Отзыв официального оппонента (авт. Алёхина Л. А.) (Русские поэтические школы XVII века (жанровые формы и топика))

OT3bIBarcceprallllrc Ky3HEI-IOBOIZ Omru ArexcasapoBHbl<<Pyccrue rrogrurlecxue urrco"ru XVII eexa (xaHponsle Qopruu u ronura)>>,[pe.{craBJIeHHyIo Ha coI4cKaHI]e yqeHof creneHI4 rauau4ara tbuloJlorllqecKlrx HayKpyccKafl nl.ireparyparro cnequailbHocru 10.01.01Ha-Kanar.rgarcKas al4cceprallllt Ky:neqonoftO:uruA:rexcangponHu-norIlITKar4ccneA6BaTl B IIoJIHoTe XaHpOBOe ceoeo6pa:ue Ii TolI4Ky He OAHoro xaxOrO-.nu6o HanpaBneHl'ItB Crr4xoTBopHbrx OIIBITaX ApeBHepyCCKOfi nliTepaTypblXVIIeexa, a no3TI.irIecKOe TBopqecTBonr4CaTeJlefi, npIIHaAneXaBIIII4X pa3HbIM [IKoJIaM, BTUIBI-iT!, cXO.4cTBoIlOTJII{queBI'IXlpolr3Be.qeHr4rx, paccMorperb oco6eHHocrr4 pa3nrlr{Hbrx crr.rxorBopHbrx xaHpoB 3roro BpeMeHI-i,HaKOHeU, npoCne.4IlTb CaMrlpoqecc cTaHoBJIeHHt paHHefo pyccKoro cTHXoTBOpCTBa.Bo Beeaeullu $oprtry:rupyercr Heo6xoII4MbIfi noilsruiiHllfi annapar. o6o:saqaercso6rerr ucc:reAonanur.

AsrOp cTaBIzT nepeA co6oil eaAa.Iy u3yseavs B:trlflHrts oT.qenbHbD([O3Tr.rqeCKHX ToTTOCOBHa CI(IaArIBaHIIe XaHpoBbIX Sopll,@yuxUl.lOHupoBaHI'lc cHcTe\lbIcTrrxOrBOpHbrX XaHpoB B paMKaX nI4TepaTypHbIX lIIKon, BbUlBJIeHI.it O6ruuxpa3Bu"t4rt nog3r4r4XVIIBeKa.flpn3TOMBAuccepTaUIII4:axoHorlepHocreIBHe ronbKo O6o6qaercq oI6lT[peArrrecTBeHHrrKoB B 3roM tsoflpoce, Ho aHanr.r3lrpyrcTcr r.t BBoaqrcs n Hayuuufi o6opor uoerterro3TriqecKr,re TeKcT6r, Boolpor.r3Boar.iMbre colrcKaTeJrl,Hr.rqefipyKonr.rcHoMy c6opHr.rKyXVIIe llpu,roNenuu (c.153-175) noseKa, qTo rBr.f,ercfi HecoMHeHHbri\r .nocrotlHcrBOrt pa6orbl.flepnax r:rana rocBsllleHa ncropr.ir.l14npo6neMaM r..

YrcHfifl pyccKoii no::uPrXVII eera.3Aect Aan o63op Hay,IH6rx TpyAoB, fae TaK njlli r{Haqe 3aTparuBaJlacr, 3Ta Te\la (oT\leTq\rn 6n6:ruorpaSlru, nacvurlmarorqeii noqrl.l 150 HauveHoeaHl.li. Kpo\{e HayqHbIXIrccreAosaHr4fi o6crocreff Ho flepequcneHr,r ny6luxaqua TeKoTOB, HaqLIHaJI C XVII cro:rerlu)rrOIryTHo, VrOIrlirrepecuo, qro aBTop He rrpocro paccMarpHBaer I,IcroplrorpaoHlo BoIlpoca- a Blcilrcqaer eeKOHTeKCT pa3BIl.tr4t CaMOf0 ApeBHepyccKofo cTrixoTBopqecTBa Ha(aHyHeco.rriHeHfifi npe4cranureleii llpura:noft rrlKo-lrbr aoHoaoro nperteHltno::lfii crapoo6pqaqeBB- orH nocjle.4oBarejleiCnueona floroqroro. B pesym'rare, colicxareJlbHrrua npfixoal'Ir K BblBo.(y o nepc[eKTI'IBHocrunanbHefinero243yqre1ug.uayunrd o6oporIIo33I4!I 3TO|O BpeMeHI.i B CaM6IX pa3HbIX aoneKTax: BBeaeHI{eHeH3BecrHbIx reKcroB,BI'Ix BcecropoHHee onllcaHr{e H nonyrcpH3auHlo'HaKOHeq, CO3AaHue pa3BepHyTofi ncTopr4rr [o3Tr.rqecKr-rxruxor XVIIBeKa KaK IIpeAIIOCbIiKy ,4nt6olee r:ry6oxoro [oHI4MaHI'tt Bcero Ircropl]l<o-nI'ITeparypuoro npoqecca s PoccHt'Bo BTopofi rJIaBe aHanlz3llpylorcs oco6euHocrr xy'qoxecrBeHHoro lIero'aaBe'4yuru\{crxxorBoprleB XVII seKa.

