Отзыв на диссертацию (авт. Кузнецова А. А.) (Творческая эволюция Е.А. Нагродской в контексте идейно-эстетических исканий 1910-х годов), страница 2

flonynflprroii 6erue'r'pl.icrr.rru>(r'av xe).3ar.ev lllo 14ur,Br,rpax(ae.r.yAr.rJreHHe,q-ro BbiBo/rbtH.M. 3opnoi.ipa3t\eJt]l^laIr.A. llr,axona, u Bo3paxae.rHa:)To cJlcJlyrorquMcyx/lc ucu: <Oattaxtl ryMacrcrr, .,.rar'uSrot uo,"nuroturu,r,aKI lel{'Il4poBallllUMel'lIl0 OTpUqaTCnbllLlC KaqeCTIla C'I'uttI4C-tt4KMnuCaTeJILHl4Ubrr..t3aryr e Balro 'l'o, q fo npr4BneKalror<uef grruvarrue qu r.arouteiiny6;ruru> (c. 29)..{yrraaerc:r, q'ro Lreprbt crtinr, I repeet.lclreHLlr,te ll.A.

/]r,lxosoii, rar pa: unpuBneKaJtr4BrruMaJ.lHeuuraloulei, ny6nul(H - Maccouofo lturareJl'.no3Bojrrrtlr.A. lir,rrconoiicorLracu'r'r,orc I I.M. 3oproi.i.l la cc. 36-37 JLrotr4ut,,3alr(Hrr(alrrpano 6erl re.t.pr1c.l.lr{t4Ha cyltlecl.BojlaHHe.ccbrrae'l'crl Ha MHeHlre 9ecTeprolra, onpeAeJlr o le e nHl'epa fypy KaK pocl{o rb, a6erlerpucrur<y rar< neo6xoAl4Mocrr,.erlr a6cortto.r.tro.Mr-rerruecI|opHoe: ueo6xoTltruocr.t, 3t.o xtrc6, rco.r.opr,riluce, d 6e-rr:relprc luKa lrpl/( Jl14uyx(na, rax xle6. Jrro/\lNl Kynr,r'ypHblM nloj.lrrM.rrHTalelroMaccotovyaa, lo ry.t' c.farroBl.l.c' lte oqeLIl, rolt,ftro,3aqel\4o'fc'ral4lla'r'r>ltpaBo MacooBor,ilcy;rr,'r'ypr'r a cylrlec'f uoua ue, ecJ|4.,rlo 14n; cLlh.r.ae.r.n 14carejll,Hl'llI' Koropblx Kacaelct 3To ee BbIcKa3l,IBaHt4e, He npLrHaAnexault.jMll,,ue,runor,,I,,MaccoBor, r(yJtb'rype ro r(oHtla: <l{ar< ue rp l.tHa/tJle){arjleerpacxo)trcMy MaccoBoMy [oroKy r l4Tepi:l1ypr,t 6yl.ie'r' paccual pr.lBarbcr n aaHrrt)fipa6oi'c 14'uJopgcc'nlo lJalpoTlcxor.i..

. > (c. 30)h parccMa.l.pr4uae.f t.e qepl.bi ,xTBopLlec'r'sa,Ko topt,re nbllloArr et o 3a paMKLj 6e_rt_rie.r.przcl.uxr.i u rrpnd,ru;raxl.r rtnrrcoxofi,'rureparype?l l a c . 3 8 J I t o J 4 r r rH, p o l t H q H o3aMeqacl,v'r'oM. I(y':rr,Irarr,c.{cjtaJrt} llrreBLt},l(cI-leJrccl'Hyro3anr,tcb o 1'llopqec' lc I lalpoTlcrcoii (r{ol/(a, oLreBti/lrro, rrecKoJrLr{orroa:a6;r,;r, ri'fo olta eto pl,irotHra, a 'r'aKxe ot(porll4'leJtr,c'loBara eMy! oMot.arl|Iy()nul(oBaTr,c').q'lo 14poHHl 'ly't HeyMecrlla, IloloMy qro JI14qHbre!yvaelcl,Kaqec.t.llaqeroBer(a 14Jrufepalypllbre ,4ocrohtrcrua efo rrpoH3Be,tteHtii Mofyt' uMe'rb pa3Hr,leo l t e l l K r , ra.

