Отзыв оппонента 1 (Методика оценки влияния климатических условий и эрозионного износа на характеристики ТРДДФ)

OT3bIBo+uquarbHoro o[rloHeHTatKaHAITAaTa rexHllqecKrrx HayKBosra Muxaula lOPrenuvaHa Arrcceprarlr4oHHyro pa6ory A6AenrsaxuAa MoxauueAaoueHKI4 Brrulr:a:,z:fl. KrzMarl4rlecKllxxapaKrepvrcrLrKkrTPAAO),sneKTpopaKeTHbre ABr4raTerrurlo<Mero4uxaycronufi v 3po3uoHHoro I,l3Hoca HanpeAcraBneHHyroKaHAr{Aara rexH}rqecKrrx HayKEallaHacoI4cKaHI4e yueHofi creIIeHrIoneqllaJlbHocrl405.07.05<<Teulonue,kt 3HepIoycTaHoBKH JIeTaTeJIbHbIX annapaToB))Aucceprarluonsufi coBer [212.125.08 npLI MocxoncrouBaBr{auLIoHHoMHHcTI,Iryre (uaqzouaJlbuoM LlccJIeAoBaTeJIbcKoM yHl{Bepcz'rere).Pa:pa6orr<a MeroAr{K[ilflonpeAeneHLIfl TexHl4rlecKoro oocroflHHrv efo 3Kc[nyaTaI{LloHHbIX XapaKTepI4cTI{K .flBJI.rIeTC.rIsaxHofi 14 axryalruofi saAaqefr.

Oco6enno gro aKTyanbHo c ror{Kl4 3peHrlf,aBr4ar\vo]FlHofo ABr{faTelqgKg1rJryaTarryrr4 ABr{raTerrf,rro ero rexHl4qecKoMy cocToflHl4ro.coBpeMeHHbrx MeToAOB pactreTa, ocHoBaHHbIXHAIzIcnoDsoBaHI4eMaTeMaTVqecKoMMoAenr4poBatyrkr, rlo3BoJlfler coKparl,ITb BpeMeHHr,Ie ra SuuancoBble 3arparbl HarrpoBeAeHI,Ie 3KcnepI{MeHTaJIbHbIx uconeAoBa:auit.Tar<xe,KarrecrBeHHbleMATCMATIIIIECKUC METOAbI IIO3BOJIf,}OT NPO|HO3HPOBATb TCXHI4I{EOKOE COCTOf,HI4EABrlrarenq.

Pa6ora ASAenrBaxvAa MoxauueAaupo6neneEallanocBflueHa aKTyanr,sofinpu 3KcnnyararryrvorIeHKe ocHoBHbrx napaMerpoB nBl4rare:rxBoJIOXHbIX KrI4MarI4r{eCKI4X yCnOB}Ifl X'Hecuorpfl, Ha 6onguofi o6neu nonyqeHHblx AaHHbIx IIo sKcIIJIyaraWV4nurarelefi, BHacro-fl111ee BpeMqorcyrcrByror pa6orn rIocBrIrIeHHbIeorIeHKeB3aHMHoro Brr{.sHu{ pa3nr4qHsrx QaxropoB Ha xapaKTept4crktKpr y3noB I{ ocHoBHbIxnapaMerpoB ABHrarenf,.

