Неофициальный отзыв 4 (Исследование тепловых процессов в системах твердофазного аккумулирования и очистки водорода)

OT3hIBHa asrnpe¢epaT .[(HCcepTa1zyn1 I>JlliHOBA ,[(MMTPM.51 BHKTOPOBINA«lfccne,[(osam1eTennoBbIXnpoueccossCHCTeMaxTBep,[(o¢a:moroaKKYMYJIHpOBaHH51 H oqHCTKH BO,[(Opo,[(a», npe,[(CTaBJieHHOH K 3aIUJ1Te HaCOHCKaHHeyqeHOHcneu;HanbHOCTHCTerreHH01.04.14 -KaH,n:H,n:aTaTeXHHqecKHXHayKno«Tenno¢H3HKa H TeOpeTHqecKaSJ TennoTeXHHKa,CHCTeMbl KOH,[(HU,HOHHpOBaHH51 H )l{H3Heo6ecneqeHH51»Bo MHOfHX CTpattax MHpa HCCJie,[(OBaHHH B o6nacTH BO,[(OpO,[(HOH 3HepreTHKH HBJIHIOTCHrrpHopHTeTHbIM ttanpasnettHeM ttayK11 H TexHHKH. Ba:tKHettrnan 3a,[(aqa, perneHHe KOTopoii 6y,n:eTcnoco6cTBOBaTb6e3onaCHOfO,,n:anbHeihueMy3¢¢eKTHBHOf0cpa3BHTIHOBO,ll;Opo,n:HOHTeXHHqecKOHH3Hepre111KH,3KOHOMHqecKOHCOCTOHTTOqKHBopramnau;HH3peHHHxpatteHIDIHTpaHcrropTHpOBKH BO,n:opo,[(a.Cpe,n:H pa3pa6aThrnaeMbIX HOBbIX TexHonornw H pa3JrnqHbIX ycTPoifcTB aKKyMyJrnposaHIDIBO,n:opo,[(aHaH6onee3KOHOMHqecKHnpHeMneMbIMHH6e3onaCHblMHBbl,n:eJIHIOTCHCHCTeMbl,OCHOBaHHbie Ha HCIIOJib30BaHHH IrnTepMeTaJIJIHqecKHX coe,n:HHeHHH, cnoco6HbIX H36HpaTeJibHO Ho6paTHMO nornomaTh BO,n:opo,[(.

3TOT MeTOJl: aKKYMYJIHpOBaHHH BO,[(Opo.n:a o6ecrreqHBaeT 6oneeBbICOKYJO, qeM B )KHJl:KOM BH,[(e, o6beMHYJO nnoTHOCTh xpatteHIDI so,[(opo.[(a (6onee3TOMOCHOBHaHo6ecneqHsaeTMaccaso.n:opo,[(anpe,[(errhHYJOHaX0,[(11TCH6e3orracttocTbBnpHCB513aHHOM3Kcrrnyarnu;11HnornomettIDI/BbI,[(eneHH51peaKu;m1ttHTepMeTann11qecKorocnnasa,TBep,[(0¢a3HOMTaKHXIlpOHCXOJl:HT6oJibIIIOHTennosoti3¢¢eKT753Kr H2/M ), npHCOCTOHHHH,YCTPOHCTB.cqTo06paTHManttarpeBOM/OXJiruK,[(eHHeMpeaKu;HHo6ecneqHsaeTsecbMaClfJibHYJO 3aBHCH.MOCTb paBHOBeCHOfO ,[(aBJieHHH BO,[(Opo,[(a Ha,[( cnnaBOM OT TeMrrepaTypbI, qTOno3BOMeT 06ecneq11saTh npose.n:ett11e npoueccos norrromettHH 11 Bb1,n:enett11sr so,[(opo,[(a 3a cqeTpecypcOB ropnqeif H XOJIOJl:HOH BOJl:bl HMeIOJUHXCH B CHCTeMe 3Heproo6ecneqeHIDI H ocymecTBHTb6e3MallIHHHOe KOMnpHMHposatttte BO,[(Opo;::i:a 3a cqeT HCilOJib30BaHHH HH3KOIIOTeHUHMbHOf0 TennanoTepbBTonnHBHOMHHTepMeTanJIHqecKHMHfa3006pa3HbIX3rreMettre.CsoiicTBocoe,[(HHeHttHMHnpHMeceif,npwieMm611paTeJihttoroIl03BOJIHeTqHCTOTaocymecTBJISJTbBbl,n:eJIHIOIUefOCHnornomeHHHoqHCTKYBO,n:opo.n:aso.n:opo,[(aso.n:opo.[(anpe,n:eJlbHOOTBblCOKa(99,9999% 06.)OcttoBtthIMnHMHTHpy10mttMnpoueccoM,onpe,[(eAAIOII(HM3¢¢eKTHBHOCTbpa6oThIMeTannor11,n:pH):(HbIX peaKTOpOB, HBJIHeTCH TeilJIOMacconepeHOC B MeTanJIOfHAPH.ll:HOH 3aCblnKe rrpHcop6uttHl,[(ecop6u.mr.