B I c B I T H I ((c) 6 b r , ] r r rnrl . . t t xIy t \ ) . 9 1 t j 1 g i j 1 1 1 j 7 1 C, JH ( )A V M a I ( ), 1a H e t ( ) .u't o lpe6yro'r' rrpl4Jrr.trtulr.iApyxecKue cBr3u.lla cc. 42-43 Jho l4rrr, 3aMeqac'r o Kpti.t.l4l{cC. liopo.rune: <<Z oirrrl, r,.lr,rBcrpeqaeMcr c 'r'eMu xo,re6aHltlvr.r 11 coMHeHu'lMrr, l(oropbre He ro3Bonr orcepbe3rroMy Kpr4Tr4nyrnr.3narr,, uTo "Hrrrepcc o, )r(HBo fi yBneKarenbtlo'FIarl14caFIIlocfIpoI'l3l]eAclIIde Moxe'f peAclaBJItlt' HII'fepec/.lJIfiu3btcKaleJrbHotoqu'fa'relrr. 14 /le.lrae'rghlno/l: <'l'arroii rro/txo/l ttutstuui pa3 u BHI t eJtbct.Bye.f,Li.r.oteorcllecrBcr rfrar KpH'l'l4Ka ...

Hc Mofra |Io aocl'o]4 crBy oqcHH.l.b r-r<tsbtii1.14|IloBecrBoBa]lutl - c rojlollol(pyx{HTenbl ILIMfi noBopo'raMti croxera, aBaHTtopHl,rMt43JleMetjl'aMuH c'tpeMu'leJIbtlo NletIfilo lHMfict fcporjMH).flyrr,tae'r'c;r,q'ro o6o6rrlarr, fi lteJlarJ,lo4o6rrlui ntngol\ c-l.ol4Jlo6sr, eclu 6nI ) c r l , r r r a ( ) l r p ( ) hl J c n c l l . . j r x .u a n p H \ 4 c 1 ft [. o c r o c r r er r ( )ot .

r ( ( ) T o p b t fl it e f l y u a . t c tyBreKafcJlt,Hl,lMH cloxe'taMH-B r , t u h ' r a r ib r M H1 4 3 I ( p 1 4 M H I rrut r J { b r x t t o e o c t c r z .coMrjerjHr{ )Ke KpHl'HKa ro nonoAy ,''uopqeo.r'BaIlar.poacxoii r4Meror trecKrzcocHoBaHU{,KOTOpbreoH r43Jroxl.rJrJa ,rlro I4sl rje ociropr4JraHa AoKa3a,ferbHoMypoBrie.6<uce ro'., 'a c.47 caua Jlo l4ul :ravcqaer'o Kprzrur(eA.l{o6pov:'r.cM,Ljr.oKpH1.r.rK<1-axyroouerrKy poMalra Moxrro o6.ucurz.r.r,rrollxolHJr K rreMy,noMHr ' O 3aBel'ax rc,raccliqecxoii pyccxor.i Jrfireparypbr, He rrpueurrnxrei.lnr4raKTr4t{r{ti fipaBoyr.lr.{Terruuor<iro a ... .

Pouarr xe ILarpolcxofi 6r,t,rpaccuuraltqura'r'errHa cperrlefo...>. B :rol',r Bbrcl(rBr,rBaljurJ )lt<>I4ns coAep)rr4Tc,oueHr{axy/loxec'nrclrtrox) ypoltHr poMaHaKar{uecbMaHcltblcoKoro_ B JlyrtueMcjryqaecpe/lllefo,fl ee Ilorlbl fl(t4 (np14llo/lHrrb)) Il14ca'ferl)l rrllly l]btrnr/It1. Kat( Tr,1llHqHa'qpe3Mepr{arMOJIOAOfO riccjreAoBaTenraJlryBneqeHHocrbrrpeAMeroM1 4 C C I e l { O I j a F I HBr ,| O I H e t r p o c t . H .

f e J r r , H a rBr ,t l p o l r e M .I lprare:ly ellle pr/r 3allaJrb,rl.rnbrxnr,rcra:lrnarrur.iBne/teuur. o6r,rcHreurrx' rl o i , iu.lcucrrlocIr,ro.;IIa c.48Jlo tr4rrr' 3aMeqae' ro noBo/ly r{p,Tl.iKa lr. Ko*oHoec*ora:<cHaqa-rta oHa I'ollopu'I, rr'fo o1r rrall].icaH "lrfiBL^,r, rn6xuv, oltyxor,rJopeuHbrM-rl3l'txorv". A nolol/Iy floqeN,ry-To,rto6antl'ler, LtTo n3b1l( fepoeB poMaHa JIHUIeHco.lHoc t H L4 c)t'tu "roBoprl'noqrH oAHHM H TcM )Ke r3r,rr(ou".

