Отзыв оппонента 2 (Повышение управляемости фазоповоротных устройств с тиристорными коммутаторами)
Описание файла
Файл "Отзыв оппонента 2" внутри архива находится в папке "Повышение управляемости фазоповоротных устройств с тиристорными коммутаторами". PDF-файл из архива "Повышение управляемости фазоповоротных устройств с тиристорными коммутаторами", который расположен в категории "". Всё это находится в предмете "технические науки" из Аспирантура и докторантура, которые можно найти в файловом архиве НИУ «МЭИ» . Не смотря на прямую связь этого архива с НИУ «МЭИ» , его также можно найти и в других разделах. , а ещё этот архив представляет собой кандидатскую диссертацию, поэтому ещё представлен в разделе всех диссертаций на соискание учёной степени кандидата технических наук.
Просмотр PDF-файла онлайн
Текст из PDF
OT3bIBOsuuuanbHoro orrroHeHra Ha Auccepralluto Oe4oponoft Mapuu I'Iropennu<<f|onumeHlley[paBJIqeMocT[ycrpoftcrnSarononopoTHblxTIrpIrcTopHbIMIlcKaHALIAaTarexHllqecKfixKoMyyraropaMrD>, rrpeAcraBJreHHyroHa coucKaHue yrenofi cre[eHLIHayK IIo crequallbHocru 05.09 .12 <<CralonaseneKrpoHl{Ka)2030 I'oAa HB flporparvrMax MoAepHra3aur.rneneKTpoeHeprerl'IKu Ha IrepHoA AoPoccnu Ha rlepuoA AoMoAepHr,r3aqglrEAranofi Harlr{oHirnrnofi eneKrplr.recrofi cerl'I (EHOC)2020 roAa c llepcreKrueofipasBI'ITI'ItAO 2030 foAa B KarrecrBe KrK)qeBoro HarlpaBneHvfl,SneKTpl'IqecrofiBbrreneHo co3AaHl,reuHTenneKTy€IJlrnofioHeprocplcreMbl c aKTI'IBHo-aAa[TI'IsHofiHaAexHocrI,I u eS$errI'IBHocr[cerbro.
oHa HarrpaBrreHaHa rroBbrrrreHr.reoneKTpocereBoro KoMrJreKca. Cpe4u rrprroprrrerHbrx rexnolorufiOynrquoHHpoBaEvflrpllcyrcrBylorperyJrupoBaHnfl flapaMerpoB cerrr r{, B qacrHocrlil, SasononoporHble ycrpofictsa.cerueficrBo ycrpoficrn,ycrpoficrnaOHI'I BxoAffT Bco3Aarouux rra6ryrc, ytrpaBnfleMylo cllcreMy nepeMeHHoro tora'TarTexHoJrorrlflFACTS.Ha3bIBaeMiuI(ofly@agonosoporgbre ycrpoficrBa c rr,rpprcropHbrMr,IKoMMyraropaMuBecbMa rrepcrreKTlrBHbrMlr 14 Moryr3aMeHLITbuMerouuec TK) tBrflrorcscefi'Iac B MI'Ipe SasononoporHbleCBOIOHeHaAe)KHOCTbrpancsopMaropbr c perynsropaMrr noA Harpysrofi, Koropble noKuil|bIBaIOTOIIV, oAHaKo B caMoeB rrpr,rMeHeHlrr{.B poccnr,r He BBeAeHoB gKcflnyaraqnrc rloKa HLI oAHoroB [ocneAHrIe ro.4bl BeAyrcs6nuxafiruee BpeMs raKoe rroJroxeHlre Aen Mo)Ker LI3MeHLITbC.fl.[epcleKTrlBHbrxpaspa6orru OIIV c TK I{ rccneAyrorcs pa3rr,rrrHbrerorroJrOrI,IHCXeM.orutofi I'I3paccMarpnBaercfl BcxeM flBJrrercs @fIV c TK H Cr,rMMerplrrrHbrMperynrpoBaHl{eM, KOTOpitf,UCCJIeAOBaHI'IU'AaHHOMApICCeprauI4oHHOMyrpaBileHHsHa Aasurrfi uoueHr cyrqecrByror pa6oru, B Koropbrx rpuBo l lTcfl,cuoco6uTK OfIy,rpuu 6uctpo4eficrnuro'Koropbrx Bo3HIrKZlrOrOrpaHv.qre$fifl,rro yrpaBnfleMocrucoMHeBLrfl'.[ns 6oneeflosronry aKTyuurbHocrbAasuofi Alrccepraur,roHHofi pa6orbl He BbI3bIBaereQSemuBHOrO y[paBJreHr,rs rroroK€tMr,r arrusHofigHepr.ocflcreMax neo6xoAnuoMoITIHOCTI'I BCJIOXHbIX 3zlMKHyrbrx[oBbrrrreulre vrvr xe AocrLIxeHI,Ie nolnofiy[paBnfleMocrrILr-rrenr4fl.O fly H3 oAHoro c o cro flIdvIfl'B Apyro e.rroBbrrrreHue6ucrpo4efi c rBvrr,repeKnroBBeAeHI'It, rrerblpex HIaB 14 3aKrloqenr4fl.
