Отзыв на диссертацию (авт. Кузнецова А. А.) (Творческая эволюция Е.А. Нагродской в контексте идейно-эстетических исканий 1910-х годов)

roro olrrrorIer11aO'r':l,rno{rraurzaJrLro Ar4ccep'faufinJiro tr4ur,<'fnopuecral seolrrorlr4l11.A.Harpogcuotr s xouLer<cle uAefiso-acreruqecKhxucxauuit l9 I 0-x roAorrr,lrpcAc'faBneHHoiua coucrasue yueuoi cre[eH!.ta (r n.lto.ttot'uuecr(t4x Irayt(r(aHJll4llaiI 0.01.0 L PyccttanJll4Teparypano cneuhaJrbuocrufJraccepraqrllt Jho tr4ur lnlrrclcrcaMoctoneJlL"rtrHCCJIeAOBaHLieM,llOCBqrlleHHLIM flpe3eltTaUUU,3aBeplueHHbrMW\eiigO-3CTeTHTIeCKI4X nCXaUUii1910-x rolou B npou3BeAeuurx npo3auKa Il.A.

Ilarpogcr<oii, qle rBopqecrBo14 rrott't'ucoBpeMernraq all'l opy r(pl.rl 14Ka u 6o. ree I ro'rltnt4c 14ccJIeAoBarereAriHol.llacHoo[pe/{enr4Jrr.i B pa3pt/l <6yr t,sapuofi J]Hlepalyp},I>.I4ccleAoeasue ocHoBaHo Ha aHanlr3e6onrutot o r{opnyca xpyluoi.i v laattoilnpo3br, lz:.4aHsofrnxcare"[bHr{rleii s Poccuu Ao orbe3Aa B 3MI4fpar]I4Io.leMbt IIe noAre)Kul coMIIerJI4lo.Arlya;rsuoc'ru ra:6pat.rt-tofif{,u uulnleHunMeHTalrblloro KoHTe(c'fa H no:laer.iclBnl <o6ulux Mecf f ttoxu) Ha yMbl nroAeiir.i3yrrelMeTBopqec'fBa (B'fopopa3prlllr blx) 14(Tpcl l,cpa3prAfrbrx)) rucareJleii eajlaJIH lle Ba)I{Hcc, LIeM Kpylrn'tx, u 'fBopqecl'Be KolopLIX aln <o6ulue Mecla)I.icKaxeHbl cl4JtollbtMIroreM MoulHolo xyaoxec l'ner-rHoroirar.rpa.Bo Bsereuuu ttAuccep'larIHHu n calaoli pa6ole ue pa3 crpaBeilJr!.rnoolMeqeHo, t{'fo Hacne/rt1eE.A.

Ilarpolcxori, co4epxraluee Mlroro rtiue3rroii urr(ropuaqr.uz Anr uoseiiullrxcc:leltoBale'lreii,1o cux llop npaKfur{ecKhHe lr3yqaJIocb.Arrya:rrHlnl lBrtercl{enoclHoe paccMorpeHue npo3auqecKofo Hac'lle/(ulE.A. Harpoacrofr, enyrpeuHee eAuHcrBo Koroporo onpeaentercr uAefrltt tutzflor.lcKaMr4aB[opa, co3ByL]HblMHItoHTeKcl)/ 3noxH.KaK K Irpc3crraut4u eeAn'r'yarsrro o6patqelrue K.

feKc'l'aMttHca'r'cJli,lrHLu,ry6ex<,leuuli, c'faBtru4xpe3yJlt,'fa'foMee HpaBcf lreHHO-llcHXoJtot'ltqecKtlx lol.lct(ou.BLItBJtel{ue HllTepecltofo cn,raBa yBneqeHht nHcarerbHl.tublAxryallltoMacoI-rcKHMHI4AerMHu ee v;tc.rtefi, rocBrrl{er.Tl{Lrx(xencKoMy Bofrpocy)).14:6pauualr MeloaoJrorul HccJle1oBaH14l,coqe'r'arcu(al uvuaseurssti'i lrepMer'reBTu.iecK14t noaxoAbr, no3Bort4Jla cBrr3atr, yc'r'arroBKl.l aBrnpa fipilbrH r(o lcl(c'f 3IloxH.co3llarrr.jHxapat('lcpoBH 14cropl.]l{()-r(yjrbr)/ppcr(oMcnrar(nrj,llllr,llo/u,r nc{roplyrruporauHsteIlo.lroxeunr,HayqHoo6ocrrorranrtt,rmlt, lloKa3areJrbclBatgJttuo'lcqlluccep'fallu 14,y6e4z'rerlur,r 14xopouro apryMculnpoBanrt. I layurtr,rc pe3ynbrarr,r Llcclle.uoBanltrlbclnyer o rHqHoN4 gKJrare u ccJre/loBaletrt llJlo I4rrr, lleJroci'nLr H c tlt4,tle'l'eJrocMblcreHue JrH'repalypHolo r{acne,rlr,tlI 0-x loaon XX nexa.npcAclaBJrcIllrblxf{ocrrl ucp r ocr't'lle3yllbraroBrroATBcpxrcHanocJre.qoBarenbHlrMr.i AeraJrbr{r,rMaHa[u3oM npou:;ncAeunil E.A.

