2003 Лекции по философии

<\_^_gb_\nbehkhnbx Himera, 20031.1. Ij_^f_lnbehkhnbbb_zf_klh\aZiZ^gh_\jhi_ckdhcdmevlmjghcljZ^bpbbIj_^f_l nbehkhnbb Kh]eZkgh Nbehkhnkdhc wgpbdehi_^bb nbehkhnby ± wlh nhjfZh[s_kl\_ggh]hkhagZgbygZijZ\e_ggZygZ \ujZ[hldm p_ehklguo \a]ey^h\gZ fbj b f_klh \gzfq_eh\_dZ Z lZd`_ ke_^mxs__ hlkx^Z ihagZ\Zl_evgh_ p_ehklgh_ wkl_lbq_kdh_ hlghr_gb_ d fbjm LZdh_ hlghr_gb_ d fbjm gZau\Z_lky fbjh\haaj_gb_f ihwlhfm fh`gh kdZaZlvqlhnbehkhnby±l_hj_lbq_kdbknhjfmebjh\Zggh_fbjh\haaj_gb_>hkeh\guci_j_\h^k]j_q_kdh]hnbehkhnby±ex[h\vdfm^jhklbKms_kl\m_lb^jm]h_hij_^_e_gb_nbehkhnbb=_]_evkqblZeqlhwlh©fure_gb_hfure_gbb».F_klhnbehkhnbb \dmevlmj_Kk_j_^bguV \_dZ^hgwnbehkhnby y\ey_lky hkgh\guf we_f_glhf h[jZah\Zgby \ aZiZ^gh_\jhi_ckdhcdmevlmj_ Z ihlhfm fh`gh ]h\hjblv b hlhfqlhnbehkhnbyaZgbfZ_lp_gljZevgh_f_klh\wlhckZfhcdmevlmj_L_fg_f_g__\ihke_^gb_e_l\kz^h\hevghkbevghbaf_gbehkvbgZ^Zggucfhf_gl]h\hjblvhp_gljZevghf^Zb\hh[s_dZdhflhhkh[_gghff_kl_nbehkhnbb\jy^eb\hafh`ghIjbqbghcy\behkv[mjgh_jZa\blb_gZmdijbqzfg_lhevdh_kl_kl\_gguoijb\_^r__ddjmr_gbx\lhcbebbghckl_i_gb[hevrbgkl\Zij_`gbonbehkhnkdbodhgp_ipbc<_jhylghgZ^Zggucfhf_glfh`gh]h\hjblvebrvhlhfqlhnbehkhnbyb]jZ_ljhevh^ghcbagZmd±l_kghi_j_ie_lzgghck^jm]bfbghg_b]jZxs_cdZdhclhhkh[hcjheb\dmevlmjghc`bagbHkh[_gghklbihabpbbDbk_ez\ZHij_^_e_gb_=_]_ey©nbehkhnby±fure_gb_hfure_gbbªklZgh\blky©jZ[hq_c]bihl_ahcªdmjkZ±kfuke\lhfqlh_]hke_^m_lih^l\_j`^Zlvdhgdj_lgufb nZdlZfb lh _klv iheh`_gbyfb mq_gbc jZaebqguo nbehkhnh\ ihdZau\Zy dZdihkl_i_ggh \k_ ihgbfZxl qlh fure_gb_lh b _klv ]eZ\guc h[t_dl bkke_^h\Zgby nbehkhnbb >Z ^_ckl\bl_evgh hkgh\guf h[t_dlhf bkke_^h\Zgbc deZkkbq_kdhc g_f_pdhc nbehkhnbbb\lhfqbke_=_]_eyy\ey_lkyfure_gb_ghwlh\k_]hebrvh^gZklhjhgZf_^Zeb;_abamq_gbyfure_gby\nbehkhnbbg_[ueh[ugbq_]hghbamqZyh^ghebrvfure_gb_nbehkhnbyhklZeZkv[ugbkq_f±mfhajbl_evgufbihkljh_gbyfbhlhj\Zggufbhlj_ZevghklbLZdbebbgZq_lhevdh\k\yadZo©ijbjh^Z±q_eh\_d±fure_gb_ªb©qm\kl\_gghklv±jZkkm^hd ± jZamfª ihy\beZkv lZ bf_xsZy g_dhlhjuc