Tpu ocuoeHlte pa3aena sroii riasll flocBqlrleHblBo[ogTHqecKrrM txKoJraM oToJreTrrq flpurarHofi, Hoeouepyca,rullcxofi u Bslroecroii.BcTy[rrreJrbHbrx napafpaoax paccMoTpeH npoqecc orAeneHl4tcrllxa or npo3ll I{CTaHOBIeHI'IqaBTOpCKOfO CaMOCO3HaHH.S, HaIXeAIXefO OTpaXeHIZeBBO3MOXHOCTeii, OTKpbIBaeMbX HOBIIMI4 nHTepaTypHbIMuBI]pIxaX, Hapsaysoprvravli,ucnoHI',IMaHI',IeMolqyuleHl'IeM HeKoe[O60cO6neHHocTr4, U36paHHooTLI IIO3TI4qecKOro Kpyra.

flocneAHee, I1O MHeHLIIO aBTopa, tBIIJIOcb(BaxHr,rM $arcropou Anr o6pa3oBanr4r rro3TuqecKrrx rrrKoJr). Bo3MoxHo,3To I.i cblfpano KaKliloTO pOJI6, OAHaKO, KaK flpeAoTaBnsercs, BeAyr]_lr,rM Ans nepeqr4cneHHbtx rrrKojr6srl coqua'rr'no-ucroplrqecKui Sarrop, onpeAeJrrBtxr{fi oco6enHocrr4 r4x no33I4H: K nepBofi urKone ornocllJlacbo6pa3oBaHHar LIHTennlIfeHIII,u MocKoBcKLlx npHKa3oB,BblABIZfanI4Cb 3HaHI.lt, yr{eHocrb,BIII4TaBIUI{Xflucauut,By Koropofi Ha nepBbliocrpoyMlre; AJI' MoHaxOB HOeOnepyca,ruucKotCe6C BCe 6OrarCrgO nIiTypfHqeCKI{X neCgOnenufiHnnaHIITKOJIbI,TeXCTOB Ce.tqeHi{OrOocg6BononararcU1eft cTaHoBIIJIacb O6pa3Has XpllcrllaHcKtu{ cHMBojIHKa'3HarruTeJrbHofi cTeleHI,I cBtsaHHtuIcTeMofi Bocrpeceuur;yBaBTopoB BlrroncxOii ruxojru,oco3Haroqr4x ce6t crpaAanbllaMg 3a Bepy H xl-IBylqltx KaK 66I B npeAABepI.iH Crpalruoro CyAa.BBaXHOe MeCTO, OCO6eHHOpaHHIIX [pOI,I3BeAeHUqX, 3aHHMaiII4 nOKaJIHHLIelIOTI.lBbI,oflpeAenrrcql{Ml,l CTaHOBI.IJIIiCb O6pa3LI ArIOKalrrlCUCa.B naparpa$ax BTopoifJIaBbr paccMoTpeHr,t caMbre pzl3Hble acneKTbl IIO33I{H Ha3BaHHbD(rKon,,uarcque nonHoe [pcacTaBJreHrre 06 ux oco6eHHocTqx.

3To u KaTefopHt \Iy.4pocTl.rocTpoyMr.ig,sopuynruocrt,scTeTr4qecKaq cocTaBJgroulaJr[o3TOB llpr4Ka3Hofi IIrKOnbr. tr4 nao6opor, oTKa3HKoN{nr.insrLIBHOCT!,oT $oplty.nruocru,HB rBopqecTBeBK]'IIOqeHHOCTB Bo5pa3HocTboI4MBOJIIiqeCKOe [pOUrnOg, 3MOIIIIOHaJIbHOCT[,, nOBeCTBOBaTelbHOCTL. KOHTpaCTHajlB rrogrr4qecKrlxoflbtrax HoBor-iepycaJ'rr4McKoii urKoJrbr. HaKoHeu, Kareropl'Iu trpee\IcrBeHHocrl'lflpocBeIIIeHHOCTI4, fipenoMreHfie nvTepaTypHbIXO4narco o6parqeulieK crollbI',I14oOIbKnOpHbIX rpaAl4IlI'ril B no33[It Bblfa'pa3nur{HoMyI4 orpoMHor{y no o65e\1yMarepuu}nyrei\r'npvBoAl'ir K ToMy, r{To' Hap'.ay c o6croqrelrsln'r u rny6oKI4M pacKp6lTue}1 3aJIBreHHblxHeKoropble naparpaobl lpxo6peralor re3llcHblii xapaKrep(S 2'2'3'3crernqecxat- c.

