Отзыв на автореферат 7 (Методика оценки влияния климатических условий и эрозионного износа на характеристики ТРДДФ)
Описание файла
Файл "Отзыв на автореферат 7" внутри архива находится в папке "Методика оценки влияния климатических условий и эрозионного износа на характеристики ТРДДФ". PDF-файл из архива "Методика оценки влияния климатических условий и эрозионного износа на характеристики ТРДДФ", который расположен в категории "". Всё это находится в предмете "технические науки" из Аспирантура и докторантура, которые можно найти в файловом архиве МАИ. Не смотря на прямую связь этого архива с МАИ, его также можно найти и в других разделах. , а ещё этот архив представляет собой кандидатскую диссертацию, поэтому ещё представлен в разделе всех диссертаций на соискание учёной степени кандидата технических наук.
Просмотр PDF-файла онлайн
Текст из PDF
VTBEPXAAIO:HaYuurrft PYKoBoA?IreJIb 3aMecrl4Telr f enep aJlbHoro*\ dI4AM-*,,@Q[IIrau.II'I4'AI4peKTop aEapaHona>>rexnvqecKl'Ix HaYKv'A? ,-"'/)-/** "O.I4. Jlanuus,rpenf, 2015r'OTsnrr-H a aBr op e Q ep ar,u"oranurr"ALIo c epr aIIwt' A6yueuofi creleHr{E alr attbBaxv;La Moxavtll eAa^erexHI'IqecKLIx HayKKaHAI{AaraABI4TATEJIrInocneqllaJlbHocTl405.07.05_<<TeuloBble,SJIeKTpopaKeTHbIeJIeTaTerIbHbrx all[ap aToB)>u sHeproycTaHoBKl4M[uccepraq?IoHHaflpa6oraA6AerrrsaxuAaMoxaMMeAaEa.lrrraflocBf,uleHasp oauoHHoro ,n3Ho caoBaHr4ro Brrvr'"vrf' rro c JreAcreufiareMarrrrre cKoMy Mo Aenr4pHa rlapaMerpblqacru lr BJraxHocr]r aruocsepHofo BO3Ayxaflpororftrofi3JT.M.HTOBB IIeJIOM', a TaKXe pa3pa6orr<eLI xapaKrepl{cr}IKll TPAA@KoM[peccopoBoceBbrxMeroAI{K OIIeHKI4 STOro Blrr4flIlklfl"KluN{arffiecKl4eoco6ennocTl4peIUOHOB(rervrneparypa',AaBneHvTevrBJlaxCOCTOfllg:VTfl' aTMOoca4rcu) I'I Apyrl4e oco6ensocTllBO3Ayxa,HOCTb arrvrocsepHorooKa3brBaror 3HaqI4Harpy3Kr{, rrecrraHbre 6ypu)BerpoBbre(sauruenHocrb,csepHUXSAXrT[ ,n COOTBETCTBI.Eoposraonn'fi usHoc 3JIeMeHToBAB}IAIIUOHUTTXTEJI'HOE BTTKIfl,"*EHA 3KCIJIYATAIII4IOrroKa3areJrf,M.Tr.rrecKrrx pecypcoB rpe6ye^a'^,r(nanpu3afIbIJIeHHOCTbIo BO3Ayxauoe'uennofiBbI3BaHHbIfilpoTorrHo it uacru,KJII4MaTanyaTawrfl B ycnoBl'I{x TpoIII4qecKoIosxcnpafiouax),Mep, B rrycTbrHH'XcyuIecTBeHHO CKa3bIvtBJIaxHocTb BO3Ayxa) necruapaTeMlepaTy(uonHueHHbrerloKa3aI{x HaAexHocrI'I II pecypcHbrxrr[,aBrraq[oHnrxrrapaMerpaxBarorcfl HaIIpI4MeHeHlIfl JIeTaTeJIbHbIxqa'THOCTLI, CBlIAeTenbcTByeT OII'ITBsrou,o6TeJrflx;(BrerB p{Ae BoeHHbIx r<ousnramonABI4TaTeJL',IMI4a[[apaToB C ra3oTyp6uunHvtl4nal,r, AsraHI{CTaHHAM,rAlp')'AJIfl oIreHKIfl Btrr4flH.vrfl'grr,rM paspa6orKa coBpeMeHHbIx MeroAr{KaTMoCsepuoroI43HOCa I{ BJIaxHocTI{(epo:uouHoro^;3KcrrJryaTarlrroHHblx Qaxropon ^.oMrrp, T-TIT R rIeJIoMaKrep r4cruKr.
