Отзыв ведущей организации (Численное и экспериментальное моделирование процессов в двухфазном жидкостно-газовом эжекторе применительно к испытаниям реактивных двигателей)

Jfocrcpnopauus <POCKOCMOC)OeAepa.rrnoe Ka3eHHoe npeAnpr{rrue"Hayrxo-ucnrrrarelraufi uexrpYrnepN4aropaKerxo-KocMmecxofi rpou urulexxoctlt"llepnrrfi*@ry3aMecrr{TeJrb reHonbrTHo -Ko HcTpyrcropcOfn dIIIIPKIIDEa6yurorxa yt.,9 t., r,llepecaer, Ceprueronoca.scxufi p-n, Mocxorcra"s o6r,, Poccns,t4t320.Ten, (496)546-3321. Terexc 846246 AfAT<Daxc (496)546 -7 698, (49 5)221 -6282(83)E-mail; mail(@nic-rkp. nrOrNeBeAyrnlefrOT3bIBopraHlr3aqrr Ha ArrccepraquoHnyro pa6ory 3apanrcenuqa Urbn Anqpeenura<<rlnc;rennoe lr 3KcrrepnmeuTaJrbHoe MoAeJr[poBaHrre npoqeccoB n gnyxQauronr,rilrAKocTHo-ra3oBoM SrKeKTope npI|MeHl|TeJrbHo K ncnbITaHHsM peaKTHBHbIxABnrarqrrefi>>, npegcraBJrenHyro Ha corlcnaHlre yrreHoft crenenn KaHAnAara rexHlrrrecrux<<Ten;roBbre,3JreKTpopaKerHbre ABnrareJrn uHayK no cnequarbHocrlr: 05.07.05-3HeproycraHoBKrr JrerareJrbHbrx annaparoB>>Paspa6orra r,r MoAepHr.Barlr4r paKerHbrxsKcnepr.rMenralurofi orpa6orKr,rcparroHHbrx6roxosaBvaqtaoHHbrx ABI{rareJIefiB qacrnocru, Antfl.

orHeBbrx creHAoBbx()IPA),c 6onrIrtofi-I4KocMlrqecKofo Ha:iHarreHr,rr, Heo6xoAuMo cleqrrilJlbHoe creHAoBoecreneHbro pacnlrpeHlrr coneJr.B crenAosofi nparrnKepa3pgx(eHr,rr B r4cnbrrareJrbHbrx KaMepax npr,r BbrcorHbrxannaparbrIacnrrranr.rfinpeAHa3HaqeHHbrx AJII BepxHnx cryneHefi paKero6opy.uonaHr.re, Koropoe AoJrxHo o6ecneqr,rrb r.rMr4Tarluro BbrcorHbx ycJIoBI,IficropaHrnrrpe6yer uxzuuraquefi Harypnbrx ycronrafi sKcnJlyarallun ArAnoATBepxAeHrrrr pacqerHbrx napaMerpoB.xorAKocrHbrx paKerHbrx gnurarerefiugxerffoprr.flepcneKTr.rBHbrMpa6orblKaMepAJII co3AaHvt[crrbrranulx npltMeHtlorcr crpyfinrrerBJrrercs npr.rMeHeHlre anyxtbagHbx xHAKocrHo-raBoBbrx gxeKTopoB AJrr noBbnuenux eQQeKrnBHocrr.r npoBeAeHr4r Bbrcornux prcnrrtaHlafipeaKTrrBHbrx Asr.rrarerefi.BHacrorlqee BpeMt HeAocraroqLostlll{fiEfA'EI'fr,ffiiaNs- .,L,Bx.I,20gKcrrepr{MeHTaJrbHbrxpa6or, cBr3aHHbx c vccneAoBaHlaeMBlrvtfl:avlfl Al4crlepcHocru pa6o.reroreJra Ha y.uenbHble napaMerpbl 4eyx(pa":uoro oxeKropa.,{uccepraqzouuofi pa6ora 3apaurenu'rallrruAu4peenzua rocBtlrleHaaKTyanbHbIMBonpocaM rroBbrrrreHrzr s$QexruBHocrr4 creHAoBofo o6opy4onanvrs.Lr cHI,IlKeHI4t Marepl{aJlbHbrx3arpar rrpr4 rrpoBeAeHur4 ucrrcrcattuftcoBeprrreHcrBoBaHr,rr pa:pa6omrapeaKTr.rBHbrxAeurarereffvLrx arpefaroB nyreM4nyx$a:nsx xr{.{KocrHo-ra3oBblx crpyftnrxsxeKTopoB(xfcA).Hayunar HoBu3Ha Ir [paKTrrqecKafl 3Haql{Mocrr, pa6orrrAnropou [poBeAeH alaurltsr;rr4snvrs.

