Отзыв официального оппонента (авт. Одесская М. М.) (1102044)
Текст из файла
OT3bIBOqr.rccepraqutIIII Xoy <Tpa4nqru pyccrcoftocMblcJreHr{n rcu'raficrcqx lpo3arrroB (9exoncoucKaHr.rnf0.01. 01-xracc[.recnofi Jrnreparyplru JIy Cnnr)>,Bnpegcrae.neHnoi nay.reHoi creleHn KaHA[Aara {n,ronoruvecxgx HayK no c[eugalrbuocrltpyccxafl ,'rrrreparypaIIIu Xoy nocBsqeHa oanoMy u3 Beayrqr4x acneKToB rfulolorxvecxorouccJreAoBaHr{r - cpilBHrrrenr,HoMy nr.rreparypoBeAeHuro E 6o;ree xoHrperuo - poccuficxo-.{uccepraqurKI4TafrcKr.rM nr.rreparypHrrMcBr3rM. I,lryreuue pocctficxoft lxTepar_vpbr e Kurae ururaficroi n Poco.ru r.rMeer AaBHroro rpannuuro, a B nocreJgee Bpevr MoxHoKoHcrarr.rpoBarr oco6ufi noAreM B3trr.rMr{oro HHTepeca K KyJbrypav lB}x crpan- H B3ToM cMbrclreXorsreN,rareu4 nu6paHnax guccepranrrcoi, 6eccnopno.zr(rya-rbHa.ar4cceprarlrlr cSopuy:ruporana coucxareJrrHHuefi ;loBo..rbHo txHpoxo.
B no-teee 3peHfit onkH acneKTCaHc. HacreArae,-conocraBnTenuui asalu:TBopqecK,ur r.rHAnBr{AyanbHocrb, aTBoptiecrBaA.II. 9exoaa n11'rarcxe csr:r JIy Curu c p1.ccxoftrr.rreparypHoi TpaAr,tquei n 4ocrarowroil Mepe Hccne,qoBalubr KaK B Kurae. ran HPoccurl,u ciMa couc(arenrHull4BcryrrJreHlrll K Ar.rcceprarluu.n3f{EBIIItut llcroplrrc Bonpoca nsuer o6 aro}tClqecrelror rarxeuBr,rAurBopa6oru ua pyccKov ll xrlra.ficxorrs3brKax, nocBr IeHHbre corocraBrrrenbHoMy ananroy r{exonaIlIu Xoyu JIy Cunx. Cgoro gaJa.r.B rou, wo6u pacfiupr.rrb r(pyr aurLtn3npyevlx npou:se.teurfi.ycraHoBr,rrb reHerr{qecKr.rer4 rr.rnoJroruqecKxe cBs3urBopqecrra JIy Csu.s c 9exossnr.Conoctagregue npoBo.[I.lrcr rro reMaruqecKoMy npnuuntty.
3Tovy coorBercrBlerAeJIeHr,regHar4cceprarr{tr Ha r;raBbr. Tar, nepnar rJraBa Ha3brBaercq <<Tevr rrelnurrfibr BTBopqecrBe A.II. rlexoea n JIy Cune>;{exorar"lly CuHn>; Tperbs-rropar - <<Teua obqecne o rnopsecrae A.[I.<<Terua qerei E AercrBa B TBopqecrBe {eroae r jI1'Cuns).3aHtrlar uegrlquuofi r{exosa r4 JIy Cun-rconocraBJleHl4e pyccKoro prqeJIoBeKu-ornpaBuar roqx4rr.rraicxoro nucarelefiB .rlucceprarlHHa o6rqecrno B3aI,IMocBr3aHbL Coqna,rnrlte ornomenutIIy Cvnr - lrarucrpanbHiurJrr.rHHJrr.rccJreaoBanEc xoropofiBlIIlHar{HHaerctXo.v. Me:uunsa-B npon3Be.feHn.rx,rMcceprarlua IIIu Xoy.gexosallepnanrJraBa Arrcceprarlufi nocBqrqega MeAr.rqr.rHeu 6ole:ssu o6qecrga. Vcxoasuz6eccnopuoro rfarra, cnu4ere:rrcrByrcrqero o roM, rITo ueqr.rqr,tra c0opMupoB:L,ra y o6o[xnucarenefi oco6rrfirunTBopqecrBe pyccxoroBprnpor43BeAeHrrJrxMr4poBoclplrrrr4r,lIIu xoyxuraficxoro nucare:refi.
