Отзыв оппонента 2 (Преобразователи амплитудно-фазового распределения полей на многомодовом диэлектрическом волноводе для радиоинтерферометрической диагностики объектов)

OrsrrnoQnqua.nsHoro o[[oHeHTa,3aBeAyloqero orAenou oe4epa-ubHofo rocy.4apcrBeHHoro 6roAxeruoro yqpexAeHr{fi HayKr.rI4nuuryra lprasnru Mr4Kpocrpyrryp Pocclrfi crofi aKaAeMr.rlr HOIK,r.Q.-u.H. Barcca B.rra4nurupa Jlefi6onn.raHa Al,Icceprallrrrc laftnylnnofi ErcarepnHrr IOpreBHbr Ha reMy dlpeo6pasoBareJrr,raMnJII,ITyAHo-([aronoro pacupeAeJleH[s noreft Ha MHoroMoAoBoM AtrgireKTpr,rqecKoM BoJrHoBoAelrs.paliuokrutep(peporuerplaqecKofi AuarHocrurr,r o6rexroB)), [pe,qcraBJroHHyro Ha co]rcKaHHeyreuoft crefleHv KaHALIAaTa rexHllqecKl{x HayK no c[equaJrbHocrflM 05.12.04 - "Pa4raorexHr{Ka,B ToM ql,Icre cllcreMbr u ycrpoftcrna reneBr,rAeur4fl" vr 05.12.07 - "AHTeHHrr, CBrI ycrpoficrna uI4x rexHororl,Iu".Oanoft H3 aKTyaJIbHbrx 3aAatl Art pa3ruqubrx rrpr{Jroxeuzfi, TaKr,rx KaK paAr,roJroKarlrafi,ra3oAI{HaMvKa, p'uarHocrrlKa c[JlorrrHbx cpeA, B ToM q]rcJre rrJra3Mbr ffBr{ercs 6ecronrartnoe[oryqeHl,Ie zu(fopuaqur o cpeAe, o6terre ]rnH rrpoqecce, rrx xapaKTepr{crr{Krx I,I cnoficrsax cnrrcorofi Toquocrblo.

flprauerrr saxnoft xapaKTepr{crraroft r{3JrfrareJrefi xpafiue BbrcoKr,rx qacror(KBrI) AI,IarIa3oHa, uc[onb3yeMblx Ars Anaruocrr,rKr,r, rBflrercs Bo3Moxnoctr Soprr,rupoBaHr,rs3oHAltpylonlero rIoJIt c o[peAeJIeHHbrM]r rrapaMerpaMr,r B 3oHe Openelr, r4e Heo6xoAr,rMoytlHrblBarb 4Ia$parquounrrfi xapaKTep npoqeccoB. Tarxe 3oHAr{pyrouue ycrpoficrBa AoJrxHbr6rrtr rerro 3aMeHteMbIMrr, rITo Baxuo rrplr rrccJre.4oBaHr4r{ ra3oAr,rHaMLIqecKLIx [poqeccoB,I{Merb xopouo BocrIpoLI3BoAI,IMbIe xapaKTepr{cr}rKt4, u 6rrrs AerrreBbIMI{ B npoI,I3BoAcrBe.Kporrae roro, BoccraHoBJIeHLIe xapaKTepr,rcrr,rK r,rccJreAyeMoro o6rexra uItur rrpoqecca, B ToMqI,IcJIe 6ucrponporeKaroulefo, c sa4anHofi ToqHocrbro rro pe3yJrbraftM 3oH.qr4poBaHr,rtnpeAcraBJrfler co6oft xpariHe BaxHoe HayqHoe HarrpaBneHrre.

