Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (Психологические факторы усвоения студентами дидактической терминологии)

OT3biB O<I>:r1QHAJibHOrO OllllOHEHTAHa ):(HccepTau;mo TuxoMuposou MapuuLI AuaTOJihCBHhi Ha TeMY:«fiCHXOJIOruqecKUC fllaKTOphl ycBOCHHH cry,LJ;CHT3MH ,LJ;H,LJ;3KTUqecKOHTCpMHHOJIOrHH», npe):(CTaBneHH)'lO Ha COHCKaHHe ~eHOH CTeneHH KaH):(H):(aTancmmnoruqecKHX HayK no cneu;HanbHOCTH19.00.07- ne.n:arorMtieCKIDI ncHXonormi,lJ;MccepTa.U:MOHHOe Mccne.n:oBaHHe TMxoMHpoBoiinCHXOnOfHtieCKHX<}laKTOpOBycBOeHH.HM.A.CTy):(eHTaMHnocB.ameHo npo6neMe~e6HOfOMaTepMana.Cneu;H<}lHKa pa60Tbl COCTOHT B H3~eHHH ncHXOnOrntieCKHX <}laKTOpOB YCBOeHH.H6aJbi mo6o.H Ha~Hoii orpacnM. KaK cnpaBe.n:nMBOTeopeTMtiecKoii HH<}lopMa.U:MH OTMetiaeT):(HCCepTaHTHaOCHOBaHH"HnHTepazypHOfO063opa,YCBOeHHIOTeopeTHlJ:eCKHX OCHOB HaytJ:HOH ):(HCI.J;HnnHHbl B czy):(eHtieCKOM B03pacTe C ~eTOMnCHXOnOfHlieCKHX OC06eHHOCTeH CaMHX CTy):(eHTOB nOCB.HI.u;eHO cpaBHHTen bHO ManOHCCne):(OBaHHH, a ):(aHHIDI TeMa, HeCOMHeHHO, .HBn.HeTC.H 3HaliHMOH ):(n.H COBpeMeHHOfOBhicrneroo6pa3oBaHH.H.Hcnonb30BaHMe):(H):(aKTHtieCKOH TepMHHOnOfHHBKatieCTBepe3ynhTaTaycBoeHH.HKOHI.J;enT «TepMHHOnOfHtieCKa.H KOMneTeHTHOCTb»):(enaeT HCCne):(OBaHHe eme 6onee 3Kry3JihHhiM B ycnOBH.HX ):(OMHHHpOBaHH.H BBbiCIIIeM o6pa30BaHHH KOMneTeHTHOCTHOfO nO):(XO):(a.060CHOB3HHOCThDOJIO~CHHH,uayqHhiXBhiBO,LJ;OBHpeKOMCH,l1;3I.J,UH,cfilOPMYJIUpOB3HHhiX B ,LJ;UCCCpTai.J,UU, o6ecnetiHBaeTC.H rny60KHM H BCeCTOpOHHHMnHTeparypHbiM0630pOMnoTeMepa3H006pa3HeMHCnOnb30BaHHbiXHCCne):(OBaHH.H,MeTO):(OBHnpOJJ:YMaHHbiMMeTO):(UK,BKniOliiDI):(H3aHHOM,MaTeMaTHKO-CTaTHCTHtieCKHe MeTO):(bl o6pa60TKH 3MIIHpUtieCKHX ):(aHHbiX.IJ;enh,3a):(aliH,HaYlJ:Ha.HHOBH3Ha,npaKTHlJ:eCKa.H3HalJ:HMOCTbpa60Tbi,BbiHOCHMbie Ha 3aiT(HTY nono)J(eHH.H, a TaK)J(e BbiBOJJ:bi H3no)J(eHbi nocne.n:oBaTenbHO HnorMtiHo.ABTOp,n:eTa.JibHOOIIHCbiBaeTIIOJIYqeHHbiHMaTepHarrHHHTepnpeTHpyeTpe3yJibTaTbi, BKJIIOqaJI HX B HayqHhiH H npaKTHqecKHH KOHTeKCT.Hay'lnaH uosuJua Hccne.n:osaHIDI THXOMHposo:H: M.A.