I{arporrcxoti, aTaK)Ke r(pHTliqecxoii orlcrrxoii cyulec'rBVrorrlHx pa6o'r' rro 'reopur4 u ,1c'topuanHTepa'fypbl.tr4cc,re4ouauue6a:upyer.cl ua BHy[rr4Ten",tu* *opnyae reoperr4qecKr4x14'fpylloB,Hcl'Opr,rKO-Ju4r'epa't'yprrLtxSra6trlrorpa$rarK lu4ccepl.aqll ar.,rrovaer.24guaraueuosauuii.B nepr:ofi rraBe Et4ccepra\t4n <tltuloco4tcralnpo$nevarnxa L4xyl{oxec'rBeHHarraHTponoJrofrzrB poMaHaxE.A. Llal'poAcxofi> Br,tnBJreHacBrr3l,eaNuer.irul.rx3ThKo-3clelHqecKr.ixngeil eloxu co c.fpyKTypoil nepcouaNa yT-.larpopcr<oii.PaccvarpuRanofino3r4uur.ianornollfiqecKn,ar, /lroiorauficroro, Kpacorr,r146c:o6parrr, Jto6pa H 3la lta Ma'lcpualc poMalroul:.A. I.:tar.portcxori, Jlro I4rrr,BblrBJr'e'r IIocJrelloBarenbHoe Br,IpaxeHhe rrttca'r'ejll,surleii ee y6eN4enr.ri,lrronoBoAy JrhqHoro xH3lrecrpoeHr4tB r{orrreKcreo6qnx Mecr 3noxH, Tar{HXKar{yB.[eqeHlieaHl ur roc'fbto H BonpocaMll <ocuo6oltJ(eHfi' xeHU]HHLI), c yqe.r,oMtllra:rococpcru x,c 14xolon4LlecKrx, corll4oJronjqecic4x r..r Kynbr.ypoJlor14qecKHXxourle rlrzii(d).

Hurlrrre,O. Beiiuru|epa,3. furrruyc, J1.Kotro6aenoii,O. Ma.r.uv;.'l'o'lHollblrBJreua paqronanblar flocJ'leAoBarellr,lrocl b l]brpa]r(eHur r rrHblxy6cxrlenrfirrca'r'erLuHur,rqepe3 rroc'rpoeHr4eJrHTepat.ypHbrxxapaKTepoBr.iJro|r4l{yfix ltporBjrerrHrru cfoxeTe.^tLToIjJlo obl r()nl'Ko orMerHTb, qro raKatl BblAepxal{lla'nocneAoBarent,t.tocrt).l.pe.t.bcfoxapaK'lepHa hMctrrro lIJrr IIHca'l'cltcH rlropol.o Hp'/Ia, BClloMIIhjl,HanpnMep,KaK xaJlonarcl Jlee To'lrc'r'oirua cBOeBorHeAHuu Kapeuuuoii,6opurleeca c ero xyl(oxecrseuHoli so,refi:<Korr.tas 1883 r.oly f .A. pycauon'I'olcrofi3aFOBOpr.tno6 o'rnouentrul aBTopar Arlrrc I{aperrr.rrroii,cHoBacocJrarclHa ol )r'r'I 1yr-rrrnHa."l'oropln, q'lo lrbr oqerib )r{cc'foKoIrocTyII4JInc AHHoilI{apeHarroii,3acl'aB}lBee yMepe'tblo/t BaloHot\4,q.r'orre Morjla xe oHa scK) xl,r3r{l>cl4Ac'11,c <<l't'orituclrrr.rlrofr> Alercecr,r Alercarrlll0tH.{eM", - cra:a,r Pycauor:."...1)'r'ourrcrrne Ha oMt4rraetvue crryuari,6LtB ir.iiac flyurrulrr,lv, - o'rBe't.fiJtl-o:rcrofr.