rTA B rre,roMe cc op oB,r xapHaytrHo-rrnfi HavtrHoarrya*nofiB csssu c,*#;';;;ill'ts Aatr.,.,Nr vrLJo'?##'ffiru";;HecoMHeHHo, f,Br',IercnHO^ ^6r,yr^^r/r ra qriArrwMocTb.3Har{I'IMocrb, Ho-rTeoperl,rqecKyloutrlerorqerz He ToJIbKoTpAAo),TexHl{qecrofi saAa'reir,LIHaIIpaBJIeHHOCTb'BbrpaxeHHylo flpaKTl',IqecKyroOETIII{H OTAEJI MAHIlpra peueHuv rrocraBJreHHbrx 3a4av ilvccepraHToM I{crroJIb3oBaHbI coBpeMeHHbre MeroAbr, BKrroqa, pacqerbr 3D re.reHufi e JlolraroqHblx MaluuHax, ocHoBaHHbre Ha perueHnvr ypaB:aerruit Hanre-CroKca, ocpeAHeHHbIx no PefinonrAcy.
Kcox€ureHr4o, B anrope$epare, no-Br{.{LIMoMy, LI3-3a orpaHl{\eLrufi, o6rerrta He orpaxeHbl MeToALIqecKue IIOAxoAbI, IIpI4MeHeHHbIe An.fl )^leTa B agpOALIHaMI4rIecKIIxp acqeTax KoMrrp e c c op oB BrruflIJvrfl Berr{qlr H p aI'vrurblJblx 3 a3opoB, I{3M eHqIOIIIUXCflBCJTeACTBHe SpO3r,IOHHOrO r43HOCa, rITO BeCbMaBaXHO Anfl OIIeHKI{ aAeKBaTHOCTH[onyqeHHbrx pe3ynbTaToB c yqeroM TeMarr4Kr.r 4auHofi.qvccepTaquouuofi pa6orbl.K AocrozHcTBaM pa6oTbl cneAyeT orHecTH To, qTo AlaccepTaHT rlpoBenOIIeHKy BIIyrflHYIfl. 3po3I{OHHOro I{3HOca Ha xapaKTepI,lCTHKLI KOMlpeCcopOB HeToJrbKo ((no coBoKyrrHocru $ar<ropon>, Ho oIIeHHJI Blrvfl:aue KaxAoro Qarropa noTAenbHocTr4, qTo rrpHBeno K rronr{eHuro HeTpI{B}IaJIbHbIX pe3ynbTaToB.flpe4craur.,rror 6esycnonnrrfi znrepec pe3ynbrarbl pacqeroB BCX TPAtr@PA-33-2C c f{eroM Brrr4flHkrfl, spo3r{oHHoro r43Hoca pa6oul{x JIorIaroK KacKaAoBKoMrrpeccopav rroBbrrueHnofi eraNHocrlrt arrraoc$epHoro Bo3Ayxa.
Ilorasano rolr{qecrBeHHoe Brr?rfl:nzre H3Hoca Ha pexl4Max MaKcI{MEUIrHoM I{ rIoJIHoro SopcaNaHa T{fy ABHfaTeJrfl. vr 3arracbl fEBoAr{HaMr{rlecrota ycroI4lII4BOCTI{ KaCKaAOB KOMrpeccopa (oco6ennoe 3Harrr{reJrbHoe 4nx AK, KBD. HeoxuAaHHbIM oKa3€ulc.aBbrBoA o ToM, qTo, cofJracHo pe3yJrbTaTaM pacqeToB, ((B AaHHOM CJIyqae BJIHflHI4e3pO3HOHHOTO H3HOCAHa yBenZqeHIIe yAeJIbHOTO pacxoAa TOIJILIBa He3HalII'ITeJIb-Ho); xitjlb, rITo n anropeSepare He AaHo o6r.scHeHl4-f, AaHHovry Sarcry.IIpn pacuere BJIU-f,HHfl BJIaxHocrI4 HA ocHoBHbre rapaMerpu TP[,{@ uaMaKCr4M€uIbHOM pexr{Me, K COxtaIIeHHIO, HE EccJIeAoBaHo Bo3Aeficrsue Ha 3ToBrrurfllakrenrr6opa 3aKoHa ynpaBneHr4fl, ABr4tareneM; KaKorleneHrar,r 300[U4AMrIoKa3€LrII4 rIpoBeAeHHbIe BvccneAoBa:avrfl.