A]rclepcHocrlr pa6oueft xI,IAKocrI4cMecr{TeJrbHoro grreMeHTa oxeKTopa Ha yAenbHble napaMetprrXfCA.Pa:pa6oraHa Mero4rrKa qucreHHofo MoAen:rrpoBar^vrs. pa6o.rero flpoqecca xlrAKocrHo-ra3oBoro 4nyxlpasuoro gxeKTopa B rraKerax nplrKnaAHbrx nporpaMM rr{Apora3oAlrHaMr{Krr cyqeroM rrapaMerpoB cTpyl4.flpone4eua orIeHKa rlorperxHocrrr sKcrrepr4MeHTaJrbHbrx AaHHbrx r{ cpaBHeHue r4x cpe3ynbraraMr.r trprcJreHHofo MoAeJrkrpoBaHars, npoqeccoBe4nyx$a:HoM xlrrKocrHo-ra3oBoM3xeKTOpe..{auus$fpeKoMeHAarlrrr4eruunn o crr.I npoBefloryreHnueeHeprerrzr{ecKprereutrflrroMoAenr.rpoBaHlrro 4nyxlpasnrrxBbIc o rHbxrzXfCA AJII [oBbIIIreHI{-trcusrraHlaft P,{.ra6apnru vucuuranufi XP,{ u P.{ 6esgKcrIepLIMeHTaJrbHbre AaHHbre rro3BoJr.sror cHr,r3r4Tb3arparrr crpyfinrrx arraparoB rrpu rpoBe4enurvrcHr,rxeHr.rt I{x [pol,I3BoAurenbHocru.npr,rKnaAubrx nporpaMuB pa6ore rroKa3aHa Bo3Mo)KHocrb lrcflonb3oBaHr,rr naKeroBANSYS r{ MoAynr CFX ans pacqera gnyx(pasnsx xr4AKocrHo-ra3oBbrxcrpyfturx alnaparoB 6eg rroreprr rorrHocrrlr onpe4eneHrr.f, xapaKTepr,rcrrrK 4nyxQasuorosXeKTOpa.[ocronepnocrb p$yJrbraroB rl o6ocnosaurrocrb HayqHbrx rroJro)r(eHr{fi o6ecneqeHayrreroM nau6oree BaxHbrx ra3oAl{HaMrrqecKr4x npoqeccoB B 4nyxlparnorvr gx{eKTope,rrprrMeHeur,rerra cepru(prrqupoBaHHofo KoMMeptrecKofo(ANSYS CFX), xopoureft cxoAr{Mocrbro pacqeroBO6qrerzcpegcrBa rrucneHHofo MoAenl{poBauutsKcreprrMeHroB.cBeAeHr{s o Arrcceprarluosnoft pa6ore,{uccepraqvronnas.

pa6ora 3apaHxenuua W.A. cocror4T vr3 BBeAeHrr{, Tpex rJraB,3aKJIIoqeHHg, cttrlcKa ycnoBHblx o6osua.{euufr, cnucxa ucrroJrb3oBaHHbrx rrcroqHr4Koe. O6reN{Ar4cceprarlur{ cocraBJrrer 101 crpaHr.ruy, crrrrcoK rzcrorrHr.rKoB BKJrroqaer 183 ccrrrlxra.BoseeAeHura o6ocnoBaHa aKTyanbHocm pa6oru, cSopuynr4poBaHa rlenb r,r 3aplaqvrrrccneAoBaHlr.g, nplrBe.qeHbl rIoJIox{ eHus, BbrHo cr,rMbre Ha 3 arrl'rry.B nepBofiFJraBe npeAcraBJIeH o6sop JluTeparypHbxI4CTOTtHHKOB. nOCBqIIeHHbIXuccneAoBanilrv, gnyxQarnrx xcI4AKocrHo-ftBoBbIX gxeKTopoB c yrreToM npItMeHeHI4taBlraq[onHofirzBpaxurnofi rexnure u o6rqefi npoMbIruJIeHHocrI,I.Bo nropofiruraBe onucaHo6rerrrrccJreAoBannt, rpanuqHble ycJloBvlfl, vIcnoJtb3yeMbleMaTeMaTVqecKI4e MoAeJrrr, npr,rMeHeHHbrenpoucxoArrru4xnnpHqUcJIeHHOM MOAeJII'pOBaHIdI'I npoqeccoB,4nyxtfasnou )Kr,rAKocrHo-fa3oBoM o)KeKTope.