- O,rjrraxrt,r orr cxa3ar KoMV-l.or43cnoax npulretrcfi: <flpe71cr.ars.KaKyroturyKy yApana co uuoii vos Tall,nual OHa - 3aMyx{ Bbtil;ta. Sroro lr-l-oIlllKaK He OX(tr.rt2U]Ot'Hee".Nc cavoe Ll r M()]-ycr(a3arbIIpo Arrrry l{apenr.rr-ry.Boo6ulc repou 14l'cpo'.rrH Mor.iAeraro'r'Huor'/lal.aKne ur.ryKu,KaKr.{xl He xeJlaJt6t,r: oull /(enatolro, qTo .rloJllKHbltsoii xll:Hu u rcarc/.leJlarbn leticrgu.r.e.n6r,rBae.r.LITon Aeicrgrzrerr,s<'ti.'txuzllu, a He ro,MHexoqcLcr,r'.Bcl nlopoi r'.llanc<XylolKecnleHrroc ltotrJrotueuHeruracorrcrc.rxlrrci.i>ocyrrlecr'rltctr anutLi3 rrpon:tuc71ctrr,tr.i lr.A.

I lar.pqlcroii, o6.se/tuseunuxur|LeurlueiiBr,tpaxeHr..i'ee MacoHcKl.rxy6exlennl.i: paccr(a3a<AHrr)),IloBec}l<)i{Hrrae OlnmnuaAlr-Ienn>,poMaHoB <Bopl6a urtrpo6or>u <Be.nanrri.oKoJroHFra/ra)).3lecl, cnpancA:n4BorroK:l3arro,repoH 3Tl4x npou:te4eHufrIlecbMa I I OCJleltOBaTenLHo llpo'fhBOltoc fat:,Jlet{t,l/tpytr j a l e A r u H c n e p r I t , r u [ y 1 ' l ) J ] l . . r L t r r o f]oK H 3 H e c T p o e u h ' ./.lpyry KaK Halrrelltufie U He' (tl.H. Torcroi B aocnoMfiHaHurxcoBpeMeHHhxo8))?I 2-x roMax,T.

1. M., 1g55,c.231-232.Z 't'arNe Moxuo 6r,r,lto6tt 3aMe1'r4'lb, rt ro ltoc.lieAoBa'teloro peaJII43oBaLItralaBTOpCKarrparlHorlarbl'toc'r'b IIp14Boat4'rK ctoxert-roMy cxeMa'fu3My u t|JItAerctlpr.r3Har(oMr{enbrcoKoro xyAo)Kecf BeHHor-oypoBHrr npousneTleuuii.B rperleriuane <<Malar rtpo3a: gevnr]roloru:taqul,(tanrac-tvla Ll'rpaBecfHpoBaHI..tc)) paccMorpeHaIrpo3a Maroro xat.tpa, u ro ropofi E.A.HarpoTlcxal flpoBena pr;^q 3c1'erkqecl{l4x 3nc epr.JMeHToB,onrrb}Ke, KaKcnpaBeAnuBo nor{a3aJra JIxt 14nr,, n rrpxn,toil ri n ocJlcAoBare,tbltoii oBr3t4 cco6cTBeHr-lr,rMl..tMt4poBo33peHqecKHM14 ycraFroBKaMu.

I-{anpuvep,Kpt4ruKaxH3llccrpoolir..trrocyrilccl'llJteFla4uourzcufrcttol'ocro 9cpc3 r apo/ltjpoBarIt.lcr t p o t zr t r c t t c l r r i i n n h B c l t ) t ( e n u h t U , t, ' l t 4 o l h c i . i c l ( ( ) t ( ) r ( y n r ) t a t .3nrtogucuoliAurru6atr. 34ccr, nurepecHal llaxoAr{a }4ccJtcAoui}IcJtr- MbtcJl, o roNa,.lro ij.A.IJarpolcxarrrpelUroxr4lra <<cuoii,"xeucruzapnan'r" ro.ffinr4) (c.

