Отзыв оппонента 2 (Граничные условия на межфазной поверхности жидкость-пар)
Описание файла
Файл "Отзыв оппонента 2" внутри архива находится в папке "Граничные условия на межфазной поверхности жидкость-пар". PDF-файл из архива "Граничные условия на межфазной поверхности жидкость-пар", который расположен в категории "". Всё это находится в предмете "технические науки" из Аспирантура и докторантура, которые можно найти в файловом архиве НИУ «МЭИ» . Не смотря на прямую связь этого архива с НИУ «МЭИ» , его также можно найти и в других разделах. , а ещё этот архив представляет собой кандидатскую диссертацию, поэтому ещё представлен в разделе всех диссертаций на соискание учёной степени кандидата технических наук.
Просмотр PDF-файла онлайн
Текст из PDF
OT3hIBOIPHUHaJIbHOrO OrrrrOHeHTa Ha ,[(HCCepTaUHOHHYJO pa60TY IOpHHa EBreHHJI I1ropeBHqa «fpaHHqHble YCJIOBHJI Ha Me:>K<pa3HOH rrOBepXHOCTH «:>KH,[(KOCTb - rrap», rrpe,[(CTaBJIeHHYIO Ha COHCKaHHe yqeHOH CTerreHH KaH,[(H,[(aTa TeXHHqeCKHX HaYK 01.04.14 -rro CrreUHaJIbHOCTH,[(HCCepTaUHOHHaJI pa60TaHa Me:>K<pa3HOHrroBepxHocTHE. 11.IerrJIo<pH3HKa H TeOpeTHqeCKaJI TerrJIOTeXHHKa. IOpHHa rrOCBJlIUeHa orrpe,[(eJIeHHIO rpaHHqHbIX YCJIOBHH«:>KH,[(KOCTb-rrap»,aHMeHHOHCCJIe,[(OBaHHIO rrpoueccoB,rrpoHcxo,[(JlIUHX Ha MOJIeKYJIJlpHbIX MaCIIITa6ax rrOpJl,[(Ka (a cKopee MeHbIlle) ,[(JIHHbI cB060,[(Hororrp06eraMOJIeKYJIbIBra3e.OCHOBHaJIueJIbpa60TbI-3TOOTblCKaHHeBH,[(a<PYHKUHHpacrrpe,[(eJIeHHJI HcrrapHBIIIHXCJI qaCTHU rro CKOPOCTJlM, H3 KOTOPOH B03MO:>KHO orrpe,[(eJIeHHeMaKpOCKOrrHqeCKHX xapaKTepHcTHK rrpOI~ecca HcrrapeHHJI.
3Ta <PYHKUHJI JlBJIJleTCJI rpaHHqHbIMYCJIOBHeM rrpH peIlleHHH KHHeTHqeCKOrO ypaBHeHHJI H, HeCMOTpJl Ha 06HJIHe pe3YJIbTaTOBqHCJIeHHbIX HCCJIe'[(oBaHHH, rrOCBJlIUeHHbIX ee orrpe,[(eJIeHHIO, ee BH,[( ,[(0 CHX rrop BbI3bIBaeT,[(HCKYCCHH.HayqHaJI HOBH3Ha pa60TbI 3aKJIIOqacrcJI B TOM, qTO BrrepBble rrOJIyqeH TeOpeTHqeCKHHBbIBO,[(TaKOHMo,[(eJIHpOBaHHJI<PYHKU;HH,CaMaMeTO,[(OM<PYHKUHJIMOJIeKYJIJlpHOHcomacyeTCJI,[(HHaMHKH.CCH3BeCTHbIMHrrOMOIUblOpe3YJIbTaTaMHrrOJIyqeHHOH<PYHKUHH06bJlCHeHhI H3BeCTHhle 3KcrrepHMeHTbI rro orrpe,[(eJIeHHIO TeMrrepaTypHoro CKaqKa. I1ccJIe'[(oBaHrrpouecc HHHUHHpOBaHHJI HcrrapeHHJI rOpJlqHM