Iloeronry aBTop nocBflTrrJI aBoro AHccepraUl4oHllylopa6ory paspa6orKe MeroAr{Kr4 orIeHKr4 B3aI4MHoroBlrvrflHr4fl,spo3rroHHoro I'I3Hoca 14BJlaxHocru aruocQepHoro Bo3Ayxa Ha xapaKrepl{crlzKl4 TPAA@.oErul{u 0TAE,n MAI{bx.t\la.--".--,AA,.-of206,,,{rzccepraqux cocrol,ITnr,rreparypbrr43v3BBeAeHlIfl, TrflT:a rJIaB, BbIBoIoB, crIHcKa95 naulrenoeanufi u 2 npwroxeuufi. O5Ir1ufi oSnevr Al4ccepraqlrl4175 crpaHraq.Bo sne.ueHuu o6ocHosaHac$opnrynupoBaHbr rlenbvaKTyanbHocrb reMbr Ar4cceprarluouuofi pa6orrt,3aaa.ulr, HccneAoBanr4fl,3Hairr{Mocrb pa6orrr, MeroAbr rrccJreAoBaHrfl3arrlr4Ty, avorpaxeHbl HayrlHaf,HoBI,I3Ha,froJloxeHraq, BbrHocI4MbIe HaraKxe anpo6aqrzx pa6omr.B uepnofi ruane paccMarplrBarorc.f, oco6eHuocrrr 3KcrlJryara\Lrkt fTAKruMarurrecKr{x ycnoBr{flx.HaB cJroxHblxocHoBe BbrrroJrHeHHoro o6:opa nlrreparypbl notaccnetroBaHlrro Blrkrfl:a:afl gpo3r4oHHoro r43r{ocaBo3Ayxa Ha xapaKTepr4crr4Krr KoMnpeccopafTAkr BrlaxHocrrra'rnaoc$epHofoyaraHoBneua ueo6xoAllMocrl,paspa6orKl4 HoBbrx qacrHbrx MeroAHK yrrera BrruflHr4s.

3po3lroHHoro H3Hoca vBJraxHocTr4 Bo3Ayxa Ha xapaKTepvcrkrK[ KoMllpeccopa,MeroIHK orIeHKHBrruflHr4fl. grr4xa raKxe KoMIIJIeKcHbIxSaxropon Ha gKcrrnyararlt,roHuble xapaKTepI4crI4KI4.qBI4raTeJIf,.Bo eropofi rraeeKoMrrpeccopoBcnpeAcraBJreHa MeroAlrKa pacqera xapaKTepI,IcrI4K oceBbIXnprrMeHeHr4eM coBpeMeHHbrx MeToAoB pacr{eTa TpexMepHoroTerreHr4-fl B JrorrarorrHbrx Marur{Hax(CFD-xoa). Ilponoaprrcfl. oueHKa aAeKBarHocrrrpe3ynbraroB pacqera xapaKTepr4crrrK oaeBbrx KoMrlpeccopoB.B ruane npoBe.(eHaHAIILI3 SKCnepLIMeHTaJIbHOTO I4CCIeAOBaHI4{ I43MeHeHI4-f, reOMeTpI4II noIIaTOK Bpe3ynbrare 3po3r4oHHoro r.r3Hoca.

Anropou r{3JroxeHa pa:pa6orannafl, MeroAI'IKaSopuupoBaHnfl. upo@ranefi JroraroKrro pe3ynbraraMI43MepeHHf, reoMerpl4l4rro[aroK. Ilpe4crawreHbr pe3yrrbrarbr 3-D pacrrera BIrvrflHLrfl nocle4crrilffopo3r4oHHoro rr3Hoc a Ha xap aKTepI4crHKH KacKaAoB KoMrpec copa TPAAO.B rperrefi rrtase H3JroxeHbr reoperr4rrecKr4er4MeroAr,IqecKne ocHoBbI yr{eraBrrvfrHvrfl BJraxHocrr4 Bo3Ayxa Ha csoficrna paSor{ero reJla I4 xapaKTeprrcruKl4KoMrrpeccopa (npra KoHKperHbrx 3HarreHurx orHocl4Telruofr BJIaxHoarl4 vreMrreparypbr arMocdlepuoro no:4yxa). llpegcranJreHbr pe3ynr,raru 3-D pacrreraBlrr4ruvtfr BnarocoAepxaHr4, Ha xapaKrepr,rcrr4Klr KacKa.qoB KoMnpeccopaB .Iereeprofi rrase H3JroxeHbr ocHoBbr pa:pa6orassofiTPf[@.MeroArrKH pacr{eraBblcorHo-cKopocrHbrx xapaKrepucrrrK TPAA@ (ua upunaepe ABr4rarenx P[33-2C)Anfl oIlpeAeneHr4, 3KcnnyaTarlzoHHbrx xapaKTepr{cTr,rK ABr4faTeJrfl trpt4 3aAaHHbrx3HarreHrr-flx BJlarocoAepxaHa-s Bo3Ayxa.fauuax MeroArrKa rro3BoJrfer onpeAeJrr{TbnapaMerpbl ABr4rarenfl Ha MaKcr{MaJrbHoM Lr SopcaNuovr pexr4Maxc yrreroMBlrLrflHr4fr BIaXHOCTT4 BO3AyXa Ir SpO3HOHHO|O rr3HOCa irOrraTOK KOMrrpeACOpa.B n.srofi rraee npeAcraBJreHbr oSulrae cBeAeHr{, o ABurarene P[33-2C, pacuerHbrenapaMerprt u oco6eHHocrrr ero nporpaMMbr perynupoBaHrr{.