ijZdlbq_kdbc kfuke nbehkhnby dhlhjmxfubf__fgZk_]h^gyrgbc^_gvJZa^_eunbehkhnbbbbklhjbq_kdh_baf_g_gb_ijh[e_fZlbdbnbehkhnkdh]hagZgbyJZa^_eunbehkhnbb<gZklhys__\j_fy\u^_eyxlr_klvhkgh\guo^bkpbiebgnhjfbjmxsbolZdmxh[eZklvagZgbydZdnbehkhnbyWlhhglheh]bymq_gb_h[ulbb]ghk_heh]bymq_gb_hihagZgbbeh]bdZmq_gb_hfure_gbbwlbdZmq_gb_hfhjZebwkl_lbdZmq_gb_hij_djZkghfbklhjbynbehkhnbbmq_gb_h jZa\blbb nbehkhnkdbo mq_gbc Wlb nhjfmebjh\db^hklZlhqghlmfZgguqlh\hh[s_]h\hjykhhl\_lkl\m_lj_Zevghfmiheh`_gbx^_e± jZa]jZgbqblv \ h^ghf nbehkhnkdhf mq_gbb hglheh]bq_kdmx b ]ghk_heh]bq_kdmx khklZ\eyxsb_[u\Z_lkeh`ghZihjhcihqlbg_\hafh`gh<ijhq_fbf_gghwlbgZa\Zgbyh[uqghbkihevamxl ^ey h[hagZq_gby jZa^_eh\ mq_gby lh]h beb bgh]h fukebl_ey ± gZ\_jgh_ aZ g_bf_gb_femqr_]hBklhjbq_kdh_ baf_g_gb_ ijh[e_fZlbdb nbehkhnkdh]h agZgby :glbqgZy nbehkhnby\hagbdeZ\dhgp_VII \^hgwdZdnbabdZ±mq_gb_hijbjh^_aZl_fihy\bebkveh]bdZi_j\Zyiheh\bgZV \^hgwbwlbdZdhg_pV \^hgw<k_j_^bg_IV \^hgwbanbabdb\u^_ebeZkvf_lZnbabdZ±mq_gb_h[mfhajbl_evguohkgh\Zo[ulbyKe_^mxsb_kms_kl\_ggu_baf_g_gbyijhbahreb\gZqZe_Kj_^g_\_dh\vyf_klhnbabdbf_lZnbabdbbeh]bdbaZgyeblZdb_^bkpbiebgudZddhkfheh]bymq_gb_hfbj_l_heh]bymq_gb_h;h]_ikboheh]bymq_gb_h^mr_H^gZdhkgZqZehfGh\h]h\j_f_gbbwlb^bkpbiebgubf_xsb_y\gucj_eb]bhaguc mdehg ihkl_i_ggh jZa\bebkv \h \iheg_ k\_lkdb_ hglheh]bx b ]ghk_heh]bxwlhlijhp_kkaZdhgqbekyk\hagbdgh\_gb_fdeZkkbq_kdhcg_f_pdhcnbehkhnbb\dhgp_XVIII\_dZDjhf_wlh]h\gZqZe_XVII \_dZ©\hajh^bebkvªnbabdZ±l_i_jvm`_ih^gZa\Zgb_fgZ1lmjnbehkhnby±beh]bdZ\dhgp_;9,,,\_dZihy\beZkvwkl_lbdZmDZglZbihke_^g_cbklhjbynbehkhnby±\jZ[hlZo=_]_eygZqZeZXIX \_dZHkh[_gghklbihabpbbDbk_ez\ZaZdexqZxlky\lhfqlhhgex[blijhke_`b\Zlveh]bdmwlh]h kZfh]h bklhjbq_kdh]h baf_g_gby Zj]mf_glu lZdh\u i_j\uf h[t_dlhf bkke_^h\Zgbcq_eh\_dZ[ueZijbjh^Zihwlhfmi_j\hcihy\beZkvnbabdZIjbbamq_gbbijbjh^uklZehihgylghqlh\wlhfijhp_kk_b]jZxljhevdZdhdjm`ZxsbcfbjlZdbfure_gb_q_eh\_dZihwlhfm\lhjhcihy\beZkveh]bdZLhevdhihke_wlh]hkfh]ebihy\blvkywlbdZbf_lZnbabdZ±mfhajbl_evgu_^bkpbiebgudhlhju_ijhklhg_fh]mljZa\b\Zlvky[_aohjhr_]hagZgbyaZdhgh\ fure_gby H^gZdh gZ wlhf \kz aZdZgqb\Z_lky ± ijhke_^blv eh]bdm \hagbdgh\_gby ihke_^mxsbojZa^_eh\nbehkhnbb^hklZlhqghkeh`gh^Zb\jy^ebwlhg_h[oh^bfh±\kzwlhe_`bl \ jmke_ \ukdZau\Zgby =_]_ey ©qlh _kl_kl\_ggh lh jZamfghª ihgylgh qlh jZa\blb_nbehkhnbbg_[uehkmf[mjgufkemqZcgufghwlh\jy^ebhijZ\^u\Z_lg_dhlhju_j_amevlZlulZdh]h\iheg_eh]bqgh]hjZa\blbyKlZgh\e_gb_nbehkhnbbhlfbnZdeh]hkmFbn Ih^ fbnheh]b_c ihgbfZxl nZglZklbq_kdh_ hljZ`_gb_ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb \hagbdr__\i_j\h[ulghfkhagZgbb\j_amevlZl_h^mr_\e_gbyijbjh^ub\k_]hfbjZFbnih]j_q_kdb ± ij_^Zgb_ kdZaZgb_ ± qm\kl\_ggh_ ij_^klZ\e_gb_ hljZ`Zxs__ g_dhlhjh_ h[h[s_gb_<fbn_g_lgbq_]hZ[kljZdlgh]hZk\hckl\Zijbjh^ul_kgh i_j_ie_l_gu kh k\hckl\Zfb kZfh]h q_eh\_dZ Kms_kl\h\Zeh ^\_ nhjfu fbnh\: lhl_fbaf h[h`_kl\e_gb_ `b\hlguo±bfijbibku\Zebkvq_eh\_q_kdb_q_jlubk\hckl\ZbiZgl_baf[h]bgZ^_e_gudZdq_eh\_q_kdbfbq_jlZfblZdbk\hckl\Zfbijbjh^guoklbobc>eyi_j\h[ulgh]hq_eh\_dZgZb[he__\Z`guf\fbn_[uebagZgbyhkZfhfk_[_bagZgbyhijbjh^_g_h[oh^bfu_^ey`bag_^_yl_evghklbIhkmlb^_eZfbnklZekihkh[hfi_j_^ZqbagZgbch`bag_^_yl_evghklbhlihdhe_gbydihdhe_gbx\hagbdeZnhjfZh[s_kl\_ggh]h khagZgby Gh \ mkeh\byo ^bgZfbqgh]h baf_g_gby mkeh\bc `bagb fbnu lZd`_ ^he`gu[ueb baf_gylvky ijbqzf baf_gylvky ^hklZlhqgh qZklh ± ihjhc ih g_kdhevdh jZa aZ \j_fy`bagbh^gh]hq_eh\_dZH^gZdhfbnulj_[h\Zeb\_juZ\g_aZigZy©i_j_kljhcdZª\_ju\k_]^Zhq_gvljZ\fZlbqgZ^eyq_eh\_dZykghqlhlZdhcimlvg_mkljZb\Zeq_eh\_dZgm`gh[uehkha^Zlvqlhlhgh\h_±bwlhgh\h_ihy\behkvEh]hk LZdbf h[jZahf lj_[h\ZeZkv bgZy nhjfZ h[s_kl\_ggh]h khagZgby kihkh[gZy©[_aihl_jvªi_j_kljZb\ZlvkhagZgb_ex^_cnhjfZmqblu\ZxsZyijhbkoh^ysb_baf_g_gbyWlZnhjfZ\hagbdeZ\ j_amevlZl_ jZa^_e_gby agZgbc hijbjh^_ b agZgbc h q_eh\_d_ g_jZaju\gh kh_^bgzgguo \ fbnheh]bb J_amevlZlhf ih^h[gh]h jZa^_e_gby klZe eh]hk h[h[sb\rbcagZgbyhq_eh\_d_b^h[Z\b\rbcdgbfZ[kljZdpbx±\u^_e_gb_\uqe_g_gb_=h\hjy ^jm]bfb keh\Zfb, eh]hk h[hagZqZ_l _^bgkl\h fukeb b