rrapOM -3Ta 3a,[(aqa aKTYaJIbHa ,[(JIJI orrHCaHHJIrrpouecca COHOJIIOMHHeCueHUHH.ITpaKTHqeCKYIO 3HaqHMOCTh HMeeT rrOJIyqeHHaJI B pa60Te <PYHKUHJI pacrrpe,[(eJIeHHJI,KOTOPaJIrr03BOJIJleTorrpe'[(eJIHTh MaKpOCKOrrHqeCKHe rrOTOKHHcrrapeHHJI,HCrrOJIh3yeMhle BMo,[(eJIJlX paCqeTa TerrJIO- H Macco06MeHa B 3HeprOTeXHHKe (B rro,[(p06HhIX ,[(HHaMHqeCKHXMo,[(eJIJlX, yqHThIBalOIUHX rrpou;eCChI HcrrapeHHJI H KOH,[(eHcaUHH).PaCCMOTpeHHhIe3a,[(aqH0KOHTaKTe:>KH,[(KOCTHCrreperpeTOHrrOBepXHOCThlOHHHHUHHpOBaHHH HcrrapeHHJI rrpe,[(CTaBJIJlIOT TeOpeTHqeCKYIO ueHHOCTb - rrOCJIe,[(HHe rpaHHqHhleYCJIOBHJIHe06xo'[(HMOrrpHMeHJlThrrpHpeIlleHHHypaBHeHHJIP3JIeJl(B3a,[(aqeCOHOJIlOMHHeCueHUHH), qTO, B03MO:>KHO, BHeceT 60JIhillYlO JlCHOCTh B 06bJlCHeHHe rrpHpO,[(hIpaCCMaTPHBaeMoro JlBJIeHHJI.060CHOBaHHoe C rr03HUHH KJIaCCHqeCKOH H CTaTHCTHqeCKOH <pH3HKH TeOpeTHqeCKOeHCCJIe,[(OBaHHerrO,[(KperrmleTCJIMOJIeKYJIJlpHOH,[(HHaMHKH),pe3YJIhTaTaMHrrpOBe,[(eHHoroCqHCJIeHHOrOMo,[(eJIHpOBaHHJIHCrrOJIh30BaHHeMCOBpeMeHHhIX(MeTO,[(OMTeXHOJIOrHHrrapaJIJIeJIhHOrO rrporpaMMHpOBaHHJI H BepH<pHUHpOBaHHoro C rrOMOIUhlO ,[(aHHhlX NISI.CTPYKTYPHO,[(HccepTaUHJIrrpHJIO:>KeHHH, H3JIO:>KeHHbIX HaBo BBeAeHliu102COCTOHTH3BBe,[(eHHJI,qeTblpexmaB,3aKJIlOqeHHJIHCTpaHHuax.KpaTKOH3JIaraeTCJI aKTYaJIhHOCTH pa60ThI, ee CTerreHb pa3pa60TaHHocTH,HayqHaJI HOBH3Ha, ueJIH H 3a,[(aqH HCCJIe,[(OBaHHJI, rrpHBe,[(eHa MeTO,[(OJIOrHJI HCCJIe,[(OBaHHJI.C<p0PMYJIHpOBaHhI rrOJIO:>KeHHJI, BbIHOCHMhle Ha 3aIUHTY.
ITpHBe'[(eHhI CBe,[(eHHJI 06 arrp06aUHHpa60ThI.TIepBaBr JIaBarrOCBJlIUeHaorrHcaHHlOMeTo,[(aMOJIeKYJIJlpHOH,[(HHaMHKH,rrpHMeHeHHoro H peaJIH30BaHHoro B pa60Te. ITpHBe'[(eHbI ypaBHeHHJI H MeTO,[( HX qHCJIeHHOrOpeIlleHHJI, rrapaMeTphI H xapaKTepHCTHKH paCqeTHhIX 06JIaCTeH. ITPHBO'[(HTCJI H HJIJIlOCTpHpyeTCJIMeTO,[( MaCIIITa6HpOBaHHJI CKopocTeH, HCrrOJIh3yeMhIH ,[(JIJI KOHTPOJIJI TeMrrepaTyphI rrO,[(JIO:>KKH.IaK:>Ke rrpHBO,[(JlTCJICOOTHOIlleHHJI ,[(JIJI paCqeTa KHHeTHqeCKOH13HeprHH, rrOTOKa MaCChI H:meprHH. B3aBepIIIemm rJIaBbI rrplfBe):{eHbI ):{eTaml 0peaml3yeMoM rrpOrpaMMHOM KO):{e Hpe3YJIbTaTbI rro ero OTJIa):{Ke H BepH<)mKaUHH.BTopaH [JlaBarrOCB5II[(eHa OTbICKaHHlO <PYHKUHH pacrrpe):{eJIeHH5I rro CKOPOCT5IM H:meprH5IM.