3aKJIIOqaeTc~, npe)l()];escero, s TOM, qTo ,n:mi ou:eHKH pe3yJII>TaTa ycsoeHH~ cry,n:eHTaMH TeopeTHqecKo:H:HH<l>OpMau:HH BBO.ll:HTC~ KOHIJ:eiiT «TepMHHOJIOrHqecKa~ KOMIIeTeHTHOCTh», KOTOpbiHrapMOHHqHo BIIHCbiBaeTC~ B KOMIIeTeHTHOCTHbiH IIO.lJ:XO.ll: COBpeMeHHOrO BbiCmeroo6pa30Ba~. AsTOpOM Bbi,n:emiiOTC~ IICHXOJIOrHqecKHe xapaKTepHCTHKH cry,n:eHTOBCpa3JIHqHbiMypOBHeMycsoeHH~,aTaK)I(eycTaHaBJIHBaeTC~CIIeU:H<l>HKaBbi~JieHHbiX xapaKTepHCTHK B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT IIpo<PecCHOHa.JibHOH 3HaqHMOCTHH3yqaeMOH TepMHHOJIOrHH.3acJiy)I(HBaiOT OC06oroBHHMaHH~ ,n:aHHbie 0IICHXOJIOrHqecKHX<f>aKTOpaxypOBH~ TepMHHOJIOr:HqeCKOH KOMIIeTeHTHOCTH B o6JiaCTH «.lJ:H,n:aKTHKa» y CTy,n:eHTOB,OpHeHTHpOBaHHbiX H He OpHeHTHpOBaHHbiX Ha ne,n:arorHqeCKYJO ,n:eneJibHOCTb.3H3'1HMOCTb pe3yJihT3TOB ,lJ;HCCepT3IJ.HOHHOrO HCCJie,l];OB3HHH ,lJ;JIH uayKH HnpaKTHKHOIIpe,n:eJI~eTC~TeopeT:HqeCKOHKOHKpeTH3aU:HeHIICHXOJIOrHqecKHXxapaKTepHCTHK CTy,n:eHTOB, .lJ:OIIOJIHeHHeM npe,n:cTaBJieHHH 0 pe3yJibTaTaX yCBOeHIDIHayqHO-IIpo<PecCHOHa.JihHOHKOMIIeTeHTHOCTHOrOTepMHHOJIOrHHIIO.lJ:XO.ll:aBBBbiCIDeMKOHTeKCTeOCHOBHbiXo6pa30BaHHH,IIOJIO)I(eHHHyroqHeHHeMpoJIHIICHXOJIOrHqeCKHX OC06eHHOCTeH CTy,n:eHTOB B ycBOeHHH HayqHOH TepMHHOJIOrHH,Bhi~JieHHeM IICHXOJIOrHqecKHX <l>aKTOpOB Hnpe,n:HKTOpOBTaKOrOYCBOeHH~ B3aBHCHMOCTH OT npo<PecCHOHa.JlhHhiX IIJiaHOB cry,n:eHTOB.Oco6ocne.n:yeTno,n:qepKHyTI>npaKT:HqeCKYJO3HaqHMOCThnpose,n:eHHOHTHXOMHposo:H: M.A.