yaudZ ^hoh^ys__ ^hihegh]h lh`^_kl\Z Eh]hk klZe hkgh\hc dZd nbehkhnbb lZd b gZmdb _]h hkgh\gZy q_jlZ ±ihy\e_gb_ Z[kljZdpbb LZdbf h[jZahf nbehkhnby g_ [ueZ aZg_k_gZ ba\g_ Z \hagbdeZ dZdj_amevlZl_kl_kl\_gguoijhp_kkh\ ih^h[gu_ baf_g_gby [ueb hkh[_ggh Zdlb\gu \ ljzo j_]bhgZoA_feb±DblZ_Bg^bbb=j_pbb\j_amevlZl_lZf\hagbdeZgh\ZynhjfZh[s_kl\_ggh]h khagZgby gZa\ZggZy iha^g__ nbehkhnb_c >Ze_dh g_ \_a^_ wlZ nhjfZ h[s_kl\_ggh]hkhagZgbymdj_ibeZkvlhevdh\?\jhi_hgZgZ^he]hklZeZp_gljhfdmevlmjgh]hjZa\blbyihwlhfm bf_ggh bklhjby _\jhi_ckdhc nbehkhnbb ij_^klZ\ey_l gZb[hevrbc bgl_j_k ^ey bamq_gbyG_dhlhju_k\_^_gbybaeh]bdbA^_kv[m^mlijb\_^_guebrvg_dhlhju_hij_^_e_gbyg_h[oh^bfu_^eyihgbfZgbyihke_^mxs_]hl_dklZ^Zggucdmjknbehkhnbbgb\dh_fkemqZ_g_ij_l_g^m_lgZk\yagh_baeh`_gb_eh]bdbdZdhkh[h]hjZa^_eZnbehkhnbbG_kfhljygZ\k_jZa]eZ]hevkl\h\ZgbyDbk_ez\ZdZ`_lkyqlhq_eh\_dmjZ[hlZxs_fm\h[eZklb_kl_kl\_gguogZmd\iheg_^hklZlhqgh2`bl_ckdhc[ulh\hceh]bdb±[he__ih^jh[gu_agZgbyebrvjZkrbjyxldjm]hahjg_ihfh]ZyjZah[jZlvky\j_amevlZlZowdki_jbf_glZBlZd ihgylb_ ± nhjfZ fukeb kh^_j`ZsZy kms_kl\_ggu_ ijbagZdb ij_^f_lZ ihemq_ggu_kihfhsvxhi_jZpbbZ[kljZ]bjh\ZgbyH[tzfihgylby±\k_ij_^f_lufukebfu_kihfhsvx^Zggh]hihgylbyKh^_j`Zgb_ihgylby±gZ[hjkms_kl\_gguoijbagZdh\ij_^f_lZKh^_j`Zgb_ b h[tzf ihgylby k\yaZgu h[jZlguf khhlghr_gb_f q_f [hevr_ h[tzf l_ff_gvr_kh^_j`Zgb_bgZh[hjhlHij_^_e_gb_ ± eh]bq_kdZy ijhp_^mjZ jZkdju\ZxsZy kh^_j`Zgb_ ihgylby < nbehkhnbbh[uqghbkihevamxlkihkh[hij_^_e_gbyq_j_ajh^bjh^h\h_hlebqb_\gZqZe_ij_^f_lih dZdbflh h[sbf ijbagZdZf hlghkyl d ]jmii_ ij_^f_lh\ Z aZl_f \u^_eyxl ijbagZdb\u^_eyxsb_ij_^f_lbawlhc]jmiiu<ijhq_fih^h[guckihkh[g_ijbf_gbfddZl_]hjbyf±ihgylbyfgZb[hevr_]hh[tzfZ\wlhfkemqZ_qZklhbkihevamxlhij_^_e_gbyq_j_aijhlb\hiheh`ghklvlh_klvh^gh\j_f_ggh_hij_^_e_gb_iZjuijhlb\hiheh`guoihgylbcIhgylbyfh]ml[ulvdhgdj_lgufbhibku\ZxloZjZdl_jbklbdbij_^f_lZbZ[kljZdlgufbhibku\Zxlkhhlghr_gby[hevrbc±f_gvrbce_]q_±ly`_e__Km`^_gb_±kh\hdmighklvihgylbcmfhaZdexq_gb_±gZ[hjkm`^_gbcKm[t_dlij_^bdZl«32.