33). liopoii ue flonr{aloT AocTaTOqHOi apfyl{eHraul]rl BbIcKa3bIBaeMLIeKaxlrctlpearrojroxeHut (o n:arEltocn.rsu Blrpuefi u a36yKoBHHKOB - C 45) Heonpaelauurrrlllu npol{3BOJIbHr,Ie CpaBHeHI4.S, AonycKaeMr',Ie I-IHOIIa aBTopov: TaK' OopaueHl.ieB Haqa-Ie crHXorBopHbrxHOBOIrepycanI{MOKI.IX CTITXO rBopIIeB (K He6ecHbIM 3aCTynHrlKaMcocTaBnflIotqarrK My3e))TeKcToB)) ynoAoonseTcr ToMy, (KaK [o3Tr,r ApeBHOCTI4 O6pauIaJILIcbcaMoM TIpITBeAeHHOM AUInee noSTIlqecKoM o6pa IeHI',IIiKBenHKovyseHHKy(c.

63). XorrnfeoprHlo 3Byrlarqro [psMble aHaJlofl]li cneayer l{cxarb B TIoJII'ITBaX (<Haylna He B aHTl.iqHofi no33r.rH. ]4 Hao6opoT, npl.lBjleqeHlre .(r'lt conocTaBjleHHtcnoBa, no,{cKa3blBarcxlus,MoneHr4ro)),TaX'HeKOTOpI'X 6OrOCnyxe6i[,Ix TeKcToB He BTIOIHe KOppeKTHOue:rl:r foBop]tTb HH O KaKOM'[ocBqureHHoM AiIeKcHlo'4aNe c.la6ou, 3auMcrBoBaHulz I'ts AKaQncra B crl{xorBopeHHH'B XIX eexe'qenoBeKy EoNuro (c. 74), m KaK AKaOucr 3roMy cBsroMy 6r'l:r co:aaH rojlbxoI,hu e rperrefiuosraMXIXrJraBe, paccMarpr.rBaJr xaHp crr.lxorBopHofo nocraHrlfl, aBTop firrurer: <floao6noseKa, rrocBrulaBrrr4M rrocJraHr4r 3ounaM-Kpr.rrr4raMBeKa aApecoBanu Br4prxri B $opMe noc:raur.rfi14r4HbrM (BparaM>,arropu XVIIraKxe K He,4pyraM...) (c.97-98), qroHeBoJrbHoHapy raeT xpoHoJroruqecKrre cBr3ri.B ro Ne BpeMr, nplr AeraJrbHoM uo6crosrersuoM paccMorpeHl4l4 KoHTpacrl{ofio6pa3Hocrll iIogrI,IqecKI,IX TBopeHvfi Hoeouepyca:rulrcroftnr.rrypruqecKvM reKcraM raBHrrMaHr4e Ha notBJIeHIreurorsr(c.

7$,xBaraer orcbIJIKlIKAra$ucry Bocxpeceuuro Xpacroey, xort aBTop H o6paulaerycroftvunux pr,rSv co cnoBoM (paaocrs> (c. 75). HanolHesnocrl3Tofi [o93LiI4 <cBeuofi HaAexAoft) Ir MeraoopaMH, cBt3aHHbIMI'l3Be3AaMrr)).sBHo He(c:apei, lyrallu,coJIHIIei\{,rax xax uonpe4enterc.s lIMeHHo flacxaJlbHofi TeMaruKoii,Horouepyca,uzucxufi vonacrupr nocBtuleH BocrpeceuNrc Xpncrony. I'l:recrHo,fr4Mnax, crpot4Brlruxct no o6pasy Ara$ucracaltrroeflpecerrof Foropoauue, xepern3Mll B HKocaxo6teAl,IHtlorct flonapHo, cooruoctrct pI]TMI,IqecKIr, HepeAKo pIa$v1'rorcr. Kpo:vte roro,g,r-eHrix xapaKTepHo npvMeHeHLIe flapannenlr3Ma,I.IBlaKBCHHoHHMHI], aHTI'ITe36I, BCTperlaiOUHXcqno33r4r4 HOBOI{epyCanI.iMCKI{X aBTOpOB.T,{-^."ao r-*--^no6nre JonycKaroTctnnnvnrrI.,\r.^s HeKoppeKTHbIeHprnnncrarHr-re coflocTaBreHuqaonocraRneHuc TeKcToB.TeKcToR[peA[ocneaHeM naparpa$e eropofiuantr re(cTcTr.rxorBopeHraxXVIIBeKa cpaBHHBaercr c6u6reftcxulr, Ho He Ha uepKoBHo-cnaBtHcKoM q36IKe, a B pyccKoM nepeBo.{e (c.