HayqHo:H: pa6oThi. IlonyqeHHI>Ie Ha ocHose 3MIIHpHqecKoroHCCJie,n:OBaHH~,n:H,n:aKTHqecKOHBbiBO.lJ:bl0pa3JIHqiDJ:XTepMHHOJIOrHHyBIICHXOJIOr:HqeCKHXCTy,n:eHTOB,<f>aKTOpaxOpHeHTHpOBaHHbiXYCBOeHIDIHHeOpHeHTHpOBaHHbiX Ha IIe,n:arornqecKyro ,n:e~TeJibHOCTh, MOryT BbiCTYIIHTh OCHOBOH2.[I.JUITIO)U'OTOBKifnporpaMMTICHXOJIOro-ne.naroDflleCKOHTIOMOIIJ;HCTJ,ll.eHTaM,HCTihiThiBaiOIIJ;HM CJIO)I(HOCTH B ycBOeHHH HayqHo-npo<PecCHOHaJibHhiX 3HaHHH, ,ll.IDIpa3pa6oTKHHcoBeprneHCTBOBaHH}IMeTo.n:aqecKoroo6ecneqeHH}Inpou;eccaH3yqeHH}I TICHXOJIOrO-ne.narorHqecKHX ,ll.HCI(HTIJIHH.,rt;ocTosepuocThC006IIJ;eCTBOMpelyJJhTaTOBo6ecneqeHaTeopeTHqecKHMHHnpH3HaHHhiMHMeTO,ll.OJIOrHqeCKHMHHayqHhiMTI03Hl(H}IMH,CO,ll.ep)l(aTeJihHhiM aHaJIH30M HayqHOH JIHTepazypol TIO npo6JieMe HCCJie.[I.OBaHH}I,a.[l.eKBaTHOCThiO MeTO,ll.OB, BaJIH.[I.HbiX H Ha,ll.e)I(HhiX MeTO,ll.HK l(eJIH H 3a,ll.aqaM pa60Thl,penpe3eHTaTHBHOCThiOaHaJIH30MBhi60pKH,3MTIHpHqecKHXpa3HOCTOpOHHHM.[l.aHHbiX,MaTeMaTHKO-CTaTHCTHqecKHManpo6au;HeHOCHOBHhiXTIOJIO)I(eHHHHCCJie.[I.OBaHH}I Ha KOH<PepeHI(H}IX pa3JIRqHhJX ypoBHeH.CTPYKTYPa~uccepTa~uu cocTOHT H3 BBe.neHH}I, 1pex rJiaB, 3aKJIIOqeHH}I,CTIHCKa HCTIOJib30BaHHbiX HCTOlJHHKOB HaaeoenuuBo5 npHJIO)I(eHHH.aBTop onpe.neJI}IeT aKTYaJihHOCTh TeMDI Hccne.noBaHH}I, o6oeKT,npe,ll.MeT, l(eJih, rRTIOTe3hl H 3a.[l.aqH HCCJie,ll.OBaHH}I, o603HaqeHhl MeTO,ll.OJIOrHqeCKa}l,TeopeTHqeCKa}lHMeTO,ll.UqeCKa}l6a3a,ll.HCCepTal(HOHHOHpa60Thl,eeHayqHa}lHOBH3Ha, TeopeTHqeCKa}l H npaKTHqeCKa}l 3HaqHMOCTh, npe,ll.CTaBJieHhl OCHOBHhieTIOJIO)I(eHH}I, BbiHOCHMhie Ha 3aiiJ;HTJBnep60U 2Jl06enpHBO,ll.HTC}I TeopeTHqeCKHH aHaJIH3 TIOHHTHH «yCBOeHHe»,paCCMa'I'pHBaiOTCH Bhl,l1.eJIHeMhie B TICHXOJIOro-ne.narornqecKOH JIHTepazype ypOBHHycBOeHHH.AKI(eHTHpyeTCHTepMHHOB.BKaqecTBeBHHMaHHepe3yJII>TaTaHacneu;H<PHKeycBoeHH}IYCBOeHH}ITeopeTHqecKo.H:TIOHHTHHHH<PopMal(HHHBHaCTOHIIJ;eH pa6oTe npHMeHHeTCH KOHI(eTIT «TepMHHOJIOrHqecKa}l KOMTieTeHTHOCTb»,TIOHHMaHHe KOTOpOrO TaK)I(e paCKphiBaeTC}I B TeOpeTHqeCKOM 063ope.CorJiaCHOBo3pacTHOH nepHO.lJ.H3al(HH czy.neHqecKoro 3Tana ,ll.HccepTaHT Bhi,ll.eJIHeT HaH6onee33Halfl:IMbie IICHXOJIOrH~eCKHe xapaKTepHCTHKH CT)',ZJ:eHTOB, CIIOC06CTBYIOIIJ:He, KaKIIOKa3aHO B Hay~OH JIHTepazype, ~IDeMY ycsoeHHIO ~e6HOH HH<l>opMaiJ;HH.Bo3TaiibiBmopou maBe M.A.