B HaqaJIe rrpHBO):{HTC5I paBHOBeCHoe pacrrpe):{eJIeHHe H KJIaCCHqeCKHe paCCY)I(L{eHH5I06orrpe):{eJIeHHH):{OJIH06cY)K):{aeTc5I pa60TaHcrrapHBIIIHXC5I1997qaCTHU,ro):{a )l{axoBcKorocrroc06HbIXB. B.HcrrapHTbC5I.H AHHcHMoBa C.M.,B2.1pa3):{eJIeKOTOPM rrOKa3aJIa, qTOpa60Ta BbIxo):{a HMeeT HeKoe pacrrpe):{eJIeHHe. B pa3):{eJIe rrpHBOMTC5I ):{aHHbIe H3 pa60TbI1997ro):{a, TeOpeTHqeCKM 3aBHCHMOCTb H pe3YJIbTaTbI rrpOBe):{eHHoro qHCJIeHHOrO Mo):{eJIHpOBaHH5Irroorrpe):{eJIeHHlOrrpHBo):{HTC5I<PYHKUHHpacrrpe):{eJIeHH5I0630ppa60T,rrorrOCB5II[(eHHbIXrrOTeHUHaJIbHOHorrpe):{eJIeHHlO:meprHH.B<PYHKUHH2.2pa3):{eJIepacrrpe):{eJIeHH5IHcrrapHBIIIHXC5I qaCTHU rro CKOPOCT5IM MeTO):{OM MOJIeKYJI5IpHOH ):{HHaMHKH. ,l.{aJIee KJIaCCHqeCKHepaccY)K):{eHH5I, rrpHBe):{eHHbIe B HaqaJIe rJIaBbI, Pa3BHBaIOTC5I H rrpHBo):{HTC5I TeOpeTHqeCKHHBbIBO):{ <PYHKUHH pacrrpe):{eJIeHH5I rro CKOPOCT5IM HcrrapHBIIIHXC5I qaCTHU B 3aBHCHMOCTH OTpa60TbI BbIxo):{a.
ITpHBe):{eH aHaJIH3 pacrrpe):{eJIeHH5I: BJIH5IHHe OT BeJIHqHHbI pa60TbI BbIxo):{a H eepacrrpe):{eJIeHH5I,pe3YJIbTaTbIHeperYJI5IpHOCTHqHCJIeHHOrOrroBepxHocTH.Mo):{eJIHpOBaHH5I,B3aBepIIIemmrrpoBe):{eHHoroBpa3):{eJIarrpHBOMTC5I):{HccepTauHH,KOTopbIecomacYlOTC5I C rrOJIyqeHHbIM TeOpeTHqeCKHM BH):{OM H pe3YJIbTaTaMH ):{pyrHx aBTopoB.B TpeTbeH [JlaBerrOJIyqeHHOe pacrrpe):{eJIeHHe rrpHMeH5IeTC5I ):{JI5I HaXO)l(L{eHH5I rrOTOKOBHcrrapeHH5I. ITOJIyqeHa oueHKa K03<P<PHUHeHTa HcrrapeHH5I, paBHMrrepeqeHb3KcrrepHMeHTaJIbHbIXKOH):{eHcauHH.AHaJIOmqHOpa60Trroorrpe):{eJIeHHlOpe3YJIbTaTbIorrHcaHbI H3BeCTHbIe pa60TbI rroK03<P<PHUHeHTarrpoBe):{eHHoroHcrrapeHH5IHqHCJIeHHOrOKOH):{eHcaUHH,rrpoueccaKOHTaKTa)KH):{KOCTHCrreperpeToH3.2HcrrapeHH5IHorrpe):{eJIeHHlO K03<P<PHUHeHTa3.13aBepIIIeHHH pa3):{eJIaMo):{eJIHpOBaHH5IcomaCYlOI[(HeC5IrrpHBe):{eHHbIMH TeOpeTHqeCKHMH OueHKaMH.
