Отзыв оппонента (Методика оценки влияния климатических условий и эрозионного износа на характеристики ТРДДФ)

OrsrrnHa Alrccepraurzro A6Aenrsaxr,rAa Moxauue4a Barra, [peAcraBneHHy]ocor4cKaHr4eHay.renofi crerreHlr KaHALrAara rexHr4rrecKr4x HayK rro cneIII{€L[bHocrI405.07.05 Teuronrre, gneKTpopaKerHbreABrrrareJrl4Lr3HeproycraHoBKl4rrerareJrbHbrx anlapaToB.ns6panuofiTeMbr AIdAC,eprarJJIu 3aKrloqaerc,ueo6xo4raMocrr{ pa:pa6orKrr MeroArrKr4 Korr4qecreeHHofi orIeHKpI coBMecrHoroBrrr4fltakrfl.

3po3rroHHoro r43Hoca nporouuofi .tacrv oceBblx KoMnpeccopoBaBr.rauuoHHbrx fTA vr BJraxHocrr{ Bo3,qyxa Ha ktx xapaKTepkrcrr4nr4 klxap axTep ucrt4Kr4 aBr{arlrroHHo ro f TA B rreJroM.ArryaruuocrrHay.{Haq HosrasHa pa6orrr 3aKJrroqaercf, B paspa6orre xoirauercsofrMeroAr{Ku v [porpaMMbr pacr{era [nfl KorHrrecrBeHHor4 oIIeHKH Blrr4fl}{vrfl3po3rroHHoro Lr3Hoca gneMeHToB flporor{Hoit'tactn KoMnpeccopa aBpraurloHHorofTA 14 BJraxHocrr{ aruocSepHoro Bo3Ayxa He roJrbKo Ha xapaKTepvclr4KrKoMrrpeccopa, HoLrHaxapaKTepI{cTI{KH ABHfaTeJL B IIenoM.Ilparru.recraq guaqr.rN{ocm pa6orrr 3aKJrrouaercr BBo3MoxHocrlrr{cfroJrb3oBaHptfl pa:pa6o:raHHbrx B Arrcceprarlr4u MeroAI4KAn, nporHo3l,IpoBaHl4qTexHr{qecKoro cocroqHrl-f, aBr4arlr4oHHbrx Asrararerefi B npouecce I4xsKcrrJryarar\w B 3afrbrJreuuofi lr BJraxHofi aruoc$epe.

Pacuerbr c r4crroJlb3oBaHueMyKa3aHHbrx MeroAr4K Aaror Bo3MoxHocrb pa:pa6athlBarb peKoMeHAar\r4t4 rroMeroAaM TexHur{ecxofi er<cuilyarapti fTA B ycJroBl4qx 3albrJlesHofi u nrtaxnoitaruocSepu. llpornoarapyx Brrvfllrrkre 3arrbrJreHHocrrr v BJraxHocrl4 Bo3Ayxa HaxapaKTepLrcrrrKpr fTA MoxHo 6oree .{ocroBepHo orIeHI{Tb raKTpIKo-TexHHqecKZeBo3MoxHocru aBr4arlr4oHHoro KoMrrJreKca B rlenoM rr ero 6oenyro e$Ser<rueHocrb.Kpoue roro, Bo3MoxHocrb orIeHKr4 creIIeHH 3po3uoHHofo I{3Hoca Jro[aroKKoMnpeccopa aBr{arluoHHoro fTA, pa6orarorqero B ganrrneuuofi aruoc$epe,rro3BoJrfler nupa6orarb peKoMeHAau[H no seo6xo4rauoft qacrore KoHTponf, 3Toror{3Hoca B npoqecce sKcnnyarar1vrv fTA c qenbro npeAorBpalrleHu.f, orKa3oBABr4f aTen fl krrrkr rrpe3 Mep Ho ro yxyAlx ellprfl ef o xap aKTepH QTI4K.TE noJr) {eHHbrx B ilprccepra\r4r4 pe3ynbraroB o6ecueqeua[cnoirb3oBaHr4eM e Hefi r43BecrHbrx r4 xopomo 3apeKoMeHAoBaBIxux ce6s.