3raHecor)racollatrHoc|b ollHAe'r'eJI bc']'Byel o lrelltIHMal cJiLHOC'I.HH OBepXHOC,I.HOCl.[.1Kpl4TriKa B u ocJre/loBaHl.i14n3blKa poMaHa u rrecrroco6uoc.r.u yrly6,rl1.bc,Boco6eunocu )t(eHcr(ofo l3blKa B TBopqecrBe [uca.ferbHhubt>. 6orocr, r]1.o3aecr,JIro tr4rrr, r'reAoloHrra npo6,rel,ry u crenara cJrH[tr(oN4KarefopurrHbrt Br,tBor.l{pr.r'r'zr Br)tcKa3aJrMHerrHe, u.r.o llarpo2lcKari l rt: yMeethca.r.b )JL,raJrct.u_flepe/laBa1'bLlnltwrluAy anbHoc'rb r-oBoprtrler.0tJ ern lp1vot)i peqH; rrpl,l 31oMaBTOpCKat pcql> B poMallc apcrtaHur,t||c Br)l3blr]:lc.r.l-luxaxoro nporr.lBoperturr3lleclJHe'1, )'l'o1'Iler{oc'rafoK xapaKlcpeH IJI' JIli1'epa'r'opoBIleBlrcoKoro ypoBtr'.Iluixe ,rho IZr', o6o6lrlabr.: <...uce fcpor.irrH,o.fc.rarzBarou{'e i.t.^ o.aeu.ltoraHHble a8'topoM B 14pOHHqeCKOMpaKypce, t(prl.l.r4KaMuBOC p14HHMaJlticr>Bcepr,e3))(r'arr,txe,48).

Iiorocs, !l.r().ccltH B l{pt4Trjrtccuoli peuenquu 6lrlo raroee/llrHonracHc, 'l o 3 fo BIlna ait topa, Irc yMetoulelo Br.l'.fHo epejla.fb cBoHl.rH'feHufi14.Ila cc. 49-50 JIlo L4,s coo6ulaer, q.ro cyulecrBerrHbrii crBrar BpaccMo'lpellHhLIacjIcllHtlIIarpo21crtoi.iltpot43outcJtri llcripoJiopax,I tos lll4llrrtr.{xc1t]cBtr3u c ee rolrqarroii. l{yuae'rcr, q'l'o rreKpoJror'- .rI o fo]. xaHp, B no.r.OpoMrunep60:ru:arlrr /loc for-rHcrB rllJlrel crr xaHpoBbrM 3ailaH'.reM,no3ToMy Bptrl] nuef0 Mo)r{fiocepbe3rio paccruaTpuBaTbB Aa HOMI(OHTe(CTe.B pc:y.rr,l'a're rra c. 56 ,ilo 14nr, 4e.lae r gbnloA, Ltr,o ((lpoBeaeHHoecorroc'faBJteHlle UU'reur\uii an'ropa "frresa f]n<trrHca" u furrrtuyc rrorl{HMae].I{arpoacryro Ao ypoBnrr BeAy[rr4x r]peAcla Bfir'eJr",.i u.rv no,rh:N,rar, 9.r() B r(oprrcH C B C n l l ( ' . t t a q e c r s c H t r r , r i i y | ( ) t .

r c l, r t 1 t 0 ur n c . r f l r H i . . i t a K o L , C ( ) n O e t a B J t ( ] l r H fr Iepcouerrfi'lt, nectroco6uo./{yvae'r'cl, o/.lHalto, riro caMa llo irlHr, 3.ro 'oHr4Mae.r,noct(onr,Ky n frase ]na c.64coo6r(aer': <11.A. I-larporcKar rrecorl3McprrMarro AapoBaHfiro cyKa3a rrr,rMr.tBr,rlxeaBTopaMH...) (peq6 uAe.t.o M. Ilue r.acBoii,l(. Ba aHor:e,ll.Eax'n'e, o. Man4er'uraMe).14 Bce 3i'r4 (HacKonH) MoJloAoro ,ccJle,[oBareJl, r.raorr,lrHI'lx Kpr,rrHKoBMoxHO O6r'rCHurr, er-o s,rrc6rrerrrjocrLro B peAMeT.2). 13o-r;'r'opttx, 3t.o Bcl.peqarculHecl tr pa6o.r.c uorrbrl.Krz lepeouelrKt43Clerrzqect(o|o ypoBHi xy,rroxecl BeHHr,tx[po].l3llel lcl n i.i c orropoii Ha 3Tr.jrrecKue)reMcHTLrreKora. Bo nne4euuu cBoe coMHeHfie i: flpunii4Lter(Hocrrz rBopqecrBaA.

