Отзыв_2_оппонента (1026399)

Просмтор этого файла доступен только зарегистрированным пользователям. Но у нас супер быстрая регистрация: достаточно только электронной почты!

Текст из файла

B 4Iaccepralll4oHHbrfi coeerA212.141.21 ua 6ase O|EOY BO<<Mocr<oscnufi ro cyAapcrseHHrrfi rexHruecKllfiyHrrBepcl4rer rIMeHIa H.3. Eayvraua>rro aApecy: 105005, r. Mocr<sa,2-t Eayvaucr<at'ytr., 9.7.OT3bIBOOUUI4AJIbHOI O OTIfTOHEHTAHa Ar{cceprarlrroHHyro p a6ory A6panroeofi Eneurr lOprenurtHa reMy <MexaHustr QopnrrapoBaHrrt na6opa KoMrrereHruocrefiyrrpaBneHqecKux KaApoB Anq [peArrputtuit 3neKTpooHeprerl4Kz)), rpeAcraereHHofiHa col4cKaHr,re yr{eHofi creneHV KaHg:r,.p.ara 3KoHoMI4r{ecKI4x HayK rlo cnequaJlbHocrl4<3r<onoMuKa rr ynpaBneHr4e HapoAHblrr4 xosqfrcrBoM)) (10. MeHe4xueHr)08.00.05-Ha orstrn [peAcraBJIeHLI:-Arrcceprar\r4fl o6rerraona 143 crpaHI4IIbI, cocrotulaq r{3 BBeAeHvrs, crrr4cKaTepMr{HoB v onpe4eleHrafr, Tpex rJIaB, 3aKrroqeHl4q, crrl4cKa nr{Teparypbl,BKJrroqaroxrero I 16 narzvreHosaHl4fi, 19 pvrcyHKoB u 7 ra6tutl;- aBTopeSepar, B KoropoM AaHa o6ula-s xapaKrepverr4Ka pa6orrr, KparKor43JrOlKeHO O CHOBHO e COAepXaH Ve V \pr4BeAeHbI o cHo BHbIe p e3ynbraTbl.Cnucox ony6luroBaHHbrx pa6or cor4cKarer-s ilo reMe Al4ccepralll4rr BKnroqaer19 nazrr,reuonauuit, B ToM r{r4cre 5 ny6nzxa\uit B }rypHaJIaX, peKOMeHAOBaHHbIXBAK Poccun.Pesylrrarbr u3yr{eHVA rrpeAcraBJreHHbIX AoKyMeHToB rrpeAcraBJleHbl HI4xe.Pazsu1ye 3Heprerr,rqecKoro KoMrrJreKca Poccuficr<ofr (De4epaqvttr, B r{acrHocrl4oneKTpo3Heprerfirrecr<ofi orpacJrrl, flBIrflercs, ocuoeofi crparefuqecr<ofi 6esonacHocrl4crpaHbl, orHocrrrcr K rrr,rcny KJrroqeBbrx $arropoB BblcoKorexHoJlorrrrlHoro pa3BLrrufl'oKoHoMI4Ku Poccrau.Peattuu coBpeMeHHoro Mrrpa ALrKTyror poccuficrzu 3neKTpo3HeprerI'IKaMHoBbre npoSecczoHarrbHbre Bbr3oBbr vr craBflT cJro)KHbIe 3aAaql1 coAepxaqvecs' B3ueprerv.recKofi crparerr{ra Poccuu lo 2030 roAa.

Peurenrae au6uquosHblx 3aAar{pa3Br4Ttfl gneKTpo3Heprerur{ecrcofi orpacJltr HeBo3MoxHo 6es BocrIoJIHeHrrt vrpa3Bvrr1rfl, saxHefruero pecypca - r{eJloBerlecKoro, 6es nupa6orr<u ornevarorqeilcoBpeMeHHbrM Tpe6oeaHuqNa cr4creMbr rloAroroBKr4 kr neperloAroroBKll KaApoB, BrrepBylo oqepeAb, y[IpaBneHqecKl4x.3a uocleAHr{e roAbr rocyAapcrBo npnno)I{I4Jlo HeMaJIbIe yckrnvfl. n'nfl, pa3BZTr4flKaApoBoro rroreHrlr4aJra npoMbrruneHHblx npeanputtuit, aKTHBHo crr4Mynvrpyfl'o6pa:onareJrbHbre opraHlr3arruu Bbrcrrrefo o6pasonauzr K B3arlMoAeftcreurc cpeanbHbrM ceKTopoM 3KoHoMr4Kz.