I1pou.ecc cop6u,tttt 3ttaq11TerrhHO 3aTpy.[(H51eTcsr B rrpHCYTCTBmt pa3n11qtthIXrrpHMeCHblX ra30B B BO,[(OpO,[(e, HJIH Heo6paTHMO OCTaHaBJIHBaeTCH npH HanHqHH XHMHqecKHlaKTHBHblXITOOTHOillemuoKMenumorHAPHAYr<t30B.Teopm1TeIIJlOMaccoo6MeHaBMeJlKOAHCrrepCHbIX cpeAaX rrpH HaJIHqHH cpa30BbIX rrpeBparn,eHHH "peaKQHH cop6QHH/Aecop6QHH BrrpoToqtthrx MeTaJTJlOrHAPMAHhIX cwcTeMax, ytJMThIBmorn,aH pa3Meptthie H Macnna6tthie 3cpcpeKThI, BttacToHrn,eeBpeMHOTCYTCTByeT.B3To:HCBH3HBa:11rneiiUIMMH3aAa1.JaMHcTaHOBHTCH3KcnepttMeHTaJJhHbie ttccJieAOBaHIDI npou:eccoB TennoMacconepettoca B peaKTopax npoTOlJttoro nmaHpa3pa60TKa 3cpcpeKTHBHbIXMeTOAOBMXMaTeMaTttlJeCKOroMOAem1poBaHID1 HHH)l{ettepHblXMeTOAHK OTITHMH3aQHH KOHCTPYKTHBHhIX perneHMH.IToMttMo perneHM5l 3aAalJ o6ecneqeHHR 3cpcpeKTttBHoro -Tennoo6Metta B MeTannorttAPMAHbIXpeaKTopax xpaHemrn tt 01.JHCTKM BOAOPOAa, He Mettee Ba)l{HI>IB KJiacc HaYlJHbIX " TeXHuqecKHx 3aAalJCBH3aH c H3yqemteM npou:eccoB CHCTeMHOH HHTerpaU:HH MeTaJJJIOrHAPMAHblX ycTpOHCTB xpatteHHH HoqHcTKH BOAOPOAa cosMecTHO c 3HeproycrnttoB.Koif Ha octtose T3, oTpa6oTKo:H pe)l{HMOB pa6oTI>IKaKOTAeJTbHhlX3JleMeHTOBpa3pa6aTbIBaeMOH3HepreTuqecKOHCHCTeMbl,TaKHpa60TbI3HeprocMCTeMhl B u:eJIOM.HineHcttBHoeu3yqeHHeBnocJTeAHHeroAbIB03MO)l{HOCTHrroJiylJeHtt.si:BOAOPOAaB6ttOJTOrttqecKHX CHCTeMax Bbl3hIBaeT orpOMHhIH HHTepec KaK B POCCHH, TaK H BO BCeM Mttpe.

TaKHa3bIBaeMbIH «6HOBOAOPOA» BhffJTHAHT HaM60Jlee nepcrreKTHBHhIM "3KOJlOrHqecKH 6e3onaCHbIM«3HeproHOCHTeJTeM», T.K. ttanpHMYJO CBH3aH c ecTecTBeHHhIMH npou:eccaMH B fomc<Jlepe 3eMJIH. P.si:AttaylJHhIX11TeXHMlJeCKHXnpo6JleM,cBsl3aHHhIXcYAaJieHHeMyrneKMCJlorora3a,MeTaHa,ceposo,L1.op0Aa, yrapttoro ra3a 11 AP· H3 6uopeaKTopa npw npoM3BOACTBe BOAOPOAa, a TaIOKeB03MO)l{HOCTb HHTerpaU:HH IIOA06HhIX ycTpOHCTB B COCTaB 3HeproycTaHOBKH H3ylfeH He,ll.OCTaTOlfHO.HcxoA» 113 BhillleCKa3aHHoro Bh16patttta.si:TeMa uccJieJwsauuunJTHHOBa,n:.B.»Bm1eTc.si:a1nyaJibHOH.Hay•rnou uosu1uoiipa6oTbIEmrnoBa.ll:MttTp1rnBHKTopoBnlfaHBJTReTc.si:KoMrrJTeKcBhlIIOJrneHHhIX uccJJeAOBattH:H npou:eccos Tem10Maccorrepettoca B MeTaJJJiortt,ll.pH,ll.HhIX peaKTopaxnpoToqHoro ,ll.eMCTBHR 01.JHCTKH BO,ll.OpOAa rrptt HaJTHlJHH ttea6cop6upyeMblX ra30BhlX npHMeceit.3KcnepuMeHTaJThHO rrOKa3atto ,ll.BH)l{ettne cppoHTa peaKn:MH cop6rurn BOAOPOAa BO BpeMH npou:eccaoqnCTKH.