Pa3):{eJIITpHBe):{eH KpaTKHHK03<P<PHUHeHTaHcrrapeHH5I H KOH):{eHcaUHH MeTO):{OM MOJIeKYJI5IpHOH ):{HHaMHKH. BrrpHBe):{eHbI0.8.rroorrpe):{eJIeHHlOC H3BeCTHbIMHpa60TaMHHrrOCB5II[(eH qHCJIeHHOMY HCCJIe):{OBaHHlOCTeHKOH(HarpeToHBbIIIIeKpHTHqeCKOHTeMrrepaTYPbI). ITpHBe):{eH rrepeqeHb pa60T, rrOCB5II[(eHHbIX B3PbIBHOMY BCKHrraHH5I. C):{eJIaHarrorrbITKa TeOpeTHqeCKOH oueHKH rrJIOTHOCTH TerrJIOBOrO rrOTOKa, rrpH KOTOPOM rrpOHCXO):{HTB3pbIBHoeBCKHrraHHe.B3aBepIIIeHHHpa3):{eJIarrpHBO):{HTC5Ipe3YJIbTaTqHCJIeHHoro3KcrrepHMeHTa, B KOTOPOM XOJIO):{HM )KH):{KOCTb 3arrYCKaeTC5I B CTOPOHY rreperpeToH CTeHKH HrrpoHcxo):{HT HX KOHTaKT, cOrrpOBO)l(L{alOI[(HHC5I HHTeHCHBHOH rrepe):{aqeH 3HeprHH. Pa3):{eJI3.3rrOCB5II[(eH Borrpocy HHHUHHpOBaHH5I HcrrapeHH5I XOJIO):{HOH )KH):{KOCTH 3a CqeT ee KOHTaKTa CroP5lqHMrrapOM.BblL{eJIeHbI):{BaMexaHH3MaTaKoroHHHUHHpOBaHH5I.MrrpHBe):{eHaTeOpeTHqeCKM oueHKa rpaHHUbI Me)l(L{Y HHMH.
B 3aBepIIIeHHH pa3):{eJIa rrpHBe):{eHbI pe3YJIbTaTbIcepHHqHCJIeHHOrOMo):{eJIHpOBaHH5IKOHTaKTaXOJIO):{HOH)KH):{KOCTHHrop5lqerorrapa,comaCYlOI[(HeC5I C rrpHBe):{eHHoH TeOpeTHqeCKOH oueHKoH.qeTBepTaHrJlaBarrOCB5II[(eHa orrHcaHHlO H3Mep5leMOrO B H3BeCTHbIX 3KcrrepHMeHTaxTeMrrepaTypHoro CKaqKa,BeJIHqHHa KOToporo He corJIacyeTc5I C BbIBO):{aMH KHHeTHqeCKOHTeopHH. ,l.{aeTC5I rro):{p06HbIH 0630p TaKHX 3KcrrepHMeHTOB H ):{eJIaeTC5I BbIBO):{ 0TOM, qTOHMelOI[(ee MeCTO HeCOrJIaCOBaHHe TeopHH H 3KcrrepHMeHTa CB5I3aHO B rrepBYIO Oqepe):{b C TeM,qTO H3MepeHH5I rrpOIt3BOMTC5I BHYTpH KHy):{ceHOBCKoro CJI05l, a pe3YJIbTaTbI 3KcrrepHMeHTaB03MO)KHO orrHcaTb C rrOMOI[(blO rrOJIyqeHHbIX B ):{HccepTaUHH rrOTOKOB HcrrapeHH5I.
ITPHBO):{HTC5ITeOpeTHqeCKHHBbIBO):{BbIpa)KeHH5I ):{JI5I paCqeTa H3Mep5leMOrOcpaBHeHHe paCqeTa C pe3YJIbTaTaMH 06CY)K):{aeMbIX 3KcrrepHMeHTOB.3aMeqaHHH no ,lJ;HCCepTaU;HOHHOH pafiOTe B u;eJlOM2TeMrrepaTypHoroCKaqKa H1. B pa3.n;eJIe 1.1 C)I{aTO II3JIO)l(eH MeTO.n; qIICJIeHHOrO peIlleHIISl, He paCKphIThI npIIqIIHhIBhI60pa IICnOJIh3yeMoro MeTo.n;a"velocityVerlet", ero npeIIMyrn:eCTBa no cpaBHeHIIIOC.n;pyrHMII(HanpIIMep,MeTo.n;aMIIPYHreKYTThIqeTBepToronopSl.n;KaIIJIIIIIhepMepa BOChMoro nopSl.n;Ka).2. AHaJIOrIIqHOe 3aMeqaHIIe MO)l(HO c.n;eJIaTh 06 II3JIO)l(eHIIII aJIrOpIITMa KOHTPOJISITeMnepaTyphI B qIICJIeHHOM Mo.n;eJIIIpOBaHHII (pa3.n;eJI 1.3).3. B pa60Te IICnOJIh3Y1QTCSI CIICTeMhI C qHCJIOM aTOMOB B paCqeTHOH 06JIaCTH OT 2 .n;o10 ThICSlq.