:glbqgZynbehkhnby Himera, 2003H[sb_aZf_qZgby<j_f_ggu_jZfdbGZqZehZglbqghcnbehkhnbbhq_\b^gh^he`gh[ulvk\yaZghk i_j_oh^hfhlfbnZdeh]hkmkf\dmevlmj_^j_\g_c=j_pbbLZdhci_j_oh^[ue^hklZlhqgh^he]bfbkeh`gufaZlygm\rbkvihqlbgZp_eh_klhe_lb_ihwlhfmb]jZgbpZgZqZeZZglbqghcnbehkhnbbjZafulZIjbgylhkqblZlvi_j\ufb^j_\g_]j_q_kdbfbnbehkhnZfbij_^klZ\bl_e_c fbe_lkdhc rdheu \ mq_gbyo dhlhjuo ihy\bebkv i_j\u_ ohly b \_kvfZ kdjhfgu_Z[kljZdpbbwlhdhg_pVII\_dZ^hgwL_fg_f_g__ba\_klghdh_qlhbhk\h_h[jZaguo©ij_^r_kl\_ggbdZoªfbe_lp_\±©k_fbfm^j_pZoªh^gbfbadhlhjuoqZklhgZau\ZxlkZfh]hNZe_kZbfbgZau\Zebex^_c^h[b\rbokyagZqbl_evguoj_amevlZlh\\k\h_c^_yl_evghklbbl_fkZfufihemqb\rboZ\lhjbl_liha\hey\rbc^Z\Zlvkh\_lu^jm]bfex^yfLZdh]hijZ\Z ^_ckl\bl_evgh gm`gh [ueh ^h[blvky ihkdhevdm \ ^j_\g_]j_q_kdbo ihebkZo ]hjh^Zo]hkm^Zjkl\Zolh]h\j_f_gbpZjbe^modjZcg_]hbg^b\b^mZebafZBlZd^eykhojZg_gbyk\h_]h agZgby ©fm^j_puª knhjfmebjh\Zeb ijZ\^Z g_ba\_klgh \ dZdhc nhjf_ hkgh\gu_ ijZ\beZ ih\_^_gby hkgh\Zggu_ gZ \iheg_ jZpbhgZevghf ZgZeba_ kh[kl\_gghc ^_yl_evghklb Zg_ fbklbq_kdhf ihdehg_gbb ;h]Zf :[kljZdpbc lZf ih\b^bfhfm g_ [ueh Z ihlhfm ^_yl_evghklv©fm^j_ph\ªdnbehkhnbbg_hlghkylHdhgqZgb_Zglbqghcnbehkhnbbk\yau\Zxlkihegufm]ZkZgb_fg_hieZlhgbafZbmdZahfbfi_jZlhjZXklbgbZgZ]haZij_l__j_lbq_kdbomq_gbcb\qZklghklbg_ojbklbZgkdbo nbehkhnkdbo rdhe D wlhfm fhf_glm m`_ ^hklb]Z_l jZkp\_lZ gh\Zy ojbklbZgkdZynbehkhnby±iZljbklbdZghhgZg_hlghkblkydZglbqghklbhkgh\guf\hijhkhfiZljbklbdbklZeh khhlghr_gb_ \_ju b jZamfZ lh]^Z dZd ZglbqgZy ljZ^bpby ij_^iheZ]Z_l [_amkeh\gh_]hkih^kl\hjZamfZgZ^ke_ihc\_jhc\hqlheb[hBf_gghihhlghr_gbxdjZamfmjZa^_eyxljZgg_ojbklbZgkdmxnbehkhnbx±iZljbklbdm±biha^gxxZglbqgmx±g_hieZlhgbafI_jbh^baZpbyKms_kl\mxljZagu_ih^oh^udi_jbh^baZpbbZglbqghcnbehkhnbbhij_^_eyxsb_ky jZaebqgufb p_eyfb ih^h[guo deZkkbnbdZpbc Dbk_ez\ aZq_flh ijb\h^blkjZam g_kdhevdh \ZjbZglh\ gh h gbo g_kdhevdh gb`_ < ^Zgghf `_ kemqZ_ deZkkbnbdZpby[m^_l^hklZlhqghijhklhc\ljZ^bpbyohkgh\guobklhqgbdh\±>@b>@±\u^_ebf ljb i_jbh^Z.