flpunogurcr pealmsa\ufl,r{r.rcreHHoro MoAenr,rpoBaHhfl. B ANSYS CFX, a raKxep$ynbrarbl pacqerHo-TeoperllqecroroHCCJTeAOBaHUT.B rperrefi ruraBe onrrcaHgKcneplrMenramnufi creHA, Aagtcfl onlrcaHnenocneAoBaTeJrbHocTr.r npoBeAeHr.rfl gKcnepuMeHToB,a TaKxenpeAcTaBneHbl ocHoBHbIep$yJrbrarbr zcnrnanufi paspa6oranHoro AByxQa3Hofo gxercropa.

flpano4lrcx peKoMeHAaIILtrIn npeAnoxeHnr no npoeKTlrpoBaHltrc n opraHz3aqnu pa6orrr crpyfinoro ailnapara.B saKnroqurelurofi qacrpt Arlcceprarlnr,r nprrBeAeHbl BbIBoAbr rI peKoMeHAarI[[.flo reMeHa ceMnncepoccuficrnxUMexAyHapoAHbx ron<fepenqyltx, a ocHoBHbre peyJrbrarbl Avcceprallnu orry6tuKoBaHblB 3Avcceprarluu npe4craBJreHbr AoKJraAbrperlercupyeMblx xypHanaxAnrope$epar orp tDKaer ocHoBHoe coAep)I(aHI,Ie AI'IccepraI{LII4.Cquraeru neo6xoAuubrM BbrcKa3arb cJreAyroulee 3aMeqaHl4e no pa6ore.1 Hassanrae pBAeJrapa6ovravr reJroMc2gucceprauur4 "HucJreHHoe MoAeJIrIpoBaHIle gx(eKTopa c 4nyx(pasnurra[pr4MeHeHHeM MeroAoB KoHeqHbx sJIeMeHToB".Boo6ue foBopt, s CFXnplrMeHrerct MeroA KoHeqHbIx o6reuon, a repMr,rH MeroA KoHeqHbrx gJIeMeHToB orHocuTctKpacqeraM HanprxeHHo-4etf oprvrupoBanHo ro cocrotHlrt rBepAbx reJI.2Bnucceprarruu HanvcaHo, rrro3filepa".

,{aneeArrnpr,rBoAr4Tcr yroqHeHuepacqeroB npllHtra "rranoroSa3HaJl MoAeJIr 3filep-- "BpaMKax MoAeJrn 3finep-3finepa, ucrroJlrcyerctMoAenb cMe[reHr4r gneMenrapnrx tpasonrx o6teuoB IaJII,I MoAeJIb cno6oAnofi rraex(pasnofinoBepxHocrn". V3 Aalrnefiurero onucaHr,rr c oqeHb 6omruuu rpyaorr,r Mo)IGo noHtrb, qroLI3r.rMeroquxcr uoAenefi rraKera CFX, nueracb BBr.rAy MoAeJIb nanoro$asuofi cuecu, B Koropoftcno6oluar rraex(fasHar noBepxHocrb-uHTeptfefic ne paccMarpllBaerct. O.reHr ne6pexuoeonncaHlre MeroAoB pacrrera 3aTpyAHreT oqeHKy p$ynbTaroB pacqeToB, no4rqaeMbx B paMKaxnrr6pannofi MoAeJIH.3 Oannr,ts rryHrcroB nocraHoBKr4 3aAar{rd-"Paspa6orKa HaI4MeHee pecypcoeurofi MeToAHKLItrr4cJreHHoro MoAeJrnpoBaHr4r ocHoBHbx napaMeTponpa60ru 4nyxQasnoroxI4AKocTHo-ra3oBoro gxeKTopa B naKerax npr4KJraAHbrx nporpaMM rIrApora3oAI4HaMHKI,I." O,qHaKo, noHarrrr4M orIeHKaM, pacr{erbrnoAo6nofi gaAaqfi Ha cerKe3ug I7,7MJIH.

tr{eeK rpe6yrorKoMnblorepa c oneparr4BHoft naMflTbro noprAKa32f6, l6 slepnoronpoqeccopa u, nocKoJrbKycoJrBep Hecrarrr{oHapnufi, BpeMr pacqera cocraBr4T noprAKa 100 qacoe.[eranrnrrfi pacqer 4nyx$asHofo reqeHur B o6racrn BbrxoAa )Kr4AKocr]r us $opcynxn uBHyrpv cnepxsnyroeofi KaMepbr cMelreHrrr g)KeKTopa, Koropar o6na.qaer pa4uantnoficl4MMerplrefi,no3BoJII4JIouoxno 6rno rpoBecrrr Ha AByMepHofi cerre c 30 - 300 ruc. sqeer.