,{uccepmqr{oHHa-f, pa6orafaftuynrauofi E.IO. ilocBsuleHa aKTyaJrbHofi ua 4auHoM grane pa3Br{Tr{r HayKr,r }r rexulrKupaspa6ome npeo6pasonarerefi BoJruoBbrx uonefi KBII Ar.rarra3oua cnpo6renaeI,ICNOJIb3OBAH}IEMMHOIOMO.IIOBOIOBOJIHOBOAA AJITAr,r9 JreKTpr.rqecKo ropaAr,ror,rHTeplpepouerpu.{ecroft Ar,rarnocrr.rxra o6rerroB 14 npoqeccoB.Ile.rrrrc pa6orrr sBrtrocb l{ccJleAoBarr[e Bo3MoxHocrr,r (poprr,rraponauur noneftBoJIHoBoAHbD( npeoopasonareleft 4rfl, MHoroKarraJrLHbx cr{creM Ar,rarHocr}rKr{ HaMHoroMoAoBoM IrlupoKo(popruanroM rrpffMoyroJrbHoM Ar,rgJreKTpr,rqecKoM BoJrHoBoAe lr co3laHr{enpeo6pasonaterefi, o6ecueqrnaroqux elplperrrannoe nsarnruo4eficrBr.re 3oH4lrpyroqeroBOJIHOBOTO [rrKa C O6rerrOU AI4arHOCTr,rKr{ U HaAeXHOe r.r3BJreqeH}re un(poprrraqrara oxapaxTepr,rcruKax efo ABr,rxenprfr, u Ar{HaMr4Ke r.r3MeHeHr.rr ero Qoprrau.,{uccepraql{t I,I3JIo}KeHaHa 165 crpaurErlax reKcra r,r cocrorrr rr3 BBeAeHr{fl, qerbrpex fJraB,3aKrIoqeHI,Is, npranoxenr,Ifi, cIrI4cKa corpaqeuufi v ycnoBHbrx o6ognaqeuufi, ctrr{cKaIII,ITI{pyeMoft m.rreparypBl, BKJlloqaroqero ny6nuKaL\prfi aBTopa.

Cnracox Jr}rreparypbr coAepxr,rr85 uauuesosanuft.Bo BBeAeHHrr o6cyx4aercx aKTyaJrbuocrb [pg,ucraBJreHHoro Ha[paBireHr.rtlIccJIeAoBaHI,rft, conperraenHoe cocrosuue n nu6pauuofi o6nacru, c(fopuynupoBaHbr ocHoBHbreqenv rI 3e.,;a'-'ifi pa6oTbl, HoBI{3Ha I,I npaKTr,rqecKar 3Haqr{Mocrb pe3yJrbTaToB Ar.rccepTarluu.B nepnoft ruraBe aBTopoM Ar4cceprarluu paccMarpr,rBzrrorcs ocHoBonoJrararcqraenpLIHIIlInbI (popnazponaHlar 3oHAI,IpyIoUero KBrI rroJrr B 3a,4arrax Ar,rarHocrr,rKr{rlepeMelqaloquxcs o6rerton. flpone4eno qr4cJreHHoe MoreJrr,rpoBanvre pr gKcrrepr.rMeuTzrJrbHoeI4ccJIeAoBaHI,Ie aMrIJII,ITyAHoro pacfipeAeJreHufi nyqKa faycca-3pM]rra HyJreBoro flopfiAKa Hnoryqeu MaccI,IB ,{anHbrx Iro 3aBI{cIaMocrrM rrr}rprrHbr nf{Ka or $oprraara ceqeHr,rr Ha aneprypeKJILIHoBI,IAHrTx H KoHycHbIx BoJrHoBoAHux upeo6pagonareneft.

CQoprraynr4poBanbr rpe6onannx rttMTIJII{TyAHO-saSOnOUy paorlpgAeJreHr4ro 3oHArrpForqero floJrr, B ToM qlllcre AJrr peaJrbHbD(ycuonuft AJIfl MHoroKarraJrbHoro paAr,rounrep(peporr,rerpa, cMo,qeJrr,rpoBarrHofo B BHAe rpexBoJrHoBoAHrx npeo6pasoearerefi .Bropan rJraBa nocBtlrleHa I4ccJreAoBaHHIo Bo3MoxHocrlr cr,rnTe3a aMrrJrr.ITy,{Ho-(pa:onoropacrrpeAeJleHufl 3ouAl{pyfouero rroJr.fl Ha aneprype BoJrHoBoAHoro npeo6pa3oBareJrr Ha ocHoBecyMMbI coocTBeHHbrx BoJIH MHOTOMOAOBOTO [prMOyrOJrbHOrO .4r4gJreKTpI,ItIeCKOrO BOJTHOBOAa.Paccuorpenu npu6rl4x(eHHble MeroArr orfircartus, MoA [prMoyroJrbHoro AflgJreKTpuqecKoroBoJIHoBoAa, v Alrfl,IiIccJIeAoBaI-Iils paCnpOCTpaHeHI,Ifi BOJIH B IIpsMoyroJIbHoM .qI,IsJIeKTpI4qeCKOMBoJrHoBoAe nrr6paua ylporleHHzur MareMarrlqecrofi MoAeJrb Ha ocHoBe rrJranapHoroAr,rgJreKTpr{qecKoro BoJrHoBoAa.