rrpLIMeHHrerIbHox TP[[Tutra[C-90A,nrr6op 3aKoHa yrrpaBneHurfl. B 3Haqr,rreJmrofi crerIeHI,I olpeAenrer crerreHb BIrLrflHr{f, BJraxHocTrr Bo3Ayxa Ha rlapaMeTpbl ABI{faTeJI.fl..{raccepraHT pa3yMHo coqeraer pacqerrr BCX c noMoIIIbIo tIoJIHofi uareuaru.recrofi MoAeJru, B Koropofi, e uacrHocrr{, yquTblBaerc.rl I43MeHeHI{e repMoAI{HaMuqecKr,rxynpouIeHHbIxcsoftcrB pa6oqero reJra rro rpaKTy ABI,IrareIrfl, ca1;aJlqrTlz.uecKI4x3aBI4clrMo ctefipa6ouux pexlrMoB Ha xapaKrepncrlrKe KBA.ucrloJrb3oBaHpleM, o III{cbIBaro nlux n onoxeHlle ruuuilHecnaorp fl. Ha rloJloxuTenbHyro B IIenoM oIIeHKy anropeSepara Aklccepra-qvn A6.qeJIbBaxI4Aa M.8., Heo6xoAI.,IMo cAeJlarb HeKoropble 3aMeq alevrfl:1. B rerccre aBTopeQepara He oqeHb qerKo o6osna.IeHo Mecro 4annofi pa6orrr cpeAu pa6or aHaJroruquofi nanpaBJreHHocru: He rIoK€BaHo, B qeM Al4ccepTaHTBy^AVTTHeAOCTaTKU Vrrvr He3aBepUeHHOCTb paHee BbIIIOJIHeHHbIXpa6Or, B KO-Topbrx paccMarpvrBankrcb aHalorr{rrnue upo6JreMbl, qeM npI{HIII4[I{aJIbHo orrrl4ua-s AaHHofi pa6ore.
Yra:ano JI}IIrII, uro B uepnoftc o orBercrByloilIlae o 6:op u.rcTc.f, MeroAr{Kra, rrpeAJroxeHHbrerJraBe Ar,rc c epraIILII{ Bblrro JrHeHbI2. Orl,re.{eHo, rrro nepu6zra\Lrfl, pe3ynbraroB pacqeroB xapaKTepucrl4KnrrpoBaHHoficrynenz C-16 nI43o-KHI TPAAOHeHHeM rrporpaMMHoro KoMrrJreKcaP[-33-2C, BbIrIoJrHeHHbrx c npl4MeNUMECA Fine/Turbo (r.e. couocraBJleHl4e LIxc pe3yJrbraraMuucrrctta:aufi) rroKa3iura y,qoBnerBoplaTenbHylo cxoAl{Mocrb cocpe4nefi [olperxHocrbro I-3 % Bo BceM Al4ana3oHe rlacror BpaIrIeHurI. I-{enecoo6auQ$epeHrlr4poBarb 3ry KoJrr4qecrBeHHyro oIIeHKy ArItr KoHKperHbIx [apaMerpoB: 6esycnonHo, ,qJr.f, fi**, Gnp, I**, AK, oHa Aonxua 6urr pa3nv.t'-pa3Ho6ruo 6unofi.3.
Eruro 6rr xelareJrbHo, .rro6H Ar4ccepraHT yAenLIr 6otrure BHI4MaHI4r busz.recKofi cropoHe orrkrcaHtrs. Toro, rroqeMy B pacqerax [pLIH.gro orIpeAeJIeHHoeH3MeHeHr{e upo$unefi loraroK rrpr{ opo3I4oHHoM H3Hoce flpu vtroroo6pa3nvr perurbHbrxronszrypa\uit[r3HorrreHHbrx Jror]aror<.JraH Ha @oprvransno-MareMarr{rrecKoMB anropeQepare xeaKIIeHT cAe-rlpeAcraBlre:rt:avr Ia3MeHeHI4x upoQranefi.Vrasauo, r{ro An.f, TPAA@ P[-33-2C (3aKoHoMepHocrb I{3MeHeHI4fl opo3zoHHoro r{3Hoca JroraroK PK uo cryrreH.rrM KHA r,r KBI 6:r,ta 3al.alaa B coorBercrBr4r4 C pe3ynbTaTaMLr SKcrrepr{MeHTajrbHofo }IccneAoBaEufl H3Hoca JIoIIaTOKTPAIO F100-PW-100, r.K. AaHHufi 4nurarerrb rro KoHcrpyKrryu v rapaMerpaMpa6ouero npoqecca corocraBuM c ABrarareJleu P[-33>.