MeroAI4KpacqeTa xapaKTepr4crr.lK oceBbrxKoMrpeccopoB pr xapaKTepI4cTI4Kryp6opeaKruBHbrx (TPA@ 14 TPAAO) Anurarerefi B I{enoM. Oua raKxerroATBepxAeHa y.{oBneTBopr4TeJrbHbrM krx cofJlacoBaHrreM c I{3BecTHEIMrr3KCrrepr4MeHTarrbHbIMlI AaHHbrMr4 Lr AaHHbrMr4, IIpHBeAeHHrIMI{ B reXHPr.IeCXofrAoKyMeHT ar\prkr Hccne.qyeMoro TP,.{[O.Creuenr o6ocnoeauuocru Hayr{Hblx noroxeuuff, BbIBoAoB HpeKoMeHAa:qui.t, cSopuynupoBar{Hbrx B AI,IccepraIII4I4, noATBepxAeHayAoBneTBopr4TeJrbHbrM cofJracoBaHpreM pe3yIrbTaToB, froJryr{eHHbrx B ALICcepTarI4H,-""t'':;:['i:ir;l.::--.-|\,L.t- ;-1-0-1===:'15)cI43BecrHbIMI4 sKclepl4MeHT€t[bHbrMr{aBTOpOB.lloz HayqHhrMr4 pe3ynbraraMrr pa6or ApyrrrxMarepI'IaIIaM ALIccepraIII4I4IlMeercr AocrarorlHoe KoJrr4qecrBorlyonplKallvrd u BblcrynJlereuit *ta HayrrHbrx r<ouSepeurla-{x r{ ceMr4Hapax 11o reMepaccMarpranaeuofi Al4ccepraquz.

rlerblpe ra3 yKa3aHHbrx uy6lur< aqufi r{Meere.f,Bv34aHkrax, peKoMeHAoBaHHErx BAK p@.B uepsofr rrasevAHccepraIIHI4 npr4BeAeHbr rrr4cJreHHhre raHHhre oKoHlleHrparJr4kl rrbIJIH n pafiouax Enraxuero Bocroxa u Cesepnofi A$praxu,aTaKxe AaHHbIe rlo prcMeHeHHIo reMrreparyprl H orHocraTeJrbHofi sraxgocrr4 rroMecrIIaM B Pecny6nrar<e Cy4au. 3:ra AaHHbre racrroJrb3oBaHbr aBTopoM trpkrrIpoBeAeHI4I{ pa0rreroB xapaKTepr4crr{K oceBbrx KoMrrpeccopoB kr BbrcorHocKopocrHblx xapaKTepacrl4K ABurareJrt P!33-2C, excnlyarr{pyrcqrrxcf, n erofipecny6lrar<e.3Aecrxe AaH no4po6nrrfio6sop pa6or, rocB{uleHHbrx oueHKe BrHqHaflspo3HoHHoro I43Hoca Ha xapaKTepprcrLrKkr oceBbrx KoMnpeccopoB ra fT! BUeJroM.llg eroro auanuia aBTop Aenaer BhIBoA o6 ocuonHrrx rrocJreAcrBr{.f,x spo3qoHHorou3HOCa, B qacTHocTI4, Ha KOMIIpeCCOp:-cHr4xeHr4eeroxos$SraqpreHTanoJre3Horo geircreur,HanopHocTr{;(KIIDu-yxyArrreHr{e ra3oAuHaMra.{ecxofi ycrofiuuaocrt4;BO3HT4KHOBeHAe yClonufi ycr€urocrHofo pa3pyueHkrf, norraroK.Kpolae roro, 4auustfi alurLr3 tro3BoJrrrJr o[pe.qenuTb xapaKTep H3HocaJIOTIaTOK oceBEIX KOM[peCcopoB KaK fro pailvycy) TaK a nouporouuofiqacrkl.

Ycrauonneuo raKxe, rITo I{HTeHcI4BHocrr H3Hoca Anr4HeJrolaroK oceBblxKoM[peccopoB 3aBprcvrror @u:uuecrux ceoficre rrhrJrr4, oco6eHno orKoHrIeHTpa\HV s Hefi qacrr,rq KBaprIa.B srofi rre rJIaBe BbIrIonHeH TaKxe o6sop pa6or, uocB-f,[IeHHbrx aH€urLr3yBlrt4fr}rl4fl BIaXHOCTI4 BO3AyXa Ha ocHoBHbre napaMerpbr KoMlpeccopav ABr{rareuB uenoM. Yctanorneno, rITo 3Haql,rrerbHoe [oBbllrreHr4e BJraxHocrr{ Bo3AyxaTIpLIBOAI{T K CHI{XeHI.{IO TqfI4 14 froBbrlueH}rro yAenbHofo pacxoAaToIIIHB a HaHecKonEKo rrporleHToB. llpuueu, 3TO CBq3aHO, B OCHOBHOM, C yxyArrreHl{eMnapaMerpoB KoMrrpeccopa.B saKrrotleHl're erofi rJraBbI c$opnrynupoBaHa crpyKTypa MeToAr4Kr4 y{eracoBMecTHOfO BrruflHl,,.fl 3afrbrJreHHocTr4 BO3AyXaxapaKrepvc'rrKr oceBoro KoMrpecc opa u TPAA@.CfOBJIAXHOCTI4HABropaq rraea ,,ocB{.ueHa }IccneAoBaHr.rro Brrkrfl.,,rfl gpo3,oHHoro r43Ho ca HaxapaKTeprrcrlIKl4 oceBoro KoMrlpeccopa.