IIpu gToM yqr4TbrBruorcs ToJrbKo co6crseHHrre BoJrHbrAr.rcKperHoro crreKTpa ,4ugJreKTpr,rqecKoro BoirHoBoAa. C Hcnolb3oBaHr{eM .uauuoro rroAxo,qa6rtno upoBe,4eHo qllcrenHoe MoAeJrr{poBaHue xapaKTepr,rcrr.rK pac[pocrparrenriff BoJrH(uauprxeuHocrl,I greKTpuqecKofo noJrfl, roe(f$uqneHToB 3aMe,qJreHlrrr n gucuepcuonnofi3aBr,rcr,rMocrur Arrfr rrepBbrx HecKoJrbKlrx ocHoBHbrx qernbD( naoa). florasano, rrro cr{HTe3aMrlJlliryAuo-$asonoro pacrpeAeJleHllt rr] rKa faycca-Sprraura HyJreBoro nopsAKa Moxero6ecue.rusurbcs, c srrcoKoft ToqHocrblo rrepBbMr4 TpeMr MoAaMlr AJrfl rrrEporo(foprrrafirororrprMoyfoJrbHoro AI4SJIeKTpI4qecKoro BoJrHoBoAa, rrpr,r SToM o[peAeJreH rlHTepBaJI onrunaanruofimLIpIiHbI TaKoro BoJIHoBoAa, o6ecueuunarorqrafi pac[pocrpanenr4e 9Tr,rx rpex MoA.Tperrn HraBa [ocBtlrleHa paspa6oraHHoMy aBTopoM cnoco6y nos6yNgeuurorrpeAeJreHHbrx MoA rnrporcoSopMarHoro [prMoyroJrbHoro Ar.rgneKTpurrecKoro BonHoBoAa c3a,4aHHbIMI,I COOTHOIIIeHuTfrM'VI rIX aMnJrr,rTyA r,r p{I3HOCTrMr.r 6ag c uCrrOJrb3OBaHr,reM JrOKr}JrbHbD(Heo.qHopoAnocreft (u1eua, naua4nr.r), o6ecueur,rBnroqr4x MaJroe Bo3MyrqeH[e napaMerpoBAr4oJreKTpr.rqecKoro BoJrHoBoAa (.uuerenrpn.recroft npour{rlasMocrn).

Antoporrn no4o6paurrpuBMepbl yqacrKa cBff3LI rrs. ruuporo$opMaruoro [pffMoyroJrbnoro Ar,rgJreKTpr4qecKoroBoiIHoBoAa 3aAaHHbrx ptBMepoB c yqeroM coorHorrreHr,rs aM[rr,rrya n $as uo4 HE11, HErg IaMI4HHMI,I3aTITII{ BKJIaAa HErs g[rfr $opuuponauur aM[Jrr.rryAHo-$a:onoro paclpeAeJreur{fi3oHAl,Ipyloqero rrorlfl n 6nIaNnefi sone, 6rusKoro K fiy.rKy faycca-3pMr.rra HyJreBoro nopffAKa.Ha ocHose co6crneuubrx MoA peryrspHoro [prMoyroJrbHofo AragJreKTpr,rqecKoro BoJrHoBoAapaccMoTpeHbl BoJIHbI B ALIgJIeKTpr,rqeCKOM KJrr.rHe, r4cloJrb3yeMoM B KatrecTBe rrJraBHoronepexo.qa or oAHoMo.4oBoro BoJIHoBo,qa K mraporo(popMaruoMy rrprMoyroJrbHoMyIr,r9JreKTpfi qecKoMy BoJrHoBoAy, IrpoBeAeHo r4x rrr,rcJreHHoe MoAeJrrapoBaHr,re.B .rerneprofiHraBe [pLIBeAeHbr pe3yJrbrarbr recr]rpoBanr,rr parpa6oraHnoro 14co3.qaHHoro BoJIHoBofo npeo6pasoBarers c npeAJro)KeHHbrMr,r aBTopoM gJreMeHTaMn 4rrflcrrHTe3a 3aAaHuofo aMrrJll{TyAuo-(fasonoro pacfipeAeJreufir 3oHArapyrouero nors B Br,rAe rrfrKafaycca-3pMl4Ta HyJIeBoro rloptAKa, B ToM rrr.rcJre, Ha MerpoJrorr4qecKlr arrecroBaHHoM creHAe.Pa:pa6orana rexHoJlorlit LrcroroBJreHr4r paspa6oranuoft KoHcrpyKrlr..rlr BoJrHoBofonpeo6pasoBareJrr I43 $ropounacra.