Bce 6es ucrmoqeHl,I-fl LrHlzlJlzurvert MuHo6puayrrzPoccuu, TaKr.re KaK flporpaMMbr pa3BrTr4fl Qe4epanrHbrx, HarlproHanbHbrxr4ccneAoBareJrbcKr4x yHrrBepcr{TeroB, onopHblx By3oB, llpeaz4enrcKa-s nporpaMMaroBbrrreHuq rnarz$ur<a\vvr r{HXeHepHbIX KaApoB B 2012-2014 roAbr,Be4orrcrneHHas rlereBa-s nporpaMMa <<Hosble KaApbI OIIK)) H \pyrvq B KaqecrBeoS.sgaremHofo ycnoBr,r-s flonyr{eHr4rMep focyAapcrseHHofi rroAAep)KKr4npeAnonafarrv co$zuaHcurpoBaHrre npoeKToB pa3Br'tr4fl. yHr{Bepcr4TeroB, B nepByroorrepeAb, B ooJracTr4 noAfoToBKr{ r{ rroBbrrlreHz.fl KBanvQHKaI\vLl KaApoB, co cTopoHbr3ar{HTepecoBaHHbrx pa6oro4arerefr .Brraecre c reM, HecMorpq Ha rrpeAnpr4Hr,rMaeMbre ycr4nr.rfl) B Hacroslqee BpeMqMox(Ho KoHcrarllpoBarb HaJrr4r{r{e AocraroqHo cJro)KHofi curyaqupl, cJroxrur.lteircsuapbrHKe rpyAa B 3neKTpo3HeprernKe: KoMnereHrlrru BbrrrycKHkrKoB npo$unrurrxBy3oB, B ToM r{rrcJre z B o6racrl4 yrrpaBJreHut, He B nonuofi uepe yAoBnerBop-srorrpe6onaHnrru pa6oro4arerefi.

llpo6neua KaApoBoroo6ecneqeuu-syrrpaBneHr{ecKr4Mr4 KaApaMr4 3neKTpogHeprerr4Kr4 raMeer crzcreruurrfi xapaKTep6rrrr perxeHaLrcKJrroqkrreJrbHo rryreM frparHflTlzr KoMrrJreKcHbrxcrparer[r{ecKr.rx Mep npn cofJIacoBaHHbIX geitcrnul^x Bcex yqacrHr4KoB npoqecca.Kax rroKa3brBaer sapy6eNurrfi v yxe Haxourenuufi oreqecrBeusrrfi orrbrr,eS$er<uanHoe 83al4MoAeficrsue Bcex 3ar4HrepecoBaHHbrx cropoH (rocy4apcrna,o6pa:onareJrbHbrx opraHrr3aqwi'r, luzuec-coo6rqecrBa, o6yuarorqvrxefl rz 4pyrux) nnpoqecce $oprr,rzpoBaHnfl t<ovuereuquft kr KoMllereHruocreft KaApoB, Bbr3brBarorMeroAr.rqecxuft I4HTepec y l4ccneAoBarerefr v [paKTr4r{ecxuft r.rHTepec yrp eArpprr rwfi,-zarcazqnKo B KaApoB.B cs-flsz c 3TrrM Al4cceprarluoHHa-fl pa6ora A6panronofr E.IO., nocBf,IrleHHa.f,pa:pa6orKe MexaHrr3Ma $opnrzpoBaHkrfl ua6opa KoMrrereHruocrefr ylpaBneHrrecKr4xKaApoB, yAoBnerBopf,rcIrlnx rpe6oeaur4-flM npeAnpuxtuit 3neKrpo3Heprerr{qecKoroKoMrrJreKc a) flBrrs.ercr aKTyars nofi .Crpyr<rypa Arlccepralluouuoft pa6orrr Jrorr4r{Ha v coorBercrByerMo)Kerr4fIOCTABJIEHHbIM 3AAAqAM.Ilepean zna6a (ctp.

14-58) nocB-srleHa aHaIru3y o6pasoBareJrbHbrx cr{creM,$opvnpyrculux coBpeMeHHrrfr prrnox o6pasoBareJrbHbrx ycnyr. B rrase orpaxeHbrnpeAflocbrnKr{ pa3Burr4fl Mr4poBoro pbrHKa cncreM o6pa:onaHz-a. focrarouHoBHHMaHI4.TI yAeneHo raKoMy BaxHoMy [oHqrzro, KaK qeroBeqecxufr KaIII{Ta[.OrpaxeHa ero rrepBocrereHHa-s 3HarruMocrb KaK apafiuepa oKoHoMr{qecKoropa3Bvr-tkrfl o6rqecrna. B pa6ore aBTopoM r4ccJreAoBa:nnfl, AaHo orrzcaHr4er{HHoBarluougofr 3KoHoMIrKI4, Koropa-s ocHoBbrBaerct Ha BbrcoKoKar{ecrBeHHoMqeJroBeqecKoM KarIr4TaJIe, pa3Br{Tofi nay.ruofr czcrerrae I4 BbIcoKoM KarlecrBe )KI43HI4rreJroBeKa.