Coucxarentnuqa BfiIurr{exosa: coanoft cropoHbr,ABa rr.rfia npauefiEAeaJrucrr,rqecKr.rfi o6pascaMoorBepxeHHoro Bpaqa, npeAaxnoro cnoefi npotfeccu[, B pacc(a3eApyrofi -rurrr npavefi npaccMarpr{Baer.qeryalr4pForquft uoA no:4eficrnr-reu /lypHoro<flouprrryrrr>,BJrrl'^:,i^:,1raco6qecrra o6pa:Ha ca-t.rorr,r AeJre, ayMasrcr. .rro grofivro6lr onpe4e,turl uuoroo6pa:ue co3.uaHHbD( HexogrlvAoKTopa Crapuena r.r3 paccKa3a <<I4onlu>.Ar.rxoroMriu HeaocraroqHo,o6pa3oB AoKTopoB.K xaxolry rurtyorHocsrcs cpa3y npHxoarurne HaTonopxor (<I-{reru :anosAanbre't, Knpullron (<Bparu>),(lftax Batrr>)r.rap.? O Hlrx aarKe He ].noMr.rHaercsflo uueuuro llIN Xoy, o6f{eHnen1'ru JIyCrirr, ou,roKTopa(<garixa>>).
AcrponB ar4cceprarlr,tu.$arylrrere oflpe.f,eJH--ro xx:uesssuiTe;recHbre HeJyrH.rrolei. cxo,rrxo uxHa Meauur.tHcxoucraJr He croJrbKo Jreqr4Tr,6orssue Ayruu. B groM cor,rcKare:rlHr{r_Iaee[opu)a.rBrrAr.rr cBr3bc rpaJuuuefi pyccroft .'ruTepaD.pbr.qecKof HanpaBneHHocrbro r.r, B qacrHocrg.crBop.recrBov 9exosa.flporpeccurHue B3rnr,qbr IIy Cuus, ero opaeHraqlu Ha eBponeficKfie .rpaJuulu Kiu( Brla{aHr4crr4MeAr,rrlr4He, TaK r.rB Jrr.rreparype, cnoco6crgoga,ru roMy, qrocBoHX npor43BeAeur4rxo6o:resHrxSt:tuecxux,IIy Cxnr.paccKa3brBiur Bo6;ruqaer orcr,Ltoe Qeo:ansnoeo6rqecrno Kurar, xoropoe He roJrrKo He xoqer orofiruorycrap€BurHx veroJoBHapognofo qeJrr,rrenbcrBa, rySurelsuo c Ka3brBiuolqHxcr Ha 3JopoBbe,repeBeHcKHXxr4Tenefi, uo o6rqecrno rarcr(e flopa.lr(eHo ]r ayxoBHo.
,{puennue nopoxuHeBexecrBo, pa3o6qeHHocrb, paBHoA,'rxue, roprrcro;uo6ne epavefiBHr4MaHr.rrraKr{xnpor,r3BeAeHufi-lo.tefi. nx- B rreHTpeknraficxoro nucareJrr, xax <Eparrr>.<3aarpa>.flo ltrenuro Aficcepr:lHrrd{, JIy Cuur Hacneayer y gexona Mero.r H3}'r{eHHtqeroBeqecKux nopoKoB, Koropbre pyccxlli nlcarer'rb sa6,rroraer n <luxcupl'er c<Cua4o6re>.roqHocrrror.rlllx Xo1.tB,ttercc paccxa3nelaHrr,rwrocrrro Bpaqa. I4 npullepou n;a lly Cunt, no MHeHHroTaKoro Br{uMareJrbuoro u3yqeHnucropxr{ 6o,re:uN qeJoBeKa<14onrrq>.Bsax,uoqurenr,sol,r naparparferlanlrcoucKarerbunua paccvarpnnaer o5parucyMacllleArrrux s (Ilanare Ns6> r{exoBa u <lnennare c}atacuretrtreroHe corJlacr,rrbctzcMHeHI4eM) JIlCnHx.