OnrcblBaerc{ err6paHnaxAnf, pacrreraxapaKrepr{crr4K oceBoro KoMrrpeccopa rporpaMMa (nporparrauuufi npogyxr)Numeca, B Koropofi pea-rru:oBaHo perxeHpre cucreMbr ypaBHeHHfi Hasre-Cron.qocpe4Hdnurx ro Pefiuonrgcy. Ourzcrrsarcrcs oco6eHnocru nocrpoeHr4,pacqerHofi cerxu An, onucaHt4fl reoMerpr4r4 BeHr-{oB r{ rroBepxuocrefi oceBoroKoMrpeccopa.

Brr6paHa MoAenb ryp6yneurHofiB-g3KOCTr4.B oroilrJraBe rlpeAcraBJreHbr nprrMepbr pacr{era xapaKTepr4crr,rK oceBofivt KoMnpeccopa Hrz3Koro ,4aBneHuq ABuraren{ Pil33-2C ccryneHr{ C-16noMoulblo [polpaMMbl Numeca, rroKa3aBrur4ecofJracoBaHr{e c 3Kcrrepr4MeHTatrbHbrMr4 AaHHbrMr,r.xey.qoBnerBopr{TenbHoeKnpeAnoxeH uonrrfi rroAxoAMoAenr4poBaHuro xapaKTepaI,I3MeHeHH, reoMerprlqecKl{x napaMerpon npo$unefi rouaroK nocJre 3po3r4oHHoro[3Hoca. ZcnonrsoBaHlae SToro [oAxoAa rro3BoJrr{Jro paccqurarb xapaKTepr4crr4Kr,rcryneHu C-16, KHA Lt KBA PIJ33-2C npa :rra:luqvtkt pa:nuvuofi crerreHr4opo3l4oHHoro I43Hoca ee JlorraroK.

Pe:ymrarrr 3Tr,rx pacqeroB rroKa3aJrr{orpl4llaTeJrbHoe BrI4qHHe Spo3I4OHHO|O r43HOCa HA CTefreHb noBbrrrreHLfl traB[re]F^prs(zr**) u roe0@uqLreHr noJre3Horo geircrnut (r-*) cryreHr{ u KacKaAoBKOMrrpeccopa.3AecsIIlpe4craeJleHo raKxe nonyr{eHHoe pacqeroM r43MeHeHVe napaMerpoB rropaluycy I4 flo AnHHe nporoqHoir \acru cryneHr{ C-16 r4 KacKaAoB KoMrrpeccopaPA33-2C, a raKxe rorq pacnpeAetenuir quceJr Maxa H cKopocrefi Ha pa3nr4r{Hbrxpatrkrycax norlarot{Hblx BeHIIoB H KacKaAoB KoMnpeccopa 6es sposraoHHoro r43Hoca14 c r,rsHoioN{.

Auarra: orr,rx pe3ynbraroB rroKil3iur, r{To epo:uoHurrfi r43HocnpI4BoAI4T K cHI4xeHI4Io zt** H rl** cryleHrr H KoMnpeccopa. Ilpr,rueu ocHoBHoeoTplluaTeJlbHoe BJIH{HI4e Ha 3Tr4 napaMeTpbr oK€L3brBaer yBenr4rreHrre paAr4iurbHofo3a3opa rr ero Sopua.B rnase 3 paccMorpeHo BJIt4rHr4e BJraxHocrr{ Bo3Ayxa Ha xapaKTeprrcrr4Kr4KHA u KBI ABl{rarent P[33-2C. B pe3ynbrare pacqeroB ycraHoBJreHo, r{rogyBenl4qeHl{e BJraxHocrH Bo3Ayxa HanopHbre Kpr{Bbre Ha xapaKTepr,rcrHKaxyKa3aHHbIx KacKaAoB cMeularorc{ B cropoHy yMeHbrxeHr4r orHocr4TelrsofrnJrorHocrH roKa Ha BxoAe B KoMnpeccop tq(h)] 14 [**.