209).Hayulrau rrollu3la pa6o'rbr o6yc:ronleua c:le/lylou.tuMt4 $arroparrau. 3.r.o.npex/(e ncero, o6parqeHue K Kopuycy Heu3yrjerrll j,rx n MaJtot43yr{eHutrxrexc.r.or;lr.A. I-larpo2lcr<oii,,r<oropr,rcr.tyxAarorcrr lt rreper43/lat1r.ll4t4 l.layqHoManarru3e.grzccep'r'auulJBuncpBr,le llpeAltputrrl a\ fii3 o6paron lepcouaxeii B rrpo3eE.A. Harpogcxofi u n;rlgleHlr BorrJlollleHHr,reB Hux aB'ropcKr.leLrH.reHqr4u.'Flosusnao6ecne.leHa ral(xe paccN4orpeHteM npo3at4rlecKofo rBopqecrBaI:.A.

Ilalporte r<oli r(aK llc-loL"rrroi.i xytro>rcccurerrrrr)i.i cHc tcMrir, o6.rallarouru.rcBor.lMnoco6errHoc'r'rrNar..tl.t Blly'fpeHHtlMl13aKoltaMl.i.J'arcuu o6pa:orv, t(eJrr, Hccne/(oBarrHfl- paccMorpet{14e<r.eopuecx<lii3Bonrout tl L.A. I larpo4crrtli'feHI{eHuHrMrznurepa'ryp}rot'ogolM r-paqfil4 n coorno[reurr H c BeAyutl.tMtlnpouecca I 91 0-x lr.> H ur,rrB;reHr4e(AHnaMHKhr r o c u l ) u rt t 4 t r l ( ) c l t M l ] ( ) J u . 1 ( ' t c l ( o t.

(t )h c t ( )n c a . r l r er r n r r u t . . t e< n x u n t e r t t l r . t i . il rroTu.rccnot 'rpaAullrzH), rrro llo3Bojlrrcr Bnl]ca'lL ee hMr (B flapaAur.MyMoAcpLllrclcKHx r.tcranuii XX c'r'o.rre|r.l'r> (c.6) - ltoct,Hr] ty-t.a, I locl.allJrerrFrLlcSa,ItaqHpc r.uc r,r.[r.rcceprarlul J]ort4rlto nbtcrpoeHa 14yilaqHo c.fpyl(rypr4poBaHa, Harrucal{axopolllHMrr3btr(oM uaKKypaTHo ocfopu,re r.r:,r, oTpa)KaeT I{aqr4TaHItoc.l.blrccnelloBa'teJrr,r{Hl_lt,rH ee cBo6oI oe Bjral(crrue o6lxupHr,rrrl ret(ctoBblMMaTepHaJroM.[1pz o6ulcit sr,rcoxoii ouef] Ke /p.lcceprau]414Herr,3rrHe o'rMcl.rrb HeKo'ropbrece IIcr(ortctbr.l). llo-lcpr:r,tx, Iro prA uecl(oJlbl(o3atralrr,qHBl,lx cylt2leuuii co 13neleuzu, uKoTopoMJho Zrrr, olpcAc:rrcl r,reclo tl.

Ilalpo;1cr<oi.iu JtHrepa.rypr.loMtrpouecce,qecKueo6o:penan Kpl4Tv14nr4TeparypoBeJtqecKHeoLleHKZee rBopqect.Ba.I3 o6:ope nonei.innx ucc,re4otarrui xieHcr<oi npo3l,l Konua XIX - rra.raJlaXX scrca JIto l4nr, y rBepxAacrJ rtro B coBpeN4cu.uoMJrllrepa.rypoBeAeHt4H lteul'tpa6o'r'atrocr, o pelteJrcIIlto|oMljerII4rr o roc14leJlbtIop14r.rHcJteHr.ltnpou:neilerruii A. ISep6rzurcoi;i,c roroptnrx r(pHTut{x-coBpeMeHHr.tKr.1nocloflHLrocpaBrruBanr4E. Flaryro4cxyro,rMaccosofr <6ynr,napHofr>>6el,rerpucrnre.ra c'r'aBHr'ro/r coMLlcl]Hc]ror,rBycMbrcilcrrrbref{nccepTar':tnbmolll,r11.M.3oprroia,Ilp14 31'oM IIpH3l'lallat,9'fo HccjIcj(ollaLcJtl,ttnrlcuycIIcluHo pctuct-ra3aAarla(or/lejru1b :epua S,rraropo/lHofor4cr{ycc'fBao'r IJrcBeJrpacxoxu x tolle;ror<> (c.28) u nnepnbre nor(a3aHbr<xolr6uHaqur4,cro)r{erub.rexoAbr, ocr,roBrrr,lerHrrr,rcroxel'olt ...