I_j\uc – ^hkhdjZlbq_kdbc ± \dexqZ_l \ k_[y \k_o fukebl_e_c jZ[hlZ\rbo \ ^mo_nbabdbbamq_gbyijbjh^u[_a\gbfZgbydihagZxs_fmkm[t_dlm±q_eh\_dmKx^Zhlghkylky b nbabdb V \_dZ b rdheZ >_fhdjblZ dhlhjuc kh[kl\_ggh ]h\hjy hl nbabdb gbdm^Z g_mrze <lhjhc i_jbh^ gZqbgZ_lky k j_\hexpbb \ nbehkhnbb hkms_kl\ezgghc khnbklZfb baZdZgqb\Z_lky gZb[he__ agZqbl_evguf mq_gb_f :glbqghklb ± dhgp_ipb_c :jbklhl_ey >eywlh]hwlZiZoZjZdl_jgh[hevrh_\gbfZgb_dihbkdmkmsghklb\k_o\_s_c\q_eh\_d_dhlhjZyijZ\^Zgbdq_fmohjhr_fmg_ijb\_eZ-ZlZd`_kha^Zgb_]jZg^bhaguomq_gbchkgh\ZgguogZf_lZnbabd_dZdgZmd_h[mfhajbl_evguohkgh\Zo[ulbyKx^Z[m^mllZd`_hlg_k_gu khdjZlbq_kdb_ rdheu dj_idh k\yaZggu_ k dhgp_ipb_c kZfh]h KhdjZlZ GZdhg_p lj_lbci_jbh^ – weebgbklbq_kdhjbfkdZynbehkhnby±ij_^klZ\ey_lkh[hc\j_fyihkl_i_ggh]hmiZ^dZZglbqghcnbehkhnbbgZi_j\h_f_klh\uoh^yl\hijhkuwlbdbZf_lZnbabdZmoh^blgZaZ^gbcieZg<f_kl_kg_c moh^blgZaZ^gbcieZgbjZamf mklmiZyf_klh\_j_nbgZehfklZgh\blkyihemfbklbq_kdbcg_hieZlhgbafdhlhjuch^gZdhm`_g_\kbeZogbdhgdmjbjh\Zlvgbkhljm^gbqZlvkgZ[bjZxsbfkbemojbklbZgkl\hfMkeh\byaZjh`^_gbyZglbqghcnbehkhnbbWlhl\hijhklZd`_ijbgylhjZkkfZljb\Zlv\ k\yab k ihy\e_gb_f nbehkhnbb \ >j_\g_c =j_pbb Hkgh\ghc b \_jhylgh _^bgkl\_gghcijbqbghcy\ey_lkymklZgh\e_gb_gZl_jjblhjbb=j_pbb\_kvfZk\h_h[jZagh]h]hkm^Zjkl\_ggh]hmkljhckl\Z±ihebkghckbkl_fu±kihkh[kl\h\Z\r_cZdlb\guflhj]h\ufhlghr_gbyfBgh]^Z^Z`_]h\hjylhjughqghcwdhghfbd_^j_\g_]j_q_kdboihebkh\qlhh^gZdhZ[kmj^ghih ijbqbg_ bkihevah\Zgby [_kieZlghc jZ[hq_c kbeu ± jZ[h\ L_f g_ f_g__ fy]dbc kj_^ba_fghfhjkdbc debfZl b \u]h^gh_ ]_h]jZnbq_kdh_ iheh`_gb_ kihkh[kl\h\Zeb [mjghfm wdhghfbq_kdhfmjZa\blbxihebkh\<j_amevlZl_fgh]b_]jZ`^Zg_bf_eb[hevrh_dhebq_kl\hk\h[h^gh]h\j_f_gbaZgboljm^bebkvjZ[udhlhju_fh`gh[uehljZlblvgZkZfu_jZagu_4\_sb aZgylby kihjlhf gZibkZgb_ ihwf dgb] fmaudb ba]hlh\e_gb_ kdmevilmj Gm Z _szfh`gh[ueh^mfZlvh[mkljhckl\_fbjZbwlbkZfu_fukebaZibku\ZlvohlydZdgZ]ey^ghijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zeb dbgbdb fh`gh [ueh b g_ aZibku\Zlv- Ijbf_jgh lZd b ihy\beZkvnbehkhnby LZd`_ h[jZsZxl \gbfZgb_ gZ ijhba\_^_gby =hf_jZ dhlhju_ [_amkeh\gh g_y\eyxlkynbehkhnkdbfbghbf_xljy^\Z`guoklbebklbq_kdbohkh[_gghkl_coZjZdl_jguo^eynbehkhnkdh]hl_dklZeh]bq_kdbk\yagh_baeh`_gb_kljmdlmjbjh\Zgghklvh[jZagh]hjy^Z\khhl\_lkl\bbkoZjZdl_jbam_fufbkh[ulbyfbbebfukeyfbHkh[_gghklb ihabpbb Dbk_ez\Z A^_kv ke_^m_l ijhklh ijb\_klb q_luj_ \b^Z i_jbh^baZpbbno comments.1.