8l). uroreKcrorofrqecKlz HeBepHo. tr4.:ru a rperrefi r:raee (c. ll9) npu yno\{IIHaHHI'I Ara$lrcragecrnolry Kpecry Aelaercs orcLurKa x <Ma,roI nogopoxuoii KHI.rxllIIe) Opauuucxa Cxopunsluaneqaransofi s 1522 roly (:a crolerAo notBneHlts flprara:uoii IIIKoJILI cruxorBopqeB!).BpeMr KaK gTOr TeKCT HeOAHOKpaTHO ny6:ruxoea:rcxKaHOHHTTKOB, BEIIyCKaBITIUeCIBron XVII eexe B cocTaBe axaQucruuxorl,trlrnorpa(blrtMI4 KIaeea, Bu:rr'uo, Moru.jlega.Tperra r:rana, nocBtueHHaJI xaHpoBbIM $opuau xnl'lNsofi no::llH XVII sera'Bcrper{aroul.IMct B TBopqeorBe pa3nllx [IXoJr, cocroqr I.i3 nByx pa3.lerloB B nepnolrpaccMaTpr,rBaroTcr KjraccuqecKr4e xaHpbr, K KoTop[,IM aBTOp OTHOCI]T CTIIXOTBOpHble nocjlaHut.flpe,4ucnoBlit, snura$uu.Bo nropouonpe.qenqercc BrHqHue ronocoBHecTa6I,InbHbIx xaHpoBtIX cTpyKTyp: a36y.{Hbrxtr4z xpecroo6pa:HblxnaQoprrHponauuecTIrxoB, Buprei o clrepTu.ec:ru o4nalr.r XaHpaM B JIi{TepaTypoBeAeHI.IIl yxe y,4entlocb HeMaJIoe BHI.i}{aHHe, TO Apyr}reIIOKa OCTaBaJILICb nOqTU HoI4CCJIeAOBaHH6IUIA.3rOrnpOOen B 3HaqHTenEHOH \{epe BOCnOJrHceTc.sgauuoii pa6orofi.

Xaupoo6pa:yrcqrzMu TonocaMr4 B KlraccllqecKlix xaHpax. noaBropa, cranq rercroo6pa^:yroulaerpyxecKoii [o33I,M, t4 Tax$opnylu: An.{ fiocnaHufi-$opv1''rlt'Ha3bIBaeMbIe Sopvylrr-<saKpenKl'I),Mo3ar,rrrHocrr, r{ AeKoparvBHocrl' TeKcra,as:^'^st]?Ira$uit-art\{HeHHlOxapaKTepHble a'IsnpetrHciloBH[npauoe o6pauleHHe K r{urarejlto'-Oco6rrft r4Hrepec flpelcraBnrer pasnepuyruf naparpaQ, nocesuleHHHfi uecra6umnsmxaHpoBbrM crpyKTypaM.

Aualusupyr a^:6y.ruue crr4xr.r, coHcKareirrHr4rla rroKa3blBaer uxflprrHrlunna]nbHoe orJrr4q[eorBr4plllefr c KpaerpaHecr.ieM,noAqepKHyroe 3uaqeHue Haqa,'rbHoro cJroBaxorq re14Apyrue opIreHTI-ipoBaHbI I{aB crpoxe. B crrixorBopeHll{x o Kpecre ouao6parqaer BHr4MaHrae na aua$opu 14 fiapannenz3M, aaree noApo6Ho ocraHaBJIIrB aercs' HacraHoBneHItI4 xaHpa crllxorBopnoftnpar.ru. Hau6olee uy6oxo elo Irccneaylorc.s BltpurucMepru, rAe oHa BblAerser HecKoJIbKo yponneil noHI.iMaHIzt o6pa:a, orr'.revaeroBJtH.tlHIieIIepeBoAHbrx [aMrrHrrKoB enponeficrofi nrrreparypbr, npocnexllBaer ]icnoJIB3oBaHHe MorI,IBacMepTrr B coqLrHeHLIgx pa3H6rx xaHpoB.Oanaro, He6egocHonaterbHo yKa3bIBtuI na so:aeftcreue eeponeficxux sesnuhpyccKyro nos:uroXVIIngTypflrqecKr4x reKcroBzBeKa, colIcKareJIbHI4IIa ltHorAa He,qooueHl'IBaer ponl.lCs.rruleHHoroflucauut, Korop;re mo6r,tv rparttorHr'IM.{peuneft Pycu annrrtaa.nncb I.i ycBauBar}icb c aercrBa.ynOMr4HaHI.tH EU6:reficxrzxruUr,6eSHaMonHTB,rreroBeKoMB pe:ynsrare.