOB B P a M K a X4MOAeJIH OCHOBHOrO H H H 3 K O J I e X a a H X 3JIeKTPOHHbIX T e P M O B HOHOB X e J I e s a , C Y M M ~ P H ~BKJIaAI~~r p w H e H T O B 3JIeKTpHYeCKOrO IIOJIR KOTOPbIX OIIpeAeJIHeTCH ~ O J I ~ ~ M ~ H O B C KYCPeAHeHHeMUMIIO@ o p ~ y n e :Vzz=CVz,'xexp(-E,/kT)/Cexp(-E,/kT)?HH3KOJIeXaaHX6 y n e ~B O s p a C T a T b ,TePMOBnpanoHHXeHaHII03TOMYBCJIyYaeTeMnepaTypbIOAHHaKOBbIXBKnanr3n3HaKOBr3nOCHOBHOrO H HH3KOJIeXalIIHX T e P M O B C Y M M ~ P H ~ I ~ ~ H KBaAPYIIOJIbHOe P a C a e I I J I e H H eOT6yny~PaCTH C I I O H H X e H H e M T e M I I e p a T y p b I .6.
HapHcyHKe56BHA, q H @ @ e p e ~ u ~ a n b ~ o cr noe K T p a ,nonyYeHHoroBpesynb~a~eaIIIIpOKCHMa4Hki M ~ C C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O CB I ICe KKT pOa ~OnHHMOKBaApyIIOJIbHO P a C U e I I J I e H H b I M A Y ~ J I ~ T O M ,OAH03HaYHO y K a 3 b I B a e T H a TO, YTO CIIeKTp c ~ I I ~ ~ I I o ~ H ~ H oHHCOCTOHTH ~ I ~ ~ KaK MUHUMYM H 3 ABYXKOMIIOHeHT ( K B ~ A P Y I I O J I ~ H ~ I XA ~ ~ J I ~ T O B~) .O ~ T O MAYa J I b ~ e f i I I I l l e P a C C Y X A e H U X A 0 IIpHBeAeHHRp e 3 y n b ~ a ~~a o ~ oa fn ni p o K c H M a u u uJ I l l ~ H f iBIIep~0fiMOAeJIH (0.32(1)Hapuc.
58 uB~ a 6 n .12H B J I R ~ T C H H ~ J I H L U H U M U .LLIHPHH~IMM/C) U BO B T O P O ~ ~(0.29(1) MM/C) @ ~ K T H Y ~ C K OAIIHaKOBbI,Bn 0 3 T O M y H e COBCeM KOPPeKTHO r O B O P H T b 0 TOM, YTO B I I e p B O M C J I y Y a e JIHHHH YIIIHpeHbI.7.B b 1 3 b 1 ~ a eCOMHeHHe~aIIIIpOKCHMauHH M ~ C C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O CBn eCKKT pHO BX H a PHC.o 6 y c n o ~ n e ~@a0 p M a ~ p e ~ b eMf i~M a r H H T H O r O CeKCTeTaAOCTOBepHOrO~ H H T HKOMIIOHeHTbIO ~ ~Fe(116? npkl 5 KBbIXBJIeHHHTpeTberO62H67. Y ~ M~ e ( 1H) a~PHC. 62? K a ~ u eIIIHPHHbI JIHaHfi yCOOTHOIIIeHHe c H r ~ a J I / ~ r r y BM C I I e K T p e CJIHIIIKOM MaJIO AJIHCeKCTeTa.AAJIRCIIeKTpaIIpHT=77 K,CyAHIIOA H @ @ ~ ~ ~ H ~ H ~ J CI I I~e KHTop yM, B~ 4 e H T p e BO3MOXeH K B ~ ~ ~ P Y I I o J I A~ H~ ~~I J~ I~ C~ OT O, T B ~ T C T B Y I O ~ H ~ ~COeAHHeHHH,Fe3+. HaPHC.67CeKCTeTHBJIHeTCH OCHOBaHHeM AJIH COMHeHHH.Fe(3)IIO HHTeHCHBHOCTH HBHO 6 ~ 1 ~ 1 3K0 ~UIYMY, YTOEcnu 661 a B T O p6oneeIIpOBeJIaAJIHTeJIbHOe H 3 M e p e H H eI I p u B e n e H H b I X CIIeKTpOB H IIOJIyYHJIa 6b1 COOTHOIIIeHHe c H ~ H ~ J I / I I I ~ XOTRM60nb111e,Y e M B I I p H B e A e H H b I X CIIeKTpaX, TO O H a CMOrJIaa n n p o ~ c w ~ ac n~e ~K T~pma a, B e p o m H e eHaCTP.114 B67: c t K p o ~ TOrO,eH a RApaXKoHqe nocneAHeroBcero,IIOJIyYHTb6oneeB YeTbIpeAOCTOBepHyH,npyrae p e 3 y n b ~ a ~ b 1 .a63aqa A.C.