TnxoMHposoii rro.n:po6Ho orrncnmaeTc.H rrpoue.n:ypa nHCCJie,ZJ:OBaHH.H,KpHTepHHOIJ;eHKHypOBH.H,ZJ:H,ZJ:aKTH~eCKOHycsoeHH.HTepMHHOJIOrHH, a TaiOKe IICHXO,ZJ:HarHOCTH~eCKHH HHCrpyMeHTapHH.TpembR maBa rrocs.Hm:eHa H3JIO)J(eHnroIICHXOJIOrH~eCKHXpOIIHTepMHHOJIOnmBoco6eHHOCTeH3aBHCHMOCTHOTrrony~eHHbiX pe3yiinTaToB, a TaiOKeCT)',ZJ:eHTOBHXB,ZJ:H,ZJ:aKTH~eCKOHycsoemm:opneHTaiJ;HHHarre.n:arorn~ecKyro,ZJ:e.HTeJibHOCTb. 0co6o CTOHT OTMeTHTb, ~TO aBTopy YJl:aJIOCb Bbl.HBHTb KaK o6m:ne HCIIeUH<l>H~eCKHeIICHXOJIOrH~eCKHeTepMHHOJIOrHH .n:JI5Irre.n:arorH~eCKYIOCT)',ZJ:eHTOB,,ZJ:H,ZJ:aKTH~eCKOHycsoeHH.HopHeHTHpOBaHHDIX HHe opneHTHpOBaHHbiX Ha,ZJ:Byx rpyrrrr.3QKJliO'lellUUo6o6m:eHbiypoBH.H,ZJ:e.HTeJibHOCTb, TaK H IIp.HMO IIpOTHBOIIOJIO)J(HOe IIpO.HBJieHHe 3THX<l>aKTOpOB y CT)',ZJ:eHTOBB<l>aKTOpbiOCHOBHbie,ZJ:HCCepTaiJ;HHrrpe,ZJ:CTaBJieHDIOCHOBHDieHTOrHpe3yJinTaTDI,rrpe,ZJ:CTaBJieHbirrepcrreKTHBbipa60Tbi,,ZJ:aJibHeHIDHXHCCJie,ZJ:OBaHHH. rHIIOTe3bi HCCJie,ZJ:OBaHH.H IIO,ZJ:TBep)J(,ZJ:eHbi.TeKCT .n:nccepTau;Hn HarrncaH xopomHM Hay~niM .H3biKOM, .n:aeT rronHoe n.HCHoerrpe.n:cTaBJieHHeTHxoMnposoiioBbiiiOJIHeHHoMnccne.n:osaHnn.Ha~Ha.Hpa6oTaM.A.

orpa)J(aeT TBop~ecKHH rro.n:xo.n: asTopa K H3~aeMoH rrpo6neMe.3aMe1J3HUH.1.Ilpnorrpas.n:aHHhiMHe(rrpe.n:rronaraeTc.H,orrpe.n:eneHHHrpyrrrrorpaH~HBaTbC.H~Torrocne.n:HHencrrniT)'eMDIX.n:eneHneMHeHarrpe.n:cTaBAAeTc.Hrre.n:arorosopneHTHposaHbinHe6oneerre.n:arorosHa rrperro.n:asaTeJibcKyro.n:e.HTeJibHOCTb). KaK rroKa3biBaeT rrpaKTHKa, 3Ha~nTeJihHa.H ~aCTb OTHeceHHbiX Krre.n:aroraM, BOBCe He 06.H3aTeJibHO HMH CTaHyT B ,ZJ:aJibHeifmeM.KpoMe TOrO, 3THrpyiiiini pa3IIH~aiOTC.H H IIO TeppHTOpHaJibHOMY rrpH3HaKy. IlocJie,ZJ:Hee rpe6yeT,ZJ:OIIOJIHHTeJibHbiXaprYMeHTOBBIIOJib3YTOrO,~TO6y.n:ym:nerre.n:arorHH34CeBepO.IJ:BHHCKa, KpOMe TeX, KTO 6y.n:eT B CHCTeMe)J:eHCTBHTeJibHO6y.n:yTBKJIJoqeHbiu;enecoo6pa3HbiM Bbi.HBJieHHeyBHHKJI103HBHOrO o6pa30BaHH.SI,)J:aHHYJOBcex KaTeropuii:CHCTeMY.Ilpe)J:CTaBJI.HeTC.HHaJIHqu.s )l(eJiaHH.SI nonyqeHH.H)J:OnOJIHHTeJibHOH KBaJIHtPHKai.I;HH.2.06bJqflOBTopa.s rnaBa HaquHaeTCHcMeTo.n:onoruqecKoroaHaJIH3a,nocne qero noruqHo .n:aBaTb xapaKTepucTHKY MeTO.IJ:OB H MeTO.lJ:HK.