3KcrrepuMeHTaJThHO Jl,0Ka3aHa rrpttMeHHMOCTb TeXHOJTOrHH rrpoTOlJHOH OlfHCTKH BOJJ.Opo)J.a,B TOM qttcJTe oco6oe BHHMaHHe yJl,eJleHO npttMeHHMOCTH Jl,aHHOro MeTOJl,a 01.JHCTKH B CHCTeMax6ttOJIOI'H1.JeCKOronpOH3BOACTBaBOJJ.OPOAa.3KcnepHMeHTaJThHOIIOATBep)l{Jl,eHOOTCYTCTBHe)J,erpaJJ.aU:HH MeTaJJJIOrHAPHJJ.HOro CIIJiaBa npM B3aHMOAeMCTBHH c yrneKHCJibIM I'a30M B ycJIOBHRXttarpesa AO TeMneparyphl, He npesh1rnmorn,e:H3KcnepuMeHTaJTbHOonpeJ1,eJTeHHHTepMeTaJIJTttqecKoro3KcnepttMeHTaJTbHhieKmcpcpuu:ueHTcoeAttHeHIDIo6pa3U:hl70 °CH ,ll.aBJieHttH, He npeBh1rnmorn,eeBR3KOCTHOHLaNi 48Mn03Fe0.1.2rrpOHHQaeMOCTHPa3pa6oTaHhIMeTaJTJTOrHJJ.PHJJ.HhlX peaKTOpOB0,65HMila.3aCbIIIKHH3roTOBJTetthInpoTOlJHOro JJ,eHCTBHRoqucTKHBO)J.opo)J.aPX0-83HeproycTaHOBKaHHaPX0-8H,OCHOBeaTaIOKepa.3pa6oTaHaTBep)J.OITOJIHMepHOfOHC03)1.aHaTOITJIHBHOfO3KcrrepHMeHTaJibHaH3JleMeHTa,HCITOJib3YJOW:aHBKaqecrne TOITJIHBa 6HOBO)J.Op0)1..Bpe3yJJI>TaTeBbIITOJJHeHHbIXHccne)J.0Batt11.HC03)1.aHbIHayqtto-TeXHHqecKHeocHOBbITeXHOJIOflIH MeTaJIJIOfH)J.pH)J.HOM O'IBCTKH BO)J.OpO)J.a npoToqHbIM MeTO)J.OM )J.JIH npHMeHeHmlaBTOHOMHhIX 3HeproycTaHOBKaxHaocttoseTITT311CHCTeMaxo6ecrreqeHH»BBhICOKoqHcThIMBO)J.OpO)J.OM B MHKp03JieKrpOHHOM, cpapMal.leBTHqecKOM, rruw:esott: " p»)J.e )J.pyrux orpacJieM.I1crroJib30BaHuepe3yJihTaTOBcpe3yJibTaTOBBcospeMeHHbIXH3MepuTeJibHbIXTeopeT~eCKHMH pacqeTaMHony6JJHKOBaHHhIX060CHOB3HHOCTbHpa6orax,JJ.OCTOBepHOCTbrrpu6opos,.ll.PYfHX aBTOpOB,HaaTaIOKeKOHcpepeHI.lHHXHayqHblXcpaBHem1e"TIOJJO)J(eHHH,rronyqeHHbIXarrpo6al.lH» OCHOBHhIXceMHHapaxBblBO)J.OB,ITO)J.TBep)l{)J.aeTpeKoMeH)J.al.lHHH3aKmoqeHHH, rronyqeHHbIX B )J.HCCepTal.lHH.OcuoenL1e pe1yJILTaThl uccJie,lloBanuH B )J.OCTaToqHoif cTeneHH ony6m1KoBaHbI B 185rreqaTHbIX pa6orax, H3 KOTOphlXnorra)J.aIOT IIO)J.