CneAoBarlo 6rI orosopr4Tb, r{To 3To ycnoBr.re HyxHo paccMaTpl{Barb rax uprz6JII4xeHI{e, [ocKoJIbKyKoMnpeccopa 3Tr4x ABkrrarenefi sce xe pa3nLTrlarorc-fi B qacrn upo$iatupoBaHl{f,,KOHCTpyKTT4BHO|O rrorroJrHeHkrfl,, rrpl|[MeltrleMblxMaTep[anoB, TexHoJIofLII{; KpOMeTO|O, MOUrr4 pa3nurraTbcfl. xapaKTepr{cTr,rKr.r 3arrbrJreHHocTl4 (pa:LaepH n $opurrKBaprleBbrx rracrrrrerc z 4p.). Terra He MeHee, rrpuMeHensrrfi [oAxoA cneAyer npl{3HaTb OrrpaBAaHHbrM, T.K.
TaKOfO pOAa HCXOAHbIe AaHHbIe .{n-fl KOHKpeTHO|O ABI'I-rareJlf, peAKo 6rrsarcr B HaJrr{qurl, a rIoJIyrreHHbIe KoJILIqearBeHHbre oIIeHKI4 Blrr4fl.Hus u3Hoca:ea xapaKTepr{crr4Kr{ KHA u KB,{, HecoMHeHHo, rrpaKTurlecKll IroJIe3HbI.44. BHsrrnaer yAuBJreHr.re yrBepxAeHrre Ar4ccepraHTa o roM, tITo, KaK noKa:an o6sop, (orcyrcrByror MeroAr{KH, o6ecueur4Barorrlue uommrfi yqer Lr3MeHeHI{,csoficrs pa6ouero reJra no BceMy rpaKTy ABrrrareJr.s B pe3ynbrare u3MeHeHI,Ifl. BIrarocoAepxa:alafl>>.
Taxze MeroAraKr4 rrpLrMeHrrorc-fl B Pocczu npr,r repMoAraHaMr4rrecKoM pacqere rrapaMerpoB ABurarenefi, uo rpafiuefi uepe, c 1970-x r.r. (-fl.T.LItrruuen,B.Vl. fllr.rcu:a r.r Ap.).Oueerz4Ho, Ar4ccepraHT r{MeJr B Br{Ay BJrlr.f,Hr4e BJIarocoAepxaHr4fl. Ha xapaKTepr4cTr4Kr.r KoMrrpeccopa, KoTopbre oH flonyqan pacrleTHbrM nyTeM.IIpzoqeuKeBrr4.flHra.f,BJrarocoAepxaHr{fl Bo3Ayxa Ha xapaKTepvrcrr4Kr KoM-rpeccopos 6Hr paccMorpeH Akrarra3oH or d:0 Ao d:0.04, rrro B 3eMHbIx ycnoBl,I.f,xcoorBercrByer ra3MeHeHr4ro orHocr4remnofi BJraxHocru e or 0 ao I00 %. Ilpar<rruecrcHfi aHTepec flpeAcraBJrflerr{3MeHeHr.reqB 6oree y3KoM A}Iana3oHe, noSTo-My pr Brrr4fl:rtue Ha xapaKrepLtc^rarKkr 6yaer 6oree yMepeHHbIM.5. firaccepraHT He rro;lcHxer, rroqeMy norpe6osanacr pa":pa6otKa rlporpaMMbr pacqera BCX TPIIO BMecro r4croJrb3oBanufl, roroBbrx rporpaMM.
He noxcH{ercfl TaKxe, uoqeMy npv HHTepnonflrlr.rr4 rrclonb3yercfl Herpa.{r4rlraoHHax Qopltao\r4canurr xapaKrepr{crr4K KHA u KB,{, Koropaf, rrpeAcraBJlf,erc.r nepeycnoxHeHnofi (rnana 4); HeflcHo, KaK ora Qopua [o3BoJr-f,er f{r{TbrBarb r{3MeHeHHe nporpaMMbr yrrpaBneHras PHAKBA.B qenorr,r Marepr4irlbr aBrope$epara Auccepraqr,rra A6AenbBaxI{Aa M. E. cezAereJrbcrByror o roM, qro Ar,rccepraHT BloJrHe BnaAeer MarepvanoM I{ o6raAaersHcorofi xnanu$zxa\uefi,. Pe:ymrarrr pa6orrr rpournr{ aupo6aqzlo - oHLI AonoxeHbr Ha HayrrHo-TexHr{qecKr4x rou{epen\hflx vr ceMr4mapax.