Bep6urlroii x r'aaccosofi nr4Teparype,rho r4rrl ocfroBLrBaer Ha HccreAoBaHr,rz(uoAqepKFry.na upeiiroe r roBa.l.opclBo Bep6rarlxoiz,A.M. l-paveuoii, roloparnogeo.lrinurefice6e "napaloxcajrsr{o" repeocMbrcJrhr.r,r.eopHHo. BeiiHr.rur.eparznoneMI-'l3XpOBa'rbC oraejrbl-tbrMHnojto)1(cHLlfdMr4tltu.jrocodlurzI Iuq]re.

14 :ro, rroMIleII]. Or4ccJIeAoBaTe!'tLI.tHI lbl.c.r.aJlo"o'r'paxerrucvnpoucxogturlciificnxoJlort4qecroi.inepecrpoiiru xeucroro co3Haul.lr">(c. 29).q'r'olcr,r.ueiiHoeljogaropc'rrlo Hc rnJlrclcl feM Kaqecl.nor\4,/(yrraaer(o.r.opoencl3Boitret npHqrcnurL nHTeparyprroe npou3Bclterruc t( Br,rcotr14Mo6pa:lqar,rJll4'lcpa'fypbl, ocllollolloltat atolttr4MtlpH3fraKoM:],l(ccl,llblc'tylrae'f JrrzreparypHoevacrQcrBo. A Bo'r' /(ll ucctrerl0Bauui..i no crlxojlo|hH l.i corlnoJlor-14i4Kar( pa3MaccoBarrnHTeparypa tBrrel crr qeHl,tocl'blo, TaK r{ar( aaer ocuoBr{ofi uarepual.]lo :'lo orrl r) xe lre ro3nolrre'r' pr4qlrcJrr'r'r,rrorrylrqpHbrx rruca.r.erei.rKnpeAcl'allu'leJItll\4Hallholla.llbHolzJit4Tepa'fypbr.l|ocrioJ >Ky trepBl.tqHI).1B .r.aKOMIlpeJ]cTauuTeJrbc'flte 3c1e |Ij qecKue Ka'Ier.opul.l.l{a,ree J1x>tr4r'rr':laveqaer, qro (onperererrlr bre AocrouHcrBo) co.rnHenulaA.Bep6uqxoil<por,ranruvecxuri na(roc, ol(pblJleHnocrb repoeB, Axycrpe^4neIIHocll, l( cqac'fiito - cyMeJlfi otleFtHlr, t'ojrbt(o Kpr,1TttKucot(HaJraeMoKparuqect(oro(M.rarep'O,lr,uu rrcl<nr:i,A.Ilyr.lauapcr<r.rr.i).llpol'uuo oc'laBuB cBoc MIIer{r4cllalraAKaMH6yp;rrya:uoti KpH.t.ht{H,o6nuHluurciin !{ca'fe:rr,rJHrIyB l{ypnoBr{ycuu> (r.al,rxe).liyri,raercl, ql'o 3lecb ,rfuo I4ul HeKpr4.n4qecxr4orHecracb K lllcKypcy l_r'IepM14non of H14 rtcKo'fopbixlzc.fortr1Hr(oB.