r n a 3 ~ o ~n war r r e T nonoBogy cneKTpa H apac.AJIH BCeX KOMIIOHeHT IIPHHHMaJIHCb P a B H b I M H BeJIHYHHbl CBePXTOHKHX n 0 J I e f i5 7 ~ eYTO,HhfX a p a K T e p H O nJIH OflHOTHIIHbIX K ~ H c T ~ J I J I o ~ ~ ~ @ H Y ~ II03HIJPifi))cKHxH IIPHBOAHTAaHHbIe aIIIIpOKCHMaqHH BIIpHBeAeHbI P a H e e B~ a 6 n .16. A H ~ J I o ~ H Y Hp~e 3I y~J I b T a T b I~ a 6 n .14P a B e H C T B a CBePXTOHKElXAJIH CIIeKTpOB H a PHC.C P a B H b I M H 3HaYeHHHMEI AJIH62. O A H ~ KHO3IIoJIefi AJIH M a r H H T H b I X KOMIIOHeHT CIIeKTpOB,PaCCTOHHHe M e X n y IIOJIOXeHHHMH K ~ ~ ~ ~ JHI HE~ Ik iXf i(1 -fi H8.6b16b1 pa3a~ O Y ~ M YI I p HaHaJIH3ePHC.62H67HhfH e BHAHOKOTOPbIe OIIpeAeJIHIOTCR KaK6-fi) B CeKCTeTe.HH3KOTeMIIepaTypHbIXB ~ M ~ ~ , C~ BbICOKOCIIHHOBbIMH~ ~ ~ F ~ ~ ,HOHaMH~ ~ oFe3+~aBTOpM ~ C C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O B CCIIeKTpOBK H XHePaCCMaTpHBaJIaMOAeJIbI I a p a M a r ~ H ~ ~poe Jf Iia K C a 4 H H C p a 3 J I H Y ~ o f 3aCeJIeHHOCTbIOiA Y ~ J I ~ T OKpa~epca?B9.
ABTOPY T B e p X A a e T H aCTP.1 12-1 13 0 HaJIHYHHC I I H H - C I I H H O B O ~p~e J I a K C a 4 H H B M a H r a H H T eB ~ M ~ ~ , I I~0 X~a p a~K T e~p y Fp a 3~M b 1~~ 0 f.i M~ ~ ~~ H Ho T ~H KOMIIOHeHTbIO ~ ~5B HH3KOTeMIIepaTYpHbIXH ~ B ~ C T H OTO,M ~ C C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O B Ccnempax.K H XC ~ M H - C ~ H H O B O ~p ~e n a K c a u msacToTaFe3+,n 0 3 T O M ynpOIIOpUMOHi3JIbHa K O H U e H T p a U H H I I a p a M a r H H T H b I X HOHOB, B AaHHOM C J I y s a e HOHOBXem R IIOATBePXAeHHR 3 T O r 0 Y T B e P X A e H H R H ~ O ~ X O A H M OH3MePEiTb I I p H 3THXMaHraHMTbI~ i ~ n l , ~ ~ F e C~ 0APYrEiMH30 6 ~ a p y X H ~ bC O O T B e T C T B Y I o u e eKOHUeHTpauHRMHH3MeHeHkieCTeneHHX5 7 ~ ea,H30TOnaPa3MbITOCTHTeMnepaTypaXHanpaMep,Tpe~befi M~THHTHO~~KOMnOHeHTbI.10.