Anrop Alzccepraql4oHHoro rrccneAoBalavfl TaKXe BblrBr-ser KJrror{eBbrerroKa3arenrr Bocrpe6oeaHHocrr4 noAroroBKr4 BbrrrycKHr4KoB rr orpaxaer cnoco6rr ux|IoBbI[IeHn.f,.2Bo emopoil znaee (crp.59-106) pacrpblBarcrc-s MexaHl4srvru $opMI4poBaHI{qHa6opa KoMuereHrnocrefi ilpv noAroroBKe yrIpaBJIeHr{ecKHX KaApoB cr4crroJlb3oBaHureM npoqeccHbrx MoAeJIefi 4exrelbHocrl4 3HepfernrlecKl4xAnrop [poBoAr4T rny6oruftrouuauufi.aHarrr43 TepMI,IHa ((KoMrrereHIII4I4)), AeranbHopas6upaer MoAenH QopvrupoBalulafl.

r<orunerenqufi BbIrIycKHI4Ka o6pa:onarelruoftopraHV3arIr4LI Bbrclrrero o6pasonauur. Ha ocHoBe lpoee4eHHofo aHaIrr43anpeAnaraercr cr4creMa ynpaBneHu.s no4roronxofi ynpaBneHr{ecKlzx KaApoB,pe3ynbraroM Ae-flTenbHocrrr xoropofi qBrtercq BbIrIycKHr{K, nocrpe6oeaHHtrfiorpacnbro. Oupe4eleHnufi Hayvuufr r4Hrepec ilpeAcraBr.ser rlpeAnaraeMafl.

MoAenbpbrHKa BbrnycKHI'IKoB, B noropofi BblAen.serct HecKoJllro ypoenefi.HayuuyrorleHHocrb r4Meer crpyKTypl4poBaHHoe ofII4caHI4e3neKTposHepfeTuqecKofo KoMrrJreKca no BUAaM AeqTenbHocTII c BbIAeJIeHueM fpynfirtpegnpv.xruit u aHzltrrr3oM vx xapaKTepHbIX oco6euuocrefi. Cne4yer orMerl4Tb[pr4MeHeHr4e npoqeccHofo rroAxoAa K OIII4caHIIIO AeqTenbHOCTI4 Vr BbIqBIeHHIOnorpe6uocreir pa6oroAareneft. 3acnyxr4Baer BHIIMaHI4a cQopvupoBaHHa.f, aBTopoMcoBoKyrrHocrb KarrecrB, KoropblMu AonxeHo6la4arrBbInycKHlrK.B mpemueil zno6e (ctp.l07 -I27) aBropoM rlpeAnoxeH anropl4rMB3ar4MoAeircrlvts, c pa6oro4areJl-xMl4 B paMKax QopnrupoBatkrfl ua6opaKoMrrereHrnocrefi BbrnycKHr4Ka. Irlnrepec npeAcraBr.f,er paspa6oraHHafl cxeMaB3ar{MoAeitctsuq 6HsHeca u o6pa:oBareJrbHofr oprauz3ar\krr4 Bblcllrero o6pasonaHu-4.B xa.recrBe 3HaquMoro HayqHoro-MeroAl4rlecKoro pe3ynbrara vccileAoBaHllg MoxHooTMeTI4Tb rrpeAnafaeMylo MoAenb cIIcTeMbr cTpaTefl'IqecKofo ilnaHl,IpoBaHvrfl B By3e,a TapKe npe,4nox{eHHyro MeToAr4Ky orIeHKr{ KarIecTBa BbInycKHI4Ka, IIOCTpOeHHyIOCyqeToM ocHoBHbIX IpIIHIII4TTOB OIIeHKT{ KaqeCTBa.Creneuro6ocno ea HHocrrrrI oJIo?I(eHufi , nu noAoB I{ pe KoMeH ila\utrl,cQopvryrrpoBaHHblx B AncceprallnuOcuosHrIe HayqHble froJrox{eHvf,, BbIBoAbr I4 peKoMeHAaIJprr4 Mo}IGo crrl,ITarbo6ocHoeaHHbrMr.I, rITo [oATBep](Aaerc-s:oVcrroJrb3oBaHr4eM B KarlecrBe reoperl4r{ecrofi Sasrt uoloxeHufrHopMarrrBHbrx npaBoBbrx aKToB PO, [porpaMMbl crparerll.recKoro pa3Bkrrr4floHeprerr4rrecKoro KoMrrJreKca Pocczz, TpyAoB orerlecrBeHHblx u :apy6exnrrxyr{eHbrx B pa3Br4Tr4fl, coquanbHo-3KoHoM[qecKl4x cklcreM pa3nuqHblx yponHefr,cTpaTefr4qecKofo yrrpaBneH[A yHVBepcr4TeTaMr4, yllpaBneHvrfl I4 OIIeHKI4 IIepCOHana.olIpuMeHeHI,IeM B Ar,Icceprarlr4oHHoM I{ccJIeAoBaHkrv B KaqecrBeTeoperr4Ko-MeroAoloruqecr<ofi 6asrr: AlaaJleKTrrqecKofo, clrcreMHoro v ApyrI,IXMeTOAOB r{CCneAOBAHI,{fl, TeOpUn ynpaBneHI4t, KOHIIeIIqUI4 3aI4HTepeCOBaHHbIXcropoH, Teopr{r4 crpaTefkrrrecKofo IInaHnpoBaHLrfl., IlpoqeccHoro rIoAXoAa.oOrcyrcrBr4eM nporr4nopeuufr Teoperl4rlecKuM 14 rIpaKTpIqecKI4M AaHHrIM,coAepxaqvMcfl B TpyAax rr3BecrHbrx yqeHbrx e o6racru 3KoHoMI4KlI, MeHeAXMeHTa,rroAfoToBKr,r y[paBJleHrrecKux KaApoB.06 cyx4eHLIeM ( anpo6 aqzefipa6orbl Ha Bcepoccllficrux 14) ocuoBHbrxrrorro)KeHuir gnccepraquouuofiex{AyHapoAHbrx HayrrHo-[paKTr{qecKlrxrcoH$epenrJLrflx.ollcrroJrb3oBaHrreMMaTepr4aJroB AHccepTarlr{oHHofo r.rccJreAoBaHvrfl.