Ilpone4eua oqeHKaaAeKBaTHOCTI{ pe3yrrbTaT0BpacrreTa BbrcoTHo-cKopocTHbrx xapaKTep14cTHKABl4raren, PA33-2C, roJIyrIeHHbIXcnoMolrlbro paspa6orauriofi rporpaMMblpacrrera. Ilprzno4xrcx pe3ynbrarbr r{HcJreHHoror4ccrreAoBaHnfl. Brrkrfl:evrfrv BJraxHocrr4 Bo3Ayxa Haxap aKrep ?rcr u:r.Lr ABr4raren t P [3 3 -2CSpo3r,roHHoro H3HocaBbrcorHo-cKopocTHbre.B ga4lroqeHrae pa6orrr [peAcraBJreHbrocHoBHbre pe3ynbrarbr pr BbrBo4br rlo[poBeAeHHoMy .4r{ccepTarlrroHHoMy Hccne.{oBaHr,rro.Hayuuax HoBr{3Ha paSomr 3aKJrroqaerc, B paspa6oraHHblx MeroArlKaxpacrlera fa3oAr4HaMr,rr{eQKr4x xapaKTep[crprK oceBblx KoMrrpecaopoB H BblcorHooKopocrHbrx xapaKTeprrcrrrK TPAAO c yr{eroM spo3rroHHoro r,r3Hoca 14 BrlaxHocrl4Bo3Ayxa.flocronepHocrbrao6ocnoBaHHocrb nonyrreHHbrx B Aucceprarlur,r pe3yJlbraroB[oATBepx4aeTcfl, HcrroJrb3oBaHHeM rrrLrpoKo npr4MeHseMblx MeToAoB pacr{eTare.IeHufi B Jloflaror{Hbrx MaIrIHHax v MareMarl4r{ecKoroMoAenupoBa:nkrfl.

pa6ouero npoqecca TPAAO, a raKxe repu$uxaqueitTpexMepHbIX[onyqeHHbrx pe3ynbraroB c 3KcnepI4MeHT€uIbHbIMI4 .4aHHbIMrr.Ouy6nzxoBaHHbrel\lacceprar\uu. Pa6oraMexAyHapoAHbrxpa6oru locrarorrHo orpaxaloranpoSrzpoBaHaHaocHoBHoe coAepx(aHHeHayrrHo-TexHI4r{eoKI4xLt Bcepocctrficxzx xoH$epeurlu-f,x. IIoreMeouy6rur<oBaHbr ABeHaArIarb pa6or:, kr3 Koropbrx r{err,rpe crarbr{ceMr4Hapax,AVCCepraqr4HBHayrIHbIXv34aHnflx, peKoMeHAoBaHHbrx BAK P@.Co4epxauueanrope$epara coorBercrByer ocHoBHbrMrroJroxeHr4-flMA14CCepTarIHA.3ame.raHrrfl rro pa6ore:HeoSxolr{Mo orMerr4Tb prA 3aMerrauuit uo pa6ore:1.B pa6ore orcyrcrByer aHaJrr{3 (4axe oqenouurrfi)MexaHrr3MoBo6pa:onaHuf, 3po3uu.