Onracana (fopnayna narenrnofi 3arBKrr, uo4annoftKOJIJIEKTI4BOiT,TPASPA6OTq}IKOB, BKIIOqAII ABTOPA AI,ICCEPTAIIUII.B rarc.rrroqenrrn c{opuynupoBaHbr ocnosurrd pe3yJrbrarbr, rroJrfreunbre B AncceprarlI,ru.B ra.recrse rJraBHbIx Hayrrnblx p$yJrbraroB AI,IccepraHToM BbrABr{Hyrbr noJro)Kenl{t:1) [porleAypa cI,IHre3a aMnJll{ry.qHo-Qaroaoro pacrpeAenennx (AOP) son4r.rpyrorqerofloJrr B Br{Ae rrfrKa faycca-3pMr,rra HyJreBoro [opsAKa Ha ocHoBe uo4 HE11, HEr:, HErsnrnpoHo(popMarHoro nprMoyroJlbHoro ArdoJreKTpr.rqecKofo BoJrHoBoAa, o6ecnevuBarouatAocraroqHyro An[ [prrKJraAubrx qelefi TorrHocrb.2) Cnoco6 yIrpaBJIeHr4s AOP c noMorqrro nos6yx4euvrs.HaJroKaJrbubx HeoAHopoAHocrfixruuporo(popMarHoro [psMoyrorbHoro Al4gJleKTpr.rqecKoro BoJrHoBoAa rpe6yerraoro ua6opaBbrcr[Lrx MoA c 3aAaHHbrMI,r aMnJrr.rryAaMnu $azatvtu.3) @uszvecKl,Ie npI4HIIlInbI pa6oru npeAJroxeuHbrx BoJrHoBo.qHbD( npeo6pasonareneft uaocHoBe MnofoMo,4oBbrx uraporo(popMarnbx rrprMoyroJrbHbx.qrrgJreKTprrrrecKlrx BoJrHoBoAoB cJroKzIJrbHbrMr,I HeoAHopoAHocrrMlr npu nos6yN,ueHr{tr KJrr,rHoBr{AHbrM fracrKoMAUgJreKTplIqeCKOrO BOJTHOBOAa.4) Yrouueuubre MareMarr{qecKar MoAeJrb r,r nporleAypa cr.rnre3a AOP gonaupyroqerollors c rIeToM BIIvIfrHvIS- KJII{HOBI{AHO|O yqaCTKa Ar.rSJreKTpr,rqeCKOfO BOJTHOBOAa Bnpe.qJroxeHuoft roucrpyKrlr{u BoJrHoBo.qHoro npeo6pa3oBareJrr na lpusu.recKr,re flpoqeccbr BHEM.5) Hosrre rrareHToc[oco6urre Koucrpyrrlfirr BoJrHoBoAHbx upeo6pasoearereft AJrtnpr{KJra.qubrx 3aAatr oAHoKauaJrrnofi u MHoroKaHaJrruoff pa4r,rouurep$epoMerpr,ru.CreneHr odocnonanuocrrr Hayrrnbrx p$yJrbraroBBrrno4rr Ar,rcceprarluu o6ocnoBaHbr r{ colepxar s ce6e pe[reur{e [ocraBJreHHbrx 3aAaq.Anrop KoppeKTHo r{crroJlb3yer rrcBecrubre MeroAbr o6ocHonaHr.rs noryqeHHbrxpe3yJrbraron.