O.n;HaKo KpIITepHeB, comaCHO KOTOPhIM BhI6paHHoe KOJIIIqeCTBO MO)l(HOCqIITaTh .n;OCTaTOqHhIM, He npIIBe.n;eHO.Bo06rn:e rOBopSl,CJIe.n;yeT npaKTIIqeCKIIBcer.n;a B TaKoro po.n;a 3a.n;aqaX npoBo.n;IITh IICCJIe.n;OBaHIIe 3aBIICIIMOCTII pe3YJIhTaTOBOT qIICJIa qaCTllIJ;.06rn;au xapaKTepHcTHKa .LJ;HCCepTanHoHHoH pa60TLIOTMeqeHHhle3aMeqaHIISlSlBJISlIOTCSIcKopeenO)l(eJIaHIISlMII.n;mI.llaJIhHeHIllHxIICCJIe.n;oBaHHH. ITpe.llCTaBJIeHHM .n;lIccepTauHoHHM pa60Ta BhIIIOJIHeHa Ha BhICOKOM HayqHOMypoBHeIICO.llep)l{IITpeIlleHIIeaKTYaJIhHOHHayqHO-TeXHIIqeCKOH3a.llaqH.ABTope<pepaTOTpa)l{aeT co.n;ep)l(aHHe .n;HccepTaUHII, OCHOBHhIe pe3YJIhTaThI ony6JIIIKOBaHhI B 4HayqHhIXTpy.n;ax COIICKaTeJISI B peueH3HpyeMhlx )l{ypHaJIaX, BKJIlOqeHHhIX B nepeqeHh BAK.
Pe3YJIhTaThI.llHCCepTaUHoHHoH pa60ThI, BhIHOCHMhle Ha 3arr.J;HTY, npOIllJIH anpo6aUIIlO Ha 7-MII HayqHhlxKOH<pepeHUHSlx, B TOM qHCJIe C Me)l{)lYHapO.llHhIM yqaCTHeM.)J;lIccepTaUIIOHHMMe)l{<pa3HOHpa60TanOBepXHOCTHIOpIIHaEBreHIISl«)I(II.llKOCThnap»HrOpeBIIqa«rpaHIIqHhleSlBJISleTCSIYCJIOBIISI3aBepIlleHHOHHaHayqHoKBaJIH<pIIKaUIIOHHOH pa60TOH, B KOTOPOH nOJIyqeHhI HOBhle HayqHhle pe3YJIhTaThI, KOTophle6Y.llYT BOCTpe60BaHhI HCCJIe.n;OBaTeJISlMII B 06JIaCTII TenJIO- II Macco06MeHa.npe.n;CTaBJIeHHaSl.n;lIccepTaUIISly.n;OBJIeTBOpSleTBceMTpe60BaHIISlMn. 8CqHTalO, 'ITO«ITOJIO)l{eHIISl0npHcY)l{)leHHH yqeHhIX CTeneHeH» BAK, a ee aBTop IOPIIH EBreHIIH HropeBHq 3aCJIY)l(HBaeTnpIIcY)l{)leHHSI yqeHOH CTeneHII KaH.n;H.llaTa TeXHHqeCKIIX HayK no CneUHaJIhHOCTH 01.04.14 TenJIo<pll3IIKa H TeOpeTHqeCKM TenJIOTeXHIIKa..n;OKTOP <PH3HKo-MaTeMaTIIqeCKHX HayK, Be.n;yrr.J;HH HayqHhIH COTpy.n;HHK<1>e.n;epaJIhHOrO rocy.n;apcTBeHHoro 61O.n;)I{eTHOrO yqpe)l()leHHSI HayKII HHCTHTYTa 06rn:eH <P1I3HKIIHM.
A.M. ITpoxopoBa P AH119991,r.MocKBa,YJI·BaBIIJIoBa,38.TeJI: +7-499 135-02-47, mayorov sa@mail.ru C.A. MaHopoBC.H. AH.n;peeB3.