I4sNaeHeHrae In*KoMrlpeccopa rrpu I43MeHeHHr{ rpHBeAeHHbrx o6opo'ron (nnr) ueoAHo3HarrHo: npr4HeKOTOpbIX 3HalIeHI4flX nnp OH yBenr{qr{BaeTcf,, a frpv HeKoTopbrx- yMeHb[raeTcq.Pac'reraNala raKxe ycraHoBJIeHo, r{To H3MeHeHI4e noJroxeHr4, fpaHI4IIbIycrofiuraeofi pa6omr KoMnpeccopa npu yBenurreHr4r4 BrraxHocrr4 Bo3AyxanpaKTr4qecKH He npor4cxoAzT.Cne4yer orMerI4T6, rrro B pa6ore He o6rscn-flerc-f, rrpr4-uar:ea raKorou3MeHeHI4-s IlapaMerpoB KacKaAoB KOM[peCCOpa npH pr3MeHeHr{r4 BJraxHocrHBO3Ayxa.filasa 4 [ocBqilIeHa pa^:pa6orKe MeroEwKu pacr{era BbrcorHo-cKopocrHbrxxapaKrepl4crrIK (BCX) TPtrAO c yr{eroM BJraxHocru Bo3Ayxa r4 opo3r4oHHoroI43Hoca JlolaroK KoMflpeccopa. C grofi rleJrbro B rJraBe r43JroxeHa MeroAr,rKaonpe'4eneHH{ xapaKrepr{crr4K fa3ofeHeparopa (ff), rapaMerpoB ryp6uurr,pexl4Ma pa6omr ryp6oxollrpeccopHoro MoAynx (TKM) u napauerpoB ABrrraren-fl.B e'rofi MeroAI4Ke yr{I4TblBaercfl BrrkrflHr4e BJraxHocru aruocsepHoro Bo3Ayxa Haero Sra:raqecKl{e cnofic:rea u Ha cnoficrsa cMecu Bo3Ayxa u npoAyKToB cropaHr4rTOrrJrr4Ba B KaXAOM XapaKTepHOM CerleHr4r4 ABr4fTTeilfl.Cleayer orMerhrb, r{To [ptl onrrcaHrrrr \rero.]IIKII onpe.{e.;reHufl pexl4Mapa6orrr TKM Ha crp.116 ucnonb3)-ercq roH.f,ruIe (( ...npu6luxeHHafl pa6ouaxrrr4Ht4s, KHI ...)), Ho He orracblBaeTcr, KaK oHa o[pe.{eneHa.

Kpoue roro, rrpupa:pa6orKe MeroAI4KI4 orlpeAeneHl4, BCX ABurarenq npuHf,r pqA ylporualoquxAonyrueHgfi. Xorq Bo3HHKarouIar npu fipnlflrpru Kax.qoro Aony[]eHras ouru6r<aoqeueHa, Ho cyMMapHoe I4x BJII4flHr4e Ha KoHequufi peayJlbTaT He qcHo.npoBeAeHa orIeHKa crerreHla coorBercrBl4{ pe3ynbraroBpacr{era BCX c noMotrlEro pa:pa6orannofi B Arrccepralll4l4 MeroAr'IKHlacroprHbrM AaHHbrM ABurarenx P[33-2C.

OHa noxasana yAoBnerBopprreJlbHoecorJracoBaH[e pacr{erHbrx vr nacloprHblx AaHHbIx. Ilocle yr<a:aunofi oIIeHKH61;t:rw rrpoBeAeHbr pacqerrr BCX ABurarenxP[33-2C n ycnoBuflx BJIaxHocrpI I43a[brJeHHocri4 Bo3Ayxa B [varra3oHe 3Haqeuuit, ero reMrreparyprl, xapaKTepHblx.{:r_f, Pecnyltuxu Cygall. Pac.{errt [oKa3€LIII4, iITo KaK HanI4r{He BnaxHocru, TaK I{3a[br-rreHHocru aruoc$epHoro Bo3Ayxa [pI4BoAIaT K cHl4xeHr4w rflir4 ilBntarelrfl vrgro cHJIbHo nporBJlrercr),BeJuqeHr{ro yAenbHoro pacxoAa rorrJlrrBa.