AntopoM ra3freHbl r,r npoarraJrr;r3r{poBaHbr rr3BecrHbre ,qocrr,rxeur,rs s o6racrzsneKTpoAHHaMr{rrecKLrx pacqeToB xapaKTepr4cTLtK r8Jrr{eHr,rf,, Teopr4r,r pacqeToB peryrspHbrxAr.rgJreKTprrqecKrx BonHoBoAoB, Taxxe n o6nacru rrpr,rMeHeHr,rfi. pap;notr:nreplpeporuerpoB ,qrsArirarHocrr,rKr4 o6beKToB r.r [poqeccoB.Oqenrca HoBrr3Hbr rr AocroBepHocrnPesynntarrr, [oJryqeHnble aBTopoM, sBrrrorct HoBbrMrr Haf{HbrMri3Haur.rsMr{,rroJryqennbrMll B paMKax cnelll{aJlbHocreft "Pa4uorexHr4Ka, B ToM rrr4cJrg crrcreMbr r.r ycrpoftcrnaTeJreBlrAeHurfi" rr "Aureuuu, CBq ycrpoftcrnavx rexHoJrorrru". Paspa6oraHua.f, aBTopoMTeop[r cHHTe3a npeo6pasonatereft aMrrJrr.rryAHo-$asororo pacnpeAeJreHrlr fioJrefi na ocHoee.qngJreKTpr{qecKrix BoJrHoBoAoB rBJrrercs. 6asoir AJrr co3AaHr,rff KoHcrpyr<q[ft eorHoBoAubrxnpeo6pasonareneft KBH usnyr ennfr, 3arquueHHbx rrareHTaura P@.Hay.rnan HoBrr3Ha pa6oru 3aKflroqaercr B cJreAyrorqeM:1) O6ocnonaHa Bo3Moxuocrb Soprraraponanr,rs 3oHAr,rpyroqero BoJrHoBoro o6pasonauua cfipaeruuuofi pa3penaroulefi cuoco6Hocruo rro nonepequbrM Koop,quuarau ]r He3aBlrcr{MbrMyrIpaBJreHI,Ieu AOP rIoJIt B AByx oproronzurbHbrx HarrpaBJreur..rffx mupoKolpoplaarurnrarrprMoyroJrbHbrM,{B r rr,ruoroMoAoBoM pexr.rMe.2) Bnepnrre npeAJroxeHa rporleAypa cr,rHre3a AOP 3ouAr,rpyrouero noJrr B Br{Ae nf{Kafaycca-3pMr{ra HyrleBoro rroprAKa Ha ocuoBe uoa HEl1, HE13 u HE15 IIIIAB,o6ecneq[sarcqa"fi AocraroqHyro AJrfi npr,rKJraAHbx rlenefi Torruocrb.3) Bnepnue rpeAno)KeH r,r rpaxrr,rqecKr,r peaJrr,r3oBan cnoco6 nos6yN,4euur rpe6yenrorona6opa BbIcr[]Ix MoA c 3aAaHHbIMH aMnJll4TyAHo-Qaeonrnrrr{ coorHorrreur.rflMll Ha JroKaJrbHbD(HeoAnopoAnocrrx IIIIIAB.)VIccrc4oBago BJII,ITHue SusIE.recKr.rx npoqeccoB B KJrr4HoBr{AHoM yrracrKerrpeAJloxeHnofi crpyxrypu BlI, c freroM groro yrorrHeHbr MareMarr{qecKar MoAeJrb r,rilporleAypa crlHre3a AOP goH.qr,rpyrqero nonn upeo6pa3oBarers.5) CogAanrr KoHcrpyKIII{[ npeo6paronarenefi Afi.fi [pr4MeueHras B rranororanalruoftpa.{[or{HTep(pepouerpuu.

3ro rro3BoJruJro KoJrJreKT}rBy aBTopoB 3arrlr{Tr,rrb r{x Bapr,ranTbrnarenravu P@.locronepnocrb rroJrfreHHbD( B Ar{cceprarlu}r pe3yJrbraroB o6yc.noueHa rrpr,rMeneu}reMlBBecrHhD( npu6nnxeHHblx gJIeKTpoAr{HaMr,rqecKHx MeroAoB rrpIa :aaJfirqkrkr KoppeKTHo3aAaHHbx orpaHxqeHuft p.ns. pelrreHl,Iff gapia.r Ar4arnocrr{Kr{, a raKxe xopour,IM coruracoBaHr,reMp$yJrbTaToB TeopeTI4qecKI,IX pacqeToB c pe3yJrbTaTaMrv gKclepr,IMeHToB vr qprcJleHHoroMOAeJrllpOBAHVrs.floryueuubre pe3ynbrarbr r,r3BecrHbr crrequaJrucraM. OcHonnrre pe3yJrbrarbr Ar,rcceprarlutrony6rzronaHbr B 22 \eqaruatx pa6orax,'r.r3 Koropbrx 6 n pe([epupyeMbrx )KypHaJrax (Aurennrr,I4gn.BY3on.(Dusuxa) I,I3 clrllcKa BAK, a raKxe 4 narenra ra 1 sasnra Ha rso6pereur{e, oHHHeoAHoKparHo o6cyxga-uucr Ha pa3rraqHbD( ron$epenquxx (<Arcryalruue npo6neurr(r.