Bo,{ucceprarlproHHiur pa6om cocrol,IT kr3o6ogna'reHa uenb I,IccneAonauutrt,BBeAeHlru o6ocgoBaHa aKTyaJrbHocrbrrocraBJleusofi 3a!raLrr4,HOBH3Ha,AOCTOBepHOCTbIIOn]ruIeHHbrXpe3ynbTaToB[paKTl'IqecKaflvr3HatILIMoCTbpTCCIeAOBAHI/IVI,[pI,IBeAeHbI OCHOBHbIeIIOJIOXeHH', BbIHOCHMbIe Ha 3aIIIlITy.@lIY.flpuneAeHaynpaBJreHI,IeM. Ouucanuupo6leurraHEIII,I3 pa3JII,IqHrxr.rrane [poBo trLrrcfl, cpaBHr,rreruurulB nepnoftO|IyxnaccuQr,rKarlgrcronyrpoBoAHr,rKoBbrMHa ouroBannu oflplcaHHbIxcyruecrByrcrrlux cnoco6oB r,r aJrroplrrMoB yflpaBJleuus TK OlIy.npo6nerr,r nrr6paHsl HarrpaBrrenvrfl r,rccneAoeaur,rfi u tIocraBJIeHa 3atraqa Al,IccepraulloHHororlccneAoBanJr4fl.uonufi,flpnne4encpaspa6orannufifracrl,IeMrrccne4oBa14q, cuoco6 v iurropr,rrM yrrpaBneHrrf, TK OIIy.aBTopaAuccepralluoHHoro,{anee cJleAylouue rpl4 ruIaBbIcsoficrs groro HoBoro cuoco6a yllpaBJleH.vfl'Ar,rcceprapu [ocBsrrleHbr HccneAoBaHI,IronropofiBorJraBe paspa6oraHbranaJrkrrkl.IecKlre MoAeJII,I Enfl MareMarl4rrecKoroHerroJrHosasnrrx cuMMerplrrrHbrx u Hec[MMerpHtIHbIX pexLIMoB pa6oruo111rca1r4s.OfIy,Koropbre Bo3HlrKaror' rrpu pezur,r3arllrn rrpeAJro)KeHHoro cuoco6a y[paBJIeHI,Ifl TK.
,{aHurteMoAenr{ flBrsrorcs rroJrHocrbro HoBbIMu, Ao aBTopa oHH B HafrHofi mateparype orcyrcrBoBzulpl.MoAenukr pe3ynbTarbr pacqeroBny6mraquxxHa rax ocHoBe AocTarotlHonoJIHO [peACTaBJIeHbI BaBropa. Eomruoe BHrrMaHLreyAeneHo aBropoM nepnSnxaldiau paspa6orannofia1aJfirrvrqecrofi MoAenH rryreM cpaBHenl,rs pe3ynbraroB anaJrvlrldtlecKoro 14 LIMI{TaIIuoHHoroB npofpulMnaeMatlab&Simulink.MoAenI,IpoBaHHflaHurI,ITI,IqecKofiuoAelru \nfl, HenoJIHoQasHrx pexl'IMoBBnepnue ilpoBeAeHa BaJrr,rAauufl,pa6orrr OlIyc TK nyreM corrocraBJreHr,rr pe3ynbraroB aKaJrr4TrryIecKoroMoAeJIHpoBaHHtI'IrroJrfreuHbrx n a S nsurrecKoM MaKere oKcrleptaMeHTuIrIbHhrxAaHHbrx.BarrvAauuuy6eglrreJrbHo noKa3blBaror, rITo Bce rpH MoAenI'IPesynsrarbr BepuQrErcaqvrr4prLrMeK)T xoporuyrocxoAuMocrb,paspa6oraHHarra*aJrvrr4tlecKalpa6oru OIIVpe>Kknr,ronHcrroJrb3oBaHaNw, r4cc.treAoBaHLrfr.MoAenb Moxer6rrrruoesrM aIIropHTMoM [epeKnlo9lelJufl.Tr,rpHcropHbrxMocroB c IIenbIo cMeHbIcryleHl,I perynI4poBaHl'It Oily.TperrnoilycTK,BJILIsHufl.laecuMMerpllrrHbrx pe)KI'IMonpa6otuHraBa rrocBrrrleHa r,rccJreAoBaHl,IroBO3HnKarOrqux KparKoBpeMeHHo rlpu[crroJrb3oBaHl,Iu HOBOTO iIJrrOpLrrMarrepeKJrroqeHnfl(ArurrcnbHocrb - rreplaoA cereBoro HarlprxeHnr)Ha JIuHkIrosneKTponepeAatlil, aTaKXe Ha perIfllrrlu pa6oru TK.