BnpaKrr'rqecrcofi AerreJrbHocrrr IIAO <IrIurepPAO>, OOO <<Macca>>, a rarcKe Byve6novr ilpoqecce raQe4pu DKoHoMr,rKr'r B 3Heprerr,rKe H rrpoMbrrxJreHHocrlr OfBOyBO (HI,IY (M3I4>.flo reue I4ccJIeAoBaHr4fl. ony6ruxoBaHoB rrerrarr4 19 pa6or, B ToM qracle 5ny6:i'urcaquit B LrcAaHkrtx, peKoMeHAoBaHnux BAK P(D, qro cBr.rAereJrbcrByer oAOCTaTOqHOM ypOBHe aIpOOaIIHH pe3ynbTaToB LrccJreAoBaHvrfl,, noATBeplKAaroqr{x3Haql4Mocrb nortyqeHHblx BbIBoAoB Lr paspa6oraHHbrx peKoMeHAa\uit.Ony6nuxoBaHHble MarepI4anbl IlonHocrbro orpalKaror pe3ynbrarbr rrpoBeAeHHoroI4ccneAoBaHtas, cAeJraHHbIe aBTopoM BbrBoAbr r4 HoBr43Hy Allcceprarlr{oHHofi pa6oru.Hay.rHan HoBu3Ha u 3Harr[Mocrb pa6oruHayvuax HoBI43Ha Ancceprar\Lrvr 14 lonyrreHHbrx pe3ynbraroB pa6omr3aKlroqaeTct B perueHl,Iu aKTyanbHbIX HayqHbIX I4 npaKTr4rlecKux 3a4aq, Kacarcqr4xcf,paspa6orKl4 TeoperzqecKl4x [ono]KeHrzfi uo co3AaHr{ro r4 npvMeHeHr,rro MexaHr43MavKoMllereHrnocrefinpuSopvrzpoBaHkrfl na6opar<ouuereHqrauyrrpaBJreHqecKr4x KaApoBAnfl SneKTpoSHepreTI{Kpr, ocHoBaHHoM HaIIoAroroBKerrpr4MeHeHr4ur[poqeccHofo rroAxoAa.HayvHa-r 3Harrl4Mocrr pa6orrt orrpeAenrerc.f, ee o HoBHbrMr4 pe3ynbraraMkr:l.

Характеристики

Тип файла PDF

PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.

Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.

Список файлов диссертации