rpe6oBaHH& HayqHbIX H3)1.aHHH, B KOTOpbIX)J.OIDKHhl 6hITb orry6JIHKOBaHhl OCHOBHbie pe3yJibTaTbI )J.HCcepTallHH Ha COHCKaHue yqeHOH CTeneHHKaH)J.H)J.aTa HayK.OcuoBHLie 1aMe-..auuH no JJ.HccepTaQnouuoii pa6oTeIlo pa6oTe MO)l(HO BbICKa.3aTh CJie)J.yIOW:He 3aMeqaHlUJ:I. ~1u1pa.3pa6oTaHHhIX peaKrnpoB npoToqttoro THrra PXO -8 He yKa.3aH Kmcpcpu101eHTTeITJIOOT)J.aqH co CTOpOHhl XJia)J.areHTa.2.Cyw:ecTByeT HeCKOJibKO MeTO)J.HK npuroTOBJieHH» fa30BhlX CMeceH:, Ka)l{)J.aH H3 KOTOphIXxapaKTepH3yeTCH CBOHMH npeHMyw:ecTBaMH H He)J.OCTaTKaMH.

06'beM aBTOpecpepaTa HeII03BOJI&eT IIO)J.p06HO OCTaHaBmrnaTbCSI Ha onucamrn npHMeHeHHOH MeTO)J.HKH, O)J.HaKOCJie)J.OBaJJO 601, JKa.3aTb MeTO)J., HanpuMep, 0)1.HOBpeMeHHOe CMemeHue KOMIIOHeHTOB cperynHpOBKOH pacxo)J.a HJIH CMemeHHe B 60JibllIOM o6'beMe c KOHTpOJieM )J.aBJieHHSI.06~ee 1aK.1110-..euue o pa6oTeOTMeqeHHI>Ie3aMeqaHHHJIHIIIbBHe3Ha1uueJibHOiicTeneHHCHH)J(aIOTKaqecTBOnpoBe)J.eHHbIX HCCJie)J.OBaHHM " He BJIHSIIOT Ha HayqHyIO l.leHHOCTh, )J.OCTOBepHOCTb H npaKTH1JeCKYIO3HaqHMOCTbOCHOBHbIXrronyqeHHbIXpe3yJJhTaTOB.~uccepTal.lHOHHaHpa6ora~.B.bJIHHOBa«HccJie)J.OBaHHe TeTIJIOBhIX npOI.leCCOB B CHCTeMaX TBep,l1.0cpa3HOfO aKKJMYJJHpOBaHHSI H oqHCTKHBO)J.OpO)J.a» orneqaeT Tpe6oBaHHSIM «IlOJIO)J(eHHH 0 rropH)J.Ke rrpHCY)J()J.eHHSI yqeHblX CTerreHeH (rr.

7)BAKP<I»>,npe)J.'hHBJIHeMhIMK)J.HCcep-ral.lHOHHbIMKaHml)J.aTa nayK. ABTOP pa6oThI,pa6oTaMHacoHcKaHHey11eHoifcTerreHuIiJIHHOB ~MHTpttif BHKTopoBH1i, 3acJiy)l(HBaeT npucy)l{)J.eHHH3yqettoii cTerreHH KaHAH.D.aTa Texm1qecKHx HayK no cneu,HanbHOCTH 01.04.14 - Tenn0<pH3HKa HTeopeTMqecKa.sI TellJIOTeXHHKa.3aBe.lJ.YIOrn,Hii na6oparnp11eH: 3HeproeMKMXH KaTaJIHTHqecKH aKTHBHbIX Bern,eCTB~---.- - - - - -.lJ..X.H., npo<Peccop.ll:aTat!JG,.//fi Ult.IlO.lJ.IlMCbBep6eQKHM BttKTop H11KonaesHq~K.X.H, ,lJ,OLl,eHT.ll:aTa4t: ./'{)_ 20/6IlO,U.IlHCbII0,u.n11c11 Bep6eu,Koro B.H.

11 MttTpOXMHa C.B.3aBepfilOYqeHblM ceKpeTapb 3Bepesa HaTaJib.sI neoHH,U.OBHaXuMu'l.ecK.uii <}JaKJ!Jlbmem MI'Y UMe11u MB.Jl0Mo11ocoeaI'ep6oeaR ne'l.amb)JamaXuMu'l.ecK.uu <}JaKJ!Jlbmem MocK.oecKoco 20cyoapcmee1111020 y i'M~~~mti UMe11u MB.Jl0Mo11ocoea119991, I'CII-1, MocK6a, Jle11u11cKue 20pbl, o.1, cmp.

3Te!le<}Jo11:+7 (495) 939-16- 71e-mail: dekanat@chem. msu. ru4.