IIaIl oll4lu qecr(oMlro.;lcXy/{O}KcC'flle}lI I Llc /IOCIOHIIc'fllaJIHlCpa'l'}pllblXltp('143Bcltcrrtr.ifl14lleJr}4pyrotc11,aaKllell f hpyrol crr Hl[eoJroll.lr]ecKri Br,lto/urbre /te'larjr.r. /lejreHue xe KptlTr.rK14rrzl<6ypxya:nyto)) 14(reMoKparr.j qecKylo) ccrogHlrur rr.rii HccneAoBarcJrbHeAonxcnoc'raBJrrllb6er per|:rexcrall.I Ia c 50 Jho I4ur, pHIloAHt tl o6o6rtletruc ( flc ul.lHMaTelrr,ubrx>rlbrrJororiorrautpaH'r'cr<ou lipl4'f141(t4 Br,tcKa3blBaHue f.Allauonlrqa,l(o.foporollHellr'rr4Marer bllocrr4 x rrovy-,ru6o ) frpcl(fry'fr) ortcrrr, 'fpyllHo: (...ol.ra caMa"co:lranala", v'Lo "r'o, q'to oHa na HCaJla,ne 6r,r.rro,,nr,rcor<oiz:ru.repa.r.ypoil,,>,Inpl4 3'l'oM qyBcrByr, "qro y Hee ecrb raJlaHT", ,,noHrva:ta' qro raraH.ry 3ToMy HexBaraer lureparypuofr KynbrypLr 14 crpofocrH r ce6e", 3areM c coxajreFrlleMnpr4Bo,r]1.r1'xapaKl'cpHcrl{l(y l.crpyne<f_{arrlclrar60,rec AJlr4 Mcucc6y:truaprral>, (crH3r{ocopilrar Ju.r'r'epat,},pa),a 3al cM o1,Mer{ac.r.(upopbi'),ocylt(ecll,rreHHr,tu Bo.lrr,Qratlou l{a:arorr.

(/.(aBrrrHMt,goprrec.f}rynuca.r.eJibn14ltr,taocraroqHo no3HTHBtryroouerllry: eMy oKa3arocb /toporo ee HeroBepue K Lrr1cro"paquona.ttt,ttovy ltoc'r'HXetrulo tnr.r3lH", ", ,,rar,uroarure Heu36e)totoi..txa'r'ac'r'por.pr,r">.tr4: scex t.{r'rar B}rAllo, riro rtoptir{aHue]lcer./IaKacaercJrJtl4.fepa.r.ypHOlr).reKc].a,MacTepc'r'Bafiuca fenbrll4tlbrt4 lcTeTarlecriHxKaqec-t.Ba noJ'loxj4TelbHr'lcoTKJrtlr(r4 u71er.it ro-co/lepxafeJrb r,rx Mol Hllou,/,toc1.onrIct.BaKoropbtx,oAHaKo, clonblllaf o f xydoacecntceuH)l/oIteuHocl't,reKcIa.B lov xe pycnc nonbtrKu(noAI{cpxKr.t>:lcL.e.ruqedx<)to3Tr4qecr}tMrexuTIlbrcl(a:ir,lBarrr.ie r..r3fJaBr,rIII (c.

175), noct'uteruroii Nra,.toiilpo:e E. I-Iarpoacr<or7.Ilto VIur, ynoMllrraer cy)r(AeHr4eKpMt Ka K). AilxeneanbAa o <rpy6oia Iocxop6urenluoii npuTlyvar:HocrH) paccKa3a<Povarruqecroe npriKnloqeHue).Oua napr.rpyer:<Ocuc,rruuca npeanonoxln't,, rr'o 3/-lccbLryrr,e3ToMy rouKOMyI(phlnr{yH3Mclrr4Jlo)),trpuuol{rlt ltol(a3areJrr,clropa':5opnpr4eMarrepeoAcuat.n4lcs K c l ( y p c o MR H c t o p l . l l oJ t Ht e p t f y p t , t u n l t e i u o i l l a r p y 3 t ( Ht r o r o l f H c M a BpaccKa3e Har-pojturoii. Ho BeAb Kpl,rruK roBopl.{Jr o xyAoxecrBeHHoiqTo eMV(l43N4errr4rorlyrbe), ynt4parrraHeyoeilt4TenlHocrupaccKa3al14lloKa3aTr,,ulelirryro Hafpy3r(yocuoBlroro llpaeMa rrpot43nc/lell r.lr, treBo3Moxrlo.Muesr.rrox p l l ' t t t r a c l o h J I o 6 t , t t t p o t a t t o t t o c t a I I H ' I/ bl o K a 3 a l e J I r , c l rlJJaI e f a H r H o c r u3 a M h l c J rfaiBllcol<oxyaoxecl BelrHocTtt r-lcfrolulellur, ec,ru 6r,r lx 6srro Bo:]Mox o nain u ytec.,ru 6l,r 3'r'o uxorlrino B 3aAalry ticcJle21oBaleJll.