He paccMorpeH Borrpoc: roqeMy Ha nouarr<ax FIAHea pa6ovue Koneca [oABepxeHbr raKoMy3Har{HTerbHoMy rasnocy? Kpoue roto, ro pe3ynbraraM 3Kcnnyarapr3po3u.f,Bo3HrrKaer,ABllrarenefi e sanruensofi ar:lloc0epe, Br4AHo, r{To u3Hoc JrorraroK pa6oul.rx$op*y. BosuoxHo, rrro a:aarrv3aBTopy :aaitru perxeHrre lnfl cHr4xeHr4rKoJIec r,rMeer .rrpKo BbrpaxeHHyroMexaHH3Ma opo3rrr4 rro3Borrrrr3po3r4r{.2. AnropnpaKTI{rIecKH He yAenfler BHr4MaHr4.rr MeroAZKe rpexMepHoro pacrreraB reKere [pr.rBeAeHa roJrbKo KoHcrararlr,rf, Sarra, r{Topacr{er BeAercfl c r4crroJrb3oBaHr{eM MoAeJrr4 ryp6yneHTHocrr4 SpalartAllmaras, [pr{BeAeHo KoJrr4qecrBo -f,rreeK B cerKe.

flanee [prrBoA-rrrc.f,pe3ynbrarbr pacr{era Lr cpaBHeHHe c gKCrrepr4MeHToM. floryueuur,repacxoxAeHu.r{ aBTop crrr4Taer Aorrycrr4MbrMrr, Ho Bo3Moxr-ro eu6opKoM[peccopoB.ceroqHofr MoAeJIIT 14 MoAenrr ryp6ynenrHocrr{ rro3Bolr?rrcxoAl4Mocrb pacrreroBr4DKcrreprrMeHTa. Kaxraronoft,froBbrcrzTba:aarrut3 rrocraHoBKr{rpaHurrHbrfi ycronufi ua pacuer orcyrcrByer.3.flpe4craBrreHHaqMMTP,{.{<DoM f,BJlflerc.s MoAenbro lrreparlr4oHHoro 'rkrrra.Hauucaga oHa, AocrarorrHo ynporqeHo,cr4crroJrb3oBaHr4eMqenoro pstra4AonyqeHr4fi.

Vpoeeus, paspa6oraunofi MoAeJII{, rlo3BoJlrer irpoBoAl4rbToJrr,Ko KaqecrBesuufi aHaJrr,r3. Konra.{ecrneuuufi a:e.alwt3 neoSxoAlarrtoBecrl4 ToJIbKo Ha MM 6olee BblcoKoro ypoBH.aupopa6orr<ra.CrtelosareJlbHo pe3ynbTaTbl pacrleToB, tlo paspa6orassofiMM, HeJIb3.rIpaccMaTpr{BaTbKaKr,rcTorrHr4K trpvrHflTkrfpelxeHl4forlpeKparueHIj'l43KcnnyaTarJ[vr ABr{fareJr.rr B pe3ynbTaTe yxy,4lxeHl{, ero xapaKTeprlcrr{K.Tarxe MoxHo orMerr,rrbpaSorrrvr4 Apyrr4e 3aMeqaHl4.fl, Kacarouuec, o$oplnlneuuaarvlrfl. H3iloxeHrlq, Ho He cMorpfl. Ha loalrtrque 3aMeqauuil H HeAocrarKoBocraerc, [onoxrlTeJlbHoeMHeHI{e o Al4ccepraqlzounoff pa6ore.Baua .f,BJlrercfl saKoH'IeuHofrorBerlaer rpeSonanuru BAK PO,,{uccepraqras A6aenbBaxr{Aa MoxanMeAarnalusuraquonsofi pa6orofi unpeAbqBnfeMbrMK KaHAr4.{aTcKr{MArrCCepTaIII{flM,a ee aBTop 3acnyxHBaeTnpr4cyxAeHvrfl.

y.reHofi crerreHlr KaHAr{Aara rexHl4tlecKr{x HayKno cnequaJlbHocrl4v3HeproycraHoBKl{05.07.05<<Tenrtonrre, 3JreKrpopaKerHbre ABrrrareJlr{JrerareJrbHbrx anflaparoB)).OSuqraanrsrtfi orlroHeHr,Bonx129301, r. MocxBa, yil. KacarruHa, 13.Ter.: +7(499) 7550593e-mail : mihail.vovk@okb.umpo.ruIloAuncr Bonra M.IO. 3aBepr-fr salaecrlaTeJlb reHgp?JlbHorrruaeHrrfi KoHcrpyKropOKB uwr. A.JkorIbKI4,1$wxuara OAO(YM[IO)Krzprcxran B.B..