He-rstaAlrccepralrrKlt o roM, rITo IIoBecrLI 9exona <9epHsrfi vonar"<flanara N6>, a raxxe <,{uenuux cyr{acrueAmero) IIy Cuut lpoaonxalor 6orarFoTpaArrqmopyccxoi nr.rreparypbrocyr{acrrrearur]x (fpu6oeaon,flyurrnu. foro;rs.n,{ocroencxr.rfi). <IlalaryNe 6>, xaxcqrrraercor.rcKarenbHr.rqa,HecnpaBeAJrr4Bocru.<.{uennltx c)'Maclnealtrero)), o6!e.{HHter,[porecr repoeB npou:ne4eunfi nporlrBB <.{nennuKe cF{acne,4rrrero), Ka( u B (flarareMorrxe>, aBTopbr, rrocollualnbnofiJ\b6>u <qepuonrroKzBbrBauor (fiepeBepuyroe> flpeAcraBnen{eIIIu Xoy,MHeHr4roI<aKo6rqecrna o HopMa,'rlHocrr4. Cropefi B gToM cMbIcJIe <,{nennur cyMacme.qnero)) MoxHoc6rusult (uro ne pas yxe ge:ranocr) c <3anlrcraruu cyluaculealxero) foro:ra. A 9exoa,He raK oAHo3HaqHo cynlTr4MeHHo KaK Bpaq,3axmo"mrelsssri nr,rrog rraruraxofi:c6one3Htx, oco6enno ncHxI'IqecKI{x-<Measquna pacuupser Ieyro3op nHcareJUI, lt,6raroaapr MeAnuI4He, y uero (nucaremKpecrbrHaMr4,o-orJrroabMn, crpaaaJoIIInMH6ollueM.O.) ecrr'6eanocrusuIaHcoB o6lqarbcc cO6a nqcarext1vlal,u,)Kele^r*.6ecuoro.srcs o nlo.4tx, KoropL're xnByr B (reMHoM qapcrre> (c.
57).Bropan rJraBa fipo4onxaeru ruraficxoro rlrcarereft. Bgexona>, nauofir nepaofi TeMy o6qecrBeHHoroHar{ar}Toesr:r.r4,naparpatfe <Xypua,rsHar .aetretlHocrb II1' Cnur unepnorr,rnenporecra p}'ccKoroonpaBAaHuo fipoBo.(crct flapzL];Ie;rrivex:1' pa6orofiAurorrru gexonre B loMoplrcruqecKtx xqrpHilJl,x l.t corpyJHrlqecrsovpeBonroquoHHoM vsAalvr:- <Hosas Monoaexr>.rleJrri, He roBopryxe ocorpyAul4qecrBon6y:nnapuofi flpecce 6uno,Clurrr.r4efi,Nlpna,r <Hosat Monoaexb)>--TpyAuo rarNe corJlaclrrbctIj ccH3aztHLi. Ec.ru ,arc YexoBao,4sofi cropoHbl.
cnocoSo\lBo3MoxHocrblo orraqHBarl rlepo. To3To rpu61'na .Lru nportirrauilllo ueu Aocraroquo olpeAeneHHoCxHs sflpexge Bcero y fiucareteii 6r'l'tn paruuepa3nLIqHoM xapaKTepe ctMI'Ixzapa6att;sattul Ha )ruBHb, a c .qpyrofiIIllttulerpecaMa coucKaretbHuuarrr,rl1'Bo-llouHouHblxxa c' 68-69.raKI'IM yrBepx.qeHneM. t1ro (ocHoBono.'Iaralorrlg\{xyAoxecrBeuubn4 npteMoM) ans rlexosa n JIy CnH-e cBilt-'Iacb carupa.