floxasaso, rrro HeAorrycrl,IMhlx [epeHarlprxeuufiHe Bo3Hr{Kaer. OAnaro n Sasax TK n Ha rLlpucropixrro roKy B 1rvr11rvru reperpy3oKMocroB TK soguuKtllorrrepeHanpfiKeuufl,. Koropbre Moryr 6urr paccrruTaHbrc [pLIMeHeHHeM anaJil4TvrqecKuxtuoAelefiAr.rccepraHTau yrrrenu Aolxurnvr o6pasoM fipu [poeKTI,IpoBaHI,IurexHLIrrecKLIXcpegctn TK.orMerrrrb,Baxnoqelefio6osHa.reHHbxqronrr6pannaxaBTopoMMeroAI.IKao6ocnonanHofiflBrflercfl.anaJturruqecKlrx uoAenefir{MeHHoI{crIoJIb3oBaHI,Ifl Lnflvrqenecoo6pasnofi, uocKoJrbKy rro3BoJrrer yxe Ha rlepBblx orarlax o6cyx.qeHus sH6opa MecraycraHoBKu OIIyAocrarorrHo rorrHo orleHr{Tb ero rlapaMerpbl kr BsUIBI,ITr TeHAeHIIIIHXI,I3MCHEHI,IS.Taxxe B HraBe roKa3aHo, rrro npeAnox(eHnrrfi cuoco6 ylpaBJreHLIt KoMMyraroporu OIIYB [peAenaxo6ecneqlrBaer rronHyro ynpaBnfleMocrb 14 Orrcrpo4eficrsuerepl{oAa cereBoroHarrpnKelavrfl.3ro nolo x(eHlre AoKEBauo raKxe gKc[ep[MeHT€LIIbHo.BuerneprofirJraBe HaocHoBaHuLI pe3yrlbraroB,MoAenr,rpoBa1vrfl, paspa6oralaa1aJfi4TprrrecKorofrr{TbrBaer ronoJror[roc[onytIeHHbIXrroMoulbloMeroAHKa pacqera HaAe)KHocrLITK, xoropaflgneKTpr{.recrofi cxeMbr TK.
Aanee c yrreroM rloKa3arenefi HaAexuocrl{paspa6oraHa MeroAHKanrr6opa neo6xoAlrMoro KorlrqecrBa rllpncropoB s TK OIIy.florasano,rrro HoBufi anroprrrM ynpaBneHnr rpe6yer yBeluqeHHoro rII,IcJIarI,IpLIcropoB B nJletlax MocroBTr,rplrcTopHoro KoMMyraTopa, qTo paHee He oTMerliulocb B cylqecTBylouuxlpoeKTgpoBaHrfl. .{annuft pesynrrarMeToAI'IKaxflBrrflercs rpafiue Ba?KHrIMc rlpaKTlaqecrofi ToqKH spelJ%fl,nocKonbKy aHaJroruqnrrfi pexfl,rM Bo3Hr,rKaer v npu paHee uc[oJrb3yeMblx aflropllTMax ccr,rMMerplrqHbrMyrrpaBneHlreM nppr 3aIrII,ITHoMorKrroqeHl{H rlpeo6paronareJlt B HopMuIJIbHoMpexr4Me pa6oru cerlr rro cr{creMe yrpaBJreHr{r.