B .IJ:aHHOM TeKcTenepe.n: BbiBO)J:aMH no nepBOH rJiaBe )J:aHa KpaTKa.H CCbillKa Ha TO, qTo aHaJIH3JIHTepaTYPbi no npo6JieMe HCCJie)J:OBaHHH Onpe.n:eJIHJI Bbi60p MeTO)J:OB H3yqeHH.HBbi.IJ:eJieHHbiX nCHXOJIOruqecKUX oco6eHHOCTeH cry)J:eHTOB. Il03TOMY H TeKCT BTOpOHrJiaBbi COCTaBHJI 22 CTpaHHI.I;bi.3.XoTH B TeKcTe .n:uccepTau;uu o6ocHoBaHa KJIIOqeBaH poJib MOTHBau;uuyqeHHH, He Bee ee acneKTbi nonyqunu ou;eHKy.

TaK, HanpHMep, He .n:ocTaToqHoBbNCHeHO BJIH.HHHe OTpHI.I;aTeJibHOH MOTHBai.I;HH yqeHH.H Ha OTHOilleHHe K YCBOeHUIO)J:H)J:aKmqecKOH TepMHHOJIOrHH, XOTH COOTBeTCTBYJOII.I;a.H )J:OKTOpCKa.H )J:HCCepTai.J;H.H6bma 3aiUHIUeHa B 5IpocnaBJie (KapnoBa E.B. CTpyKrypa H reHe3HC MOTHBau;uoHHOHc<Pepbl JIHqflOCm B yqe6HOH )J:e.HTeJibHOCTH) B 2009-M ro.n:y.BbiCKa3aHHbie 3aMeqaHH.H HOC.HT )J:HCKyCCHOHHbiH xapaKTep H He CHH)l(aiOTo6II.J;eiiu;eHHOCTHnpoBe.n:eHHOroTuxoMupoBoii:M.A.uccne.n:oBaHH.H.TeKCTaBTOpetl>epaTa nOJIHOCTbiO OTPa)l(aeT OCHOBHOe CO)J:ep)l(aHHe )J:HCCepTai.J;HH.3aKJII0'1CHHe.,[(uccepTaUH.HTuxoMupoBoii:MapHHbiAHaTOJibeBHbi«IlcuxonoruqecKHecpaKTOpbi ycBOeHH.H CTy)J:eHTaMH )J:H)J:aKTHqecKOH TepMHHOJIOrHH>>, npe)J:CTaBJieHHa.H K3aii.I;HTe Ha COHCKaHHe yqeHOH CTeneHH KaH)J:H)J:aTa nCHXOJioruqecKHX HaYK nocnei.J;HaJibHOCTH 19.00.07 -ne.n:aroruqecKa.H nCHXOJIOrH.H, .HBJI.HeTCH 3aKOHqeHHOHHayqHO-KBaJIHqmKai.I;HOHHOH pa60TOH.5ITo CBOeMY co,n:ep)J(aJUUO,aKT)'aJibHOCTH H HayqHOH HOBH3He,06beMYnpOBe,ll;eHHOro HCCJie,ll;OBaHIDI H co6paHHDIX 3MTIHpHqecKHX ,n:aHHbiX, TeopeTHqeCKOHH npaKTHqecKOH U:eHHOCTH TIOJiyqeHHbiX pe3yJioTaTOB ,ll;HCCepTaU:HOHHa5l pa6oTaTHXOMHpOBOH M.A.