3ro6rr cne6oJIbrIILIMIt KoMnbrorepHbrMr4 pecypcaMr4 locroBepHo nocqnrarb Bce rroJrtnapaMerpoB Ia paccquraru roetp$HrlueHT 3xeKrlr4r,r,r4uAanee onrlrMr43upoBarb FeoMerplrqecKr4epexraMHbre napaMeTpbr 3)r(eKTopa.Ecll,u He npoBoAr.rnacb orIeHKa BrwrflHvtfl, MoAenrr ryp6ynenrHocrr.r Ha pe3yJrbrarbrpacqeroB, ro xaxofi cMbrcJr 6rm usueJrbqarb cerKy n pafione creHKr.r u paccMarpr.rBarbpacnpeAenenraeHeYf?.npnne.qen o6utuit sLtA pacqerHofo o6reua, He npr.rBeAeHbr raruKe napaMerpbrconBepa, cooTBeTcTBeHHo, HeT orleHKr.r noprAKa TOqHOCTTT, C KOTOpbTM npOBOAr4nHCb paoqeTbr.4 HerBo3Mox(Hocru cpaBHltrb paccqlrraHHbrexu4xofi Sasu, xors 6u AJrt Kaqecrnennofiu n3MepeHHbreorleHKr.r.pacnpeAeJreHur KoHueHTparruu3a cnepxsnyxonofi xauepoficMerrreHrrtpacqeTbl npoBoAIrJIHcb, Ho AaHHbIe He npr,rBeAeHbr, KaK HeT r,I SKCnepUMeHTaJrbHbX AaHHbrX.flpnre4enu Qororpatfuutpaxena pacnbrna$opcynru (6es cnepxsnyronofiKaMepbr crvreruenu-a),HO HeT paCr{eTOB.5He6pexnoe otfprvrneHze Ardcceprarlulro:Pucyuorc7, ulaeroquitcs s anropetfepare, B Ancceprarrulr orcyrcrByer,npr4BeAeHbr na puc.o B asropetpepare55-5 8 s Ar.rccenpnBeAeHo,pra\wr vxorr gru AaHHbreHa pvc.l 0.

anrope$ epara.qro npu lrcnbrraHlurxr,r3MepeHue Ar.rcnepcHocrlr noroKaonpeAeJltJlocb MeToAoM MiLJroyfnoBoro paccevrBaHvfl., oAHaKoBAr.rccepTarlrrH HeTAaHHbrx, noJryr{eHHbrM STrrM MeToAoM.ooHerccbrJrKr4 Haplrcynox 48.Ha pplcyHKe 14 anropetfepara orcyrcrByer JrercHAa3xer0opa c[poeKTupoBaHHoro crrparpnryKfI,{no"rrnop:BMepHoronpr.rMeHeHr.reM qncJreHHoro MoAeJrLtpoBaHufl..Orvreqennsle 3aMer{aHvrr, He cHux€ror n o6rqevr noJroxuTeJnnofi orleHru pa6oru r,r HeBJILIflTOT Ha OCHOBHbTep$ynbTaTbr.finccepraql4oHHat pa6ora orBer{aer rpe6onanurM nyHKTa9 <floloxeHlrr onoprAKenpucytqeHplt yqeHbrx crenenefi>>, yrBep)KAeHHoro flocraHosreHr4eM flpanurelrcrnaPocczftcrofi @e4epaqulr or 24 cemn6ps 2013 roaa itlb842, npeAbrBJrreMbrMcol4cKaHlleK Ar.rcceprarrr4rM Hayvenofi creneHll KaHAuAara HayK, a ee aBTop, 3apanxesu'a Hnsn AH4peenuu,3acny)s4Baer nplrcyx,{eHl4q yqeHofr crenenu KaHAr{Aara rexHr,rqecKrrx HayK no cnerluaJrbHocrr{05.07.05-<<Tenlonue, gneKTpopaKerHhre ABr{rareJr}rugHeproycrarroBK}r JrerareJrbubrxa[[apaToB)).Orcun Ha ArlcceprallploHHyro pa6ory 3apanreeuq Vlxss.

An4peenu.r paccMorpeH vrogo6pen Ha 3aceILarrvrv ceKrlrdr.r (C) HayqHo-rexHr.rqecKoro coBera @KII (HI4U PKII>,IrporoKorr Ns 8or 29 lr'ox6pt.20l7 r.frasHufi uayrurrftcorpyAur,rKA.f. faneenAoKTop rexHr.rqecKuir wayx, npo$eccopCrapnruft uayrHufi corpyAur{KKAHAI,IAAT TEXHI,IqECKI4X HAYKc7*Ja7 .le.. 3.011B.A. Opnonff&rr/-.