B lllcceprauHHgroBbrpDKeHo cneAyloqlrM o6pa3oM: <Cartpnuecxoe MlrpooqyueHHe con\TcrBvero6ouu aaroparvr Ha nportxeul{r{ Bcero rBopqecKoro nyru) (c. 66). IIo KpaiHefMepe.npr.rMennreJrbuo x r{exony noao6Hoe yrBepxleul,Ie HHKax He o6ocnosaxo.Cparneuue npou:ne4eultfi gexona <9epusIfi lrosax> E (O'lHHoKufi) JIy Cunr lIIu Xo1'crpour Ha orIIIo3I.rqrIu: repofi-oguuo.rxanpuxoar.rr K BlIBoay colrcKarenbHllqaoauaKoorcraJloe, KocHoe o6qecrno. <Pa:1veercr. --yKonpuna l,r Jkur-u-v ecrbBe-'IUKaJI ve{Ta-ro, qeto oHrI xenaror Ao6urrcr u o6 ocylrlecrn-reHHn qero Meqraror.Aocrllqb B orcrajloM o6rqecreeHJII.IJrroArr He CnOCO6nu npnHsTb n CrOft(c.77\.-Tp)'JHoB KoporKoe BpeMt, TeM 6o:ree 'rro ok?\xarolrlHeXplr O6rqeHHt cT6.nbHe1OXO)1C.IX Ha HHX .-IH'{HOCTefr >llro6oeHrre ApaM;r repoeB r{exogacorlrralJrlHrxz IIy CuutraKxe paccMarpuBarorcs c rotIKI,r 3peHucron$lurron.
floutlocrr o6rraenriofi xr.r3Hlt, orcraJloecrar{oBrrcr npu.nrnofi r{eBo3Moxuocrlr coeAnnr.rrEcralsmo6suux repoen <,{alrlt cco6aqrofi> r,r rparuuecroi ru6e:ru repouuu <Crop6r no )'uearuei>npox3BeaeHur 9exoeao6urecrnolly Cuyn. C6nnxaqu JIn Cuus H paccMa'IpllBat Hx c roqKlr 3peHnc couaaibHoilIIr Xoy, cnoBuo Bo3Bparuaer Hac B enoxy 50-x roAoB npounoro croJrgrr'It,rorga raxofi rroaxoa K rrpoqreHuro xyroxecrBeHHbrx npouraegeuufi 6rlr B3Haqr,rMocrrr,Jrr,rreparypoBeAeHr.rfi focnoacrByrorqr,rM.r{rJIaBHoerarofi no.e(or HHBenI'Ipyeroco6ensocru rBopqecKoro Meroaa Kax.qoro ul nncare:refi.,{onomno Heoxr.raarrHbrM BbrrJuaurA-Krro>,qeJIoBeKacor.rcKarenbHr.rrl4c6e: ulrenu,cpaBHeHLIe rroBecrlrJIy Cnxr <floJ-runsar HcropHt(MaJIeHbKoro qeiroBeKa), KaK \apalcrepn3]ereronoBecrrlo 9exosa (CKf{HiuI HcropxtD.
Ilc;ropan Hnro:racCrenaHoeHqa paccMarpuBaerce coHcKareJIbHHuefi xaxncroput nocreneHHor .lerp4lauHHa qyxe ,ftrrrpr,rr Ctapuena: < Kar u B flpo]l3Beaeulrl{ "l'IoHrrq" a "Cryvuofi ucropHH"[oKa3aHa AefpaAaIIHt HeIIJIoxpx .[roAefi. OrqacnuaxcrKarr, oc]'nyBltrHficc Msxarcr@eaopon 'r, npoQeccop, xoroprfr Haql{Haer 3JIocJIoBnrb BMecre co BceMH.rroBeAeHuexort panbuenpurrerei Ka3arocb eMy orBparurenrnsrv > (c.
103). H ec,ru A-Kt to. xari uero oAHocejlbqaHe, KpuTLrKyeTct aBTopoM 3a To, qro npItMHTI'tBHo MbICJrr H He noHHvagrcMbrcJra r.{ 3aAaq peBoJlrousu(c.94), To, noMHeHI,IIoHrlronas Crenanonuua, B (florepe o6ueft uaeI.rcorrcKarenbHuua,-npr4rrr.IuaIIIu Xoy.-Kop€Hb Bcexu.,res 6ora>. <<BnepexnmHli:rov.-nojlarasru rrry6ororo orltHorlecrBa u 6ecn,roJnocrn ero Hcxauufi.
Характеристики
Тип файла PDF
PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.
Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