OAuaro nepeHarrptxeHnt B pexuMe 3aIrI[THoroOTKIIOTIEHIIS PAHEE HE YIILITbIBZUIPICb.HavqHag nonngna ocnonurrx pegvlrraronn nrrnonon:HonusHa, H& rvrofi B3rJrf,A, cocrolrr B ToM, rrro npeAno)Kennrrfi cnoco6 yrtpaBneHlasKoMMyraropoM [o3Bonfler o6ecueqr,rrb [oJrHyro y[paBJrreMocrb Ia 6ucrpoAeficrelre[epproAa cereBoro Harrpr>Kenttfl.,a raKxe, rrro Bce cleuuQuvecruepe€IJII,I3aIIUI,I HOBOTO anfopl{TMa,,llocronepnocrrpe3ynbraToBIoJIHOCTbIOnoJrvqenHrrxailaJrvrTt4rrecKoro vgKcrrep[MeHT€urbHbrx AaHHbrx.Oil'ICaHbIB flpeAenaxpe]KHMbI,Bo3Hl{Karouue npplaHaJIpITI,IqeCKH.pegvnrraronnoATBepx,4eHaconocraBJIeHI'IeMr,IMI,ITarIIOHHOTO MOAeJII,IpOBaHLIflCflpurvreHeHHbre MeroAbIuccneAorlanuirpe3ynbraTaMl',IcoorBercrBylorrrocraBJregHbrMrlensM. Ha ocHoBe pe3ynbraroB LrccneAonawuit cQopuylupoBaHbl HafrHbren oJIoxeHug, Koropble rlpeAcraBJltroTc.f,AocToBepHbIMI'I.IlennocrrflparrzuecKyropa6oruOIIy.[ns nparcrnxll:3Haqr4Mocrb [peAcraBJrrlorI,IccJIeAoBaHHbIecuequSuqecKHe pe)KI'IMbIIIpu peaJrugdwu IlpeAnoxeHHoro urnroplrrMa yrIpaBJIeHpIf,,MeTOAI,IKTpacqerayqr,rTbrBiuoruuecnoco6 yrpaBneHl{sHaAexHocrr4u Bbr6opa Konr.rrrecrBarlrprcTopoB B TK Ony,KoMMyraropoM oIIy.[paKTurrecrcofiTaxxerleHHocrbroo6raAaetI,IMI,ITaIIuoHHaf MoAenbyrrpaBneHlrfl u pea.JrbHaflcr,rcreMa yrrpaBnenvls, Koroptul 6urarpoqecceBHeApeHa B OlIyBHe4peHue pe3ynbraroB pa6otrrBbrroJrHenvrs.
pa6oru.cI,IcreMbIc TK BB paMKax (De4epanrsofiuelenofi nporp€lMMbrerqe pa3 roATBepAI,InococrotreJlbHocrr pa6oru.Marepuirnhr Alrcceprarlnonnofi pa6orrr H3noxeHu n 14 HayrrHhlx pa6orax, AoKJIaAaxuTe3ucax, ony6nuroBaHHbrx B orerrecrBeHHoit u sapy6exnofi ue.Iaru. B topt qucJle 4 crarsuugpeKoMeHAoBaHbr BAKcnrlcKaPO.coAepxaHl{eaAeKBarHo orpaxaerAnropeQeparAucceprarllronHofi pa6orrr.CoorsercrnuecoAepxaHr.rs AucceDrauHH vragaHHofi cneunamHocr[:Tar rar AlrccepraunoHHuur pa6ora HanpaBneHa Ha paspa6orKy rIpuHIIurIoB [oBbIIrIeHLIsyrrpaBJureMocrr{vre$SercruBHocrlrycrpoficrnQarononoporHbrxKoMMyraropaMr,ru u rro cyrr,r rrccJreAyer pe)Kr,IMbI pa6orrtnpeo6pasoBareJrs, To B coorBercrBuuc[acnoproMcrI,IpLIcropHbIMI,IcuJloBoro [onylpoBoAHllKoBorocleIIH€IJIbHocrt4 At4cceprallrloHHoeuccneAoBaHr{ecoorBercrByer nay*rofi creuuiubHocrrl 05.09.12 - <Curonas oneKTpoHLIKD).3apreqaHus uo AucceprauuonHofipa6ore:B pa6ore rprIBeAeH 6olrIuofio6renaTeoperr{qecKlrx Lr gKcrrepLrMeHTiIJrbHbD(AaHHhD(,nx o6crotreJlbHas.
